Chapter Text
The stragglers at the hotel didn’t stay for redemption anymore, because of course they didn't. There were no meals served (though Charlie would, on occasion, drop small parcels of food outside the doors of the occupied rooms), there were no activities planned. Rarely did they come out to socialise with the Princess of Hell (though she did try to remember their faces if she bumped into one of them in the corridors) or the Radio Demon.
They were just squatters. They came and they went and they did as they pleased.
One room hosted a drug den, another was being used to make moonshine, another was hotboxed so much by its occupant that Alastor could smell the giggle smoke a whole floor up on the other side of the building. Still others engaged in carnal acts, or mended and invented firearms out of the scraps that could still be found, and there was supposedly a gambling ring around bug fighting of all things – which he certainly believed; after years of Niffty’s pest control and Baxter’s experimentation the bugs were aggressive and potent enough.
It seemed that everywhere he looked in this building, there were echoes of the original hotel residents.
None of this was anything Charlie would have been pleased with, were she still her old self. And Vaggi? Dear Vaggi, if she were still here, she would have been furious at the debauchery. Maybe frustrated with Charlie’s apathy to it. Maybe she would have argued with Charlie after this long a depression. Maybe she would have joined her in it.
If Alastor killed them, for good, with the shard of holy steel he now possessed, he’d be doing the Hotel a service, really.
But for now, no. It would just not do to squander the very finite number of potential victims he had left.
So he just let them be, unless they crossed his path in the wrong way, and then he would kill them or maim them in the usual way, with a usual, unblessed weapon. Sometimes it would frighten the sinner away from the Hotel once they’d reconstituted. Other times they just went crawling back to their room and carried on with their depravity.
(Then there was that one fellow who seemed to get off to being killed.)
If Charlie found out about it, he could plead self-defence.
…
Speaking of Charlie.
Since the assassination attempt, things between them had stagnated for a while. She had indeed refused to go out in his company… though he was sure she was using her portal-creating skills to circumvent him. Which aggravated him,
Ah well. He was still going on his hunts out in the ruined streets, behind her back, at the dead of night. They both could keep their secrets.
But eventually, maybe as a result of some unsavoury experience he wasn’t privy to, or maybe from her sheer need for company, she had relented and asked him if he could come with her again. And it made him feel pleased, perversely, so much so that he got frustrated with himself for it.
Was it just the fact she was admitting he was right? Was he getting weak and sentimental (no friends in Hell, after all)?
Or did he just want her?
He did concede to her pacifist notions, though. Breaking up the monotony of strolling the broken boulevards of Pentagram City felt very much called for, at any rate.
So he took her on hikes. He may have been born on the bayou, but he could manage an invigorating trail through the rugged mountain wastelands encircling the crater of Pentagram City. She kept pace with him easily enough, with her limitless antichrist energy, though her clumsiness led to a few stumbles and scrabbles and slips on the rocky terrain.
They made it to the summit of the highest remaining peak together. From up here, in the dark, even the ruins of the city and the scattered lights of the shantytowns looked almost beautiful. Alastor watched Charlie watch them, and the silent tears that rolled down her cheeks seemed bearable for her.
Charlie may have been broken, but she was still Charlie Morningstar. She still had songs in her, and Alastor could coax them out of her. He’d hum as they went on their hikes, and eventually, she would join in. He taught her how to play the blues on piano. He paused in his broadcasts, or in his reading, or whatever he was doing at the time, when she started to sing of her own accord; not the snippets of sniffling laments but more mature melancholy tunes.
He cooked for her, and tried to rotate a variety of the creole cuisine of his life (at least what he could remember, that wasn’t meat-based) each day. One day, when she asked for it, he sucked up his pride and tried to make pancakes the way Lucifer had. She seemed to enjoy it… but he was dissatisfied with them.
He still made pancakes for her, after that. He just switched to making them Cajun style.
And he made sure to feed Keekee too. The poor old hotel cat was very much slowing up now, she looked worse than Husker had on his bad days. She slept a lot, she couldn’t levitate anymore and walked with a limp, and her big eye was getting cloudy with a cataract. She sought out Charlie’s company a lot, but sometimes she would find her way to Alastor and bunt his legs while he was recording another broadcast, or pursuing the surviving books in the Hotel library.
That is, when she wasn’t bumping into the legs of a chair or table.
He did think that fresh meat ought to do her good; after all, she was a cat; a carnivore.
