Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warnings:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of A Deal Not Taken AU
Stats:
Published:
2026-11-15
Updated:
2026-11-15
Words:
13,958
Chapters:
3/18
Hits:
4

A Deal Not Taken

Summary:

Charlie stepped out of handshake range. “No.”

Alastor’s smile was unwavering, but his ear twitched, and there was a spike in the static that accompanied him wherever he went. “I’m sorry? I must have misheard—”

“No,” Charlie repeated, doing her best to sound authoritative. “I don’t want your deal.”’


Charlie doesn’t take Alastor’s deal when he offers her the information that could save the Hazbin Hotel in exchange for a favour owed.

This changes things.

 
Featuring illustrations by Elcee_Rod and Floots

Notes:

Huge, huge thanks to Elcee_Rod, Floots, and SquigglyAverageJo(e) for being invaluable betas; to Elcee for doing the cover art, and to Floots for illustrating each chapter!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: disclosure

Summary:

♪ This meeting’s over! ♪

A prologue. You already know most of this part.


Chapter Text

By @elcee-rod.bsky.social. An illustration cover of a fanfiction AU titled: A Deal Not Taken, by Kiwi8_Fruit6. Charlie and Vaggie are standing back to back, angry and heartbroken respectively. Alastor, above Charlie head, is frustrated, the ouline of his rejected hand glowing green with runes. Above Vaggie's head, Angel Dust looks hurt and glaring, Husk looks angry, and Sir Pentious looks worried, all three's gazes pointed at Charlie's direction. The Hazbin Hotel in the background is portrayed with a bright ray of light shining down the middle, symbolizing the emotional rift in the hotel. Silhouettes of Adam and Lute are swooping down in front of the beam, charging at Charlie and Vaggie respectively. The title text is black and fancy with a green glow around it, the same colour as the green magic glow around Alastor’s hands.

“♪ Don’t you act all high and mighty
Did you ever think your little girlfriend might be a liar?
♪”

“Don’t, Adam, please—!”

“What’s the fuss?

“♪ Why hide the fact
that you’re
an
angel
JUST
LIKE
US?
♪”

 

An angel. 

An angel – an Exorcist – like them. One who had slaughtered so many of her people, so many souls undeserving of such a cruel and thoughtless end. The souls she was trying to save.

The souls she’d thought they were both trying to save.

That’s who Vaggie had been. Not a newly fallen sinner caught out in the open on Extermination Day, slumped against the side of a back alley dumpster with her clothes all ragged and her left eye gouged out – but an Exorcist. The one in the court’s scrying orb, staring resolutely ahead, her image proud and stern as if taken right out of a propaganda poster – that was her. That was her aquiline nose, and the bob cut she’d worn when they first met, except her bangs were neatly parted, baring both eyes, present and functioning and set in a glare so much fiercer and harder than she’d ever fathomed her partner’s gaze could possibly be. That was her spear, the angelic weapon Dazzle had found in another alleyway on the very same day she’d brought Vaggie home; the spear she had gone on to give her new girlfriend (and self-appointed bodyguard) as a gift.

That was Vaggie. That was who she’d been. Who she was.

Just like them. An angel.

A murderer.

She fell to her knees. She covered her eyes so she didn’t have to see, because she didn’t want to see any longer. Not the courtroom, not the wicked grins on the Exorcist leaders’ masks, not the angles of Vaggie’s face that were now that much harsher and sharper because of what she’d been, because of what she’d done. She wanted to hide; hide from this truth, hide from her pain, hide the tears welling up in her eyes from those who had hurt her. But she could still hear Adam and Lute’s laughter, and the murmurs of Heaven’s jury. She could still hear the footsteps that rushed to her side; could feel the hands that gingerly half-embraced her in an attempt at comfort, and she knew now that those hands had so much blood on them.

Why hadn’t Vaggie told her? How could she have not told her?

How could she?

“I’m sorry… but this court finds no evidence that the souls of sinners can be redeemed. The Princess Morningstar’s case is dismissed.”

“Oh, fuck YES! I WIN! Suck it, bitches!”

…Wait.

No.

No, no, no no no no no no, he couldn’t. They couldn’t. They COULDN’T! How could Heaven still side with Adam, when the horrible truth, the atrocity, of the Exterminations had been laid out bare in front of them? How could they have no compassion for human souls; no remorse for the bloodshed they’d allowed? Where was the justice, the impartiality, the grace that Heaven was supposed to embody?

Her dad had said Heaven wouldn’t listen, but she hadn’t wanted to believe it. She’d poured out her heart and her dreams to him, to bridge that distance between them, and convince him that it was worth trying, that she was worth striving for. But even though she’d changed his mind, he had been right after all.

“Sera, no, there isn’t—!”

“Emily…”

“—there’s no evidence that she’s wrong, either! And Adam didn’t have any proof that he was right, aside from that note he wrote! What about—?”

