Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warnings:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of A Deal Not Taken AU
Stats:
Published:
2026-11-15
Updated:
2026-11-15
Words:
13,958
Chapters:
3/18
Hits:
4

A Deal Not Taken

Chapter 2: refusal

Summary:

Charlie, whatever you do, do NOT make a deal with him!

Charlie makes a different choice when Alastor offers her that deal. No one walks away happy.


Chapter Text

Charlie Morningstar, the Princess of Hell and the daughter of Lucifer, had been holed up in her room, crying in bed, for hours. Hours since her unceremonious, forcible return from Heaven, with nothing but that awful memory of it playing on repeat inside her head. 

Nothing but her failure to dwell on. Nothing to do but remember, and hurt, and cry.

How could she not cry? Victory had been snatched away from her, so, so cruelly. And she’d been so close, too! Heaven’s court had been in an uproar, an actual Seraphim arguing on her side, making her elder sister shrink back in shame! She had brought to light before the jury the very existence of the Exterminations, and not only that but exposed the Achilles’ heel of Heaven’s moral posturing: that they didn’t even know what made a soul worthy of being saved in the first place! That they had no moral right to condemn sinners, let alone cull them!

The angels in the courthouse had even seemed about to change their minds! Everything had been going so well!

…And then Adam and his second-in-command had pulled back the curtains on who Vaggie had really been, and both Charlie’s case and her resolve had collapsed like a house of cards. And she’d had nothing.

All because Vaggie had lied to her.

Well, hidden the truth – but wasn’t that the same thing? Lying by omission? Concealment?

Paltering?

Confabulation?

…

Did it even matter?

Vaggie had still been an Exorcist, and Charlie had faltered when she’d found out. Adam had gotten his way, and now her home and her friends… and girlfriend… were right in the firing line, with a month to go till the next Extermination and no chance of getting another meeting with Heaven. No chance of changing their minds. No time to redeem anybody. No hope of saving her people from the slaughter. All she had done was paint a big fat bullseye on the Hazbin Hotel.

If Vaggie had just told her she was an angel when she’d found her… this could all have been avoided. 

Charlie sobbed anew, gritting her teeth. She accepted another tissue from Razzle. Or was it Dazzle? Her vision was so blurred with tears she couldn’t tell her lifelong companions apart as they hovered within arms reach off the right side of their bed. 

She tried not to think about how this side of the bed was Vaggie’s. 

…

Oh. She was thinking about it.

She tried instead to concentrate on getting the tissue to her face. She tried to let the weight of the blankets ground and comfort her. That seemed like a good idea… yeah, just think about the bed, Charlie. Not Vaggie. Think about the colour of the sheets (purple, the colour that Vaggie had picked out), or the sensation of the shed hairs tickling her nose and the back of her neck.

Or how those hairs belonged to Vaggie. Or that she was lying on Vaggie’s side of the bed, or that Vaggie rolled around restlessly in her sleep if Charlie wasn’t there next to her, or on top of her; touching her in some way…

Or that she’d kept her past a secret the whole time they’d known each other.

…

Welp, there she was, still thinking about Vaggie.

Stillllllll thinking about her.

It was kind of like the ‘don’t think of a pink elephant’ thought exercise she’d read up on: she had to think about Vaggie when she was thinking about not thinking about her, and that was so confusing… but not as confusing as the fact Vaggie had just… lied to her. Or that Charlie had somehow never thought to look further than her initial presumption that Vaggie was a sinner, and her girlfriend had just played along with it. How had she not noticed that Vaggie might be more than she appeared? Why had she thought nothing of the grey tunic and the hint of feathers hastily stuffed inside a gold-stained trash can in the same alley she’d found her girlfriend? 

She felt so stupid.

She sobbed again. She blew her nose, and, for a moment, gave no mind to how the sound of it seemed to carry on, hissy and staticky, even after the used tissue had been discarded.

Between Razzle and Dazzle, a shadow sprouted from the floor and resolved itself into a red suit worn on a tall and lanky frame. “Oh, Charlie, Charlie, Charlie. Aren’t you an absolute mess.”

The Goat Bois parted like the Red Sea.

