Work Text:
Everyone had gathered in front of the classroom of Dark arts. Neville’s 7th year had begun only a week ago, and the classroom already felt empty without Harry, Ron, and Hermione. The mood across the castle grim, with the second Wizarding war hanging overhead.
But he didn't get that much time to think about any of that, as Amycus Carrow came into the room. His presence immediately laid all the students silent as their faces turned towards him.
“Hello students, today we will be practicing the cruciatus curse.” As he spoke he grabbed his wand from the holster on his belt, “The classroom has already been prepared, you will be practicing on the students we have caught misbehaving over the course of the previous week. Before trying the spell, please remember what we've learned the past week, as for this spell the fact of meaning it, is just as- if not more important than knowing both the pronunciation and wand movement.” As he finished talking he tapped his wand on the doorknob, opening the door using a spell —Neville assumed it was alohomora, but he wasn’t sure— without speaking a word.
The students walked into the classroom, with the Slytherins up front, of course they were. Neville walked in last, shocked at what he saw as students, ranging from first all the way to sixth years, and even one from seventh —a boy from Hufflepuff he had never talked with, but recognized as being in some of his classes— bound up in the room. All of them were bound by their ankles to the ground with chains, while similar chains were attached to their wrists and the ceiling, just long enough for them to sit, but they seemed to be unable to get in any kind of actually comfortable position.
Crabbe was the first to step forward, he approached a nearby student, pointing his wand at the student he said “Crucio!”. Just like that, the screams of the young girl from Ravenclaw filled the room as Neville was being forced to watch in horror.
The rest of the students followed his example one by one as they started to notice Professor Carrow was getting rather impatient. Taking out their wands they all took place in front of a different student, pointing their wands and saying the incantation, moving their wand, all exactly as Carrow had thought them so eagerly. The room was quickly filled with many ear-piercing screams. Not everyone did as well, as for some the curse would stop working after only a couple of seconds, while others lasted longer, but they would all keep trying again and again, scared to discover what the professor would do to them if they didn't.
All but Neville, who hadn't moved an inch since Crabbe spoke the spell. He felt like he had stood there for ages already, surrounded by those screams. All he could think of were his parents, who —due to this exact sick spell— had gone insane. In his mind, he saw his parents in St. Mungos hospital, he could see their faces clear as day in his mind with how often they had visited the hospital growing up. They hadn't spoken in years because of the spell, it had driven them crazy. Was he really going to risk doing that to someone?
While he was sunken away in his own thoughts, his own imagination of what that’d look like, the Professor had noticed he was the only one not practicing. Approaching Neville as he spoke: “Mr. Longbottom, you should get to practicing the spell as I told everyone to. You are no exception.”
“No,” Neville said firmly, he wasn't going to do it. He wanted to protect the student who impossibly did anything bad enough to deserve this, knowing that if he didn't, he would never be able to let go of the guilt. Nobody deserved that fate, not even the biggest trouble-makers.
“No?” Carrow repeated his words, as to make sure he heard that correct. He looked dead serious as he approached Neville, keeping his face directly in front of his. “You think you can disobey your professor?”
“Yes professor.” He said, appearing way more calm than he actually felt.
“And why is that?”
“Because I don't believe they deserve this, professor.”
“Oh, you don't.” He stepped back, walking across the room with his hands gesturing for the students to stop. So they did, all lowered their wand and looked at Neville, probably happy they got to take a break from executing such torture upon what could just be their friends, or their siblings.
“Let's show the class what happens when people try to disobey their professor.” Then, he quickly pointed his wand, yelling “Crucio!” before Neville even had time to grab his wand and react.
Neville immediately fell to the ground. Violently moving around as unbearable pain filled his body. It felt like white-hot knives were piercing every inch of his body, hitting every wrong nerve, making him scream as loudly as his own throat allowed him to.
Carrow didn't stop, he kept the spell intact longer than Neville felt like he would be able to handle, longer than most of his classmates had been able to. It was clear he had experience with the spell, and oh if he meant it? He clearly did.
Neville could already feel himself going crazy, ending up like his parents. So much potential wasted because a professor wanted him to do this. Especially now he felt like he understood why this curse was unforgivable even better than before.
When he finally stopped, Neville tried to stand up, but failed dizziness clouding his head. He fell right back onto the ground, and decided to stay there for as long as Carrow would allow him to.
Then Carrow spoke to the students who had all watched in absolute horror: “And that, students, is what will happen to you if you try to disobey the commands of your professor. Now continue particing!”