“Accusations are not proof, Emily. If the redemption of damned souls was possible, it would have already taken place.”

“Not just that – a genocide?! Of human souls?! Demon or not, there is no reason to be doing this—!”

“This verdict is final.”

Or maybe it was her fault. Maybe she hadn’t argued hard enough. Maybe she hadn’t done enough to heal and redeem her friends. She’d squandered this chance; Dad's efforts to get her this meeting were all for nothing.

She’d let him down. She’d let Mom down. She’d failed her people. 

Those familiar-now-unfamiliar hands tugged her to her feet as a pair of shadows loomed overhead.

Vaggie had failed her.

“Well, well, well! It looks like we still get to pay your failed little hotel a visit after all! Hope you saved the date, cunts, ‘cause we’re coming for you FIRST!”

Her stomach dropped.

“What? No!”

Adam was specifically targeting her friends and her dream, just to rub salt in the wound. It wasn’t enough that he’d keep on culling her people, he had to make it personal. And he wouldn’t have, if not for this meeting she had asked him for.

She’d made everything so much worse.

And if it felt like the ground had already fallen out from under her feet twice already – first when Vaggie was shown to her in the orb’s projection, then when Sera cast her judgement and condemned her dream – this time it swallowed her whole. It viscerally yanked her off balance and threw her into its maw.

It took her a moment to realise the sensation was real.

The portal Adam must have opened behind them tugged her inexorably back – tugged her and Vaggie both back, off their feet and to the brink. She reached out, but for what? The marble floor of the courtroom offered no grip, no purchase, nothing to hold on to.

She heard herself scream.

“No, you can’t—NO!”

Then Vaggie.

“You MOTHER—!”

She thought she heard a third cry from the highest level of the gallery.

“Charlie! Don’t give up on—!”

It cut off.

The courtroom receded, and then vanished altogether, as the portal spat them out in a heap on the floor of the Hotel lobby. She heard Vaggie immediately scramble to her feet and storm towards the portal as it snapped shut mockingly.

“—FUCKER!! ¡Despiadado hijo de puta APESTOSO!! ¡BASTARDO!!!”

She did not follow suit.

She did not trust her trembling limbs to hold her weight right now. So on her hands and knees she stayed, cowering from her failure, a failure bigger than all the other fuckups and mistakes she’d made before. 

Cowering from the sound of the angel raging into thin air a few feet away from her.

“…Adam, I hope you CHOKE on your spare ribs! ¡Jodio cerdo CABRÓN!! AARGH!”

Cowering from it all. 

Vaggie was an Exorcist, just like them, and the Extermination was still coming in a month's time, and her friends were almost definitely going to double-die. The cold hard fact of that more than ate away at her. It devoured her. It felt like even the hotel building itself was condemning her for failing to protect it.

Even though that’s what she’d been trying to do. Even though not all of it was her fault.

Because Vaggie hadn’t told her she was an angel.

Don’t cry, don’t cry, don’t cry, do not cry…

…

She lost the fight. A sniffle slipped out.

Then she heard a gasp.

“Charlie? Oh no, Charlie!”

Then rapid footsteps: Vaggie, running back to her side, her fury gone, her tirade ground to a halt. She felt her shadow fall upon her, and her presence as she knelt at her side; she heard the thump of her knee as it hit the floor.

“Charlie, I’m sorry, I am so sorry, I should have told you from the start. You deserved to hear it from me, not them, and I promise I can explain… I just… I just…”

And there were her hands on her elbow and shoulder again. Hands that had been bathed in the blood of her people. How many sinners had Vaggie killed? Hundreds? Thousands? How dare she be so gentle, when in reality she’d never been that at all? 

Her partner, her girlfriend, had lied to her.

She looked up, and despite the concern and care plain as day in her expression, she still saw the image of Vaggie’s mouth set in a grim, martial frown; lips she could never imagine kissing. She saw, in her mind, her girlfriend’s missing left eye, and how cold and dispassionate it had been. 

Now she knew what the X on her eyepatch – the X that showed through her bangs – truly meant.

“… Here, let me help you up—”

(“♪ I was told not to trust in angels… ♪”

“By her?”

“Ha! She should know!”)


No. She recoiled from her touch.

She turned away, hugging herself. She couldn’t bear to look Vaggie in the eye… even as she heard her breath shudder, and her own name leave her lips beseechingly. 

“Ch-Charlie…?”

She couldn’t take it. She couldn’t face her.

(An angel, just like them.)


She should go.

So she picked herself up, and she fled upstairs.

By @helluvafloots.bsky.social. Charlie, kneeling, turns away from Vaggi, hugging herself, there are tears in her eyes. Vaggi, kneeling, reaches out, looking shocked and hurt at Charlie rejecting her.