There were many people Charlie didn’t want to see right now – no, scratch that, she couldn’t stomach seeing anyone right now. Her friends, her dad… she was sure they’d be so disappointed in her. She’d failed them. She wouldn’t be able to stand seeing that disappointment in their eyes, even if they pitied her or tried to comfort her. And she didn’t want to see Vaggie for… obvious reasons.

Stop thinking about her, Charlie!

But Alastor? The Radio Demon? She knew he wasn’t here to offer any pity or comfort. She knew he wasn’t disappointed in her – the opposite, if anything. He was here to enjoy her despair and her failure. And, in a lot of ways, that was worse. Pity stung, but mockery? That was an old wound being reopened. That ached.

She pouted at him, and burrowed deeper under the blankets. “Go away, Alastor.”

Alastor did not go away. He sat himself down at the foot of her bed. “Now, now, I’m only concerned! Is this any way to act after picking a fight with all of Heaven and dooming everyone you love?”

The reminder nearly made Charlie start crying again. “It is! I don’t need you mocking me right now! I have enough on my mind without hearing your sadistic idea of a joke, asshole.” She rolled over…

…And found his face just inches away from hers. “Who’s joking?”

Charlie yelped and tumbled out of her own bed.

Alastor smiled down at her innocently, like he hadn’t teleported himself right next to her and spooked the living daylights out of her. “You have a captive audience downstairs, waiting to hear what scheme you’re cooking up, what kind of inspiring performance you have planned next!” He swept his arm through the air theatrically, as if conducting an orchestra. Oh, and it certainly was all a show to him, not a fight against literal genocide with her friends’ afterlives on the line. 

“I can’t!” Charlie picked herself up off the floor, only to sit back down again against the side of the bed. “I can’t think of any way to solve this. And how can I face the others when I failed them? They came here to be saved, and all I did was make them a target!” Fresh tears filled her eyes, and she scrubbed them away. “I’m worse than the cruellest Overlords! At least they don’t go around giving false hope.”

“My, my! I never expected to hear such miserable, defeatist self-loathing from our starry-eyed demon belle!” That was such a blatant lie. Of course he did. The gleeful chirp in his voice gave it away. Everybody wanted to see Charlie break. 

She stormed to her feet in a sudden fury. “Oh, fuck you, Alastor! All you do is stand there smiling—” He wasn’t standing, he was lying prone on her bed, kicking his legs back and forth in the air – but he was smiling as wide as ever. “—while you watch us struggle! You belittle me for wanting to save sinners, for trying to make Hell a better place – it’s like you want us to fail, and the Exterminations to keep on happening!” She turned her back on him. “I don’t know how you can find that entertaining. I don’t know how you can enjoy it so much.” In a way, she did want to understand why he was like that, so that she could change his mind, prove him wrong about his worldview, and maybe even redeem him too… but it revolted her just to try and comprehend the notion of getting a kick from other peoples’ suffering. 

Claw-like fingers curled over her shoulders from behind. 

“Ah,” Alastor chuckled darkly, “but just because you see a smile, my dear, don’t think you know what’s going on underneath!” He twirled her around to face him. Grabbing her cheeks, he pulled the corners of her mouth into a facsimile of a grin she didn’t feel one bit like wearing. “A smile is a valuable tool; after all, you’re never fully dressed without one! It inspires your friends, keeps your enemies guessing, and ensures that, no matter what comes your way, you’re the one in control.”

With that, he let her go, poking her in the chest with his staff for emphasis. Charlie pushed it away.

“But I’m not! I’m the farthest thing from ‘in control!’” She found herself pacing over to the huge window that overlooked Pentagram City, and she leaned against it, not really looking out over the uncaring urban skyline that never seemed to give a damn about its own damnation, but inwards, at her own failure. “The person I trust most has been lying to me about who she was for our whole relationship, Heaven refuses to change their mind, and even if they did, I can’t prove the Hotel works. Adam has an invincible army pointed right at my doorstep, the Extermination is still going to happen, and there’s nothing—” she beat her fist against the glass, “—I can do—about any of it!”

She panted into the stillness that followed, her breath fogging up the windowpane.

