Work Text:
As the storm clouds rolled in and the wind started whipping around them, Mario could only ask himself in despair: Why couldn't he have a normal vacation for once?
Mario, Peach, and Luigi made their way to the center of town, pushing against the Toads who were fleeing into their homes. In the middle of the town square, the air was crackling and twisting and warping until, with a sharp crack, a young woman appeared. She threw her arms out wide, long dark hair draping over her shoulders. “Hello, lovely townsfolk! Did you miss me?” She smirked cruelly.
“Oh, is it Halloween now?” Luigi muttered, eying the way she slightly glowed.
Peach narrowed her eyes. “Tacky dress.” There were holes in it and everything.
Mario was more focused on the wand she was waving around threateningly.
“No!” A child’s voice cut through the fearful silence. “Go away!”
“Wha —? You little brat!” Furious, the woman swung her wand sharply in front of her. "I'll show you!"
Mario was already moving, running and scooping the kid out of the way of the incoming magical blast. It tore through the flowerbeds that were just behind them, spraying dirt into the air. Someone nearby screamed.
Mario looked the kid over; they looked fine, aside from a scrape and being a bit traumatized from the consequences of their outburst. Peach and Luigi rushed over, too — Peach to heal the scrape and Luigi to stand protectively in front of them all. “What’s the big idea?” Luigi met the woman’s gray eyes with a glare.
“Oh, tourists? How fun!” she said, twirling her wand as if she didn't just try to blast a child off this mortal coil. “I love messing with tourists!”
“Attacking a child? How awful!” Peach shouted, providing an opening for the kid to scurry away into a nearby house.
The woman laughed. “Playing hero, are we? Girlie, this grudge of mine has been alive for decades, so don't even think about playing peacemaker. These people deserve what they’re getting.”
Luigi looked confused. “Decades? You don't look old enough for that...”
“Why thank you,” she batted her eyelashes. “Wanna go out for coffee sometime?”
“Uh. No thanks.”
She scowled. “Why not? ‘Cause you're already with the pink girl? You think she’s prettier than me?”
“I’m not with anyone,” Peach protested, choosing to ignore the slight against her appearance.
“Oh please.” She rolled her eyes. “You are with one of them aren't you? Or both? Lucky you.” The sarcasm dripped from her voice.
Mario gaped at her. That was certainly a new one.
“Excuse me?” Peach looked similarly offended. “Since when did going on vacation together mean that there’s any dating involved?!”
“Don't make a fool out of me!” Magic gathered around the crystal of the woman’s wand. She fired another blast at the trio.
Peach threw her arms forward, blocking the attack with a pink shield of her own. But the momentum of the attack still flung them backward clear through the wall of a house. They heard a cackle, and the crack of the woman teleporting away.
Luigi sat up in the rubble with a groan. “Is everyone alright?”
Mario was fine, aside from being baffled by their conversation with that strange woman. Peach was tired from the sudden spell-casting, but she’d live. She was still sour about that earlier assumption that woman made, though.
“‘Or both’,” she hissed, mocking. “As if I even had the slightest urge or desire to date even one of you.” She caught Mario’s stare. “Oh. No offense.”
None taken. Mario waved a hand, a knot loosening in his chest. Dating wasn't really his thing, anyway, being aromantic and all.
Meanwhile, Luigi was gingerly getting to his feet. “Are all your vacations like this?!” he asked, incredulous.
“Unfortunately,” Mario and Peach responded in tandem. “I need to overhaul the tourism board,” Peach sighed as the boys helped her to her feet. “They can't keep recommending me places with power-crazed magic users.”
The three of them went to the Mayor’s house to ask about the events of earlier. Namely, why there wasn't a warning for it in any of the travel brochures.
The Mayor sighed heavily. “You have to understand; this town has been struggling for years. If we included talk about Jade’s misdeeds, then who knows how worse off we’d be.”
“Jade, huh?” Luigi munched on a cookie. “She had a real bone to pick with you lot.”
“She’s had a bone to pick with us for decades now. And despite our efforts,” the Mayor sighed again. “We haven't been able to stop her.”
Mario frowned. Was there anything they could do to help?
“No, I couldn't ask you to do that.”
“Why not?”
“There’s...a rumor,” he said, carefully choosing his words, “that there is something out there that can defeat her, but...”
