Chapter Text
But it seemed that did stop the worst of Charlie’s hallucinations. And contained the worst of her libido, too – her most manic wants that intruded on Alastor’s existence. And above all, her moments of inconsideration.
Now she only requested sex when she was certain – or as certain as she could be in her tenuous sanity – that she was lucid. When she absolutely needed him. Filtering out any chance of her using him for convenience or enjoyment.
She kept her overt horniness, and her craving love and affection, and missing Vaggi to herself. She let Alastor top; though he never would repeat the dominating assertion of that night when he came back. The memory of her hurt gaze, superimposed with what he knew maman’s disappointment would’ve looked like, stayed his instinct for vengeance.
In fact, Charlie didn’t close her eyes in the act anymore. She watched Alastor as he fucked her.
A part of it was disconcerting, it made him feel exposed. It reminded him of the power she held over him, could use against him, had used against him. And yet there was a seriousness in her demonic stare that told him she was obeying his command to keep herself aware. He knew she was doing it so she didn't lose herself again, and see anyone other than him in his place.
Maybe, despite the continuing unease, he appreciated that. He couldn't really tell.
Now, he sometimes remained flaccid while inside of Charlie, but it still seemed to do something for her just for him to be inside her. He preferred fingers, if possible, and tolerated that it took longer to bring her to orgasm. Sometimes, this way, she needed two climaxes before her lust was sated and she became herself again.
He found himself trimming the nails of his middle and ring fingers for these nights. He would not repeat the night of coaxing out blood-tinged vaginal secretions. That, maybe, was the biggest shame.
He observed her orgasms and the relief in them, and repeated the affirmations in his head that this meant nothing, this was only relief at the termination of her suffering for the month.
More and more he could believe it.
Thank fuck if Charlie felt like she was going, every time, she told him. And he knew not to linger, to maybe throw at her a sex toy if it was convenient for him to, fetch his robe, and hurry out into the hallway.
It may be strange, but it was the most comfortable he felt with her now. When she was respecting him and his boundaries.
But he might never completely trust her again, would never let his guard down around her again.
And yet he still found himself lingering outside her door, flirting with the edge of the boundaries he insisted on. Listening as she screamed and cried in agony, knowing whatever implement of self-manipulation she is using in there is just not enough.
She was not just a lustful creature.
She was lonely. Tortured by her own demon powers.
...
He pitied her. He didn't want to. He hated her, for what she'd done to him, for how she'd briefly controlled him. The way she'd lashed out. He made himself remember the feeling of being endangered by her, to keep a distance, to keep her on his toes.
Or maybe it was something more, something masochistic, something to emulate the way his mother would've lambasted him for shredding the inside of Charlie's core (or the way Niffty, Mimzy, might have turned her back on him had they known his actions.)
He also missed her. He missed their old closeness. Their shared love of song and showmanship; though he was trying to guide and cultivate her he enjoyed time spent with her. Her cheerful moods. The way their shared preference for pineapple and bacon on pizza rankled Angel Dust. Even though their partnership had its downs, cost him in injury, and had been at the order of Rosie Roo to cultivate her daughter – at the time, it felt good to be around her, to see her smile.
But Alastor hadn't seen her smile since that night.
He missed when she had come to him for comfort or advice. He missed when her touch had just been platonic, or familial, depending on who was asking him: Lucifer or anyone else.
... They did use to be friends, he realised. They did. Charlie had called everyone at the Hotel her friends; her family, even, but it had never grated the way Vincent Vox saying it had. And despite the heel-face and face-heel turns he pulled,
She had gravitated to him after the apocalypse not just because he was the only one left, but because she liked him. And she hadn't started out with the intention to woo him or bed him, Alastor was certain of at least that.
And now she was even more distant outside of their trysts. Oh, she stayed in the same room as him, sure, but she didn't engage with him anymore. She didn't approach him. She kept her distance.
She looked almost grey, leached and bleed dry of colour. Her red suit jackets had faded and nearly lost their colour. She now dressed in almost funeral hues, and wandered around the Hotel in teary-eyed madness. She was unaccompanied by her ghosts now, and whether that was because she was no longer projecting her hallucinations or no longer seeing them at all, Alastor couldn't tell.
There was no music from her. No ideas. Nothing.
The inspiring woman he got entangled with, the girl he once knew, was gone.
They had lost that bond they once shared completely. Because of what she did, his ego kept on telling him. But he did something violating to her too, something that lowered the standards he'd set himself even as he began his fun in the living world.
What he did might well have killed her spirit.
Alastor knew he had to do it, but his shame ran deeper than his justifying logic.
One morning – it might have been months, or years later, because time was meaningless now – they shared the breakfast table. A rare occurrence these days, with them not actively seeking each other's company anymore – but Alastor had been busy and only belatedly remembered his hunger.
He sat down on the opposite side of the table with a plate of semi-fresh meat fetched from the ailing refrigerator. Charlie had made herself some buttered toast – but with the toaster on the fritz, it was barely toasted. She ate it in slow, absent-minded bites. Alastor matched her pace.
The table was dirty, faded, unvarnished, and had borer holes in it. It hadn't been washed. Charlie was too depressed to clean, and Alastor was finding it more and more pressing to maintain his audio equipment. That took up most of his time now. It was his only tie to his proud identity left, and by whatever powers that were left in the fractured universe he would cling onto it for as long as he possibly could. But some things, like vinyl records, would wear down irreversibly, and could not be replaced.
Irreversible, like so many other deeds.
Alastor was broken out of his thoughts by Charlie's voice. "How long...?"