She didn’t know why she had vented like this to the guy who had openly told her that he didn’t share any of her goals, the guy who wanted to see the sinners in her care fail to redeem themselves and rub it in her face. A part of her still wished she could have talked to her girlfriend instead, just now, the first person who’d supported her goals, who’d let her express her anguish and frustration without judgement, who’d given her a safe space where she didn’t have to force herself to be optimistic or keep carrying her mother’s hope all the time.

But Vaggie had kept her own past from Charlie for years. She had been an exorcist. She had killed sinners – who knew how many, for who knows how long.

Could Charlie trust that Vaggie had ever truly believed in her dream?

Behind her, the hum of static rose in volume. She squeezed her eyes shut, and steeled herself to be made fun of again.

But the mockery didn’t come.

“♪ I know something you don’t knooow… ♪” Alastor sing-songed.

“Huh?” Charlie’s eyes snapped open, and she whipped around.

The Radio Demon was, all of a sudden, very invested in plucking leaves from the potted plant on her bedside table. “You seem so sure your impending doom is a foregone conclusion. That those big scary angels are just as indestructible as they seem.”

“It… is? They are?” But now Charlie wasn’t certain of that. Whatever Alastor was hinting at, he sounded absolutely sure of it. An anxious spark of hope rekindled inside her. “Al, what are you talking about?”

“Just that you and your little band of misfits might stand more of a chance than you think.” Alastor walked away, coyly. In the back of her mind, the voice that sounded the most like Vaggie (why are you still THINKING about her, Charlie?) reminded her that Alastor was baiting her. 

But she took the bait anyway, and trailed after him. She had to.

A myriad of improbable possibilities raced through her mind. Was Alastor able to contact Heaven with his radio powers, so she could ask for another meeting without having to admit to her dad that she’d wasted the chance he’d given her? Could he directly reach out to Emily, since she probably would be the only high-ranking angel on Charlie’s side? Were his own demonic abilities capable of shielding against the Exorcists’ weapons?

Could a sinner who’d arrived in Hell with such unprecedented power know something that her mom – and dad – hadn’t told her?

“How?” she begged. “I’ll do anything!”

Alastor stopped in his tracks and snapped his head around a hundred and eighty degrees. He looked victorious. “Anything?” 

Charlie froze. She had the strongest impression that she’d made a big mistake.

With a flourish, the Radio Demon twisted the rest of his body around to face her and proffered his left hand. “Then… let’s make a deal!” 

A shiver ran down her spine.

She remembered.

“Charlie, listen to me.”

She remembered her father, bouncing her on his knee when she was just a little kid, conjuring up light show of ugly creatures being banished by a golden heroine as he told her for the very first time: “You don’t take shit from other demons!”

“You can’t believe this creep! He’s a dealmaker! Pure evil!”

She remembered Alastor himself, purring salaciously, belittling her belief in better things and second chances to her face: “I want to watch the scum of the world struggle to better themselves, only to trip and fall into the fiery pit of failure…”

“AND he’s most likely looking for a way to destroy everything we’re trying to do!”

She remembered her own voice, as she (gently, of course) slapped away Alastor’s proffered hand and nipped the menacing green glow of his gathering powers in the bud: “Nope! No shaking! No deals, or magic tricks, or strings attached!” 

“Charlie, whatever you do…” 

And she remembered someone clutching her arms, the voice of an angel beseeching her, pleading, louder than all of the other warnings and omens and memories that came before:

“… do NOT make a deal with him!”

That made up her mind for her.

Charlie stepped out of handshake range. “No.”

Alastor’s smile was unwavering, but his ear twitched, and there was a spike in the static that accompanied him wherever he went. “I’m sorry? I must have misheard—”

“No.” Charlie repeated, doing her best to sound authoritative, like a Princess of Hell should… like her mother would’ve wanted. (Like Vaggie would’ve wanted.) “I don’t want your deal.”

He grinned wider, and laughed – but it was a tight laugh, like how he sounded whenever the subject of television came up in conversation. “Why, Charlie, you must be feeling better already if you have time for jokes!” 

His microphone burst into life. “I say, the dame must still be dizzy from her heavenly misadventure—!”

“Shut UP!” Charlie clenched her fist, and the canned laughter cut off with a screech. “I’m not kidding! I mean it! No!”

Alastor blinked. He clutched his staff to his chest, and stroked the top of the microphone as if comforting a frightened pet. “That was rude.”

