Preface

A Deal Not Taken
Posted originally on the fanfiction.lol at https://fanfiction.lol/works/1959.

Rating:
Explicit
Archive Warnings:
Graphic Depictions Of Violence, Major Character Death, Rape/Non-Con
Category:
Femslash (F/F)
Fandom:
Hazbin Hotel
Relationships:
Charlie Morningstar/Vaggi (Hazbin), Angel Dust/Husk (Hazbin) - Implied/Referenced, Angel Dust & Husk & Sir Pentious (Hazbin Hotel), Angel Dust & Charlie Magne | Morningstar, Husk & Charlie Magne | Morningstar, Angel Dust & Vaggi (Hazbin), Husk & Vaggi (Hazbin), Cherri Bomb/Sir Pentious (Hazbin) - Mentioned/Background, Charlie Morningstar & Sir Pentious (Hazbin), Alastor & Niffty (Hazbin), Adam/Lute (Hazbin) - One-Sided, Emily & Sera (Hazbin), Charlie Morningstar & Lucifer Morningstar (Hazbin)
Characters:
Charlie Morningstar (Hazbin), Vaggi (Hazbin), Angel Dust (Hazbin), Husk (Hazbin), Sir Pentious (Hazbin), Alastor (Hazbin), Niffty (Hazbin), Valentino (Hazbin), The Egg Bois (Hazbin), Cherri Bomb (Hazbin), Vox (Hazbin), Carmilla Carmine (Hazbin), Rosie (Hazbin), Velvette (Hazbin), Lute (Hazbin), Adam (Hazbin), Emily (Hazbin), Sera (Hazbin), Lucifer Morningstar (Hazbin)
Additional Tags:
Angst, Tragedy, Alternate Universe - Modified Canon, Canon Divergence, Episode: s01e07 Hello Rosie! (Hazbin), Charlie Morningstar-centric (Hazbin), Vaggi-centric (Hazbin), Charlie Morningstar Needs a Hug (Hazbin Hotel), Vaggi Needs a Hug (Hazbin Hotel), Angry Charlie Morningstar (Hazbin), Vaggi Tries Her Best (Hazbin), Vaggi Angst (Hazbin), Arguing, Misunderstandings, Break Up, Alastor Being a Jerk (Hazbin), Adam Being a Jerk (Hazbin), Alastor and Vaggi Do Not Get Along (Hazbin), Lute Being a Jerk (Hazbin), Crying, Drinking, Drinking to Cope, Blood and Injury, Gore, tags contain spoilers, Grief/Mourning, Demon Charlie Morningstar (Hazbin), Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation, Sad Ending, BAMF Lucifer Morningstar (Hazbin), POV Alternating, Illustrated, Beta Read
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of A Deal Not Taken AU
Stats:
Published: 2026-11-15 Words: 13,958 Chapters: 3/18

A Deal Not Taken

Summary

Charlie stepped out of handshake range. “No.”

Alastor’s smile was unwavering, but his ear twitched, and there was a spike in the static that accompanied him wherever he went. “I’m sorry? I must have misheard—”

“No,” Charlie repeated, doing her best to sound authoritative. “I don’t want your deal.”’


Charlie doesn’t take Alastor’s deal when he offers her the information that could save the Hazbin Hotel in exchange for a favour owed.

This changes things.

 
Featuring illustrations by Elcee_Rod and Floots

Notes

Huge, huge thanks to Elcee_Rod, Floots, and SquigglyAverageJo(e) for being invaluable betas; to Elcee for doing the cover art, and to Floots for illustrating each chapter!

Chapter 1: disclosure

Chapter Summary

♪ This meeting’s over! ♪

A prologue. You already know most of this part.


By @elcee-rod.bsky.social. An illustration cover of a fanfiction AU titled: A Deal Not Taken, by Kiwi8_Fruit6. Charlie and Vaggie are standing back to back, angry and heartbroken respectively. Alastor, above Charlie head, is frustrated, the ouline of his rejected hand glowing green with runes. Above Vaggie's head, Angel Dust looks hurt and glaring, Husk looks angry, and Sir Pentious looks worried, all three's gazes pointed at Charlie's direction. The Hazbin Hotel in the background is portrayed with a bright ray of light shining down the middle, symbolizing the emotional rift in the hotel. Silhouettes of Adam and Lute are swooping down in front of the beam, charging at Charlie and Vaggie respectively. The title text is black and fancy with a green glow around it, the same colour as the green magic glow around Alastor’s hands.

“♪ Don’t you act all high and mighty
Did you ever think your little girlfriend might be a liar?
♪”

“Don’t, Adam, please—!”

“What’s the fuss?

“♪ Why hide the fact
that you’re
an
angel
JUST
LIKE
US?
♪”

 

An angel. 

An angel – an Exorcist – like them. One who had slaughtered so many of her people, so many souls undeserving of such a cruel and thoughtless end. The souls she was trying to save.

The souls she’d thought they were both trying to save.

That’s who Vaggie had been. Not a newly fallen sinner caught out in the open on Extermination Day, slumped against the side of a back alley dumpster with her clothes all ragged and her left eye gouged out – but an Exorcist. The one in the court’s scrying orb, staring resolutely ahead, her image proud and stern as if taken right out of a propaganda poster – that was her. That was her aquiline nose, and the bob cut she’d worn when they first met, except her bangs were neatly parted, baring both eyes, present and functioning and set in a glare so much fiercer and harder than she’d ever fathomed her partner’s gaze could possibly be. That was her spear, the angelic weapon Dazzle had found in another alleyway on the very same day she’d brought Vaggie home; the spear she had gone on to give her new girlfriend (and self-appointed bodyguard) as a gift.

That was Vaggie. That was who she’d been. Who she was.

Just like them. An angel.

A murderer.

She fell to her knees. She covered her eyes so she didn’t have to see, because she didn’t want to see any longer. Not the courtroom, not the wicked grins on the Exorcist leaders’ masks, not the angles of Vaggie’s face that were now that much harsher and sharper because of what she’d been, because of what she’d done. She wanted to hide; hide from this truth, hide from her pain, hide the tears welling up in her eyes from those who had hurt her. But she could still hear Adam and Lute’s laughter, and the murmurs of Heaven’s jury. She could still hear the footsteps that rushed to her side; could feel the hands that gingerly half-embraced her in an attempt at comfort, and she knew now that those hands had so much blood on them.

Why hadn’t Vaggie told her? How could she have not told her?

How could she?

“I’m sorry… but this court finds no evidence that the souls of sinners can be redeemed. The Princess Morningstar’s case is dismissed.”

“Oh, fuck YES! I WIN! Suck it, bitches!”

…Wait.

No.

No, no, no no no no no no, he couldn’t. They couldn’t. They COULDN’T! How could Heaven still side with Adam, when the horrible truth, the atrocity, of the Exterminations had been laid out bare in front of them? How could they have no compassion for human souls; no remorse for the bloodshed they’d allowed? Where was the justice, the impartiality, the grace that Heaven was supposed to embody?

Her dad had said Heaven wouldn’t listen, but she hadn’t wanted to believe it. She’d poured out her heart and her dreams to him, to bridge that distance between them, and convince him that it was worth trying, that she was worth striving for. But even though she’d changed his mind, he had been right after all.

“Sera, no, there isn’t—!”

“Emily…”

“—there’s no evidence that she’s wrong, either! And Adam didn’t have any proof that he was right, aside from that note he wrote! What about—?”

“Accusations are not proof, Emily. If the redemption of damned souls was possible, it would have already taken place.”

“Not just that – a genocide?! Of human souls?! Demon or not, there is no reason to be doing this—!”

“This verdict is final.”

Or maybe it was her fault. Maybe she hadn’t argued hard enough. Maybe she hadn’t done enough to heal and redeem her friends. She’d squandered this chance; Dad's efforts to get her this meeting were all for nothing.

She’d let him down. She’d let Mom down. She’d failed her people. 

Those familiar-now-unfamiliar hands tugged her to her feet as a pair of shadows loomed overhead.

Vaggie had failed her.

“Well, well, well! It looks like we still get to pay your failed little hotel a visit after all! Hope you saved the date, cunts, ‘cause we’re coming for you FIRST!”

Her stomach dropped.

“What? No!”

Adam was specifically targeting her friends and her dream, just to rub salt in the wound. It wasn’t enough that he’d keep on culling her people, he had to make it personal. And he wouldn’t have, if not for this meeting she had asked him for.

She’d made everything so much worse.

And if it felt like the ground had already fallen out from under her feet twice already – first when Vaggie was shown to her in the orb’s projection, then when Sera cast her judgement and condemned her dream – this time it swallowed her whole. It viscerally yanked her off balance and threw her into its maw.

It took her a moment to realise the sensation was real.

The portal Adam must have opened behind them tugged her inexorably back – tugged her and Vaggie both back, off their feet and to the brink. She reached out, but for what? The marble floor of the courtroom offered no grip, no purchase, nothing to hold on to.

She heard herself scream.

“No, you can’t—NO!”

Then Vaggie.

“You MOTHER—!”

She thought she heard a third cry from the highest level of the gallery.

“Charlie! Don’t give up on—!”

It cut off.

The courtroom receded, and then vanished altogether, as the portal spat them out in a heap on the floor of the Hotel lobby. She heard Vaggie immediately scramble to her feet and storm towards the portal as it snapped shut mockingly.

