Comment on Updates, Bug Fixes, and More!

  1. Generic pseud icon

    we prefer parentheses! There's examples of each style of tag in the faq haha https://fanfiction.lol/faq/tagging?language_id=en#what-are-some-examples-of-how-to-tag-alternate-universe-fics so im not totally sure what u need there. im glad u like the tagging here, ive been working super hard on making it as functional as possible :3

    Comment Actions
    1. Generic pseud icon

      I did see those few examples. They've been quite helpful so far.

      I simply meant that some of the stuff around tagging is all in the body text of the announcements, which, like all the stuff we use as inspiration, is open to each person's interpretation. I think I've been interpreting it right so far, but I just thought that if there are preferred ways you would like things tagged, maybe ending each of the announcement pages on tagging with written examples of the format you prefer so there is no need for interpretation.

      For example, on first reading the page you linked before I started posting anything, I assumed that the tag would be Modified Canon - (Change to canon). But the first time I used it, it turned out to be Alternate Universe - Modified Canon, and then any 'Change to Canon' would be its own additional tag. So I was suggesting putting the exact form that you prefer the tags to be entered, as well as the existing textual explanation of how to use the tags. The only example of the tag itself I saw on the announcements linked was the Triad - Relationship ones.

      Another example would be preferences around characters themselves. Again, there are a few examples in the body text of the FAQ, but it doesn't address the site preference for the names. For instance, I'm an HP writer, where the lazy naming conventions JKR set up often result in similarly named characters, characters who tend to be named with nicknames in text more than real names, and children with parents' or other family names reused ad nauseam (i.e. James Potter). So do you prefer Ron Weasley, Ronald Weasley, or Ronald Bilius Weasley? Should we use the full names, for better wrangling and filtering, or their preferred names in the story.

      And for the aforementioned James Potter (Harry's Dad) vs James Potter (Harry's son). There currently isn't anything I can see in the FAQ about how to name different generations with the same names. Middle names could resolve that one, but then should we put middle names on all characters for consistency, or keep them out unless needed to keep tags from being too long? Do we use James Potter (I), James Potter (II), James Potter (Senior), James Potter (The First), etc, etc? Does that even work when they aren't subsequent generations but further separated than that? Am I MASSIVELY overthinking all of this?

      I know wrangling is the background process to make all that work as one tag; I just wanna ensure I'm doing my part to make it work smoothly without adding a tonne of extra work for you folks.

      I also just noticed that the Tagging FAQ you linked is not one that is linked in the above announcement, nor on the posting page. So all we're currently linked to are the four announcements (which are great), but not the much more detailed Tagging FAQ, which seems to be where most of the proper examples of how to format the tag are written out, all together in one place.

      Sorry, this got kind of long as a reply. Like I've said, love the system, very happy using it so far, even if my OTP is still very sparse on here. Just wanna do what I can to help streamline the process for you wranglers and us posters. If we know how to format the tags when posting, it makes your jobs a bit easier. Though I know a lot of folks tag by feeling a lot of the time, regardless of existing tags or site formatting preference.

      Having said all of this, once I get my HP/SG fic posted up on here, I think I will do my utmost to find a way to include a Lesbian space pirate from the Edwardian era. Because that does sound totally wicked.

      Comment Actions
      1. Generic pseud icon

        hey! appreciate the level of thought :] not sure what you mean about the modified canon tags, bc that is how we do them tho? There are some scenarios (canon divergence tags for example) that don't necessarily fit the modified canon - (descriptor) format, but that definitely describes most of them. The reason we don't like the tagging faq is because you can find it on the site faq, but it's just more detailed of an explanation than most users need. It's more useful to link something less descriptive that ppl actually read lol. For character tags, it... honestly depends on how canon differentiates them. also if you need anything cleared up, site canonicals can usually be a useful guide to formatting :]

        Comment Actions