“Well, so is coming into my room without knocking!” she shot back. “What do you take me for, Alastor? You think I can’t tell you’re trying to take advantage of me right now?”

He gasped and placed his fingertips against his chest, making a big show of offense. “A gentleman would never—!”

“Then why can’t you just tell me what you know?”

“Information has a price, dear.”

Charlie felt a knot tighten in the pit of her stomach. This was exactly what Vaggie had warned her about when Alastor first showed up at the Hotel. “You want my soul, don’t you?”

“Your soul? Heavens, no! What could I possibly do with a soul such as yours? Besides, what I know isn’t worth as much as you are.” Ugh. That was slimier than Sir Pentious. “All I would be asking from you is a favour! One itty-bitty favour!” Alastor pinched his fingers together. “What’s a favour between friends?”

“Friends wouldn’t dangle something important over my head like this,” Charlie scoffed. “Friends would just tell me.” Vaggie didn’t tell you she was an angel, her mind reminded her, and she felt another pang in her heart.

“Why, Charlie,” Alastor admonished, “I thought you’d be more trusting, what with the kinds of sinner you’ve taken under your wing. And after all I’ve done for the Hotel? This suspicion is not in your nature.”

“Not in my—?” Oh, she was enraged. How dare he tell her who she was. “You think I’m naive? Don’t tell me you don’t, I know you and—and the whole rest of Hell think I am! ‘Oh, look at little miss rainbows, she thinks the sun shines out of everyone’s asses, she’s so gullible and useless and she matters so little!’” It hurt so bad to repeat the things she’d heard being said about her: Katie Killjoy’s ridiculing, Lute’s sneering, all the mocking that she’d faced for her dreams of trying to help Sinners and just do good. She blinked away any tears before they had a chance to well up in her eyes. “But you’re wrong. I’m not ignorant. I’m not blind to the fact that sinners do bad things! I am the Princess of Hell, and I’ve lived in Hell for two hundred years – that’s longer than you’ve been here!” 

Alastor’s smirk grew ranklingly wider at that. Charlie didn’t spare it more than a moment’s notice and irritation, and she sure didn’t stop.

“Yes, I believe that every demon has good inside of them, and can choose to change for the better, but I know that out there, there are souls who have done – choose to do – cruel, mean, horribly fucked-up things!” She thought of Valentino, briefly, and the way he’d dragged Angel out of his dressing room so roughly and made her friend look so frightened, so cowed. But Alastor was the one here in front of her right now, the guy who’d professed to finding suicides and orphans amusing, who had felled overlords just for the fun of it, whose broadcasts were filled with screams of pain and terror. “Sinners like you. I know your reputation, I was warned about you!” 

“Ah, but by who, dear?” he asked, piercingly. “Those newsreel narrators on the picture box? Your impotent, absentee father?” 

“Don’t insult my—” Charlie tried to interject, but she’d lost her momentum. Alastor steamrolled on.

“Or was it your sweetheart, who – what was it? – concealed her heavenly identity from you for as long as she could manage?” He started stalking towards her, backing her down. “What makes you think you can trust them any more than me? What makes you think they could give you what I am offering to support your kitschy aspirations?

“And how badly do you really want to save these sinners from their demise, if you’re turning down the only way in which you can?”

Charlie flinched. She didn’t have a comeback for that; his words had hit home. What if he was right?

For just a moment, pinwheeling tuning dials flashed in Alastor’s eyes. “I am being generous with you, Charlie. A favour, in exchange for what I know.”

She glared up at him, fuming, her chest heaving. She wanted to be defiant, but she didn’t think she was doing a good job at it. She tried to fold her arms, but she suspected it looked more like she was hugging herself.

A part of her mind told her that if there was a chance Alastor was right, she should accept his offer, and then she could deal with the consequences of it later. Another part of her mind resisted, and countered the first, telling her she should stick with her gut instinct that he was trying to extort her and trick her. But her gut instinct also told her that fighting off Heaven and saving her friends was the most important thing of all, and hadn’t she meant it when she’d said she’d do anything to know what the secret to fighting off angels was?

She was at war with herself, and she didn’t know which side to pick anymore. She didn’t know what she should do.

Alastor’s expression softened, as if he could sense her inner turmoil.

