Actions

Work Header

A Wish to Be Loved.

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Jason and Tim sat perfectly still while Damian cleaned the cuts on their faces, following every instruction without complaint. Absorbed in his work and his own thoughts, Damian barely noticed the silence settling over the infirmary.

Dick stayed beside him, helping whenever the other two let him. He seemed perfectly content just to be useful to Damian.

From somewhere deeper in the Cave, Damian could hear the persistent tapping of keys. His father was still awake, working on something Damian knew nothing about.

Perhaps it had something to do with all of this.

When he’d finished tending to his brothers, Damian left the infirmary and found his father still hunched over the computer.

“We have a situation.” Damian kept his voice steady. The last thing he needed was to alarm anyone. “I need your help.”

Bruce looked up, his gaze moving from Damian to the three brothers who had followed him.

“What are you doing in Gotham?” he asked Dick, without a hint of reproach. His voice was as flat and neutral as only Batman’s could be.

Dick draped an arm around Damian’s neck. “I missed my little brother, so I came to visit.”

“Hmm.” Bruce studied him for another moment. If he had anything else to say about it, he wisely kept it to himself. “And what about you two? I’ve had unanswered notifications from the Teen Titans and the Outlaws.”

Jason snorted and set a hand on Damian’s shoulder, nearly pushing Dick aside.

“They can manage without me for once, don’t you think? I can’t put them first when Damian needs me here.”

“My team can handle things on their own,” Tim added, taking up Damian’s other side. “I’m not leaving Damian alone. Not for anything.”

Bruce’s expression hardened.

“You’re all compromised.” Bruce’s tone left no room for argument. This time, he turned to Damian. “Have you run any tests?”

“Blood, magic, and aura,” Damian reported.

“I’ll run them again. I’m going to examine each of you myself. Thoroughly. Understood?”

Damian nodded first. The others followed without hesitation.


The room fell silent, tension hanging heavily in the air.

Neither the physical examinations nor the basic magical tests had turned up anything. Whatever magic was behind the wish seemed to be beyond even Batman’s limited knowledge of the subject.

His father went through paperwork and sent messages, making plans he had yet to share with anyone. Damian watched him, doing his best to stay calm while managing the three brothers who refused to leave his side.

He’d put them on a schedule. They could each have what they wanted, so long as they took turns.

Every twenty minutes.

Now it was Tim’s turn.

Damian had settled comfortably on Tim’s lap. Tim had both arms around his waist, while Jason and Dick held one of his hands each.

“Would you do me a favor, Dick?” Damian pointed toward the little box.

Dick complied immediately, sliding both willow boxes across the table toward their father.

After recovering the second box, Damian had gone back through the artifacts from their last mission, checking each one for anything they might have missed in the chaos.

There had been a third box. Finding it had made his blood run cold. How many more might there be?

That was another conversation he would have to have with his father once this situation was under control. A much longer one, preferably when everyone had come to their senses and could actually help.

Magic like this couldn’t be allowed to circulate unchecked through Gotham.

“How long have they been like this?” Bruce asked.

“More than a day. Less than two.”

His father pressed his lips together, his expression darkening as he read the words printed on the box. Damian knew them well by now. He’d read and cursed every one of them.

“Did you call the number?” Bruce asked.

“I did. They weren’t much help.”

“What did they—”

A chime cut him off. Jason quickly silenced the timer and held it up for everyone to see.

“It’s my turn.”

Tim’s arms tightened around Damian’s waist, his gaze snapping toward Jason.

“You tampered with it. There’s no way twenty minutes have passed.”

Bruce spoke before Jason could make it worse.

“I set it and programmed it myself. There’s no mistake.” He held out his hand, gesturing for Jason to give him the timer. “We established these rules to keep Damian safe, and you all agreed to them for his sake. If you start fighting over him, he could get hurt. I expect you to behave. Understood?”

Damian would have been speechless if he hadn’t already been. His father had figured out how the spell worked with astonishing ease, despite having little more to go on than Damian’s recent interactions with the three of them.

