Actions

Work Header

Bury Me at Stark's Pond

Summary:

Seven years have passed since Firkle Smith's drowning at Stark's Pond.

After the case is reopened and hastily ruled as an accident, high-school senior Henrietta Biggle isn't convinced. Certain that someone else in South Park must know something further about—or be responsible for—Firkle's death, she forces her reluctant best friend, Kenny McCormick, to come to her aid in piecing together the secrets behind the tragedy.

However, unearthing the timeline of events may include unearthing painful memories surrounding the separation of the Goths. Between Michael's reluctance to open up about the mysterious fallout of his and Pete Thelman's friendship, and Pete's own despondency towards the state of their old friend group, it is unclear as to if reuniting the group is even worth it, much less possible.

Notes:

All depictions of mental health/illness as well as societal commentaries originate both from my own experiences, which I have attempted to translate into writing as realistically as possible. Not every individual with a mental health condition will behave in the ways depicted in this fic, nor will everyone's experiences with be the same: this is just one perspective out of thousands of possibilities. Please take this into account while reading.

NOTE: This was originally posted on my AO3 account under a different username. Major alterations have been made to the story over the years, and those amendments will be made alongside the original, unfinished fanfic that was posted on AO3 when the site goes back up. In other words, this fanfic will be posted on both AO3 as well as on here. Thank you!

Chapter 1

Notes:

Important notices will be listed at the beginning of every chapter, while the more fun notes and commentary will be saved for the end.

TW/CW: Detailed exploration of grief and prolonged bereavement, discussions around child death.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

HENRIETTA

- ONE WEEK AFTER FIRKLE’S DEATH -

It was a closed casket. The soft, warm glow of the pillar candles decorating the chapel hall aimed to provide a comforting ambience, yet Henrietta couldn’t tear her eyes from the fogged over, stained-glass windows decorating the walls of the church. Raindrops pitted themselves against the panes, a faint orchestra of thuds striking against the glass, then slithering their way down, leaving only deep streaks of water behind. The windows’ mere presence only served to make the candles, the abundant flowers, the collages of photos that hung overhead—in an instant, they had become all that much more artificial. And it wasn’t because the rain made her depressed, nor teary-eyed, or any of that cliché shit, but because all Henrietta could think about was how—if this were any other day—her and her friends would sit together, out in that very rain, and ramble on and on about life, whether that be their shared hatred for it or the occasional admittance that, even for them, there was some sort of comfort that could be found. It didn’t matter if their makeup got smudged, or if it flattened their perfectly crafted hair, because all that mattered was the four of them being in their element: together.

It had begun to sink in that that would never happen again.

Henrietta stared forward, refusing to even glance around the room and risk making eye contact with anyone. She could feel her skin tingling from the weight of Michael’s eyes boring into her. He sat beside her, close enough to show some extension of camaraderie, but not too close as to where it appeared as though they were actually friends. Pete mimicked the same pose on the other side of Michael; Henrietta could discern—from all the time that they spent together—that Pete, too, refused to make eye contact with either of them. The goths wanted it to seem as though they tolerated each other at best, yet, at their worst, were “too nonconformist” to ever truly be friends with each other.

While Henrietta was old enough to understand their bonds were closer than that, she still refused for any outsider to believe anything that could hint to the contrary.

Father Maxi’s voice drifted through the pews, wedging itself between Henrietta and her thoughts, refusing to let her slip away into this escapist realm she had begun living in. She shifted in her seat as these “heartfelt” sentiments came spilling from Father Maxi’s mouth: that Firkle was a ‘good child,’ a ‘good boy (despite his quirks),’ and a ‘good kid’ who was so young when he had (“mistakenly”) fallen into that lake.

Even at her age, Henrietta struggled to wrap her mind around the delineation between what a ‘good child’ and a ‘bad child’ was. She tried to understand what Father Maxi’s perspective may have been while preparing his speech, but she had overheard his other sermons before, including his tirades on how every member of South Park ‘were all sinners, and would, therefore, be banished into the lake of fire.’ In the wake of Firkle’s death, this sentiment appeared to have vanished overnight, because here he was, just as emotional as all those present with him seemed to be. If ‘good’ and ‘bad’ were opposite ends of the same spectrum, yet could change over the course of a single night, then what purpose did they serve? Why did they only mourn ‘good kids,’ the ones who “deserved” to be remembered, and what did such a delineation even mean? Henrietta struggled to understand, but what she could understand, greater than anyone else here ever could, was that they were all wrong about how Firkle had passed.