“—FUCKER!! ¡Despiadado hijo de puta APESTOSO!! ¡BASTARDO!!!”

She did not follow suit.

She did not trust her trembling limbs to hold her weight right now. So on her hands and knees she stayed, cowering from her failure, a failure bigger than all the other fuckups and mistakes she’d made before. 

Cowering from the sound of the angel raging into thin air a few feet away from her.

“…Adam, I hope you CHOKE on your spare ribs! ¡Jodio cerdo CABRÓN!! AARGH!”

Cowering from it all. 

Vaggie was an Exorcist, just like them, and the Extermination was still coming in a month's time, and her friends were almost definitely going to double-die. The cold hard fact of that more than ate away at her. It devoured her. It felt like even the hotel building itself was condemning her for failing to protect it.

Even though that’s what she’d been trying to do. Even though not all of it was her fault.

Because Vaggie hadn’t told her she was an angel.

Don’t cry, don’t cry, don’t cry, do not cry…

…

She lost the fight. A sniffle slipped out.

Then she heard a gasp.

“Charlie? Oh no, Charlie!”

Then rapid footsteps: Vaggie, running back to her side, her fury gone, her tirade ground to a halt. She felt her shadow fall upon her, and her presence as she knelt at her side; she heard the thump of her knee as it hit the floor.

“Charlie, I’m sorry, I am so sorry, I should have told you from the start. You deserved to hear it from me, not them, and I promise I can explain… I just… I just…”

And there were her hands on her elbow and shoulder again. Hands that had been bathed in the blood of her people. How many sinners had Vaggie killed? Hundreds? Thousands? How dare she be so gentle, when in reality she’d never been that at all? 

Her partner, her girlfriend, had lied to her.

She looked up, and despite the concern and care plain as day in her expression, she still saw the image of Vaggie’s mouth set in a grim, martial frown; lips she could never imagine kissing. She saw, in her mind, her girlfriend’s missing left eye, and how cold and dispassionate it had been. 

Now she knew what the X on her eyepatch – the X that showed through her bangs – truly meant.

“… Here, let me help you up—”

(“♪ I was told not to trust in angels… ♪”

“By her?”

“Ha! She should know!”)


No. She recoiled from her touch.

She turned away, hugging herself. She couldn’t bear to look Vaggie in the eye… even as she heard her breath shudder, and her own name leave her lips beseechingly. 

“Ch-Charlie…?”

She couldn’t take it. She couldn’t face her.

(An angel, just like them.)


She should go.

So she picked herself up, and she fled upstairs.

By @helluvafloots.bsky.social. Charlie, kneeling, turns away from Vaggi, hugging herself, there are tears in her eyes. Vaggi, kneeling, reaches out, looking shocked and hurt at Charlie rejecting her.

Chapter 2: refusal

Chapter Summary

Charlie, whatever you do, do NOT make a deal with him!

Charlie makes a different choice when Alastor offers her that deal. No one walks away happy.


Charlie Morningstar, the Princess of Hell and the daughter of Lucifer, had been holed up in her room, crying in bed, for hours. Hours since her unceremonious, forcible return from Heaven, with nothing but that awful memory of it playing on repeat inside her head. 

Nothing but her failure to dwell on. Nothing to do but remember, and hurt, and cry.

How could she not cry? Victory had been snatched away from her, so, so cruelly. And she’d been so close, too! Heaven’s court had been in an uproar, an actual Seraphim arguing on her side, making her elder sister shrink back in shame! She had brought to light before the jury the very existence of the Exterminations, and not only that but exposed the Achilles’ heel of Heaven’s moral posturing: that they didn’t even know what made a soul worthy of being saved in the first place! That they had no moral right to condemn sinners, let alone cull them!

The angels in the courthouse had even seemed about to change their minds! Everything had been going so well!

…And then Adam and his second-in-command had pulled back the curtains on who Vaggie had really been, and both Charlie’s case and her resolve had collapsed like a house of cards. And she’d had nothing.

All because Vaggie had lied to her.

Well, hidden the truth – but wasn’t that the same thing? Lying by omission? Concealment?

Paltering?

Confabulation?

…

Did it even matter?

Vaggie had still been an Exorcist, and Charlie had faltered when she’d found out. Adam had gotten his way, and now her home and her friends… and girlfriend… were right in the firing line, with a month to go till the next Extermination and no chance of getting another meeting with Heaven. No chance of changing their minds. No time to redeem anybody. No hope of saving her people from the slaughter. All she had done was paint a big fat bullseye on the Hazbin Hotel.

If Vaggie had just told her she was an angel when she’d found her… this could all have been avoided. 

Charlie sobbed anew, gritting her teeth. She accepted another tissue from Razzle. Or was it Dazzle? Her vision was so blurred with tears she couldn’t tell her lifelong companions apart as they hovered within arms reach off the right side of their bed. 

She tried not to think about how this side of the bed was Vaggie’s. 

…

Oh. She was thinking about it.

She tried instead to concentrate on getting the tissue to her face. She tried to let the weight of the blankets ground and comfort her. That seemed like a good idea… yeah, just think about the bed, Charlie. Not Vaggie. Think about the colour of the sheets (purple, the colour that Vaggie had picked out), or the sensation of the shed hairs tickling her nose and the back of her neck.

Or how those hairs belonged to Vaggie. Or that she was lying on Vaggie’s side of the bed, or that Vaggie rolled around restlessly in her sleep if Charlie wasn’t there next to her, or on top of her; touching her in some way…

Or that she’d kept her past a secret the whole time they’d known each other.

…

Welp, there she was, still thinking about Vaggie.

Stillllllll thinking about her.

It was kind of like the ‘don’t think of a pink elephant’ thought exercise she’d read up on: she had to think about Vaggie when she was thinking about not thinking about her, and that was so confusing… but not as confusing as the fact Vaggie had just… lied to her. Or that Charlie had somehow never thought to look further than her initial presumption that Vaggie was a sinner, and her girlfriend had just played along with it. How had she not noticed that Vaggie might be more than she appeared? Why had she thought nothing of the grey tunic and the hint of feathers hastily stuffed inside a gold-stained trash can in the same alley she’d found her girlfriend? 

She felt so stupid.

She sobbed again. She blew her nose, and, for a moment, gave no mind to how the sound of it seemed to carry on, hissy and staticky, even after the used tissue had been discarded.

Between Razzle and Dazzle, a shadow sprouted from the floor and resolved itself into a red suit worn on a tall and lanky frame. “Oh, Charlie, Charlie, Charlie. Aren’t you an absolute mess.”

The Goat Bois parted like the Red Sea.

There were many people Charlie didn’t want to see right now – no, scratch that, she couldn’t stomach seeing anyone right now. Her friends, her dad… she was sure they’d be so disappointed in her. She’d failed them. She wouldn’t be able to stand seeing that disappointment in their eyes, even if they pitied her or tried to comfort her. And she didn’t want to see Vaggie for… obvious reasons.

Stop thinking about her, Charlie!

But Alastor? The Radio Demon? She knew he wasn’t here to offer any pity or comfort. She knew he wasn’t disappointed in her – the opposite, if anything. He was here to enjoy her despair and her failure. And, in a lot of ways, that was worse. Pity stung, but mockery? That was an old wound being reopened. That ached.

She pouted at him, and burrowed deeper under the blankets. “Go away, Alastor.”

Alastor did not go away. He sat himself down at the foot of her bed. “Now, now, I’m only concerned! Is this any way to act after picking a fight with all of Heaven and dooming everyone you love?”

The reminder nearly made Charlie start crying again. “It is! I don’t need you mocking me right now! I have enough on my mind without hearing your sadistic idea of a joke, asshole.” She rolled over…

…And found his face just inches away from hers. “Who’s joking?”

Charlie yelped and tumbled out of her own bed.

Alastor smiled down at her innocently, like he hadn’t teleported himself right next to her and spooked the living daylights out of her. “You have a captive audience downstairs, waiting to hear what scheme you’re cooking up, what kind of inspiring performance you have planned next!” He swept his arm through the air theatrically, as if conducting an orchestra. Oh, and it certainly was all a show to him, not a fight against literal genocide with her friends’ afterlives on the line. 

“I can’t!” Charlie picked herself up off the floor, only to sit back down again against the side of the bed. “I can’t think of any way to solve this. And how can I face the others when I failed them? They came here to be saved, and all I did was make them a target!” Fresh tears filled her eyes, and she scrubbed them away. “I’m worse than the cruellest Overlords! At least they don’t go around giving false hope.”

“My, my! I never expected to hear such miserable, defeatist self-loathing from our starry-eyed demon belle!” That was such a blatant lie. Of course he did. The gleeful chirp in his voice gave it away. Everybody wanted to see Charlie break. 

She stormed to her feet in a sudden fury. “Oh, fuck you, Alastor! All you do is stand there smiling—” He wasn’t standing, he was lying prone on her bed, kicking his legs back and forth in the air – but he was smiling as wide as ever. “—while you watch us struggle! You belittle me for wanting to save sinners, for trying to make Hell a better place – it’s like you want us to fail, and the Exterminations to keep on happening!” She turned her back on him. “I don’t know how you can find that entertaining. I don’t know how you can enjoy it so much.” In a way, she did want to understand why he was like that, so that she could change his mind, prove him wrong about his worldview, and maybe even redeem him too… but it revolted her just to try and comprehend the notion of getting a kick from other peoples’ suffering. 

