Preface

No Scoutmaster Left Behind
Posted originally on the fanfiction.lol at https://fanfiction.lol/works/947.

Rating:
Teen And Up Audiences
Archive Warning:
Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Category:
General (non relationship-focused)
Fandom:
PEAK (Video Game)
Characters:
Original Character(s), Scoutmaster Myres (PEAK)
Additional Tags:
Mountains, Climbing, Wilderness Survival, Camping, Team Bonding, Rescue Mission, Scouts, Family Bonding, Fluff, Angst, Hurt/Comfort, Fluff and Angst, Fluff and Hurt/Comfort, Blood and Injury, Near Death Experiences, Canon Compliant, Eventual Happy Ending
Language:
English
Series:
Part 2 of Conquering the PEAK
Stats:
Published: 2026-11-02 Updated: 2026-11-13 Words: 14,581 Chapters: 4/13

No Scoutmaster Left Behind

Summary

Two months after the newly founded Peak Scouts escaped from the island, they were called upon to return to it. This time, though, everything has changed and an old foe seemingly wants them to stay away. Can they brave a new set of challenges and threats while also rescuing Scoutmaster Myres in the process? Or will they fail and join him in an eternity of suffering?

Updates happening weekly!

Chapter 1: Home

Chapter Notes

Sunday, August 2nd, 2026

The time crept over into 4PM just as Riley was applying the finishing touches to their house in Minecraft. It was nothing more than a basic wooden house with a few details but what they were building didn’t really matter to them. What mattered was the fact that the process was incredibly therapeutic to them. Something about the calm music as they worked away at a build felt just right.

They were sitting on the couch with Jade to their right, quietly observing. About an hour ago, Jade had decided to make Riley their pillow and they remained there since then. It was a surprise they hadn’t drifted off into sleep considering they were wearing sweats and a t-shirt while wrapped up in a warm fuzzy blanket.

A few months ago, that kind of contact would’ve been nothing more than a distant memory. It was nice to see that Jade had warmed up to them considerably in that time. It seemed they were getting a little more comfortable falling into place in their new role and new home.

They weren’t able to find much time to play video games anymore, especially not after taking in the kids, so it was nice to have a moment like that every once in a while. They didn’t mind though. Their free time was a sacrifice they were absolutely willing to make if it meant their kids had a happy and safe home.

On the topic of taking in the kids: given the… “extraordinary circumstances” that Dave mentioned in the past, it made initiating the fostering process for their kids incredibly easy. On the same day they went in for the appointment, just a day after returning, they had signed a ton of paperwork to foster the kids. They were able to all go home together later that same day.

Even a few months after, they still found it incredibly hard to believe it was that easy, especially when it wasn’t so easy for…

Suddenly, Jade gently nudged them in their side. It was only then that they realized they had spaced out. In that time, it seemed their laptop had also slid down their lap a bit, so they grabbed it and gently set it down on the coffee table in front of them before they could end up dropping it.

When they finally took a look to their right, they noticed that Jade was staring at them. It almost felt like they were staring directly into their soul, which only made Riley feel uncomfortable on top of being confused.

“Uh… what’s up, Jade?”

“You doing okay? You spaced out for a minute there,” Jade inquired.

“I’m… fine. Sorry. I think I need some fresh air,” Riley replied.

“That’s probably a good idea. You’ve been hacking away at that since the others left.”

Right. The others.

Jamie, Luna and Evelyn left a few hours to go to the park after the rain had cleared up. Jamie and Luna were starting to get antsy being trapped for the entire morning, so they managed to convince Evelyn to take them out to the park.

Well… that, and a ton of begging for Riley to allow them to go. They had relented for a while, but eventually they caved in.

They were just afraid of something happening to them, especially when they were still in the part of the process where it’d be so easy to lose custody over them. At the same time though, the kids deserved to get out and have some fun too.

Evelyn was a good person though. Sarcastic and witty at times, yes, but still… a good person. Jamie had even accidentally called her “mom” at one point, but they insisted that was a complete accident. She’d never let anything happen to them.

Jade’s weight suddenly pulled away from them, prompting them to get up. As much as they wanted to stay like that, they needed some air.

Once they got up, they noticed their phone was missing. However, they very quickly remembered they left it on their desk in their room, so they had no reason to panic. They’d probably need to call Evelyn sooner than later to bring Jamie and Luna home for dinner, so they decided they’d take a detour to grab it before going outside.

When they entered the hallway, they first reached the door to the bathroom on their left and Jamie and Luna’s room on their right.

They remember the younger children’s room being quite the difficult arrangement to make for several reasons. One, Luna was hellbent on sleeping on the couch for some reason. Two, Jade didn’t like the idea of having their own room. Three, Jamie didn’t like the idea of Jade not having their own room.

It eventually spiraled into almost being an argument, so Riley ended up having to mediate it, which lead to Jamie and Luna sharing a room while Jade got their own. Luna sleeping on the couch was absolutely not an option.

The door was left wide open so they were able to take a look inside. It… probably didn’t hurt to make sure everything looked good anyways, though they should’ve done that before letting them go to the park.

The walls were a reddish-orange with a white ceiling and carpet. Their beds and desks were also white to match the floor and ceiling. All of the furniture seemed to have been dusted off recently and the shared trash can empty. The lamp over on Jamie’s end table had been left on, so Riley went over to turn it off. They made a mental note to bring it up to them later.

Both halves of the room seemed to mirror one another, at least in terms of furniture placement. In the back corner was a bed with an end-table to its side and in the corner closest to the door was a desk and chair. On the middle of the back wall was a large window with reddish-orange curtains covering it.

On Jamie’s side—the left—was an accordion door which lead into their shared closet. On Luna’s side was a large dresser with a small television on top. Like the closet, the dresser was also shared. The television didn’t get used very often, which Riley ended up being happy about. At least some kids actually wanted to peel away from their screens still.

There were a ton of posters and miniature replicas of mountains on Jamie’s side of the room; they had become even more obsessed with climbing after their first ascent of that island. They also framed the climbing outfit they had long since retired along with their old sash. They, along with everyone else, ended up getting promoted so they wanted to keep their outfit and Rabbit Scout sash as memorabilia.

Luna’s side was… much emptier with only a few space posters and miscellaneous photos with their new family hung up. A telescope, neatly re-packaged, sat beside their side of the window. Riley had passed it down to them a few days after they had moved in, but seemed afraid to touch it for a few days. However, Jamie taking initiative by opening it themselves seemed to change their mood about it and it has been used frequently since.

They ended up copying Jamie with their own frame, retiring their old Turtle Scout outfit and Scout sash. They ended up jumping up two ranks to the Rabbit Scout rank, which was unheard of in scouting history. Given everything they dealt with while only being a Scout though… it was a well-deserved promotion.

In spite of Riley’s best efforts to spruce up Luna’s side, they insisted they were fine with what they had. Riley wasn’t too happy about that arrangement, but they didn’t want to force Luna into anything they didn’t want or need either. They were terrified of pushing too hard and losing them.

The room was tidy… or, well, at tidy as it could be with a fourteen and a twelve year old living in it. It was good enough for Riley not to complain though, so they decided to just move on.

Next, they passed by Jade’s room but since the door was shut, they decided against snooping around. The kid deserved some privacy too and it was usually extremely tidy anyways. Maybe they’d get a chance to check up on it sometime in the future.

They finally reached their own room and took a step inside. Their room’s color palette wasn’t quite as exciting as Jamie and Luna’s, but they were perfectly fine with the black and white theme they had going on.

Across from the door sat a decently sized desk right in front of a window. On that desk was a monitor and computer tower, along with several photos with their family and Evelyn. The chair in front of it was a black leather chair. It had certainly seen better days, but considering it still functioned fine, they had no interest in replacing it.

To the left of the desk was a door that lead to the master bathroom. They were uninterested in wandering into there at the moment.

In the back left corner was a queen sized bed. The pillows, blanket and sheets were white while the bed frame was black. They had no end-table though, which was rather inconvenient when they wanted to get rid of their phone after scrolling at night. At the very least, they did set their bed up near an outlet, so they could at least stay in bed to plug their phone in.

In the back right corner was the door to their closet, which was quite messy. Truthfully, they were scared of even going back in there, given how much of a mess it had become. They kept telling themselves they weren’t a hoarder, and yet… they’ve done nothing to remedy the issue.

Maybe some other time they’d do something about that.

Their room was a bit messy since they often forgot to tidy it up. Jamie had pointed that out in the past when being lectured about their own room, which has forced Riley to be a little more conscious about it. Though, it was still something they forgot about at times since they’ve still not completely adjusted to the fact they don’t live alone anymore.

While it was messy, it wasn’t filthy by any means. They didn’t eat anything in there and their drinks were limited to water and coffee, both of which were disposed of shortly after being finished. That much they could take pride in.

Unlike the others, they decided against framing their old clothing and sash from their previous expedition. Their coat was damaged beyond repair and even after repeated washing, it just didn’t smell good, so they unfortunately threw it away. As for their Wolf Scout sash, they tucked it away in their closet, while their new Scoutmaster sash was tossed over the back of their desk chair.

They wished they could’ve given their new sash to Luna, seeing as how they were fascinated by the design, but they knew it would’ve caused problems with other people if they were wandering around with the wrong sash. As much as the sparkly galaxy sash would’ve complimented their new favorite and similarly sparkly outfit, they still weren’t a Scoutmaster.

