Actions

Work Header

strange things are happening to me

Summary:

‘I had friends
I had lots of friends
Now all my friends are gone
And I’m doing the best I can to carry on

‘I had power
I was respected
But not any more
And I've lost the love to the one whom I adored’

– Randy Newman


Charlie and Alastor are the last ones left in the Hotel. More than that – some of the last ones left in a much emptier Hell.

And now that the heavenly, mortal, and infernal realms have been severed and cut off from one another… what does one do when one is purposeless? What do you do when the show’s over? The last two left on stage to clean up and close up shop – how do they cope?

Notes:

Trigger advisory for specific chapters

  • Chapter 4 contains explicit graphic violence and character death.
  • Chapter 6 contains animal death.
  • Chapters 10, 11, and 13 contain explicit sex, dubcon.
  • Chapter 11 contains revoked consent, elements of noncon, and graphic violence.

All other chapters are effectively at an M rating.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: Scène

Summary:

The beginning of the end.

Chapter Text

 

The Hazbin Hotel still stood at the end of one of the boulevards slicing through Pentagram City.

Not much else did.

 

Pentagram City was years removed from its former… well, no, not glory, hardly. It had never been a glorious place, perish the thought! But it had had a certain je ne sais quoi. A melting pot of all of the worst worsts of humanity and demonkind, it had been; and yet in it’s heyday you could still pan through those wretched deposits and find the thrills and delights and the most enduring remnants of the indomitable human spirit – the culture. The cuisine. The desire to create.

The desire to carve out a name for oneself.

The desire to destroy. The conflict and drama and bloodshed to partake in, or to sit back and watch.

The entertainment.

Some had compared this place favourably to New York, or Los Angeles, or Bangkok, or any of the number of sin cities scattered around the planet Earth. Personally, he’d preferred to compare it to New Orleans. 

It truly had been like his birthplace, his old home, in the ways he fondly remembered.

But it wasn’t like that anymore. 

The sprawling metropolis in the crater that had been formed when the Morningstar fell, all those millennia ago, had been cratered again and again. Huge chasms and cracks and sinkholes that clearly were not the result of territorial battles (or pathetic copycat overlords with unearned access to a holy light cannon) jostled and ripped apart the urban fabric and took bites from its flesh.

A sloppy, unfinished butchers’ job.

The old maps laid out by the overlords of their borders and districts would do no good now. The star-shaped network of main roads and avenues had been smeared beyond recognition by the hellquakes, the side-slip faults. The most enduring urban landmarks: the Heaven Embassy, the Carmine compound, even the old Morningstar palace… they were gone. Razed. As if they were just among the other meaningless constructs and buildings that had been decimated.

Even the craggy mountains at the city limits had been removed from their place.

Even the eyes that had watched from every dark corner had been gouged away.

 

To put it shortly, the Pentagram was in ruins. 

Not entirely destroyed, no. And not entirely abandoned either. But it was ruined. No longer was it home to millions upon millions of lost souls… now its population numbered in the thousands, tops. 

And the afterlife that remained clung to a few pitiful shantytowns where the ground was most stable, or where utilities and resources could still be readily accessed or obtained – makeshift power lines wobbling through the desolation, off into the distance where they hooked up to the grids that powered the surviving hellborn cities in the Pride Ring’s other circles. Syphoning off of their lifeblood of electricity, until the imps or the surviving Goetia noticed and cut them off, and an expedition would be sent out to reconnect the lines and inevitably subtract themselves from the general population of sinners.

A population that would never increase again.

 

Vee Tower no longer blighted the horizon. Cannibal Town had long been swallowed up. The Magic Kat casino was less than rubble. 

But the Hazbin Hotel still stood. 

It was derelict now, too, but by no means completely decrepit, and certainly in better condition than the rest of the city. Even if the proudly gilded exterior had dulled, rusted, and fallen into disrepair (or in the case of the fountain with the dragon statue at the front gates, been stolen), the neon sign on the roof still flickered and spluttered lukewarmly, branding its name into the minds of any passer-by's.

(Not that there was anyone new who’d be unfamiliar with it now.)

And the lights still burned. They burned on the ground floor, in the windows of the owners suite, in the radio tower cantilevered off its right-hand side, and in an ever-changing pattern of a handful of rooms scattered up and down the side of the great towering building. This was still a hotel, after all – for people passing through temporarily. 

But there was nowhere for sinners to come from anymore, and nowhere for sinners to go to either. So what was the point of it, really?

The Hotel was still alive, but it was on life support. A pale imitation of its former glory – and there, he could not deny, for the passion project of a phantasmagoric princess, the word glory had been fitting. 

It had truly been something, once upon a time.

Now it was a has-been too.

 

And in the eternal twilight; in the darkened, scarred and fractured skies above, a bright, blessed star was missing. 

A reminder to the last denizens of this place, or to the sole remaining royal (if she ever had the nerve to look outside and up for more than a few seconds without throwing up and then relapsing into hysterics again) that no wayward soul could seek redemption, now, ever, or again.

Even if they wanted to.

 

Chapter 2: roo-pocalypse

Summary:

How the end came about.

Notes:

Be advised: major angst and sloppy 2am writing inbound.

Chapter Text

It had all happened so fast.


 

Sin’s final intrusion into the universe tore at the very fabric of reality. Enraged by her blood daughter’s betrayal, her active choice to resist and defy those long-seated seeds of evil planted deep in her body, Roo was not holding back any longer. Either she would conquer all, or she would destroy all – and either way, those who had wronged her would suffer.

Already, many were. 

The torrent of sinners falling from Earth into Hell had become a deluge, and the new arrivals spoke in fearful voices of the planet burning, the stars falling, crops failing and wars raging. 

The End Times, it seemed, had truly begun.

And Charlie Morningstar lay bed-ridden from the effort and the consequences of denying her intended destiny. 

Vaggi – or Vaggie, or Vagatha, or Vagene, she of the many name-changes – kept a constant vigil kneeling by her side, day and night, her feathers and hair ill-kempt and ill-looked after. It was clear she was not going to return to her duties as Hotel manager while her girlfriend was in such a faded, wounded condition. 

Lucifer joined her there, too, as much as he possibly could. But the business of actually taking part in the governance of Hell, in these dark days, kept him away long enough to make him miserably exhausted. 

Lilith vanished once more, this time in shame. And when she did return, her voice was gone. She was quiet, she was meek, she barely met her husband’s eyes or her daughter’s.

And Alastor? In between running the Hotel in Charlie and Vaggi’s stead, he could feel the ties to those powers he’d bartered for all those years ago fraying, weakening. Rosie may have been dealt with, he may have gotten out from under her thumb, but he’d known from the moment he met her in person that an overlord could not possibly have granted him powers beyond her own. 

He knew the Root of all Evil was questioning his loyalties, his use. 

Hmph. His loyalties remained with himself, as always. Rosie had known that. Her puppeteer had to know that too. 

But now his goals aligned against this notion of universal destruction (for where was the fun in that?), the risk of her not letting him be was very much present.

As long as he stayed out of sight of her many, many eyes, he should be fine.

…Which left him very much stuck inside the Hotel. Blast.

At least there were small victories.

Heaven had been fully humbled at last, and completely acquiesced to Charlie’s agenda. They were accepting souls, even those not yet redeemed; even those with little interest in redemption but plenty of interest in self-preservation. And whoever definitely wasn’t cut out for being up there was being passed on to Purgatory, or so the rumour went.

Pathetic. They were so blatantly telegraphing their fear. 

They sent angels down to help with the tactical withdrawal of all salvageable souls from the Hotel. Familiar faces. Alastor would not forget the look on Charlie’s face when Angel Dust poked his head and halo through the open bedroom door. Followed by Sir (now Saint) Pentious. Cherri Bomb. Crymini. Rooster. 

They’d all missed that smile of hers.

It did her good to hug her friends again; it got her back on her feet at last for the first time since he’d found her flayed, shredded, and bleeding in the remnants of Cannibal Town.

 

(Alastor would not forget the look on Husk’s face, either, when Angel sat down at the bar again for the first time in years.)

 


 

“What if we lose?” Alastor overheard Charlie whisper in a husky voice, as he approached her room to deliver a status report on the evacuation. He’d freed Niffty and Husk to join their compatriot has-beens, which grated him, but he knew Charlie would be proud of him for it, and to be honest with himself he needed the praise. There was not much serotonin to be had from Lucifer now, either; he and Lilith had shut themselves up somewhere, returned to their palace, and were probably having some sober, sad half-reconciliation. Not much fun stirring that pot. 

“I’m not the only soul you saved, now,” Vaggi whispered back. “You know that for sure. You’ve done… more than anything any of us could have imagined possible, Charlie. And no matter what happens next, they’re going to be safe. Our friends. Our family. You’ve won already, Charlie.”

“It doesn’t feel like I ever have though! They may be safe, but so many other sinners still aren’t.” Oh, dear Charlie, still so endearingly naive, they were never going to evacuate that many millions of sinners in time. “And… if they’re safe… I might not ever see them again. And if I lose everyone else… I can’t lose you too Vaggi, I can’t.” Right on cue, there went her waterworks.

“You won’t. I’m always gonna be with you.”

“I wish there was time to marry you.” Well, now. That was long overdue, maybe a little too late. “Not, like, a rushed thing… but something nice. Something where we could invite everyone, and be safe, and we could all be a part of our happily ever afters…

“Oh, hon…” The sound of Vaggi shuffling across the sheets, probably trying to meld her body into Charlie’s with a hug. “I do. I do. And no matter what happens… 

“I love you.”

“I love you too.”

“More than anything?”

“Yeah. More than anything.”

Alastor beat a retreat at the sound of wet, tearful kissing. He didn’t need to hear this. There were no friends in Hell and there weren’t supposed to be lovers. This was only going to get Charlie hurt.

Maybe pain was the only way for any of them to learn their lessons. It was the way he’d learned his.

 


 

Roo’s assault began mere hours later. 

While Charlie pulled herself out of bed to hustle sinners out through Heaven’s evacuation portals with Vaggi, Alastor was tasked with holding the Hotel together against the hellquakes, and keeping Roo’s power and magic out of the building.

Miracle of miracles, the last two Seraphim came down and extended a hand to their fallen sibling and the first woman. And all holding hands, they ascended to the skies, to try and hold the universe together. 

They really were in quite the pickle, if the fate of the universe was being entrusted to that man.

And so the battle began. The sinners pushed their way through the Hotel doors, through the portal in the lobby. The ground shook. He protected the way to their salvation.

He noted as the number passing through got smaller and smaller. 

He noted when he could no longer sense the magic signatures of the other overlords from outside.

…

The hotel jolted again. Fuck. He couldn’t dwell on feelings. He was exposed, he was drained, he was in danger again. He had to prioritise himself. Damned be the fondness he had regained for the Hotel after Charlie humbled him… this was just like what Adam had done to him.

Explosions outside. Energy straining at the wards he had set up, and the doors, like floodwaters.

There was noone left to evacuate. No point in staying here. He should go, he should save himself – but to where? 

Why couldn’t he bear the thought of leaving?

Then he felt a massive pain shoot through his body. He heard himself scream.

The last thing he saw was a mass of red and white eyes, all around him, all glaring at him.

 

“TRAITOROUS LITTLE PETS GET PUNISHED.”

 

And then he blacked out.

 


 

When Alastor woke up, face-down on the floor the Hotel was quiet, and he felt different.

So, so different.

No magic, no powers singing in his veins, dancing between his fingers like sound waves. Physically, his body felt little different… but inside he felt smaller. Weaker. 

Human.

He tried to summon his powers, his shadows… but nothing. He’d been neutered. 

This must mean Roo had been defeated, somehow… but that was no comfort.

He blinked, growling as he couldn’t clear his vision. It was hazy and unfocused. He propelled himself to his feet, cutting his hands on the shattered glass of his monocle. He ran his bloody fingers through his hair – and it was curly and short?

He whirled to search for a reflective surface - and in the shine of the gilded fireplace… yes, his hair was back as it was a hundred or so years ago, when he was still alive. Not the fuck ass bob that had been part of his payment for his powers. Well, there was at least that.

And no near-mortal wounds to hide, not like last time.

Then he remembered the other implications of Roo’s defeat, the ones that affected others. 

He sought out a window, and sucked in an alarmed breath.

Pentagram City was… all but gone. Like it had been bombed, like it had been stripped bare, like the way the lush fields and pastures of France had been turned to a muddy moonscape by the great war he was shipped off to in 1918.

The sky was torn apart, black veins and seams and Lichtenberg figures looming overhead in the crimson void, casting the remnants of Hell into shadow.

And then there was a bright dot falling from the sky, trailing golden hair and droplets glistening like little rainbows.

It was her. 

Our girl, Charlie.

He couldn’t teleport anymore. He summarised he wouldn’t be able to catapult himself through the air, bounding from building to building borne on his shadows.

No, he had to run.

And it was going to be tight.

He had to leap out of the window, slither down the marquee roof at the front of the Hotel. The landing gave him ground shock. The glass shards piercing his skin gave him the adrenaline to overcome it.

Tracking Charlie falling form, he zig-zagged through the rubble-strewn, broken street.

And he caught her. 

It just about knocked the wind out of him, but he stayed on his feet.

And then he had to fight for his balance more, as Charlie started scrambling and fighting wildly against his grip. Screaming at him, something of the alarm shriek of a doe in her voice, that he had to let her go, that she had to get back up there - to her dad, to Vaggi, to Heaven, before—

—then there was a thunderclap.

They both looked up in time to see the great rifts in the sky closing up and sealing, writhing like the tentacles of a dying octopus, eyes like suckers closing and shrivelling up. The fabric of reality clumsily stitched itself back together, with great, ugly sutures and scars. 

And the distant light of Heaven faded away, like a curtain had been drawn in front of it.

Pretty easy to figure out what that meant.

Charlie stared up for only a moment, shivering, before she buried her head in his shoulder and wailed.

And all Alastor could do was hold her, and obligingly rub her back, because it was the proper thing to do.

 


 

Only days later, when Charlie had calmed down enough, had she been able to coherently tell Alastor what had happened up there.

She’d tried to join the fight.

She'd slipped into the rearguard that was accompanying the final waves of evacuating sinners; for yes, she was dead set on evacuating right up until the last possible moment.

But it hadn’t been hard to go unnoticed when Hell’s other defences had started failing. When Alastor’s power had cut out. When great geysers of black and red energy had erupted from the ground and spilled from the walls, carving sinkholes into the streets and the city. When Vaggi had called through the portal about the holy weapons and ex-exorcist guards clearing the way to Heaven being overwhelmed.

One by one, the powers of the overlords holding together the safe passageways to the Hotel had vanished. 

Finally she’d been forced to give up on saving the remaining sinners… but that didn’t mean she was going to give up on the fight. She could still fix this, she was the Princess of Hell. She could make a difference. She could save her realm.

Leaving Vaggi, Pentious, Angel and the others behind, telling them despite their pleas and protests to close the portal and make their way to the relative safety behind the new pearly gates, Charlie flew up – shakily – into the void between Heaven and Hell, where a cluster of glowing figures were zooming around the horrifying sight of Roo’s true form. 

Her uncles and aunts, the Sins, had joined the last and highest angels in the fight. But even as she approached… Belphegor fell, then Asmodeus, then Mammon and Beelzebub and Leviathan and Satan. They either dropped out of the sky into Roo’s waiting mouths, or were torn apart where they flew.

Then she felt rather than heard her voice. 

“HELLO, MY DISOBEDIANT SPAWN. YOU MAY HAVE FAILED ME, BUT YOU STILL HAVE A USE TO ME.”

And she’d felt herself weaken all of a sudden too. The eldritch form that was Roo bulged and grew and stretched out even further as she drained her daughter of her power and energy, tendrils reaching for Heaven. 

Emily had been the first to notice Charlie. She’d startled, had stammered, had frantically tried to usher her away… but in turning her back on the danger, she’d left herself exposed. 

She’d screamed as she was burned away. Charlie had tried to save her, but it was too late.

And now reality was disintegrating faster around her, great booms filling her ears.

She felt like crying. She always ended up making things worse. Her impulse to join the fight had let Roo use her like a battery and gain the strength she needed to enact her total revenge. Maybe even claim the souls of those Charlie had saved and got to Heaven. Cause if Roo invaded and destroyed Heaven… her friends would die. Vaggi would die. And it would be her fault, and they’d hate her for it which was what she deserved—

But Sera, Lucifer, and Lilith had not been angry at her. They’d shared a look, and a nod, and a gulp. 

And before Charlie could even put two and two together that they were going to make the greatest sacrifice play ever, they’d grabbed at the frayed edges of the hole in reality Roo had burst through, ripped it wider, and pulled it over Roo’s physical manifestation like a canvas sack, and twisted. And injected their little trap with all of their remaining power.

The act released untold amounts of energy, and it all seemed to explode in slow motion.

Charlie screamed for them not to do this, but it was too late.

The last smile her father had given her was as he turned his back on this nuclear bomb, and with one last burst of his former power no longer directed to his self-preservation, shoved her. Giving her the momentum to make it back to her home realm.

She’d seen it as he’d been swallowed up by the blast. Along with her mother. What was left of aunts and her uncles. The high Seraphim. They were gone in an instant.

She’d screamed as she plummeted, hairline fractures and tears in the fabric of space racing with her.

She’d seen Vaggi diving from Heaven, screaming, reaching out to try and catch her. She’d made it within a few feet of Charlie before the cracks in reality separated them. The last she’d seen of Vaggi was her distorted image being pulled back, pulled away, by someone else with wings.

That was the last she’d seen of the love of her life. 

 

Her whole world… her family… gone. Except for Alastor, sitting on her bed next to her, and Keekee in her lap… she’d lost everything. 

She’d lost. 

 

And as she’d shut down from the grief again, limply clinging onto the ring with the butterfly patterns she still wore on her left hand… Alastor hadn’t had the faintest idea of how he felt, or how he should feel. 

Chapter 3: The dream is over…

Summary:

Charlie and Alastor process in their own ways.

Chapter Text

Now, Charlie was as decrepit as the hotel she resided in.

She’d dedicated her life to redeeming sinners, to fulfilling her interpretation of her mother’s dream. And now her mother was dead, and since the realms had been cut off from one another, redemption must now be physically impossible. What a blow that was.

There would never be another greeting circle, another trust exercise, another therapy session. There would never be another meeting with Heaven, another visit from Emily, another soul whose hues changed to gentle pastel blues and yellows before they glowed and vanished from this realm.

There would never be another day or night spent with her girlfriend. She would never again be lofted into the air by Vaggi as they sang something saccharine together. They would never again thoroughly enjoy a night together to the point that they could be heard through the walls of their bedroom.

Her dream was over.

So she dedicated her whole existence, in the present, to grieving her lost friends, her family, and her lover. Grieving them, even though many of them were still ‘alive’, up there in Heaven. Certainly Angel was thinking of her, and Pentious, and Baxter and Niffty and Crymini too.

Certainly Vaggi was thinking of her the most.

That fact was no comfort to Charlie. They were gone. She couldn’t get them back. 

(Alastor thought that maybe she’s a little bit greedy for that. And he admired her for that little bit of sin. But also, he understood. His fondness for Husker and Niffty still lingered uselessly.

This was why you didn’t love in Hell. he thought.)

 


 

Charlie stayed in bed a lot, with Keekee curled up on her lap or next to her. The hotel cat had grown lethargic and grey-furred. The plush goat toy that had once been Razzle lay tucked in next to her.

She stayed inside. She kept the curtains drawn. The few times she chanced looking outside – whether at the destroyed cityscape, or up at the empty sky – it inevitably made her break down crying. 

Even inside, she cried at the portraits of her redeemed family (blood, adopted, and found), until Alastor purchased curtains to hang over them and hide them.

She didn’t smile anymore.

And she clung to Alastor. She’d sit next to him at dinner, shuffling her chair close until it was physically touching his. She invited herself into his room, or his radio tower when he started putting on his broadcasts again (music only, for he no longer had access to the voices of the souls he’d trapped and amassed in his century here in Hell). She’d get closer, and closer, without saying anything, until he eventually sighed, and acknowledged her presence.

And then she’d ask him if she could touch him. Lean against him. Hug him, even. 

He let her, because it was the proper thing to do. 

But he’d also tell her when she needed a bath, because her depression was causing her to neglect her self-care.

 


 

Alastor didn’t know what to make of all this. This reality, this aftermath, was not entertaining. 

He no longer had the powers he’d craved and received upon his fall to this realm. He could not broadcast the screams of suffering of those who’d mocked or hindered him. He could no longer make anyone suffer, not in that way. His shadow was now a singular, inanimate thing cast onto the floor. He could not summon black tentacles from the void, or cast a green aura as he reached beyond the corporeal to inflict soul-deep damage on his enemies. He no longer had the bayou in his room.

He could no longer tug at Husk’s chain and make him grumble or squirm, get the satisfaction of putting him back in his place when he disobeyed. He could no longer enjoy Niffty’s company.

And although there was a small comfort in the collection of old records he could broadcast on the radio – swing and big band increasingly amended with the blues – no one was really listening, anymore. 

The knowledge of that made him feel sick.

Alastor still did things, oh yes. Because it would drive him insane to do nothing at all. He went on errands, collecting supplies for the Hotel, mostly foodstuffs. He still put on obligatory radio shows, and busied himself in repairing his equipment by hand now that his magic no longer kept it in pristine as-new condition. He poured himself whiskey, and if he got tipsy enough he’d put on the rotting cockroach crown Niffty had made for him years ago.

He couldn’t slam back whiskey like he used to be able to. He would wake with hangovers.

When he was sure Charlie slept, he would take a knife from the hotel kitchen, sneak out, and find a sinner to carve up and slaughter. In some ways, resorting to his old murder methods – his human murder methods – was liberating. He was glad he’d never gotten sloppy with his fitness, his physical fighting prowess, or his ability to be stealthy, while he was an Overlord.

Especially when the remaining sinners were few and far between, and had become quite twitchy and reclusive, making it a challenge to hunt down.

And the fact his victims would still pull themselves together from the disembodied scraps of flesh and organ he left lying where he’d killed them meant that he’d never run out of this.

But on the other hand… he’d done that already, for the golden years of his human lifespan. He’d grown bored of it even while he was still alive. It was ho-hum.

There were no exciting possibilities anymore. 

And what could he get out of Charlie? This poor, wilted demon belle had lost all her charm and moxie; what could he exploit her for? That wasn’t all because her spark had gone out, oh no, it was also because there was no one worthy left in Hell for him to use power against.

(He also didn’t think he could quite stomach being that dependant on someone else’s power. He’d won his power with his own skills and smarts. He’d wanted to win something from her, not just take it.)

Yet Charlie relied on his physical presence, on contact with him, almost in a vampireish way. She wanted him. She needed him. 

And that discomforted him. 

He didn’t like being wanted for only what he could give.

He was supposed to be free now.

What his former soul owner wanted was now irrelevant. Rosie was gone. Roo was gone, banished from reality. She didn’t need him watching over her daughter anymore.

He didn’t need Charlie anymore.

Why was he still staying?

Why did he feel compelled to stay? 

…

They’d both just have to carry on, he supposed. 

Chapter 4: a weapon to kill demon royalty

Summary:

The fallout of the apocalypse drives one imp to try something desperate.

Notes:

TW // Graphic violence and character death in this chapter. The dead dove has flown in.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Hell and Heaven had been separated for good, but Hell had also been cut off from the living world. 

The end times would have happened at some point, whether Roo’s final assault on the universe had happened or not. But her injection of potent, unrefined sin tipped things over the edge so much sooner. 

Humanity spiralled. There were wars. Horrific, apocalyptic wars. Then the climate changed, as years of greedy pollution caught up with humankind. Crops failed. The remaining coastal cities flooded.

By now, like in Hell, Earth’s population was decimated. By the end of the century, mankind would be extinct. 

And none of their souls could ever go to Heaven or Hell, now that the realms had been separated for good. They would be cast out into the void for all eternity.

 


 

But down in Hell, they didn’t know that. They couldn’t know that. 

All they knew was that there were no more new sinners, just the stragglers from the great evacuation rush: the ones Heaven wasn’t willing to take, the ones who’d hunkered down and been lucky to avoid Roo’s hungry tendrils. Wandering around in a city of dead, closed, hacked out eyes.

And the Hellborn – the loyal servants of the sins, the ones who had been sent on missions to the human world to seduce them into sin – they had no place to go. They had no roles anymore. The succubi and incubi had no humans to tempt into sex. The infestor demons had no humans to terrorise, no minds to read. 

Without the Sins, and with many high-ranking Hellborn dead, it was chaos out there. There were frequent riots. The surviving Goetia, few in number, could not keep the old order. The provision of utilities and supplies was just about the only thing that held together, and even then it was hanging on by a thread.

Now, these demons were just permanently trapped denizens of Hell, doomed to survival for survival’s sake; growing crops and producing products and scraping by on the fruits of a wounded world.

Doomed to a pointless existence.

And because of that, they began to resent the last remaining Morningstar. 

Alastor knew it. He listened to his competitors’ radio stations. The only ones left were the hellborn stations in the other circles. And they were angry. Bored to death with their lack of purpose (and oh, he understood that very well), raging at the deaths of their leaders and celebrities. Mourning those lost when Roo had tried to rip reality apart. 

They needed someone to blame.

Lucifer was dead. The Sins were dead. All those crucial to the final battle against Roo were dead… except for Charlie. She was their only outlet for their rage. And she was doing nothing to lead. She was just mourning and rotting in the hotel, so wrapped up in her own grief that she couldn’t see the consequences of her inaction.

So by the time Charlie started venturing out again, after driving herself nearly half-mad from being cooped up inside, Alastor would always accompany her. He walked on the outside of the footpath. He linked his arm through hers. He brought her to the pop-up markets where he procured the foodstuffs to fill the Hotel’s pantries. 

On this first outing, an idle part of his mind suggested that she might attempt suicide by getting run over by a car. But with the thrashings she’d taken over the years in her fights; from Adam, from that Von Eldritch girl, from her own mother, her father… and Roo… she would probably survive. Besides, with the state of the streets, Pentagram City was not suited to cars anymore. 

It was the hellborn they should worry about. The demons – mostly imps – who’d moved into Pentagram City to scavenge what was left. They glared as he and Charlie walked past; whether they were sifting through rubble, setting up camp, or trying to raid a surviving drugs vending machine. They’d glare, until he nonchalantly adjusted his jacket and let them see the handle of the knife in its inner pocket, so they’d know he was fully capable of fighting back.

Lacking his overlord capabilities, though… it still had Alastor feeling vulnerable.

He was mindful of the odds of some hellborn going through with some retributive attack on Charlie. Something that might harm him, too, whether as collateral or the intended target. He was putting himself at a great deal of risk to his afterlife.

It wouldn’t affect him if she died, really. He’d be free of her. He wouldn’t have her invading his physical space. He wouldn’t be endangering himself for the sake of someone else’s protection. He’d be no worse off without her.

Why then, did it leave such an ill sensation in his gut when he entertained that line of thought?

…

It was bad manners. Yes, that was all it was.  

 


 

When it happened, it was so close to home. So close to the Hotel. 

They were just about at the gates, returning from a shopping trip (Charlie had cried over a bottle of bleach because it reminded her of Niffty, and then cried over the liquor section of the market they frequented because it reminded her of Husk)… when there was the crack of a bullet burying itself into the wall just behind Charlie’s head.

And then, milliseconds later, the crack of a gun firing from some distance away. 

Charlie jolted, but sluggishly. If the bullet had been a few more inches to the left, it would have gone right through her head. 

And, as Alastor fought down the memory of being shot in the bayou that unfortunate day in 1933, to analyse the situation… he saw the bullet embedded in the wall was glowing a gold so bright it was almost white.

An holy bullet. 

An angelic gun. 

Carmilla Carmine was gone, but her weapons lived on.

That could have killed him. 

That could’ve killed Charlie. Angelic steel had taken down powerful Goetia, had weakened Lucifer when he was trapped in Vox’s cannon to the point of collapse and mild haemorrhaging. No doubt in his mind that it could have killed her.

And Alastor felt rage.

It wasn’t like the rage of his demon form. In a weaker, smaller body, it felt less potent. But it was still so strong. Uncontainable. 

How dare they. 

Who did this? he asked himself as he tried to hustle Charlie along, though she was like a deer in the headlights. 

He got his answer soon enough.

“YOU BITCH!!!” An imp, large for his species with impressive ibex-like horns, came stumble-running out of a nearby building, chasing them down. “YOU FUCKING BITCH, YOU TOOK EVERYTHING FROM ME!”

Charlie stammered. “Wh-what did I do?”

The imp stopped in his tracks at that, and laughed a manic, desperate laugh. “What did you do? What the FUCK did you do?! You know what you did!” He swung his arm around, gesturing at the ruined buildings and moonscape of shattered mountains. “Look around! Look how empty this place is!! I have nothing! My FAMILY has nothing!”

“I—I—”

“You cut us off from the mortal world! Now there’s no more sinners, now there’s no more humans – I’M OUT OF A JOB!!” He gesticulated wildly with the rifle in his right hand. “My whole BUSINESS is GONE!! All the things your royal – your royal lack of ass took for granted are gone!”

“But it—it wasn’t…me…” That was the wrong thing for Charlie to say. It enraged the imp even more.

“Of COURSE it was you! You and your family, they split the fucking universe apart! I NEED to go to Earth for my job! I killed humans in the living world for clients here! And now I CAN’T!”

Ah, that rang a bell. The jingle Alastor had caught over the airwaves, or overheard playing on the hotel TV, for that plucky little imp business that had taken hits in the mortal realm. An assassin. His grip on reality and overly emotional state aside, Blitzø Buckzo might just be a challenge to take out. And despite the manner of his provocation, Alastor felt enjoyment at the prospect of doing so.

Charlie, meanwhile, looked revolted. “You’re a—?” She was stuck on the imp’s line of employment, because of course she was. Still more concerned with an obsolete moral code than the danger to her existence. But, with her distracted, he could start to slip away, out of the imp’s line of sight, and get in the right position to strike.

“Ohhhh, and you think I should feel sorry for you, huh? A princess who never cared about who made Hell tick? Who doesn’t even care about – about other royals?” The imp kept ranting. Alastor worked his way close enough now to see tears streaming down his face, as he fidgeted with the inert amber crystal stuck onto his left forearm. “FUCK YOU! There’s no way to fix this, and you don’t want to fix this! So the least I can do is blow your stupid barbie face to bits. That way we ALL suffer!” 

