Chapter Text
So Alastor did his best to distract Charlie, detract from her hallucinations, and win back her attention.
But that inevitably involved joining in on the conversations she held, because he’d have to acknowledge her delusions to get in her good graces. He should be more active in her existence again, even if that meant playing along. That was surely the proper and polite thing to do.
(The thought that his mama would have pinched his ear and given him quite the scolding for ignoring a belle in need popped up in his mind, and he shoved it back down.)
He tried to steer her out of conversations in the way he used to, stealing her attention with an old-timey joke. And he did this more and more often. Hell, he even resorted to allowing her in the kitchen to help him with meals – supervised and guided, of course.
And yet the hallucinations wormed their way back in and stole her focus from him. She would wander from the scullery to converse with ‘Emily’, or try to pet ‘Keekee’ and then cry when her hand passed through the cat’s semitransparent image.
Talking wasn’t enough. Seeing him wasn’t enough.
Alastor realised Charlie needed his touch to ground her.
Touching her had been commonplace to him once. He’d twirled her, danced with her, manoeuvred her where he needed her to be – and that had often been away from Vaggi’s helicopter girlfriend influence, or Lucifer’s clumsy love-bombing attempts as he reconnected with his daughter. But as Charlie attempted to forge her own path and grew beyond his control and influence, they’d drifted apart. His near-death at the hands of Adam had given him a repulsion to the ‘weakness’ of attachment, and it had taken time (and a face-heel turn, then a heel-face turn) for him to open himself up to being fond of others again.
After the apocalypse, though… having to give up his hold on Husker and Niffty, and the loss of his powers, appeared to have made him relapse.
He’d found Charlie’s clinginess bothersome at first. He’d wanted to resist it.
Now, somehow, she was one of the few things he had left, and her touch and attention would be welcome, and he couldn’t get her absence off his mind.
He should be cultivating her. Not that there was nearly as much of her spirit left to cultivate, or a world to bring her to life in.
But as long as he had a basis for initiating physical contact with her (which he did), he could do it.
Now, Alastor would take her hand in his, and fold her fingers closed, if she tried to make an offering to her ghosts. He would rub a finger across her knuckles, and feel how unnaturally smooth her skin was, no fissures or pores or patterns to be found. He would twirl her into his side, or twirl her to make her look him in the eyes.
Somehow, he took extra care with his physical contact now. Not because she was fragile and faint, and certainly not because he was afraid of her (why should he be?). He just had to get her attention the right way to get what he wanted this time…
He didn’t often make time for self-reflection, for why should he doubt himself and the means through which he’d survived? But he couldn’t help remember how he’d been so eager to help the Hotel only when it seemed like an easy investment for his entertainment.
But no, Charlie had been… was… someone he had to earn.
And yet his efforts didn’t stop the slide. Charlie’s madness still consumed her… to the point that she was starting to forget herself.
A while later, the last handful of sinners still squatting in the Hotel’s degrading rooms unanimously decided to move to fresher pastures in the rooms on the upper floors.
The rooms that had used to belong to Charlie’s closest friends, her ‘found family.’
The rooms that Charlie had taken upon herself to restore to their former glory, bit by bit over the passing months, to levels of obsessive detail that would have made Niffty proud. She hadn’t taken Alastor’s advice to let go of the past, and she clearly hadn’t thrown anything out of the clutter like he’d suggested to occupy her – that was what she brought the boxes downstairs for, then, on the night he decided to indulge in one-sided conversation with ‘Husk’.
Instead, she’d done up Angel’s room exactly how it was months… no, years ago, with its pink bed, heart-shaped couch, heart-shaped throw rugs and mess of cosmetics atop an overstuffed dresser. The recreation of Cherri Bomb’s around the corner was a bit rougher, more clumsily done, and the graffiti on the wall was definitely not in Cherri’s art style (or nearly as explicit in language).
What had once been Pentious’s memorial room, and then had been converted back into a regular room once the news of his redemption was undeniable, got returned to its former purpose, with the statues and paintings the long-hatched-and-redeemed egg boi Frank had made.
Of course, Charlie had proudly showed him her work, pulled him upstairs, even, and he’d had to play along and be interested, because she was showing interest in him again. He patted her on the head as he complimented the job she’d done, and she beamed.
He didn’t tell her that her eyes looked bloodshot, and were twitching.