About a month after the crash, they ended up becoming the founder and Scoutmaster of Troop 525, which was also the first troop to be founded under the newly founded Peak Scouts. The troop only consisted of them and their kids, though they also extended an invitation to Evelyn in the event that she felt like transferring.

They realized they were spacing out again when the breeze from their ceiling fan brushed them in the eye, so they grabbed their phone and left their room. They weren’t going to get any fresh air if they just stood around inside.

As they were walking to the back door, they noticed something peculiar in the living room. More particularly, Jade was actually playing on the laptop! It was hard to tell what they were doing from where they stood, but they could tell they were at least actively doing something.

They decided against commenting on it or staring any longer, since Jade could be spooked very easily in those scenarios. They weren’t sure why the kid was so averse to indulging in something like a video game but…

Right. Their grandparents. All of those kind of behaviors just… led back to their grandparents.

…

Poor kid.

Riley quickly sneaked out the back door before Jade could notice and closed it gently. Once outside, they picked a random chair to sit in and turned it to face out towards the backyard.

Despite how muggy it felt following the rain, it actually wasn’t a terrible day to be outside. While it was still a bit cloudy, the temperature was just right to be out and about. Not too hot, not too cold. The air smelt nice… or, well, as nice as suburban air could smell. At least the remnants of rain on the ground helped out with that.

They noticed that the poolside basketball hoop they bought for Jamie’s fourteenth birthday had fallen over onto the surface of the water. They assumed it was because of the weather though, so they didn’t feel the need to lecture Jamie about it later. Instead, they approached it themselves and re-adjusted it so it was once again standing upright.

On the topic of Jamie’s fourteenth birthday… they recalled that being a complete pain to sort out.

…

It was just three days after they had returned from the island when Jamie turned fourteen. Riley only remembered because Jade was panicking about it, unsure what to do for the occasion. Of course, that meant that Riley also started to panic, because they also didn’t know what to do.

Jamie had insisted they didn’t want anything for their birthday. When Riley attempted to argue, Jamie brought up the fact that they’ve provided them with a roof over their head and a whole new room and a bunch of “cool stuff” already.

That didn’t stop Riley or Jade from feeling like they were inadequate for not doing anything though. So, one day, they convinced Evelyn to babysit Jamie and Luna while the two of them went to a random store in town. They weren’t really looking for anything in particular, but they were hoping that they’d come across something Jamie might’ve liked.

They eventually came across a poolside basketball hoop which Jade pointed out instantly. Riley grabbed it without even taking a look at the price tag. Just before they were going to check out though, Jade pointed out the rather annoying fact that it didn’t come with a basketball, so they had to backtrack to grab one of those too. They then bought both items and took them home.

They then presented the gifts to Jamie, who seemed a bit annoyed at the gesture, but still thankful nonetheless. They dragged Luna inside shortly after and Jade followed, curious about what that was about.

In the meantime, Riley and Evelyn constructed the hoop and stood proudly at the finished product. Truthfully though, it really only needed one person to construct. They were just glad they got to spend a little time with her.

Before either of them could react, Jamie nosedived into the pool with the ball and tossed it in the hoop. Luna and Jade were far more careful with their entry thankfully. They were all in their swimwear and ready to have some fun.

“That kid’s gonna hurt themselves one day…” Evelyn sighed.

“I keep telling them that and they keep not caring,” Riley replied.

“Maybe they’ll learn when they actually get hurt.”

“I hate to say it, but yeah. Might be what they need to realize how reckless they can be.”

…

Though that bout of Jamie’s recklessness still irked them months later, they couldn’t help but still feel happy about the moment overall.

In spite of Jamie’s initial protests of not wanting anything, they still seemed to enjoy the basketball hoop. Even months after, any time they’re swimming, they made sure to shoot a couple shots. Luna had taken a couple shots at it too, but at first it seemed like they were still a bit too weak to get the ball in the hoop.

Though… Riley did steal some glances at times and often noticed that Jamie lowered it just for Luna. Eventually, they just kept it lowered and said nothing about it. Luna seemed pleased by that arrangement.

They returned to their seat and felt relaxed as a gentle breeze blew and the sounds of birds chirping filled the air. Aside from being overcast, it actually wasn’t terrible for a random Sunday in August. Given the heat they endured in the previous summer months… it was a nice change of pace.

Suddenly, the back door slowly creaked open then clicked shut just as Jade appeared in their line of sight. It seemed they had abandoned both the blanket and the laptop inside. They grabbed their own chair and positioned it beside Riley’s then sat down.

“I figured I should get some fresh air too, considering I’ve just been sitting with you all day,” Jade said.

“Yeah,” Riley paused for a moment. “It’s not so bad out here.”

“Mm. Maybe if it was a bit less humid…”

Riley shrugged. “To each their own.”

Then curiosity hit them. They couldn’t see what Jade was doing on the laptop earlier, so they wanted to ask about it. No harm in asking about it, right?

“So, Jade… what’d you end up doing on the laptop?”

Jade suddenly tensed up after hearing the question. “Uh… y-you saw me on it…?”

“Yeah. I didn’t say anything though because I didn’t want to bother you.” Riley smiled. “It’s nice to see you doing something for yourself for once.”

Jade seemed to ease up a little at the reassurance. “I… didn’t really have a plan. Just found an open spot and let my hands do the thinking.”

“That’s how it usually goes for me. Just… let it happen first, come back around to pretty it up later.”

“Sorry… by the way.”

So much for bonding on that front.

“For?”

“…Nevermind.”

They had a feeling they knew exactly why Jade was apologizing.

“You don’t have to be scared of openly enjoying things, Jade.”

“Old habits die hard, I suppose.”

Old trauma, you mean…

Jade suddenly changed the topic. “Tacos for dinner, right?”

Riley seemed confused but decided to go along with it. “Yeah. Nothing too crazy. I… kinda forgot to plan something better for tonight.”

“It doesn’t always have to be some grand meal. Food’s food.”

“Yeah. I guess so.” Riley suddenly remembered they were carrying their phone when it vibrated. Just another email. “I’ll call Evelyn in a bit to bring Jamie and Luna back. I think a couple hours is enough for them to be tuckered out. We need to eat soon too.”

Jade laughed. “For Jamie? I find that hard to believe.”

“Kid’s still gonna get tired and hungry eventually.”

“True.”

The two of them sat in a comfortable silence for a while. Moments like those didn’t happen very often so they were happy to be able to enjoy it. Despite the occasional child being obnoxious somewhere in the neighborhood or someone working on some random project, it was relaxing to just… be outside.

That moment didn’t last for much longer though because their phone started to vibrate again in their pocket. This time, it lasted longer, meaning they were receiving a call.

They sighed and allowed it to vibrate for a few more seconds, but decided that whoever was calling would likely be upset if they were ignored. As annoying as it was to deal with phone calls on a Sunday, it would be even more annoying to be lectured about missing them.

They finally pulled it out of their pocket and when they took a look at the screen…

The name that showed up was one they really didn’t want to see.

Chapter End Notes

Moving to chapter-specific notes now that I'm not mass importing chapters from my doc. Hello! Each chapter will have a slightly more personable end note now, isn't that cool!

Anyways, this is a very descriptive opening chapter, I tried to tackle as many details as I could without being too obnoxious about it. Don't worry, the next chapter will be the complete opposite! Yay!!!

Also, I think my end notes will be slightly different here than on AO3 until it comes back on. So I guess this is another FFL exclusive.

Feel free to join my Discord server to keep up with updates and discussions of my fics! I do stuff on Tumblr too, but you may have an easier time reaching me on Discord.

Chapter 2: The Call

Chapter Notes

They had to do a double take on the name because they just couldn’t believe what they saw.

Headmaster Raymond?!

They groaned immediately when it finally registered in their head who was calling. Raymond was one of the last people they wanted to talk to, especially on a Sunday.

To them, he just didn’t seem like the kind of person that was emotionally mature enough be in charge of an entire subdivision of Scouts. He often jabbed at them over random things and would often tease them and Evelyn being a “thing.” To make matters worse, his attitude and personality seemed to always put Luna on edge. Overall, he was just not the kind of person they liked.

Though… he did do an exceptional job at keeping everything in order, and his colleagues did recommend him for that very reason, as long as they could get past all of his flaws. Additionally, his presence relieved them of the possibility of being a Headmaster, which was a relief for them. On that front, they could at least tolerate him.

If they were in charge… well, the Peak Scouts probably wouldn’t have existed for long. They were barely Scoutmaster material, let alone Headmaster material. Besides, if they were a Headmaster, they’d just be stuck at a desk doing boring stuff, much like their actual job. At least as a Scoutmaster, they actually had the opportunity to do fun stuff and it was far easier managing only one troop.

“Let me guess, Headmaster Raymond’s giving you a call?” Jade asked.

“Yeah…” Riley sighed.

“Again? Why is it always on a Sunday?”

“No clue,” Riley replied. “Should I just… let it go to voicemail?”

“No, remember the last time you did that?”

Oh, they remembered. Very vividly, in fact. They got an earful about “neglecting” their duties as a Scoutmaster because they just so happened to “miss” a call from him. That call happened to land on another Sunday where they didn’t feel like dealing with him.

They really didn’t want a repeat of that. Getting lectured once was enough and they were likely on thin ice regardless. They weren’t in the mood to hear it again.