“But?”
“It requires a great and terrible sacrifice. I cannot in good conscience let you do that for us.”
The three exchanged glances. “Heroes are hardly strangers to making sacrifices to help people,” Luigi finally said, “so could ya tell us anyway?”
The Mayor gave it some thought. Finally, he asquecised. “But I’ve already told you everything I know,” he told them. “You’ll have better luck asking around town for information. You aren't the first to want to do something about Jade.”
“Thank you so much,” Peach said as she and the Bros got up to leave.
The Mayor nodded back at them, looking weary.
“Shall we split up?” Peach asked when they got outside. “We can cover more ground that way.”
Mario nodded. Sounds like a plan. Meet back at the inn?
“Sure!”
The information-gathering took longer than expected, and they reconvened in Mario and Luigi’s room at the inn after dinner, each with a different set of information.
Luigi had been roped into helping repair the town square and got to hear gossip from some older ladies about Jade herself. She used to be a pretty thing, apparently, who was a bit of a maneater. A woman-eater? A person-eater. Whichever it was, it didn't change the fact that despite constantly hanging off someone’s arm, she always looked so sad. Up until her parents tried to do something about how she refused to tie herself down to anyone, to which she snapped and made them disappear. She’d been a terror since, even now, after (distressingly) she’d been dead for ages.
Peach had found out from some kids that the object they were looking for is some sort of enchanted gemstone; they had overheard their parents talking about it. Those parents had heavily discouraged them from playing hero, though, because of the daunting legend that whoever touched that gemstone would be doomed to a life of eternal loneliness.
Mario had talked to a man sitting at the back of the bar who had a secret - he had actually found the gemstone in the caves outside of town, a number of years ago. Faced with the prospect of sacrificing ‘true happiness’, though, he’d regrettably turned back. He couldn't do that to his wife, he’d told Mario. Not with a kid on the way. However, he did give Mario a clue on how to find where the gemstone rested: the green of nature's cavern lights will lead the way.
“This gemstone sounds like bad news,” Luigi worried, “are we sure we want to be looking for it?”
“Of course,” Peach replied. “We have to help these people!”
It was getting late, though, so they decided to set out in the morning tomorrow.
Late morning found Mario, Luigi, and Peach deep in the caves outside of town. The ‘cavern lights’ the man at the bar spoke of turned out to be a glowing trail of bioluminescent moss, which wound up and down a path that stretched past old, rusted mining equipment and through tunnels dripping with water.
“We’ve been walking for a while...” Luigi said, absently pointing his flashlight at various stalagmites.
“I’m sure we’re almost there.” Peach knocked a Swooper out of the air. “The moss trail is getting thicker...”
“What do you think, Bro? Are we close?”
Mario snapped out of his thoughts. He’d missed their discussion completely.
Peach put a gentle hand on Mario’s shoulder. “You've been quieter than usual today...what’s on your mind?”
Admittedly, it was a minor thing but...Mario rolled the thought around in his head. There was something...off about the way the people in town talked about the “great sacrifice” that they would have to make. Sure, it was probably, well, "great", but something still didn't sit right with him about it.
“Oh, that?” Peach hummed. “That is a concern isn't it...hopefully everyone was just exaggerating.”
“But what if they weren’t?” Luigi shook in fear. “Somebody back there mentioned a fate worse than death, you know! What if we’ll have to give up something like...garlic bread?!”
...For all his misgivings, somehow Mario didn't think that was it.
They trekked onward. Finally, they got a change of scenery from dark stone walls; the tunnels opened up into a large cavern, where the moss trail they had been following stretched across the entire floor and up to cover the walls and dot the ceiling. There was enough light cast into the cavern that they could finally turn their flashlights off. It was quite a beautiful sight. But they'd hit a dead end. What now?
“Maybe there’s a secret entrance somewhere,” Peach suggested, inching forward.
“Or maybe there isn't, and we can go home?”
Luigi got two exasperated looks.
“Fine, fine.” He wandered toward the middle of the room. “But don't blame me if something terrible happens to any of us — !”
Between one blink and the next, Luigi disappeared, leaving a gaping hole in the moss and the echoes of a yell behind. Mario scrambled towards where he fell.
“Luigi!” Peach called out, making her way over a bit more carefully. “Are you okay?”