Claw-like fingers curled over her shoulders from behind. 

“Ah,” Alastor chuckled darkly, “but just because you see a smile, my dear, don’t think you know what’s going on underneath!” He twirled her around to face him. Grabbing her cheeks, he pulled the corners of her mouth into a facsimile of a grin she didn’t feel one bit like wearing. “A smile is a valuable tool; after all, you’re never fully dressed without one! It inspires your friends, keeps your enemies guessing, and ensures that, no matter what comes your way, you’re the one in control.”

With that, he let her go, poking her in the chest with his staff for emphasis. Charlie pushed it away.

“But I’m not! I’m the farthest thing from ‘in control!’” She found herself pacing over to the huge window that overlooked Pentagram City, and she leaned against it, not really looking out over the uncaring urban skyline that never seemed to give a damn about its own damnation, but inwards, at her own failure. “The person I trust most has been lying to me about who she was for our whole relationship, Heaven refuses to change their mind, and even if they did, I can’t prove the Hotel works. Adam has an invincible army pointed right at my doorstep, the Extermination is still going to happen, and there’s nothing—” she beat her fist against the glass, “—I can do—about any of it!”

She panted into the stillness that followed, her breath fogging up the windowpane.

She didn’t know why she had vented like this to the guy who had openly told her that he didn’t share any of her goals, the guy who wanted to see the sinners in her care fail to redeem themselves and rub it in her face. A part of her still wished she could have talked to her girlfriend instead, just now, the first person who’d supported her goals, who’d let her express her anguish and frustration without judgement, who’d given her a safe space where she didn’t have to force herself to be optimistic or keep carrying her mother’s hope all the time.

But Vaggie had kept her own past from Charlie for years. She had been an exorcist. She had killed sinners – who knew how many, for who knows how long.

Could Charlie trust that Vaggie had ever truly believed in her dream?

Behind her, the hum of static rose in volume. She squeezed her eyes shut, and steeled herself to be made fun of again.

But the mockery didn’t come.

“♪ I know something you don’t knooow… ♪” Alastor sing-songed.

“Huh?” Charlie’s eyes snapped open, and she whipped around.

The Radio Demon was, all of a sudden, very invested in plucking leaves from the potted plant on her bedside table. “You seem so sure your impending doom is a foregone conclusion. That those big scary angels are just as indestructible as they seem.”

“It… is? They are?” But now Charlie wasn’t certain of that. Whatever Alastor was hinting at, he sounded absolutely sure of it. An anxious spark of hope rekindled inside her. “Al, what are you talking about?”

“Just that you and your little band of misfits might stand more of a chance than you think.” Alastor walked away, coyly. In the back of her mind, the voice that sounded the most like Vaggie (why are you still THINKING about her, Charlie?) reminded her that Alastor was baiting her. 

But she took the bait anyway, and trailed after him. She had to.

A myriad of improbable possibilities raced through her mind. Was Alastor able to contact Heaven with his radio powers, so she could ask for another meeting without having to admit to her dad that she’d wasted the chance he’d given her? Could he directly reach out to Emily, since she probably would be the only high-ranking angel on Charlie’s side? Were his own demonic abilities capable of shielding against the Exorcists’ weapons?

Could a sinner who’d arrived in Hell with such unprecedented power know something that her mom – and dad – hadn’t told her?

“How?” she begged. “I’ll do anything!”

Alastor stopped in his tracks and snapped his head around a hundred and eighty degrees. He looked victorious. “Anything?” 

Charlie froze. She had the strongest impression that she’d made a big mistake.

With a flourish, the Radio Demon twisted the rest of his body around to face her and proffered his left hand. “Then… let’s make a deal!” 

A shiver ran down her spine.

She remembered.

“Charlie, listen to me.”

She remembered her father, bouncing her on his knee when she was just a little kid, conjuring up light show of ugly creatures being banished by a golden heroine as he told her for the very first time: “You don’t take shit from other demons!”

“You can’t believe this creep! He’s a dealmaker! Pure evil!”

She remembered Alastor himself, purring salaciously, belittling her belief in better things and second chances to her face: “I want to watch the scum of the world struggle to better themselves, only to trip and fall into the fiery pit of failure…”

“AND he’s most likely looking for a way to destroy everything we’re trying to do!”

She remembered her own voice, as she (gently, of course) slapped away Alastor’s proffered hand and nipped the menacing green glow of his gathering powers in the bud: “Nope! No shaking! No deals, or magic tricks, or strings attached!” 

“Charlie, whatever you do…” 

And she remembered someone clutching her arms, the voice of an angel beseeching her, pleading, louder than all of the other warnings and omens and memories that came before:

“… do NOT make a deal with him!”

That made up her mind for her.

Charlie stepped out of handshake range. “No.”

Alastor’s smile was unwavering, but his ear twitched, and there was a spike in the static that accompanied him wherever he went. “I’m sorry? I must have misheard—”

“No.” Charlie repeated, doing her best to sound authoritative, like a Princess of Hell should… like her mother would’ve wanted. (Like Vaggie would’ve wanted.) “I don’t want your deal.”

He grinned wider, and laughed – but it was a tight laugh, like how he sounded whenever the subject of television came up in conversation. “Why, Charlie, you must be feeling better already if you have time for jokes!” 

His microphone burst into life. “I say, the dame must still be dizzy from her heavenly misadventure—!”

“Shut UP!” Charlie clenched her fist, and the canned laughter cut off with a screech. “I’m not kidding! I mean it! No!”

Alastor blinked. He clutched his staff to his chest, and stroked the top of the microphone as if comforting a frightened pet. “That was rude.”

“Well, so is coming into my room without knocking!” she shot back. “What do you take me for, Alastor? You think I can’t tell you’re trying to take advantage of me right now?”

He gasped and placed his fingertips against his chest, making a big show of offense. “A gentleman would never—!”

“Then why can’t you just tell me what you know?”

“Information has a price, dear.”

Charlie felt a knot tighten in the pit of her stomach. This was exactly what Vaggie had warned her about when Alastor first showed up at the Hotel. “You want my soul, don’t you?”

“Your soul? Heavens, no! What could I possibly do with a soul such as yours? Besides, what I know isn’t worth as much as you are.” Ugh. That was slimier than Sir Pentious. “All I would be asking from you is a favour! One itty-bitty favour!” Alastor pinched his fingers together. “What’s a favour between friends?”

“Friends wouldn’t dangle something important over my head like this,” Charlie scoffed. “Friends would just tell me.” Vaggie didn’t tell you she was an angel, her mind reminded her, and she felt another pang in her heart.

“Why, Charlie,” Alastor admonished, “I thought you’d be more trusting, what with the kinds of sinner you’ve taken under your wing. And after all I’ve done for the Hotel? This suspicion is not in your nature.”

“Not in my—?” Oh, she was enraged. How dare he tell her who she was. “You think I’m naive? Don’t tell me you don’t, I know you and—and the whole rest of Hell think I am! ‘Oh, look at little miss rainbows, she thinks the sun shines out of everyone’s asses, she’s so gullible and useless and she matters so little!’” It hurt so bad to repeat the things she’d heard being said about her: Katie Killjoy’s ridiculing, Lute’s sneering, all the mocking that she’d faced for her dreams of trying to help Sinners and just do good. She blinked away any tears before they had a chance to well up in her eyes. “But you’re wrong. I’m not ignorant. I’m not blind to the fact that sinners do bad things! I am the Princess of Hell, and I’ve lived in Hell for two hundred years – that’s longer than you’ve been here!” 

Alastor’s smirk grew ranklingly wider at that. Charlie didn’t spare it more than a moment’s notice and irritation, and she sure didn’t stop.

“Yes, I believe that every demon has good inside of them, and can choose to change for the better, but I know that out there, there are souls who have done – choose to do – cruel, mean, horribly fucked-up things!” She thought of Valentino, briefly, and the way he’d dragged Angel out of his dressing room so roughly and made her friend look so frightened, so cowed. But Alastor was the one here in front of her right now, the guy who’d professed to finding suicides and orphans amusing, who had felled overlords just for the fun of it, whose broadcasts were filled with screams of pain and terror. “Sinners like you. I know your reputation, I was warned about you!” 

“Ah, but by who, dear?” he asked, piercingly. “Those newsreel narrators on the picture box? Your impotent, absentee father?” 

“Don’t insult my—” Charlie tried to interject, but she’d lost her momentum. Alastor steamrolled on.

“Or was it your sweetheart, who – what was it? – concealed her heavenly identity from you for as long as she could manage?” He started stalking towards her, backing her down. “What makes you think you can trust them any more than me? What makes you think they could give you what I am offering to support your kitschy aspirations?

“And how badly do you really want to save these sinners from their demise, if you’re turning down the only way in which you can?”

Charlie flinched. She didn’t have a comeback for that; his words had hit home. What if he was right?

For just a moment, pinwheeling tuning dials flashed in Alastor’s eyes. “I am being generous with you, Charlie. A favour, in exchange for what I know.”

She glared up at him, fuming, her chest heaving. She wanted to be defiant, but she didn’t think she was doing a good job at it. She tried to fold her arms, but she suspected it looked more like she was hugging herself.