Riley let out a deep sigh and answered before the call could go to voicemail.

“Hello, Headmaster Raymond,” Riley flatly answered.

“Hm. I see you actually picked up this time. You couldn’t even give me a ‘good afternoon’ though? What’s the matter with you?” Raymond retorted. He didn’t sound upset though… but incredibly sarcastic, which only irritated Riley more.

“You calling me out of the blue on a Sunday afternoon is the matter. You obviously have a reason this time, right?”

Raymond chuckled. “Of course I do! You’re just ready to get down to business, huh?” He then sighed when Riley responded with total silence. “Yeah, okay.” The way he said that made Riley feel guilty for their hostility. “Anyways, uh… that island you all escaped from? Back in June? You remember it, right?”

“Of course. That’s… kinda the whole reason why the Peak Scouts exist, no?”

“So you do remember, good,” he replied. “A few days ago, a small team and I went out to investigate the island but… things are different from what you four reported to us.”

“Different? You sure you went to the right island? There’s probably a lot of remote islands out there…”

“Yes. It was at the same coordinates and all. Our pilots confirmed that much. It just… seemingly changed… and any signs of wreckage disappeared.”

“You sent a dive squad and all to check it out?”

“Indeed. There was nothing.”

They didn’t have a good feeling about this.

“What are you getting at here?”

“There seems to be some kind of… ‘magic’ involved. A lot of weird stuff that wouldn’t normally happen elsewhere happened there.”

They already suspected that, given all of the crazy stuff they witnessed back then, but feigned ignorance to avoid raising suspicion. They all had conveniently left out all of those details when debriefing Raymond days after returning.

“Magic?”

“Yeah. Like… we spotted some blue beam in the sky, so of course we followed it. When we got there, sitting inside a random crevice was this statue of a scout holding some kind of amulet but… when one of our guys heard voices from it, they got spooked and ran off.”

Well, now they were intrigued. They never saw that before.

Raymond continued. “And… that campsite you were at? It’s like you were never even there. There was fresh firewood and food there. No ashes, no tracks, nothing. Also, there was another bigger statue, but…”

“But?”

“Well… shortly after one of us touched it, it crumbled and made the gal who touched it very sick. Not only that, but we saw some creepy zombie looking man, so we got the hell out of there.”

Oh no.

“Did he say or… do anything?”

“Yup, and this is exactly the reason I’m calling. He said: ‘You are foolish to be here. I will spare you whelps so you can warn those… ‘Peak Scouts’ to never come back.’”

“And… let me guess. You’re calling me to try to reel us back in? You and your crew got scared so you’re gonna ask a Scoutmaster and their children to do the dirty work for you?”

“Am I reeeeeeally that predictable?” he asked sarcastically.

“Yeah, I’m afraid so.”

“Darn. Well, let’s talk more about this at my house at 10AM tomorrow. Bring Scoutmaster Evelyn and your kids. I’ll be debriefing all of you on what needs to be done and the preparations you’ll need to make.”

“Wait, what? Eve? Preparations? Who said I agreed—” Then he hung up. “Damn it…”

Jade cocked their head to the side. “Well?”

“Long story short, Raymond and his crew found out something’s up at that island we were at and he expects us to go back to it. He wants us to meet him at 10AM tomorrow to discuss it more… or something. Glad we could clear up our schedule before confirming that…”

Jade simply hummed in response.

“Why me…” Riley muttered under their breath. “What do you think, Jade?” they asked Jade.

Jade only seemed confused by the question. “What do I think…?”

“Yeah.”

“I think… I don’t have a good feeling about this. I’m not very optimistic about us being the second choice to return to the island behind his ‘crew.’”

“Well, I think we could at least hear him out, maybe make a more informed decision? After all, we’ve got more experience with this island than him and his crew do. They don’t even know half of what went on there.”

“Mm. I suppose it wouldn’t hurt, but what about school? Don’t you have work, too?”

“If we get to the point of actually going, I’ll make sure he knows time is something we will not compromise on. And, uh, I can still take some of time off before the end of the year.”

“Okay. I’m in, then.”

“Then… I’ll give Eve a call, talk about what we learned, have her bring Jamie and Luna back, stuff like that.”

“Good idea.” Jade then got out of their chair. “I’m going back inside. This humidity is starting to bother me a little bit.”

“Okay.”

Jade then slid their chair back into its original spot and entered the house, leaving Riley alone with their thoughts.

Of course… We just can’t catch a break, can we? They let out a deep sigh. Well… maybe it could be fun, considering we’re not crashing this time. Sounds like we’re not going back for fun though. Could also save Myres while we’re running around over there…

They opened the Contacts app on their phone and scrolled down to Evelyn’s contact. They tapped on it and their finger hovered over the call button before they just… set it down.

I’ll call her in a minute.

Then their phone started vibrating again.

I swear—

This time, it was Evelyn calling.

Oh. I guess that works out for me.

Evelyn, on the other hand, was a much more pleasant person to talk to, even on Sundays. They’d kill to go back to the days where they could just… talk for hours on end. Neither of them were in school anymore though and had their own responsibilities so that ritual kind of became nothing more than a distant memory.

So, that time, they didn’t even think twice before accepting the call.

“Yo, Rye!” Evelyn chirped.

“Hey, Eve,” Riley replied, sounding just a little too annoyed.

Evelyn picked up on this instantly. “Uh… you good? Wait. Did something happen at your house? Are you okay? Is—”

“Yes! We’re fine! Sorry. Just… got off the phone with Raymond.”

“Ugh. The hell does he want from you now? And… why now?”

“I’ll answer that after you tell me why you called. The kids doing okay?”

Evelyn sighed. “Yeah. We’re all good. Luna’s been tuckered out for like… an hour, but Jamie had so much more energy. Both are tired and hungry now though, so I just wanted to call and let you know we’re gonna head back in a few.”

“Good timing then. I was actually about to call you for the same reason. We’ve gotta eat soon so we can settle down for the night.”

“Right. Now… answer my question.”

“So, remember that island we escaped from?”

“Yeah? What about it?”

“Well, turns out… Raymond sent a crew out there and… a lot has changed since we left.”

“Duh. With nobody there to keep up with it, and the elements doing its thing… not really a surprise…”

“Not like that. I mean… like, completely changed. Unrealistic levels of change. ‘All traces of us being there suddenly vanished’ change.”

“You sure it was the same island?”

“He insisted it was. Though, with all of the weird…” Less swearing, Riley. “Stuff we witnessed there…”

“Oh… yeah. I see how that’s a possibility now… Wait, why was he even bringing this all up to you anyways?”

“He wants us to go back and check it out. He wants all of us, including you, to meet him at his house tomorrow at 10AM. He kinda spilled most of it over the phone though, so not really sure why he couldn’t just… spill the rest.”

“Why me? I wasn’t with you four on the plane.”

“Beats me. Probably just wants to tease us again for no reason.”

“Maybe I’ll pretend I’m sick, then we won’t have to deal with that,” Evelyn suggested.

Riley laughed. “Might not be a bad call, honestly.” They hummed. “Though… you did say you wanted to go camping again…”

“Riley… I wanted a normal camping trip. Not whatever… this is.”

“Let’s at least hear him out before coming to a conclusion, okay? It’s not like either of us are guaranteed to be able to take off work on such short notice anyways. Not only that, the kids have to go back to school soon, so this could just be a bust.”

“Fine, I’ll humor him, but only for you.”

“Appreciate it, Eve. You’re the best!”

“Aww, you’re too sweet—woah, watch it, Jamie!” She then started talking to someone outside of the phone, presumably Jamie. This went on for a minute before she returned to the phone. “You, uh… wanna talk to Jamie for a sec? Seems like they’re really eager to talk.”

“Sure.”

“Cool, one sec.”

Silence, followed by the faint sound of the phone transferring to a new set of hands.

“Riley! Hellooooo!” Jamie shouted.

Riley winced and pulled the phone away from their ear for a moment. They quickly returned it though before Jamie could yell again. “Hello, Jamie. What’d you want to talk to me about?”

“Just wanted to talk about what me and Luna have been up to!”

“I’m all ears.”

“So! We played some more Zombie, and uh… I won! A lot! But… I felt kinda bad, so I let Luna win too. After that, we just started playing around on the park. Turns out that a lot of the equipment can just be climbed on top of!”

“Jamie… don’t tell me you climbed atop literally everything there.”

“Uh… maybe?” Jamie replied, followed by an awkward chuckle.

Riley sighed. “You’ve seriously got to be more careful before you get hurt.”

“Yeah, yeah, I know,” followed by a pause. “But, uh… I think we’re ready to come home, so… we’re gonna do that.”

“So I heard. How’s Luna doing?”

“They’re fine! Just tired, is all. They’ve kinda been laying around looking at the sky for some time. I kinda wanna join them… they seem comfortable.”

“That’s good to hear. At least you two got to get outside for a bit.” Riley smiled at the thought of Jamie and Luna sprawled out and looking at the stars. Those two definitely had grown very close in the past two months. “Could always ask them if they want to stargaze with you later tonight.”

“Yeah, maybe I will. Anyways—huh? Oh, you want the phone back? Okay… Bye Riley!”

“See you soon, Jamie.”

The phone soon returned into Evelyn’s possession, as confirmed by her voice.