When she wasn’t paying attention to him, Alastor fumed to himself, and drank whiskey and smoked in private. This could not end well.
The actually extant Sinners presently inhabiting the Hotel, while they evidently appreciated Charlie’s efforts to make the room nice, had no respect for keeping the rooms in that pristine museum-like state. The next time he peered through the door of Angel’s room, the sheets were dirtied, the bed was messy, and there was a suspicious stain on one of the pinup posters of the former porn star.
And no occupant in the room, at least for the moment.
He scowled, and shut the door, and on second thought locked it (both to keep said occupant out and to keep Charlie from finding out). It might be best to keep her sanity from degrading further, he thought.
Unfortunately he neglected to check the condition of the other rooms.
Alastor was doing his rounds one morning when a sinner, bruised, bleeding, and terrified, came scrambling down the corridor, panting and whimpering.
A demon silhouette, black with swirls of red and glowing eyes and long arms with claws that scraped through the wallpaper, levitated down the corridor behind him.
The sinner looked back and shrieked in terror.
“YOU DARE DIRTY AND RUIN MY DEAR FRIEND’S ROOM LIKE THAT?!” Charlie’s voice, distorted and legion, roared. She reached from impossibly far back and snatched the sinner, reeling him in. Alastor stepped smoothly into the recess of a doorway to avoid getting hit or ran into. “THE FIRST REDEEMED SINNER? THE ONE WHO DIED FOR US?! GET THE FUCK OUT OF MY HOTEL AND DON’T COME BACK!!”
“Okay! Okay!” the hapless victim quailed. “I won’t! I promise I fucking won’t! I’m going!” And his legs were a blur before Charlie even put him back down on the ground, he hit the ground running and sprinted away. Ironically there weren’t even any elevators down the hallway in that direction, but it seemed like the poor thing might’ve been considering a dive out a window.
Charlie growled, tail lashing. “Fuck him. Fuck him!”
Alastor stepped out of the alcove. “Charlie, dear, this is all very out of character for you—”
She snarled. She didn’t even look at him; “Nobody disrespects my family like that! NOBODY!!” And with that, Charlie resumed the chase. Flames trailed behind her, and Alastor had to quickly brush a smouldering ember off of his shoulder lest it burn his jacket.
He blinked after her, eyes following the trail of blood staining the carpet that would never be cleaned by Niffty again. That didn’t stop the ghostly image of her racing along with a phantom bucket and sponge, attempting to scrub each and every red drop and puddle with glee.
He didn’t pay it mind. He had thoughts.
And feelings.
Wasn’t this was what he’d once wanted? For Charlie to lose herself, to let her darkness in and her demon side out. To violate her morals – she had wilfully injured someone who lived under her roof for sullying a selfish memorial – no, when he checked the scene of the crime afterwards, it was nothing more than shifting furniture.
She had been broken at last, and had started to tap into her true potential. Her sin. Her rage.
Why didn’t he find it entertaining?
Why?
Perhaps it had something to do with the fact that she had still ignored him…
He didn’t want her like this.
He missed the way she’d been.
Once more, Alastor redoubled his efforts to reclaim her.
He played the songs Charlie seemed to like the most or gravitate to over the gramophones and speakers in the Hotel. Judy Garland. Barbra Streisand. Even songs sung by that warbly frog puppet who had been the delight of the living world – the most popular of which was all about rainbows.
He made pancakes Lucifer-style again, much as it felt distasteful to drown the stack and accompanying apple slices in syrup and powdered sugar. He followed her around the Hotel, keeping an eye on her, keeping an eye out for the squatters who now quailed from her in fear, even as she ignored their presence.
In letting her lead, he found she’d made a clumsy grave for Keekee out in the courtyard.
So Alastor went back up to Husk’s restored room. He rummaged around in the drawers, and found a token with a cat on it and a fallen-out pin feather deep in the chest of drawers. And on the way downstairs, he found a key jammed in a freshly vacated room, still bearing Keekee’s eye in the middle of its bow.
He brought the mementos to lay on the tombstone, and he waited solemnly there until Charlie made what seemed like her daily visit. She got teary-eyed, of course.
Then she stood shoulder-to-shoulder with him, and leaned into his side.
His smile couldn’t help but widen.
They stood there together for the better part of an hour.