The imp locked and loaded the rifle with shaking hands and a grunt of effort. He took aim. At this close range, a rifle of that calibre would make a mess. 

And Charlie was still frozen in place. 

But Alastor was close enough.

He leaped, and he tackled the imp to the ground, swatting the holy rifle out of his arms. He had the time to get a closer look at it – a bolt action rifle with a scope, rusted in places, but still bearing the swirling embellishments that had been the Carmines other specialty along its blessed steel barrel. 

The imp responded sluggishly, and tried to worm his way out and reach for the gun, but that just gave Alastor the opportunity to kick the gun away, sending it skidding across the pavement.

It was only now that the imp seemed to realise he’d been attacked. Alastor noted that his eyes were somewhat unfocused, and that his face was gaunt and sickly. “Oh, fuck you, freaky red guy!” the imp spat, scrabbling at Alastor with still-sharp claws. A few rips were torn in his coat – oh, at least he was a fighter.

“Guy? No, I’m not just any guy!” He let the imp out of his grasp, but kept himself between him and the gun. Let’s at least try to have some fun here.

The imp tried to charge him, now, throwing wild haymakers that were easy enough to dodge. Al was nearly twice as tall as the imp, not counting those huge horns, and that gave him an easy advantage.

And speaking of those horns…

Alastor yoinked the imp as if picking up a suitcase, and flung him into the kerb. Hard. The imp struggled to get up, even as Alastor took his sweet time stalking him down.

“Alastor, that’s enough!”

He’d barely made it to his knees when Alastor was upon him, knocking him to the ground with a much more coordinated punch, and pinning him there.

“I am Alastor… the Radio Demon…”

“Where the fuck’s your radio, shithead?” the imp spat.

“…You attacked Charlie Morningstar.” Undeterred, Alastor unsheathed his knife, and raised it above his head. “So now I am your demise!”

Charlie cried out. “Alastor, no! NO!”

But it was too late. 

Alastor swung the knife down into the imp’s chest, driving into his lung. The imp gasped, spluttering. He carved a gash down his chest before pulling the knife back, and – oh, imp blood was black. How fascinating. He hadn’t gone after hellborn before. He tuned out Charlie’s screams, and stabbed again – but the imp, suddenly possessing a sense of self-preservation, pulled one side of jacket across to protect himself and tried to roll onto his side. The knife bit into leather. 

“Now, we won’t have any of THAT!” Alastor scolded. He made to work the imp’s jacket off, wincing when his hand came into contact with an unexpected set of spikes… no, wait, those were quills. Running down his back. 

He took a moment to grin before ripping the jacket off so violently that it yanked two of those spines out. The imp tried to scream, but, with a punctured lung, he could only wheeze. Clearly he had been malnourished, too, that jacket had added a lot of bulk to his silhouette that just wasn’t there anymore. Alastor could see his ribcage through his skin… and where his first stab had opened up his chest, he caught a glimpse of a rib in all that ebony flesh.

“Let’s start here, shall we?” 

He carved across, a stroke from right to left, careful not to go for the heart just yet, and slashed open the imp’s liver. Blood started overflowing out of there. The imp twitched desperately, and Charlie’s screams rose in pitch and intensity. Then he stabbed again, into the imp’s stomach. The knife came out coated in bile, and, in a moment of inspiration, he held it to the imp’s face and shaved it over the white mass of burn scar tissue on the right side of his face. 

The imp flinched, as his own stomach acid burned against his freshly sliced skin. Alastor could tell he was trying to scream, but no sound came out.

Alastor repeated the process of shaving and leaving little acidic cuts, as far as the scarring went down the imp’s neck. But he wouldn’t go for the jugular, no. That was too quick and easy. Drawing this out, while the imp was bleeding out and his bile was leaking into places and organs it really shouldn’t be (if you cared about that sort of thing) was all too gratifying.

Disappointingly, this mere kitchen knife wouldn’t allow for him to take the imp’s horns off easily. Or to debone him properly.

Instead, for the grand finale, Alastor would fall back on his trust old favourite, and dear Niffty’s old favourite technique: more stabs.

The first landed in the imp’s other lung, and Alastor tried to drive it as deep as he possibly could; he put his whole weight behind it. Beneath him, he heard the crack of breaking bones. The imp’s distress seemed to increase tenfold; aah, had adrenaline finally been injected into his emaciated body? Well, too little, too late for that. He slashed up the imp’s collar, nicking his windpipe open. The imp started to gurgle.

Then the second stab went straight for the centre of the imp’s chest. The imp’s uncoordinated twitching and struggling merged into a full body spasm.

Another stab, a little bit to the right. The imp jolted again. 

Another. He wasn’t aiming anymore.

Another. A smaller spasm.

Another.

And another. And another.

And another and another and another and another.

His stabs turned to slashes; sloppy, but doing their job of tearing the imp’s flesh and body to shreds. The knife must’ve been blunted by now, clashing and hacking against bones as much as it was, but who cared about a clean kill, at this point? Not him!

Blood splattered against his face, dotted the lenses of his glasses, as he finished carving the imp’s body up, like a butcher. Had he croaked his last? He must have. But Alastor hadn’t heard it. His ears were ringing, and the rush of bloodlust just felt so good. So did the realisation that he was still deadly, dangerous, capable. Worthy of fear. He’d earned his reputation again. 

And then, as he surfaced from his trance, Charlie’s screams were joined by more.

Alastor glanced up to see two smaller imps and a grey-and-white-furred hellhound, standing further down the street, watching on in absolute despair. The hellhound fell to her knees, paws tearing at her mane of long fur flowing down from her head. The male of the two imps, still dressed rather dapperly for the end of the world, was adding to a puddle of vomit in the middle of the roadway. The female imp, though… despite the tears streaming down her face, she looked ready to charge with her oversized battle axe. 

He snatched the rifle from where he’d kicked it to, and pulled it on the intruders. “I wouldn’t join your compatriot in death, if I were you,” he warned, as he checked that there were still bullets in the chamber. And there were – three, to be exact. What a pleasant coincidence. “Only one of us here has holy arms.”

He locked, loaded, and aimed. “And it isn’t you. Run along, now.”

The male imp retreated immediately. The two ladies didn’t. Ah, it was good to see some moxie from them.

The hellhound went down on all fours, transforming into a larger, feral, properly canine form. She was foaming at the mouth, trembling, taut and ready to run him down… and yet tears trailed down her muzzle. Through the rabid demonic rage, this dog was grieving.

Once upon a time, a barking dog had startled him in the middle of disposing of his latest victim. In raising his head to see the threat, he’d been killed by the hound’s master. He’d accordingly held a grudge against the more canine of sinners, and of the Hellhounds too.  

This time, he was the hunter. And he revelled in the fear, the grief, the suffering in their eyes.

“NOW.” He shot at the pavement right near the hellhound’s paws, sending bits of concrete and blessed shrapnel spraying into her face. She yelped and whined, blood spilling from the many cuts to her snout and face, before she turned tail and ran. The female imp, head darting between him and her hound for a moment of fearful indecision, followed. 

Ha! In a sense, Alastor had finally got back at the dogs that had given him away.

He felt grand. He may have been stripped of his power, but he could still inspire fear and cause pain. Unholy fuck, that felt good. It had been his favourite part of being the Radio Demon. 

He still was the Radio Demon. 

And, wiping his glasses clean, he looked down at the imp’s remains; a stew of flesh, organ and bones marinating in the bowl of his torn-up body. 

He did this.

With a triumphant grunt, Alastor drove the barrel of the rifle into the imp’s chest. The barrel cracked and split into shards as it impaled him, and the shards clattered and splattered into the imp’s remains. He dropped the gun stock and knelt to pick up one of the pieces, carefully avoiding contact with the glowing edges. It was vaguely blade-shaped; very crudely. But putting function over form, any sort of angelic steel would make him a force to be reckoned with.

This was not just a trophy. Give this a handle, and it would become a truly lethal knife.

In this day and age, he could still be the dominant force in Pentagram City. He could stand atop the heap. 

In the puddle of blood, his reflection smiled back at him. 

But when he turned to Charlie, she looked utterly horrified. Her eyes were red, and wide. Her tail was lashing, and so was her hair. It was the first time he’d seen her slip into it since the final battle with Roo. 

“You—you didn’t have to do that,” she hissed, voice shaking. Then she said it again, louder; an accusatory shriek. “You didn’t have to do that! You didn’t have to DO THAT!” And she turned and fled, stumbling her way through the gates outside the Hotel, and not bothering to close it behind her.

Alastor stood there, alone in the street, for a good minute. He pulled out his handkerchief and wiped his face clean. Then, inquisitively, he dabbed his finger to the splatters of blood that had gotten on his jacket, and raised it to his mouth. He took an experimental taste.

He spat the blood out immediately. It was tainted with booze and pharmaceuticals. Not a pleasant taste at all. He wouldn’t be secreting this carcass back to the Hotel pantry.

 


 

Charlie kept away from him for the rest of the day, and that suited him just fine. 

He washed the bloodstains off his clothes, poured himself a whiskey, and put on his original pressing record of ‘Let’s Misbehave’.

 

Notes:

…Yep. Stolas is dead too. I’m sorry.

Chapter 5: an apology tour?

Summary:

Charlie thinks Alastor should apologise. Alastor thinks Charlie is ungrateful.

Notes:

Context for anyone who skipped the previous chapter: Blitzø tried to assassinate Charlie, and Alastor gruesomely killed Blitzø in retaliation. In front of Loona, Millie, and Moxxie.

Charlie is extremely upset with Alastor.

Chapter Text

The next day, Charlie went out without Alastor.

 


 

She was still in her demon form; eyes red, horns out and tail lashing, when she cantered down the stairs and marched for the doors. 

“Going out twice in as many days?” he chirped. “How wonderful to see you’re recovering! Let me accompany you again.”

“No.” 

“But it’s for your safety, my dear! You remember what happened yesterday—”

She scoffed. “I remember what happened VERY fucking clearly, Alastor. I don’t need your cruel idea of protection. Besides, I’ll be using portals. I know how to make those.”

That mollified him somewhat. “Where are you going?” he inquired out of genuine interest.

Charlie didn’t answer him until she was almost at the door. “Imp City. To find the family of the guy you killed,” she said through gritted teeth, “and give them some sort of compensation. If they lost their livelihood—”

“The imp who tried to kill you?” he pointedly reminded her.

“I KNOW! I know he tried to assassinate me! But you didn’t have to be so horribly violent stopping him!”

“Why, Charlie, was it really any different to how I defended the Hotel from those loan sharks, all those years ago? And in your best interests too?”

“Yes! Because lower class hellborn are mortal! You killed him permanently!”

“So did I to Sinners, in years gone by! When I still had my powers.” A burst of laughter from an unseen audience would have gone well there, he thought, but, alas, his staff was a mere microphone now.

“Well… you…you…you didn’t have to enjoy it so much!”

“But I did! It’s the first time in months I’ve felt close to my old self, Charlie!”

“Fuck you,” she spat. “I really thought you’d be a better person by now, Alastor.” 

“Ah-ah, but why should I be?” he shot back, coolly. “Redemption? Why pursue something that’s completely out of reach? Why continue to impose your morality on others?” This was perhaps too provocative, but she needed to hear this. “And, need I point out, I saved your life, Charlie. I thought you’d be more grateful for that. Didn’t you try to ingrain on us the virtue of humility?”

The air around Charlie turned to fire, and her horns grew even longer. She bared her teeth. She SNARLED. But she did nothing more than just seethe at him this way. Alastor didn’t even need to step back from the flames. He felt a surge of satisfaction… but also a stab of disappointment. Charlie still had her powers. And she still wouldn’t use them. Not on him. 

She wouldn’t dare drive him away.

“You could have at least made it quick,” she muttered as she turned and opened the door. “He would have made it quick if he’d hit me.”

That… was a disconcerting sentence to hear out of her mouth. “Charlie—”

But he was met with the hotel doors slamming shut, and an angry, muffled yell of “Don’t follow me!” from outside, before the brief burst of a portal opening and closing shone through the stained-glass windows.

Alastor sighed. Of course he couldn’t follow her, without the power to teleport. There was nothing else he could do.

 


 

He waited in his radio tower for the rest of the day; not facing his microphone or the mixing desk, but instead keeping an eye out the window, musing. 

Was he worrying about Charlie? Of course not. There was no room for worrying about others in his heart. 

But it did feel oddly like the early days of his life when he’d been waiting for his mama to come home each evening.

 

Finally, as the darker darkness of the new nights set in, he saw the flash of a portal opening within the hotel grounds. Then Charlie walked back inside, hugging herself. 

Alastor went downstairs to meet her. He found her curled up morosely in one of the tattered lobby sofas.

She didn’t say anything at first. So he didn’t either. He just went and made jambalaya.

Charlie hadn’t moved at all when he left the kitchen, bringing her a bowl. But Keekee, despite her rapid aging and frailty, had managed to clamber onto her lap, and curled up there.

He handed Charlie the bowl, and sat down at the other end of the sofa. He busied himself with consuming his own bowl. 

But he did notice, out of the corner of his eye, that she set her bowl down without eating it. And, once again, she was inching her away along the couch, closer to him. Not looking at him, but still shuffling closer, until they were shoulder-to-shoulder.

(Well. Shoulder-to-upper arm. He still had the height advantage.)

And, finally, she told him how her outing had gone.

She’d found which office the imp had worked at (an abandoned tower with horn shaped finials), and from there she’d found the address of Blitzø Buckzo. But when she’d knocked on the door and proffered a hefty sum of cash to the hellhound and two imps residing in that apartment, they’d refused, and slammed the door on her.

She still felt she had to do something.

She recognised in the brief glimpse into the apartment of the hung pictures of the imp with one of the Goetia, Stolas – the one who had been exiled. He had died in Roo’s armageddon. But his daughter still lived – no longer Princess Octavia, the highest ranking surviving Goetia, but now just an elected representative of the largest intact faction in Imp City.

So Charlie had sought her out.

Octavia had said she’d do something to help Blitzø’s family, she knew them, after all.

But she too refused Charlie’s offer of compensation. And she’d told Charlie, to her face, what Alastor had surmised – that the Hellborn resented Charlie. That of course they were going to hold the last Morningstar accountable; even though her parents had brought about this calamity in the first place, she was the last figurehead. The scapegoat.

And sure, they’d survived and Roo had been defeated – but had the universe really been saved, if they were all as broken and lessened as this?

Charlie had still pleaded that she could try to make things better, but Octavia had told her not to bother. Had told her to keep to herself, that it would be safer. And, as she’d looked wistfully at a painting of her late father overseeing the harvest festival in Wrath, she’d murmured that one assassination attempt would usually be followed by another.

 

“Smart woman,” Alastor declared, when she’d finished telling her tale. “I would take her advice to heart if I were you, Charlie.” It might have seemed cowardly to hide away, but if she were to extend an olive branch to the Hellborn or step up to lead Hell again, it would need to be once the generations that resented her had died, and the memory of her failure were all but forgotten. Plus, in this state, she was clearly just as inexperienced and incapable as she’d been when he’d seen her first attempts at redeeming Angel Dust. 

Charlie heaved a tired breath. “Yeah, yeah, ‘you told me so,’” she mumbled. Then, eventually: “You did save my life.”

She’d admitted it, acknowledged it, at last.

But she didn’t say any more.

“And yet you won’t thank me for it.” Alastor could tell she was still cut up about it. If she really wanted to be spared the sight of necessity… “How about we make a little deal?”

“Fuck you, Alastor.” Charlie let out a hollow chuckle. “Why are you even asking? You can’t even make binding soul deals anymore.”

“This deal doesn’t need that.” He felt stung by that reminder, but he could put it aside for now. “You stay inside, and I don’t have to hurt anyone in the act of protecting you. Or, if you so badly desire your freedom to go out, you merely accept my company, my protection, and accept me for who I am.”

“A murderer?” she asked bitterly. “A sadist?”

“A survivor,” he answered.

Charlie said nothing for a minute. Then she started to cry.

“Why do I always hurt people when I never meant to?” she wept. “You killed that imp. On purpose. Why don’t you get the accountability for that? It’s not fair!”

Ah, the poor girl. Life was not fair. The afterlife wasn’t either. The way her father had sheltered her from the reality of things down here stood out very clearly. He had always admired how long she’d clung to her optimism, her saccharine delusions. He’d approved of the strength of her convictions. He just knew her convictions would have to be broken down at some point. 

Decorum dictated that he should apologise, or offer comfort. He knew that. His mama taught him that. She’d have wanted him to be a gentleman. But he wasn’t sorry for enjoying the kill, for reclaiming his reputation.

He wasn’t sorry for saving Charlie’s life. Just like she wasn’t openly thankful for it. Tit for tat. 

And he noticed she hadn’t made any attempts to move away from him, the whole time. No, in fact, she’d buried her head into his shoulder, dampening the lapel of his jacket with her tears.

So he didn’t say anything. He didn’t need to. Charlie wasn’t going to drive him away for this.

She needed him.

 

He still didn’t know how he felt about that.

Chapter 6: cat’s in the casket

Summary:

Alastor pulls a prank on Charlie.

Notes:

TW // Cannibalism, murder, animal death.

Chapter Text

The stragglers at the hotel didn’t stay for redemption anymore, because of course they didn't. There were no meals served (though Charlie would, on occasion, drop small parcels of food outside the doors of the occupied rooms), there were no activities planned. Rarely did they come out to socialise with the Princess of Hell (though she did try to remember their faces if she bumped into one of them in the corridors) or the Radio Demon.

They were just squatters. They came and they went and they did as they pleased. 

One room hosted a drug den, another was being used to make moonshine, another was hotboxed so much by its occupant that Alastor could smell the giggle smoke a whole floor up on the other side of the building. Still others engaged in carnal acts, or mended and invented firearms out of the scraps that could still be found, and there was supposedly a gambling ring around bug fighting of all things – which he certainly believed; after years of Niffty’s pest control and Baxter’s experimentation the bugs were aggressive and potent enough. 

It seemed that everywhere he looked in this building, there were echoes of the original hotel residents.

None of this was anything Charlie would have been pleased with, were she still her old self. And Vaggi? Dear Vaggi, if she were still here, she would have been furious at the debauchery. Maybe frustrated with Charlie’s apathy to it. Maybe she would have argued with Charlie after this long a depression. Maybe she would have joined her in it. 

If Alastor killed them, for good, with the shard of holy steel he now possessed, he’d be doing the Hotel a service, really.

But for now, no. It would just not do to squander the very finite number of potential victims he had left. 

So he just let them be, unless they crossed his path in the wrong way, and then he would kill them or maim them in the usual way, with a usual, unblessed weapon. Sometimes it would frighten the sinner away from the Hotel once they’d reconstituted. Other times they just went crawling back to their room and carried on with their depravity. 

(Then there was that one fellow who seemed to get off to being killed.)

If Charlie found out about it, he could plead self-defence.

…

Speaking of Charlie. 

Since the assassination attempt, things between them had stagnated for a while. She had indeed refused to go out in his company… though he was sure she was using her portal-creating skills to circumvent him. Which aggravated him, 

Ah well. He was still going on his hunts out in the ruined streets, behind her back, at the dead of night. They both could keep their secrets. 

But eventually, maybe as a result of some unsavoury experience he wasn’t privy to, or maybe from her sheer need for company, she had relented and asked him if he could come with her again. And it made him feel pleased, perversely, so much so that he got frustrated with himself for it.

Was it just the fact she was admitting he was right? Was he getting weak and sentimental (no friends in Hell, after all)? 

Or did he just want her?

He did concede to her pacifist notions, though. Breaking up the monotony of strolling the broken boulevards of Pentagram City felt very much called for, at any rate. 

So he took her on hikes. He may have been born on the bayou, but he could manage an invigorating trail through the rugged mountain wastelands encircling the crater of Pentagram City. She kept pace with him easily enough, with her limitless antichrist energy, though her clumsiness led to a few stumbles and scrabbles and slips on the rocky terrain.

They made it to the summit of the highest remaining peak together. From up here, in the dark, even the ruins of the city and the scattered lights of the shantytowns looked almost beautiful. Alastor watched Charlie watch them, and the silent tears that rolled down her cheeks seemed bearable for her.

 


 

Charlie may have been broken, but she was still Charlie Morningstar. She still had songs in her, and Alastor could coax them out of her. He’d hum as they went on their hikes, and eventually, she would join in. He taught her how to play the blues on piano. He paused in his broadcasts, or in his reading, or whatever he was doing at the time, when she started to sing of her own accord; not the snippets of sniffling laments but more mature melancholy tunes. 

He cooked for her, and tried to rotate a variety of the creole cuisine of his life (at least what he could remember, that wasn’t meat-based) each day. One day, when she asked for it, he sucked up his pride and tried to make pancakes the way Lucifer had. She seemed to enjoy it… but he was dissatisfied with them.

He still made pancakes for her, after that. He just switched to making them Cajun style. 

And he made sure to feed Keekee too. The poor old hotel cat was very much slowing up now, she looked worse than Husker had on his bad days. She slept a lot, she couldn’t levitate anymore and walked with a limp, and her big eye was getting cloudy with a cataract. She sought out Charlie’s company a lot, but sometimes she would find her way to Alastor and bunt his legs while he was recording another broadcast, or pursuing the surviving books in the Hotel library. 

That is, when she wasn’t bumping into the legs of a chair or table.

He did think that fresh meat ought to do her good; after all, she was a cat; a carnivore.

And when she was done eating – she rarely finished her bowl anymore – he would pick her up and carry her to wherever Charlie was.

Charlie got teary-eyed when Alastor did that. She said it meant so much that he was showing he could care. And when he tried to brush it off, she’d cuddle up to his side with purposeful affection. 

He still didn’t know how he felt about that. He’d rather she not rely on his touch so much. But it was routine now. On the days when she hadn’t, something had felt… empty inside him.

So he tolerated her leaning against him for a few seconds longer each time.

 


 

It was approaching one year since Roo brought about the end times.

He didn’t need to check any calendar; he could tell from Charlie’s demeanour. Her depression returned, she lingered at the still-covered portraits of her parents and her lost friends. She stopped going out, and looking out the window at the empty sky made her cry again.

Suddenly, Alastor’s physical presence, and his music, and his charm, wasn’t enough to keep her buoyed up. 

That rankled him.

This wasn’t like before, he told himself as he waited outside Charlie’s room, listening to her muffled sobs from within. Charlie had noone else to turn to now. Lucifer wasn’t here to interfere, with his frankly juvenile competitive streak. Lilith wasn’t here to give orders. Vaggi wasn’t here to coddle and take up all Charlie’s time. 

Alastor had Charlie all to himself. 

Except she kept herself from him—

He snarled, and went stalking through the corridors. Curse propriety. Curse his humanity. Curse whatever it was that was drawing him to Charlie when there was nothing he could get from her anymore…

A warm body bumped into him. Then a hand tapped him on the rear. “‘Ey, watch where you’re goin’, babes.” 

Nothing except… a reaction.

His hand slipped inside his jacket; not to check for being pickpocketed, but to reach for the holy steel shard. “How disrespectful.” 

“What? Can’t a doll appreciate a pretty twink such as yourself, and see if you really don’t have that tail—WHOA WHAT THE SHITTING FUCK—!!”

The makeshift blade sliced into her abdomen like butter, and the sinner, tall and lean and insect-like, yelped as the qualities of the blessed steel burned and entered her veins like venom. Thinking quickly took the chance to shove her into the nearest unlocked room, through the door as it opened, before any of her blood could touch the carpeted floor out in the corridor. 

“MOTHER-FUCK!!” The sinner clearly wanted to fight back, and she certainly had enough limbs to do so, but the blessedness in her unholy body was weakening her fast. Alastor stood over her, fending off her kicks and punches, and got to work carving her up and gutting her, making sure to make enough progress before she expired.

As he dragged her entrails out of her body, it occurred to him that she bore quite the similarity to Angel Dust, in spirit and demeanour.

A punch to his cheek, despite being feeble, managed to detract him from his task for a moment, and then the sinner’s knee caught him in the crotch. He’d already freed her of her genitalia, she seemed to want to return the favour.

Perhaps she reminded him of Valentino more, with his hands-on fighting style.

Or Vox.

Alastor gave her no sign of the annoying pain she’d inflicted on him, and tore open her jugular with his teeth.

 


 

“Alastor?” 

“Mmm, yes, dear?”

Charlie, wearing her PJs and carrying Keekee, shuffled up to the dining room table. “Where’s… the woman who was staying in Room 2810?” 

Alastor took a sip his mug of blood-spiked coffee. “Who?”

“You know, the… woman! With the mandibles and the fuzzy antenna-things. Who never wore a shirt!”

“Ah, yes! Her!” He took another sip. “Haven’t the foggiest. Did you consider she might have checked out?”

“Noone uses the guest book anymore, Al.” She gently placed Keekee on the floor when the old cat squirmed. “And I checked, and… the key’s still in her door.” 

“Hm. Well, maybe she’s like our dear old friend Anthony, working the streets.” He smiled at her deceptively. “Nothing you need to worry about, Charlie. I’m sure she’s where he’s supposed to be.”

Charlie nodded mutely, tears welling up in her eyes again. She turned and retreated to the isolation of her bedroom.

That said and done, Alastor took the bowlful of the sinner’s remains, raw and still juicy, from underneath the tablecloth and put it on the floor next to Keekee. It ought to be quite the treat for her. The hint of blessedness in the meat gave it quite the kick, if he did say so himself.

 


 

Every couple of days or so, he would target another sinner. Just one at a time.

He made the effort to be random, to allay suspicion, but most of this batch of final Hotel residents were either mentally addled or inebriated enough to not pay attention. So this secrecy was just for Charlie’s sake, to keep stringing her along.

First went the mechanic, trying to rebuild their armed and armoured motorcycle; so fixated on their work were they that they didn’t notice him creeping up behind them until it was too late. Then the first of the stoners; a gentle, slothful soul, so addled by his  smoking that his fellows just watched Alastor slaughter him with no more than a disappointed “Dude, not cool.”

He tried to pick those who he assumed were the most moral. The most kind, or the least sinful. The ones who would’ve seemed closest to redemption to Charlie, who thanked her for the food she brought up to them. The ruse had to be convincing.

It took about three or four sinners going missing for it to click for her, and for her to take the bait.

Alastor had expected her cautious hope to grow and flower into jubilation; the belle just could not keep her expectations realistic. Soon she was totally convinced that Heaven had somehow fixed the universe, and that redemption for sinners was possible once more.

He enjoyed seeing the hope flooding into her face, making her less pale and pallid. He chuckled at the way she dragged a telescope up to her balcony, and scanned the skies for any sign of Heaven.

He resented the way she started talking to the portrait of Vaggi; asking questions, telling her the scant details she’d observed about the “new arrivals” as if her almost-fiancee would hear her and be able to recognise them. 

 

But Alastor didn’t expect Charlie to rush up to him one day, panicked and hyperventilating, while he was in the middle of breakfast.

“You might get redeemed too,” she blurted out in a rush.

He startled, then snorted. “I hardly think so, dear—”

“No, no, I’m serious! You’ve been doing better recently, Alastor, you’ve been doing virtuous acts, taking care of Keekee and being selfless and… and if Heaven’s only able to receive sinners now but they can’t communicate to us yet…” Tears filled her eyes. “Alastor, I need you to sin.”

He blinked at her. “I beg your pardon?”

“Just a little! Just a little bit of sin!” She wrung her hands anxiously. “Like, shoplifting, or jaywalking, or—or kicking someone in the shins!”

Such minor, improper things? He may be a serial killer, but he had standards. Besides, kicking shins had been Niffty’s thing. “But Charlie, why ever should I do that?”

“I need you to stay here with me!” Charlie just about shrieked. “I can’t lose you too, Al!”

“How selfish of you.” He leered at the idea of thinking he was worthy of redemption, but it was also very interesting that she was breaking her values of giving everyone a second chance. This was something to probe at. “Why do you want to keep me here?” What do you need out of me so badly? 

“No, I—I—I want you to stay because you’re my last friend!”

Friends? The memory of Vox’s pitiful face, decades old, flashed in front of his eyes. Friendship leveraged as a means to an end. “Wrong answer. Try again. Why should I stay? And don’t tell me ‘you’re all I have left’. I want to know why you want me. Pick your words wisely, now.”

Charlie took several deep breaths, eyes glancing up to the ceiling as she thought. “You helped make the Hotel what it is – I mean, what it was,” she said, shakily. “You fought by my side, you fought for me. You were there for nearly all that the Hotel accomplished – what I’m trying to say is you’re someone important in my life.” She was crying now; she hiccuped. “Vaggi’s not here anymore. My parents are gone. I just – I need someone, Alastor.” 

Silence, other than the sound of her little sobs. Alastor dwelled in it, considering Charlie’s words.

Then, softly, he said: “Alright. If you insist. I’ll do what I can to stay.” He couldn’t even let the irony slip into his tone of voice.

Her sobs intensified with relief, and she hugged him. He allowed it.

 

Later, as he ran another radio broadcast and set ‘Little White Lies’ playing across the airwaves, Charlie invited herself into his studio, and sat by his side. She was still crying, it seemed.

“I’m sorry,” she whispered. “You said I was being selfish, and I think you were right, I’m denying you the chance to see Niffty, Husk, your mother again…”

“Trust me, my dear,” he replied easily, “there’s no offence taken. I can’t ignore the command of a princess, now, can I? And I do find you agreeable…” no, that wasn’t a strong enough word. “…enjoyable company.”

She leaned into his side again. She didn’t seem to have any words left to say, she just hummed along to the tune of the strings and trumpets playing from his mixing desk.

A part of him felt… warm, now he’d said it out loud. Charlie was enjoyable company, when she was in the mood. And even when she wasn’t… he found that agreeable. It was the truth. She still compelled him, and maybe there was something to be learned in her evolving responses and reactions, thanks to the depressed funk that Roo’s apocalypse had brought upon her.

That she wanted his company too, seemingly just for the sake of it… pleased him too.

But as Clare Hanlon began to warble about ‘Heaven being in someone’s eyes’… he felt something approximating guilt.

 

When Alastor killed his next victim out of the remaining Hotel population, it didn’t feel satisfying. It twisted his gut. It felt like taking candy from a baby – there was no challenge in this. Nothing for him to be proud of. He was only doing this to hurt Charlie.