“Had to pry the thing away from them before they could go on and on…” Is that a bad thing…? “Alright, I’m gonna bring these two back now.”

“Sounds good. See you all soon.”

“Yup. Later!”

Then she hung up.

They looked at the time once again. 4:17PM. They really needed to start preparing dinner soon, and they also needed to let Jade know that the others were returning.

They took one final look out at the sky before bidding it farewell. They slid their chair back into its original spot and stood up, but not without popping a few bones in the process. I am too young to be doing that…

Immediately upon entering the house, they noticed that Jade was in the kitchen making preparations. They didn’t get far in that short time, but they were in the process of dicing an onion. They seemed to have a few more vegetables set out and ready to be cut up.

They felt very mixed about the help. They weren’t complaining about it necessarily, but they also knew the kid’s intent was a mixed bag. Sure, they could be simply trying to help, but they also knew that behavior also stemmed from their grandparents’ neglect.

And for that… they didn’t want Jade to get the idea they were being neglected again, even if it was unintentional. With that having happened in the past… that being a possibility just made them feel uncomfortable. They were perfectly capable of taking care of everyone.

Now… if they had asked after Riley was already in the process of prepping and cooking… that would’ve been an entirely different story.

“Jade,” they said. Jade immediately stopped and stared at them. “Thank you for the help, but please go relax.”

“Are you sure? I don’t mind helping.”

“I’m positive.”

Jade complied and stepped away immediately. “Okay.” At least they learned to stop arguing about it a while ago.

They gently put a hand on Jade’s shoulder as they passed. “Oh and, by the way, the others are on their way back. Just thought I’d let you know.”

“Okay. Thanks for the warning,” Jade replied with a chuckle.

…

4:42PM

“…And that’s what he told me,” Riley said between bites.

“Wait, so does that mean we get to go back to the island!?” Jamie asked excitedly.

“Well, not quite… or, not yet, anyways,” Riley replied. “We’ve gotta figure out if Eve and I can even make the time for it first. I don’t really feel comfortable sending you three away on your own so…”

“I-It sounds like i-it could be fun! Well, s-since we’re not… crashing,” Luna added.

“Yeah! It’s like… a camping trip, but way cooler!” Jamie gasped like they’d just remembered something. “Wait! We can go back for Myres too, right? Not just whatever… dumb stuff Headmaster Raymond wants us to do?”

Riley hummed in thought. “I considered that as well. Depends on what he wants us to do in what amount of time and if he’ll be trying to hold our hands throughout it. It’d be a lot easier to tackle it if we could do this on our own terms without being supervised.”

“It also sounds like it’d probably be a lot more interesting than what Raymond has in mind for us…” Evelyn grumbled.

“Two birds with one stone, right?” Jade added. “We do whatever Headmaster Raymond wants and we get Myres out of there too. It’s a win-win… win scenario.”

Luna raised their hand. “Uh… q-question…” They seemed to fold instantly when everyone’s eyes landed on them though. “N-Nevermind…”

They instead seemed to whisper something in Jamie’s ear. Jamie ended up echoing it out loud. “What’s Evelyn got to do with all of this though? She wasn’t with us when we crashed.”

“No clue. My only guess is that he wants to tease us again,” Riley replied.

“Seriously?” Jamie scoffed. “Doesn’t he have anything better to do? It stopped being funny after like… the first time.”

Evelyn raised an eyebrow. “It was funny to you?”

“Uh…” Jamie suddenly stuffed a taco in their mouth and swallowed. “Mmm! This taco is soooo good!”

Evelyn shook her head in disapproval but still seemed to be humored nonetheless.

Jamie’s reaction to the news was to be expected, of course. That kid loved taking any opportunity they could get to climb, and lately… they seemed quite invested in going back for Myres. That really caught Riley’s attention though, because as far as they could tell, Jamie had little interest in the guy. Maybe they just saw his salvation as an excuse to do some more climbing…?

“Wait. I already forgot. Tomorrow’s just the meeting, right?” Jamie asked.

“Correct,” Riley replied.

“’kay. Thanks.” Jamie then went back to eating, seemingly no longer interested in the topic.

“Wait… w-what about school?” Luna asked.

“You all go back on the 17th, right? Considering how long it took us the first time when we were completely clueless, I imagine this time won’t take quite as long.”

“Okay…”

“Here, how about this?” Riley started. “I’ll, uh, try to get the entirety of next week off and make next weekend our deadline… If that’s not enough, Raymond can suck it up. Should be easy. Nobody’s really taking time off around this time of year.”

“Same,” Evelyn interjected. “My work isn’t… the most conventional. I think my dad would be chill with me disappearing for a week because of a random impromptu camping trip slash rescue mission.”

“I sense sarcasm in that response,” Riley teased.

“Me? Sarcastic? I’d never!” Evelyn feigned surprise.

“That works for me,” Jade butted in. “At least then, we’d still have the weekend before school starts to… I dunno…”

“Complain about how school sucks and that we don’t wanna go back?” Jamie suggested.

Jade laughed. “Sure. That works.”

“Sounds like we have ourselves a plan then,” Riley said.

“Yay!” Jamie cheered. “More climbing!”

“We’re not—oh, what the heck… yes, we’re doing more climbing,” Riley conceded.

Nobody seemed interested in continuing the conversation, so they went back to eating before their food could get cold. They got about where they expected to get with it anyway. They’d likely just start going in circles if it continued.

Now that they were able to chat with their family about the call, they felt a little less skeptical about it all. Jade did still have a valid concern about being next in line, though given what they’ve all endured the first time around, they felt pretty good about their odds. Plus, they did promise they’d go back for Myres, so that was their chance to do so.

The only hurdle they needed to get over now was their meeting with Raymond, which they were absolutely not looking forward to.

Chapter End Notes

Welcome to the dialogue heavy chapter! I wasn't joking when I said it'd be the opposite of Chapter 1. Hopefully this helps establish a few more things though and sets the stage for how things will go.

I should've probably addressed this in Chapter 1, but I'll do it here instead. Yes, the fic is shorter. In-universe, my excuse is that they have a better idea of what to do and generally work far better together as a team now as opposed to two months ago (in the fic) when they crashed. Other than that, I don't want to spend so much time on the little things, I don't think I can handle another 33 chapter fic.

Feel free to join my Discord server to keep up with updates and discussions of my fics! I do stuff on Tumblr too, but you may have an easier time reaching me on Discord.

Chapter 3: The Meeting

Chapter Notes

Monday, August 3rd, 2026

The five of them arrived at Headmaster Raymond’s house at exactly 9:55AM. They didn’t arrive quite as early as they would’ve liked to but… at least they were on time for once. They were usually a few minutes late to those meetings, much to Raymond's frustration.

They immediately noted that his house seemed quite messy for a guy who was such a hard-ass towards them about every little thing at their troop meeting spot.

The front perimeter of the house was littered with weeds, with some even threatening to reach his windows. Interestingly enough though, his lawn was nearly in perfect shape. They were confused by the contrast. Why not take care of the weeds while already taking care of the grass…?

Riley sighed and unbuckled their seat belt. As much as they were ready to get that meeting over with, they also weren’t really ready to have it in the first place. They weren’t necessarily concerned about the trip itself, but they still weren’t fond of dealing with Raymond.

“Let’s go before he can find another reason to get upset at us,” Riley suggested.

“Ugh. Fine,” Jamie retorted.

“Look on the bright side, Jamie! The sooner we do this, the sooner you get out of that uniform,” Jade said.

Jamie hated the Peak Scouts uniform, but they also hated every other uniform equally as much, so Riley never took any offense. Truthfully, it wasn't really their favorite either. Their old trench coat was cooler…

“True…”

Riley was the first to unbuckle and exit the vehicle. They shut their door then heard three more doors open and shut shortly after.

Once everyone was outside, Luna came up from behind and attached to Riley’s side, not even bothering to hide their anxiety. Poor kid.

“Here, I’ll sweeten the deal for you all. We get through this meeting with no problems, we can get ice cream after,” Riley offered.

“Isn’t it a bit early for ice cream?” Evelyn asked.

“Since when?” Jamie scoffed. “Any time is a perfect time for ice cream!”

“Exactly,” Riley affirmed.

Evelyn rolled her eyes. “Weirdos.”

“And yet you still like us.”

“Never said being weird was bad.”

Riley shrugged and headed up towards the front door. As they approached the front porch, they noticed a few beer cans haphazardly scattered across the table. They never really understood why Raymond never bothered to clean up after himself, especially when the cans were left in a place where anyone passing by could easily see them.

Luna's grip tightened as they passed by the cans. That was definitely not a coincidence, given the fact Riley recently learned that Edmond's actions towards Luna were fueled by alcohol.

That knowledge was enough for Riley to quit entirely. They were already on the verge of pushing it away entirely given their own experiences, but when they found out about Luna's expreriences… Well, they didn't need any further convincing to quit.

There were far better ways to "deal with their sorrows" or "have fun" anyways, like… writing or actually spending time with their friends and family. The thought of drowning themselves in alcohol for either reason only made them feel sick to their stomach.

Once they arrived at the door, they wasted no time banging on it. Luna's anxious shuffling only confirmed that they should get going. “We’re here, Raymond! Let’s get this meeting over with!”

“Riley… how the hell did you convince me to come…?” Evelyn muttered.

How the hell did I convince myself to come?

