Chapter Text
Chapter Text
So finally, back to the main topic of this essay: my version of the Royal Plumbing Polycule.
I couldn't resist putting my aromantic hands all over it, so things got kind of complicated (and also they’re all aro). So below is a little relationship chart! Green is platonic, yellow is queerplatonic, red is romanic, and blue is sexual. The captions are self-explanatory, haha.
One of the major appeals of this polycule to me is that it makes me think about how Peach and Bowser have to interact now that they're in Relationships with the same little guys. And that’s really funny.
The other major appeal is that in this polycule, Mario gets to put his Hero Hat down and rest, Peach isn't defined by her crown here, Luigi is empowered by everyone’s support, and Bowser has people who will push back, if he pushes them in turn.
But above all else, it’s just a fun thought exercise to indulge in. The main question is, like with all ships, is “how the fuck did we get here?” And answering that question is all of the fun :D
My answer to that question
1) Mario and Peach form a QPR post-Mario Odyssey
In the ending cutscene of Mario Odyssey, Mario and Bowser fight to propose to Peach, and she rejects them both. Some fans would tell you that this signifies a romantic rejection of both men. In reality, Princess Peach has been kidnapped, dragged across the entire world, stuffed into a dress that she fucking hates, is currently ON THE FUCKING MOON, and literally almost died not even 5 minutes ago. And now these bozos are shoving bouquets in her face? Nuh-uh! Absolutely not! Go away!
Anyway, wrapped up in the above assumption is that Mario was proposing to Peach for-realsies, when in reality what probably happened is that because Mario is a competitive weirdo (source: various Mario Sports games) he probably saw Bowser make the attempt and the need to one up him superseded the concept of “maybe Peach will be mad if I do this”.
All this to say, as far as my polycule is concerned, this is also when Mario reveals he’s aromantic, except he doesn't know that yet, so he talks about how the proposal thing was “something he felt like he should be doing”. From there, Peach takes that and does some research and the “Aromantic” label surfaces itself. As does the concept of a QPR, which they decide to formally enter into, because many aspects of it felt like they matched their current relationship as it stood.
2) Luigi and Bowser start a friends-with-benefits thing
It's an impulsive thing on Luigi’s part, really. Convinced by Peach to disguise himself as her to head off the next Bowser kidnapping, only for said kidnapping to be orchestrated by Bowser Junior under his father’s nose instead, Luigi had felt the least he could do was entertain the kid for the next few hours while Bowser finished figuring out if he should be proud of his son for all this or not.
But as the day passed, he kept seeing glimpses of Bowser watching them from a distance, with a Look on his face. And then after Junior was shooed off to bed and Luigi tried to take his leave, Bowser claimed that since it was so late, he’d be generous and let Luigi stay the night, nevermind that he was already technically kidnapped and wasn't meant to leave anyway. And when Luigi had dithered in the foyer not quite sure what he was meant to be doing as a not-prisoner-almost-guest, Bowser had dithered beside him, until he’d offered the contents of his alcohol cabinet to share, looking surprised at the words coming out of his own mouth. And a few drinks in Luigi watched the hair fall into Bowser’s face as he failed to resist staring at him and, well.
He’s made worse decisions in his life, surely. Hopefully he wasn't reading things wrong?
(He wasn't.)
3) Two Pairs Collide (sort of)
A few months of this status quo later, a wrench in the works!
Because Mario and Peach are in a QPR, and Mario and Luigi are practically a bonded pair, Luigi and Peach have ample time to get to know each other and hang out themselves. Which eventually leads to Luigi catching Feelings. What kind of Feelings? He’s not sure! They seem rather Important, though, which is a problem because Peach is already not-dating his brother and these seem like the type of Feelings that would step on his toes.
Bowser’s no help about this, cheerfully inviting him to the metaphorical “I have Unrequited Feelings about Princess Peach that will never go anywhere” support group, as its acting president. This admittedly spooks Luigi enough that he decides to just hide from Mario and Peach for the rest of his life. It takes a day and a half for the pair to notice this, and a week to finally corner him to ask what the hell is up with him.
Luigi tearfully confesses about his dilemma, to which Mario and Peach look at each other because, like. Mario had just coached Peach through losing her mind a week before this all had started about the fact that she’d gone and gotten Feelings about Luigi, too. And she’s reasonably sure these Feelings are romantic. Hence the aforementioned losing her mind. And Mario, to be honest, doesn't find he minds the prospect of it all that much, either.
So Luigi’s got quite a bit to think about! It rattles around in his brain enough to spill out around Bowser the next time they meet. And it…doesnt go well. Even though his crush on Peach had taken a major backseat since his relationship with Luigi had started, something about the fact that, in Bowser’s mind, Luigi had succeeded so simply where he’d failed for years and years just kinda snaps something in him. So he explodes, for lack of a better word. Starting at yelling at Luigi until he cried and ending with kidnapping Peach in the middle of the night not 12 hours later and she gives him such a thorough rage-filled dressing down of her own that it crashes him into a low point.
4) They Move Forward
They don't hear from Bowser for a while.
Now officially a triad, Mario, Peach and Luigi worry that perhaps Bowser is planning something in the wake of his outbursts, as the weeks go by. But then Bowser’s Fury happens, and Mario’s able to report back that no, Bowser’s just…taking some time for himself, with his family.
Eventually, Bowser gets his head settled on straight and reaches out to them; first to Luigi (to apologize for the yelling), then to the group as a whole via letter. And then, after some discussion — Luigi thinks Bowser’s properly turned a new leaf about things, Mario’s willing to see it though, as long as Bowser’s actually serious about it, and Peach is willing to give him this one last chance, for theirs and her own sake — they all meet in person for proper conversation. More apologies happen, obviously, and even a peace treaty gets brought up and started, and then worked on over the course of weeks, and then finalized, and then they drift back together and now they're four, but also they still do the whole kidnapping thing, albeit on a planned schedule now. It's enrichment :)