And when she was done eating – she rarely finished her bowl anymore – he would pick her up and carry her to wherever Charlie was.
Charlie got teary-eyed when Alastor did that. She said it meant so much that he was showing he could care. And when he tried to brush it off, she’d cuddle up to his side with purposeful affection.
He still didn’t know how he felt about that. He’d rather she not rely on his touch so much. But it was routine now. On the days when she hadn’t, something had felt… empty inside him.
So he tolerated her leaning against him for a few seconds longer each time.
It was approaching one year since Roo brought about the end times.
He didn’t need to check any calendar; he could tell from Charlie’s demeanour. Her depression returned, she lingered at the still-covered portraits of her parents and her lost friends. She stopped going out, and looking out the window at the empty sky made her cry again.
Suddenly, Alastor’s physical presence, and his music, and his charm, wasn’t enough to keep her buoyed up.
That rankled him.
This wasn’t like before, he told himself as he waited outside Charlie’s room, listening to her muffled sobs from within. Charlie had noone else to turn to now. Lucifer wasn’t here to interfere, with his frankly juvenile competitive streak. Lilith wasn’t here to give orders. Vaggi wasn’t here to coddle and take up all Charlie’s time.
Alastor had Charlie all to himself.
Except she kept herself from him—
He snarled, and went stalking through the corridors. Curse propriety. Curse his humanity. Curse whatever it was that was drawing him to Charlie when there was nothing he could get from her anymore…
A warm body bumped into him. Then a hand tapped him on the rear. “‘Ey, watch where you’re goin’, babes.”
Nothing except… a reaction.
His hand slipped inside his jacket; not to check for being pickpocketed, but to reach for the holy steel shard. “How disrespectful.”
“What? Can’t a doll appreciate a pretty twink such as yourself, and see if you really don’t have that tail—WHOA WHAT THE SHITTING FUCK—!!”
The makeshift blade sliced into her abdomen like butter, and the sinner, tall and lean and insect-like, yelped as the qualities of the blessed steel burned and entered her veins like venom. Thinking quickly took the chance to shove her into the nearest unlocked room, through the door as it opened, before any of her blood could touch the carpeted floor out in the corridor.
“MOTHER-FUCK!!” The sinner clearly wanted to fight back, and she certainly had enough limbs to do so, but the blessedness in her unholy body was weakening her fast. Alastor stood over her, fending off her kicks and punches, and got to work carving her up and gutting her, making sure to make enough progress before she expired.
As he dragged her entrails out of her body, it occurred to him that she bore quite the similarity to Angel Dust, in spirit and demeanour.
A punch to his cheek, despite being feeble, managed to detract him from his task for a moment, and then the sinner’s knee caught him in the crotch. He’d already freed her of her genitalia, she seemed to want to return the favour.
Perhaps she reminded him of Valentino more, with his hands-on fighting style.
Or Vox.
Alastor gave her no sign of the annoying pain she’d inflicted on him, and tore open her jugular with his teeth.
“Alastor?”
“Mmm, yes, dear?”
Charlie, wearing her PJs and carrying Keekee, shuffled up to the dining room table. “Where’s… the woman who was staying in Room 2810?”
Alastor took a sip his mug of blood-spiked coffee. “Who?”
“You know, the… woman! With the mandibles and the fuzzy antenna-things. Who never wore a shirt!”
“Ah, yes! Her!” He took another sip. “Haven’t the foggiest. Did you consider she might have checked out?”
“Noone uses the guest book anymore, Al.” She gently placed Keekee on the floor when the old cat squirmed. “And I checked, and… the key’s still in her door.”
“Hm. Well, maybe she’s like our dear old friend Anthony, working the streets.” He smiled at her deceptively. “Nothing you need to worry about, Charlie. I’m sure she’s where he’s supposed to be.”
Charlie nodded mutely, tears welling up in her eyes again. She turned and retreated to the isolation of her bedroom.
That said and done, Alastor took the bowlful of the sinner’s remains, raw and still juicy, from underneath the tablecloth and put it on the floor next to Keekee. It ought to be quite the treat for her. The hint of blessedness in the meat gave it quite the kick, if he did say so himself.
Every couple of days or so, he would target another sinner. Just one at a time.
He made the effort to be random, to allay suspicion, but most of this batch of final Hotel residents were either mentally addled or inebriated enough to not pay attention. So this secrecy was just for Charlie’s sake, to keep stringing her along.