About a minute later, the door swung open and Raymond was standing on the other side.

The blue night gown and cap he wore covered up his red skin and part of his shaggy hair. Though, parts of it were close to reaching his shoulders.

Despite his lighthearted and sarcastic nature, he had an almost permanent frown attached to his face. They weren't really sure why, but they assumed they weren't close enough to ever find out.

He was a bit older, coming up on thirty-two, but he looked like he was in his twenties. They felt slightly envious that he sometimes looked younger than them. Maybe one day they'd ask about his skin routine.

In his left hand was a cup of freshly brewed coffee. From a quick waft, it didn't seem to have any sugar or other sweeteners, but at least it was far better than alcohol.

They never really saw him in such an informal manner. He was usually also wearing the Peak Scouts uniform… but they were also at his house fairly early in the morning. It was possible they just caught him at a bad time, but that didn't seem very likely considering it was only a few minutes until the meeting was due to start.

They also felt a bit awkward considering they barely convinced everyone to climb into their actual uniforms. It was the right thing to do when meeting with a Headmaster, but it felt so strange when the Headmaster himself didn’t adhere by that expectation.

“Oh, good! You’re all here, and on time for once…” Raymond scoffed.

“Surprise…?” Riley said awkwardly.

“A surprise indeed,” Raymond responded. “Come in and close the door behind you! You're letting the cool air out!”

“Oh, right,” Riley replied. They understood that concern very well. Everyone else seemed to as well, considering they all quickly piled into the house so they could shut the door.

Contrary to the house’s messy appearance, a faint lavender smell wafted in the air. Despite knowing that was his scent of choice for air freshener, it always caught them off-guard. They didn’t visit very often, so it was something that often slipped past their mind.

The faint smell of eggs and toast also lingered in the air. He must’ve had breakfast very recently. And as expected, the smell of coffee was in the air too. It all came together to form a nice comforting smell.

“Any of you hungry? Thirsty?” Raymond offered.

“No. We just ate like… half an hour ago,” Riley replied.

“Okay. Your loss."

“The thought is appreciated.”

“Didn’t think you were capable of being nice to me, Riley.”

Riley sighed in response, which caused Raymond to rub the back of his neck awkwardly. “Uh… right. The meeting. I’ve already got everything set up in my office, so let’s get to it.”

Everything set up…? What does he mean by that…?

"You're not gonna get out of your pajamas?" Evelyn asked.

Raymond shrugged. "Not like it would change anything. You've already seen me in them."

"But if it was us…" she muttered under her breath.

"Hm?"

"Nothing. Let's get this meeting over with."

Everyone quietly followed Raymond as he started walking towards the door of the basement. His basement seemed like an odd place to put an office, but he insisted that it gave him extra space for models and boards and things of that nature. He was a very expressive person in that nature, so it made sense.

Still… why the basement? He had a large enough living room…

As they were walking down the hallway, they noticed a mirror on the wall. They stopped to take a quick look at their reflection. Even if the meeting was unorthodox, they could at least still make sure they looked presentable.

They were wearing a variant of the scouting outfit that they all agreed on back when the Peak Scouts were first created. Their shirt was a light-green with dark-green accents. Both their collar and their shorts were brown with light-brown accents. On top of their uniform was their Scoutmaster sash, which had a few more badges from after the crash. They wore a green hat on their head with a symbol of a mountain embroidered on it.

It was simple but nice to look at. It reminded them of the peak of the mountain, which is how they all ended up agreeing on it.

Their collar was a bit out of place so they adjusted it. Everything else seemed to be in shape though, so they hurried to catch up with the others before anyone could notice they were gone.

Thankfully, nobody seemed to notice they had fallen behind when they approached the entrance to the basement. They spotted the others near the bottom of the stairs so they quickened their pace to catch up.

The first thing they noticed once they entered the basement was the presence of a few boards and what appeared to be a replica of part of a mountain. It wasn’t the same mountain they saw though, which piqued their interest.

He was clearly prepared to talk about what he found, which hopefully meant the meeting would go by quicker.

Upon closer examination of the replica, a lot of the details they expected to see were either completely different or absent. The sand was black with splotches of pink spiky balls, which was quite the contrast to the sand they saw. Additionally, there was a strange statue that looked nothing like the campsite statues with a blue circle around it. It was holding something green, but it was far too tiny to show any details.

“Told you it was different,” Raymond said.

“I wasn’t doubting you,” Riley replied.

“I know. Just saying.”

Their eyes strayed up to the top where there was a bundle of gray thread beyond the mini campsite. Based on previous experience, they could only assume that was the fog. Furthermore, given the fact there were no more replicas and based on what Raymond said during the call, his crew really didn't make much progress.

But then… how could Raymond be so certain the whole island has changed? Neither him nor his crew actually explored the whole thing.

Well, that's probably where they came in.

“Disappointed that you only see the beach?” Raymond asked.

“Are you… reading my mind?”

“I mean… it’s not that difficult to figure out when you seem disappointed.” Riley only glared at him, prompting him to clear his throat before continuing. “Anyways… that’s as far as we managed to get, which is why we only have this part of the replica to show.”

Jamie popped up to Riley’s right to take a look at it themselves. “Why? You get tired or something?” they snickered.

“No… but I assume Riley explained it to you all already?”

Jamie tensed up a little bit, but thankfully, Raymond didn’t seem to notice. “Some, uh… creepy, scary, monster spooked you all, right?”

“In simple terms, yes. It seemed very persistent on us leaving and you four… well, five, not going back there. Did any of you make it mad or something?”

Riley shrugged. “I think it was just jealous of us.”

“Jealous? That might be the dumbest thing I’ve heard.”

“Yeah! Jealous that we actually survived all of the stuff it made us suffer through! We were just too cool for it!” Jamie followed up enthusiastically.

“Y-Yeah! W-We were… so cool!” Luna affirmed, though they deflated when Raymond made direct eye contact with them.

Raymond rubbed his chin and hummed. “You know… that makes sense actually, considering its prey escaped from its grasp and all…” He then patted Riley on the shoulder. “Sorry for saying what you said was ‘dumb,’ Riley.”

“Jeez, didn’t think you were capable of apologizing.”

“Don’t test your limits with me, kid.”

“I’m twenty-four, not a kid.”

Raymond rolled his eyes. “Whatever you say, kid."

Jade finally spoke up. “So, uh… is this it? With the replica and the boards?"

“Part of it,” Raymond replied. “Well, actually… most of it. Just wanted to point out the inconsistencies between your stories and what we found, but… Detective Riley was already on the case the moment you all walked in.”

Riley decided to ignore that slight. “I’ve… got a question for you actually, Raymond,” they said instead.

“Go on.”

“This…” They pointed towards the smaller statue. “Statue. What’s different about it?”

“Well… unlike the other one, this one was holding some kind of… amulet? Gem? I dunno.” He paused for a moment. “We saw some kind of engraving at the base of it, but it seemed to be in some kind of ancient language. And, like you probably already figured out, it’s smaller and a lighter gray.”

“Did any of you pick up that amulet?”

“No. Like I said over the phone, one of our guys got close and got creeped out.”

“So you want us to go back just to grab some stupid amulet?” Evelyn asked.

“Yes. Though, I’d also appreciate if you all took another complete trip to the top just to document any differences. And who knows? Maybe there’s a few more badges to be had from there.”

Jamie raised an eyebrow. “Badges, you say? You already sold me at climbing, you don’t gotta sweeten the deal!”

“Will we at least have a proper landing and gear this time?” Jade asked.

“That was something else I wanted to address while you were all here.” Raymond walked over to a board with two faces…

Oh no. Not them again…

“You’ll all be going by helicopter with Judy and Todd as your pilots. They were the only ones to volunteer this time around. You’ll likely have better success with them anyways considering they saved you all the first time around, so they’re a little more familiar with the area.”

Evelyn sighed in relief, though Riley couldn’t shake this strange feeling they had in their chest. Even though the two of them did rescue them, they still felt pretty sour about how their encounters with both of them went.

At the same time though, two annoying but reliable pilots were better than one pilot bribed into attempting to kill them.

Raymond then walked over to the freezer and opened it. Inside was a bunch of pre-packaged food, and to the side outside of it sat several cases of bottled water. “Food and water is on us. However, clothing and tents will be your responsibility. I’d go ahead and just pack for all climates, because who knows what you’ll run into out there?”

Riley nodded in approval at the sight. “That’s good and all but… when are we going?”

“Well… when do you want to go?”

“As soon as possible, preferably. School’s starting back up soon.”

“Ah, right. Hmm…” He walked over to a nearby calendar. “The 11th? Next Tuesday? You'd be departing from Bing Bong Airlines around six in the morning. And before you can ask, I’d prefer if you all get out of there by the weekend.”

Riley and Evelyn looked at each other in horror. "Wait… Bing Bong Airlines!?" Riley asked.

"Hey, hey!" Raymond raised his hands in panic. "I know what you're thinking, but again, you're flying with pilots you can actually trust! We're just… using their tarmac for your departure and arrival."

"Mm. Alright. Just… don't have good memories from there."

"I know. It's the only place I can reserve this little in advance though."

"Well… I suppose it'll work if that's the case… I should probably clear this with my job first though."

"Good call. Anyone else?"

“I’m in!” Jamie chirped. Luna hummed a "mhm" in agreement.