Henrietta knew Firkle well enough to know he would never make the mistake of falling into a lake just to drown, nor would he ever throw everything away by intentionally making such a choice. Firkle wasn’t careless enough to do that, especially when—behind all the makeup and the clothes and the faux desires he expressed for the sweet release of death—Henrietta knew Firkle loved life. He had a strange way of showing it, often hidden behind his proclivity for violence or the distance even he kept with his fellow goths, but Henrietta knew it was there. Somewhere, deep inside, Firkle loved his friends. He couldn't fathom ever hurting them in this way, even if by mistake.

“…Before we commence with the burial of this young, innocent soul,” Father Maxi said, “our dear friend, Michael, has offered to come up and share a few words about Firkle Smith, and the positive impact he has had on all of our lives.” 

From the corner of her eye, Henrietta watched as Michael fumbled with the paper in his hands. He had always served as the representative of their group, taking on the role of leader whenever necessary; Henrietta knew he hated the attention he garnered as a result. Michael had never shared this thought with her aloud, with her observances of such moments being relegated to slight downturns in the corners of his mouth, or a certain reluctance in his inflections that hadn’t been there moments before. Henrietta concluded it was because Michael didn’t want anyone else to take on the burdens he had to. She refused to say it out loud, but she admired him for it.

The rest of the room turned to Michael as he stood. He locked eyes with Henrietta, which only served to make her heart ache in that disgusting, desperate show of grief she’d been wanting to avoid, before turning his back on her, approaching the podium at the front of the chapel. Father Maxi gave a light nod to Michael, stepping aside and allowing him to take center stage next to Firkle’s coffin. Firkle’s coffin. Those words sitting next to each other would never feel right.

Silence continued to infest the room, settling beneath the floorboards and within the cracks of the walls. It nestled its way even further into Henrietta’s heart, which had been left vulnerable due to Michael’s glancing, weighing her down heavily. Just as the silence began to suffocate her, however, Michael finally spoke.

“…I’m not a person who usually gives speeches,” Michael started; despite him only being a year older than her and Pete, Henrietta always viewed him as much more mature and wiser than the aforementioned two, “...but Firkle was one of the closest friends I had here in South Park, even if…if a part of me doesn’t want to say that. I speak on behalf of our entire friend group when I say that…Henrietta and Pete, that is.”

Henrietta glanced over to Pete, who was already giving her the same look. Without as much as a verbal acknowledgement, the two moved closer. Henrietta could feel the weight Pete was carrying in that moment, with a somber tenderness festering within her that she was sure had infected them both.

“He didn’t talk much, but when he did, he always said something super profound for how young he was. It was like…like he waited for the perfect moment to speak. He only spoke when it was necessary, and we all appreciated it. I think it was one of those…things that you had to be there for to fully understand,” Michael paused for a moment before continuing, “…Firkle was also a great guitarist. I remember when we performed at the school talent show together, and he did a great job. I remember feeling…feeling proud of him.”

The words came jumbled out of Michael's mouth, but Henrietta couldn't fault him for it. Looking back, it was a lot to expect from someone who was barely a middle schooler—for a child to have to speak openly at the funeral of another child.

"Even if you weren’t very close with Firkle, I—we, thank you for coming.” Michael glanced up from the paper in his hands, gaze befalling where Henrietta and Pete sat, “…we don’t want his memory to be forgotten. Ever.”

The speech was awkward, it was short, and imperfect, and likely wasn’t peer-reviewed, but it was authentic.

That day, Henrietta allowed herself to lapse into emotionality, and she cried.

 


 

- SEVEN YEARS LATER (PRESENT DAY) -

Smoke billowed out of Henrietta’s mouth like a chimney, cigarette balanced between her middle and forefinger as she loomed by the window of her upstairs bedroom. She watched the occasional car drive by, breaking the monotony for just a moment, yet still leaving behind nothing insightful for her to look at. Instead, her brain swam with thoughts, the kind of thoughts that left her wading through waist-high water, struggling to fight against the current of her own anxieties.