First went the mechanic, trying to rebuild their armed and armoured motorcycle; so fixated on their work were they that they didn’t notice him creeping up behind them until it was too late. Then the first of the stoners; a gentle, slothful soul, so addled by his smoking that his fellows just watched Alastor slaughter him with no more than a disappointed “Dude, not cool.”
He tried to pick those who he assumed were the most moral. The most kind, or the least sinful. The ones who would’ve seemed closest to redemption to Charlie, who thanked her for the food she brought up to them. The ruse had to be convincing.
It took about three or four sinners going missing for it to click for her, and for her to take the bait.
Alastor had expected her cautious hope to grow and flower into jubilation; the belle just could not keep her expectations realistic. Soon she was totally convinced that Heaven had somehow fixed the universe, and that redemption for sinners was possible once more.
He enjoyed seeing the hope flooding into her face, making her less pale and pallid. He chuckled at the way she dragged a telescope up to her balcony, and scanned the skies for any sign of Heaven.
He resented the way she started talking to the portrait of Vaggi; asking questions, telling her the scant details she’d observed about the “new arrivals” as if her almost-fiancee would hear her and be able to recognise them.
But Alastor didn’t expect Charlie to rush up to him one day, panicked and hyperventilating, while he was in the middle of breakfast.
“You might get redeemed too,” she blurted out in a rush.
He startled, then snorted. “I hardly think so, dear—”
“No, no, I’m serious! You’ve been doing better recently, Alastor, you’ve been doing virtuous acts, taking care of Keekee and being selfless and… and if Heaven’s only able to receive sinners now but they can’t communicate to us yet…” Tears filled her eyes. “Alastor, I need you to sin.”
He blinked at her. “I beg your pardon?”
“Just a little! Just a little bit of sin!” She wrung her hands anxiously. “Like, shoplifting, or jaywalking, or—or kicking someone in the shins!”
Such minor, improper things? He may be a serial killer, but he had standards. Besides, kicking shins had been Niffty’s thing. “But Charlie, why ever should I do that?”
“I need you to stay here with me!” Charlie just about shrieked. “I can’t lose you too, Al!”
“How selfish of you.” He leered at the idea of thinking he was worthy of redemption, but it was also very interesting that she was breaking her values of giving everyone a second chance. This was something to probe at. “Why do you want to keep me here?” What do you need out of me so badly?
“No, I—I—I want you to stay because you’re my last friend!”
Friends? The memory of Vox’s pitiful face, decades old, flashed in front of his eyes. Friendship leveraged as a means to an end. “Wrong answer. Try again. Why should I stay? And don’t tell me ‘you’re all I have left’. I want to know why you want me. Pick your words wisely, now.”
Charlie took several deep breaths, eyes glancing up to the ceiling as she thought. “You helped make the Hotel what it is – I mean, what it was,” she said, shakily. “You fought by my side, you fought for me. You were there for nearly all that the Hotel accomplished – what I’m trying to say is you’re someone important in my life.” She was crying now; she hiccuped. “Vaggi’s not here anymore. My parents are gone. I just – I need someone, Alastor.”
Silence, other than the sound of her little sobs. Alastor dwelled in it, considering Charlie’s words.
Then, softly, he said: “Alright. If you insist. I’ll do what I can to stay.” He couldn’t even let the irony slip into his tone of voice.
Her sobs intensified with relief, and she hugged him. He allowed it.
Later, as he ran another radio broadcast and set ‘Little White Lies’ playing across the airwaves, Charlie invited herself into his studio, and sat by his side. She was still crying, it seemed.
“I’m sorry,” she whispered. “You said I was being selfish, and I think you were right, I’m denying you the chance to see Niffty, Husk, your mother again…”
“Trust me, my dear,” he replied easily, “there’s no offence taken. I can’t ignore the command of a princess, now, can I? And I do find you agreeable…” no, that wasn’t a strong enough word. “…enjoyable company.”
She leaned into his side again. She didn’t seem to have any words left to say, she just hummed along to the tune of the strings and trumpets playing from his mixing desk.
A part of him felt… warm, now he’d said it out loud. Charlie was enjoyable company, when she was in the mood. And even when she wasn’t… he found that agreeable. It was the truth. She still compelled him, and maybe there was something to be learned in her evolving responses and reactions, thanks to the depressed funk that Roo’s apocalypse had brought upon her.