A small spark of hope stirred in his chest.

Bruce continued, “He loves all of you, and he doesn’t want any of you getting hurt. Do him a favor. Be good brothers and follow the rules.”

Tim lowered his head in shame, his arms loosening around Damian’s waist.

“I’m sorry,” he whispered. “I’d never do anything to hurt you.”

Damian swallowed against the ache in his throat. They kept saying things he had always wanted to hear. Things he had wanted so badly. Just not like this. Now, every word sounded false.

“I love you all, too,” he said.

He had lost count of how many times he had said it over the past few days. Almost a spell of its own. A few pretty words to satisfy the needs the wish had imposed on them, and everyone would settle down for a while.

They tasted a little more bitter every time.

A little more false.

He loved all three of them, but not these versions of them. Much as he hated to admit it, he missed the people they’d been before the wish.

At least then, he could believe that the little love they gave him was something real.

Tim finally let him go, and Jason settled Damian on his own lap. Their father watched the exchange with barely concealed concern. The situation was wearing him down, and he no longer seemed to have the energy to hide it.

“I’ll call Zatanna and Constantine,” he said. “They have to know something. A magical spell in a box can’t possibly be stronger than they are.”

Damian nodded, desperate to believe his father was right: that the man on the phone had been wrong, and that he’d said those terrible things only to torment Damian over his wish.


The four of them settled into the living room. There was room for everyone around Damian, and Alfred was there to make sure they kept to their places.

“Would you like something to eat?” Alfred asked.

Jason hummed, resting his chin on top of Damian’s head. “It’s still a little early for breakfast. Maybe some hot chocolate and cookies?”

Tim scoffed. “You can’t keep offering him cookies. Damian’s a growing teenager. He needs to eat properly.”

Damian bit back the remark on the tip of his tongue. Tim, of all people. Since when did he care so much about what Damian ate?

“Milk and a piece of fruit would be better for him,” Tim concluded.

Dick raised a hand before Jason could argue.

“I left Blüdhaven in a hurry. Could you make me something to eat, Alfred? I didn't have dinner before coming here.” Dick kept his eyes on Damian the whole time. “Would you like a snack, Dami?”

A snack.

Something substantial enough to count as a meal. Healthy, but not a dessert. Simple enough to keep everyone happy.

Had Dick noticed what Jason and Tim were doing? Could he tell how much it was getting to Damian?

The tension eased out of Damian’s shoulders. He would have sighed in relief if he’d let himself.

Dick had always been the best at keeping everyone in line. He’d done it often enough before.

Damian managed a shaky smile and squeezed the hands that still held his. If he could soothe the two of them, perhaps he’d be able to calm down a little himself.

“That would be great, wouldn’t it?”

Both hesitated, caught between what they thought was best for him and whatever part of the spell insisted that his opinion was the only one that mattered.

“Please?” he added.

The word hurt more than it should have.

He hardly cared what they ate. He wanted his brothers back. He wanted things to go back to the way they’d been before the wish, and he was terrified they never would.

Jason and Tim nodded immediately.

Of course they did.

They had no other choice.

His conversation with Tim already felt distant, the way a dream did once you tried to remember it. He could almost believe it had never happened.

Could he reach Tim again? The next time they fell asleep, could he reach one of the others? Dick. Jason. Someone who could tell him it would be all right. Someone who trusted him to fix it.

He closed his eyes against the sting of tears. He couldn’t cry now. He had no right to feel sorry for himself when this was his fault.

He hadn’t meant for any of it to happen, but he hadn’t stopped it when he had the chance. He’d been afraid of his father’s reaction. Of the reprimands. Of everything going back to normal so quickly that he’d have to face his two older brothers and their cold cruelty all over again.

Be selfish a little longer… just a little longer… You weren’t supposed to hurt anyone.

The timer chimed in the living room.

All three shifted into their places at once. Nobody protested.