A part of her mind told her that if there was a chance Alastor was right, she should accept his offer, and then she could deal with the consequences of it later. Another part of her mind resisted, and countered the first, telling her she should stick with her gut instinct that he was trying to extort her and trick her. But her gut instinct also told her that fighting off Heaven and saving her friends was the most important thing of all, and hadn’t she meant it when she’d said she’d do anything to know what the secret to fighting off angels was?

She was at war with herself, and she didn’t know which side to pick anymore. She didn’t know what she should do.

Alastor’s expression softened, as if he could sense her inner turmoil.

“I know what you’re thinking,” he purred, coiling around her, the radio filter gone from his voice. “That you can somehow do this on your own. And believe me, I know, oh I know that foolhardy determination well. But you’re unpractised, Charlie. You suppress your true power. No, you wouldn’t know what to do with yourself if you tried to go it alone. You’ve said as much already. You need guidance. From someone with… hands-on experience. Someone who, dare I say, has already been invaluable to this project of ours?”

Abruptly, he straightened up, voice and countenance returning to his usual chirpy self. “And we can’t have all your potential going to waste in a pointless last stand! So, shake my hand, and you get to save your friends.” Once more, he extended an open hand to her, in the showiest, twirliest way possible. “Whaddaya say?” 

Charlie didn’t say anything. She eyed Alastor’s open palm warily.

But she couldn’t help but think of how his words rung true. As much as the Story of Hell Lilith had left her was a comfort to her, she also felt the weight of her mother’s expectations on her when she read it. She didn’t know how she was supposed to carry on her mother’s hope successfully. Her father, even before he shut her out, had never taught her much of how to use her demonic powers, and high school hadn’t been any better in that area (especially with Hellsa Von Eldritch around, distracting her from studies with cliquey bully bullshit). She just tried to be authentic to herself and her values, going through trial and error, and, after so many years of trying and trying and trying, she had to admit it felt like she was getting nowhere. 

Not even with her dad’s help.

Not even with Vaggie.

And the fact that Alastor wasn’t calling her useless, like so many other demons did – even if he did demean her lack of experience, and even if the way he talked about her power and potential was kinda creepy – in a way, it felt like a show of faith in her. Something that Mom might be proud of her for. A show of faith that few had ever put in her before.

Vaggie hadn’t trusted her enough to tell her she was an Exorcist.

Charlie swallowed. Maybe… maybe she should reconsider her choice?

Cautiously, she unfolded her arms. 

Alastor’s eyes gleamed eagerly. “So we have a deal, then?” Far too eagerly.

His fingers brushed hers. Charlie realised he was slipping his hand into hers, trying to force the deal.

She erupted.

“NO!” she roared. And she shoved Alastor away with a strength more than merely corporeal. She felt her horns and tail sprout from her head and back, felt the air grow hot as flames ignited and whirled around her; her demon form had come out with her rage. 

Alastor went sliding all the way across the room, almost to the door, as if the carpet were an ice skating rink. He’d gone full demon, too; the whirling dials were back in his eyes again. Glowing green stitches tugged his snarl as wide as it could go, and sigils of the same colour phased in and out of existence on either side of him. His limbs stretched and creaked like the branches of a tree in a storm. And the whole room flashed with gold and green, demonic energies branching and spreading across the walls and ceiling like ivy, like lightning, as they clashed and battled for dominance. 

Alastor fought the worst of his demon form back down, but he still gave the strong impression of an angry buck snorting in the winter; green St. Elmo’s Fire flaring from his nostrils, his eyes wide and his pupils dilated from the rush of being in the briefest contact with a demon princess and her powers.

Charlie, going demon form, has shoved Alastor away from him across the room. He’s also gone demon form. Fire whirls around the room

Charlie, though? She didn’t let hers down. Alastor had provoked her, tried to force a handshake on her, and she had zero doubts in her choice not to trust him any longer. 

“I said NO!” she bellowed. “You’re clearly trying to manipulate me, and I never wanted you to come in here in the first place! You need to—” She stopped herself, and took a deep breath. She had to word this carefully. “As Princess of Hell, I order you to stay out of my room – unless invited in!” That felt right. Something with no loopholes Alastor could exploit – at least, none that she could think of. She found surety in her righteous anger.

Alastor’s lip curled nastily. “You know you’re throwing away a real opportunity here, dear.”

“GO.” Charlie pointed at the door. She could feel Razzle and Dazzle’s presences at her back, and hear their growls. If needed, they could transform into their own demon forms at the snap of her fingers. They weren’t just cherubic little goat plushies brought to life to be companions or concerningly-bad-at-driving valets; they were her bodyguards for a reason.

For a moment it looked like Alastor would give them that reason; he seemed like he was itching for a fight. But the moment past, and then, anticlimactically, he straightened up and brushed his coat down. “Suit yourself, Charlie,” he sneered. “I shall look forward to watching you reap what you’ve sown.”

And before she had to tell him to get out a third time, he melted into the shadows, and the shadows melted into the cracks in the wall and the gaps in the floor. The room felt lighter without the Radio Demon’s presence. Razzle and Dazzle let out twin sighs of relief.

Charlie felt triumphant. She hadn’t taken Alastor’s shit. She’d stood up for herself, and had commanded her authority as the Princess of Hell – against one of the most powerful Overlords to boot! She’d done her dad proud. She’d done her mom proud!

She’d done Vaggie proud…

… but Vaggie had taken part in the Exterminations. And her mom wanted her to stop the Exterminations by bringing hope to her people. How would she make her proud if she’d turned down a way to empower Hell against Heaven? 

Her demon form, her righteous anger, and her brief sense of victory all evaporated. What if she’d made the wrong choice? Had Alastor been telling the truth, after all?

She began to pace anxiously, hands pressed to her forehead again as her mind spun up. Sure, she knew Alastor was a manipulative dealmaker. He had tried to take advantage of her. He had tried to manoeuvre her into a deal, under duress, while she was alone and isolated. His words and actions just now had had all the hallmarks of coercion. That tempting little hint that there was a way to stop the exorcists could have just been a lie to tempt her into capitulating.

But, just as equally, he could have been telling the truth. And if he had… then the deal he’d offered could have been worth it, maybe?

What kind of favour had he even wanted from her in return? He might have wanted her to do something that would have involved hurting someone – or someones? – and she never wanted to do that at all, not ever, especially not for him… but it also might not have been that. He’d said he didn’t want her soul, and it made sense that a sinner couldn’t do anything with the souls of those higher than him in Hell’s hierarchy. Maybe he had just wanted her to sing something for him on his radio show! Maybe he’d wanted to swap rooms with her and Vaggie, so he could his expand his studio into the penthouse!

Or maybe he’d just wanted her to throw all the TVs out of the Hotel! Which she would have been more than happy to do, without a whole deal thing – but if that would’ve been all he wanted, she’d have shaken his hand in a heartbeat!

…Or maybe he’d wanted her to close the hotel. Maybe he’d wanted her to renounce redemption, and concede to him that her dream was impossible, and that sinners didn’t deserve a second chance. Maybe, somehow, he’d even wanted her to… marry him? No, that wasn’t right; she was pretty sure – mostly sure – that Alastor was asexual. He’d always turned down Angel Dust’s advances, even when they were jokes, and had nodded along in agreement whenever Charlie espoused the virtue of chastity in group therapy. He’d said himself that he saw her more like a daughter, and he’d never objected to her and Vaggie being in a relationship.

Her and Vaggie…

Vaggie was the one who’d told her not to trust Alastor, not to make a deal with him. But Alastor was right. How could she trust Vaggie anymore? Vaggie had lied to her about her past, hiding the truth that she’d been an active participant in the genocides Charlie so abhorred, and now her advice could have cost Charlie the only opportunity to fix things before Adam came back. If she’d taken Alastor’s deal, she could have gotten the key to defeating the angels and having a real shot at fighting for her friends’ afterlives.

But she had listened to Vaggie instead. Vaggie, the person who had been by her side when no one else was, who she had entrusted her dream and her heart to for the last three, nearly three-and-a-half years.

And look where that had gotten her.

It sunk in that she'd made another dumb decision that just made everything worse. And it more than ate away at her. It devoured her.

Charlie began to cry again. She couldn’t do anything right. She’d lost – no, she’d turned down what might have been her one chance to right her wrongs, and she couldn't take it back. She wasn’t empowered, she was stupid. She couldn’t do anything with the hope she was supposed to bear while her mother was gone.

She’d fucked up.

She was a fuckup.

Because if Charlie couldn’t stop the Exterminations, or save her people from them, she couldn’t redeem herself from being the reason the they had started in the first place. 

So she burrowed back under the covers to bawl her eyes out some more, ignoring the worried bleats of Razzle and Dazzle as they rushed to provide her with a fresh box of tissues. She was certain she’d doomed them, and all of her friends, all over again.

Chapter 3: liable

Chapter Summary

This one judges everyone and everything ‘cause she hates herself.

Vaggie’s introspection, and her explanations to the others, are interrupted by the fallout of what happened upstairs..


Chapter Notes

CW // Use of a lesbian slur

Silence reigned in the Hotel lobby.

It had since Vaggie had finished recounting to the other residents what had happened up in Heaven – the trial, the courtroom observations of their night out with Angel’s friend, used as evidence both for and against Charlie’s mission – and given the obligatory explanation, the ‘Hey, guys! Guess what? I was lying about being a sinner, I’m actually an angel, I used to try and kill you guys in the Exterminations, you know, the thing that Charlie’s trying to stop!’ that she’d owed them now. It was better that she’d been the one to confess it, instead of them finding out from her girlfriend, or being left guessing why they’d returned from the club to find Vaggie, kneeling alone and guilt-stricken in the lobby.