That she wanted his company too, seemingly just for the sake of it… pleased him too.
But as Clare Hanlon began to warble about ‘Heaven being in someone’s eyes’… he felt something approximating guilt.
When Alastor killed his next victim out of the remaining Hotel population, it didn’t feel satisfying. It twisted his gut. It felt like taking candy from a baby – there was no challenge in this. Nothing for him to be proud of. He was only doing this to hurt Charlie.
He didn’t stop, though.
And as he minced up the remains of the plucky little chemist, he noticed Keekee retch and vomit onto the carpet. He realised that she’d been looking even more poorly since he introduced her to the diet of double-killed sinner meat.
Tonight, she’d left her dish nearly entirely uneaten.
Charlie found out what Alastor was doing, of course, eventually.
He let her find out. He knew how not to be sloppy and to take good care of the remains of his victims, so well that it was ingrained habit for him. To be sloppy, for him to slip up, was a wilful choice.
And why pull a prank if you didn’t get to see your victim when the rug was pulled out from under them?
Alastor watched and smiled as she stormed up to him, holding the severed arm from the garbage dumpsters at arms length. He let her demand answers, let her horrified yells wash over him harmlessly. He showed her the murder weapon; shard of the angelic rifle’s barrel, sharpened to a point and caked with burnt-in blood.
He watched the hurt and betrayal flood her face. He caught the severed limb when she threw it at him, and he watched as she stormed away upstairs.
She didn’t talk to him for days. She actively avoided him, even.
At first he was disappointed. Her demon form hadn’t even flared up this time; no, it had faded away the minute he confessed. Was she really still clinging to her unneeded morality?
Then he was vindicated; she still wouldn’t kick him out, no matter what he did. He still had security, here, at the Hotel.
Then he was curious; she’d never avoided him for this long.
…
Then he realised he felt empty, without her company.
After nearly a week, he had to do something about that.
But there was no way to corner Charlie or try to approach her when she was still dodging him, when she’d locked him out of her room. He knew where she’d been (especially her attempts at cooking for herself that had reduced the Hotel kitchen to one functional stove), but not where she was at the moment.
Eventually, he found Keekee limping down the corridor, shivering and caterwauling miserably. There was a particular note of despair in her meows. Whatever she was searching for, whoever she was calling for, she could no longer see. Her degrading eyesight had reached the point of complete blindness.
Alastor stooped and picked her up. In his arms, she remained tense.
He could hazard a guess as to who she was seeking out; the same person that he was.
Still carrying her, he went upstairs to Charlie’s door. He didn’t knock, he tested the doorhandle like he always did. Maybe she’d left it unlocked, or maybe Keekee still had enough of an aura emanating from her frail body that she could still unlock doors just by being near them – either way, it opened, and Alastor entered.
Charlie was sitting in bed like an invalid, knees tucked to her chin. When she saw him, she scowled, but her gaze softened when she saw Keekee, and whatever command to get out had been on her lips faded away. Alastor didn’t say anything, either.
He just approached her, and handed her the old cat, and Charlie took her, straightening her legs so that Keekee could rest there. The cat mewed, butted her head against Charlie’s hand, and curled up delicately in her lap, making soft, croaky purrs as Charlie petted her.
Alastor pulled up an armchair and sat, facing Charlie, waiting for when she was ready to talk to him.
“You tricked me.”
“I did.”
“That was really cruel, Alastor.”
“It was.” He couldn’t deny it. “But Charlie… my dear, why are you still surprised? We have known each other for so long now.”
“I thought you were my friend,” Charlie hissed. “I thought you wouldn’t do that to me.”
‘There are no friends in Hell’, felt too cruel to say. And maybe it was a lie. He did see her as… something. Not the way Vox saw friends as stepping stones to power and influence, not in the way that she saw him as someone to be emotionally dependant on… but he was fond of her. If that was friendship, then yes, he saw her as a friend.
“Why should friendship and a bit of cruelty be mutually exclusive?” he asked, genuinely.
She growled at him. “Of course. Like you kept Husk on a leash and still thought you could be all chummy with him, when you physically abused—”
“I never did any such thing! Never actually laid a hand on him! Only a little scare, a little tug, every now and then.”
“I’d never dream of even doing that to someone I loved—!”
“Of course not,” he said mildly. “Accidental hurt was always more your speed.”