He didn’t stop, though.

And as he minced up the remains of the plucky little chemist, he noticed Keekee retch and vomit onto the carpet. He realised that she’d been looking even more poorly since he introduced her to the diet of double-killed sinner meat.

Tonight, she’d left her dish nearly entirely uneaten.

 


 

Charlie found out what Alastor was doing, of course, eventually.

He let her find out. He knew how not to be sloppy and to take good care of the remains of his victims, so well that it was ingrained habit for him. To be sloppy, for him to slip up, was a wilful choice. 

And why pull a prank if you didn’t get to see your victim when the rug was pulled out from under them?

Alastor watched and smiled as she stormed up to him, holding the severed arm from the garbage dumpsters at arms length. He let her demand answers, let her horrified yells wash over him harmlessly. He showed her the murder weapon; shard of the angelic rifle’s barrel, sharpened to a point and caked with burnt-in blood.

He watched the hurt and betrayal flood her face. He caught the severed limb when she threw it at him, and he watched as she stormed away upstairs.

She didn’t talk to him for days. She actively avoided him, even. 

At first he was disappointed. Her demon form hadn’t even flared up this time; no, it had faded away the minute he confessed. Was she really still clinging to her unneeded morality?

Then he was vindicated; she still wouldn’t kick him out, no matter what he did. He still had security, here, at the Hotel.

Then he was curious; she’d never avoided him for this long.

…

Then he realised he felt empty, without her company.

 


 

After nearly a week, he had to do something about that.

But there was no way to corner Charlie or try to approach her when she was still dodging him, when she’d locked him out of her room. He knew where she’d been (especially her attempts at cooking for herself that had reduced the Hotel kitchen to one functional stove), but not where she was at the moment. 

Eventually, he found Keekee limping down the corridor, shivering and caterwauling miserably. There was a particular note of despair in her meows. Whatever she was searching for, whoever she was calling for, she could no longer see. Her degrading eyesight had reached the point of complete blindness.

Alastor stooped and picked her up. In his arms, she remained tense. 

He could hazard a guess as to who she was seeking out; the same person that he was.

Still carrying her, he went upstairs to Charlie’s door. He didn’t knock, he tested the doorhandle like he always did. Maybe she’d left it unlocked, or maybe Keekee still had enough of an aura emanating from her frail body that she could still unlock doors just by being near them – either way, it opened, and Alastor entered.

Charlie was sitting in bed like an invalid, knees tucked to her chin. When she saw him, she scowled, but her gaze softened when she saw Keekee, and whatever command to get out had been on her lips faded away. Alastor didn’t say anything, either.

He just approached her, and handed her the old cat, and Charlie took her, straightening her legs so that Keekee could rest there. The cat mewed, butted her head against Charlie’s hand, and curled up delicately in her lap, making soft, croaky purrs as Charlie petted her.

Alastor pulled up an armchair and sat, facing Charlie, waiting for when she was ready to talk to him.

“You tricked me.”

“I did.”

“That was really cruel, Alastor.”

“It was.” He couldn’t deny it. “But Charlie… my dear, why are you still surprised? We have known each other for so long now.”

“I thought you were my friend,” Charlie hissed. “I thought you wouldn’t do that to me.”

‘There are no friends in Hell’, felt too cruel to say. And maybe it was a lie. He did see her as… something. Not the way Vox saw friends as stepping stones to power and influence, not in the way that she saw him as someone to be emotionally dependant on… but he was fond of her. If that was friendship, then yes, he saw her as a friend.

“Why should friendship and a bit of cruelty be mutually exclusive?” he asked, genuinely.

She growled at him. “Of course. Like you kept Husk on a leash and still thought you could be all chummy with him, when you physically abused—”

“I never did any such thing! Never actually laid a hand on him! Only a little scare, a little tug, every now and then.”

“I’d never dream of even doing that to someone I loved—!”

“Of course not,” he said mildly. “Accidental hurt was always more your speed.”

Charlie flinched from that. He knew that was a weak point of hers. She’d never forgiven herself for every time she’d inadvertently gotten one of her friends upset with her; she’d only distracted herself from it.

This girl just could not move on when she needed to for her own sake.

He needed to guide her into that, and maybe now was the right time to deconstruct these delusional notions of hers that she could fix the end of the world.

“But you did do something nice for Husk,” Charlie said, out of the blue, meeting his eyes again. “And Niffty. You freed them and let them go to Heaven, in the end.”

Alastor remained silent.

“Do you miss them?” she asked, misty-eyed.

He did. He didn’t find their absences unbearable, he could go on without them, but it would have been pleasant to tease Husker over a whiskey, or enjoy hearing Niffty’s rivetingly bizarre flow of consciousness, again. He nodded.

“I miss everybody,” Charlie whined. “I really wish… I just wanted to, maybe, see them again. I know I can’t be redeemed… but maybe they’d have let me visit again. Or just let me know that everyone’s doing okay up there. That’s why your bullshit practical joke hurts so much…” Her tears fell, and her voice rose to a wail. “Redemption is possible! I proved you and everyone else wrong! I know you’re capable of caring, and yet you still go and do something like that…”

“Charlie,” said Alastor, gravely; the smile nearly gone from his face. “You know redemption is no longer possible. You must accept that. I accepted that I did not want it while I were still alive, for I knew I was a lost cause from the very first kill I made.” Longer than that. From the moment he was old enough to understand that the colour of his skin was a curse; not a literal one, but a curse in how white folk would treat him, and that he would never free himself from that if he tried to play their game their way. 

His mother had eased him through that lesson. Now, he knew she was the one member of his blood family who’d deserved to enter the Pearly Gates. But even if he could bear the thought of a puerile, stiflingly saccharine afterlife… he did want to spare Mama the grief of knowing what he’d become after he buried her. 

“You don’t feel remorse?”

“I do not. I embraced my fate, and reclaimed my future.”

Charlie didn’t say anything for a few minutes. “Vaggi felt remorse. For what she did while she was an Exorcist. She tried to do better when she was with me, and she succeeded. She redeemed herself.” And she looked back up at Alastor, eyes huge and watery. “If we’re going to be together for the rest of eternity… I want you to be better. Someone I can be proud of. Someone I can lo—” She caught herself, looking looked startled at what she must have been about to say. She gulped down air, fighting back the sobs.

“Perhaps it is better to be opposites,” Alastor mused. He’d ignore that cut-off statement of hers. “To balance each other out, or meet in the middle. After all, it’s what you and Vaggi did. She was unlike you in so many ways. Especially temperament, and look how well you two got along.” He raised a claw and gestured at her finger, where she still wore the promise ring appropriated from her mother’s jewellery collection. “But she didn’t challenge you to do better, to refine your beliefs. Think about it. Were she here in my place, would you be any better off? I daresay she would also have killed that imp for his assassination attempt.”

”She would have cared about what I thought, about what I was going through!” Charlie insisted. “She would have listened if I asked her to show mercy to that—Blitzo—Blitz—him! I would have felt better with her, because she wouldn’t prank me like you have! I would have been able to look after the sinners you killed, with her by my side—“

“Or would you two have dragged each other down into despair from the ending of your shared dream? Maybe even made a suicide pact? Vaggi put all her self worth into your redemption scheme; how do you know she might not have cracked worse than you now that Heaven is closed off to us for good?” Alastor shrugged as he let his words sink in. “We shall never know, for I am here instead of her, and maybe the grass on the other side is not as green as you think it might be. I’ll repeat myself: Redemption is no longer possible, and you won’t see your friends or your lover again.”

He leaned closer. “I want to hear you admit it, Charlie.”

She swallowed, nodded tearfully, and, like she had long ago, on that stage, with Vox ready to put his dirty hands on her shoulders, repeated what he’d asked her too. “It’s not p-possible anymore…” she whimpered. And there was a sense of finality in how she said it.

Satisfied, Alastor stood up. “Let go of it, Charlie. Adapt to this reality; don’t cling to the old. It doesn’t do you any good to dwell on what has been.” And he left the room, leaving her still in bed, still idly stroking the motionless furry body in her lap.

He didn’t tell her that Keekee had stopped breathing and her heart had stopped beating minutes ago.

She would figure that out soon enough.

Chapter 7: Just a burning memory

Summary:

What happens when a reality-warping demon princess starts having hallucinations?

Alastor gets jealoustor, that’s what.

Notes:

Originally meant to be a single chapter, this one’s getting split into two parts.

Chapter Text

After Keekee’s death, after Charlie came to terms with the reality that her dream was well and truly lost, time went on. The days, the weeks, and even the months all blurred together as Alastor and the princess settled back into monotonous routine.

He’d passed the time like this well enough in his life, camping out in the bayou. And he’d bided his time during the Exterminations… or when he was forced to wait out those long seven years at ‘Rosie’s’ behest, letting opportunity slip past and time erode his reputation. If he’d survived that, he could survive this new era of Hell too.

So Alastor marked the days by counting his way through his record collection, and, when he’d exhausted his whole little library of hits and tunes from his era, he decided to experiment, and listen to something a little newer. The cabaret and ballads of Angel Dust’s heyday as an adult performer, the rock and roll of dear Niffty’s fancy; even, begrudgingly, the show-tunes from that brief near-companionship back when Vincent Vox was still somewhat-agreeable company.

It was the rhythm and blues of the era of Husker’s passing that he lingered the longest in listening to. Motown caught his ear, and Marvin Gaye in particular. Sometimes his choice in lyrics could be too overtly sexual for Alastor’s liking, but oh, he had a good voice and impeccable production values, and that Alastor could respect.

(‘Distant Lovers’ made him unsettled, though. It made him unwittingly recall an overheard conversation; an almost-proposal from the night before the apocalypse, and the last woman in his existence yearning, nurturing a foolish hope for an impossible reunion, all because of a lie he told. 

He only listened to that song once, and only halfway through at that.) 

 

Alastor still charged himself with the essential Hotel upkeep, like cooking meals, but he no longer restocked the pantry with bodies. He gave up on hunting down the last stragglers squatting in the Hotel’s many abandoned rooms. The notion of it unsettled him now, somehow.

…It was because he’d fulfilled his purpose for doing that little experimentation, and there was nothing entertaining or noteworthy about that manner of underhanded, lowbrow killing. That was his reason, and nothing more.

Nothing more.

On occasion, when the boredom got to him, he toyed with the idea of travelling to the other circles in Pride. The radio stations in Imp City spoke of him with fear and respect now. He had well and truly re-earned his old reputation, and that councilwoman Charlie had met with clearly did her additional part keeping her peoples’ minds away from acts of vengeance against the Hotel.

(There was still an itch in the back of Alastor’s mind asking whether he could take on a Goetia.)

…

No. That wouldn’t be very sporting of him. 

 

Or maybe he could travel further afield, and see if the old magic barring sinners from the lower rings had decayed, and set foot there? 

…

Perhaps not. Not unless he brought Charlie – and she still showed little willingness in going out.

Maybe he had to concede that what he had was enough.

(It wasn’t. He knew in his heart and soul that it wasn’t. He had always desired to gain more than the lot he was given in death, as in life. He had been meant for more. But the risks of seeking more outweighed the meagre chances of gaining meagre scraps in this ruined afterlife.)

So Alastor settled, stayed put at the Hotel, hung up his makeshift holy blade, and sampled bits of the future he had so long resisted.

And Charlie?

Well… she seemed to have lost her spark again. Her acceptance of reality had also pushed her back into a deep depression, and cracked open the rift between them again for a while. 

To her credit, she got up, she got dressed, and she would spend her days out of her room instead of rotting in bed. Maybe that was her fortitude… or more likely Keekee’s death in her lap had given her an aversion to staying in the place where it had happened. The bags under and lines around her eyes spoke of a lack of quality sleep in general. 

She made as much food as Alastor trusted her to in the kitchen (which, after what had happened to the stoves, was little more than pouring cereal and milk in a bowl). She lingered in the Hotel library, and she lingered in the hallway where the curtain-covered portraits of her lost friends were. She spoke if spoken to, but she didn’t initiate conversations, and she didn’t seek Al out of her own accord.

Charlie functioned, but she was so visibly sad. That charming, indomitable spirit of hers was missing. 

Alastor pitied that. He pitied her. 

So he kept her engaged, tried to keep her from falling into isolation again. It just wouldn’t do for her to hole back up in her room. If she wasn’t going to talk to him, he would talk to her. 

He chatted with her about music as he put on the radio, asking for her opinion about the newfangled tunes he was listening to, or explaining at length the differences between swing and electro-swing. He would get out one of Husker’s last left-behind pack of cards, or a board game like Cluedo or Sternhalm, and prompted her to play with him, and she would. 

He spent more time in her presence. And he waited for her to lean into his side, or rub shoulders with him again. 

But despite his efforts, she didn’t. 

 

She talked to the portraits more and more, though.

 


 

Then, one day, she started talking to thin air.

 

Alastor caught Charlie standing, stock still, in the middle of the lobby, hand reaching out for something he could not see, and murmuring sweet nothings he couldn’t make out. 

“Who are you talking to, dear?” he asked.

She startled, as if she hadn’t even heard him enter the room – though this lack of situational awareness was increasingly common as of late. “I—whuh—Al!” she stammered, whipping around to face him, furtively. “I was just talking with…” Turning back around to point out the empty space she’d just been addressing, she trailed off.

“With…?” Alastor prompted, after a pause.

Charlie was acting very much like she’d lost something. She searched frantically, head scanning the room ever-faster; then, she seethed, and angry tears boiled over. 

“You made her go away!” she accused, before she stormed her way past him with her arms folded. 

“Made who go away?” he inquired after her retreating form. “You know that doesn’t answer my question, dear!” But he was a smart man, and he’d already put two and two together.

So Charlie Morningstar was finally losing her grip on sanity, it seemed. Alastor wondered whether it would be amusing to watch her fall to madness. It had been so long, after all, since he’d been drawn to her, compelled by the notion of her freeing herself from her own moral shackles. Maybe the long lonely wait for entertainment would be worth the fruit it bore.

 


 

A few weeks later, Alastor saw it for the first time. 

He was sitting in the lobby with Charlie, reading, when Vaggi appeared in the corner of the room. 

He wasn’t proud to admit it, but he did startle at the sight. His reading glasses fell off, and, just to be sure he was seeing right, he gave them a rigorous cleaning before putting them back on. 

And Vaggi was still there by the time he did; transparent, with a faint halo glow that wrapped around her whole body (which explained the lack of a shadow). Other than that, she was just as she had been, in her crimson blouse and dark lavender skirt, with her hair up in a ponytail and that big cross hovering over where her fringe hid her eyepatch. 

She wasn’t real.

The ghost float-walked over to the couch Charlie was on and ruffled her hair. “Hey, hon,” it said affectionately, in a voice muted like it came from underwater or was being run through a high-pass EQ filter without any of the microphone’s warmth and grain. 

“Vaggiiiii,” Charlie crooned needily, leaning into the hallucination’s ‘touch’. The ghost of Vaggi bent down to kiss Charlie on the forehead, too, and Charlie leaned up into that, but Alastor didn’t think she was able to feel it. Indeed it seemed that the hallucinated kiss didn’t sate her want for contact; the princess still had something of an air of anxiety about her.

Any other time, Alastor would have tutted or scoffed loud enough to hear, and returned to his book. But not this time. He found himself unable to look away, and he wasn’t happy about it

“You got the lesson plans for next week figured out yet?” ‘Vaggi’ asked, sitting on the arm of Charlie’s armchair. “Heads up, though, I might not be able to help in those if that Prince Stolas guy wants me to visit a week early for,” it covered the away side of its mouth with her hand and stage-whispered, “reasons.”

“Reasons.” Charlie giggled, dumbly.

“Well, yeah! Getting a commission for a princess’s wedding ring and bouquets and prophecies is a big deal, who would’ve known?” The hallucination paused thoughtfully. “I think your dad threw in that last part. Funny how everyone’s stressing about the ceremony except us.”

Charlie’s fingers went to the ring on her finger; she hadn’t stopped wearing it since Roo brought about the end times. It had lost its shine, and Alastor could swear it was starting to rust in its butterfly-pattern engravings. “We’re getting married?”

“Yeah! You did ask me!” The hallucination laughed, Charlie laughed along with it, and something in that was a little hysterical. “Don’t tell me it’s only just sinking in, hon. I know you wanted to do a big theatrical fancy proposal, but, really, the way you asked me was so sweet. And I‘m so glad that wasn’t the end for us, that everything worked out alright.”

It hadn’t. But Charlie seemed to be slipping into believing that it had. The puzzled scrunch of her snout was beginning to fade… and somehow that made Alastor’s lip curl. 

His lip curled more, and his eyes narrowed, when the hallucination kissed Charlie again, this time on the lips, long and slow. 

Finally, it ended the kiss and got up. “Well, I’ve got to do something about tomorrow’s dinner plans,” it said lackadaisically. “If Angel – I mean, Anthony – and his spider family are coming, I guess it’ll have to be authentic Italian – so Hawaiian pizza’s off the menu, I’m afraid. We’ve got guests who know not to break spaghetti to cook it, right?”

The ghost walked away towards the kitchen, and it disappeared.

“Vaggi—?!” Charlie stood up in alarm, as if to try and follow the hallucination-projection wherever it may have gone. 

“She’s not real, Charlie,” Alastor told her, getting up too. He patted her on the shoulder, prompting her to sit back down. Somehow he couldn’t put any more than a gentle emphasis into his voice. “She wasn’t real.”

Charlie sighed, still rubbing the ring where it sat on her finger. “I know,” she replied, bitterly. “I know.”

 


 

But Alastor was increasingly unconvinced of that.

Charlie’s hallucinations appeared to his eye more and more often, and the conversations she held with this ghostly false Vaggi grew longer and longer. One time Alastor timed it, Charlie spoke with her delusion for two hours in the doorway near the kitchen, and when she was done she was so weak he had to help her back upstairs to bed. In the middle of the afternoon to boot.

That proved his hypothesis the hallucinations came from her and her reality-warping powers.

Soon the hallucinations were happening daily. And soon they expanded from just Vaggi to the rest of their former companions: Pentious. Angel Dust. Niffty. Husk.

(The first time he saw those two, Niffty’s visages as she as before she became an angel, he needed a stiff drink and a cigarette to nurse for the rest of the night, sitting in his studio with the lights down and a melancholy old favourite tune playing.)

Then the other Hotel guests: Baxter, Mimzy, Crymini, Rooster, and more. Indistinct flashes of the many faces that had passed through the doors over the brief year or so of operation. How had Charlie kept track of all their names and faces with her whimsical, hyperactive mind?

Then Razzle and Dazzle. Charlie would cuddle them in midair, and then get confused when she saw the tattered old stuffed toy that the real Razzle had become, lying whereever she’d left it, because she carried it around with her for comfort now Keekee was gone.

(Alastor overheard her crying in her room more than once, accompanied by ghostly distressed bleats.)

Then Keekee, and even Fat Nuggets.

Curiously, Lucifer was one of the last projections to show up – not that Alastor was that particularly interested in his appearances.

And Lilith was always faceless.

 


At first, Charlie’s hallucinations were only present in her immediate vicinity; Alastor would only see them when he was in the same room as her. If he was in another room he might hear her talking to them, and all he had to deal with was the discomforting feelings of anger and envy.

But as time went on, the range at which she projected her hallucinations increased, and sure enough they started to show up when she wasn’t in the room.

He saw it coming. He tried not to be surprised when it happened.

Yet Alastor still felt something faintly resembling a gutpunch the evening he found Husk behind the bar, scowling as he half-heartedly cleaned glasses, as he had for so long.

He halted on the threshold of the room, glancing subtly around for Charlie, even though he knew he’d left her upstairs tidying up Angel’s old room, sorting mementos that had to be kept and those that could be sacrificed for bartering, or firewood – though Al knew full well Charlie could very well be on her way to restoring the room to its former pink and fluffy glory.

Then, maybe against his better judgement, he sat down at the bar.

“Husker, old friend,” he said. “It’s been a while.”

The ghost didn’t greet him back, or even flick an irritated ear. Because of course it didn’t. Alastor had already figured out that the projections only responded to Charlie, that they were a function of her memory. He could walk right through them and they wouldn’t react.

Sometimes they didn’t even react to him walking through them when Charlie was watching. Sometimes Charlie didn’t even react to him walking through them – as if he was the ghost and they the real being.

Alastor shook those thoughts off. “How is Heaven?” he asked rhetorically. “I don’t suppose they took the arrival of a half-redeemed, three-sheets-to-the-wind, soul-owning former overlord well, did they?”

Mildly he recalled the circumstances of Husk’s unconventional admission to Heaven; a last-minute reprieve that had only been able to take place once Alastor had released his soul from the contract he’d won over a game of cards. And even then, Husk had stayed behind almost to the last minute helping usher evacuating sinners through, to the point that Alastor had cracked at least one ill-received joke about Husk getting kicked out of the holy realm 

Maybe that had been cruel. But he was a demon, cruelty was kind of his thing.

“I…presume you’re well up there. Almost certainly better than this decrepit old realm. Though I will say, since I know you’re not really here, it hasn’t been all bad. I had my chains broken too.”

‘Husk’ still didn’t respond.

“Yes, yes, I’m sure you’d enjoy the irony. You’d probably consider it karma that I no longer have my powers.” No amount of time spent around Charlie Morningstar could convince Alastor that any other demon worth his, her, or their salt would’ve lorded ownership over him and his soul. Husker had been willing enough to talk back to him and prod at his “vulnerabilities”. 

“But no use for moping, I must look on the bright side! I have my old locks back!” As the ghostly projection turned around, Alastor preened on reflex, brushing a hand through his hair. It had taken him a while to reacquaint himself with a good curly hair care routine, but he’d gotten the hang of it. No more ‘fuck ass bob’ for him, no sir.

Husk’s ghost did nothing more than look away.

“I’m trying to picture you as a Winner. Would you have gotten a change in colour scheme, like our angel Angel did? Lighter fur? Longer fur? Curls? If that’s the case, then we’d be matching.” He guffawed. “Oh – why, now I can see you being one of those squash-faced Persian show cats! How embarrassing that would be for you!” 

His laugh trailed off, and there was only silence.

Alastor sighed sourly. Stupid, stupid him. What was the point of this one-sided conversation? He wasn’t friends with Husker, there would never have been a time he would’ve bared his heart like this to Husk. He was the smarter and stronger of the pair, more assured of and accepting of his sinfulness and able to take ownership of it. He was the superior one in their partnership, and that had been the way it had to be.

And yet it had still made him downcast that Husk left. Husk’s companionship was enjoyable. He missed teasing the cat; the amusement of it, and the sparring words, and the way Husk complained on the days when he was all bark and no bite.

He missed him

As he sat there stewing, Angel Dust’s ghost took a seat beside him, and suddenly Husk’s projection came to life. Husk smiled, wide and warm, and accepted the spider’s greeting kiss to the cheek. 

“I have a question for you, Husker” Alastor started up his end of the conversation again, regardless of the illusionary interruption. He reached over the bar, grabbed a dusty glass and a corked bottle of whiskey, and poured himself a drink. “I distinctly recall you said ‘you’d lost the ability to love years ago.’”

He glanced to his side, in time to see Husk and Angel were nuzzling their snouts together. It made his lip curl, but almost on autopilot, he pressed on. “How ever could you tell you were getting it back?”

He thought Husk’s ear twitched at the question.

Then footsteps came tapping across the lounge floor to the bar, and Alastor cut himself off from asking any more, focusing instead on his drink. 

“Oh! Hi, Angel!” Charlie chirped. 

“Hey, toots!” ghost!Angel called back cheerfully. 

“I got some stuff from your room you might want if you’re going back to Heaven!” And then Alastor was subjected to the sounds of Charlie showing items from a heavy box to her hallucination, then crying when the hallucination couldn’t hold any physical object handed to it, and apologising profusely.

He pretended he wasn’t there, sipping at his glass all the while. 

 


 

One-sided monologues with an unresponsive spectre were a guilty pleasure Alastor could easily temper. But Charlie? Oh, no, she was getting dependant on hers.

When she wasn’t hallucinating, when she couldn’t see any of her friends, her emotional state became anxious, bordering on unhinged. She’d stim with her hair nervously, bouncing her leg, and look around fretfully, seeking, and she wouldn’t stop until one of those ghostly figures appeared. On the rare days when she had no hallucinations, her mental state would get worse and worse. She would not eat, she would get hysterical and the cold turkey-ness of her condition would not improve until her powers arbitrarily conjured up a familiar face.

She was addicted to her own madness.

And it was always the sight of the phantom Vaggi who eased her self-destructive cravings the most.

Clearly, she missed Vaggi so much.

It was remarkably tragic, even he had to admit it. With how hard Charlie still mourned and pined, it was almost enough to make Alastor believe in the concept of soulmates.

And that infuriated him.

It irked him, that someone else – someone who was gone – could still give Charlie something that he apparently couldn’t. It made him feel… quietly, seethingly enraged.

He, Alastor realised, was jealous of a ghost.

He wanted to be the one Charlie relied on. Always had.

Still did. 

And it wasn’t amusing to watch her be stolen from him… by herself.

Chapter 8: Gradations of arms length

Summary:

Alastor tries to reel Charlie back in.

Notes:

TW // Graphic violence, gore, and character death.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

So Alastor did his best to distract Charlie, detract from her hallucinations, and win back her attention.

But that inevitably involved joining in on the conversations she held, because he’d have to acknowledge her delusions to get in her good graces. He should be more active in her existence again, even if that meant playing along. That was surely the proper and polite thing to do.

(The thought that his mama would have pinched his ear and given him quite the scolding for ignoring a belle in need popped up in his mind, and he shoved it back down.)

He tried to steer her out of conversations in the way he used to, stealing her attention with an old-timey joke. And he did this more and more often. Hell, he even resorted to allowing her in the kitchen to help him with meals – supervised and guided, of course.

And yet the hallucinations wormed their way back in and stole her focus from him. She would wander from the scullery to converse with ‘Emily’, or try to pet ‘Keekee’ and then cry when her hand passed through the cat’s semitransparent image.

Talking wasn’t enough. Seeing him wasn’t enough.

Alastor realised Charlie needed his touch to ground her. 

Touching her had been commonplace to him once. He’d twirled her, danced with her, manoeuvred her where he needed her to be – and that had often been away from Vaggi’s helicopter girlfriend influence, or Lucifer’s clumsy love-bombing attempts as he reconnected with his daughter. But as Charlie attempted to forge her own path and grew beyond his control and influence, they’d drifted apart. His near-death at the hands of Adam had given him a repulsion to the ‘weakness’ of attachment, and it had taken time (and a face-heel turn, then a heel-face turn) for him to open himself up to being fond of others again.

After the apocalypse, though… having to give up his hold on Husker and Niffty, and the loss of his powers, appeared to have made him relapse.

He’d found Charlie’s clinginess bothersome at first. He’d wanted to resist it. 

Now, somehow, she was one of the few things he had left, and her touch and attention would be welcome, and he couldn’t get her absence off his mind.

He should be cultivating her. Not that there was nearly as much of her spirit left to cultivate, or a world to bring her to life in.

But as long as he had a basis for initiating physical contact with her (which he did), he could do it.

Now, Alastor would take her hand in his, and fold her fingers closed, if she tried to make an offering to her ghosts. He would rub a finger across her knuckles, and feel how unnaturally smooth her skin was, no fissures or pores or patterns to be found. He would twirl her into his side, or twirl her to make her look him in the eyes. 

Somehow, he took extra care with his physical contact now. Not because she was fragile and faint, and certainly not because he was afraid of her (why should he be?). He just had to get her attention the right way to get what he wanted this time…

He didn’t often make time for self-reflection, for why should he doubt himself and the means through which he’d survived? But he couldn’t help remember how he’d been so eager to help the Hotel only when it seemed like an easy investment for his entertainment.

But no, Charlie had been… was… someone he had to earn.

 


 

And yet his efforts didn’t stop the slide. Charlie’s madness still consumed her… to the point that she was starting to forget herself.

A while later, the last handful of sinners still squatting in the Hotel’s degrading rooms unanimously decided to move to fresher pastures in the rooms on the upper floors.

The rooms that had used to belong to Charlie’s closest friends, her ‘found family.’

The rooms that Charlie had taken upon herself to restore to their former glory, bit by bit over the passing months, to levels of obsessive detail that would have made Niffty proud. She hadn’t taken Alastor’s advice to let go of the past, and she clearly hadn’t thrown anything out of the clutter like he’d suggested to occupy her – that was what she brought the boxes downstairs for, then, on the night he decided to indulge in one-sided conversation with ‘Husk’.

Instead, she’d done up Angel’s room exactly how it was months… no, years ago, with its pink bed, heart-shaped couch, heart-shaped throw rugs and mess of cosmetics atop an overstuffed dresser. The recreation of Cherri Bomb’s around the corner was a bit rougher, more clumsily done, and the graffiti on the wall was definitely not in Cherri’s art style (or nearly as explicit in language).

What had once been Pentious’s memorial room, and then had been converted back into a regular room once the news of his redemption was undeniable, got returned to its former purpose, with the statues and paintings the long-hatched-and-redeemed egg boi Frank had made.

Of course, Charlie had proudly showed him her work, pulled him upstairs, even, and he’d had to play along and be interested, because she was showing interest in him again. He patted her on the head as he complimented the job she’d done, and she beamed.

He didn’t tell her that her eyes looked bloodshot, and were twitching.

When she wasn’t paying attention to him, Alastor fumed to himself, and drank whiskey and smoked in private. This could not end well.

The actually extant Sinners presently inhabiting the Hotel, while they evidently appreciated Charlie’s efforts to make the room nice, had no respect for keeping the rooms in that pristine museum-like state. The next time he peered through the door of Angel’s room, the sheets were dirtied, the bed was messy, and there was a suspicious stain on one of the pinup posters of the former porn star.

And no occupant in the room, at least for the moment.

He scowled, and shut the door, and on second thought locked it (both to keep said occupant out and to keep Charlie from finding out). It might be best to keep her sanity from degrading further, he thought.

Unfortunately he neglected to check the condition of the other rooms.

 


 

Alastor was doing his rounds one morning when a sinner, bruised, bleeding, and terrified, came scrambling down the corridor, panting and whimpering. 

A demon silhouette, black with swirls of red and glowing eyes and long arms with claws that scraped through the wallpaper, levitated down the corridor behind him. 

The sinner looked back and shrieked in terror.