“Well, if these two want to do it… I suppose it wouldn’t hurt,” Jade said.

Evelyn shrugged. "I'll go where these goobers go. Someone needs to keep them out of trouble."

Riley rolled their eyes in response. "That slight aside, I'm gonna lock this in."

They opened up the calendar on their work's app and thankfully, nobody else was requesting time off for the remainder of the month. They tapped on the 11th and requested time off until the 15th. They weren’t sure why they picked the 15th considering they were off work that day anyways but… at least the request was made.

They weren’t really expecting a response right away, so they just closed the app and began to put their phone away. However, to their surprise, their phone vibrated once. When they pulled their phone back up, they noticed the request was instantly approved with a note.

I’ll cover for ya! – Teddy

Riley smiled. Maybe they’d pay him back for this favor one day. “Well… good news, Raymond. Looks like I’m in.”

“That’s that, then.” Raymond clapped his hands together. “I’m so glad we could get through a meeting without trying to kill each other this time!”

“Don’t push your luck,” Riley warned.

Raymond laughed awkwardly. “Of course.”

“Are we free to go then?” Evelyn asked.

“Yes. I don’t think you need me to escort you out of the house…” He glared at Riley. “You’re grown ups. You can manage.”

Evelyn sighed angrily. “Let’s get out of here before I actually try to kill him,” she mumbled.

“Yeah…” Riley replied in a low whisper. “See you on the 11th, Raymond!” they said, slightly louder that time.

“I look forward to our next meeting. Until then though… Farewell, Peak Scouts.”

He then saluted, prompting everyone else to subconsciously salute. They held that salute for a few seconds until his hand dropped. With that out of the way, they were now truly free to go.

They all scrambled up the stairs as fast as they could without actually running. While they were interested in getting out of there quickly, they could at least be civilized about it.

Once outside, they slowed their pace but only stopped once they actually arrived at their car.

“T-That wasn’t s-so bad!” Luna chirped.

Jamie shrugged. “Felt kinda like a waste of time. He kinda spoiled it all last night already, could’ve also just told us everything else over the phone too.”

Jade nodded. “I have to agree with Jamie here. Why couldn’t he have just told us all of that last night? Could’ve saved time and gas.”

“And I wouldn’t have to see his face as much…" Evelyn sighed. "How do you do it, Riley?”

“Restraint. Lots of it. I hate him just as much as you do but… can’t just beat everyone up and get away with it. Plus… he’s a lot better at being a Headmaster than I’d be.”

Evelyn frowned at their self-deprecation. “C’mon, have more faith in yourself, Rye! You’d be a kickass Headmaster!”

“Look, I appreciate the optimism, but let’s be realistic about it too. It takes a lot more to be in his shoes than it takes to be a Scoutmaster. I also like that only these three are my responsibility.”

Evelyn shrugged. “Oh well, I tried. Maybe one day I can replace him then.”

“Hopefully, you mean.”

“Yeah…” She smiled. “Hopefully. You think I have what it takes?”

“Eve… you are…” Their face was already starting to feel a bit warm. “A damn good woman with a lot of intelligence in that head of yours. Not only that, but you’re a natural at this kind of stuff. You might be… you, sometimes, but you’re also very confident and headstrong. Those are traits of a Headmaster. Not some… weirdo who can barely even keep their own troop in check, let alone several.”

“Like… Raymond?” Evelyn sighed. “Look. If you don’t wanna be a Headmaster, cool, I get it. It’s a big responsibility and all. But… if someone like him can pull it off, I think you can too.” She opened the passenger door. “Just… think about it sometime.” She then closed it, effectively ending the conversation.

After Evelyn entered the vehicle, they noticed that the kids had been eavesdropping. “Why don’t you two kiss already?” Jamie teased.

“Why don’t you get in the car already?” Riley snapped back.

“Haha, okay! You should’ve seen the look on your face though! You were toooootally blushing!”

“You should see the look on your face when you don’t get any ice cream…” Riley muttered.

“What was that?”

“Nothing. Just get in the car already so we can get some ice cream.”

Jamie shrugged. “If you say so.” They then got in the car without any more teasing. Jade and Luna followed suit, choosing not to add fuel to the fire.

All things considered, that meeting went way better than they expected. Raymond also seemed to be slightly more friendly too, but that wasn’t exactly a high bar to clear. Pretty much all of their concerns regarding transport, time and supplies were addressed too, so they felt a little more confident about making that commitment.

In the present though, they still had their end of the deal to hold up with the kids. They all survived the meeting, so they were all entitled to some ice cream, as promised.

When they got into the car, they noticed the children were already excitedly discussing everything about the trip in excruciating detail. Maybe it wouldn’t be so bad after all, considering everyone was more eager to do it this time around. They really had no reason to be so pessimistic about it.

“Whatcha thinkin’ about?” Evelyn asked.

“Hm?”

“Ice cream. Where are you getting it from?”

“Dairy Queen?”

“Hell yeah.”

“Language.”

Evelyn rolled her eyes. “Sue me.”

“Sure… and the settlement is no ice cream for you.”

They randomly glanced in the mirror and caught Jamie looking at them with a smug expression. That was their sign to shut this moment down and move on.

“Alright…” They quickly shoved their keys into the ignition and turned them. “Let’s get everyone some ice cream.”

And then they set off to enjoy a sweet treat before preparing for their next journey.

Chapter End Notes

Still... setting the scene... but everything is starting to come together. Just a few more chapters and we'll be back in action! Also, as if Luna didn't have enough trauma... have some more! Poor kid just can't catch a break.

Probably just gonna commit to posting chapters every Friday from here on out. I'm pretty comfortable with it and it's still going up at the end of the week... so it's a win-win situation for me.

Feel free to join my Discord server to keep up with updates and discussions of my fics! I do stuff on Tumblr too, but you may have an easier time reaching me on Discord.

Chapter 4: Where It All Started

Chapter Notes

Tuesday, August 11th, 2026

Riley glanced over at their phone to check the time: 5:07AM. It was far later than they were comfortable with, but according to Jamie, they missed all three of their alarms and several attempts at being woken up. They were running about thirty minutes behind because of that.

The feeling of being rushed was the last thing they wanted to feel right before their trip, but they really needed to make sure everything was squared away before leaving. Had they gotten up earlier… maybe they could've taken a little more time. Now, though, they had no time to kill.

To make matters worse, they still needed to somehow find time to feed everyone. They initially planned on whipping up some breakfast quickly, but considering how late they got up… they'd probably just grab something on the way to the airport instead. They weren't particularly fond of the idea of eating out… but they didn't really have a choice.

They opened up their suitcase and mulled over the contents a few more times: a winter coat, a tank-top and shorts, swimming trunks, and a rain coat, all with the appropriate footwear. Of course, they also made sure to include the usual like undergarments, medicine and personal hygiene. It would've been real awkward if they forgot those.

It was quite the diverse selection of items, but given what they knew about the climate of the mountain both from their own experience and Myres' knowledge, they really needed to be prepared for any and every thing. They could only hope their children also took that advice seriously.

They also had a large backpack with some oddities in it. The most notable was a small blue journal labeled "Mountain Journal," which they intended to use to document everything they could find. They'd fill it out with pictures after the trip since Luna was the one responsible for the camera. Other than that, they had a two-person tent and sleeping bag occupying the remaining space inside.

Everything seemed to be in order, so they zipped up both the backpack and suitcase. They slung the backpack over their shoulders and the suitcase on the ground. They pulled out the suitcase's retractable handle and dragged it out of their room.

They were going to check in on the kids as they passed by their rooms, but both rooms were unoccupied and seemingly tidied up. Maybe they were already done preparing? But then… where were they?

They continued onward until they arrived in the living room. They noticed three backpacks and suitcases waiting by the front door and all three kids sitting at the mini bar, presumably waiting for food. Surprisingly, all of them appeared to be wearing their uniforms. They fully expected that Jamie would've fussed about it and worn something else, but no…

Of course, Jamie was the first to spot them. "Good morning, sleepy—ow!" They were stopped by an elbow to the gut from Jade.

Jade continued, though in a much nicer tone. "Good morning, Riley. While you were asleep, I confirmed that everyone packed everything in both their suitcase and backpack. I'm carrying mine and Jamie's tent in my bag. Both of our rooms are tidy as well."

Great, two less problems on their list. "Wonderful, thank you Jade."

They were reminded they didn't have much time when they received a text, presumably from Evelyn.

    at the airport. where are u all at??? waiting for my bestie and their adorable family! <3

Riley sighed and tapped away at the screen. Why did she keep teasing them like that?

    Might run late. Slept in. Also, is the heart really necessary?

They then shoved their phone in their pocket and moved on, but just a few seconds later it vibrated.

    tell it to ray then. he's already pissed ur not here like an hour early lmao. and yes it is necessary <3

It really bothered them that she didn't take texting seriously but they never bothered to bring it up to her. It… wasn't really that big of a deal. They could only hope she wasn't so informal with her texts when it came to something more serious like work.

Come to think of it, that would be incredibly annoying to deal with in a professional setting. They'd hate to be her boss.

    Whatever. We'll be there ASAP.

They once again shoved their phone in their pocket, now ignoring the vibration that followed. They really didn't have time to sit there and chat with Evelyn. Besides, they'd have plenty of time to do that later in the airport and on the way back to the island.