“I know what you’re thinking,” he purred, coiling around her, the radio filter gone from his voice. “That you can somehow do this on your own. And believe me, I know, oh I know that foolhardy determination well. But you’re unpractised, Charlie. You suppress your true power. No, you wouldn’t know what to do with yourself if you tried to go it alone. You’ve said as much already. You need guidance. From someone with… hands-on experience. Someone who, dare I say, has already been invaluable to this project of ours?”

Abruptly, he straightened up, voice and countenance returning to his usual chirpy self. “And we can’t have all your potential going to waste in a pointless last stand! So, shake my hand, and you get to save your friends.” Once more, he extended an open hand to her, in the showiest, twirliest way possible. “Whaddaya say?” 

Charlie didn’t say anything. She eyed Alastor’s open palm warily.

But she couldn’t help but think of how his words rung true. As much as the Story of Hell Lilith had left her was a comfort to her, she also felt the weight of her mother’s expectations on her when she read it. She didn’t know how she was supposed to carry on her mother’s hope successfully. Her father, even before he shut her out, had never taught her much of how to use her demonic powers, and high school hadn’t been any better in that area (especially with Hellsa Von Eldritch around, distracting her from studies with cliquey bully bullshit). She just tried to be authentic to herself and her values, going through trial and error, and, after so many years of trying and trying and trying, she had to admit it felt like she was getting nowhere. 

Not even with her dad’s help.

Not even with Vaggie.

And the fact that Alastor wasn’t calling her useless, like so many other demons did – even if he did demean her lack of experience, and even if the way he talked about her power and potential was kinda creepy – in a way, it felt like a show of faith in her. Something that Mom might be proud of her for. A show of faith that few had ever put in her before.

Vaggie hadn’t trusted her enough to tell her she was an Exorcist.

Charlie swallowed. Maybe… maybe she should reconsider her choice?

Cautiously, she unfolded her arms. 

Alastor’s eyes gleamed eagerly. “So we have a deal, then?” Far too eagerly.

His fingers brushed hers. Charlie realised he was slipping his hand into hers, trying to force the deal.

She erupted.

“NO!” she roared. And she shoved Alastor away with a strength more than merely corporeal. She felt her horns and tail sprout from her head and back, felt the air grow hot as flames ignited and whirled around her; her demon form had come out with her rage. 

Alastor went sliding all the way across the room, almost to the door, as if the carpet were an ice skating rink. He’d gone full demon, too; the whirling dials were back in his eyes again. Glowing green stitches tugged his snarl as wide as it could go, and sigils of the same colour phased in and out of existence on either side of him. His limbs stretched and creaked like the branches of a tree in a storm. And the whole room flashed with gold and green, demonic energies branching and spreading across the walls and ceiling like ivy, like lightning, as they clashed and battled for dominance. 

Alastor fought the worst of his demon form back down, but he still gave the strong impression of an angry buck snorting in the winter; green St. Elmo’s Fire flaring from his nostrils, his eyes wide and his pupils dilated from the rush of being in the briefest contact with a demon princess and her powers.

Charlie, going demon form, has shoved Alastor away from him across the room. He’s also gone demon form. Fire whirls around the room

Charlie, though? She didn’t let hers down. Alastor had provoked her, tried to force a handshake on her, and she had zero doubts in her choice not to trust him any longer. 

“I said NO!” she bellowed. “You’re clearly trying to manipulate me, and I never wanted you to come in here in the first place! You need to—” She stopped herself, and took a deep breath. She had to word this carefully. “As Princess of Hell, I order you to stay out of my room – unless invited in!” That felt right. Something with no loopholes Alastor could exploit – at least, none that she could think of. She found surety in her righteous anger.

Alastor’s lip curled nastily. “You know you’re throwing away a real opportunity here, dear.”

“GO.” Charlie pointed at the door. She could feel Razzle and Dazzle’s presences at her back, and hear their growls. If needed, they could transform into their own demon forms at the snap of her fingers. They weren’t just cherubic little goat plushies brought to life to be companions or concerningly-bad-at-driving valets; they were her bodyguards for a reason.