“YOU DARE DIRTY AND RUIN MY DEAR FRIEND’S ROOM LIKE THAT?!” Charlie’s voice, distorted and legion, roared. She reached from impossibly far back and snatched the sinner, reeling him in. Alastor stepped smoothly into the recess of a doorway to avoid getting hit or ran into. “THE FIRST REDEEMED SINNER? THE ONE WHO DIED FOR US?! GET THE FUCK OUT OF MY HOTEL AND DON’T COME BACK!!”

“Okay! Okay!” the hapless victim quailed. “I won’t! I promise I fucking won’t! I’m going!” And his legs were a blur before Charlie even put him back down on the ground, he hit the ground running and sprinted away. Ironically there weren’t even any elevators down the hallway in that direction, but it seemed like the poor thing might’ve been considering a dive out a window. 

Charlie growled, tail lashing. “Fuck him. Fuck him!”

Alastor stepped out of the alcove. “Charlie, dear, this is all very out of character for you—”

She snarled. She didn’t even look at him; “Nobody disrespects my family like that! NOBODY!!” And with that, Charlie resumed the chase. Flames trailed behind her, and Alastor had to quickly brush a smouldering ember off of his shoulder lest it burn his jacket.  

He blinked after her, eyes following the trail of blood staining the carpet that would never be cleaned by Niffty again. That didn’t stop the ghostly image of her racing along with a phantom bucket and sponge, attempting to scrub each and every red drop and puddle with glee. 

He didn’t pay it mind. He had thoughts. 

And feelings.

Wasn’t this was what he’d once wanted? For Charlie to lose herself, to let her darkness in and her demon side out. To violate her morals – she had wilfully injured someone who lived under her roof for sullying a selfish memorial – no, when he checked the scene of the crime afterwards, it was nothing more than shifting furniture.

She had been broken at last, and had started to tap into her true potential. Her sin. Her rage.

Why didn’t he find it entertaining?

Why?

Perhaps it had something to do with the fact that she had still ignored him…

He didn’t want her like this.

 

He missed the way she’d been.

 


 

Once more, Alastor redoubled his efforts to reclaim her.

He played the songs Charlie seemed to like the most or gravitate to over the gramophones and speakers in the Hotel. Judy Garland. Barbra Streisand. Even songs sung by that warbly frog puppet who had been the delight of the living world – the most popular of which was all about rainbows.

He made pancakes Lucifer-style again, much as it felt distasteful to drown the stack and accompanying apple slices in syrup and powdered sugar. He followed her around the Hotel, keeping an eye on her, keeping an eye out for the squatters who now quailed from her in fear, even as she ignored their presence.

In letting her lead, he found she’d made a clumsy grave for Keekee out in the courtyard.

So Alastor went back up to Husk’s restored room. He rummaged around in the drawers, and found a token with a cat on it and a fallen-out pin feather deep in the chest of drawers. And on the way downstairs, he found a key jammed in a freshly vacated room, still bearing Keekee’s eye in the middle of its bow.

He brought the mementos to lay on the tombstone, and he waited solemnly there until Charlie made what seemed like her daily visit. She got teary-eyed, of course.

Then she stood shoulder-to-shoulder with him, and leaned into his side.

His smile couldn’t help but widen.

They stood there together for the better part of an hour.

 

But still… frustratingly, every time he thought he was tugging Charlie back towards him, her hallucinations, her madness, her desperation, her attachment she just couldn’t let go of, pulled her away again.

He was no longer powerful enough to teleport through the shadows and travel upstairs and downstairs near-instantaneously. He couldn’t keep up with her anymore. He couldn’t always be there. And he had to eat and maintain his less-powerful body too.

So it happened again and again that Charlie would become lost in her hallucinations.

And it happened again and again that she would run into one of the last sinner residents staying where they shouldn’t be, and chase them out of the Hotel before holing up for days on end trying to clean up the mess they’d made in her mourning museum of empty rooms – which got even worse now they were holing up in there more and more often to hide from her.

Bit by bit, she was wittling down their numbers. They were starting to leave even without her involvement; Alastor watched individuals pack their bags and slip out in the dead of night – with a bit more haste if they noticed the glint of his eyes from where he sat on watch in the lobby.

He overheard those remaining talk about ghosts in low whispers, through the walls. They speculated that the Hotel was haunted. One mention of a distasteful series of stag flicks from the living world by a woman called Bethany, whose voice apparently bore a resemblance to Charlie’s?

The thought of Charlie following the same profession as Angel Dust had made Alastor acutely angry.

Some argued that this new Hell was miserable enough without phantoms of the past all around them. Alastor understood their point keenly, what with how he was trying to pull Charlie out of the past. A few others, the more slothful of the squatters, thought that the benefits of free shelter were worth the “haunted house vibes” the Hotel was now giving.

Would that last?

Something had to give. Alastor could feel it in his bones. His frustration was approaching breaking point.

 


 

It was not him who broke first. Nor the squatters.

It was Charlie.

One morning, one of the freeloading sinners came downstairs to steal from the kitchen one morning while Charlie was languidly grazing on her cereal at the dining table. She didn’t mind the theft. She didn’t acknowledge his presence.

And Alastor felt it unproductive to punish or even call out a sinner for it while Charlie was right there. She ignored his attention-drawing attempts in the past.

But then her hallucination-projections popped up again. ‘Baxter’, brewing some concoction up over the abandoned, non-functioning stove. ‘Cherri Bomb’, chatting up ‘Pentious’ in the corner. And ‘Vaggi’, right behind the sinner still rummaging through the refrigerator, holding a clipboard, frowning and shaking her head.

The sinner found what he was looking for, straightened up and turned around – and he jumped, and he shrieked, launching the carton of leftover jambalaya across the kitchen.

What an arm he had! He must have played baseball, or cricket, or some other bat-and-ball sport, for he threw the plastic container right out the kitchen window and across the dining room – where it bullseyed a portrait of the original Hazbins, right in Vaggi’s face. The old plastic split open and cold rice, meat, and vegetables splattered all over the painting.

“FUCK ME!” yelled the sinner, and punched the fridge door shut so hard it rebounded and smacked him again, knocking him to the floor. Alastor couldn't help but stifle a chuckle.

The sinner picked himself up and looked up at 'Vaggi', who was still scowling at the fridge with a dent in its door. “Oh, fuck off, you haunted whore-bitch!” he yelled. “I didn't get any sleep cause of that crazy ghost maid running 'round the place giggling ALL NIGHT, and now you make me lose my breakfast?! FUCK! FUCK YOU, WHOEVER YOU WERE, WHEREVER YOU COME FROM YOU ANGEL BITCH!” 

Charlie’s head shot up. She dropped her spoon. She looked to her left, and saw the food soiling the painting. She looked to her right, and saw the sinner jabbing his finger in ‘Vaggi’s’ face.

She started to tremble. The spoon rattled on the dining table, rocking back and forth. 

”I should’ve known. I should have known this place would never stop being Hell,” he ranted. He threw a punch at the ghost “Fuck, fucking FUCK!” 

Then he picked up a knife and threw it at her.

It didn’t connect, of course, because there was nothing really there to connect with. And of course a ghost wouldn’t care. It just clattered against the tiles on the other wall, and ‘Vaggi’ just put her hands on her hips.

Charlie cared, though. 

So much. 

In an instant, red veins sprouted and bulged, running up and down the surface of her now-black arms. Charlie rose into the air, and she floated at speed over the table, slamming through the kitchen doors, and she passed through the ghost of Vaggi and loomed over the sinner. His eyes went wide for just a moment before, with a mighty swipe, Charlie sent him flying across the kitchen.

Alastor stood up, and followed discretely. He had to see this.

“HOW DARE YOU!!” she screamed. “HOW FUCKING DARE YOU!!”

“F-fuck,” the sinner gasped. He’d crashed headfirst into the sink, and there was a huge gash on his forehead. “Psycho cunt – get—get away from me!”

“THAT’S MY FIANCÉ!! THAT’S MY FAMILY!!” Her howls were fast becoming incoherent. “FUCK!! YOU!!”

Her hands – no, by now they were paws – lifted him and slammed him to the floor again. Her nails, now long claws, dove into the wound she’d already caused, and she ripped

and tore

and shredded.

Alastor saw bone in a record few seconds. Tendons sliced and released from their places. Gouges carved into jawbone, into sternum. Hunks of flesh dug up like clods of earth.

The sinner, gasping and spluttering as his blood entered his lungs, tried to drag himself away. 

“NO – YOU DON’T GET TO GO ANYWHERE!!” Charlie roared, her tail stabbing the sinner through the leg. “I WANT JUSTICE!! FOR VAGGI!!”

The sigils and patterns in the architecture – the railings, the wallpaper, the skylight – lit up in a menacing red. The lights started to flicker. The whole building started to shake.

Voices came from upstairs. The calamity Alastor was thoroughly invested in had drawn the last squatters – and he could count them all on a single hand – from their drug-induced recluses. He heard the shock in their voices, but he couldn’t hear their words over Charlie’s constant growling.

Her continuing swipes and slashes were tearing the sinner’s arms out of their sockets

“Please,” coughed the sinner, desperately. “Please, I’m sorry, just… don’t—”

“‘SORRY’ IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH!!” Charlie roared. “YOU HAD YOUR CHANCE.”

She’d said the unthinkable.

Years ago, she’d sung about how it ‘started with sorry’ to a snake who had tried to spy on them. Now, she wouldn’t even begin to accept it, even if the sinner was only apologising to save what was left of his skin. Now she was repeating the same rhetoric that she had opposed so vehemently. 

Because of a knife thrown at a hallucination. 

Wasn’t that selfish?

Now the air grew hot, and Alastor had to step back as a fire whirl spun into life around Charlie. Her flaming claws still tore away at the sinner, and her exhales blew fire into his face.

The sinner ignited. 

The sinner burned.

He wasn’t making any noise anymore, but he was weakly struggling and twitching, even though he was little more than a torso and barely attached legs. His skin scorched and blistered and blackened – burns rising from the first degree to the second, and then the third. 

Alastor had no idea if he’d be able to reconstitute himself afterwards. 

But Charlie, whether she thought the same thing or was acting in blind rage, made sure he wouldn’t.

With a mighty cry, Charlie summoned her pitchfork (its prongs tipped with blessed steel since before that battle against Adam), and ran the sinner through the chest.

There was a flash. A backdraft of flame and smoke raced out of the kitchen doors like a backdraft. Alastor had to shield his eyes and cover his mouth. 

When the air cleared, the sinner was a black carbonised husk of his former self.

And Charlie was still a furious demon.

She raked through his ashen corpse for good measure, and only once he’d been strewn out of the toadish-humanoid shape he’d once been did she stop. 

Then she dropped her pitchfork and stalked out of the kitchen. She wasn’t dropping her demon form, and the air still warmed the closer she got. Lesser beings would have backed away from her, or hid. 

Alastor didn’t. 

Her anger was not directed at him. She wasn’t noticing him. If she had been noticing him, instead of ‘Vaggi’… he was convinced she wouldn’t have broken like that.

He was amazed at her performance, but he hated the circumstances that brought it about. 

Charlie stopped out in the lobby. For a moment Alastor thought she had noticed the last 5 squatters, standing aghast on the mezzanine. Was she going to attack them? Had she come to her senses?

It was the loudest silence Alastor had ever heard.

But Charlie did nothing.

Then the squatters scrambled.

“Fuck this.”

“I’m out of here. No shitting way am I staying with that monster.”

“Guess you were right after all.”

“Of course I was fucking right, I’m always right.”

“Thought she was supposed to be nice.”

“She deserves to rot here by herself.”

He watched the sinners troop past. Some dragging bags, some with bindles over their shoulder, some carrying nothing except in suspiciously bulging pockets. He caught sight of paraphernalia for making and abusing substances that Charlie had once tried to keep of the Hotel, and Vaggi had threatened to kick Angel Dust out for (or charge him a pittance of rent).

Their eyes darted at him, but then darted back to where the shadowed silhouette of the Princess of Hell, with her horns out, her eyes glowing and her For the first time, they were more afraid of Charlie than him. They seemed to use his body as a shield from her line of sight. 

Charlie didn’t seem to even see them.

One final sinner flipped the bird at them as they sidled out the door – and then ran for it. The door slammed shut behind them, and the noise echoed in the empty lobby.

Charlie did nothing but growl back at the noise, in such an animalistic way.

For the first time since Angel Dust’s arrival, the Hotel was empty, save for two occupants.

 


 

Charlie left the charcoalised remains where they were on the kitchen floor. Alastor disposed of it in a dumpster about a block away.

When he returned, his eyes fell upon the hotel guest book, pages still open, gathering dust on a sideboard. 

They hadn’t had use for it in years. And they wouldn’t, ever again.

Alastor took it in his hands, removed the pen from the hinge, and closed it for the last time. Then he put it in the back of the drawer, and locked the doors.

The Hazbin Hotel was closed for good now.

 


 

It took most of the day for Charlie to come down from her demon form rage.

Alastor tracked her as she roamed the building, snorting, growling, ranting to herself. She went up to the master suite, babbling to ‘Vaggi’, asking if she was alright, telling her that she’d get justice for her. 

Then she seemed to be chasing ‘Niffty’ around, begging for her skills with a needle to stitch up ‘Vaggi’s’ knife wound, or to clean the jambalaya staining that portrait. But ‘Niffty’ didn’t seem to hear her, and Charlie got more and more frustrated, and her shouts and growls resumed. She relapsed on pushing away – the same thing she’d apparently done with her father and Vaggi when they interfered with her manic attempts while he was biding his time ‘imprisoned’ by Vox. 

Finally, she made it back downstairs to the lobby, panting. Her tail lashed, Her shoulders were still tensed. Her horns were still out.

Alastor, still tailing her, watched from the top of the stairs as the hallucinations of the other Hazbins melted back into existence, one by one.

With the way Charlie had reacted, he thought the hallucination of Vaggi might not have showed up, not after Charlie thought she saw her stabbed. 

But finally, she did. 

And Charlie noticed right away. 

“Vaggi,” she whimpered joyfully, melting back from her demon form to her usual self. “You survived!” 

‘Vaggi’s’ mouth moved. Alastor couldn’t hear anything come out of it – was this for Charlie’s ears only? – but Charlie – oh, he saw her face crumple. 

“W-what?”

Alastor crept down the stairs, straining his ears. The hallucinations hadn’t fallen silent, but their voices were muted as if coming from underwater, or like how Charlie had described panic attacks to the group therapy classes back when the Hotel was running. 

Charlie glanced past Vaggi’s ghost, through the dining room and into the kitchen, and paled. The bloody aftermath of her killing the sinner, the pitchfork – Alastor hadn’t cleaned those up. Those were still there. 

The hallucinations grouped together, speaking as one. Their gazes turned to harsh glares – even ‘Pentious’s’, and ‘Niffty’s’. The most friendly of the Hotel bunch, and they were now acting like they hated her. They were judging her.

Like a dial had been turned somewhere, their voices tuned back in.

“You aren’t the Charlie we knew.”

“You are ssscertainly not”

“You abandoned all the morals you said you stood for.”

“You failed your mother. What would she think of this?”

This must be Charlie externalising her internal monologue. Were she cognisant of this it would have been an interesting psychological reflection, but Charlie was not in the right mind. She looked around like a cornered animal, shaking her head. “No, no, I didn’t—I don’t— I did that for a reason cause he was attacking you Vaggi! He killed you! He threw a knife, a-and it went through your throat—”

“What knife?” ‘Vaggi’ asked bluntly. “What sinner? I wasn’t there, Charlie. You killed that guest by yourself.”

“No, no no please, no, guys I didn’t mean to, I—I—I was trying to avenge–protect—I was trying! No, please, I’m sorry! I’m sorry!” She shrunk in on herself. Her fingernails dug into her skin. And the more she cowered the closer her jury of hallucinations got.

She was on a precipice. 

Alastor realised he couldn’t stand the idea of her losing herself like this: through this regression. It was self destructive, and worst of all she couldn’t help herself. 

He couldn’t stand the thought of losing her to insanity, or to suicide, or to corruption. 

She was one of the last things he had.

He had to step in. 

And so he rushed over to her. He stepped through the hallucination-projections, getting in front of Charlie, to block her view of them. He took her hand, and he brought it to his mouth, and, gently… he kissed it. 

Her skin tasted… almost waxen; it seemed a fitting match to her porcelain appearance. But there was a bitter note, something that gave the impression of the ivory keys of an old piano that hadn’t been properly cleaned in a while.  

And underneath it all, he could feel the demonic, sinful energy in her body, coursing through her veins, like static electricity. Anger, starved greed and gluttony and envy. He hadn’t even taken a bite out of her, and yet this was more invigorating than the lingering aftertaste of angelic energy in each mouthful of a permakilled sinner’s carcass.

It was a gentle kiss, a brief kiss, and he thought he’d meant it to be pragmatic and platonic… but he felt alive from it.

Alastor finished the kiss, He lifted his head. “You should really look after yourself better, mon cher.”

Charlie stammered. She was blushing. Then she shook herself out of it, and she tried to protest, to look over his shoulder to where her hallucinations must’ve still been. She still wasn’t focused enough on him. “I need to—”

“No, no,” he shook his head. “Run yourself a bath, dear. I can lend you soap if you’ve run out, or perhaps some bath salts?”

“But— but I fucked—I fucked up so bad. I was so angry—” 

He understood the red fog of rage well. “It’s perfectly alright, Charlie.”

“No, it’s—I—I don’t—I—I… they hate me!” He didn’t know if she was talking about the ghosts, or the former squatters… but finally, finally, she looked at him. Finally he had her undivided, watery-eyed attention. “Alastor… please don’t hate me.”

“My dear, I never could. This is what I always wanted to see you do.” 

She broke. She cried into his chest.

“Good girl,” he told her, patting the top of her head gently. “Good girl.”

He glanced over his shoulder, and saw the projections of the others were still there, glaring disapprovingly. At her, or at him? He couldn’t tell.

They didn’t vanish when Charlie’s focus wasn’t on them. That was off-putting.

He leered at them.

Then he ignored them.

 


 

So in the end, Charlie gravitated back to him. As she should.

As he wanted her to.

She sought Alastor out to play board games, now. She invited him to the room where the Hotel's piano was, wanting to play songs and learn new ones. She wanted to know what he was reading, and she tried to understand the circuit diagrams he was poring over when he needed to repair the Hotel radios. 

She didn’t go back to the museum of rooms of their former compatriots.

She brought him a bunch of Furbys, buried in a box of toys from one of the former therapy rooms, and he made an organ out of them, and that made her laugh for the first time in… how long? A long, long time. She seemed to surprise herself with the sound of it.

It reminded him how endearing she could be.

 

As a final test, Alastor left Charlie alone downstairs, to see if she’d come find him in his radio tower.

And she did. She sought him out minutes later, anxious and fidgeting.

“Al,” she whimpered, and without asking, wrapped her arms around him and, with no room to sit next to him, sat on his lap.

And he didn’t dislike it.

He thought he saw her hallucinations of Vaggi, Lucifer, and faceless Lilith at the door to his studio out of the corner of his eye, but he didn’t care. Charlie was ignoring them, and that was what’s important.

So he let her fall asleep in his lap, and stroked her hair as he considered the melody of Heartaches by Al Bowlly.

He wasn’t addicted to or dependant on her, no, not in the slightest. He was in control. But he did crave this, he acknowledged. And he was indulging that craving. He didn’t see what was so wrong with that.

He craved the power he had over the others, even if they were just a memory. He knew how strong Charlie loved, how much she mourned. To win her affections from them proved he was strong.

He may have lost his physical powers, but he was still powerful where it had always counted: his smarts, his willpower. More powerful than Charlie’s hallucinations. Powerful enough to ground her from her demon form.

Powerful enough for Charlie to want him.

It was nice to be wanted.

It was nice to be wanted back.

Of his own violation, Alastor gently took Charlie’s hand, raised it to his mouth, and kissed it again. 

Notes:

(shoutout to anyone who noticed the Everywhere At The End Of Time references in the last two chapters)

Chapter 9: “Once a month, on the full moon…”

Summary:

Charlie requests something of Alastor he does not expect.

Notes:

CW // Non-explicit setup to dubcon (character giving consent despite being uncomfortable), mentions to menstruation and some sexual themes in this chapter.

Please mind the tags.


For the purposes of this fic, Alastor is written as a sex-averse acearo character – as opposed to sex-repulsed. That is, he’s just not a fan of engaging in it unless he sees a reason to.

Alastor is also a prideful character, and I believe Viv has said he’s masochistic. He hates showing weakness or vulnerability and masks heavily. Therein lies the nature of the dubcon tag. He won’t say no if he thinks he can tolerate something, or that there’s a worse alternative, or that he stands to gain something. ‘It’s A Deal!’, and his putting up with Vox’s BS, is a prime example of this.

Alastor’s whole thing with relationships and his willingness to partake seems inherently woven with whether he stands to gain anything, but more importantly (and especially if he doesn’t) whether he has the upper hand in the power dynamic. Challenging that is something I’m very invested in for personal reasons. So far in this fic, Alastor has been the one with the upper hand between him and Charlie; more in control, while she’s grieving and having a sanity slippage. But flipping that power dynamic between him and Charlie so far has been what the fic is building up to.

The title of this chapter is a hint to how that comes about.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

More time passed. Months. Maybe even another year, or a year-and-a-half – who could really tell anymore?

Then, something began to change between them.

 

One day, Charlie began to act as if she were sick.

It seemed that she had a fever – but Alastor had never known her to get a cold or a flu before. She was flushed, and yet she shivered. She itched and fiddled at her clothes, taking off her jacket then putting it back on again. She was all tensed up – he could hear her grinding her teeth.

Then she became oddly distant.

She wasn’t shunning him, no, not like the other two times. So it wasn’t out of anger or offence. He hadn’t done anything to prank or upset her this time. It seemed it was out of some sort of anxiety on her part – she was suddenly shy in his presence.

Which was strange, when they’d known each other for years now, when they’d been each other’s only company for years. Weren’t they familiars? Something more than companions? Something rarer than friends?

She would utter little meeps when she saw him, especially if he approached her or appeared right next to her. She stuttered and stumbled when he spoke to her, tripping over her words, and then she power-walked away in a hurry. It was truly quite fascinating, and he found that with a few strategic smiles or a bit of teasing he could have quite the fun with this.

Out of the corner of her eye, Alastor would catch her lingering afterwards to view him from afar, thinking she was cleverly hiding herself around a corner. He would turn around and meet her gaze with a smile, and she would startle and vanish around the corner. 

He got some good chuckles out of that.

Affectionate ones, of course.

 

But Charlie’s affliction worsened over the next few days.

She started panting and breathing through her mouth. Her eyes would flash red and her horns would peek through her hair before she tried to shove them back down with her fingers. She was restless. She would shiver. She was feverish.

And she would give the telltale signs that she was in pain but trying to hide it. He applauded her for trying to mask it like that, but Charlie never had been successful at dressing her upset up with a smile. Never had been, never would be.

She acutely reminded him of the deer he used to hunt. Of the men he used to hunt, as they regressed to their base instincts of survival. She was getting more-and-more animalistic. 

 

And then Charlie shut herself in her room.

How thoughtful of her, he thought – but he was a sinner. A mere cold wouldn’t affect him, at least not badly. It definitely wouldn’t kill him, if the most meagre of sinners could’ve reconstituted themselves after he ripped them to shreds, back in the day.

It must have done her good enough, though – for, a few days later, she finished her seclusion, and it seemed she had returned to her normal self.

Albeit with a lot of blushing and embarrassment and apologies.

“It’s nothing to be embarrassed about, my dear,” Alastor reassured her with a pat on the shoulder. “We all go through such times of ill health!” He’d had a ghastly case of the yellow fever in 1905 that had nearly worried his mother to death too. And of course he knew about a woman’s time of the month, from the sinners who overshared complaining about it over Vox’s airwaves and podcasts, to that one unruly new gal in “Rosie’s” colony who had propositioned him with the outrageous offer for him to drink her period blood.

(He was a serial killer with a simple preference for raw meat, thank you very much, not a pervert.)

“Yeah,” Charlie chuckled nervously, her eyes darting about evasively. “I guess so….”

 

Alastor did notice that her awkwardness lingered for a few days longer before she went back to her melancholy, clingy self. He suspected it was just that she’d never had one of these episodes in recent memory, not during her time as the Hazbin Hotel’s founder and therapist. Or that she used to have someone else she could confide in: Vaggi, or Lilith, while she suppressed her woes to try and appear as if she could fix everyone else’s.

It was curious, though, why it took this long for such an episode to happen.

 


 

Then, the next month, it happened again.

And again, the month after.

 

Each time was stronger than the last. He saw more flashes of her demon form. Each time she struggled to contain her pain, her true self. It took her longer, and it took her more effort to snap out of it.

Each time, he saw more beads of sweat on her forehead. More of her forearms and her chest as her jacket came off sooner (and stayed off) and her shirt became unbuttoned.

Each time, he found himself having to force himself to look away.

She didn’t put herself in seclusion any sooner, though. She lingered in his presence just as much as the first time. She watched him more, and when he looked back at her, she seemed less shy and more… longing.

Hungry, even.

It left him with the vague impression of a hunter. An impression of the way he’d stalked down his prey – the game of cat and mouse, reeling them in, thinking he had what they wanted.

That...that left Alastor starting to feel a little disconcerted.

 

Charlie still shut herself up in her room, though, each time. Eventually.

And when, out of curiosity, Alastor decided to pass by her door… he heard noises. Sexual noises. Like Angel Dust’s moans when he and Husk were rutting, but more genuine than the act of a prostitute so well practised that the act crept into his authenticity. 

Yet it sounded more like suffering than satisfaction. 

Angel had foisted his proudest stag flicks on the Hotel’s first show-and-tell therapy sessions, whether the residents liked it or not, but Alastor well knew what the cries of pleasure, and what cries of pain sounded like, well before he had made his first kill. Such was the joy of living in certain parts of New Orleans. He’d passed through Storyville enough times.

He knew what it sounded like when someone was trying to hide and hold back their noises of pain, and this was exactly that.

Charlie was in pain.

This wasn’t entertaining.

Something was going on with her. This couldn’t be just a passing fever, or a normal condition. Alastor knew that menstruation was a painful experience, thanks to Mimzy’s oversharing and ‘Rosie’s’ more educational gossip – but he didn’t think it ought to be so agonisingly bad that it should make a lady cry in pain like she was giving birth. 

Or become so... libidinous.

What had got Charlie acting like…like a buck in rut?

Or a doe in heat?

 

 

(He should have known that was exactly what it was.)

 


 

Three months later, Alastor got his confirmation. 

Charlie came to him on what he’d figured to be the first day of the fourth repetition of her strange cycle. She was already flushed, red-eyed, and had parted ways with her jacket as if it were a summers day – when in fact the days in Hell had steadily grown milder, if anything. Sweat beaded on her brow, wetting down her drooping fringe. 

(That blush of hers was quite peculiar. How could a being of such porcelain complexion glow so rosily?)

But her eyes were clear, and she seemed to be her usual self: anxious to please, hesitant to self-advocate, yet wanting something oh so badly, deep down.

“Alastor…” she started, her voice a fragile veneer of trying to be businesslike over a great deal of nervousness. “I have, uh, I have a request to ask, and an explanation to give. First. The explanation.” She shuffled where she stood, and cleared her throat. It reminded Alastor of how she’d start all those inspiring speeches she used to make – the ones for which he used to lend his microphone to her. “You… probably noticed I’ve been acting a little… different lately.”

“Mmmm, I hadn’t noticed,” Alastor retorted, gently sarcastic.

Charlie giggled a little hysterically, as if he were the funniest being in the universe… which right now, he supposed, he might well be. “Okay, good. Good. Yep. Cool beans.” She blushed harder, and turned away from him to whisper to herself. “C’mon Charlie, you can do this you can do this you can do this—”

“Take your time, dear.”

Naturally, hyperactive as she was, Charlie only took a few more harried seconds to psyche herself up. With one more deep breath, she turned back around to face him. “Okay, so, when my mother—” She paused, and swallowed, clearly wrangling with that painful truth. “When Roo created me, she did it so that it would seem like I was my mom’s biological child. And you probably know my mother and father created the Hellborn… with the help of my aunts and uncles, of course… so I also have traits from the different Hellborn demons.”

She took another steadying breath. “One of them being… succubi.”

Alastor had been eyeing Charlie for a long while, ever since he saw her on Vox’s picture show, but now he looked her up and down again. Yes, he could see bits and bobs of the myriad of Hellborn races in her – her hooves reminiscent of the most humanoid Baphomets, her tail reminiscent of those of imps, her eyes (when she went into her demon form) the same red-with-yellow as Hellhounds. But he didn’t know if he could see any much of the succubus or incubus in her. Though, to be fair, they were as diverse in form as mortal humans had been, so Charlie’s slender figure might have easily fitted into the ‘cubi population as it might have with humankind or imps, were her skin a shade of magenta pink or red.

“And that is relevant …how?”

“Succubi have heat cycles.” Charlie seemed to want to hide behind her messy hair. “And so do I.”

Alastor tensed up unbiddenly. “Ah.” It all fell into place. He hadn’t been wrong to make that comparison of her strange behaviour to rut, months ago, and now hindsight made it all so obvious. The way she’d been tailing him, watching him afar, seemingly bidding him to pursue her despite her shyness… it was exactly how does courted bucks during the rut.

He should’ve recognised that, hunter that he once had been. Had being around cloddish men, and women who didn’t beat around the bush as much as Charlie did (women like Mimzy) dulled his faculties?

“Yeah, soooo… I’m having those right now.” Charlie twiddled her index fingertips together awkwardly. “It’s…kinda like the equivalent of a period for me? They last a week and they… actually get more painful the longer they go.”

“My condolences,” Alastor said, not really meaning it. He was mulling over the timing again. Roughly a year and a half had passed since the apocalypse, and yet: “Strange how this… issue… should only crop up now.”

“It’s been, well, unpredictable… for most of my life,” Charlie offered up as an explanation. “Auntie Bel actually gave me medication to take to suppress them, when I was in my teens, and again, after my mother left and… all that. Then, I ran out, forgot to get a refill… and then, I had Vaggi. She used to keep this at bay.”

“Yes, we could all tell.” Neither Charlie nor Vaggi had been the most subtle about their love life once Vaggi started gaining confidence in herself. Sometimes it had kept multiple Hotel residents awake. And now Alastor could put together the pattern of which nights they’d been loudest too.