It had been seven years since Firkle’s funeral, but every evening, Henrietta found herself back in that moment where everything had retroactively shifted. Little things triggered the memories, like the stinging she felt in her throat whenever she smoked. If she dwelled on the sensation for too long, she could almost feel that same stinging in her eyes, where tears once flowed that no longer did. She struggled to acknowledge that nothing would ever go back to “normal” after Firkle passed. A part of her didn’t want for things to be “normal,” fearful that would mean forgetting Firkle’s existence in its entirety, but she longed for him to not be looming over her head when others spoke to her, like he was a ghost that was always haunting her. So, instead, she pushed these thoughts away, watching them dissipate into the air as she puffed smoke at them, their forms melting together into one.

“…This is cool and all, but I know we could do something better than just sitting here in awkward silence.” 

Henrietta exhaled, glancing back over her shoulder at the boy lounging on the floor of her bedroom. She observed Kenny, watching as he held the wrapper of a candy bar that Henrietta had bought for him, his fingers crinkling the foil above his head, with that restlessness he always seemed to have. She would never admit that it was nice having someone like Kenny around; he was so far separated from anyone she had met before. He was a non-conformist in every sense of the word, but in a distinct way from how she was. She had never considered the why behind her reasons for being a non-conformist—the true why, not just some explanation she conjured up to save face in front of her old friends—until she and Kenny had gotten to know each other. She was a non-conformist by choice, and Kenny wasn’t, because he had never been given the option to choose. Between her and herself, Kenny really wasn’t all that bad. He was, at best, tolerable.

“You got any better ideas?” Henrietta said, “you know there isn’t shit to do around here.” 

Kenny fell silent; Henrietta could hear the rusted gears in that head of his struggling to turn themselves from across the room. In the wake of this abrupt pause, a toothy grin spread over Kenny’s face.

“Wanna take a joyride in your car?” he suggested.

Henrietta squinted at him. “…It’s not really a joyride if it’s in the car I own, is it?”

“Well,” Kenny sighed, pushing himself up into a sitting position on the floor, “I’m not feeling adventurous enough to spend the night in jail, so it’s the best I’ve got. Maybe doing something else’ll make it easier to talk to you.”

Henrietta rolled her eyes at him before turning away. She made it known to Kenny that she was offended—even though she wasn’t—as she gazed back out the window. Her eyes gravitated further down the street, off down the road and into the distance, where just around the corner, and out of sight, Stark’s Pond sat near the edge of town. She always seemed to be drawn to it, even in the rare moments where she wanted to think about anything else. It continued to fester, somewhere deep inside her.

She turned her back on the window, tucking her cigarette in-between her lips as she grabbed her keys from her bedside table. The jingling of the keys and the taste of smoke on her tongue grounded her.

“Let’s go before I change my mind,” Henrietta said, muffled, “you can drive.”

She could already hear Kenny pulling himself up from the floor. “Sweet.” 

The two made their way out the door and down the staircase of her home, with Henrietta refusing to even spare a glance at the framed photos lining the walls. She could feel the gaze of her childhood-self staring at her through the frame, and she didn’t want to acknowledge her existence. Not today.

Despite her parents lounging in the living room, Henrietta strolled past them, puffing on her cigarette as Kenny followed close behind.

“Henrietta,” her father said, glancing up from the newspaper in his hands; he behaved too much like a sitcom dad for her liking, “if you’re gonna smoke, don’t smoke in the house.”

“We were just leaving anyway,” Henrietta said, removing her cigarette from in-between her lips as smoke continued to billow out her mouth. She wrinkled her nose up in her father’s direction. “Kenny and I’re gonna drive around town.”

“Well, don’t be gone for too long,” her mother hummed close by, hands busy knitting some sort of clothing for Henrietta that she would never wear, “dinner’s in the oven right now. We’re having meatloooaf!”

“That’s nice,” Henrietta mumbled.

“Bye, Mr. and Mrs. Biggle,” Kenny said as he waved, interjecting himself into the conversation while he and Henrietta found their way to the front door.

“It’s always nice to see you, Kenny,” Henrietta’s mother said, stealing a glance at the two just as Henrietta’s father looked back down at his paper, “come back anytime.”

Once the two escaped out onto the front porch, and Henrietta clicked the door shut behind her, Kenny lightly punched her arm.