Charlie flinched from that. He knew that was a weak point of hers. She’d never forgiven herself for every time she’d inadvertently gotten one of her friends upset with her; she’d only distracted herself from it.
This girl just could not move on when she needed to for her own sake.
He needed to guide her into that, and maybe now was the right time to deconstruct these delusional notions of hers that she could fix the end of the world.
“But you did do something nice for Husk,” Charlie said, out of the blue, meeting his eyes again. “And Niffty. You freed them and let them go to Heaven, in the end.”
Alastor remained silent.
“Do you miss them?” she asked, misty-eyed.
He did. He didn’t find their absences unbearable, he could go on without them, but it would have been pleasant to tease Husker over a whiskey, or enjoy hearing Niffty’s rivetingly bizarre flow of consciousness, again. He nodded.
“I miss everybody,” Charlie whined. “I really wish… I just wanted to, maybe, see them again. I know I can’t be redeemed… but maybe they’d have let me visit again. Or just let me know that everyone’s doing okay up there. That’s why your bullshit practical joke hurts so much…” Her tears fell, and her voice rose to a wail. “Redemption is possible! I proved you and everyone else wrong! I know you’re capable of caring, and yet you still go and do something like that…”
“Charlie,” said Alastor, gravely; the smile nearly gone from his face. “You know redemption is no longer possible. You must accept that. I accepted that I did not want it while I were still alive, for I knew I was a lost cause from the very first kill I made.” Longer than that. From the moment he was old enough to understand that the colour of his skin was a curse; not a literal one, but a curse in how white folk would treat him, and that he would never free himself from that if he tried to play their game their way.
His mother had eased him through that lesson. Now, he knew she was the one member of his blood family who’d deserved to enter the Pearly Gates. But even if he could bear the thought of a puerile, stiflingly saccharine afterlife… he did want to spare Mama the grief of knowing what he’d become after he buried her.
“You don’t feel remorse?”
“I do not. I embraced my fate, and reclaimed my future.”
Charlie didn’t say anything for a few minutes. “Vaggi felt remorse. For what she did while she was an Exorcist. She tried to do better when she was with me, and she succeeded. She redeemed herself.” And she looked back up at Alastor, eyes huge and watery. “If we’re going to be together for the rest of eternity… I want you to be better. Someone I can be proud of. Someone I can lo—” She caught herself, looking looked startled at what she must have been about to say. She gulped down air, fighting back the sobs.
“Perhaps it is better to be opposites,” Alastor mused. He’d ignore that cut-off statement of hers. “To balance each other out, or meet in the middle. After all, it’s what you and Vaggi did. She was unlike you in so many ways. Especially temperament, and look how well you two got along.” He raised a claw and gestured at her finger, where she still wore the promise ring appropriated from her mother’s jewellery collection. “But she didn’t challenge you to do better, to refine your beliefs. Think about it. Were she here in my place, would you be any better off? I daresay she would also have killed that imp for his assassination attempt.”
”She would have cared about what I thought, about what I was going through!” Charlie insisted. “She would have listened if I asked her to show mercy to that—Blitzo—Blitz—him! I would have felt better with her, because she wouldn’t prank me like you have! I would have been able to look after the sinners you killed, with her by my side—“
“Or would you two have dragged each other down into despair from the ending of your shared dream? Maybe even made a suicide pact? Vaggi put all her self worth into your redemption scheme; how do you know she might not have cracked worse than you now that Heaven is closed off to us for good?” Alastor shrugged as he let his words sink in. “We shall never know, for I am here instead of her, and maybe the grass on the other side is not as green as you think it might be. I’ll repeat myself: Redemption is no longer possible, and you won’t see your friends or your lover again.”
He leaned closer. “I want to hear you admit it, Charlie.”
She swallowed, nodded tearfully, and, like she had long ago, on that stage, with Vox ready to put his dirty hands on her shoulders, repeated what he’d asked her too. “It’s not p-possible anymore…” she whimpered. And there was a sense of finality in how she said it.
Satisfied, Alastor stood up. “Let go of it, Charlie. Adapt to this reality; don’t cling to the old. It doesn’t do you any good to dwell on what has been.” And he left the room, leaving her still in bed, still idly stroking the motionless furry body in her lap.
He didn’t tell her that Keekee had stopped breathing and her heart had stopped beating minutes ago.
She would figure that out soon enough.