As Charlie's cheeks turned redder, he tried to keep his face as blank a mask as possible, but he was intelligent. He could put two and two together about why Charlie was coming to him; what she wanted from him. She certainly wasn’t going out anymore, so she wouldn’t be seeking sexual favours from the remaining sinner prostitutes or the significantly larger dating pool of Hellborn still out there. The fact she was coming to him – someone else would probably put it down to a saccharine and foolish notion like trust, but experience had taught him that ‘trust’ was more often than not a vulnerability that would inevitably be taken advantage of.

Wasn’t Charlie’s most recent ex before Vaggi an upper-crust demon from the Envy Ring? Had Seviathan von Eldritch and his family survived the apocalypse? Surely she could’ve gone crawling back to him instead to exploit him for this seedy cause.

Still, Alastor’s suspicions were not completely confirmed. “Out with it, Charlie,” he demanded. “I doubt you’re only here to overshare fun facts about your biology with no reason.”

Charlie blushed harder, somehow, and stammered uselessly for a good few seconds.

“We’ve got nothing but time, dear.” Alastor’s sarcasm bit a bit sharper now, courtesy of his apprehension. “Nowhere else to be.”

“Right! Right.” The princess half-composed herself once more. “So—okay. Sex is what stops my heat cycles from getting this painful, it makes them finish… faster.” She swallowed, and it mirrored the way Alastor felt his stomach drop in that same moment. “And I know you said you see me like a daughter, so this is probably going to be really weird and I’m so, so sorry in advance…”

Somehow he didn’t feel like correcting her there, right now. 

“…and I wouldn’t be asking you if… if it didn’t hurt so much…” Charlie closed her eyes, wincing and trembling. “I’ve been trying to get through it by myself, but it’s getting harder. It’s getting worse. And I don’t want you to feel obligated or forced to…but, only if you’re okay with it, would you consider… or be okay with, maybe, sleeping with me—I mean… having sex, just for one night?” 

And there it was.

Just like Vincent’s proposition, the better part of a century ago. Charlie may be much more passive and not nearly as egotistical as Vox had been, but still. She wanted something out of him. To use him for her own purposes, at his detriment. 

The penny had dropped.

That’s what she always wanted. Even if she was passive, even if she was kind, she used others. She’d set out to redeem her friends to avoid confronting her rocky relationship with her parents, to avoid confronting her inner demon, to avoid fulfilling her destiny.

She was just as self-serving as the humans she failed to understand.

And he was more vulnerable, now, in the physical sense, without his overlord powers. He would not be in control of such a situation.

Alastor looked back at her, half-lidded eyes hiding his inner turmoil, and said: “No.”

Charlie’s face fell.

Alastor stood up from his armchair. “No,” he said again. “It just wouldn’t be right, Charlie.” Wouldn’t be right of her to be in a position where she could overwrite his autonomy, sap him of his control over his situation. He was not meant to serve or be used, and he’d already been used far too much in this afterlife because of sloppy mistakes.

Charlie’s eyes had gone misty. She hunched over and hugged herself. “You’re right,” she mumbled distantly, the corners of her mouth crooking up into a broken, wobbly smile. “You’re right. It would be wrong. I—I’d be cheating on Vaggi.”

That wasn’t how Alastor had meant it. He did not expect the surge of jealousy that rose up in the pit of his stomach.

“‘Cause I know, in my heart, that she’s still alive, that she’s still up there in Heaven.” Tears were streaming down Charlie’s cheeks now, though she wasn’t fully sobbing. “It would be so wrong of me, I’d be a hor—a horrible—” She cut herself off as her voice began to hitch, rubbed her eyes, and started slowly, awkwardly, making her way out of the room. “Thank you, Alastor, for reminding me. I—I’m sorry for bothering you, I respect your boundaries and I’ll—I’ll keep respecting them, I’ll cope on my own and—I’m so sorry, again. I really am. I’m sorry…” 

She shuffled her way out of the parlour, and left Alastor there alone. He let out a long, slow breath.

He should’ve felt relieved, like he had when he’d left Vincent behind in that bar. He was in control. He had kept control of the situation and kept the outcome in his favour; the ball in his court.

But he couldn’t help but feel like he’d lost an opportunity to keep Charlie close.

 

That night, he was drawn to the corridor outside her room again, and the sounds of her crying as if giving birth. Pain and anger and frustration, guttural demon noises leaking into her cries.

And her cries went on and on through the night.

Charlie really was in immense pain, wasn’t she?

Alastor couldn’t feel sympathetic. A small part of him, the part that derived satisfaction from knowing his chosen victims had equally been monsters, or had wronged him, felt vindictive. She had thought she could violate him? Let her suffer for it.

Another part of him that sounded an awful lot like Mama, chastised him for that thought. She had brought him up to be a gentleman, taught him better. It wasn’t right to leave a lady in strife unassisted.

But what about him being propositioned out of the blue? What about his feelings on the matter?

He had turned Charlie down politely enough, he had treated her with such lenience compared to how he had to shut down Vincent. Surely that should assuage his strange feeling of… not guilt, but pity?

…

It didn’t.

…

He lingered there.

The demonic noises made him curious. Was this her power coming out because of self-loathing? Or because of some sexual fantasy? 

Suddenly, though he had long abandoned the thought of using her as a battery, or the notion of controlling her potential and development (time had proven that foolhearty, she was too potent), the curiosity of finding out her limits reawakened. How was her demonic power still functioning, now the universe was wounded, maimed, and stunted? 

Was there still latent potential within her?

…

Was this a way to revive it?

“No, stop that,” he muttered to himself, and he forced himself to walk away, back to his room. That was too dangerous a line of thought to pursue. Dangerous for him.

 


 

Charlie’s seclusion now lasted the whole week of her heat.

And in the aftermath, once she re-emerged, she gravitated to her hallucinations again. The phantom Vaggi had come back in full force, and once again Charlie was besotted with it, apologising to it for her lapse and even slipping into detailing her masturbatory thoughts that she’d tried to depend on in her futile attempts to reach climax by herself. As if it would appease or prove her loyalty to this unresponsive ghost.

(Within earshot of Alastor, to boot. It probably wasn’t intentional, but still. Alastor didn’t want to hear it. It made him uncomfortable.

It made him jealous.)

When Charlie wasn’t being all ‘TMI’, as Velvette would’ve put it, Alastor attempted to rekindle the companionship they’d settled into, by giving her the real, platonic touch that had become second nature to him. It made him feel just a little uneasy; cautious of her next moves.

She would jump if she surprised him, and she was more skittish than before around him, but she soon enough relaxed into it, seemingly glad that her faux pas hadn’t ruined their relationship. 

And she didn’t come onto him again, which was good.

But Alastor was struck with the feeling that it wouldn’t be enough for her. 

 


 

And it wasn’t.

 

Two months, and two cycles, had passed, and Alastor couldn’t take it anymore. Charlie was slipping away from him again, slipping back into her dependency on that cursed hallucination of Vaggi.

And each time her heat had started up, she was shutting herself in her room earlier, practically at the moment of onset. It could have been out of guilt, or some overcompensating attempt to “respect his boundaries” as if that would earn back his complete trust and vulnerability with her.

Or it could have been her madness. Alastor knew that she was masturbating her way through each of those weeks to the thought of her lost-girlfriend; maybe even to that apparation of her.

And he couldn’t take not being the one she relied on. And a quarter of each month without her presence was grating.

He felt like she was losing her.

Alastor still wanted her. Wanted to be the only one with influence over her, the one she counted on. Her absense compelled him. She was the one thing of fascination and intrigue and, dare he say it, some sort of attraction in this barren afterworld. Without her, he felt purposeless.

Oh, how that clashed with his discomfort at the notion of sex, the idea that by engaging in it, Charlie would get everything she needed, but he got nothing in return.

Nothing?

Yes. Nothing. Pleasure of that variety meant little to him, and if he needed it, it was something he could idly get by himself. He didn’t understand the foolish notions with which the common man elevated sex, though he had understood how to exploit it to reel in his next victim.

But he had to have Charlie. He had to.

She wasn’t like Vincent, a part of his mind provided. He had waffled around his true intentions with the false promise of partnership, and not even an equal one like that. He talked like you were a resource and he the mastermind. Charlie was honest and forthcoming with what she wants and why.

She’s vulnerable too, you know.

“Stop that,” he growled out loud to his shadow.

His shadow, being inert and ordinary now, did not respond, and the thoughts persisted.

He could not banish the compulsion. The curiosity. The tug towards Charlie.

She was attractive, he supposed. He’d always thought her charming in appearance. Her slim figure would have been in vogue in the roaring twenties.

Despite his feelings about the act, he had had sex before. He was not a virgin. Most recently he had, infact, slept with Mimzy out of mutual curiosity. An experiment, and not one that was repeated, but because they agreed there was nothing more they could get out of repeating it.

(She was a good companion. He had, deep down, appreciated her candor.)

Most of his body count, though, was from his time alive. A means to an end to his schemes and dreams – another step up the ladder of success, or a trap to draw in a few unsavory victims if they seemed interested in him in that way.

Charlie would hardly be the most objectionable lay he’d had.

…

And there, still gnawing at his mind, was that curiosity about her demon form. Her power.

If Charlie’s urges were sated… maybe it could be safe to observe how her powers came out when she tapped into deeper sins. If she was coherent, and held true to the morals she purveyed?

If it was a way of keeping her close, and learning something new about her…

…

Was it worth the risk? The discomfort?

…

Fuck it.

He would risk it.

 


 

The day he calculated that Charlie’s heat would begin again, the day she (sure enough) disappeared into her room, Alastor went to his room, and had himself a fortifying glass of whiskey.

And then he went upstairs after her.

He scuffed his feet as he approached her room, using the sound of it to block out anything he might overhear from within. And he knocked extra loudly to boot, before stepping back to wait.

In response, he heard sounds of minor chaos from within. Fumbling noises, objects being tossed or dropped or upset.

“I’m coming!” Charlie’s voice called out. “Shit. Ow. I’m coming!”

There were a few more muffled thumps and bangs. And then the door opened, and there she stood in the threshold.

“Alastor!” she said, breathlessly. “Hi!”

Charlie looked a mess. Her hair was unkempt and pasted down with sweat. She was wearing a hastily-thrown on oversized button-up shirt with some of the buttons done up wrong, and – Alastor couldn’t tell if she was wearing anything underneath it, and he decided he wasn’t going to ask. He looked instead over her shoulder, and then decided he shouldn’t, because her room was a complete mess. Bed unmade, clothes strewn everywhere… impliments of the like Valentino had been fond of scattered about, and what looked like photo albums and framed pictures of Vaggi. Evidence of her… activities.

It would have enthralled and vexed Niffty in equal measure, he thought.

“I’ve considered your… request, from a while back,” Alastor said plainly.

“O—oh?” Charlie suddenly looked very hopeful.

“Yes. You’re still in pain, are you?”

“Yes.”

“More or less pain than the last cycles?”

She nodded. “Uh… more, I think.”

“And, based on that, do you suppose it will continue get more agonising for the foreseeable future?”

Charlie paled. Alastor didn’t think she’d had the capacity to consider that outcome. She always lived in the present. “I… think it might.”

“Alright.” Alastor sighed, and gritted his teeth behind his smile. “I’ve decided to accept your request. I am willing to engage in intercourse with you. Once, tonight, as an experiment, to see if it eases your suffering. If it does…” Now he hissed through his teeth. Keeping the mask he thought fit to wear, the one that approximated care, was a challenge. “Then, once a month, on the first day of your heat, I consent to bed you.”

Charlie made a slightly indecent noise of relief. She looked overwhelmed.

Alastor chose his words carefully. “I assessed my priorities, and found you should be higher in them.”

Charlie’s eyes sparkled in that pleading puppy-dog way they did when she got emotional. “I—I—thank you so much Alastor, thank you!” Then they widened, as something occured to her. “But—but you said… the whole… ‘like a daughter I spawned’ thing…?”

“If you are concerned about incestuous implications… that was an exaggeration, to try and prod your father into doing his job. It was a jape. I saw you more as a protege then, and now…” he tried to put into his voice the genuinity Charlie would be receptive to, “well, I have been fond of you all along.”

She fiddled with the top button of her shirt. “W-what about Vaggi?”

“I’m sure she’d understand.” He’s not sure, really. Vaggi had been the jealous, insecure sort. But it was what Charlie needed to hear.

Charlie bit her lip, and her counterance brightened. She looked like she was about ready to jump his bones, and he started to wonder if she might drag him into her room right here and now. That wouldn’t do. He wasn’t prepared for that yet.

“I have conditions, though.”

“O-okay.” She nodded very fast. He had her full attention.

“We will keep it as the necessity that it is: clinical and detached. Only what is needed to stop this heat, and nothing more. I am not a man for passionate displays or outbursts.” He couldn’t tell her that he would feel uncomfortable. No attachments, no weaknesses.

Just whatever needed to be done. Nothing more.

“Yes. Okay.” Charlie swallowed. “I can try to do that.”

Alastor raised an eyebrow. “I should like more certainty, dear.”

“Will! I will hold to that, I promise!” Charlie shook herself off, and extended her right hand out into the air between them.

He stared, nonplussed, at it. “And that’s for…?”

Charlie looked puzzled. “I thought we… were going to shake on it?”

He was surprised she was willing to. But he supposed it made sense, now he was powerless. “Fair enough. Wipe your hand, first.” He may have been hours away from possibly touching her intimately, but he’d rather not touch any bodily fluids of hers just yet.

She did so on her shirt, and when she proffered her hand again, Alastor reached out, took it (noticing how warm it felt), and shook. There were no powers to bind and enforce this deal, none of that aura he’d once felt each time he claimed a soul or a promise or a favour… save for a tug of surety binding him to carry his promise out, in a voice in his head that sounded like Mama.

“I will be back at eight 'o’clock tonight,” he said, letting go of her hand and checking his wristwatch. It was roughly five’o’clock. That gave them both time to prepare. “Clean yourself up, dear,” He glanced over her shoulder and his lip curled. Sex toys and mementos of the person who’d left Charlie half-widowed would not be conductive for the task he’d agreed to do. “And your room as well.”

“Yes! Of course!” Charlie chirped. “I’ll, uh, I’ll see you later, I guess!”

Alastor nodded curtly, turning away before Charlie could say or do any more. Behind him, He heard her slip back inside her room and close her door.

Heading back to his room, he began to mentally prepare himself for the task to come.

 

Notes:

In response to two individuals’ weird speculation that I am making Charlie “a slut”, that could not be further from the truth.

Aside from this being the only plot mechanism I found I could write actual Charlie-Alastor smut via, I prefer to treat the heat cycles trope as analogous to menstruation rather than just horny times. Charlie is in pain from this. She is suffering. It's angsty and whumpy. I’m concerned if you need that literally spelled out in an authors’ note.

Chapter 10: "...followed by a night of..."

Summary:

Alastor and Charlie do the deed for the first time.

Notes:

CW // Explicit sex, dubcon (Character partakes in sex while not comfortable with it), smoking mention.

Reminder that for the purposes of this fic, Alastor is a sex-averse aroace. Alastor's attitude towards and experience of sex and pleasure here draws from my personal experience and perspective on libido and having a dick.

Please heed the tags.

Chapter Text

Two hours later, washed and freshened up, mentally steeled, and with another glass of stiff whiskey in his system, Alastor returned to Charlie’s room in a velvety red bathrobe.

She’d left the door open for him.

He halted before the threshold, narrowing his eyes. He knew better than to walk unprepared into what could be a trap without getting a grasp of things first.

Her room looked tidier, her bed seemed to have been remade (or made to appear like it had been remade, in a messy way, the way Niffty might’ve grumbled at and wondered out loud how a hotel full of women couldn’t make a bed), and the side lamps had been dimmed to create what he supposed was a sort of ‘romantic’ ambiance.

He snorted. She would. A part of him wouldn’t have been surprised if she’d scattered rose petals on the bed (even though he wouldn’t have wanted that), but the potted roses in her room were long dead from a lack of watering.

Importantly, though, the scrapbook pictures of Vaggi had been put away. That was something approximating heartening.

He still couldn’t see her, though. So the idea of just stepping inside was… exposing. Vulnerable. Like stepping into a clearing in the middle of the bayou.

Once, he’d had no qualms about transporting himself via shadows from the lobby to her room, invading her space to test her resolve and make a deal with her. The Hotel was his purview to roam as he pleased back then… and now it wasn’t. If things didn’t turn out in his favour, he didn’t have the back door of melting into the shadows any more.

But he was not a coward, nor one to not honour a deal. He cleared his throat to announce himself.

“Come in!” Charlie chirped, but she still didn’t show herself. Alastor scoffed to himself. He wasn’t going to just walk in until he knew where she was and what she was doing. He’d learned that lesson well.

So he leaned through the threshold, one hand on the door frame.

And there she was, by the dresser with the circus tent topping and string lights, standing with her hands clasped in front of her. She was still wearing just that crimson button-up, but the buttons were done up properly now. And she must have washed; her hair was shiny and sleek with just that little frizzy quality that came from using a hairdryer.

She reminded him, now, more of the woman he saw on the television, all that time ago. There was that spark of eagerness and purpose in her eyes.

(And that purpose was him.)

He shoved that thought down.

Charlie was beaming at the sight of him; like the way she used to smile so much. “Hi, Alastor!” It seemed that she was barely holding herself back from throwing herself at him. She fidgeted her hands together, and flushed brighter as he paced into her room. “Hi. Um. Hi. Yeah. Hi.”

“You do look better already, dear,” he remarked, ignoring her stammering. She did seem more in control. Was it just the act of consent that made her rebound? Wouldn’t it be preferable for both of them if that was all it took to break the spell?

“Hahaha… thank—thanks. Thanks.” Charlie tittered, as if he was flirting with her. She almost started to flirt back – eyes lidded and sultry, flashing red; eyelashes fluttering. “You look nice, too.” Then she caught herself, and snapped back. “Wait – is that too much to say? I’m so sorry if that’s too forward of me, making you uncomfortable or anything–”

That proved beyond doubt that her heat was very much still there. Well, at least she still had her tenuous sense of trying to respect boundaries.

Alastor could’ve played along with Charlie’s attempts at small talk. But he wanted to get this over and done with.

“Forward is preferable.” He nodded and stepped forward. “Shall we sit?”

Charlie froze up, eyes wide and cheeks scarlet red. “On… the bed?” she said, almost excitedly. Her tail made its first appearance of the night, and lashed – no, it wagged.

“Yes, on the bed.”

“Okay!” She did so in a rush, sitting down hastily; awkwardly crossing her legs after a moment’s thought. In contrast, Alastor took his time pacing over and seating himself two arms lengths away from her.

He was mindful of the proximity to Charlie. She clearly wanted to be close to him; while she was successfully holding back from shuffling closer, she was leaning forward just so, almost into his personal space. He could sense her anxiousness to get started on their task tonight.

He realised he was relishing the chance to stall. But he was not a coward. He would persist.

“You remember my stipulations from my earlier visit?” he asked.

Charlie scrunched up her nose in thought. Alastor thought that her heat might be making it hard to remember – and he swore he heard Angel’s voice in his head, cackling at that innuendo. Or was it Valentino’s? “That we’re not going to do much, that we’re keeping it… professional…and that it’s just to stop the heat.”

“More or less. And keeping our emotions in check. Remember what I tried to tell you about a smile, all those years ago?” He was still smiling. He hadn’t let it falter around Charlie since the end of their world, and he wouldn’t now. Even if he was about to strip down and do something so incredibly revealing, he still had that to wear.

Charlie mustered up a small smile of her own. “You’re never fully dressed without one?”

“Quite right, dear.” Alastor nodded, and adjusted his robe. “So, kissing and moaning to a minimum, please, if you can help it. Now that I have conveyed my limits… what is it you need?”

“I—uh—sex? I thought we…already…talked about having sex?” She looked confused.

“I mean specifically. What do you need of me.” No answer seemed forthcoming. Charlie was flustered, and her mind seemed fogged up by her libido, and she was dawdling. Alastor did not have the patience for this. “What exactly do you want of me?”

Charlie flinched at the sharp, terse tone of his voice. “I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I’m trying to—please don’t go…”

“I’m not going, dear.”

“Okay,” she said, self-soothing. “Okay.”

“I only need clarification on what… sex acts you expect me to perform.”

“Oh! Oh, well…” Charlie shrugged. “Anything, really.”

Alastor sighed, leaning his forehead against his pinched fingers. He resigned himself that he was going to have to ask exact questions. Explicit questions. “Are there specific sex acts that end your heat?”

“N—no, just—”

He didn’t allow her to elaborate. He plowed on through. “Does it require penetration?”

She pursed her lips in thought for a moment. “Not necessarily. Well… sometimes Vaggi would wear the strap—”

“I don’t need to hear that.” The less he had to think about Charlie’s ghosts, the better.

“—but—but oral worked too!”

“Dear, I wouldn’t trust myself with that if I were you.”

“Right, right…” Charlie nodded along. “You’re a cannibal, and all that. Don’t want you biting into my… um… down there.”

That wasn’t the real reason, but as long as it dissuaded Charlie from asking him to eat her out he would let her believe it. “Anything involving hands?” That ought to be the least personal and most detached way to do it.

“Actually, that’s the least effective…” Because of course it was. Damn it. “Too close with what I’ve been trying to do to get through the last few heats.” She squirmed awkwardly where she sat. “I need to…” she mumbled the last part.

“Speak up, dear.”

“I need to cum!” she blurted out. She had flushed even more, but not only from embarrassment; it seemed even mentioning climax had aroused her more. She was sweating again. “To… orgasm. At least once. That’s what finishes it. Most things that get me there will. But it does get… harder to get there when I’m in heat compared to when I’m not.”

Alastor nodded, considering this information, weighing the options in his head. Which style of intercourse would be quickest, most bearable for him? Vaginal penetration seemed the simplest answer. As rudimentary a position as it was, it also allowed him to be on top, to control the pace. To be in control of the situation. And it was the most impersonal too. It was so typically male, which he normally would be disgruntled by, but he needed that degree of detachment, and physical separation. At least that way he could focus on being attentive to her need.

“Wait!” Charlie exclaimed, breaking him out of his thoughts.

“Yes?”

“Do you need—or want—to, uh… cum as well?”

He had to hold himself from resorting to his usual defensive measure of laughter. That discomforted him. That made this whole thing feel like a cage. Too taking from him – she had to want that for her sake. “Is it necessary for you that I reach climax?”

She shook her head. It surprised him that she had an answer ready and waiting, after all the umming and aahing . “I don’t think so. I mean, Vaggi couldn’t cum with the strap – I mean, come like that, obviously, but I always made sure she came as well when we… y‘know. I just want to be a considerate partner in bed.”

“Mmmm, kind of you,” he said offhandedly, “but no.” Even if he trusted that she was being altruistic here and now, it would be too intimate. He really wouldn’t get enough out of it to make it worth it. But that wouldn’t the reason he’d give her. “Wouldn’t want to risk any accidental conception, now, would we?”

Charlie didn’t laugh. She looked a mix of surprised and a little disappointed. Maybe she had a breeding kink and had been hoping he would ejaculate inside her. Or maybe it was that he’d decided the method of intercourse for both of them. “Wh—huh?”

“Penetration,” Alastor explained. “seems to me like the most straightforward way to get you what you want tonight. What with the way you keep bringing up ‘the strap’.”

“Okay. Then—uh—” She stammered, and made to reach for one of the drawers in the bedside table. “I don’t know if I have any condoms left...”

“I’m a sinner, dear, I believe my sterility by virtue of being a sinner hasn’t changed.” “Now. Are there any other… considerations I should know about?”

“Like…what?”

“Your demon form, dear.”

“Oh! Oh, I mean – yeah, I can control it. Be gentle in it, I mean. My tail doessss tend to get a lil frisky though….I hope that’s not a problem.”

Alastor thought of tearing out Vox’s cables and wires as they writhed and squirmed and fought back against him. “It shan’t be.”

She nodded. “Cool! Cool beans.”

“And what of your hallucinations? Will we have any… unannounced visitors?”

“I don’t think so. It’s been better with you around.” Alastor may have lost some of his conviction in that ever since Charlie started gravitating back towards Vaggi after her first few heat cycles. But for now, he couldn’t see the hallucination of Vaggi. Or Lucifer. Or any of the others.

Come to think of it, he hadn’t seen them all evening. Not since his visit to Charlie’s door earlier.

Alastor and Charlie were truly alone now. Nothing left to do but to get on with the act he’d agreed to do.

He sighed. “So, we’re both ready?”

“Yep, yep, yepperoni!” She must have picked that verbal quirk up from… Adam’s son, he recalled. She grinned, all wonky. “Ready when you are?”

“I already said I was, dear.” There was an awkward pause as Charlie processed her latest verbal slip-up, and Alastor had to prompt her out of it. “We should get started.”

“Okay!” Charlie clapped her hands. “Which one of us should go first?” Then she blinked and slapped her hand to her forehead. “Oh! Right. Ladies first, I guess.” And she grabbed the bottom of her shirt, and without unbuttoning it, whipped it off over her head.

She struggled, for a second, to get it all the way over her head, giving him an eyeful as she did. It turned out she did have underwear on, under that shirt, and she bent over double to work them off before straightening up again.

Alastor hadn’t wanted to undress first, but he wasn’t going to be a typical man and demand that she do so. So he was almost relieved she’d taken the initiative.

But Charlie was in the nude before him now, He tried to assess her like he imagined the average lustful brute of a man would, if he were capable of that kind of lust. Like Valentino’s objectifying eye. Like the way Vox must have seen him.

Charlie’s chest had been deceptively bound by her top, and without it she was a good two-thirds as well-endowed as her mother was, proportionately. She had a slender figure closer to that of her father’s, with not a lot of meat on her bones, though he supposed she never did. Maybe she’d lost a bit of weight as a result of her monthly seclusions. Her skin was marble white all over, but flushed with patches of red, and there were scratches – claw marks – leading towards her crotch. Behind an unkempt mess of blond pubic hair, her vulva was engorged, inflamed, lips already open and weeping.

She sat back down on the bed, looking expectantly at him in a way that suggested the anticipation was causing her pain.

It was his turn to strip, Alastor supposed, and he resigned himself to it.

He didn’t want to fuss with any sort of striptease. Nothing that would’ve titillated Angel Dust, or given him the satisfaction. No, Alastor wanted to draw it out as little and efficiently as possible. So he’d only left his room in his robe and not much else. He simply undid the tie around his waist, and shrugged the robe off – leaving his glasses on.

Which let him see Charlie’s reaction.

And she was transfixed.

She stood up. She looked him up and down, and blushed even harder. “Wow,” she said in a heady, breathy voice. “Alastor…”

She must find him attractive, then. His throat tightened. He belied calmness by raising an eyebrow.

Charlie shook herself out of her trance, clearly trying to respect their deal and contain herself, but her chest still rose and fell rapidly with the intense pace of her breathing. “I, uh, always thought you were—” She cut herself off, she looked like she wanted to say a lot of things along that line. “The glasses suit you,” she settled on – maybe it was the most platonic compliment she could give in this context. Alastor was capable of filling in the gaps.

She came closer, reaching out. Alastor kept himself stock still.

And she touched his chest, gently, tracing the scar that ran across it. For a few seconds she looked more melancholy than wanting, possibly blaming herself for the injury Adam inflicted on him. Alastor didn’t know if he blamed the Hotel or his softness for that any more, but it was so long ago as to be irrelevant.

This was very personal for him. He didn’t trust her show of sympathy. Kindness was too vulnerable. Her touch may have been soft and hesitant, almost submissive… unlike Vox’s, but still to be touched where he had almost been killed was practically a violation for him now.

Thankfully, Charlie lifted her hand from his chest then. She slunk around him, looking him over, peering around his side to look at his rear. Under her gaze, he felt like prey again. Or maybe a prime cut of meat.

“Vox was lying. You do have a tail,” she said, very breathy. She reached out and bapped at it with a hand. “It’s cute.”

Her hand was dangerously close to his buttocks, so Alastor took her by the wrist and redirected her hand. The touch of his hand made her gasp.

“Limit that,” he requested primly, “unless you really must. I prefer not to be demeaned.”

“Oh—okay,” Charlie flustered. “Sorry. Sorry.”

Before she could shrink in on herself and spiral again, Alastor took her hand and pressed a quick kiss to the back of her wrist.

“Are kisses okay? she asked, needily.

“I’ll do the kissing, if you don’t mind,” he replied primly.

Now he decided it was the appropriate time for him to do the touching. He reached out, experimentally, and cupped her left breast, over her heart. He thought of the demonic blood and energy coursing through her veins. The power she had.

the taste in his mouth so similar to Vincent’s static shocks coursing through him

It made his body tense up in the right way it needed to to perform.

And the touch clearly did something for Charlie too. Her breath shuddered, and she whined as his thumb passed over her nipple, and something shifted in her. Her horns sprouted through her hair. Her tail was suddenly longer, thicker, with three spines on its dorsal side a quarter of the way along.

She was no longer repressing her demon form.

She leaned forward, as if expecting a kiss on the mouth. So Alastor pulled away, removing his touch from her chest. She opened her eyes, twitching as she held herself back from pursuing him. She was panting, fighting back control over her urges.

With those red eyes, she looked expectantly at him. At his crotch.

He was still flaccid.

Alastor kept his composure. He had always been a man of absolute self control and choice in what he does. And he was now.

He willed it so, and his erection rose.

Charlie stilled, and stared.

Alastor had never concerned himself with whether he was well endowed or not before. It wasn’t relevant to his day-to-day life. He refused to stoop to the lowbrow level of men who had to bolster their egos like so. And the few times he had had sex – well, the reviews had been mixed, but the size of his cock had never been among the complaints.

But now, with the way Charlie was looking at it so hungrily, he had to give it more thought. Was he well endowed, or was Charlie just so starved of a sexual partner, starved for sex, that anything was an oasis in a desert to her.

No matter.

He brought his other hand in to trace her jawline and lift her chin, and, on an impulse, he kissed her neck. Ironic that he trusted himself with this. He’d told her not to trust him with his teeth at her crotch, but this was a position that could wound her much worse if he chose to bite his jugular.

It spurred her demon form back to the fore. She took his shoulder – and that startled him for a moment, freeing her neck from his mouth – and overbalanced the both of them sideways onto the bed, pulling him on top of her.

That Alastor found preferable.