“I’m fine!” His voice was distant. “But you should really come down and see this!”
Mario peered into the darkness. It looked like a long way down...so it was a good thing Peach was there to push him in headfirst.
Wait.
Luckily, the fall was short, landing him on a slide that spun through many disorienting twists and turns before spitting him out in an ungraceful heap onto a pile of moss. His attempt to get back on his feet was thwarted by Peach bowling him over moments later.
“That was fun!” Peach laughed from where she sat on Mario.
“For you, maybe.” Luigi pulled her off his brother.
Mario sat up, rubbing his back with a wince. He looked around. They’d landed in a smaller cavern than the one they were just in, also covered pretty thoroughly in glowing green moss. Except the light reflected off the still waters of a lake, through which a lonely stone path stretched to the far wall, in which some sort of altar was inlaid into the stone. On that altar, a gemstone the size of a softball sparkled innocently in varying shades of green.
Everything was still and quiet as they walked down the path toward the altar. Mario was getting suspicious about how easy this was looking to be.
Luigi agreed, looking around nervously. “There’s still that sacrifice to make, though.”
“Oh,” Peach suddenly gasped, looking above the altar where words were engraved in tall, swooping letters.
Luigi read out the message, tripping over the archaic wording. “Does anyone know what this says in English?” he asked.
Mario sighed. It said that whoever touched the gemstone would be cursed to never be in love again. He should have known.
“Is that what all the townspeople were talking about?!” Peach burst out. “With the ‘terrible sacrifice’ and ‘eternal loneliness’?!”
“Eh? But Mario can't be in love and he’s doing just fine!”
Yeah, Mario thought, and if everyone could stop talking about his lived experience like it was a terrible tragedy that would be nice, thanks.
Peach muttered angrily under her breath. Something about idiots and amatonormativity.
“Well,” Luigi scratched his head. “If we need this to stop Jade, one of us still has to take the gemstone, right...?”
Peach and Luigi looked at Mario. Mario sighed. He could hardly blame them, with how his aromanticism rendered the sacrifice unnecessary.
Mario walked forward to the altar. Close up, the area hummed with magic. The gemstone glittered wickedly where it sat.
So this is what stole your true happiness away, Mario thought. Though that meant that he already wasn't able to have true happiness, since he was already incapable of being in love. But that couldn't be true, because he'd been plenty happy already.
...What even was true happiness, anyway?
Mario shook his head. Now wasn't the time to let these sorts of thoughts crawl out from where he kept trying to put them to rest (Maybe as he grew more used to the fact that he wasn't broken it would be easier to squash these doubts). Now was the time to grab this gemstone.
But before his hand closed around it, Peach spoke up. “Wait!” she said, with an intense look about her. “Are we sure it's only romantic love they're talking about?”
Uh. Probably? Since when did anyone ever consider the other types of love, when it came to things like this?
“But...” Peach bit her lip.
“Does it really matter?” Luigi shrugged, crossing his arms. “He'll still be Mario. Not like he'll stop baking with you or waking me from nightmares or anything.”
Peach nodded along after some thought. “You’re right. Sorry.” She gave Mario an encouraging grin. “As you were.”
Mario’s heart warmed. He reached out and grabbed the gemstone. As soon as he touched it, it started to glow. The surface of the gemstone felt very smooth, Mario thought absently as the glow started to intensify. He felt the magic from within it prod at him, as if searching for something; upon being unable to find what it was looking for, it vanished with an almost disappointed air. The light from the gemstone cut off abruptly along with it.
Meeting Luigi and Peach's concerned gazes, Mario found that his heart was still warm; nothing felt different. So just romantic then. Mario wasn't sure if he should be relieved or annoyed. Regardless, he held the stone up in triumph. Mission success!
“Alright!” Luigi pumped his fists in the air. “Let's go and show that Jade what’s what!” Everyone cheered.
The cavern rumbled ominously.
“...after we get out of this cave in one piece.”
Whatever path they scrambled through to get out of the caves, it didn't spit them out where they came in. No, the three of them, scuffed and sweating, finally came to a stop in a grassy clearing dotted by a few trees, a ways away from town.
“Well, we have the gemstone,” Luigi said, catching his breath. “So where do we find Jade?”
Crack. “You called?”