He glanced up at her. Her eyes were still slightly unfocused in that ever-present thousand yard stare she now had, and he would've thought she was hallucinating again, or still not of sound mind... but for the fact she repeated herself.
"How long has it been?" she asked, in a hoarse, soft voice. She was wary, but she was lucid, and it was the first time she'd initiated conversation with him for ages. "Since the old days.. when we were all..." She trailed off again.
Alastor tried to run the numbers through his head, and realised he hadn't been paying attention to the passage of time. He'd run through the combined record collections of himself and everyone who'd resided in the Hotel building twice or thrice by now. "A while. It has been... too long." Then he decided to chance a question to her. "Are you reminiscing about those days?"
She nodded lifelessly. He wondered if this was her going mute again.
"I won't deny that I do, as well. But you know we view memories with rose-tinted glasses, dear." He dwelled on the fact that he had to keep telling himself that, these days.
"Do we really?"
Charlie wasn't wrong. The past had been just as frustrating as now, filled with turmoil and injury and betrayal, but Alastor had had so much power, and Hell had had potential, and Charlie hadn't forced herself on him, and he had only tried to keep her from Roo's use and for his own instead of clawing at her insides. "I suppose not." He snorted. "It's funny."
Charlie's eyes cleared, only to level a glare at him. "What is?"
"That I came to the Hotel for a practical purpose. A duty. A solution to my old predicament" She didn't flinch at his words. That shouldn't have been surprising. "And then I went and caught feelings. Grew fond of you all. How foolish." He shook his head with a scoff.
"I know better than to ask whether you regret it," she rejoined, resentful in that quiet, defeated way. "I never understood the callousness with which you treated others – treated us..." Treated me seemed to go unspoken, if Alastor's instinct wasn't wrong. "...but now I wish I could just... not care."
Alastor did care. But he shouldn't. All this mess had been proof of that.
He finished his shavings of meat, and Charlie seemed to abandon the thought of finishing her other piece of toast. She buried her face in her hands.
"What are we?" she asked.
"I can't imagine that we're in each other's debt anymore, Charlie. I came to the Hotel to tutor you to become your mother's heir, and you used me for your gratification and your sexual wellbeing. I suppose fair's fair at the end of the world." He shrugged. "So, to answer your question, I do regret the way it all went. I consider it a shame. There was so much fun I wanted to have with you."
And he really had. Not just with the short-sighted goals of having her power on his side to humiliate and neuter Vox. Her potential was far greater than that, her immaturity would've made it entertaining to slowly break that naivety down. She had already been rooting to overturn Heaven's status-quo; his vision could have directed her to loftier goals. Overturning all of Hell's old orders, the rules barring sinners from the lower rings, the mess of Hellborn politics and entertainment and culture. Most of all, making sure that nobody would keep him down ever again.
He'd wanted to uplift her. "Now we are shackled by the consequences of our actions."
"So we're... stuck together. 'Till the end of time."
"Yes." He refused to entertain the alternatives. "But you can still look on the bright side, Charlie. Nobody else is getting their way, either." Which was true. Roo was in all likelihood trapped in the void, far away from the fragmented remains of reality that she could not piece together or derive power from.
It seemed a bitter comfort to Charlie. She raised her head, sniffled, and wiped her nose. Her eyes shone, red and watery, then she clasped her hands under her chin and looked away from him.
"I am sure Heaven has survived, though."
Another sniffle.
"Would they have have become decrepit up there, too? Not as bad as down here, of course – no..." For a moment, the entertaining idea of unredeemed sinners in Heaven gave way to the anxiety of his mother being subjected to the depravity of down here. "But perhaps the pearly gates have rusted. Now, wouldn't that be a sight? They can't have escaped upheaval up there, either."
Charlie suddenly laughed, harshly and with no humour. "I think Vaggi might have moved on from me." A surprising thing to say. "And I want to understand, like you said she would... but it h-hurts..."
Alastor felt uncomfortable at the sudden emotion and vulnerability in her voice. "Emily," he said, picking words that would hopefully ward her off, "would be a good match for her now, I think. You two were alike."
"And what about us, down here?"
Alastor froze. He watched Charlie. But she wasn't looking at him. She was staring at her unfinished plate, tears coursing down her cheeks.
And she started sobbing uncontrollably, shaking in her seat, unable to stop herself. "We could've been—we—we... I loved all my friends. I loved e-everybody. I loved you. I wanted to love you! I wanted to..." Her words dissolved into tears. She buried her face in her arms on the table, and those tears started to form a puddle that would undoubtedly coax up more rot and mould.
He couldn't stand this. This was, somehow, despite its benignity, despite Charlie's weakness and vulnerability, worse than Vincent's proposition.
He'd tolerated her wanting him for a while because she hadn't said it was a relationship, or feelings, or love. But somehow, her saying it in past tense felt like the closing of a casket.
He'd hurt her so much that she didn't have any affection for him left. She only wanted company.
She didn't want him.
(Was this how Vincent had felt? Was this how Charlie had felt when he first pulled the rug out from under her?)
So Alastor pushed his chair away from the table, stood up, and left the room.
He went upstairs to his radio tower. The floor creaked as he made for his little studio.
He picked a record at random, practically threw it onto the turntable, and started broadcasting with the volume up high.
And he just sat back in his swivelly office chair, steepled his fingers together, and listened to a woman with a powerful alto voice singing of blue-green colours flashing, and not letting someone love her, and never getting away from the sound of her haunting voice.
How ironic.
Alastor thought he could still hear Charlie crying, over the song, all the way downstairs.