His hands braced himself against the mattress, either side of her face.

“Touch me,” she gasped through her growls. “Please.”

“Then you hold me up,” he demanded in turn, and she did so – propping up his chest, carrying his weight. He raised his hands – he wobbled, her hold on his chest wasn’t the most rock-solid – and placed them on her breasts.

This contact spurred her heat onto new heights. She writhed beneath him, growling; probably biting back a much more lascivious reaction, but flames still flickered in the air around them. If she got any relief from the touch, the first touch of that kind she’d had in years, it was short-lived.

It had been a while, too, since Alastor had last engaged with someone sexually, yet he still knew the motions that were expected. Foreplay was expected. Lubrication was expected. Preparation.

He tried to keep one hand on Charlie’s breast, but with the way with the way she was pulling him down, he needed that hand back against the bed to steady himself. So it would all be up to his one free hand to do the job.

He brought it up, and used it to brush carefully along her jawline, then down the side of her neck. Her hand sought his, trying to hold it down and keep it in contact with her, but he lifted it, and resumed the stroke from the collarbone down.

She shuddered and keened. “Aah…”

As Alastor’s hand dropped further, it came across Charlie’s cleavage again. It rose, circled her nipple again, then, without lingering too long, he dragged his hand lower, down the underside of her breast, across her flat stomach… and he slowed as he came close to her crotch. He approached it indirectly, looping his hand across the curve of her inner thigh, before he reached it.

She was already wet, as he’d seen, and now he felt it on her bush. Like dew on the grass… except the dew was warm. She was wet enough that, were she not in heat, it shouldn’t take that long to bring her to orgasm.

So he went through the motions. He used two knuckles to simulate the feel of a mouth on her lips; tongue-like, swiping up the wetness, pressing down at the top, then stroking down. He probed at her entrance, stretching it just so, just enough so that she could take his cock without undue fuss.

He tried to tune out Charlie’s moans, and the way she clutched at him, and the sheer warmth of her body where they were in contact. He focused on repeating the teasing, coaxing motions with his hand, until his fingers were soaked.

“I’m ready,” Charlie gasped underneath him, as he withdrew his hand. Her hips bucked. “I’m wet enough—I’m ready I’m ready I’m ready—”

“Calm yourself, Charlie,” he cautioned her, as he wrapped his wet hand around his cock to lube it up. “Or else I’ll stop.”

“Right, right,” she panted. “Okay.”

“Good.” Alastor realised how close he was to saying “good girl”, and the thought made him hesitate. He wasn’t going to call her that again anytime soon, at least not tonight.

He gave his cock a testing stroke, ensuring his erection was firm enough for the job. Then he repositioned himself, lining up with her entrance. He had to make more skin-to-skin contact this way, with his chest ending up against hers. Her nipples were firm, almost sharp on his skin.

“Oh, fuck,” Charlie moaned again. “I’m ready, please, I’m ready, please—”

Alastor paused again. Not to reprimand, though – he was steeling himself for the task.

He pulled himself forward, and entered her.

She was all tensed up, so it was understandable she was tight. Still, Alastor felt at once overstimulated – no pleasure, no pain, just an intense, almost prickling feeling consuming the head of his cock.

It was easy to tune it out, though, because Charlie screamed.

“Is there something wrong?” he asked, because he supposed he must.

“Oh, no,” she whispered. Her demon eyes were wide, and tears were down her cheeks. “That’s—it’s—aah! It’s been so long. It’s been so long.” And she rolled her hips up into his.

He reciprocated.

But he kept his torso lifted off of hers.

Together they started towards setting a rhythm, and he looked down at her, watching as she panted and thrust and growled. Charlie was shaky, stuttery, in her movements; like she had jumped into cold water. If she hadn’t had sex with another living being in a long while, it made sense, and she had always been a more erratic and misremembering mind compared to him.

The problem was that it made it hard for Alastor to meet her start-stop pace.

“With me,” he growled in frustration, tapping her shoulder in time as a means of conducting, forcing a synchronicity between them. Finally her hips began to move in sync with his.

…

This went on for some time.

Longer than he’d have liked.

Longer than he wanted.

Charlie’s eyes were scrunched closed in effort, and she was trying to buck faster against him, but it did not appear to bring her any closer to orgasm. Her groans and whines became less lusty and more dissatisfied.

‘This isn’t working for you, is it,’ Alastor thought.

At last, finally becoming cognisant again, Charlie held up a hand to his stomach. “Wait. Wait, Al. Stop.”

He did so.

“This isn’t working,” she confirmed his suspicions for him. “I need to be on top. So I can control the angle. That’ll make it quicker—”

Her on top.

Alastor didn’t like the idea of that. He had been hoping it wouldn’t come to him, but if it ends things quicker, he would accept it and bear this debasement. He pulled out, and rolled onto his side, relieved at the brief respite from the overstimulation. “I’d rather not be ridden like a beast of burden,” he snarked, adjusting his glasses and thinking of the logical reverse of missionary position. “Are there any positions where we would be… more equally positioned?”

To his consternation, Charlie took control. She rolled him all the way onto his back, shuffling him back, propping him up at a 45° angle against the pillows stacked at the headboard. “Uncle Ozzie said this one’s called the Lotus”, she said, which meant nothing to him until she took his legs and folded them halfway cross-legged. And then she sat in his contorted lap, lowering herself onto his cock and wrapping her legs around his waist.

This was close. This was very, very close.

With this posture, their heads were level. It looked suspiciously like Charlie might want to kiss him on the lips, but she didn’t make any moves. She just… clung to him.

He tried to hold her as far away as possible, without completely pushing her away.

Ironically, that seemed to do her good. Her hips started to roll again, with regularity, with more surety. Without him needing to do much, his cock reached deeper in side her, he could feel its head grazing the sides of her inside.

He could also feel himself losing sensation in his feet. The way she’d positioned herself had her trapping his left calf under her buttock, slowly cutting off circulation.

Charlie moaned, her eyes fluttering closed, and she began to smile as she rocked and bounced.

Whatever pleasure she was getting. Alastor didn’t share. He registered a dull, detached, sensation of what by the accounts of almost everyone else he’d met should have felt like the addictive rush he got off of murder, and catharsis, and karma. The sensation was so… neutral… that it became unpleasant; it built and ebbed like the ache of a bruise when you pressed down on it.

He clenched, and he tried to keep thinking of the unpleasantness of it, on bearing to reciprocate hip thrusts, on getting through this task.

Clearly for Charlie it was more than that though.

Each successful thrust turned her eyes a brighter shade of red, in the glimpses he got when they briefly opened. It pushed her deeper and deeper into her demon form. Her skin grew warmer.

Alastor noticed the change at once. “Careful, Charlie,” he warned, holding her by the arm. His claws bit into her skin. She barely reacted to the pain, but she sighed and panted her way down.

“Are you there?”

“I—aah—I am…”

“Good.”

“I’m…I’m…” she repeated, and he was less sure that she was in fact there.

“Charlie. Charlie.”

Her vocalisations – ceasing to be understandable words – climbed in volume and pitch, and she moved faster against him. Her hair started to fly, blown by an unknown breeze, and it lashed him in the face.

Alastor braced himself.

Then it all happened very suddenly.

Charlie’s core contracted around him, and she lit up like an ember being blown on. Her whole body turned black, shot through with red veins that extended up into her lashing hair. Her eyes glowed, pupils and irises gone, and she roared. She bucked and convulsed even more uncontrollably against him.

The air around him felt thick, and the bed beneath him did not feel steady. Alastor’s cock felt wet, and hot, like it had been doused in boiling water. The pain did something to ground him.

Despite all this, he leaned forward. He was ready to observe. Ready to get what he’d been hoping for out of this sacrifice. To see Charlie completely unrestrained, completely demon, and to maybe understand how her power still worked.

The first taste of this sort of power in years… it seemed like it was going to be worth it.

But it only lasted for a moment.

Charlie’s demon form burned out instantaneously, and then she came down practically immediately. She rocked on his erection a few more times, panting and sighing with relief, before collapsing forward onto them, sweaty and cooling. Her horns were gone before they could poke him in the eye, and he watched as her tail retracted.

When she next opened her eyes, they were back to their usual gold.

“Thank you” she gasped, with an intense gratefulness that was discomforting to him. “Thank you, thank you, thank you…”

Alastor didn’t say ‘you’re welcome.’ He didn’t relax. He concentrated on letting his erection down (noting that it still felt wet and numb) and then he picked her up and lifted her off of him, seating her back on the bed near where her pyjama shirt lay.

Charlie’s thanks trailed off as he did, and her shimmering eyes turned cloudy and distant. She looked down Alastor took her chin and lifts it, and when she meets his eyes again, her expression is guilty, furtive.

He could hazard a guess at what she was thinking; who she was thinking about.

“Are you well?” he asked, partly to distract her, partly out of obligation.

“Yep. Yeah. Just… yes. I’m…” She coughed. Her voice was scratchy. “What about you, Al? Are you okay?”

He didn’t answer right away.

“Was that… okay for you?”

He flexed his left foot, coaxing bloodflow back into it. “As long as you are sated,” he said, testing his weight on his formerly-numb foot before he stood up.

“Alastor?” Charlie asked, her voice nervous.

“You need water,” he declared, tersely, and he marched into the ensuite bathroom. There was, to his – or Charlie’s – good fortune, a glass resting beside the sink basin.

First things first, he needed to catch his breath and force it back down to its usual tempo.

…

One he’d accomplished that, he used a piece of tissue to wipe down his cock. Then he rinsed off his hand, filled the glass, and brought it back out to the bedroom.

Aside from covering her chest with her shirt (though not putting it on), Charlie hadn’t moved, and she watched his face and his gait anxiously.

Alastor handed over the glass of water. “Drink up, dear.” Then without seeing if she did, he picked up his robe from the bed and, with his back to her, busied himself throwing it over his shoulders.

“W-w-wait, wait, hold on,” she called after him. “Aren’t we—?”

He let out an annoyed huff. “Remember our deal, Charlie? Only enough to ease your heat. Is it over?”

“Yes, I…”

“Then I presume self-manipulation will be satisfying for you once again,” he said bluntly, tying the cord of his robe around his waist. “When your heat returns next month, you can fuck me again. Yes, I am willing to continue this arrangement. But for tonight… I am done.”

And he began to make for the door.

“Alastor, wait!” Charlie cried, as he reached the threshold.

He couldn’t refrain from grumbling as he turned back around. “What is it?”

“I—I didn’t mean—I know you don’t want to do any more tonight, and that’s okay, it really is! But…” she looked so pathetically hopeful, “… maybe we could just… chat, or read a book, or go downstairs and watch a movie—? W-with the projector we set up in the media room, not—not on a TV, obviously…”

He paused. He scrutinised her tone and her doe-eyed expression for a moment.

She was desperate. She was pleading. In her eyes was the same loneliness that had had her begging him to sin a little, back when she’d thought redemption had become possible again. The same loneliness that had attracted her to his side even when she was angry with him for pranking her, or for protecting her from that assassin.

Charlie wanted him, for no purpose other than his company, it seemed.

But no.

He’d discomforted himself too much tonight. Their agreement was only for the vulnerability of him fucking her, no more than that. None of this weak and foolish closeness – he thought he’d made that clear. He wouldn’t stay any longer.

“No, dear. I shan’t darken your doorway any longer than has been necessary.” He adjusted his robe, turned away, and stepped out into the hall. “Goodnight, dear.”

“Oh…” he heard Charlie say meekly as he closed the door to her room behind him. “Okay… ‘night, Al…”

 


 

Once he made it back to his own room, Alastor ran himself another bath, lit up a cigarette, and poured himself a nightcap. Only once he was immersed in the scalding water, and the lingering remains of his evening’s activity washed away, did he allow himself to un-tense and slump.

“Fffffuck…” he hissed, resting his head back against the edge of the bathtub hard enough.

He had learned nothing from having sex with Charlie. Nothing that he’d told himself he would just to make sure he came to her room that night.

He had only served her.

And he’d gotten nothing out of it in return.

He downed the glass in one gulp, and set it down roughly on the ledge beside the bathtub, putting a crack in its base. “Fuck it all.”

Not an orgasm, no, he didn’t want one in the first place. Not in that context. Not at someone else’s violation. But he hadn’t gotten any information, any power, any greater purpose from tonight.

Charlie’s demon form only came out sporadically, as a reaction to stimuli. To losing something dear to her. To the animal function of pleasure. Or the ridiculous notion, the weakness of love and friendship.

And the way she’d come down at the end was proof of that. It had been like the flipping of a switch.

She was still avoidant of her own sins.

She was still too restrained.

But he had asked her to be restrained. He knew her being unrestrained was a risk to him now. He knew what Charlie Morningstar was still capable of, physically and emotionally, and now that they were literal bedfellows that was more vital than ever.

In some way that should’ve been a relief, but it wasn’t.

He saw now that it was symbolic of how, all in all, she was broken. Sad to admit, but she was. And this sexual intercourse was just a subset of that. There was none of the singing and harmony she’d had with Vaggi. None of the power and potential he’d hoped to cultivate, and utilise, and maybe harvest. Just… rutting. Base instinct.

And nothing for him, but the potential for an orgasm that he could very well get from the palm of his own hand instead, whether it be stroking his dick or holding a knife about to bring down into some poor soul’s chest.

He took a long drag from the cigarettes, and idly wondered if this was how women felt about sex with the then-increasing proportion of inconsiderate men. From the things that ‘Rosie’ and Mimzy had told him, from the things Charlie and Vaggi had said about Adam.

From his own experience with Vox.

…

But Charlie wasn’t Vincent.

She wasn’t a man. For all her flaws and her pride and her shortsighted-ness, she never had been a brute, or that type of pigheaded. Even in her prideful moments. Even as a demon in the throes of pain and pleasure. Even when she was using him.

She couldn’t help it.

He pitied her. He really did.

Despite that she couldn’t help her biology, she cared.

She cared too much.

Wanting him to stay, to toe the line of affection, to return the favour and get him off – he didn’t trust it. He couldn’t. If he did stay, he was letting her dictate their dynamic, their hierarchy. He would be letting her dictate him.

He’d had enough of that in his past life.

He couldn’t be ruled by her.

 

Alastor got out of the bath, dried himself off extra roughly, until he felt well and truly clean, and then retired to his own bed. Telling himself that there shouldn’t be any point to repeating this.

 


 

But come next month, on the day of the month when Charlie didn’t come out of her room… he was there. Waiting outside her door again, in just a robe and his glasses.

Accepting the inequity of this task.

 

Chapter 11: “…passionate fornication?”

Summary:

Something goes badly wrong.

Notes:

Trigger warnings: dubcon (character consenting to sex while not comfortable with it, character having sex while not of sound mind), elements of noncon (consent retracted, retraction of consent going unnoticed due to hallucination), graphic violence.

A reminder that this is a Dead Dove Do Not Eat fanfiction, and this chapter is the deadest the dove gets. Please heed the tags. I chose to use the ‘elements of rape/noncon’ tag instead of the Rape/Noncon warning on the basis that the act in this chapter is unintentional, and the result of a hallucination.

The author’s intent is not to endorse or glamorise what takes place in this fic.

Chapter Text

More time passed.

The months were now marked and tallied in Alastor’s mind by Charlie’s heat cycles. By the days or nights he was obliged to have sex with her. It wasn’t long before he’d had sex with her more times than he’d had sex with any one person.

Soon enough, he could no longer count off how many times it had happened on his fingers. Soon enough, he’d had sex with her more times than he’d ever had sex before, alive or dead.

He tried to do so at the earliest opportunity during each of her heats, to get it over with, to not have to endure her rutting advances as she succumbed to it. At first he assumed that this would correlate with the intensity of her moans and the sexual affections he asked her to hold back – that they would be lesser the sooner he nipped her libido in the bud.

But it didn’t seem to. Some nights Charlie was, like the first, coherent, almost in control of her inner demon, just in enough discomfort that she couldn’t mask it anymore. Other times her eyes were red and feral from the outset of their mating, her skin hot, and it took her visible effort to remain cognisant.

There was no pattern or reason to it. Just like there were still no real glances into Charlie’s demon power, beyond its exhaust when she climaxed.

Still, Alastor habitually took note of the things he learned from each night. Charlie preferred being on top, it seemed – frustratingly, for him. Soon enough, though, he pragmatically put together that, outside of control, these positions seemed to enable better stimulation for her, and if he could replicate this from on top, he might claw some back.

He experimented with adding his hands in addition to his member, though she had said that was of limited help. Contrary to the unfortunately true stereotype of men, he knew where the clitoris was, and as much as he cared about how to stimulate it. Though his nails were long, he preferred to keep them that way, and Charlie, in her demon state, showed no objection if his claws bit into the skin around her crotch a little.

He reaped a few seconds from that.

If he positioned himself in missionary, but higher up in relation to Charlie; pressing his lower stomach to her crotch as he thrusted, it seemed to offer similar stimulation where he could not use his fingers – but it was too close. Too much physical contact. He needed detachment.

Charlie said that raising her legs helped. She could put a pillow underneath her hips, and hook her legs over his shoulders, or put her legs together and brace her hooves on his chest – but that leverage against him made him uneasy. It gave her the power to push him over, or kick him.

Sitting on the edge of the bed with Charlie in his lap, though it gave him more height over her and her less physical leverage, typically led to a fall.

So it turned out he wasn’t particularly sexually adventurous – why would he be? Why would he want to be? He avoided anything too close, anything that pushed and pressed their bodies together, if he could. But ‘doggy style’, despite its physical distance and detachment, certainly felt too… vulgar for him. Not to mention he disliked the association with dogs.

And he wanted Charlie’s eyes on him.

He couldn’t put his finger on why, but he did.

So he kept to missionary, to that lotus variety of cowgirl, to the small variations of them. If Charlie responded in any way to that selection of sexual variety, he didn’t care to spend his time trying to tell. Regardless of how she felt, it was the same outcome each night that he had to do this task. Charlie came, she was sated and her heat ended, and he got to return to his room and scrub and scald his body free of any evidence.

He continued to leave immediately after each round, aside from the obligatory inquiry about her health. He made sure Charlie had water to soothe her throat. On a couple of instances, he returned to her room fully dressed to leave food outside her door, knowing she would skip a meal or few when she started her heat. She was concerningly thin.

But that was all he did.

Sometimes, though rarely, he was unable to come (that pun was completely unintentional, Angel do NOT laugh) to her at once, if he had business to attend to. Food to purchase. A singular intoxicated straggler who clearly hadn’t heeded the word-of-mouth warnings from the last guests of the Hazbin Hotel, and was rummaging around like a raccoon in the trash. Those few occasions, he went up to her room late and with (if he were honest with himself) trepidation, and Charlie was demon form, flushed, itching, feverish and wanting…

But still, she didn’t stray outside the boundaries he’d set with her. She came, and she came back into herself.

Charlie never asked for Alastor when her heats began, or reached out asking where he was when he delayed attending to her. Either she assumed he knew she was in heat, or she had that silly notion of trust in him still.

Or maybe it was something else? Their relationship had changed.

She had become more distant. She still sought him out in the weeks between their trysts, but she no longer talked as much to him. When she did, the tone of her voice had changed; she was softer. More monotone. She was less clingy when she sought his physical touch, and that came less often. She didn’t offer to sing or play music with him,

She was sadder.

Her company was duller.

Knowing her sentimental tendencies, it was probably an inevitable result of his lack of affection, both physical and social, after the act. Alastor knew aftercare was the proper thing to do, she had said she wanted it, she had invited him to stay on that first night. Supposedly she just wanted to talk.

He imagined ‘Rosie’ would judge him for not accepting that invitation. Probably all of what he was doing.

Maybe even Mama would’ve severely disapproved of his manners.

But he just couldn’t do it. He couldn’t risk it. He would not let himself become weak in that sappy, emotional way like Vincent had, like Husk had, like Charlie had. Charlie had asked so much of him it had to take away from something, and, well, evidently this was the price she had to pay: his tolerance of affection and friendliness from her, with her.

And the price he had to pay was a sense of what someone else might call guilt.

It gnawed at him. He was conflicted. He missed who Charlie had been – but who she had been would never have propositioned him with sex – her needs would’ve been sated by Vaggi.

On some nights, as Alastor recovered and reminded himself he was free and in control now, he realised he might not be so glum if Charlie returned to her hallucinationary company. That thought was immediately quashed by the sins of greed and envy; he could not surrender hard-won influence when there was precious little else in this world to have. It was a pity one could not fuck ghosts, unlike that distasteful human stag flick.

But, when he started to pay more attention to Charlie’s habits again, it seemed like she was filling the spaces in which they might have engaged socially before she made her request with her hallucinatory Vaggi.

… Yet it wasn’t like before.

Charlie didn’t recreate her old mile-a-minute conversational style with this summoned ghost. She was muted, and so this ‘Vaggi’ was muted. And sometimes her physical features just weren’t correct. Her face was blurry, the finer details of it fuzzy. Her voice became distorted, like she was speaking over a telephone – or the radio.

And her clothes started to be… wrong.

Sometimes the hallucination wore a pastel white-and-lavender-grey dress, instead of Vaggi’s red polo blouse and dark lavender skirt. Sometimes the dress was dark grey all over instead. Sometimes it was red and frilly.

One time, Alastor spotted the hallucination with its hair dark, up in a poufy 80s do; the bow in it smaller and polka-dot patterned, her dress black and gothic with red fur boots. Alastor vaguely recalled the time Angel had taken Vaggi out clubbing to loosen up, in getup just like that… but had Charlie been there to assess her girlfriend’s appearance? He didn’t think so. So how was she getting this recollection of her?

Another time, he saw ‘Vaggi’ with her hair dark, her dress more like Velvette’s had been, with a purple patterned cape, and two eyes in her head. Where had that come from? Charlie had only ever known Vaggi with a singular functioning eye on her right-hand side, and Vaggi had told everyone that Lute cut her left eye out scant minutes before she first laid eye on Charlie in some alleyway near Cannibal Town. She barely looked like Vaggi here, and yet Charlie still recognised her and tried to talk to her.

It occured to Alastor that it had been roughly four years since the apocalypse. Charlie had known Vaggi for about that long, from the day she adopted her from the trash to the day Roo’s destruction tore them apart.

Charlie might have now gone longer without Vaggi than with.

And she was forgetting her. Sometimes the hallucination didn’t even react to Charlie when she tried to engage with her.

So, as she’d always done when something didn’t go her way, Charlie fixated. She tried so hard to solve the problem. She pulled the curtains away from the portrait of Vaggi on the wall, and stared at it as if to sear the image of her into her eyeballs. She listened to voice mail on a phone that was slow, buggy and failing (not like Alastor’s meticulously kept records). She did art therapy for herself, drew Vaggi, and accidentally spelled her name underneath with an ‘e’ at the end, and struggled to puzzle out what was wrong. And then she remembered, and cried, and destroyed that painting, and cried some more.

Alastor would hold her when she came to him for physical comfort, and she held on back… but not as tightly as she used to.

In this way, Charlie was dissuaded from interacting with her self-inflicted ghost at last. She watched it still, but didn’t try to start conversation with it.

But she wasn’t exactly coming back to him anymore – except, of course, on the nights he came to her when her heat started.

He wasn’t losing her, per se, but nothing about this felt right.

Was he satisfied that the hold Vaggi’s memory had on Charlie was finally beginning to slacken? Of course he was. But the cloud of the sexual aspect of their relationship hung over them like a dark cloud. Charlie was relying on him for sex; that was the monkey’s paw to his long want to monopolise her and be the one she relied on. That he couldn’t escape the obligation.

Was it because he felt guilt at the notion of leaving her to suffer? Or was it that he might fear what could have happened had he left her to cope through increasingly painful heats?

But what was there to fear? There was no unknown, it was all the same now. Charlie had no real passion anymore. There was less and less of the entertaining, compelling young lady who had caught his attention once.

He had nothing from her. Even her outbursts of orgasm seemed to grow dull. Even her demon form was predictable, and predicably held back.

And yet he still went on this dance with her, like clockwork.

 


 

Alastor came up to Charlie’s penthouse, the same as ever, in his robe and glasses and with a glass of whiskey in his belly. And Charlie was waiting for him, same as ever – though this time in a robe herself, short and scarlet. She greeted him with a small smile; calm, despite her demon form and the tells of pain.

Her eyes looked a little watery and distant, maybe verging on unfocused, but that was common enough these days. She noted his presence, tracked his movements, and that was enough.

No small talk was required, they both had their understanding that this was just business. Charlie unrobed, then Alastor; they climbed onto the bed, and Alastor waited for the little tells of what position Charlie was preferring. She was behorned and betailed and red-eyed, so it was evidently going to be a night with her on top again.

He sat up straight against the sideboard, and Charlie kneeled right atop his hips, waiting for his cock to become erect before she settled onto it. She gasped with partial relief, bracing her hands against his shoulders, and in practiced routine his hands grasped her hips.

He let her begin to ride him, tuning out as he did. It made these nights more tolerable for him. He wasn’t interested in hearing Charlie’s noises, her gasps and moans. They meant nothing to him. They didn’t affect him. They were just something to ignore.

Like all the times he’d had to hide out in the woods, or the bayou, to avoid being found out after cutting up another stuck-up, disrespectful waste of human life; getting bit by insects, not being able to have his fun. Waiting. He could bear it. It was just… hardly preferable.

Strangely, he missed those days. It had still been freer than this. There had been so much possibility and power, almost within his grasp. If there was a greater cosmic sense of irony, the broken universe was probably laughing at him, throwing his own words back at him.

He could see the argument how this Hell was his punishment.

Alastor preoccupied himself with following an untrodden path in his mind. Was he really as good as calculating odds and making gambles as he’d like to think he was? With ‘Rosie’, with Vox, with Lucifer… and now with Charlie, the outcomes were not what he’d hoped or planned for. Should he have kept out of touch with the demons from beyond, and settled for a longer life as a mortal murderer; settled for having to start from the bottom when he wound up in Hell?

Loathe as he had been to even entertain the though… should he have accepted the offer of redemption? Would his being bound to rules and social niceties have been worth it?

But the chance given was the life he lived before, the punishment was this. There was no undoing what he’d done. No do-overs. Why would he wish for it when he’d known it all along—?

—A hand touched his face and stroked his cheek. Alastor halted his train of thought and snapped back to full awareness at once.

He noticed the pace of Charlie’s rocking and thrusting against him had increased, pressing him deeper into the mattress each time. It was uncomfortable, it wasn’t ideal, but it was managable. He tightened his grip on her hips, trying to slow her rhythm down.

But she seemed to misinterpret his touch. Her other hand wrapped around his lower back and pulled his torso closer. He tried to resist – but there was strength behind her deceptively gentle motion.

Her gasps and moans were too loud, now, too sensual to ignore.

Alastor saw her eyes were closed. “Charlie,” he said, warningly, hoping this would snap her out of this.

Charlie opened her eyes, and she looked at him – but she wasn’t seeing him. He could tell. They weren’t quite focused. They were misty, almost cloudy. She smiled a watery smile that wasn’t the one she had reserved for him. Her hand slipped from his cheek to the back of his neck, and she pulled his head in closer – and she kissed him.

Alastor kept his lips closed and tilted his head away, but Charlie merely redirected the kiss to his neck. This was enough. This was well past his limits, and it was time to stop this.

“Charlie, stop.” He barked.

Emotional words spilled out of Charlie’s mouth. “I missed—I missed you so much… I’m so, so happy…”

Alasor looked down, to find his hands and calculate how to use them to prise himself out of Charlie’s grasp. And the sight he took in was alarming. It wasn’t his own body he saw. Suddenly he seemed shorter; curvier, with lavender-hued grey skin.

“Vaggi,” Charlie moaned. “Vaggi. Vaggi.”

Vaggi’s body. Charlie was hallucinating Vaggi right where he was. Of all the bad luck – this was the worst possible time. Oh, he should’ve known this would happen. He got sloppy. He let his guard down too much. He’d gotten used to assuming the dullness of what he and Charlie were doing was a constant. He had to put an end to this night, right now.

“Stop, now.” He purged himself of physical libido. His cock went flaccid. But Charlie didn’t seem to register it; she just ground into him harder, practically bouncing in his lap.

“Charlie! Enough!”

She pulled him closer still, her breath coming faster, her chest heaving; she was still chanting Vaggi’s name, over and over. Alastor conjured up all his fury and strength and indignance, placed his hands on her stomach and her breast, and shoved her away.

“I said, ENOUGH!”

He didn’t even have time to disentangle their legs – and he was going to – before Charlie reacted, and she did like he’d never seen her before. She lit up, blindingly; red veins and a fiery corona. The rest of the room beyond her plunged into darkness.

“No—! NO! NO!! VAGGI—VAGGI—VAGGI!!!” Charlie screamed; desperate, betrayed pleas at a deafining pitch and volume. And she lunged towards him, and her hands scrabbled against him, trying to pull him back into her embrace. Her claws sliced at his arms, his sides.

Alastor fought back on instinct. He had well-honed memories of the movements he could’ve once used to summon shadows and tentacles; even without his power there was usually some use to blocks and punches and swipes. But the moment he touched her forearm, it burned hotter than any hot poker or coal or hellfire ember he’d ever held had.

For the first time that night, he flinched.

But each flinch just led to Charlie carving into him more, trying to tug him back, as she howled Vaggi’s name over and over, begging to know why was she doing this in pure anger and betrayal. Her wrath was overwhelming, and he was at the receiving end of it.

He tried to escape again, swiping at her arms to try and cause her even the slightest bit of pain; pressing his nails into her demonic flesh; putting a hand against her jaw to leverage himself away, or push her face away. It would break a mortal’s neck; it might have broken hers were Charlie her usual self, but in this moment Alastor didn’t care, couldn’t care.

The next impact of Charlie’s flailing hands flung his glasses from his face, and he heard them shatter against the wall. His vision was now blurry, and he could not clearly see the blows coming as Charlie clawed at his face. He was even weaker. For the first time that night, he froze, and that allowed Charlie to swing and slice a gash in his neck as she tried again to pull him closer – so very close to his jugular. It burned shut in almost an instant from her hot, hot touch – but it was so close. Too close.

Then there was a slash across his chest, opening up old scar tissue, following the line of an old wound. And, for a moment, Alastor saw Adam, towering overhead, swinging his garish hybrid of a guitar and an axe. Cutting into him. Almost killing him a second time. He saw Vox slicing through the cockaminnie stitches he’d tried to sew himself together with, salting the wound while he was down and out for the count.