For a moment it looked like Alastor would give them that reason; he seemed like he was itching for a fight. But the moment past, and then, anticlimactically, he straightened up and brushed his coat down. “Suit yourself, Charlie,” he sneered. “I shall look forward to watching you reap what you’ve sown.”

And before she had to tell him to get out a third time, he melted into the shadows, and the shadows melted into the cracks in the wall and the gaps in the floor. The room felt lighter without the Radio Demon’s presence. Razzle and Dazzle let out twin sighs of relief.

Charlie felt triumphant. She hadn’t taken Alastor’s shit. She’d stood up for herself, and had commanded her authority as the Princess of Hell – against one of the most powerful Overlords to boot! She’d done her dad proud. She’d done her mom proud!

She’d done Vaggie proud…

… but Vaggie had taken part in the Exterminations. And her mom wanted her to stop the Exterminations by bringing hope to her people. How would she make her proud if she’d turned down a way to empower Hell against Heaven? 

Her demon form, her righteous anger, and her brief sense of victory all evaporated. What if she’d made the wrong choice? Had Alastor been telling the truth, after all?

She began to pace anxiously, hands pressed to her forehead again as her mind spun up. Sure, she knew Alastor was a manipulative dealmaker. He had tried to take advantage of her. He had tried to manoeuvre her into a deal, under duress, while she was alone and isolated. His words and actions just now had had all the hallmarks of coercion. That tempting little hint that there was a way to stop the exorcists could have just been a lie to tempt her into capitulating.

But, just as equally, he could have been telling the truth. And if he had… then the deal he’d offered could have been worth it, maybe?

What kind of favour had he even wanted from her in return? He might have wanted her to do something that would have involved hurting someone – or someones? – and she never wanted to do that at all, not ever, especially not for him… but it also might not have been that. He’d said he didn’t want her soul, and it made sense that a sinner couldn’t do anything with the souls of those higher than him in Hell’s hierarchy. Maybe he had just wanted her to sing something for him on his radio show! Maybe he’d wanted to swap rooms with her and Vaggie, so he could his expand his studio into the penthouse!

Or maybe he’d just wanted her to throw all the TVs out of the Hotel! Which she would have been more than happy to do, without a whole deal thing – but if that would’ve been all he wanted, she’d have shaken his hand in a heartbeat!

…Or maybe he’d wanted her to close the hotel. Maybe he’d wanted her to renounce redemption, and concede to him that her dream was impossible, and that sinners didn’t deserve a second chance. Maybe, somehow, he’d even wanted her to… marry him? No, that wasn’t right; she was pretty sure – mostly sure – that Alastor was asexual. He’d always turned down Angel Dust’s advances, even when they were jokes, and had nodded along in agreement whenever Charlie espoused the virtue of chastity in group therapy. He’d said himself that he saw her more like a daughter, and he’d never objected to her and Vaggie being in a relationship.

Her and Vaggie…

Vaggie was the one who’d told her not to trust Alastor, not to make a deal with him. But Alastor was right. How could she trust Vaggie anymore? Vaggie had lied to her about her past, hiding the truth that she’d been an active participant in the genocides Charlie so abhorred, and now her advice could have cost Charlie the only opportunity to fix things before Adam came back. If she’d taken Alastor’s deal, she could have gotten the key to defeating the angels and having a real shot at fighting for her friends’ afterlives.

But she had listened to Vaggie instead. Vaggie, the person who had been by her side when no one else was, who she had entrusted her dream and her heart to for the last three, nearly three-and-a-half years.

And look where that had gotten her.

It sunk in that she'd made another dumb decision that just made everything worse. And it more than ate away at her. It devoured her.

Charlie began to cry again. She couldn’t do anything right. She’d lost – no, she’d turned down what might have been her one chance to right her wrongs, and she couldn't take it back. She wasn’t empowered, she was stupid. She couldn’t do anything with the hope she was supposed to bear while her mother was gone.

She’d fucked up.

She was a fuckup.

Because if Charlie couldn’t stop the Exterminations, or save her people from them, she couldn’t redeem herself from being the reason the they had started in the first place. 

So she burrowed back under the covers to bawl her eyes out some more, ignoring the worried bleats of Razzle and Dazzle as they rushed to provide her with a fresh box of tissues. She was certain she’d doomed them, and all of her friends, all over again.