"Sounds like Raymond's getting impatient that we're not there, so we should get going," Riley suggested.

"And you think I'm impatient…" Jamie scoffed.

Riley chose to ignore that comment, instead grabbing their suitcase and rolling it towards the front door. They gave their pockets another pat down to confirm they had everything: phone, keys, wallet. Once they did so, they opened the door and went outside.

The sun had yet to make its presence known, so it was dark and cool outside. It seemed like it was going to be a clear day given they could see the moon and stars and the non-existent breeze put their fears of extreme turbulence at bay. Perfect conditions for a flight.

"Wait…" Jamie interjected. "What about the food and water Raymond was supposed t' give us?"

"Good question," Riley replied. "I assume—and hope—he's gonna hand it over to us when we get there."

"Huh. Okay. And if he doesn't?"

"Then I guess we're not going. You don't want to eat only berries, coconuts and mushrooms again, do you?"

Jamie cringed at the thought of that. "Not really, no."

"Didn't think so."

They all arrived at the trunk and tossed both their backpacks and suitcases inside. Riley fully expected to have to play Tetris with all of the luggage on their own, but it seemed the kids had a pretty solid idea on how to organize it all naturally.

Getting everyone inside the car and situated was also just as easy. They were surprised to see that nobody called dibs on the front passenger seat, but maybe none of them felt like arguing over it at five in the morning.

"Uh… one more question," Jamie said.

"Hm?"

"We gonna eat before we go there, or…?"

"Oh, yeah. McDonald's sound good to all of you?"

"Duh!"

"Mhm!" Luna replied.

"Sure," said Jade.

"Great." They turned the key in the ignition and waited for the car to start. "Let's go then."

…

5:41AM

After dealing with traffic and a slow line at McDonald's, they finally arrived at Bing Bong Airlines. It felt weird to return to the place that tried to kill them before, but at least now they were flying with a trusted crew. Also, how it managed to avoid being closed was a mystery to them.

They were still almost twenty minutes early, but given that Evelyn mentioned that Raymond was annoyed by them being "late," they assumed it was for the best if they went inside early.

"Let's go, before Raymond can complain about us not being here early enough," Riley said sarcastically. Being almost twenty minutes early is pushing our luck."

"Yeah, maybe if we get there fifteen minutes early, he'll lose his mind! Haha!" Jamie laughed.

Everyone exited the vehicle and scrambled to the trunk to grab their luggage. That process also ended up going incredibly smoothly. They hoped the flight would be just as smooth, but it'd be their luck—

No, don't jinx it now, Riley. Everything will turn out okay.

The parking lot was surprisingly empty, but given the even worse reputation that preceded Bing Bong Airlines now, everyone tried to avoid it even if they were on a budget. There were only six vehicles present, counting their own. They assumed Raymond, Evelyn and the pilots had their own, but… whose was the last?

Oh well, it didn't matter. What did matter was actually getting inside on time.

The doors to the airport automatically opened as they got close, inviting a rush of cool air to blast them in the face. it wasn't that hot outside, but it still felt nice nonetheless.

The inside seemingly remained unchanged, and they had no time to explore anyways, so they wasted no time in hunting down Raymond and Evelyn.

Though… as they passed the rock climbing wall, Jamie tugged on Riley's arm and pointed out a stranger climbing on it. How they didn't notice them before, they weren't sure, but they had their full attention now.

They were purple—like Jade—and were wearing a dark purple vest atop a grayish-tan shirt with a green plaid collar and cuffs. Strangely, they were wearing a wizard hat on their head, and their eyes almost appeared cat-like. Holstered on their belt was a chalk bag, which contradicted the purpose of their gloves but… it was better to be over-prepared than under-prepared. Beneath that was a green plaid kilt which nearly reached their knees. They had on brown hiking boots, which seemed to be playing a huge role in helping them keep their footing. Maybe Jamie should take some advice from this person…

However, Riley was extremely confused by their presence. Why were they there of all places? They didn't get time to actually confront the individual though, because as soon as they spotted the group, they dropped down from the rock climbing tower and darted out of the airport. What an… odd… character.

They decided to shrug it off and resume their hunt for Raymond and Evelyn. That didn't prove to be a difficult task though since the two of them were hanging out by a kiosk close-by. Raymond seemed to be in possession of a large cooler, which likely contained all of the sustenance they'd need to survive. Judy and Todd were a little further away, seemingly more interested in their phones than each other. Other than that, the airport was empty.

Evelyn beckoned them over with a wave. When they were a little closer, she nearly tackled them in a hug. "Hey, bestie!"

"Uh…" They desperately tried to push her away, to no avail. "Hey, Eve…" They then looked over at Raymond like he'd do anything to help.

"Ahem."

Evelyn instantly detached from them and returned to her previous spot. "Sorry… just a little excited, is all!"

"Strange, considering you didn't seem too interested at first."

She simply shrugged in response.

"Anyways…" Raymond saluted the scouts, who all saluted in return. "Good morning, Peak Scouts… and Scoutmaster Evelyn."

"Hello, Raymond. How are—"

"Did we get here a little too late for—" Jamie teased.

"Jamie," Riley growled. They shrunk in on themselves immediately and muttered a "sorry."

The kid was getting a little too out of control for their liking.

"Uh… no? You four…" He looked at his watch. "Got here at the perfect time, actually. What gave you the impression I'd be upset?"

"Well…" Riley glanced over at Evelyn. Raymond definitely seemed to notice.

"I see. What did you tell them, Evelyn?"

"That you were… getting antsy… because they weren't here…?" she awkwardly chuckled.

He sighed and rubbed his brow. "I suppose it doesn't matter now since you're all here, and on time, at that. I appreciate you four being more punctual lately."

"Of course," Riley replied.

"Oh, Luna, your collar is a bit messed up… let me help with that," Raymond offered.

Riley tried to intervene. They knew how this would end. "Uh… I can—"

"Nonsense. I'll—" The moment he reached out to Luna, they jumped back until he was out of arm's reach. Even when he backed off, they remained glued to that spot.

"Okay…? I guess one of your family members can fix it then…"

Jamie approached Luna and fixed up their collar for them. "There you go, Luna. I think we should go play around on the rock climbing tower for a bit!" They then grabbed Luna's hand and glared at Raymond before running off.

"I… should probably keep an eye on them. Wouldn't want them to get hurt before we can leave… or something like that," Jade said. They quickly bolted off to catch up with Jamie and Luna.

Raymond started after the kids were out of earshot. "What was—"

"You know they don't like when you get close," Riley retorted.

"…Why?"

"Seriously?"

Raymond was starting to panic. "L-Look Riley, I don't know what you're going on about—"

"You know, the fact you can't clean up your own beer cans, the fact that you even drink that crap in the first place, and you're just enough of a prick… it all reminds them of Edmond," they growled. "And to be blunt, their fear of you is a pretty big part of the reason why I don't like you all that much either."

"I… see. Why didn't you say anything before…?" He seemed genuinely bothered by that. Maybe that wasn't the right approach.

No… the truth always hurt. Backing down wasn't an option now.

"You never bothered to ask. You're just… in your own world."

"I'm sorry," Raymond replied. There was a slight crack in his voice. "I didn't know."

Now they felt guilty. "Raymond, look, I'm not trying to be—"

"No, no, I get it. I'm a mess. Always have been. I'm sorry that it's affecting you and yours. I'll try to do better."

They had a feeling they weren't going to make any breakthroughs so they conceded. "That's all I want from you."

"I'll… be on my way now. Make yourselves comfortable before you leave, maybe have a chat with Judy and Todd too. I've… got some work to do at home. Good luck." He then swiftly walked away, leaving Riley with no opportunities to drag the discussion on.

Riley watched—feeling almost ashamed—Raymond walk away hastily while he exited through the front door. Their gaze remained locked on the doors until they felt a hand place itself on their right shoulder.

"Don't sweat it, Rye," Evelyn reassured.

"I feel like I was too harsh."

"I feel like you weren't harsh enough. Did you see how Luna reacted?"

"…Yeah. I did. I feel like I still got my point across though. Unlike Edmond, he… seems interested in being a better person."

"I guess so," she replied. An awkward silence followed for a few seconds. "I'll… go watch the kids if you wanna catch up with the pilots."

"Sure. Probably need to make sure there's nothing they need before we leave."

"Yup. Alright, well, good luck!"

"Thanks."

Riley approached Judy and Todd, but they both seemed to be preoccupied by their screens again. How are they worse than most kids these days…?

"Uh… hello?"

Judy nearly dropped her phone out of her hands when Riley said that. "What the— Oh, jeez, you scared the crap out of me!"

Todd laughed and shoved his phone in his pocket. "Hey, Riley!"

"Hello, Judy. Todd."

Todd almost followed up with something but Judy butted in. "Oh, I never got to say this before, but I'm sorry about before. Y'know, I don't think anyone would be happy having to fly out to some random island to rescue people. Still doesn't make it right that I was a jerk though."

"What are you…" Then they remembered: she was… not the nicest to them before. "Oh. It's fine. I suppose that's fair."

"Anyways, uh, what's up? You need something?"

"Well… I figured I should catch up with you two before we headed out."

"I guess we've just caught up then," Judy flatly said.

Glad to see you still have some edge… "Yeah. I guess so."

"…Right. Uh…"

Her eyes drifted down to the suitcases and cooler. "Oh! Todd and I can toss all of the heavier stuff in the helicopter for you, if you'd like."