Aside from a few barbed comments – mostly from Angel Dust – the others had been… surprisingly neutral. They hadn’t been horrified, they hadn’t seemed frightened of her, and they hadn’t tried to leave. They hadn’t even had that many questions, and of those they did ask, most of them had been about her lack of angelic attributes: wings and a halo. And, for whatever reason, Niffty had asked her about her bust size, and Angel had latched onto that because of course he would seize the opportunity to call her ‘flat’.

Now, it seemed, they had nothing more to ask. So Vaggie paced a hole in the rug, chewing on her nails, as she dwelled on the last question Angel had asked her:

“And where is little Miss Fearless Leader anyways? Isn’t it about time for another doomed-to-fail plan?”

And her answer:

“She’s upstairs. Coming up with something, I’m sure… in our room… alone…”

Charlie was always the first and foremost thing on Vaggie’s mind; she had been for the last three-and-a-half years. And right now, Vaggie couldn’t get her mind off the memory of Charlie turning away from her, giving her the cold shoulder when she’d tried to help her up after they’d been returned from Heaven. It was the first time her girlfriend had shut her out in their whole relationship, and it broke her heart.

She knew Charlie wasn’t coming up with anything, not with how long she’d spent upstairs. Vaggie knew she’d hurt her lover badly, and oh, how she hated herself for it.

But how could she have told Charlie she was an angel? When could she possibly have told her? When they first met, when Charlie plucked her from that dark and bloody alleyway? Sure, she knew now that the Princess of Hell wouldn’t have killed her if she’d known she was tending to an Exorcist – but at the time, Vaggie hadn’t known that. At the time, she’d feared that any demon who came across her would have killed her on sight. It was what she’d been taught, after all: that demons were sinful, bloodthirsty, violent creatures who threatened Heaven and all that was good in the universe.

Even the beautiful, kind woman who’d been so horrified by her wounds and had bandaged her up without question. Vaggie had thought even she would turn on her, if she’d known what she was. Or thrown her back out into the streets, to be at the mercy of angry, vengeful sinners. 

By the time Vaggie knew for sure that Charlie wasn’t that kind of person, and trusted that Lucifer’s daughter was in fact fairer, kinder, better than any angel she’d known in Heaven, she’d kept up the ruse of being a sinner so long that she’d known it would destroy Charlie if she found out. The pain wouldn’t be in the truth, it would be in that Vaggie had lied.

By the time she trusted Charlie, she was afraid for a completely different reason: Vaggie was afraid of losing her.

She didn’t want to lose Charlie. She wanted to stay with her, to be her partner and protector. She loved her so much; this generous, kind-hearted woman who’d saved her, who fought against the odds to stay so kind and upbeat even in a realm like Hell. And she’d been hoping to find a time, someday down the road, when (no ifs, it had to be when) the Hazbin Hotel had worked and redeemed enough sinners to make up for the thousands of souls she’d slain, the red on her ledger – maybe then it would be safe for her to tell Charlie. 

Maybe then Charlie wouldn’t cut her off, kick her out or leave her behind, if she’d proved she’d made up for her crimes.

Because Charlie had given Vaggie hope that it might be possible to redeem herself, too.

Her pacing slowed as she came about to face the others again, and, as her train of thought paused, she took in their expressions. 

Angel and Pentious hadn’t moved from their seats since the lukewarm interrogation began. Keekee had settled in the serpent’s lap, pinning him in place, and judging by his big sparkly eyes – including the one on his top hat – he was more than happy to stay there and pet the kitty. Niffty had checked out of the topic at hand, and was back to waging her campaign against the Hotel’s resident bug population, while Husk had gotten up, probably to get a refill from the bar.

But the porn star was still glaring at her.

The judgement in his gaze hit Vaggie like a punch to the gut. Sure, he hadn’t been openly hostile – none of the others had, they’d all reacted better than she was expecting – but he was still evidently pissed off with her. Condemning her. 

She didn’t like how that felt. It reminded her, just a little bit, of Lute’s strictness – a distant echo of it. 

Vaggie averted her eye. She avoided looking in the direction of Alastor’s armchair, because she did not want to see his smarmy, shitass smile; not in this predicament, not at her predicament. So she looked up at the ceiling instead, itching at her gloved forearms, as she thought once more of Charlie, and how she’d sworn she heard her girlfriend crying as she vanished from sight up the Hotel stairwell.

At last, Angel broke the silence.

“Soooo, Dollface is takin’ this whole ‘secret identity you kept from her’ thing reeeeal rough, huh?” he snarked, both sets of arms folded and an eyebrow raised tauntingly at her.

Vaggie gave a half-hearted scoff and turned her back to him. Ignore him, and he’d stop, right?

Wrong. “No wonder your trust exercises were shit.”

“Shut up, Angel,” she growled back.

“Kid‘s got a point,” Husk butted in, coming – annoyingly – to Angel’s defence as he returned with a fresh bottle of cheap booze. He plonked his butt back in the armchair with a grunt. “Throwin’ us into a warzone, expectin' us to fight our way out? You being an Exorcist explains why you put us through that shitshow.”

“Yeahhhh,” Angel concurred, waggling his hand così così, “it was giving ‘shitty drill sergeant.’” 

Oh, he had no idea what a real shitty drill sergeant was like. Vaggie shook off the memory of Lute that had wormed its way into her mind, as well as the phantom ache that had suddenly flared up in her back. 

Pentious, still stroking Keekee, nodded idly. “Yesss, it wasss… harsssh. Though I mussst admit it did bring usss clossser together…”

Angel rolled his eyes. “Get offa da fence, Pen’.”

“I liked it!” Niffty piped up, kneeling on the floor and having just impaled a couple of obliviously fornicating bugs with her favourite sewing needle. She looked at Vaggie guilelessly. “I wish you’d thrown me off the building too.” 

“‘Course you do, Niff’,” Husk grumped. 

“Didn’t you use to enjoy getting into bullshit turf wars?” Vaggie asked Angel, very pointedly.

“Only when I wanted to,” the porn star retorted, unfussed. He draped one arm casually over the back of the sofa. “It’s called consent, Vagina. Tried to teach ya about that at the dungeon I took us all to, but ya didn’t wanna listen.”

“Don’t call me that.” Vaggie bristled. She did not need to be deadnamed. She did not need to be reminded of Adam right now, not after what he’d done to her and Charlie. 

“Eh, sorry, toots. You lost correct name privileges when ya lied.” Angel stuck his chin out leeringly, and Vaggie felt her gut twist at the accusing bite to that last word. The spider then glanced at the ceiling thoughtfully, scratching at his chin. “Are all Exorcists named after a woman’s parts?”

Yes, unfortunately. All her former sisters had similarly objectifying names. Clitorissa. Labianne. Titilia. Areol. Vulvala. Pusstricia, of all things. The Exorcists numbered in the thousands, and Adam had gotten lazy with coming up with names for his girls over the years. Some even had the same names (spelt differently, if they were lucky), so they picked nicknames to differentiate themselves, nicknames like Vala, or Tilly, or Trisha. Others had nicknames foisted upon them… nicknames like Vajasaurus.

(Vaggie had always resented that Lute had gotten off so lightly in comparison to her. Yes, she knew there was an innuendo in Lute’s name, but it was subtle; you had to think about the motions of playing a stringed musical instrument to figure it out.)

But she wasn’t going to answer Angel’s question and give him more ammunition to goad her with. 

Speaking of – Angel had kept on rambling out a stream-of-consciousness barrage of questions. “…And are there any male Exorcists? Never seen any fellas out there, aside from the big boss.” He snorted. “Hey, hey – Charlie said that when she met him he wanted her to call him ‘Dickmaster’. Did he really make you bitches call him dat?”

“…He did.” Vaggie pressed a hand to her forehead. She was almost afraid to ask. “Where are you going with this, Angel?”

“Weeeell…” He coyly coiled a lock of hair around one finger, and a lock of chest fluff around another. “How big was it?”

She recoiled. “What the FUCK—why would you even ask me that?! Why would you think I would know?!”

“I know, I know, you’re a dyke,” Angel flapped a hand at her. She growled at his use of the slur. “And I’m not sayin’ ya fucked or anything – but I know guys! They all like talkin’ about their dicks, and how they’re so long and girthy…” He arched his back, moaning the words out lasciviously while putting on the trademark Angel Dust O-face.

Vaggie's fingers twitched, craving her spear.

“They like to give out measurements, too, that’s why I’m askin’. Though they usually exaggerate by, like, an inch. Trust me, I know first-hand.” In the middle of miming a handjob, Angel caught sight of her reaction and grinned. “What? Wanna stab me, ex-Exorcist?”

“…No…”

“Ya sureeee?” he cooed, taunting her. 

Vaggie folded her arms, sticking her hands under her armpits so she wouldn’t be tempted to follow through on her urge, and turned away, muttering under her breath. “Quisiera tirarte un cuchillo a la cabeza a otra vez—”

“Hey, when’d you throw a knife at Angel?” Shit. Husk knew Spanish?! 

“Ooh, so violent!” Angel mock-swooned, falling back across Pentious’s lap - Keekee fitting perfectly under the arch of his back - to scritch under the bartender’s chin. “Thanks for carin’, kitty-cat.”