But still… frustratingly, every time he thought he was tugging Charlie back towards him, her hallucinations, her madness, her desperation, her attachment she just couldn’t let go of, pulled her away again.
He was no longer powerful enough to teleport through the shadows and travel upstairs and downstairs near-instantaneously. He couldn’t keep up with her anymore. He couldn’t always be there. And he had to eat and maintain his less-powerful body too.
So it happened again and again that Charlie would become lost in her hallucinations.
And it happened again and again that she would run into one of the last sinner residents staying where they shouldn’t be, and chase them out of the Hotel before holing up for days on end trying to clean up the mess they’d made in her mourning museum of empty rooms – which got even worse now they were holing up in there more and more often to hide from her.
Bit by bit, she was wittling down their numbers. They were starting to leave even without her involvement; Alastor watched individuals pack their bags and slip out in the dead of night – with a bit more haste if they noticed the glint of his eyes from where he sat on watch in the lobby.
He overheard those remaining talk about ghosts in low whispers, through the walls. They speculated that the Hotel was haunted. One mention of a distasteful series of stag flicks from the living world by a woman called Bethany, whose voice apparently bore a resemblance to Charlie’s?
The thought of Charlie following the same profession as Angel Dust had made Alastor acutely angry.
Some argued that this new Hell was miserable enough without phantoms of the past all around them. Alastor understood their point keenly, what with how he was trying to pull Charlie out of the past. A few others, the more slothful of the squatters, thought that the benefits of free shelter were worth the “haunted house vibes” the Hotel was now giving.
Would that last?
Something had to give. Alastor could feel it in his bones. His frustration was approaching breaking point.
It was not him who broke first. Nor the squatters.
It was Charlie.
One morning, one of the freeloading sinners came downstairs to steal from the kitchen one morning while Charlie was languidly grazing on her cereal at the dining table. She didn’t mind the theft. She didn’t acknowledge his presence.
And Alastor felt it unproductive to punish or even call out a sinner for it while Charlie was right there. She ignored his attention-drawing attempts in the past.
But then her hallucination-projections popped up again. ‘Baxter’, brewing some concoction up over the abandoned, non-functioning stove. ‘Cherri Bomb’, chatting up ‘Pentious’ in the corner. And ‘Vaggi’, right behind the sinner still rummaging through the refrigerator, holding a clipboard, frowning and shaking her head.
The sinner found what he was looking for, straightened up and turned around – and he jumped, and he shrieked, launching the carton of leftover jambalaya across the kitchen.
What an arm he had! He must have played baseball, or cricket, or some other bat-and-ball sport, for he threw the plastic container right out the kitchen window and across the dining room – where it bullseyed a portrait of the original Hazbins, right in Vaggi’s face. The old plastic split open and cold rice, meat, and vegetables splattered all over the painting.
“FUCK ME!” yelled the sinner, and punched the fridge door shut so hard it rebounded and smacked him again, knocking him to the floor. Alastor couldn't help but stifle a chuckle.
The sinner picked himself up and looked up at 'Vaggi', who was still scowling at the fridge with a dent in its door. “Oh, fuck off, you haunted whore-bitch!” he yelled. “I didn't get any sleep cause of that crazy ghost maid running 'round the place giggling ALL NIGHT, and now you make me lose my breakfast?! FUCK! FUCK YOU, WHOEVER YOU WERE, WHEREVER YOU COME FROM YOU ANGEL BITCH!”
Charlie’s head shot up. She dropped her spoon. She looked to her left, and saw the food soiling the painting. She looked to her right, and saw the sinner jabbing his finger in ‘Vaggi’s’ face.
She started to tremble. The spoon rattled on the dining table, rocking back and forth.
”I should’ve known. I should have known this place would never stop being Hell,” he ranted. He threw a punch at the ghost “Fuck, fucking FUCK!”
Then he picked up a knife and threw it at her.
It didn’t connect, of course, because there was nothing really there to connect with. And of course a ghost wouldn’t care. It just clattered against the tiles on the other wall, and ‘Vaggi’ just put her hands on her hips.
Charlie cared, though.
So much.
In an instant, red veins sprouted and bulged, running up and down the surface of her now-black arms. Charlie rose into the air, and she floated at speed over the table, slamming through the kitchen doors, and she passed through the ghost of Vaggi and loomed over the sinner. His eyes went wide for just a moment before, with a mighty swipe, Charlie sent him flying across the kitchen.