Dick wrapped his arms around Damian as he always did. His familiar scent. His warmth. The softness of his hands. And beneath all of it, an affection Damian knew by the way Dick held him.

The only hugs that didn’t feel false. Damian knew these arms. He wanted to believe no spell could ever change the way it felt to be held by them.

Dick was holding him because he genuinely loved him. Not because he had to.

The hands still wrapped around his own felt a little cooler, but their grip remained as firm as ever.

The food came a moment later.

No one let go. They began eating in silence, each still determined to claim some part of Damian, and none interested in conversation unless it involved him.

The occasional clink of cutlery against a plate was the only sound in the room.

They ate the portions Alfred had prepared without complaint and offered Damian the occasional bite from their plates.

A compromise he was too tired to argue with.

His father couldn’t be far from getting an answer from Zatanna or Constantine. Perhaps both. Then they could finally put an end to this. Whatever happened afterward, Damian would face it. He’d take responsibility for what he’d done and apologize to each of them.

If they could never trust him again, he’d understand.

He could hardly blame them if they decided to hate him.

He deserved it.


Zatanna and Constantine had asked Dick, Jason, and Tim to take their assigned seats for the examination. Damian had been examined, too. Zatanna had recited words he didn’t understand, surrounding him with bright magic that seemed to crackle in the air.

Constantine, meanwhile, had been looking over the little box.

“Did you call the number?” he asked.

“I did.” Damian grimaced. “They weren’t much help.”

He kept the screams to himself. He didn’t want to remember them, and he still didn’t know whether they’d even been real. For all he knew, whoever had made the box could have conjured them up.

The magic around Damian faded, and Zatanna turned to Constantine.

“Any ideas?” She gestured toward all four of them. “The magic around them is strange. I can’t even get a clear sense of their souls inside their bodies.”

“What does that mean?” Bruce’s jaw tightened. “Is something taking possession of my sons?”

“Easy, Batman.” Constantine shook the box. “Magic doesn’t have a fixed set of rules. It does tend to take wishes literally, though.” He turned to Damian. “What did you ask for?”

Damian lowered his gaze. “I said, ‘I wish my brothers loved me, no matter what.’”

“And there’s your problem.” Constantine pointed at him. “Simple words. A hell of a lot of room for interpretation.”

Bruce turned on him, demanding an explanation. They needed more than that to decide what to do. They needed something they could actually use to fix this.

Zatanna picked up the second box and read through the rules again, looking for anything they might have missed.

While the others were occupied, Damian’s brothers edged closer. Only a little at a time. They seemed to know how much they could get away with before Bruce noticed and decided to lock them up while the others dealt with the magic.

They could still think as clearly as they ever had.

So what the hell was possessing them?

Tim had warned him there was more going on than the wish itself. Damian still hadn’t had a chance to speak to his father alone about it.

Three pairs of eyes remained fixed on him, none of them willing to look away.

Dick leaned in from behind him, his voice low near Damian’s shoulder.

“What are they looking for? I don’t like the way they’re talking.”

Jason’s face crumpled. Tears gathered in his eyes.

“Did we do something wrong?” He moved closer. “Whatever’s going on, you can tell us. We’re your brothers. You can trust us.”

Tim caught Damian by the shoulder, drawing his attention away from Jason.

“You’re okay, right?” Tim’s hand trembled against his shoulder. “I love you, Dami. You know I don’t want anything bad to happen to you. You know that, right?”

Damian nodded awkwardly. He couldn’t think of anything to say.

What was happening now?

He needed something that would reassure all three of them. Something they wanted to hear. How was he supposed to tell them everything was fine when he didn’t know what was happening himself?

Zatanna spoke before any of them could press him for an answer.

“Let’s use the One Wish.”

Damian jumped in before anyone else could, desperate to draw attention away from his brothers. Even after the last two days, there was something about the way they were acting now that he didn’t like one bit.

“One Wish can’t alter someone else’s wishes.”

“We’d be asking it to tell us how to solve the problem. There are thousands of universes. Someone in one of them must have found a way by now.”