Husk grumbled, which Vaggie would’ve taken as annoyance were it not for the fact that he didn’t immediately push Angel off, and that his pupils had dilated just a bit.

“It was before everything—it was after his turf war stunt that ruined Charlie’s first interview!” she protested. “And I wasn’t trying to kill him! Just… maim. Or,” she added, as a petty bit of inspiration struck, “maybe shave.”

Angel sat bolt upright, eyes alight, and jabbed a finger at her indignantly. “Hey, don’t you fuckin’ get any ideas. This floof is priceless! And it ain’t insured! Val’s a cheapskate.”

“Ooh! Ooh!” Niffty put her hand up and waved it very fast “Can you throw a knife at me?”

Vaggie ignored her.

Husk continued to stare at her in silence. She couldn’t ignore the discomforting sense that he was seeing right through her, and assessing her. She did not like feeling exposed like that. 

“What?” she demanded. 

“You know, I knew you hated yourself,” the cat said gruffly, “but I didn’t know you were this much of a hypocrite.”

Vaggie groaned and rubbed her temples, the discomfort of this bout of probing-too-deep-into-her-psyche giving her a headache. Or maybe it was the sleep deprivation. She’d been lying awake all through the night before her and Charlie’s trip to heaven, worrying about the trial and her secret, and by the time she and Charlie were sent back to Hell it had been functionally morning. “Okay, I know I was wrong for what I did, for – for killing sinners, for taking part in a genocide—”

“Eh, I don’t give two shits about that.” Husk waved a dismissive paw, surprising her. “We all got body counts here. We’ve all done fucked-up shit. But you, lyin’ to the Princess about your past? Most of this whole ‘redemption’ bullshit she’s been makin’ us do has been about trust and honesty, and you’ve been the hardest on all of us for our sins when you don’t even practice what you preach.”

“I regret what I did!” she rebutted. “That’s more than I can say for some of us here. Angel.” She shot a glare at him, and he flipped her off. 

Husk’s eyes narrowed. “If you regret it,” he asked piercingly, “then why are you always so quick to pull your spear on half the demons you meet?”

Vaggie spluttered. She didn’t have an answer to that; Husk had her there. It was the truth. But he didn’t get it – no one else did. She had to protect Charlie. She just had to, okay?

“Like I said,” the bartender finished, his voice suddenly mild, “you’re a hypocrite. And trust me, self-hatred doesn’t equal making amends.”

“Oh, is that why yer such a hardass?” Angel asked wryly.

And Vaggie snapped. She’d had enough of this judgement. “Well, at least I’ve been trying to do something to atone and help Charlie! What have you all been doing?” She pointed at the porn star first. “You still don’t show up to, like, half your therapy sessions, not to mention the group exercises you miss! I don’t think you’ve even tried to make more time away from your job, and I’m sure you’re still hiding a drug stash somewhere in the Hotel!”

“I am not—I said I wasn’t!” Angel genuinely looked and sounded hurt at the accusation. “You think it’s really that fucking simple to get away from someone like Val?”

”I don’t know,” Vaggie shot back, “‘cause I can’t tell if you’re taking responsibility for your own soul—!”

Husk came to Angel’s defence a second time; wings flaring out, he stood and jabbed an accusing claw back at Vaggie. “Hey! You haven’t seen a bit of how responsible this guy can be! Why don't you give your first patron some credit—”

“And you!” Vaggie didn’t give him a chance to finish. She’d said her piece about Angel, the others had said their piece about her, now she had to combat them and prove that they weren’t better than her. “You serve drinks at a—a man-cave bar that shouldn’t even be in a rehab meant to discourage sin! And you drink so much you probably have more alcohol than blood in your veins! You're one to talk about responsibility!”

“Eh, you know what, that’s – that’s fair.” Husk shrugged, taking another swig from his bottle to further prove her point.

Vaggie turned her attention to Pentious. “He’s still designing weapons!” The serpent had indeed gotten out a notepad and started scribbling something down, using Keekee as a desk. He startled as she gestured to him.

“I—I—uhh—it’sss only theoretical!” he protested, scrambling to get the notepad back to the safety of his pocket.

Vaggie snatched it away from him before he could. She scrutinised the page he’d been doodling on. It held nothing more than a jumble of vague diagrams, equations, and chemical symbols she couldn’t for the life of her figure out. “What is this?”

“Ah—well, you sssee, I’ve been on the verge of a breakthrough with the use of angelic sssteel in my ray gun for yearsss,” Pentious elaborated, with more than a touch of pride, “to harnessss its blessed energy for unssstoppable dessstructive power! Alasss, I was interrupted ssso many timesss…”

“By who?” Vaggie pressed further. 

He blushed and averted his eyes. “…Missss Cherri Bomb…” 

“And there it is.” She felt vindicated. “You got into turf wars, and you got hammered last night, all because you had the hots for a girl. You. Set. Youself. Back.” She poked Pentious in the chest, punctuating each word, making him quail and shrink back.

From his lap, Keekee gave Vaggie a chastising “mrrp.”

“Yeahhhh, about that…” Angel sucked in a breath through his teeth, “stiiiiiill not comfy you an’ all those other angels got to spy on our night of ‘fun and relaxation. I get voyeurism might be your kink, Vags, but, bitch, you really don’t know what consent is at all.” He patted Pentious on the back. “At least this guy does. A bit of chickenin’ out, a bit of a misunderstandin’, but you explained shit, and you didn’t get laid by the people ya didn’t want to lay ya, didja?” 

“Pleassse don’t remind me…” Pentious cringed even more, if that were possible, hiding his face behind his top hat. He tried to shrink his neck back into the collar of his suit, and it gave Vaggie the distinct impression of a turtle trying to hide in its shell.

She didn’t want to know the context of whatever had happened with him at that club. She pulled a face at Angel. “Well, you don’t seem to care about whether I consent or not to hearing about dick, or your sex life, or anyone else’s!” Pinching the bridge of her nose, she sighed heavily. “Forget it. My point is I don’t see any of you trying like I do to do better and redeem yourselves. None of you. Niffty is…” Niffty was now playing tic-tac-toe with her skewered cockroach corpses from earlier, “…well, Niffty. And Alastor?” She scoffed. “Don’t get me started on him.” 

“The guy who cleaned up this dump from the mess it was when I first moved in?” Angel deadpanned. He started counting off on his fingers, ignoring how Vaggie seethed more and more with each digit he raised. “Who protected us from the loan sharkies? And from this guy,” he hooked a thumb back in Pentious’s direction, causing the snake to cringe and hide his face again, “when he was blowing dat wall up? Speaking of, who repaired dat wall every time? And who got Niff’ and, most importantly, this handsome kitty their jobs here?” With the same hand, he blew a kiss to Husk.

“You know I ain’t gettin’ paid for this gig, kid,” the cat grumbled, without any bite.

“And you know I don’t get paid either, some days, in my line of work,” Angel purred back, coquettishly. 

That made Vaggie snap – it proved her point. Angel had turned his whole attention to flirting with the bartender, Husk was – somehow receptive to it now? – and Niffty and Pentious were completely distracted. No one was taking her seriously. No one was taking her efforts seriously. No one was taking redemption seriously. She couldn’t bottle up her anger any longer, not after everything she’d gone through today.

“¡Ay, por Dios!” She clenched her fists and stomped. Loudly. She could feel the bow in her hair curling itself up into a pair of horns.

Pentious flinched. Angel stiffened. Husk didn’t, but all three of them (and Niffty, and Keekee) finally gave her their undivided attention.

“Of course you’d get swept off your feet by the hijo de perra who swooped in and took all the credit at the right time!” she ranted, quivering with rage. “But I was the one helping Charlie right from the start, years before any of you arrived! I was with her trying to fix up this place, helping to put her plans together and make them realistic, studying how to even run a Hotel, when nobody else in all of Hell was! I’ve been doing my best to make sure her dream comes true since the day she found me, because she is a diamond in the rough of this realm, and she deserves better than to be surrounded by sinners and monsters who only want to corrupt her or drag her down with them!

“I may have done so much wrong, and I cannot not excuse myself for that – but I’m trying to make up for it, and I feel like I’m the only one in this hotel who’s trying to be better! I’m not still doing drugs, or selling my body, or trying to drink myself to double death – I am not doing the same thing that got me sent to this realm in the first place! I’m trying to help the only place and the only person who might save you guys from the Exterminations! Because I’m the only one who cares enough about it! About her!” Vaggie gestured at herself, desperately. “It has to be me! I have to do this!”

She panted into the aftermath of her outburst. She felt drained, with the rush of anger ebbing, and now she was vulnerable without it, starkly aware that what she said may have offended the others.

For a moment, though, Angel looked like he might somehow understand, despite today’s animosity. Then he narrowed his eyes, and his expression turned sardonic again. “So it’s not just the lack of tits you’re compensatin’ for.”

“Ugh!” She threw her hands up and began to pace again. They didn’t get it. They didn’t get how important Charlie was, not just to her, but to the universe. They didn’t get how important it was that redemption be possible, despite the odds, despite the mockery. But to do that, they needed to get it right the first time, and they had to follow the rules and morals and virtues Heaven laid down so that they could just get there. 

Even though it was showing mercy that had gotten her cast out, mutilated and abandoned by her sister-in-arms. 