Alastor stood up, and followed discretely. He had to see this.
“HOW DARE YOU!!” she screamed. “HOW FUCKING DARE YOU!!”
“F-fuck,” the sinner gasped. He’d crashed headfirst into the sink, and there was a huge gash on his forehead. “Psycho cunt – get—get away from me!”
“THAT’S MY FIANCÉ!! THAT’S MY FAMILY!!” Her howls were fast becoming incoherent. “FUCK!! YOU!!”
Her hands – no, by now they were paws – lifted him and slammed him to the floor again. Her nails, now long claws, dove into the wound she’d already caused, and she ripped
and tore
and shredded.
Alastor saw bone in a record few seconds. Tendons sliced and released from their places. Gouges carved into jawbone, into sternum. Hunks of flesh dug up like clods of earth.
The sinner, gasping and spluttering as his blood entered his lungs, tried to drag himself away.
“NO – YOU DON’T GET TO GO ANYWHERE!!” Charlie roared, her tail stabbing the sinner through the leg. “I WANT JUSTICE!! FOR VAGGI!!”
The sigils and patterns in the architecture – the railings, the wallpaper, the skylight – lit up in a menacing red. The lights started to flicker. The whole building started to shake.
Voices came from upstairs. The calamity Alastor was thoroughly invested in had drawn the last squatters – and he could count them all on a single hand – from their drug-induced recluses. He heard the shock in their voices, but he couldn’t hear their words over Charlie’s constant growling.
Her continuing swipes and slashes were tearing the sinner’s arms out of their sockets
“Please,” coughed the sinner, desperately. “Please, I’m sorry, just… don’t—”
“‘SORRY’ IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH!!” Charlie roared. “YOU HAD YOUR CHANCE.”
She’d said the unthinkable.
Years ago, she’d sung about how it ‘started with sorry’ to a snake who had tried to spy on them. Now, she wouldn’t even begin to accept it, even if the sinner was only apologising to save what was left of his skin. Now she was repeating the same rhetoric that she had opposed so vehemently.
Because of a knife thrown at a hallucination.
Wasn’t that selfish?
Now the air grew hot, and Alastor had to step back as a fire whirl spun into life around Charlie. Her flaming claws still tore away at the sinner, and her exhales blew fire into his face.
The sinner ignited.
The sinner burned.
He wasn’t making any noise anymore, but he was weakly struggling and twitching, even though he was little more than a torso and barely attached legs. His skin scorched and blistered and blackened – burns rising from the first degree to the second, and then the third.
Alastor had no idea if he’d be able to reconstitute himself afterwards.
But Charlie, whether she thought the same thing or was acting in blind rage, made sure he wouldn’t.
With a mighty cry, Charlie summoned her pitchfork (its prongs tipped with blessed steel since before that battle against Adam), and ran the sinner through the chest.
There was a flash. A backdraft of flame and smoke raced out of the kitchen doors like a backdraft. Alastor had to shield his eyes and cover his mouth.
When the air cleared, the sinner was a black carbonised husk of his former self.
And Charlie was still a furious demon.
She raked through his ashen corpse for good measure, and only once he’d been strewn out of the toadish-humanoid shape he’d once been did she stop.
Then she dropped her pitchfork and stalked out of the kitchen. She wasn’t dropping her demon form, and the air still warmed the closer she got. Lesser beings would have backed away from her, or hid.
Alastor didn’t.
Her anger was not directed at him. She wasn’t noticing him. If she had been noticing him, instead of ‘Vaggi’… he was convinced she wouldn’t have broken like that.
He was amazed at her performance, but he hated the circumstances that brought it about.
Charlie stopped out in the lobby. For a moment Alastor thought she had noticed the last 5 squatters, standing aghast on the mezzanine. Was she going to attack them? Had she come to her senses?
It was the loudest silence Alastor had ever heard.
But Charlie did nothing.
Then the squatters scrambled.
“Fuck this.”
“I’m out of here. No shitting way am I staying with that monster.”
“Guess you were right after all.”
“Of course I was fucking right, I’m always right.”
“Thought she was supposed to be nice.”
“She deserves to rot here by herself.”