He saw Roo in Roo’s daughter, looming there at the end of all things.

Finally, he found strength in the anxiety of self-preservation. He pushed her away enough to dislodge himself from under her, sending that burning silhouette sprawling back on the blankets. She scrambled to pick herself up, roaring and snorting, readying herself to charge.

For another moment, Alastor saw her; eldritch, twisted, warped and powerful; a nightmarish reprise of the fiery way she’d ended her song on Katie Killjoy’s picture box show.

But Charlie’s eyes opened, and cleared, and focused on him.

She recognised him. “Alastor?” she asked, in a tiny, horrified voice.

And she shrunk back in on herself: horns gone, tail gone, eyes yellow and watery. She gasped, and retched, and her hand clapped over her mouth – there was red blood all over her fingers, and a few scratches in her forearms from where he’d tried to pull her off of him. She scrambled on all fours across the bed, away from him, stumbling and slipping until her back hit the headboard.

He heard her whimper. “What have I… what have I done? No, no, no, I’m sor—I—she—I’m sorry—I didn’t—what have I done?!” She looked like she was going to be sick – disgusted with herself.

It was a pitiful display of emotion.

He must be a pitiful display of injury.

Alastor climbed off the bed in a rush, ignoring the pain in his limbs and chest, and backed away from Charlie. He snatched his bathrobe from the floor as he did so. He didn’t take his eyes off the woman – no, the creature – who had just violated and overpowered him, as she hunched over herself and trembled and shook; so deceptively small and maudlin.

She had lost control. Charlie had well and truly lost control of herself, for the briefest of moments.

‘Isn’t this what you wanted, pet?’ a voice that sounded like Charlie’s true mother whispered mockingly into his mind.

It wasn’t. It wasn’t.

He’d wanted a pupil, a tool, a powerful but subordinate companion who he could trust to remain within his power to control. And Charlie wasn’t that any more.

Alastor stood there for an eternity of a minute, his eyes locked on Charlie, frozen; a deer in her headlights. Or maybe her in his, as she shrunk from his gaze, eyes darting between him and her bloodstained hands.

The first fresh thought that occurred to him, then, that cut through the silence, was that it wasn’t right to leave a lady naked and cold like that. He didn’t pity her, he had no more grace to give to her – but Mama had raised him better than that.

Gingerly, he approached, and, keeping as much distance as he could from her, placed his own bathrobe over Charlie’s shoulders.

Then Alastor walked out.

Out of her room, and down the stairs.

He hurriedly dressed in his own room. He put his last surviving monocle in. He did a cursory job of blotting up the blood and soot on his exposed skin. He made sure his sleeves covered the claw marks and the burns. He fought back the tremor in his hands.

He didn’t pack any personal effects.

 

He left the Hazbin Hotel.

 

Chapter 12: I could've told you, Vincent

Summary:

Another V haunts Alastor, and he weighs his options.

Notes:

CW // drinking, smoking, self-harm/bad first aid practice, blood and injury, squick (drinking your own blood), mention of past sexual assault. Also Vox is kinda racist about Alastor’s hair.

Chapter Text

The flat-screen television mounted on the wall came to life as Alastor opened the door and stepped into the bar. It flickered a test pattern of distorted colours upon its cracked and broken screen, which faded to static – and then the static resolved itself into red eyes on a blue backdrop, eyes that blinked blearily and struggled to focus on him. 

Alastor paused in surprise. Somehow, Vox, stripped of his power and body, had survived the apocalypse and ended up mounted on the wall of the speakeasy they had once frequented, the place he had come to now as an escape. What a lovely coincidence.

“Hey… oh, hey, Al, you’re back!” the TV slurred. “It’s—uh—it’s been a while, old pal!”

“Oi!” One of the bar’s few other patrons bellowed: “Change the fucking channel, asshole!”

“…It has. Yes, it has.” Alastor acknowledged Vox with a careful nod, keeping his thoughts, his emotions, and his pain in check. It had been decades, but by the state of him, maybe Vox didn’t realise this. The lazy eye, the cracks in the screen, his slow and stuttered speech… it seemed his mental faculties had declined with the way he’d been damaged. 

Such a pity, such a fall from the showman (and snake oil salesman) he’d once been. At least he seemed to have found bliss in ignorance. 

The same could not be said of Alastor, unfortunately.

He made his way to his barstool, the one he’d always picked when he came here before, and it was unfortunately too close to the familiar face on the wall than he would’ve preferred. Not that he had much of a choice. Half of the bar had been eviscerated; the western wall was gone, and the floor dropped off into a giant fissure that had opened up when Roo intruded upon this realm. There were scorch marks and burns on the wood and brick near where the building had been sliced in half. One wrong step and whoops! Down into the abyss.

No one had bothered to make any repairs. But why would they, after all, in these times?

Other than that, what survived of this place was unscathed. Even the drinking bird bartender was still there. Alastor wondered if it still recalled him after all the decades.

“Barkeep? My regular, if you will,” he requested, and within moments he had a glass of whiskey in his hand. 

He stared at his battered reflection in it for a minute, noting how messy he looked. His smile was strained. The scratches and welts Charlie had left on him stood out against his skin – some of them must have bled again on his walk here. 

A visible weakness. A broken mask.

A sign of the times.

Fuck. 

“…Hey, hey, Al… did you do something with your hair?” Vox asked. 

Alastor ignored him.

“It’s a bit messy, don’t—don’t you think? But—I mean if that’s the look you’re going for, I can’t—I can’t judge – I mean, I messed up my hair getting rid of a few obstacles, if y’know what I mean. Eh? Eh?”

Alastor ignored him harder.

He took a sip from his glass. The whiskey was bottom shelf booze, less refined than he was used to, but beggars can’t be choosers in this economy. Best be grateful for what he had received, he thought sourly, and downed the glass. Then he dabbed his finger into the dregs, and used it to clean away the crusting blood on his face.

The alcohol stung, but he preferred it that way. This pain was self-inflicted. 

Better than pain dealt by someone else.

His sleeve rolled down, and he noticed a gash on his wrist, gone undealt with – and there was one on his neck too, underneath his collar.

“Another, if you don’t mind,” he demanded of the bartender, holding out the glass, even though there was red diluted in the last lingering drops of whiskey. “Don’t bother cleaning it.”

The drinking bird always had its discretion.

Now he dunked his bloody fingers fully into the glass without taking a sip first, and he cleaned out the wound on his wrist; sticking his finger in it. The pain was cleansing, in a way – no, two ways. Figuratively and literally. He swiped out blood clots and burnt scabs, and let them float into his glass. 

The whiskey had turned rosé pink by the time he downed it.

So Alastor ordered another.

And another.

And another.

Goodness, he thought hazily, as he unbuttoned the top button of his shirt and fingered whiskey into the wound on his chest, he was as bad as Husker, wasn’t he?

Evidently Vox thought so too. “Whoa-hoh-hoh, slow down there, Al!” he called jovially, like a shitty late night show host. “What is this, a—uh—a…Mardi Gras? You better have some—some time to kill in the morning! Instead of, y’know, people!”

“It’s a hard liquor kind of night, Vox,” Alastor answered, by way of explanation. He scowled and shook himself awake, buttoning his shirt back up. Vox shouldn’t have seen that. He didn’t want Vox to have noticed his weakness.

“Oh—oh, shit, I mean—I’m sorry, man.” He imagined Vox’s face falling into that pitiful look he knew well. “Yeah… you do look a lil roughed up. Did anyone—? Who? Who did it? Do ya need me to get them off your back for you…?” His voice trailed off, like he’d been distracted, as Alastor stewed at the patronising offer and the possessiveness-feigning-protectiveness. Then: “Hey, Al? Did you do something with your hair?”

Alastor’s scowl paused in confusion. Hadn’t Vox already asked that? He was supposed to have (fittingly) a photographic memory, and even in his easily-manipulatable moments of  dumb lovesickness, he had never been this much of a klutz interacting with him. Something was off.

“I WANT MY FUCKING NAKED WRESTLING!” the demon from earlier shouted, throwing a whole bottle of cheap booze at the TV.

Vox yelped, and switched to showing grainy footage of imps rolling around in mud on his screen before the bottle smashed into the wall, several inches clear of him. The bar patron made an obscenely satisfied sound and seemed to settle down

Alastor scoffed and glared down into his glass for several minutes.

Vox helping him? He didn’t need help. He didn’t need to owe any more debts. He didn’t need Vox to try and impose on him a fake friendship that would just be a front for exploiting him, like every relationship was. Especially not after all he’d been through. He was better off alone now, he thought.

Besides… “What could you possibly do, Vox?” he leered. “You’re stuck on the wall.”

The TV cycled through several channels, and Vox re-appeared. The noisy, violent patron from earlier seemed to have slipped into a stupor, and didn’t object to his picture show being changed this time.

“What’s that?” Vox grumbled. Oh, right, yeah, I am… hold on, how the fuck—when the fuck did that—did that happen?” He blinked blearily, and yawned, and then his eyes refocused on Alastor. “Oh, hey, Al, you’re back! It’s been too long, old pal! How—how have you been?”

Ah. The damage really was deeper than the surface. Vox was losing his memory. That’s why he was treating Alastor like he had before he went and ruined what they had (a proper relationship, where he knew his place was subordinate to him). That’s why — he was Vincent again. Pitiful, admiring, idolising Vincent.

That safe companion.

He couldn’t help but smile a bit more genuinely. “It’s hard times for all of us, Vince’.”

“Uh, not me! I’ve been doing fine! I’ve been, uh… what have I been doing?” Vincent scrunched his face up in confusion, and Alastor allowed himself chuckle – he allowed himself to relax. For a moment, it was decades ago, and he was enjoying pleasant company and a pleasant drink. “Doesn’t matter. I mean—whatever your troubles are, may—maybe even I could help?” 

And there Vince—Vox went, ruining it again, prying at Alastor’s business. “Are you really in a position to do that, Vincent?” He snickered. “I thought you had more faith in me. Didn’t you find me inspiring?”

“S-so? We could still do something for each other! Help each other out? I want to help!”

…That was such a Charlie thing of him to say.

Charlie. Alastor had thought he’d been safe around her too, and he hadn’t been, and he’d let the weakness of fondness for her get the better of him. It had entrapped him. It had wounded him.

He angrily downed his glass without cleaning his scars or seasoning the whiskey with his blood this time, and he didn’t order another. He’d had too much. He wouldn’t let himself get any more tipsy than he already was.

“…Alastor? You alright? You just seem a b-bit… tense. If this place is like… getting too loud or something— the only thing loud here was Vox’s idiotic voice, “—we could always go some place else, grab a malt, or a smoothie, just… chill out, chillax, what-whatever it is the kids say these days…?”

Alastor wanted to tell Vinc—Vox to spare the platitudes, or snark that he hoped he wouldn’t have his mouth all duct-taped up this time and that he could actually order something of his own, but he held his tongue as Vox trailed off.

“…Alastor? Oh, hey! I didn’t notice you come in!” Of course you did. “Hey, hey, Al?” 

“Yes, Vo—Vincent?”

“I have an idea—a proposal, I mean, I’ve been meaning to t-tell you about—I mean ask you.”

“I’m listening,” Alastor said robotically, already tuning out. He’d already heard this pitch before.

“We've been close for a—for a few years now, r-right? I mean, people know us, they love you—me—us! They love us! Haha! So, I've been thinking, Alastor, with your incredible power and my m—my big influence, we would be unstoop—unstop—ins—inv…” He fumbled over the word.“… Well, huge! Me and you – we could rule Hell, together. As partners.”

Partners. Friends. 

It was all a sham. Everybody wanted to use him. Everyone attracted to his power was going to want to exploit it, of course. He would have, in their place. It was the way the world worked. Especially someone like Vincent Whitman, ladder-climbing hogger of the spotlight, easily finding his place by virtue of mediocracy and pale skin. 

He remembered Vox’s preening. The humiliation conga line. The smell of aphrodisiac cigarette smoke. Being exposed to the sight of Vox and Valentino’s fornicating, to full frontal nudity. Touching him.

Base animal instinct.

Like Charlie, consumed by her rut.

Vincent—Vox still wanted him, even in this diminished state, and if the tables were flipped and Vox were not powerless, it would still be the same. He would want to claim him, like Charlie, and use him, like Charlie, and hurt him too, like Charlie. 

Alastor shivered, the gashes he’d doused in alcohol continued to smart.

Vox seemed to take his silence as the rejection he meant it to be. “I… hahaha, I guess it is a bit of a big decision, y’know, a partnership is a lot to tie yourself down to! Kinda like marriage—almost! Almost like marriage! Take your time, think—think it over…” 

Oh, that comparison made it even worse. He’d been tied down by Jim Crowe. Tied down by Roo. Tied down to the Hotel. Tied to Charlie. Always someone’s pet, someone’s servant, someone had to be above him because two people, two groups, two entities could not share the top spot. It wasn’t possible. Equality was antithetical to the nature of reality; it couldn’t exist, whether in Hell or Heaven or on Earth. That was just the nature of things. 

He had to do what was necessary to stay on top. But now staying on top was just staying afloat. Surviving. 

Like that cinematic adaption of the Titanic calamity, the raft wasn’t big enough for him to share.

He had to cut all his ties to the past, all the familiarities he’d let himself get too fond of. This bar visit had done nothing good for him. He’d been cut away from Roo, and he’d cut Charlie out of his afterlife, now it was well past time he leave Vox behind for good too. He had no need of him any more. 

He never had.

Alastor got up, and made for the exit.

“Oh, hi, Al—oh! Oh, you’re going already?” Vox asked, stuttering, having another lapse in his memory. “I guess it is late… at least, I think… so, s-see you around some other time, then?”

“Don’t count on it,” Alastor sneered. And then, for old times sake, he added, “Old pal.”

Vox's smile fell. “Wha—what does that mean?” 

Alastor moved out of Vox’s line of sight. 

“W-wait, where are you going? I just thought… was it something I said? Al, I’m sorry!” He didn’t stop. He couldn’t see Vox’s face any more, all he could hear was his pitiful voice; fussing, panicking, on the verge of tears like he’d always been so easy to provoke into. “Why the fuck can’t I move?! Alastor?!? Don’t leave! Don’t! Come back!! Al?!?”

He walked out the door, and Vox’s pleas were cut off.

Outside, he thought about lighting up a smoke. He still had his lighter and half a pack of cigarettes on him – it might relax him. But the other occupant of the alley had their pants down and seemed to be trying to copulate with the wall. Such was the dating scene in Pentagram City these days.

Alastor swore under his breath and walked the other way.

 



His feet led him south-east, away from the Hotel, following the chasm that had broken through his old drinking hole. He walked for hours, as the ruins grew more ruined and eventually even the rubble had been swept clean from the ground. And finally he ended up on the rim of the largest crater in the ruins of Pentagram City. A ground zero from which all the damage radiated out from.

This must have been Cannibal Town. Roo’s gateway into Hell. Though she was long gone from this realm, the impression of her breathing down his neck still lingered. He imagined he could feel the soulbound chain she’d forced on him when he thought he’d struck a bargain for a safeguard on power and influence in his afterlife.

He kicked at the gravel, knocking pebbles over the edge of the crater. Then he sat down, and lit up a cigarette. The nicotine and the breeze sobered him. 

Alastor was free, now. Technically. Free from soul owners and fallen angels. But also… he wasn’t. He was powerless and trapped in a decaying reality with meagre scraps to offer for him to claim or to be entertained by. 

Hell truly was a prison, a punishment, for him now.

He had nowhere else familiar to go, aside from the Hotel and the bar. His old residences and radio towers were probably destroyed, and he had no access to his safe pocket dimension in the shadows any more. He’d lost his bayou, his home away from home, and he’d never get it back.

He could start over, from the bottom, sure. But (at risk of being petulant) he didn’t want to. He was tired of scrounging. Wasn’t there a chance for him to just not have to struggle and strive for his place in the world any more? To rest on his earned laurels? To not have to settle for crumbs when he could’ve ruled his world?

Now he’d had them all taken away from him, and could never get them back because what was left in this reality was simply not enough for him. He couldn’t get what he wanted.

Without his powers he was as vulnerable as the lowest imp. The makeshift blessed blade he’d repurposed that Carmine rifle barrel into gave him some advantage, yes, but it could not possibly match a hundred bullets that would rip him to shreds, and once the blade was in their hands instead of his… well. He knew some Hellborn would definitely be out to kill him if their paths ever crossed again. And they would be able to do it. Blitzø Buckzo may have left behind a family, but he had also been something of a celebrity among his people, after all. 

And what of his own legacy? Decades of being the undisputed top dog in Pentagram City, for all that he’d still been on a loose leash; of being the voice of Hell, the one sinners had to listen to… all gone. Erased. Meaningless. Only for him to end up a princess’s lap dog, and then… nothing. All his powers, gone. 

Alastor rubbed his forehead. He wasn’t sure if it was the alcohol or the memory of his moment of death giving him a headache, or the weight of the decision at hand: what to do next. Or if it was the other memories chasing each other around in his head.

Vox. Charlie. Both of them wanting him in such similar carnal ways. Forcing something sexual onto him. It was so easy to picture Vox in Charlie’s place just hours before, pulling him closer, ignoring him when he said ‘no’, acting so sickly passionate.

But Vox wouldn’t have stopped. 

Vox wouldn’t have realised he was violating an agreed-on boundary, and pulled away. Because he’d have wanted to keep on going with his whole soul. 

Vox didn’t stop. Vox made him watch as he fucked Val. No matter how weak and pathetic Vincent was, the memory of the indignities he’d decided to bear lingered. That was where Alastor trusted him, to be this pale imitation of who he was. Alastor had trusted Vox insofar as when he’d trample over boundaries, when he’d make use of him when he’d crack. It had been easy to know him. Easy to extrapolate from that to know Vox would’ve fucked him, and would’ve treated any limits respected as a privilege he deigned to grant Alastor.

Vox was predictable. Charlie wasn’t. 

Vox wouldn’t have stopped in the act, once they got started.

…

Charlie stopped. Eventually.

And so she wasn’t entirely like Vox. She hadn’t wanted control, consciously, like he did. Not like that. She wanted her own way but she didn’t want to take it by force, even though that was the way Alastor would. Maybe that made her more insidious, considering all her emotional instabilities. She assaulted him because she thought he was Vaggi, because she still loved Vaggi, and she attacked him because – well, that was in-character for her, given the former point. She cared so much and had such big feelings. She denied herself indulgence in her true wants, and it all had to come out in these flashes of greed, of wrath. 

That’s why emotions were dangerous – that was why she was dangerous. 

She violated him. 

And yet… she’d still stopped. 

She’d flinched away, and crawled away, when she realised what she’d done. She felt guilt. That tenuous concept of remorse that she talked about so much in those sessions and lessons of hers, and yet, somehow, was true enough to redeem hundreds of sinners.

She hadn’t come after him. Of course he didn’t expect her to know where the bar was – but she hadn’t chased him out of her room, or barred him from leaving the Hotel. She’d let him walk away.  Hadn’t tried to drag him back. She had accepted the consequences of her actions.

Of course, she had broken her end of their bargain. 

But he had no way to enforce that any more. Breaking out of her spell was something she’d done of her own violation.

Charlie had stopped. Charlie had let him go.

Charlie might be the only one in Hell who would.

Alastor pocketed the lighter and cigarettes, and as he did, he felt something else in his jacket pocket. Something small, and metal, and winged. He pulled it out.

It was the key – not to his room, but to the whole Hazbin Hotel. He had kept it habitually in his jacket for when he went out on his outings to acquire supplies (among other things). 

Charlie probably wouldn’t be up to those outings, or to any form of self-nourishment. 


The key’s eye stared up at him, unblinking.

He stared back, for a long while.


Fuck it. There really weren’t any better options.

He supposed it didn’t hurt to see the fallout of his actions. Assess the situation. Assert his boundaries, rub it in. And if not, he could collect the rest of his items and possessions from his room, and put his roots down some place new.

He was willing to make the gamble that he could trust Charlie Morningstar to let him go again.

Chapter 13: I don't care if it hurts, I wanna have control

Summary:

Alastor returns to the Hotel, and has a chance to assert himself.

Notes:

Trigger warnings // explicit, rough sex; dubcon with noncon elements, blood, knife play. Alastor is vindictive in this chapter.

Please head the tags, and a reminder that this is a Dead Dove fic.

Chapter Text

So Alastor walked all the way across what was once Pentagram City, back to the Hazbin Hotel.

He halted at the gates to observe the state of the building after his (he checked his wristwatch) several hour absence. None of the lights were on – not the signage of the Hotel name, not the dim glow that had ever-presently burned in the ground floor windows for the past years, not even in the penthouse at the top.

It made everything about the Hotel look haunting. The great ship’s prow of the east ring now gave the impression of a wreck at the bottom of the ocean. The broken course of train tracks loomed like barbed wire strung above the trenches. The building seemed to sag and droop under its own weight and its inner darkness.

His radio tower had subsided and become crooked, too.

Alastor bounced the key in his hand for a minute, not yet taking another step forward.

He had been violated. This had come to been his home, but he had been violated by Charlie in it. That was a tarnish of memories he’d already repressed the fondness of.

Maybe under the cover of darkness his visit could go unnoticed until he deigned he wanted to be noticed. Charlie had not come to orgasm that night, so he could only deduce that she would still be in heat, and her lust might predominate her better nature again if she saw him.

There he was, second guessing himself. What a weak thing to do.

He wasn’t a coward. He would have power over this situation to see it through, take what was rightfully his – most of all himself. Get some sort of closure if Charlie came to confront him him, and leave.

So Alastor commanded himself to insert the key into the front door keyhole. Only to find the Hotel was unlocked. Unwise of Charlie to leave it like that. Had he not locked it since he left? It ought not have been his responsibility when he was leaving the premises.

(Why, he wondered, was he still sparing that much concern on her?)

He opened the door, stepped into the pitch black lobby, and closed the door behind him.

He did so quietly, and yet as soon as he did, he heard footsteps pounding distantly from upstairs. Then faint gasps and sobs of distress. A sound he was familiar with after all the years. It came closer, and closer, and the cries clarified into words:

“Alastor? Please, please, please be you, oh please be you, Alastor—”

A door on the mezzanine floor burst open with a brief flash of flame. The wall lamps came to life, one at a time, as a silhouette dashed past them, too fast to be lit up by their glow.

And then Charlie turned the corner and came racing down the staircase, her voice a babble of desperate relief. “Alastor!! Oh, thank you, you’re okay, you’re okay, you’re back, you came back…”

She descended the final few steps, and stumbled into the light cast by the coming-back-to-life hotel.

Oh, dear. She looked an absolute mess – still ill-dressed in that old pyjama shirt of hers, but now the unevenness of the done-up buttons was nowhere near seductive. Her makeup had run, her hair was knotted and might have had clumps ripped out of it. Her eyes were bloodshot, and she seemed a bit off-balance, unsteady on her feet; indeed there was a dribble of bile at the corner of her mouth. And most concerningly, there were red scratches and welts on her arms, keratin gouged out of her horns – it seemed from clawing at herself, enough to draw blood only partly washed away by tear tracks.

She may have evidently still been in heat. But her whole aura was one of regret and self loathing.

Alastor would’ve been genuinely concerned were this any other situation. He still felt a twinge. But mostly he felt harried, with the speed at which Charlie was cannonballing towards him. He readied himself to leave again, tensing up; even after years without the ability to, he habitually found himself slipping back into the motions of trying to melt into the shadows.

Charlie was still gushing tearfully, practically sobbing as she approached. “I was so worried about you, I didn’t know where you’d—thank you, thank you, I thought I was gonna be alone forever…”

Alastor took a single step back as she entered his (now-expanded) comfort zone. And Charlie instantly clued on. With a small gasp, she skidded to a halt, and, gulping, took two deliberate steps back.

“Charlotte,” he greeted her coldly.

She flinched at his voice. He knew his use of her full first name was only half of the cause. “Alastor, you’re back…” she panted. “I didn’t—I didn’t think you were coming back…”

“Oh, I’m not.” He watched her face sink, and tried to revel in how her shock and horror put out her relief like a fire. “No, not after what you did to me. I am merely here to collect my things.” His clothes, his personal effects, maybe a radio if he could carry it.

He made to brush past her and go upstairs.

“Alastor, w-w-wait! Please!” She gave him space as he went past; didn’t try to touch him, but she followed him to the foot of the staircase, pitifully. He didn’t like that.

“Don’t you try to plead your case with me,” he snarled. “You think you have the right to demand anything, after what you did to me?”

“I wasn’t… I won’t…” He heard her footsteps stop behind him. “I’m not going to try and stop you, Al – I can… I can bring your stuff downstairs for you, if you like.”

An attempted show at good faith? How saccharine. How 'touching'.

Alastor stopped halfway up the stairs and whirled around. “And don’t you think the way you tried to run into my arms just now contradicts that?” Charlie backed up another step at his words, and he sneered. “You think that will make me trust you, now? You think that will make up for what you did? Putting on this facade of nicety you wear while you keep violating others boundaries and changing them for your own purpose, telling them to give and to sacrifice for your sake? Well, sorry is not going to start anything anymore, so you can give up on that line.”

That should’ve rubbed it in enough, confronting her flaws and weakness directly. Would she fawn and plead now like was her want?

“No, I just—” Instead she fought to collect herself. How noble. “I just want to say o-one thing before you g-go.”

Well, he supposed he could hear her out. She was so pathetically emotional already, he’d probably get a kick out of it. He folded his arms. “Then speak what you will, before I lose patience.”

Charlie gulped and swallowed, picking her words. Her eyes shone brighter than ever. “I wanted to say that—that you’re right.”

He was right about a great many things. “About what?”

“About me. That I’m not a good person.” Ah, good, she’d internalised what he’d tried to tell her even if he hadn’t said it alright. “That I do keep hurting you… and I k-kept hurting others after I said I wouldn’t.”

Go on, he thought.

“A-and I’m—I’m a hypocrite, I’ve done things that g-go against everything I should stand for, everything I told sinners would get them redeemed. I’m—I raped you. I raped you. I’m as bad as Valentino. I b-betrayed the trust you put in my hands, when i could’ve coped through this heat on my own…” She sunk to her knees, her sobs intensifying to full-on bawling – so hard she started to hiccup violently. Causing herself pain.

Alastor just watched her in silence, taking it in.

“You have every right to end that deal you made with me. You had every… every right to leave.” Yes, well done.“But I just want you to know… that I’m so, so s-sorry. You won’t forgive me, I know. No one would. Even Vaggi wouldn’t —” Her saying Vaggi’s name had triggered Alastor's jealousy and anxiety in the past, but now Charlie had just rushed through it like an afterthought. “— and I’d deserve it. I promise, I’ll never forgive myself either, for hurting my last friend, my last family—the last person I could lo-love.” She retches and hiccups so hard that she brings up a fresh trickle of sick, and fails to keep it from leaving her mouth and going down her chin. “I’m irredeemable. I’m irredeemable.”

This was clearly causing her agony to say. As if sinking to her knees wasn’t enough, she collapsed to the floor, moaning, fully prostrating herself before him. “I’m so sorry, Alastor, I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I’m sorry…”

Charlie Morningstar, the Princess of Hell, was apparently willing to debase herself this much in front of him.

Vincent—Vox would have never. Nor Husker, nor Carmilla. Not Mimzy, not Angel Dust— Nobody in their right mind would ever show this much vulnerability, would ever submit so readily, to someone like him. Not even the most sheltered angel in Heaven would’ve.

This was a surrender on Charlie’s part. And Alastor realised he was still the one with power in their relationship. Cognitively, emotionally, he held the upper hand. Even though Charlie was still likely in heat, she had overcome her urges, recognised her wrongdoing. Her spirit was more willing than her flesh.

It made him feel triumphant. The feeling came back to him in a rush.

Not to mention it made him feel a little bit more secure. He’d made the right call coming back. This was the resolution he needed to this whole affair.

Meanwhile, poor, pitiful Charlie was still on the floor, coughing and crying. “Just go, please,” she bawled. “You don’t have to be around me any more.”

“Don’t be so presumptuous, Charlie. It’s another character flaw you really should work on.”

She looked up at him with weepy, bloodshot eyes. “Wh-whuh?”

Alastor approached her. “You’re really overdue an ego death, belle.”

“What do you—do you mean? Are—aren’t you leaving?”

He tried to sound idly, offhandedly humorous. “Job prospects and accommodation aren’t very good elsewhere.”

She gasped and splutter-blubbered in inelegant relief. “Buh-buh-buh, I—you—I thought—”

“Yes, I am staying after all.” He crouched, closer to her level – though still above her. He wouldn’t allow her to start gushing thanks – he didn’t want those, he only wanted her under his thumb. “You’ve done more than I could say of many other demons to embrace the errors of your ways.”

Charlie broke down sobbing again.

“But as long as it never happens again. He grabbed her by the chin – avoiding touching where the trails of vomit ran – and yanked her face up. She squeaked and gasped, flustered by his aggressive assertiveness. “Understand?”

“Of course. Of course,” she agreed, still crying.

Now he felt her, he realised her body was still feverishly hot. And the wracking sobs in her body still seemed to be causing her pain. “You are still in heat, are you not?”

A meek nod.

Alastor assessed the situation: the signs of Charlie’s heat and her demon form, and her wilful vulnerability. He weighed his options. Weighed his comfort with his need for fairness, to even the score – and a need to prove to himself and her that he was in control. And of course, to neutralise her heat, else he have to deal with her pain and self-pity.

He made his decision. “Then I shan’t leave you to suffer more than you deserve. Yes, I am still willing to bed you to stop your heat.”

Charlie looked at him, wide-eyed and flummoxed. She never had understood some things, some complexities. Such as why Angel Dust had kept going back to Valentino for so long.

Maybe that proved she wasn’t entirely like that distasteful pimp.

“But we are going to do this my way, on my terms.” For the first time around her, he intentionally dropped his smile. “I will come to you when I see fit. I will be on top, that is non-negotiable from now on. If you feel yourself slipping, I will stop. If I know your condition is that bad in advance, I will not come to your door. And if you violate me again, I will leave… but if not, if you acquiesce to these terms on these nights, that deal of ours can continue.”

Depriving her of options. A small voice in the back of his mind reminded him of how distastefully male this domineering is – but he didn’t care. She disregarded his consent, let her face the choice he’s giving her. That was the consequences of her actions.

