PurpleTurtle (Guest)
on Chapter 4
Sun 15
Nov 202610:14AM UTC
I very much enjoyed this story! I liked the idea of several intelligent and well-placed people all going back in time with an agreed-upon mission and working together. I wasn't sure at first about H & Hr going back and taking over the just-AK'd bodies of James and Lilly, but after a few pages I realized it worked much better in the plot of the story. I am looking forward to reading Part 2. I want to read what happens to the Secret Dark Wizard Dumbledore. I know Riddle, the horcruxes, and the marked DEs are all taken care of, but there are still several unknowns still waiting. How will AD be destroyed? Does AD have the True Cloak of Invisibility, where is it hidden, and how will James/Harry retrieve it? Did James get the Resurrection Stone before the Kobold destroyed the ring and it was sent through the veil? If Sirius has been made sterile, will Marlene still marry him and, if yes, how will they form a family? How will James and Lilly get Harry and Hermione together? Without the Dursleys, Harry will grown up to be a VERY different boy. Will the young Hermione even be attracted to him without the trauma of the Troll in the bathroom setting the stage? The Unspeakables seem to be able to kill DEs without any bother from the DMLE and with no due process of law. And we saw with Sirius' induction, it is fairly easy to become one. Will Part 2 examine the dangers of this power?
The answer to most of those questions will have to be 'wait and see' as it constitutes the plot for the next part.
I truly have not decided on the stone - either it was returned to Death inside the potty, or James has it in order to unite the Hallows once more. He IS the Master of Death regardless, in the past as he was in the future.
I intended Sirius and Marlene to have kids in later parts, a few years younger than Harry.
H/Hr will get together, and without the Troll, as Harry isn't going to be friends with Ron on the train. He will have grown up with Neville and Luna as his playdates. They will welcome a bright and inquisitive newcomer, without the need to destroy a toilet.
Plus, it's Harry raised by a Lily who is also Hermione mentally... There is no way that she doesn't raise him right. He'll appreciate Hermione's personality when he meets her. And 'James' is more Harry now, so is less likely to raise young Harry to be a spoilt jerk like he was when young or Draco is always.
Comment on Step Back in Anger
PurpleTurtle (Guest) on Chapter 4 Sun 15 Nov 2026 10:14AM UTC
Comment Actions
NerosDad on Chapter 4 Mon 16 Nov 2026 10:32AM UTC
Comment Actions
tyrannic_puppy on Chapter 4 Tue 17 Nov 2026 01:01PM UTC
Comment Actions