Jade appeared before them with a smirk, which melted into a look of shock when she noticed what Mario held in his hand. “You. You grabbed it,” she muttered in disbelief.
Mario waved the gemstone around. Jade looked almost afraid of it.
“Do you know what to do with that thing?” Luigi stage-whispered to Mario.
Absolutely not.
“But you had to make the sacrifice, right?” Jade regained her composure, putting on a mock pitying expression. “Poor little you, unable to be in love...” she cooed. “Must be sad, isn't it?”
Mario thought of Luigi and Peach, ready to leap into action alongside him. He shook his head.
Jade’s face flickered oddly. "But it is," she insisted. "Your life will be miserable! No one will love you if you can't love them back, a-and then you'll just be lonely...hardly the happiest way to spend the rest of your life, right?"
“But you don't need love to be happy,” Peach said, stepping forward in concern.
Jade stepped back, eyes wide.
Alone didn't mean lonely, anyhow. Mario watched her face as it started to crumble. If he could navigate something like this, then she certainly could too.
Jade’s gaze bounced between Mario and Peach, uncertainty flickering in her eyes. But then her uncertainty collapsed into anger, magic crackling and gathering around her en masse. She floated in the air, the fierce white glow in her eyes dripping from her face like tears. "You’re wrong!" Her voice shook as it echoed. "Love is the whole point!" She raised her arms.
“Uh, Mario? I think now's the time to do something!” Luigi called out over the roaring wind. The trees were starting to tear away from the ground, roots exposed and cracking.
On instinct, Mario threw the gemstone at Jade, hitting her square in the forehead. The magic stilled. She fell to the ground, the gemstone landing in her lap. They all watched it glow brighter and brighter and brighter before the light cut off abruptly. As if her strings were also cut, Jade slumped over where she sat, staring blankly at the gemstone. She looked lost. The bros and Peach exchanged glances.
Slowly, Mario approached Jade, kneeling to her level. She was going transparent, he noted, as she looked at him with a despondent gaze. He met it with a gaze that he hoped was reassuring. It must have been, with how her face changed to something peaceful as she faded away completely. The stone was gone too. The clearing was quiet.
“Well then!” Peach broke the silence. “That was...something!”
Luigi sank down to the ground with a relieved sigh.
Mario got up, still staring at where Jade disappeared from. She sounded a bit like he did (albeit much angrier) when Peach first sat him down to tell him about aromanticism. He hoped she was alright, wherever she was now.
“Well, now that the town is saved,” Peach said (and didn't that spark much less joy than what saving people usually gave her!), “do you still want to vacation here?”
Mario made a face. Luigi waved a non-committal hand from where he lay on the grass.
“Same,” Peach sighed. “I’ll call ahead for the boat. Mario, can you meet them at the docks? You should probably avoid the village anyway.”
If they found out that Mario was the one who had to make the "sacrifice", then Mario would get all sorts of unnecessarily pitying looks. He shuddered just thinking about it.
“Luigi and I will meet you there after getting our bags from the inn," Peach continued.
“Aw, but I just got comfortable...”
Mario yanked Luigi upright. He could get comfortable on the boat when they were far away from here.
Luigi studied Mario’s face. His brother looked tired, in more ways than one. Luigi crushed him into a hug. “Love you, bro,” he murmured into his shoulder.
Mario hugged him back. Love you too.
“Room for one more?" Peach approached them, grinning tiredly.
They opened their arms.
“Would now be a good time to mention that I love you both? Platonically?” she asked, putting her arms around them.
“Right back at ya, Princess!” Luigi winked.
Mario chuckled. They were all being a bit silly right now, but they’d earned it at this point.
“Ok, team!” Luigi shuffled their hug into a huddle. “Operation: Get Off This Island is about to get underway! Any questions?”
Can you hurry it up?
“Any relevant questions?”
“...Will there be any snacks?”
“I hope so!” Luigi thumped their shoulders. “Let’s-a go!” He dashed off.
“Wait for me!” Peach called, pulling out her phone. Luigi did actually stop and wait for her at the edge of the clearing.
He was really lucky to have them, Mario thought, as they disappeared beyond the trees. He took a deep breath. Alright. Now to get down to the docks without being seen. And maybe burn off some excess energy before the trip, too; there was hardly anything better than a good round of platforming to take care of that!