She held the box out toward Bruce.

“A wish for the key. ‘I wish to be given, in physical form, every existing method for undoing, erasing, or rewriting a wish made with One Wish, from every universe and every point in time.’” Zatanna grimaced. “Or something along those lines. We’ll have to make the wording foolproof.”

Constantine crossed his arms. “And what if no one has ever managed to break a wish in any universe?”

“Then there’s nothing either of us can do here.” She turned to Bruce, her chin raised, her voice steady. “There’s no way to fix it. Ever.”

Damian shot to his feet, nearly hitting Dick in the face as he did.

“You can’t say that!” Damian shook his head. He was trembling so badly he could hardly stand still. “You can’t just give up. You can’t leave them like this forever. You can’t—”

“If magic can’t give us an answer, there’s nothing more we can do.” Constantine cut in. “I’ll work on the wording. Once we’ve closed the loopholes, we make the wish and wait.”

“It shouldn’t take long, should it?” Bruce took the box Zatanna had offered him.

“Depends.” Constantine tossed his box to Damian, who caught it easily. “How long did it take yours to kick in?”

Damian thought back to the moment he’d snapped the wand and made the wish.

It couldn’t have been more than a few minutes before Tim appeared behind him at the lockers. Barely enough time to gather Tim’s things, cross the Cave, and put his mask away.

“Not long. It could’ve been almost instantaneous.”

“Lucky you.” Constantine shrugged. “The usual minimum is twenty-four hours. We still don’t know how long Batman’ll have to wait for his answer.”

Damian’s breath caught.

Twenty-four hours?

What might happen to Jason, Tim, and Dick in the next few hours alone? A whole day was far too long.

He took an unsteady step back, trying to get enough air into his lungs. Too many bodies crowded around him. Too many eyes watched him, too many hands reached for him. They were waiting for him to say something. To react.

He couldn’t breathe.

Damian spun around and ran for the stairs, clutching the box so tightly his fingers ached.

They called after him, but he kept running. He couldn’t bear to hear any more about how long he might have to wait. About how there might be nothing to wait for at all.

What would it mean if his brothers stayed like this? Would they go on living only for Damian, or only because of him? What would happen to their friends, their families, the things they wanted for themselves?

He couldn’t be the one to take all of that away from them. No matter how many disagreements they’d had in the past, none of them deserved this.

“We’ll fix this!” his father shouted from the landing.

Damian didn’t look back.

For the first time in what felt like forever, Damian had room to run. Room to feel his own body moving as he raced through the manor toward the exit.

Toward a freedom he might never have again.

“Damian!” Dick shouted behind him.

Damian wasn't surprised to hear him so close. If anyone could catch up to him, it was Dick. Not that there was anywhere Damian could run. He knew all three of them would follow him wherever he went. They would search for him, find him, and refuse to leave his side.

That was simply how the wish worked.

“Stay back!” Damian shouted as he reached the door.

His hand had barely closed around the handle when Dick caught his other hand.

“Please, don't go,” he pleaded. “I don't know what's happening. I don't know what's wrong with you, but we can fix it. I don't want you to feel bad. I'd never want to hurt you. Not in any way.” Dick gestured behind him, where Tim and Jason stood at a safe distance. “None of us would.”

Dick took the box from Damian, then wrapped his fingers around Damian's hand, his grip as firm as it was gentle.

“We'll do whatever you need us to do.” A small smile appeared on Dick's face. One Damian remembered all too well, one that felt almost real. Dick had smiled at him like that before, with genuine affection. “What do you want us to do?”

Damian swallowed hard, his throat burning. He didn't deserve any of this careful affection. Not when he was the one who had cursed them in the first place.

Behind Dick, Jason and Tim approached, both radiating the same reassuring confidence as their older brother.

“You don't have to cry,” Jason said, reaching out to wipe the tears from Damian's cheek. “We only want what's best for you.”