He watched the sinners troop past. Some dragging bags, some with bindles over their shoulder, some carrying nothing except in suspiciously bulging pockets. He caught sight of paraphernalia for making and abusing substances that Charlie had once tried to keep of the Hotel, and Vaggi had threatened to kick Angel Dust out for (or charge him a pittance of rent).
Their eyes darted at him, but then darted back to where the shadowed silhouette of the Princess of Hell, with her horns out, her eyes glowing and her For the first time, they were more afraid of Charlie than him. They seemed to use his body as a shield from her line of sight.
Charlie didn’t seem to even see them.
One final sinner flipped the bird at them as they sidled out the door – and then ran for it. The door slammed shut behind them, and the noise echoed in the empty lobby.
Charlie did nothing but growl back at the noise, in such an animalistic way.
For the first time since Angel Dust’s arrival, the Hotel was empty, save for two occupants.
Charlie left the charcoalised remains where they were on the kitchen floor. Alastor disposed of it in a dumpster about a block away.
When he returned, his eyes fell upon the hotel guest book, pages still open, gathering dust on a sideboard.
They hadn’t had use for it in years. And they wouldn’t, ever again.
Alastor took it in his hands, removed the pen from the hinge, and closed it for the last time. Then he put it in the back of the drawer, and locked the doors.
The Hazbin Hotel was closed for good now.
It took most of the day for Charlie to come down from her demon form rage.
Alastor tracked her as she roamed the building, snorting, growling, ranting to herself. She went up to the master suite, babbling to ‘Vaggi’, asking if she was alright, telling her that she’d get justice for her.
Then she seemed to be chasing ‘Niffty’ around, begging for her skills with a needle to stitch up ‘Vaggi’s’ knife wound, or to clean the jambalaya staining that portrait. But ‘Niffty’ didn’t seem to hear her, and Charlie got more and more frustrated, and her shouts and growls resumed. She relapsed on pushing away – the same thing she’d apparently done with her father and Vaggi when they interfered with her manic attempts while he was biding his time ‘imprisoned’ by Vox.
Finally, she made it back downstairs to the lobby, panting. Her tail lashed, Her shoulders were still tensed. Her horns were still out.
Alastor, still tailing her, watched from the top of the stairs as the hallucinations of the other Hazbins melted back into existence, one by one.
With the way Charlie had reacted, he thought the hallucination of Vaggi might not have showed up, not after Charlie thought she saw her stabbed.
But finally, she did.
And Charlie noticed right away.
“Vaggi,” she whimpered joyfully, melting back from her demon form to her usual self. “You survived!”
‘Vaggi’s’ mouth moved. Alastor couldn’t hear anything come out of it – was this for Charlie’s ears only? – but Charlie – oh, he saw her face crumple.
“W-what?”
Alastor crept down the stairs, straining his ears. The hallucinations hadn’t fallen silent, but their voices were muted as if coming from underwater, or like how Charlie had described panic attacks to the group therapy classes back when the Hotel was running.
Charlie glanced past Vaggi’s ghost, through the dining room and into the kitchen, and paled. The bloody aftermath of her killing the sinner, the pitchfork – Alastor hadn’t cleaned those up. Those were still there.
The hallucinations grouped together, speaking as one. Their gazes turned to harsh glares – even ‘Pentious’s’, and ‘Niffty’s’. The most friendly of the Hotel bunch, and they were now acting like they hated her. They were judging her.
Like a dial had been turned somewhere, their voices tuned back in.
“You aren’t the Charlie we knew.”
“You are ssscertainly not”
“You abandoned all the morals you said you stood for.”
“You failed your mother. What would she think of this?”
This must be Charlie externalising her internal monologue. Were she cognisant of this it would have been an interesting psychological reflection, but Charlie was not in the right mind. She looked around like a cornered animal, shaking her head. “No, no, I didn’t—I don’t— I did that for a reason cause he was attacking you Vaggi! He killed you! He threw a knife, a-and it went through your throat—”
“What knife?” ‘Vaggi’ asked bluntly. “What sinner? I wasn’t there, Charlie. You killed that guest by yourself.”
“No, no no please, no, guys I didn’t mean to, I—I—I was trying to avenge–protect—I was trying! No, please, I’m sorry! I’m sorry!” She shrunk in on herself. Her fingernails dug into her skin. And the more she cowered the closer her jury of hallucinations got.