And from her expression, he could tell that her guilt, and her fear of the prospect of loneliness into complying.

“Oh, and one more thing – I need you to keep your eyes open while I fuck you.” He felt himself puffing up with satisfaction, looming over her. “Don’t forget who I am, Charlie. Don’t forget that I am real, and she is not.”

He didn’t need to say who ‘she’ is. He didn’t need to say that he didn’t wish to be shredded again. To admit such weakness would be folly when he had the upper hand. He was the stronger one now.

Charlie gulped and nodded. “O-okay,” she stuttered in agreement. “Yes, Alastor.” She was panting, wincing, blushing – but most importantly, she was complying. Good.

“Lovely. Now,” and he grasped her arm and led her upstairs, “let’s get this over and done with.”

 


 

He brought her to her room, and kicked the door closed behind them.

“Undress,” he ordered, letting go of her wrist at last. Expecting a lady to bare herself first was impolite – but Charlie had to keep on making herself vulnerable for him.

She complied, fumbling off her shirt. Apparently she’d only been wearing the shirt when she tumbled downstairs at his arrival.

He did not undress himself, save for removing his jacket and undoing the top button of his shirt.

Once she was naked, he moved immediately. He pinned her to the bed, like he would have one of his victims, or a large hunted animal to deliver the coup de grâce. The spots that she had hurt in whatever guilt-ridden self harm she’d committed while he was gone, he used to help along with her compliance.

She whimpered as her face was pressed into the mess of blankets, and she struggled – but not too much. Manageable for him. He’d straddled stronger bodies than hers right now as he choked or cleaved the life from them.

Good.

With no preamble – he briefly assessed the state of her vulva – in went his fingers. No preparation. And he started pumping his hand back and forth with abandon. He knew where her G-spot was now by heart, and he would stimulate it with only mind to speed and intensity.

Charlie groaned, keened, and whimpered. She was squirming and bucking. But Alastor tapped into the muscle memory of keeping someone down and underneath him. He’d expected that she would fight back against this way of treating her, and he’d anticipated it.

She would not get any more than this. She wouldn’t.

He would remain in control.

Soon she started to tremble between the spasms of her body. Her arms changed colour charcoal-black; glowing red veins began to pulse visibly near the surface. Her bucking became more powerful.

Alastor braced himself, and held her down for longer. He was literally riding her now. He did not slow in the rapid movement of his hand.

Finally, as he’d expected she might, Charlie started to snap. There were her fangs, there was her head squirming and twisting, trying to bite him and throw her off. The same full-throated aggression of when she’d thought he was Vaggi, pushing her away.

“Ah-ah-ah!” He removed his hand from her pussy – it came out tinged with pink. He hadn’t trimmed his nails and he hadn’t cared to concentrate on a gentler touch tonight – and from the waistband of his pants he whipped out the blessed steel shard, and held it to Charlie’s throat.

She froze up.

So did he, waiting several seconds, until he was sure Charlie was obeying, that she was cognisant of her position, of the weapon that could kill her; that he had her under control.

“Good,” he sighed, and made to put away the makeshift knife.

“Leave it,” she rasped, surprising him. Her demon voice was flat, nearly dead. Maybe she’d accepted that she wouldn’t get any kindness out of him tonight.

He had her.

He really had her.

The satisfaction, the thrill was nearly as brilliant as when she’d placed her hand in his and shaken it, making the trade of information for a favour, in the forbearer room to this penthouse suite. A warmth rose in his body, and a tightness in his crotch.

And perhaps that coaxed him to insert his hand inside Charlie again with even more vigour.

She was stiller, but louder, as he brought her, roughly, closer to climax.

The minute she came, he sheathed his knife, and removed his fingers from her opening.His fingers came out a much stronger shade of pink, and her slick was pink, and Charlie shuddered underneath him. Without the lingering stimulation, her orgasm was over as soon as it began.

She shrank out of her demon form, back to herself. And when he got off of her she merely hunched in on herself, fetal position, breath still hitching. He stood over her stayed until she stopped crying, stopped shivering – until her demonesque traits were gone, save for her red, hurt eyes that turned to look at him with pain and betrayal.

Then he returned promptly to his room, unzipped his pants, put his dick in his hand, and quickly and efficiently coaxed out a clench, a pulse, and an amount of semen.

 


 

Afterwards, he took a shower instead of a bath.

He stood in the tub and let his hair be drenched and weighed down out; let and scalp burn from the heat of the water coming out of the faucet. He made sure the water was scalding for a different reason than before. Trying to drown out the voice scolding him in his head.

His mama’s voice.

Scolding him for treating a woman so. For being cruel, out of spite. Controlling, like other men.

She’d raised him better than this.

And he’d chosen not to be.

Because he had been violated. Charlie was more powerful than him, she was physically the greater in their dynamic now. Tit for tat was only fair. An eye for an eye. The oppressors had to know what it felt like to be at the other end of their actions.

That was the only justice that existed in this world.

That had been the tenant of his motives for decades and decades.

Women weren’t the oppressors, by and large. They weren’t supposed to be The fairer sex were subject to degradation and discrimination from men. Women of darker skin were treated even worse. He’d seen what his father did to his mother.

Of course, Rosie – Roo, and others, like Carmilla Carmine and Lilith had proved the rule wasn’t a rule. One had captured his soul, one had been a ruthless overlord and cunning businesswoman, and one a battle-hardened queen. They could embody exactly the same qualities.

And now Charlie was on that list of particular women. Worming her way into peoples hearts and then hurting them in her clumsy, privileged way. Unique in that mix of traditionally feminine charms he appreciated, and the carelessness he usually associated with the fakers, the “altruists” among men.

Like Vincent on his good days.

…

But maman would have liked Charlie Morningstar, he thought.

Would’ve taught her better, helped her grow out of all her privileged shelteredness. Mama had kept his morality grounded while he was alive, he had certainty that she’d have helped Charlie, had they been able to meet before all this apocalypse and ruin and madness.

If they met now… Alastor liked to think that she’d be disappointed in Charlie as well as him.

That was supposed to ease this bad feeling. They’d both done wrong; him and Charlie.

Maman would be disappointed if she knew, and it should have been a relief to him that she would never know the fun he’d gotten up to without her there. But the memory of her haunted him.

For the first time, it felt different. Normally, he was proud of his killings and revelled in his fun, and even if he knew she’d disapprove or worry,

Now he felt judged. He’d broken one of the core tenants of the teachings, the decorum, the wisdom she’d tried to impart. Wisdom from her own experience with men.

 

For the first time, Alastor accepted that he felt a deeper shame.

It was a pity, that he had treated one who had once been such a sweet and charming belle that way.

And his regret would not leave, even once the hot water ran out and he started to chill under the showerhead.

Chapter 14: My silver spring

Summary:

The aftermath of Alastor’s vindictiveness… and his regret.

Notes:

CW // brief semi-explicit descriptives of sex.

Also a reminder that this fic is tagged Hurt No Comfort and Unhappy Ending.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

But it seemed that did stop the worst of Charlie’s hallucinations. And contained the worst of her libido, too – her most manic wants that intruded on Alastor’s existence. And above all, her moments of inconsideration.

Now she only requested sex when she was certain – or as certain as she could be in her tenuous sanity – that she was lucid. When she absolutely needed him. Filtering out any chance of her using him for convenience or enjoyment.

She kept her overt horniness, and her craving love and affection, and missing Vaggi to herself. She let Alastor top; though he never would repeat the dominating assertion of that night when he came back. The memory of her hurt gaze, superimposed with what he knew maman’s disappointment would’ve looked like, stayed his instinct for vengeance.

In fact, Charlie didn’t close her eyes in the act anymore. She watched Alastor as he fucked her.

A part of it was disconcerting, it made him feel exposed. It reminded him of the power she held over him, could use against him, had used against him. And yet there was a seriousness in her demonic stare that told him she was obeying his command to keep herself aware. He knew she was doing it so she didn't lose herself again, and see anyone other than him in his place.

Maybe, despite the continuing unease, he appreciated that. He couldn't really tell.

Now, he sometimes remained flaccid while inside of Charlie, but it still seemed to do something for her just for him to be inside her. He preferred fingers, if possible, and tolerated that it took longer to bring her to orgasm. Sometimes, this way, she needed two climaxes before her lust was sated and she became herself again.

He found himself trimming the nails of his middle and ring fingers for these nights. He would not repeat the night of coaxing out blood-tinged vaginal secretions. That, maybe, was the biggest shame.

He observed her orgasms and the relief in them, and repeated the affirmations in his head that this meant nothing, this was only relief at the termination of her suffering for the month.

More and more he could believe it.

Thank fuck if Charlie felt like she was going, every time, she told him. And he knew not to linger, to maybe throw at her a sex toy if it was convenient for him to, fetch his robe, and hurry out into the hallway.

It may be strange, but it was the most comfortable he felt with her now. When she was respecting him and his boundaries.

But he might never completely trust her again, would never let his guard down around her again.

And yet he still found himself lingering outside her door, flirting with the edge of the boundaries he insisted on. Listening as she screamed and cried in agony, knowing whatever implement of self-manipulation she is using in there is just not enough.

She was not just a lustful creature.

She was lonely. Tortured by her own demon powers.

...

He pitied her. He didn't want to. He hated her, for what she'd done to him, for how she'd briefly controlled him. The way she'd lashed out. He made himself remember the feeling of being endangered by her, to keep a distance, to keep her on his toes.

Or maybe it was something more, something masochistic, something to emulate the way his mother would've lambasted him for shredding the inside of Charlie's core (or the way Niffty, Mimzy, might have turned her back on him had they known his actions.)

He also missed her. He missed their old closeness. Their shared love of song and showmanship; though he was trying to guide and cultivate her he enjoyed time spent with her. Her cheerful moods. The way their shared preference for pineapple and bacon on pizza rankled Angel Dust. Even though their partnership had its downs, cost him in injury, and had been at the order of Rosie Roo to cultivate her daughter – at the time, it felt good to be around her, to see her smile. 

But Alastor hadn't seen her smile since that night.

He missed when she had come to him for comfort or advice. He missed when her touch had just been platonic, or familial, depending on who was asking him: Lucifer or anyone else.

... They did use to be friends, he realised. They did. Charlie had called everyone at the Hotel her friends; her family, even, but it had never grated the way Vincent Vox saying it had. And despite the heel-face and face-heel turns he pulled, 

She had gravitated to him after the apocalypse not just because he was the only one left, but because she liked him. And she hadn't started out with the intention to woo him or bed him, Alastor was certain of at least that.

And now she was even more distant outside of their trysts. Oh, she stayed in the same room as him, sure, but she didn't engage with him anymore. She didn't approach him. She kept her distance. 

She looked almost grey, leached and bleed dry of colour. Her red suit jackets had faded and nearly lost their colour. She now dressed in almost funeral hues, and wandered around the Hotel in teary-eyed madness. She was unaccompanied by her ghosts now, and whether that was because she was no longer projecting her hallucinations or no longer seeing them at all, Alastor couldn't tell.

There was no music from her. No ideas. Nothing.

The inspiring woman he got entangled with, the girl he once knew, was gone.

They had lost that bond they once shared completely. Because of what she did, his ego kept on telling him. But he did something violating to her too, something that lowered the standards he'd set himself even as he began his fun in the living world.

What he did might well have killed her spirit. 

Alastor knew he had to do it, but his shame ran deeper than his justifying logic.

 


 

One morning – it might have been months, or years later, because time was meaningless now – they shared the breakfast table. A rare occurrence these days, with them not actively seeking each other's company anymore – but Alastor had been busy and only belatedly remembered his hunger.

He sat down on the opposite side of the table with a plate of semi-fresh meat fetched from the ailing refrigerator. Charlie had made herself some buttered toast – but with the toaster on the fritz, it was barely toasted. She ate it in slow, absent-minded bites. Alastor matched her pace.

The table was dirty, faded, unvarnished, and had borer holes in it. It hadn't been washed. Charlie was too depressed to clean, and Alastor was finding it more and more pressing to maintain his audio equipment. That took up most of his time now. It was his only tie to his proud identity left, and by whatever powers that were left in the fractured universe he would cling onto it for as long as he possibly could. But some things, like vinyl records, would wear down irreversibly, and could not be replaced.

Irreversible, like so many other deeds.

Alastor was broken out of his thoughts by Charlie's voice. "How long...?" 

He glanced up at her. Her eyes were still slightly unfocused in that ever-present thousand yard stare she now had, and he would've thought she was hallucinating again, or still not of sound mind... but for the fact she repeated herself. 

"How long has it been?" she asked, in a hoarse, soft voice. She was wary, but she was lucid, and it was the first time she'd initiated conversation with him for ages. "Since the old days.. when we were all..." She trailed off again.

Alastor tried to run the numbers through his head, and realised he hadn't been paying attention to the passage of time. He'd run through the combined record collections of himself and everyone who'd resided in the Hotel building twice or thrice by now. "A while. It has been... too long." Then he decided to chance a question to her. "Are you reminiscing about those days?" 

She nodded lifelessly. He wondered if this was her going mute again.

"I won't deny that I do, as well. But you know we view memories with rose-tinted glasses, dear." He dwelled on the fact that he had to keep telling himself that, these days. 

"Do we really?" 

Charlie wasn't wrong. The past had been just as frustrating as now, filled with turmoil and injury and betrayal, but Alastor had had so much power, and Hell had had potential, and Charlie hadn't forced herself on him, and he had only tried to keep her from Roo's use and for his own instead of clawing at her insides. "I suppose not." He snorted. "It's funny."

Charlie's eyes cleared, only to level a glare at him. "What is?"

"That I came to the Hotel for a practical purpose. A duty. A solution to my old predicament" She didn't flinch at his words. That shouldn't have been surprising. "And then I went and caught feelings. Grew fond of you all. How foolish." He shook his head with a scoff.

"I know better than to ask whether you regret it," she rejoined, resentful in that quiet, defeated way. "I never understood the callousness with which you treated others – treated us..." Treated me seemed to go unspoken, if Alastor's instinct wasn't wrong. "...but now I wish I could just... not care."

Alastor did care. But he shouldn't. All this mess had been proof of that.

He finished his shavings of meat, and Charlie seemed to abandon the thought of finishing her other piece of toast. She buried her face in her hands.

"What are we?" she asked.

"I can't imagine that we're in each other's debt anymore, Charlie. I came to the Hotel to tutor you to become your mother's heir, and you used me for your gratification and your sexual wellbeing. I suppose fair's fair at the end of the world." He shrugged. "So, to answer your question, I do regret the way it all went. I consider it a shame. There was so much fun I wanted to have with you." 

And he really had. Not just with the short-sighted goals of having her power on his side to humiliate and neuter Vox. Her potential was far greater than that, her immaturity would've made it entertaining to slowly break that naivety down. She had already been rooting to overturn Heaven's status-quo; his vision could have directed her to loftier goals. Overturning all of Hell's old orders, the rules barring sinners from the lower rings, the mess of Hellborn politics and entertainment and culture. Most of all, making sure that nobody would keep him down ever again.

He'd wanted to uplift her. "Now we are shackled by the consequences of our actions."

"So we're... stuck together. 'Till the end of time."

"Yes." He refused to entertain the alternatives. "But you can still look on the bright side, Charlie. Nobody else is getting their way, either." Which was true. Roo was in all likelihood trapped in the void, far away from the fragmented remains of reality that she could not piece together or derive power from. 

It seemed a bitter comfort to Charlie. She raised her head, sniffled, and wiped her nose. Her eyes shone, red and watery, then she clasped her hands under her chin and looked away from him. 

"I am sure Heaven has survived, though."

Another sniffle.

"Would they have have become decrepit up there, too? Not as bad as down here, of course – no..." For a moment, the entertaining idea of unredeemed sinners in Heaven gave way to the anxiety of his mother being subjected to the depravity of down here. "But perhaps the pearly gates have rusted. Now, wouldn't that be a sight? They can't have escaped upheaval up there, either."

Charlie suddenly laughed, harshly and with no humour. "I think Vaggi might have moved on from me." A surprising thing to say. "And I want to understand, like you said she would... but it h-hurts..."

Alastor felt uncomfortable at the sudden emotion and vulnerability in her voice. "Emily," he said, picking words that would hopefully ward her off, "would be a good match for her now, I think. You two were alike." 

"And what about us, down here?"

Alastor froze. He watched Charlie. But she wasn't looking at him. She was staring at her unfinished plate, tears coursing down her cheeks.

And she started sobbing uncontrollably, shaking in her seat, unable to stop herself. "We could've been—we—we... I loved all my friends. I loved e-everybody. I loved you. I wanted to love you! I wanted to..." Her words dissolved into tears. She buried her face in her arms on the table, and those tears started to form a puddle that would undoubtedly coax up more rot and mould.

He couldn't stand this. This was, somehow, despite its benignity, despite Charlie's weakness and vulnerability, worse than Vincent's proposition. 

He'd tolerated her wanting him for a while because she hadn't said it was a relationship, or feelings, or love. But somehow, her saying it in past tense felt like the closing of a casket. 

He'd hurt her so much that she didn't have any affection for him left. She only wanted company.

She didn't want him. 

(Was this how Vincent had felt? Was this how Charlie had felt when he first pulled the rug out from under her?)

So Alastor pushed his chair away from the table, stood up, and left the room.

 


 

He went upstairs to his radio tower. The floor creaked as he made for his little studio. 

He picked a record at random, practically threw it onto the turntable, and started broadcasting with the volume up high.

And he just sat back in his swivelly office chair, steepled his fingers together, and listened to a woman with a powerful alto voice singing of blue-green colours flashing, and not letting someone love her, and never getting away from the sound of her haunting voice.

 

How ironic.

Alastor thought he could still hear Charlie crying, over the song, all the way downstairs.

Notes:

He’ll never get away from the sound of the woman who loved him.

Chapter 15: nameless here forevermore

Summary:

The end goes ever on and on.

Notes:

Trigger warning for suicidal ideation, existentialist themes, and an unhappy, maybe grimdark ending.

Consider this chapter a purge of my real-world anxieties about the future and existence.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

And this is how their existences will be, forever. Alastor knows this for certain.

They will get up in the dimming mornings, they will go to bed each and every darker night. They will do the things they need to do to preoccupy themselves in the days – two square meals, eaten together; idle hobbies; finding which part of the hotel needs maintenance…. and they will survive just for the sake of surviving. Every month Charlie will have her heat cycle, and she will fuck Alastor for one night, maybe two if it’s a bad one.

Or she will tell him not to, becuase she’s hallucinating or because she’s sad, and she will take care of it herself in that incomplete and futile way, and he might linger and listen to her pain.

And then they’ll go back to just being… not friends, not lovers, not truly family. Just companions, in these lonely days.

But that companionship has dulled and chipped like an overused, ill-handled knife, and there is no sharpening stone to whet it with. It might rust. It might cut a more dangerous cut someday.

Yet they stay with each other. Because there is nothing else anymore. Nothing new to happen. Nothing to engage them. Nothing to divert them.

Nothing to entertain him.

Hell is barren. The prospect is almost terrifying to Alastor.

Not that he’ll admit it, even to himself.

 

For the meantime, as distraction, he has some temporary avenues.

The small population of sinners in the ruins of the city is still extant. Maybe one day, he will stop fucking around with murdering the same sinners over and over, this dull and uninteresting routine. Maybe he will snap, and see no more reason holding him back than to go after the last Goetia and Hellborn underlords. Maybe he’ll be tempted to make a power play and rule over something more than the pitiful last sinners.

Hell is smaller, now. Easily manageable. Conquering would be less of an achievement for him than if he’d done so while everything and everyone still stood.

It’s anticlimatic, and it’s unfair. The Radio Demon, once poised to have everything, would have to settle for a meagre few hundreds of souls, all because of the actions of others, years ago. Still doomed to never be in full control of himself or his destiny.

He wrangles with whether things would’ve been better than this, had he not saught out Lilith’s power and inherited Roo’s instead. Had he not been dutybound to attend to Charlie Morningstar. Had not been won over by her little performance on Katie Killjoy’s news bulletin. Maybe they would’ve been, maybe they wouldn’t have been.

Like he told Charlie, they may never know.

 

He wonders if Charlie’s been forgotten about, too.

Has she been thought dead, like he had been forgotten about during his seven year absence. The masses are fickle, after all; other fleeting grudges will have popped up. Skirmishes over valueless territory and property will have taken precedence instead.

Were she interested or capable, she might be in a position to have her power restored safely, with less threat from vengeful assassins.

But she is neither. She never wanted to rule, she only wanted to fawn, to be validated, to feel like a good person as she ran her silly little rehab that somehow worked, until Roo had enough of it.

Perhaps he’s the one who blames her more for the state of things, now, than any other creature in his dying realm.

 

Maybe one day angelic weapons – the last few degrading relics, their power decaying away, whether they be in his hand or someone else’s – will kill the last sinner, and all that’s left will be him, Charlie, and the hellborn.

Maybe one day the Hellborn will die out too. Birth rates are dropping, after all, or so he hears. Crops aren’t growing so well, with just a handful of Goetia left, and none of them taught how to curse the fields of Wrath with the light of the harvest moon – a moon permanently severed from their realm now. The oceans in Greed and Envy are apparently draining away, and the radio stations and podcasts are filled with panicked discourse.

The lower rings exist on the knife-edge of famine, and the upper rings will inevitably follow.

Conspiracists deny it, the learned ones grow panicked and pessimistic, the rabble remain in denial so vehemently that it’s almost amusing.

Alastor tries to keep above it all. He doesn’t need to worry about food. He’s a sinner. He can’t die to hunger or thirst, and farm produce doesn’t appeal to his palette.

But without fresh meat, he will hunger.

It won’t kill him. He’ll have to exist with the pain of it. And it won’t get better.

 

Would it kill Charlie, too, to have nothing to eat? She’s not a sinner, after all. Technically Hellborn, but a very unique one.

He has to admit it would be unfair to her. She’s been deprived of so much already. She has already been deprived of social stimulation, of the touch of so many of her loved ones. Deprived of hope. Deprived of her heart. Now she’s an automaton going through the motions in her faded clothes, and to deprive her of the last reliable form of sustinence might be what does it.

She may be deprived of her Hotel, too, soon enough. The building may still stand, but without Keekee, without its essense, without purpose… it is falling faster into disrepair. They’ve abandoned the two empty wings of the building, once full of sinners curious to see if they could get into Heaven, and when Alastor goes out and looks up, he can see more rot. More crumbling facade. Subsidence and collapse.

They – well, mostly him – only bother maintaining the rooms that they use. Charlie’s mausolem for her friends has had the lights shut off, though she will not know that. The preserved interiors may be rotting and degrading.

Sometimes Alastor wishes that she would find out. Other times, he hopes that she will never know.

Soon enough, it will all be just memory.

 

And even memories fade.

Maybe Charlie will forget her friends. Maybe she’ll forget her family. Because all she has now is him.

Maybe one day, Charlie will completely forget Vaggi’s face, and have more memories of fucking Alastor than making love with Vaggi. Lord knows at this rate she’ll acquaint herself with his body more than she ever had with Vaggi’s.

Maybe that will change the nature of their interactions again. He suspects it will. Her madness may deepen to the point of forgetfulness, like Vincent’s dementia. If the TV on the wall of the bar that Alastor will never go back to had lost the memories that had driven him to a murder-suicide attempt… Charlie might forget her grudge against Alastor for how he’d treated her when he came back.

She might forget that he was not enough for her anymore. The constant that they now have settled into might be upset.

 

Maybe she would want him to fuck her more and more before her fluctuating libido is satisfied and her heat eased. Or maybe she would get bored of it, and depression would cause her lust to recede again.

Or maybe Alastor would choose to say ‘no’ again, and Charlie will just burn herself up. How far could she go suffering through the agony of mere masturbation?

Would it actually kill her?

Would he have to kill her with his makeshift angelic knife, in self defence, if she became fully like Vincent…Vox… at his worst?

 

He doesn’t want to know the answer to that.

She is not enough for him, but there is nothing else out there. 

 

Maybe one day the Hotel will degrade beyond their ability to repair, even their essential spaces. Maybe one day it will collapse. Where will they go then? There are plenty of ruins, but none of them were their home.

Maybe one day those will vanish too, eroded into the ground.

Maybe even the seven rings will collapse.

Maybe one day entropy will finish what Roo started, and reality will simply cease to be.

But how long will that take? Baxter and Pentious had waffled on about the universe’s timescales being on the order of billions of years. Could Alastor wait that long without losing his own mind?

Boredom. Nothing but boredom. Nothing.

That might be the worst punishment of all.

 

But this is their lot in afterlife – their punishments for what they did before. The punishment for Alastor seeking power supposedly “above his station”. The punishment for Charlie’s pride and how she went against the old order. 

 

He won’t lie, in the face of that, he now considers the option of suicide. He seriously does, for the first time, weighing it against the few alternatives. Because there’s no more entertainment to be had in this world. Because Roo won. Because there is nothing left in the future, but the end. The escape of unawareness and an end to his consciousness is a more preferable option to being aware of nothing for the rest of time.

But every time he thinks of it, he’s reminded of Charlie. He still can’t stomach leaving her.

He can’t stomach her leaving him.

Even though she is no longer enough for him – does not crave his company, does not recompense him for his use, does not provide him with entertainment or joy or a challenge – she is the last constant he has in the universe.

…

He can’t stomach leaving without her.

 

Ironic. He’d told Charlie that Vaggi might have made a suicide pact with her, were she in his place. When she valued her subordinate purpose so highly he foresaw that this aftermath would break her. He imagined that her trying to coddle and comfort Charlie would’ve twisted into that form of euthanasia, to ease their purposeless suffering.

And now here he was considering that option himself.

 

He wouldn’t make a pact, though. No, any link in the chain is the weakest link, when you get to that point. So he wouldn’t discuss it with Charlie. He doesn’t know if she even has the capacity of forethought anymore to realise what eternity truly entails.

Forever’s a mighty long time, and there’s nothing else within it.

 

After enough time, maybe his mind will go, too.

He is steeled against insanity – he had to be, in his line of work. He had to let himself slip just enough, and keep his feelings at bay just enough to enjoy what he did, dancing on the knife-edge of insanity. But against the eons of time even his mental fortitude might not be enough.

He might lose his mind.

 

That frightens him. Losing control and agency to no other force than himself and the ravages of time is the greatest indignity.

He can already see that he will lose his identity as the Radio Demon, when his radio equipment can no longer be maintained, when his vinyl records are completely worn down. The technology that transfixed him as a little boy, that drove him through both life and afterlife, that propelled him to such heights, will one day cease to work.

It’s heartbreaking.

And losing his sanity on top of that? Powerless to stop it?

If he has to end things, he would want to end it before then.

 

All things must end, he supposes.

He just hadn’t ever contemplated what his own would look like.

 

But the show is now well and truly over, the curtains have been drawn.

The other actors and the audience alike have left.

 

Now it is just them to close up shop

 

and maybe

 

if it ever gets to that point

 

to be the ones

to turn out the lights.

Notes:

Well, there we are. What started as a thought exercise late last year, trying to figure out if there were a way I could get behind a ship that once wasn’t my thing, has become a finished 49K word fanfic. (And you know, I thought it was only going to be a 10–20K word affair, like the Blitzø Groundhog Day time loop fic. Never gonna grow out of underestimating just how long a fic will be, I guess.)

Thank you for bearing with me as I wrote this. I hope I managed to learn things from writing Alastor’s POV and trying to make his characterisation empathetic.


Anyway, hello if you’ve come to this fic from a certain tweet 👋 I’m here to correct the misinformation that that person and others have been spreading about me, my relationship with Alastor and Charlastor as a ship, and this fic.

Firstly, this is not a spitefic or a bashfic. It is not meant to slander Charlastor as “inherently a bad ship”. It is something that started out as a thought exercise on if there were a way I could enjoy and appreciate my NOTP. And as it turned out, that way was to do the opposite of common romantic tropes and cliches. I’m just not invested in the notion of Alastor being a charming gentleman or a genuine, caring person, and wasn’t interested in writing a fic where they had a happy ending. The idea that came to my head was a dark tragedy. It is intentionally depressing, hence why it has always been tagged and warned as a Dead Dove fanfic. I do not believe someone writing a spitefic would be concerned with tagging and warning their fic as such.

I admit I do not have a positive impression of Alastor as a character, or his relationship with and intentions regarding Charlie. I’ve said that Alastor reminds me of my emotionally abusive mother – this is true. My mother did not want an autistic child, so I had to be the ‘gifted’ autistic child for her. She showed little interest in my special interests or my emotional state, talked derogatorily about my social skills and failings in her eyes, but hyped up my talents when they were gratifying or useful to her. She has said cruel things to my face and refused to take accountability. A therapist speculated that she was a narcissist in a session she walked out of 15 minutes early.

I see those traits in how Alastor interacts with Charlie, in the pilot and the show. He openly shittalks her passion project to her face and hopes it fails, does not help her most of the time unless it benefits him, and has little care for her emotional state when she’s distressed or upset – but of course is very interested in cultivating her “potential”. Given my lived experience I don’t think it’s unreasonable to come to the conclusions that I have – that Alastor’s fondness for Charlie is rather patronising, that he sees her as beneath him in everything except her raw power, and that he does intent to exploit her for his own gain, that his teaching style is ‘tough love’ at best. I would hope that my aversion to the notion of Alastor’s care or tutorage of Charlie being benevolent or him seeing her as an equal from the get-go comes from an understandable place.

As well as his similarities with my mothers’ behaviour, the show canonically spells out Alastor wants to be the one on top controlling everyone else. I understand he is a black man who lived in the era of Jim Crowe and faced discrimination and hardship, but I don’t think that excludes Alastor from being abusive and controlling himself in the canon present. The way Hellaverse characters who are victims of the system can become oppressors and abusers themselves is I think a strong point that the shows should lean more into.

My hope in canon is to get a sense of catharsis in seeing Charlie stand up to him, assert her personhood, and in the process force him to see her as an equal.

This fic was not just an expression of my view of Alastor and Charlie’s dynamic, in a dark setting that challenges the both of them. It was also an exercise in writing something empathetically from Alastor’s point of view, with an element of unreliable narrator. I think that is a useful skill to have both for fiction/fanfiction and in reality, and I consider it practice for my future writing of Alastor and his POV in other fics, particularly A Deal Not Taken.

If anyone has good faith comments, critiques, questions, complaints, those are welcome – in fact I would prefer those be expressed directly to me instead of behind my back on a public social media site.