“Your parents love me,” he grinned.

Henrietta sneered at him, wiping her arm off in a show of disgust—as if Kenny’s hand was the most revolting thing in the world. “Don’t touch me.” 

Still, Henrietta stuck to her word, inching her keys in Kenny’s direction as she glanced away, with Kenny snatching them from her grasp before she could change her mind. She watched him dart down from the porch and towards her car, momentarily supervising from a close distance before following after. Henrietta knew Kenny was too poor to afford a nice car, and the one that he did own was a few miles short of falling apart in the middle of the street. She could feel her parents patting her on the back for how considerate she was being, and she shivered at the sensation as it hung heavy on her shoulders.

Kenny made sure to take his sweet time getting comfortable. Henrietta watched Kenny as he started the ignition, before fiddling with the AC, then switching it to the heater, and then pausing to check himself out in the mirror, tucking strands of his blond hair behind his ear, only serving to remind Henrietta about how much time had passed and how much they both had changed, and after she yelled at him to start the car, he let out a cackle at what Henrietta assumed was him interpreting her annoyance as fake, but all she could think about was how much she just wanted to be anywhere but in South Park. Anywhere but here.

“…So,” Kenny said after a brief silence, “what’s your plan for senior year? Not that you really seem like the type who’s just itching to get back to school!” he exclaimed, his voice exuding that fake peppiness only teachers who not-so-secretly hated working with kids seemed to have, “oh, god, I’m so excited! Don’t you just feel that school spirit already?”

Henrietta, meanwhile, stared out the window, rolling it down to toss her cigarette out into the street. “Yeah, I’m so thrilled.”

She could feel Kenny peek at her from the corner of his eye. Henrietta had been around him long enough to know he was aching to ask her something further. Tension built in her muscles as his gaze refused to lift, and she, in turn, refused to look at him.

“If you want to ask me something,” Henrietta started, “I’d rather you just say it.”

Kenny looked back at the road. She could hear him suck in his breath through his teeth.

“Well, like, on this topic, I guess…what—” he paused, “—…what ever happened with the others? You know…Michael, Pete…you never really told me.”

At first, Henrietta didn’t answer. There was that weight again. It persisted deep within her body, and she wondered if she would ever be able to escape. She couldn’t get away from it in her head, nor could she act like it didn’t exist when everyone around her treated her like it was the only interesting aspect of herself. It was the only part of Henrietta that they knew.

“There’s not really much to talk about,” she admitted, “ever since…well, everything, things just never went back to normal. Then Michael and Pete started acting all bitchy to each other and wouldn’t tell me why, so things just got…weird,” Henrietta paused as the memories flashed through her mind’s eye, making her squirm in the passenger’s seat, “I guess a part of me always hoped this would end with us being closer than we were before, but…it kinda just turned out to be the exact opposite.”

She wasn’t quite sure why she mentioned that last part, especially to Kenny. Though she’d like to consider Kenny her friend (or, at least, as much as she could consider anyone in her life to be her ‘friend’), it was hard to feel close with anyone anymore, especially when everyone treated her like she was a minefield they had to traverse.

Even with the bond that was present between the two, Henrietta closed her eyes as Kenny turned to look at her.

 “I’m still really sorry, Hen–” 

“Don’t start,” she interrupted, resting her elbow against the door as she brought her fingertips to her forehead, “it’s like every time I mention Firkle’s name, or even just allude to him, people act like they have to be sad for me all over again. You don’t need to do that. It’s fine.”

Kenny looked away, lifting the tips of his fingers from the steering wheel. “Alright, alright. I’m sorry. I didn’t mean for it to come off as, like, patronizing or whatever. I really meant it.”

Henrietta sighed, cupping her palm against the side of her face as she looked out at the street. There was something about being here that was suffocating to her, even just beyond the way everyone treated her. It was almost as if breathing the air in this town alone made her sick.

“It’s whatever,” she said, “it’s just that I want to…just talk about Firkle normally sometimes, without it being a big deal. It feels like everyone’s just…forgotten about him, I guess.” 

“Nobody forgot about him, Henrietta,” Kenny said, “I think…I think some people are just scared you’ll lash out if you hear them talking about him.”