She was on a precipice.
Alastor realised he couldn’t stand the idea of her losing herself like this: through this regression. It was self destructive, and worst of all she couldn’t help herself.
He couldn’t stand the thought of losing her to insanity, or to suicide, or to corruption.
She was one of the last things he had.
He had to step in.
And so he rushed over to her. He stepped through the hallucination-projections, getting in front of Charlie, to block her view of them. He took her hand, and he brought it to his mouth, and, gently… he kissed it.
Her skin tasted… almost waxen; it seemed a fitting match to her porcelain appearance. But there was a bitter note, something that gave the impression of the ivory keys of an old piano that hadn’t been properly cleaned in a while.
And underneath it all, he could feel the demonic, sinful energy in her body, coursing through her veins, like static electricity. Anger, starved greed and gluttony and envy. He hadn’t even taken a bite out of her, and yet this was more invigorating than the lingering aftertaste of angelic energy in each mouthful of a permakilled sinner’s carcass.
It was a gentle kiss, a brief kiss, and he thought he’d meant it to be pragmatic and platonic… but he felt alive from it.
Alastor finished the kiss, He lifted his head. “You should really look after yourself better, mon cher.”
Charlie stammered. She was blushing. Then she shook herself out of it, and she tried to protest, to look over his shoulder to where her hallucinations must’ve still been. She still wasn’t focused enough on him. “I need to—”
“No, no,” he shook his head. “Run yourself a bath, dear. I can lend you soap if you’ve run out, or perhaps some bath salts?”
“But— but I fucked—I fucked up so bad. I was so angry—”
He understood the red fog of rage well. “It’s perfectly alright, Charlie.”
“No, it’s—I—I don’t—I—I… they hate me!” He didn’t know if she was talking about the ghosts, or the former squatters… but finally, finally, she looked at him. Finally he had her undivided, watery-eyed attention. “Alastor… please don’t hate me.”
“My dear, I never could. This is what I always wanted to see you do.”
She broke. She cried into his chest.
“Good girl,” he told her, patting the top of her head gently. “Good girl.”
He glanced over his shoulder, and saw the projections of the others were still there, glaring disapprovingly. At her, or at him? He couldn’t tell.
They didn’t vanish when Charlie’s focus wasn’t on them. That was off-putting.
He leered at them.
Then he ignored them.
So in the end, Charlie gravitated back to him. As she should.
As he wanted her to.
She sought Alastor out to play board games, now. She invited him to the room where the Hotel's piano was, wanting to play songs and learn new ones. She wanted to know what he was reading, and she tried to understand the circuit diagrams he was poring over when he needed to repair the Hotel radios.
She didn’t go back to the museum of rooms of their former compatriots.
She brought him a bunch of Furbys, buried in a box of toys from one of the former therapy rooms, and he made an organ out of them, and that made her laugh for the first time in… how long? A long, long time. She seemed to surprise herself with the sound of it.
It reminded him how endearing she could be.
As a final test, Alastor left Charlie alone downstairs, to see if she’d come find him in his radio tower.
And she did. She sought him out minutes later, anxious and fidgeting.
“Al,” she whimpered, and without asking, wrapped her arms around him and, with no room to sit next to him, sat on his lap.
And he didn’t dislike it.
He thought he saw her hallucinations of Vaggi, Lucifer, and faceless Lilith at the door to his studio out of the corner of his eye, but he didn’t care. Charlie was ignoring them, and that was what’s important.
So he let her fall asleep in his lap, and stroked her hair as he considered the melody of Heartaches by Al Bowlly.
He wasn’t addicted to or dependant on her, no, not in the slightest. He was in control. But he did crave this, he acknowledged. And he was indulging that craving. He didn’t see what was so wrong with that.
He craved the power he had over the others, even if they were just a memory. He knew how strong Charlie loved, how much she mourned. To win her affections from them proved he was strong.
He may have lost his physical powers, but he was still powerful where it had always counted: his smarts, his willpower. More powerful than Charlie’s hallucinations. Powerful enough to ground her from her demon form.
Powerful enough for Charlie to want him.
It was nice to be wanted.
It was nice to be wanted back.
Of his own violation, Alastor gently took Charlie’s hand, raised it to his mouth, and kissed it again.