Even though she had lied. 

Even though she was quick to anger, even though she coveted Charlie, even though they had definitely been having sex before marriage (but not so often, lately, with the mounting stress of trying to meet Adam’s arbitrary new deadline).

Maybe Husk was right, and she was the wrong person to be lecturing sinners, to have taken up this duty…

Vaggie shook those thoughts off. No, there were people worse and more sinful than her, here in this building. People who didn’t regret their deeds. People who revelled in their sins.

Her mind went to Alastor first. He was a prime example. A sadistic, smug mass murderer. She’d never taken pride in her kill count, like him, or derived visceral joy from the job of slaughtering sinners, like he openly did. She’d always felt shame for lying, and she was certain he definitely didn’t.

…It occurred to her, all of a sudden, that the Radio Demon hadn’t contributed to the conversation at all.

She thought he would have. He liked the sound of his own voice, he enjoyed other’s misery – he’d already taunted her plenty when he first arrived at the Hotel, and when she was struggling to pull together a commercial for the place. She’d been sure he would have mocked Charlie’s failure to change Heaven’s mind, or mock her for what she already blamed herself enough for, right alongside Angel Dust and Husk.

But he hadn’t. 

His silence felt off. 

Vaggie looked around, and noticed for the first time that Alastor’s preferred armchair was empty. “Where’s Alastor?”

And just like that, as if her very question had manifested it, there were two deep, resonating thuds from upstairs. She felt them rumble through her body and shake the floor. The first one sent a brief flash of golden flames lighting up the skylights like the dawn. 

But the second? The second cast a green aura that changed the colour of the whole Hotel lobby into something sickening and menacing. Arcane sigils and electric circuit pictograms flickered in and out of existence in the air, and lightning-like patterns crackled across the ceiling and flowed down the walls. 

Only one demon here had their power manifest like that. And the only possible place he could be was upstairs – with Charlie.

“Oh, no, no!!” Vaggie cried out, panicked. She made a mad dash for the stairs. She had to get upstairs, to Charlie. She had to protect her from Alastor. She had to…

But before she could even make it to the staircase, it was over. The light show cut off. The Hotel lobby went eerily and uncomfortably quiet again.

Everyone was on their feet now – or, in Pentious’s case, on his tail. He’d picked up Keekee, and cradled her comfortingly in his arms. Her ears were pinned back.

“¿Qué carajo?” Vaggie hissed, tensed up and still ready to bolt up the stairs at a moment’s notice. “What was that?”

Husk eyed the ceiling, rubbing at his neck. “Nothin’ good,” he said warily. 

“What do you mean, ‘nothing good?’”

“Means he’s really pissed off.” Vaggie’s heart plummeted.

“Why would Alastor be mad at Charlie?” Niffty asked naively. 

“Wh—Niffty, have you not seen the way he’s a creep with—?” Vaggie retorted, but she cut herself off. Of course Niffty hadn’t noticed any of it; given how she and Alastor got on like a house on fire, she was probably going to be on Al’s side. 

“Ey, calm yer flat tits,” Angel butted in. Vaggie snarled at him, and he quickly put his hands up. “You should know better than the rest of us, that flash of fire ‘n’ fireworks was Charlie! She almost took on Val, she can – probably – take care of herself against Al—”

“You don’t know that!” Vaggie was appalled. She knew better than anyone else Charlie was so completely pacifist and unpracticed in using her demon powers or authority. She’d just told the others, moments ago, that her girlfriend needed her protection. Especially against someone dangerous she’d let into Hotel against better judgement. 

The spider got in front of her, blocking her path upstairs. “Vaggie, I mean it, listen.” he insisted, earnestly. “Don’t jump in there an’ mess shit up like Charlie did for me—”

“¡Mierda!” she burst out. “None of you are taking this seriously!” She couldn’t stand Angel’s stalling and holding her up any longer. “Charlie’s in danger! ¡Sal de mi camino!” 

She shoved past him, and ran for the staircase again—

—and only made it up a few steps before shadows slunk down the walls, and Alastor reconstituted next to his armchair. 

It was remarkable how a demon with an unwavering smile could look so sour. Like he’d had to suck on a lemon, or gotten a bone stuck between his teeth, or been served mushy jambalaya. Or, more likely, given his dubious dietary habits, cooked meat; Vaggie had never seen him eating anything done more than rare, and rarely anything done more than blue. 

There was a tic in his eye, too. He was, very transparently, not happy.

Vaggie could not find any satisfaction in that; not enough to quell her fear. “What was that?” she demanded, storming towards him. “You were with Charlie, weren’t you? What were you doing with her?”

“Ooh, Vagina’s jealous!” Angel stage-whispered. She did her best to tune him out and not react this time. His jibes weren’t important right now, what Alastor might have done to Charlie was. She couldn’t show weakness in front of the Radio Demon.

“Yeah, boss, what was that about?” Husk seconded, flattening down his fur where it had stood up on end. He sounded rattled.

Alastor declined to give any answers. He adjusted his monocle, took his time brushing off his sleeves and coat, before he sat himself back down in his armchair, completely ignoring Vaggie. 

“Alastor. Tell me.” Her fist clenched, yearning to hold her weapon for real this time. She wanted to stab him in his ugly yellow-toothed mug. She didn’t care how it would look to the others anymore – in fact, she had the sneaking suspicion Husk might appreciate it. If Alastor had hurt Charlie in any way, she would gut him and take great satisfaction in doing so.

Finally, he acknowledged her presence and looked her dead in the eye, infuriatingly unreadable for several long seconds. Then, abruptly, like he was snapping out of a trance, he turned to the room at large.

“There’ll be no saving grace from our host this time, I’m afraid,” he announced disdainfully.

Shock ran through Vaggie like a spear. The room erupted.

“Wait—the fuck?!’

“HWHAT?!?”

“Aww, why?”

“The hell d’ya mean?” Husk demanded.

“It seems Charlie’s spark has gone out, her moxie vanished,” the Radio Demon lamented. Something in the way he drew it out made Vaggie’s blood boil so much worse. “She had such promise; I did what I could to try and inspire her, but… I doubt she is willing or able to circumvent our judgement this time.”

“So this is the straw that broke the camel’s back,” the bartender muttered, slumping back into his seat and producing his bottle of booze again. “Sure loves to sing, but she can’t face the music.”

“I refussse to believe it! Charlie would not give up on usss!” Pentious insisted, looking around for support, but no one seemed to share his sliver of faith. The longer he went without someone, anyone concurring with him, the more crestfallen he looked. Angel was visibly shaken and stressing out, like he was itching for a smoke or a hit of something. Niffty fidgeted anxiously with her apron. Even Keekee was on edge; to Pentious’s dismay, she’d leaped out of his arms and now was pacing back and forth herself, fur standing on end and tail lashing. 

If the living embodiment of the Hotel was this agitated, then Alastor wasn’t lying or bluffing. He was serious.

Dios mio, he was serious.

“What did you DO?!” Vaggie all but launched herself across the room, looming (to the best of her abilities) in front of Alastor. Even seated, he was still slightly taller than her, but she’d never let that stop her before and she wouldn’t let it stop her now. Maybe, if she still had her wings, she would’ve been much more intimidating. She wondered if, before she lost them, she could have actually put the fear of God into him and his black heart. 

Alastor sits in his armchair, smugly smiling at Vaggi, who points her spear at his throat, her hair hiding her facial expression from this side-on angle.

When he did nothing but stare levelly back, she whipped out her spear and aimed it at his throat. She didn’t like how his grin widened at that. “Answer me, cabrón! I knew you were out to sabotage us from the start! I saw how you were leering at Charlie all this time! What did you do to her?!”

“Perhaps,” Alastor purred, at length, “you should be asking that of yourself, cher ange.”

Vaggie’s gut lurched.

Because she knew he was right. Alastor wasn’t the one who had given Charlie a thousand-yard stare in the courtroom, who had sent her sinking to her knees reeling from the truth of who she was. Alastor hadn’t been spurned while trying to help Charlie back to her feet. Alastor hadn’t been an Exorcist and kept that fact a secret from the woman she loved. 

“That’s what we were just sayin’, Smiles!” Angel preened, vindicated. He waved not one, not two, but three hands in Vaggie’s direction. “She projects!” 

All eyes turned to her. 

Vaggie swallowed. 

Eyes.

She felt, rather than saw, the eyes. Eyes everywhere, watching. Red eyes, white eyes, pink eyes, peachy-yellow-orange eyes. Eyes shaped like teardrops. Eyes with concentric rings of colour dancing hypnotically in them. The eyes in the Hotel’s wallpaper. The eyes that sprouted, in little mushroom-like clusters, from the ground, from the pavement, from the cracks on the sides of buildings all over Pentagram City.

Her own eye, long torn out of her skull; it, with its optic nerve pierced by Lute’s sword, was there too, staring back at her. Condemning her. 

She blinked her way back to reality. The others’ eyes were still on her; glaring, or just staring, or smugly lidded. Only Pentious’s seemed truly concerned, flickering back and forth between her and Alastor.

If it were Charlie’s eyes looking upon her, if it were Charlie who was condemning her… how much worse would it feel?

Vaggie backed away: one unsure step, then another.

Then, sucking up the courage – because she was still more afraid of Charlie’s judgement than anyone and everyone else’s – she bolted for the stairs. 

 


 

She made it to the top floor of the Hotel in record time.