Henrietta scrunched her face, turning to look at Kenny. “Well, that’s stupid. I’m not the type to lash out.”

Kenny pursed his lips. His blank gaze remained focused on the road, before meeting Henrietta’s with a sly smirk. “…You are a little.”

Henrietta parted her lips to protest, but Kenny turned back to the road as he widened his eyes. “But that’s whatever!” he assured her, “I think you just need to cut some of ‘em some slack. Maybe it doesn’t feel like it, but people really do care about your feelings.” 

She scoffed, looking out the front window. “When has anybody ever given a fuck about me?”

Silence filled the car once more, bubbling to the surface and threatening to erupt out the windows of the vehicle. Henrietta knew she was being disagreeable on purpose, but she couldn’t deny the contempt she held over how the mainstream hivemind thought. They were incessant on being high-and-mighty enough to understand how Henrietta’s mind worked. They claimed to know exactly how she felt, but, really, none of them did. All it did was remind her of how excluded she was, and how nobody she once viewed as a friend—not Pete, and not even Michael, who had always claimed louder than anyone else that he would always be there for her—truly took the time to understand her for who she was. But most of all, she hated being lied to, and that’s all that anyone did to her: lie.

“…Still,” Henrietta broke the silence, an attempt to pull her away from her thoughts, “you’re being hypocritical as fuck right now asking me all this stuff. You never told me about you and your friends either.”

Kenny smiled, letting a short exhale out of his nose. “I mean, like you said, it’s just because there isn’t much for me to say. It was gonna happen at some point, because, deadass, I think we’d all grown to hate each other years before then. I think now that that’s the only reason we stuck together for so long—us hating each other, I mean. Schadenfreude and all that.”

“Wowww,” Henrietta cooed at him with a sly smirk, despite her heart not being in it, “look at you, learning faaancy new words.”

Kenny laughed. “It’s probably all the time I’ve been spending with you. You’re infecting me like a parasite.”

Henrietta hummed in response, glancing out the window as they turned the corner.

“But, yeah, your plan?” Kenny asked, “you know, because you never answered my question.”

She paused. Henrietta had been avoiding the reality of having to return to school for so long that she hadn’t realized how the first day back had snuck up on her. It would be the first school year she could remember where she wouldn’t be in a group, and being an outcast in a group was much more fun than being an outcast alone. Still, the distance within the group had been building for years beforehand, having finally boiled over right at the start of summer. There was this fear Henrietta held, forced to the forefront of her mind, that life wouldn’t feel so different being all alone. She had been emotionally isolated for years now, and, maybe, being outcasted alone wouldn’t be such a big jump anymore. She wasn’t sure how that should make her feel.

Henrietta rested her forearm against the car door, turning her head back towards the open window. “I don’t know. I guess I’ll probably just do what I’ve always done. Skip class, smoke…just alone now, which…doesn’t have to be a bad thing, maybe. Maybe it’ll give me more time to write.” 

“Write?” Kenny asked.

Again, Henrietta hummed. 

Kenny seemed to consider her words, before grinning as he stole her another glance. “Well, hey, I know you like to pretend you’re too exclusive and awesome to hang out with me, but…I’ll be around if you ever want some company,” he looked back towards the road, “it’s not like either of us have anything better to do.”

She considered it, even though her fear of him solely showing care for her out of pity, or that his care towards her would be fleeting, was still there. Whenever Henrietta took the time to hang around with Kenny, he was patient, yet critical enough to hack at the walls she’d built around herself. It was the type of intimacy she had always wanted, and had had before, but it came to an end, just as everything around her always seemed to. Sometimes, when she could ignore the guilt she felt for doing so, she liked to imagine Kenny as someone else, somewhere else, and that her friendship with that person had grown the way she’d always wanted it to be.

But rather than saying any of that, or anything at all, she stared out the window in silence, unable to figure out what Firkle would want her to do if he were still here.

Notes:

i'm very excited to start posting my fic on a new website !! i never wound up finishing this on my original AO3 fic, but the AO3 shutdown is kinda what motivated me to return to this story in order to rewrite and finish it :) hopefully there aren't too many formatting or textual issues i come across as i try to get used to this new website

if you choose to follow along with the updates of this story, i can only hope you enjoy reading it just as much as i've enjoyed writing it !! <3 feedback is always appreciated