"Sure, we'd appreciate that."

"'kay."

They handed over their suitcase and cooler to Todd, who immediately took off with them. "I'll go fetch the rest of the suitcases."

"We'll be waiting," Judy replied.

They then went over near the rock climbing wall to retrieve everyone else's suitcases. Just as they were reaching out to grab Jamie's…

"HEY! What are you doing with my suitcase?" Jamie called from near the top.

"Judy and Todd are gonna load these into the helicopter!" Riley replied.

"Oh, okay!" Jamie then went back to climbing, leaving Riley to finish what they were doing.

"Need help?" Evelyn offered.

Riley initially didn't respond, instead focusing on Jamie's and Jade's suitcases. "Uh… No. Actually, maybe, yeah. The sooner we get these in the helicopter, the sooner we can relax."

"Mhm," she hummed. She then grabbed hers and Luna's suitcases. "Hey Luna! I'm taking your suitcase over to the pilots! They're gonna put them in the helicopter!"

Luna peeked out from the very top of the rock climbing tower. They seemed to be having a good time. "Okay! T-Thank you, Ms. Evelyn!" Well, at least they were in a better mood after… that.

They returned to Judy and Todd with the remainder of the luggage and set it down nearby. This time, Judy included herself in assisting by grabbing two of the four suitcases.

"This everything else?" Judy asked.

"Yup."

"Alright. See you at six." She then walked off with Todd and the luggage, not even bothering to wait for a response.

With nothing left to do, Riley and Evelyn returned to sit with Jade and watch Jamie and Luna have some fun. Riley considered pulling out their phone to absentmindedly scroll on social media, but they were really trying to wane off of it. It wasn't good for their mental health to be so absorbed by it.

…

Some time ago, Jamie and Luna abandoned the rock climbing tower and started to chat about the upcoming trip, but Riley wasn't really paying enough attention to make out anything specific. Regardless, they at least sounded excited about it, which was reassuring.

Or… well, Jamie was talking while Luna was listening. They did offer some input every once in a while, but the conversation was clearly being carried by Jamie. Neither of them seemed to mind though.

Though, the conversation came to an abrupt end, and Jamie gently elbowed Riley in the side not long after. "Hey Riley, when are we leaving? We're getting bored over here!"

"Uh…" They looked down at their watch: 5:58AM. "Should be any minute now—"

Judy whistled, prompting Riley to look in her direction. Both her and Todd seemed to be a little more equipped for flight. They could've sworn they also saw keys in her hand too. "C'mon, it's showtime."

Jamie nearly flew out of their seat. "About time! Let's go!"

Jade chuckled. "Talk about lucky timing." They and Luna got up at a much safer pace and floated nearby, waiting for the adults to take charge.

Evelyn and Riley got up and followed after Jamie and the pilots with the other two children in tow. As they walked by all of the familiarities of the airport, they felt a twang of nostalgia, but that's not what they were there for.

They soon approached the same hatch they had entered the airport from months prior, this time using it to return to the tarmac. The instant Judy opened it up, Jamie flew down it. She and Todd followed, then Jade and Luna went and finally, Evelyn and Riley.

Once on the tarmac, they noticed the helicopter was sitting in nearly the exact same place as back then too. What a strange coincidence…

Judy slid one of the side doors open and motioned a free arm into the cabin. "You know the drill. Get in, buckle up, secure your bags. Also got some headsets this time to keep things a little quieter and to save your ears."

"You didn't have them last time?" Riley asked.

"Uh… no, we didn't. Kinda forgot about it in our rush to get you, sorry."

"Don't worry about it. It seemed like we were fine coming back."

"Glad to hear, but I still don't want to take any chances this time. So, get to it."

"Right, right." Riley then entered the cabin, unwilling to push their luck with too much smalltalk.

They sat closest to the opposite door and shoved their backpack into pocket beneath their seat. In front of that pocket was a detachable net dangling just by the socket connected to their seat, so they connected the other part to the ground. They then found a headset hanging to their right, but decided against putting it on yet. They'd instead do that when they were all ready to actually leave.

Everyone else seemed to find their seats and get situated just fine too. Evelyn joined them on their side while Jade, Luna and Jamie—in that order—sat on the opposite side of them. Jamie seemed excited and attempting to hype up Luna, who was clearly anxious. Jade, on the other hand, was a lot harder to read. If nothing else, they at least seemed calm in all of the chaos. They were always calm though…

There was this feeling surfacing that Riley couldn't ignore anymore. It was kind of like the anxiety you'd feel right before an exam. In spite of all of the preparations they made, the possibility of something going wrong was still very real. That was something they couldn't prepare for neither mentally nor with extra supplies.

"You all comfortable? Everyone and everything secure?" Judy asked.

Riley looked around and saw that everyone was nodding, so they gave a thumbs-up.

They'd be fine. There was no way history would repeat itself. Still… they just couldn't shake that feeling.

"Cool. You should go ahead and get your headsets on. We already tested them earlier but I want you all to get them on and ensure they work. We'll take off after that, okay?"

"Sounds good."

"Great. I'll give Todd a sign when you're all situated."

Riley finally tried to put on their headset but it seemed a little small. Thankfully, it did have an adjustable headband, so they quickly adjusted it to fit snugly on their head.

They weren't entirely sure if they liked the headset. The noise-cancellation was weird and frankly, concerning, but it did feel very comfortable to wear. They didn't really have much of a choice though; it was either that or shaving off a few years before they started suffering from hearing loss.

They took a quick glance around and saw that Evelyn and Jade also had their headsets on, though Luna was struggling with theirs. Thankfully, it seemed that Jamie was willing to help them, so they soon had theirs on as well. Jamie slid their own on effortlessly and gave a thumbs-up to Judy, who then made a gesture off in a different direction.

"Testing, one two three…" Todd said over the headset. Given that everyone jolted at the sudden noise, they could only assume everyone else heard it.

"We hear you loud and clear, Todd," Riley replied.

"Good to hear. So… just one more thing before we take off."

"Hm?"

"You ever notice the dial on the cord of your headset? With the numbers?"

"Uh…" They looked down at the cord and noticed a dial with the numbers one through ten. They totally didn't just discover that. "Yes…?"

"They definitely just noticed that," Jamie teased.

Todd laughed. "Well… better now than later, I guess. Anyways, you should all see that it's currently on 'one.' That's the pilot's channel." They looked at the dial again and confirmed it was, in fact, on "one." "The other numbers are fair game for you all. Wanna have a chat with someone in specific? Get on that specific channel. Blah blah blah."

"Why not just… take off the headset?" Jamie asked.

"Well… the cabin isn't exactly padded enough for it to be safe to keep off for a prolonged period. Even though you're inside, the blades and everything else outside are still loud."

"Fair enough."

"Anyways… we put you all on this channel just for this briefing, but we'd prefer if you moved over to another one so Judy and I can communicate with each other clearly. Of course, if there's any issues, feel free to barge in."

"Right. Well, we're heading over to 'two' then," Riley replied.

"Sounds good. With everyone and everything accounted for, we'll be taking off shortly."

Riley shifted the dial over to "two" and waited for the others to do the same.

"That's cool, I guess," Jamie said.

The other three gave a thumbs-up as confirmation they were on the channel. Bit of a strange way to communicate but the justification made sense.

The helicopter suddenly and gently lifted itself off of the ground. Jamie and Luna instantly glued themselves to the window so they could watch as the ground grew more distant. The former constantly pointed out small details while the latter simply observed.

"Well, seems like we're airborne. Guess Todd wasn't joking," Evelyn said.

"I guess not," Riley replied.

"Might as well make yourself comfortable, Rye. I imagine it's gonna take a couple hours to actually get there."

"Yeah… I suppose so."

They allowed their seat to suck them in just a little bit more. Surprisingly, it was quite comfortable, despite appearing to be otherwise. They could even fall asleep there if they really wanted to.

No, don't fall asleep, Riley… You get enough of that.

Though, they still couldn't shake the feeling that something would go terribly wrong. They went through all of the motions, all of the preparations, several times over. They had no reason to be concerned, and yet, they still were.

They put so much effort into making sure they were ready, but something they didn't really account for until now was… the island was likely going to be ready for them, too.

Chapter End Notes

Fun fact: The mysterious purple scout that appeared in the airport is actually my friend 13oni's OC, Orville! As far as I can tell, they don't have a proper ref sheet, just a couple of doodles that he made up on the spot for them. He never really built on them beyond that but I did commission some art of them and Jamie so... that's something to look forward to! (they'd totally be climbing besties btw)

They have no relevance to the plot and will not appear beyond this point. I only added them because I forgot to add them to the end of Unexpected Expedition. It was intended that they would be a background character just because I could, but it completely crossed my mind as I rushed across the finish line for the last few chapters. Hopefully this appearance makes up for my failure to do it in the first fic :(

Also, we're FINALLY gonna start getting some action in Chapter 5. No more fun fluffy times. I won't go into specifics because it'd spoil the fun, but I'd say that Riley has a pretty reasonable suspicion that things aren't gonna be fun or easy for them.

Feel free to join my Discord server to keep up with updates and discussions of my fics! I do stuff on Tumblr too, but you may have an easier time reaching me on Discord.

Afterword

Please drop by the Archive and comment to let the creator know if you enjoyed their work!