She was hardly out of breath – she may have had her wings taken from her, but she still had the extra respiratory capacity the ability to fly had granted her, and she put the work in to maintain it. The one thing Vaggie did begrudgingly appreciate from her Exorcist past was the fitness regiment, gruelling though it was, so she had carried it over to her present. She still demanded from herself the same level of fitness that Adam and Lute once had – but for very different reasons. She had reclaimed it for the sake of protecting Charlie, not for Adam’s objectifying ogling… and not for culling Charlie’s people.

That was the reason Vaggie paused at the door to their room: thinking of her girlfriend, and being reminded that she’d betrayed Charlie’s values, keeping her identity and past hidden away out of selfish fear. Remembering their last interaction, how Charlie had flinched away from her touch and her voice. 

Charlie. Flinching away from her.

It was her worst fear, something she hadn’t dared think about much in the past, because it gave her nightmares: nightmares of Charlie leaving her behind in that alley, or walking away from her – and straight into harm’s way, with no one there to protect her. 

Now her fears had become real, and her nightmares had almost come true. Because she wasn’t there, Alastor had tried to do something to Charlie. She didn’t know what, so her imagination was running wild with it. But was she so wrong to suspect him? After all, the creep had slapped her on the ass on the day he arrived at the Hotel, while he dazzled and distracted Charlie with his knockoff song-and-dance.

All Vaggie wanted to do was make sure Charlie was okay, and comfort her.

But if Charlie had reacted the way she did when they got back from Heaven, would she even want to see Vaggie now?

No, no, Vaggie couldn’t think like that. It had been hours since the hearing in Heaven’s courthouse. Maybe that was enough time for Charlie to have calmed down a little – at least, enough for her to be willing to see Vaggie? Plus, she’d obviously just been accosted by Alastor. That could have redirected her anger and mistrust, reminded her who she could count on to be on her side.

Vaggie took a deep breath, stepped forward, and tried the doorhandle. It was locked.

Another painful stab of guilt. Charlie had never shut her out like this before.

Hesitantly, she reached out and knocked. “Charlie?”

There was no answer. 

“Charlie, it’s me. Alastor told us you’d… given up.” She pressed herself against the door, as close as she could, hoping Charlie would hear her soft voice and no one else. “He’s lying, isn’t he? Please, please tell me he’s lying,” she pleaded. 

Still no answer. 

“Did he try anything?” Alastor had been so touchy-feely with Charlie before, and Vaggie couldn’t dislodge the worry that he had done more than just putting his hands on her shoulders, or putting his arm around her waist, or redirecting and shunting her wherever he wanted her to go.

Then she recalled how Alastor had extended his hand and summoned his glowy green demonic powers the second Charlie agreed to accept his offer of ‘help’ – so eager to entrap her. “Or did he try to make a deal with you? You didn’t take it, did you? He came downstairs all pissed off, I’m… guessing you didn’t?” 

Still nothing.

“Charlie?”

Nothing. 

“Are you okay?”

Vaggie pressed her ear to the door, trying to hear inside. She thought she heard a muffled sob. She fretted even more. “Charlie, please, let me in, I—”

(♪ It starts with sorry
That’s your foot in the door
♪)


Shit. Why hadn’t she started with an apology?

Well, she had; she’d tried to apologise when they got back from Heaven… once she was done letting out her fury and pain at the male chauvinist who had outed her and ruined her girlfriend’s dream… but maybe Charlie hadn’t heard it. Maybe she’d been in a state of shock, and that could explain why she’d fled, too.

Charlie was usually very receptive to apologies. Vaggie knew it. Her girlfriend had forgiven Pentious for being a spy the moment he’d started snivelling and crying on the floor from being caught. She should have hope that Charlie might forgive her. She mustn’t have apologised enough. She just had to do it again, and hope Charlie heard her this time.

Vaggie took a deep breath.

“I’m sorry, Charlie, I really am. I know I should have told you earlier what I was, I know that it was wrong of me…”

Death rained from the skies in the form of her and her sisters, scattering across the infernal sprawl of Pentagram City to individually hunt down their targets. Vaggie picked her first mark: a red-haired, green-skinned sinner wearing mismatched spaulders. She ran them down and disposed of them quickly, cleanly, efficiently. Another threat to Heaven dealt with, she told herself – but her duty was never done. As long as she kept doing it to the best of her ability, she could earn her peace for the rest of the year and go back to an antisocial existence in the realm she was protecting. 

“…to keep my past a secret when it goes against everything you stand for… it’s just…”

Training. Senior exorcist after senior exorcist drilled into the new inductees’ skulls that they must never reveal any details of their mission to the Winners. Per the High Seraphim’s orders, no one but the Exorcists could know about the Exterminations.

“…Adam and Lute, they…”

Vaggie hit the ground with a scream of agony, opening her eye in time to see a sword skewer her other, cut-out eyeball. Her commanding officer’s boot pressed down hard on back of her neck, pinning her to the ground, and hands grabbed her wings, pulled… and ripped them clean off, showering her in a spray of her own blood.

The last thing Vaggie remembered before she passed out was Lute handing Adam her halo as they walked away and left her behind. Left her to die.

“…I mean, I was waiting for the right time to tell you, I…”

Adam loomed over her, leering, trying to blackmail her into betraying Charlie with the threat of outing her as an angel. Their court hearing was in hours, if not minutes, and Charlie would still be out with the younger seraph squeeing over cute animals until then. There would be no time to tell her what she'd meant to tell her on her own terms; Vaggie had squandered her chances and been robbed of her choice…

“…we… we had so much going on, there was so much on your plate…”

She watched from the sidelines as Charlie scrambled back and forth, pinning notes and clippings to an evidence board, trying to figure out why none of the Hotel residents had been redeemed yet… and she felt guilt, again, for keeping her secret. But it wasn’t the right time to tell Charlie, not when she was struggling. It would destroy her even more to know the truth right now. 

“…A-and I didn’t want to hurt you…”

Lute yanked Trisha away by her curly hair, and even as Adam grabbed Vaggie by the wrist, Trisha was all she could think about. She’d been trying to help her hurting friend, to give her some comfort, some solidarity, some respite from the way their commanding officers had mistreated her… and she had just made it all worse.

The memory of Trisha’s cry of pain, and her absence from the barracks, would haunt Vaggie’s sleep for the next few weeks.

“…I promise I’m not the person I was back then. The minute I realised what I was doing, I wanted to leave who I was behind…”

She staggered to her feet, struggling to gather up her blood-soaked, disembodied wings in her arms. She clumsily shoved the lid off of a nearby trash can, and stuffed the wings in there frantically, followed by her chainmail collar, her outer gloves, her grey battledress, her boots – everything but her tunic, her liner gloves, and the remains of her leggings. She had to act fast. If any demon saw her and recognised her for what – for who she was, they would attack her and kill her, or worse…

“…and make someone new of myself. Someone you could be proud of.”

The pretty blonde woman in the pink tuxedo knelt before her, producing bandages from her pocket and oh-so-tenderly wrapping her eye socket. Vaggie’s heart fluttered, and her mind boggled at this unexpected kindness. Charity. Compassion. Care. A part of her knew she was safe, somehow, in this dark pit they called Hell… but all of her, every fibre of her being now hated the mass-murdering soldier she’d been. She’d killed so many, and it had taken almost killing a child sinner for her to suck it up and stop.

Though she was so very grateful for it, Vaggie didn’t think she deserved this kindness, kindness that she’d never truly known before.

“…Someone worthy of you.”

Vaggie felt herself trembling as her voice trailed off. Ugh, she knew it sounded like she was just making excuses, even though she really was trying to tell the truth as best she could. She just didn’t have the words. She didn’t know what to say that would fix this and make Charlie not so frightened and hurt by her.

But she knew what she wanted to do, and that was to protect Charlie. Always. To shelter and adore her.

She strained her ears, trying to tell if her girlfriend was still crying, or if she’d maybe, hopefully, been receptive to her apology attempt. “Can I come in?”

“No! Go away!”

Vaggie’s heart ached.

Charlie didn’t want to see her right now, and it hurt so bad that the best thing she could do right now was be away from her partner. But she had to serve her girl, her hon, her lover. She had to respect her boundaries, and do whatever she asked.

“Okay,” she said. “Okay. I’ll be right out here. Whenever you want—whenever you need me,” she added, a little quieter.

And she turned around and leant against the door, sliding down until she was sitting on the floor. She took up her spear, and steadied her breathing so the lump in her throat wouldn’t turn into tears.

Charlie didn’t want to see her right now, but that was okay. Vaggie was still Charlie’s armour, and she could still protect her. Would still protect her. Would do anything to keep her girlfriend safe and give her every chance of making her dream a reality, despite the adversity they were facing right now. She would wait until Charlie was ready to talk, but, regardless, she was here for her. She had a duty to carry out.

Vaggie let her head rest against the door, and sighed, steeling herself for staying guard as long as she needed to.

She would make sure Alastor didn’t try anything else to hurt or take advantage of Charlie. Or anyone else, if they tried to get to her from inside the Hotel.

She would always be there for Charlie, somehow.

Whatever it took.

Vaggi sits against the door to her and Charlie’s room, eyes closed, looking sad. She holds her spear.

Afterword

End Notes

Chapter 4 coming…

Please drop by the Archive and comment to let the creator know if you enjoyed their work!