Tim nodded and placed his hand over Damian's, still held securely in Dick's grasp. “We're here to take care of you because we love you.”

Damian pressed his lips together, struggling to hold back a sob that threatened to tear through him. He looked past Dick's shoulder toward his father and Alfred, who were watching the exchange, ready to intervene if anything went wrong.

“I just want it to end. I want you to go back to the way you were before,” he admitted, hoping the truth wouldn't upset them. He simply couldn't keep it to himself any longer.

He managed a weak, trembling smile.

“I want to truly love you, and I want you to love me too, the way you already do.”

The sudden sound of Christmas music made Damian whip his head around.

Tim was holding the plastic willow wand between his hands.

“If that's what you want.”

Damian didn't have time to move. Neither did Bruce or Alfred. Everything happened too quickly.

The wand snapped.

“I wish for Damian to love us the way we love him.”

None of them reacted in time.

The room closed in around Damian.

And he fell into a bottomless darkness.


The light blurred before him. Behind it, a dark shape shifted, too indistinct to recognize. Words reached him as though from somewhere far away.

Damian blinked, trying to make sense of what he was seeing.

The light grew brighter. He turned his head, squeezing his eyes shut against the glare.

“Damian?”

The brightness faded. When he opened his eyes again, the man in front of him slowly came into focus.

Constantine stood with both hands raised, light still glowing at his fingertips and a deep scowl on his face.

“Damian,” he repeated, more firmly.

Damian’s throat burned. His mouth was dry, his cheeks wet. He tried to move.

He was tied to a chair.

“What?” He coughed and winced. “What is this?”

He looked around, struggling to take in the room.

Tim and Jason were bound with Wonder Woman’s Lasso of Truth—what was Diana doing here?—their faces flushed, their breathing ragged. Both watched him with expressions he couldn’t read. He’d rarely seen either of them look so tired. That particular exhaustion belonged on his father’s face.

Damian continued scanning the room. Dick hung limp in Superman’s arms. Tear tracks marked his cheeks, and the sorrow in his eyes made Damian look away.

The pieces were beginning to fit together. Slowly. His head still felt too clouded to trust them.

Farther back stood someone whose presence made no sense. Except, somehow, it did. Respawn glared at him, his hatred plain even through Hal Jordan’s glowing green restraints.

None of them were struggling now. They seemed to have exhausted themselves fighting the older heroes. Damian shifted his hands and felt the ache where his own restraints pressed against his wrists.

Was it over?

Were his brothers free?

A sob escaped him.

“I’m sorry,” he whimpered. “I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I’m sorry.”

“Enough!” Jason strained against the Lasso. “I’m not accepting apologies for this. You made a wish, and it got out of control. Big surprise. Nothing new for this family. Apparently, we need shock therapy just to admit that—that…”

He choked on the words and shook his head, fighting whatever the Lasso was trying to make him say.

Dick had no lasso compelling him, and he had no intention of holding back.

“That we love you.” His eyes stayed on Damian. “We’re a dysfunctional family. We fight. That doesn’t mean we don’t love you.”

Damian couldn’t answer. He couldn’t even stop crying.

No magic was forcing Dick to say it. He’d chosen those words himself.

Exactly what Damian had wanted to hear.

“I’m glad you kept fighting for us,” Tim said. There was warmth in his voice, the same warmth Damian had heard the night before. “That you kept looking for a way out where no one had to die.”

He gave a short, dry laugh. Jason narrowed his eyes at him but kept quiet. Apparently, he wasn’t willing to risk another admission.

“You were stronger than I gave you credit for,” Tim continued, his eyes bright with affection. “And I want you to know that I worry about you. I always do.”

He drew a deep breath. “When missions go wrong, I’m afraid I’ll fail and you’ll get hurt. We can’t lose anyone else. Not again.”

Dick’s breath caught. He looked as startled by the admission as Damian felt.

“None of us wants that,” Dick said. “No one else has to get hurt. That’s why we’re here. To protect each other.”

Superman let him go. Dick stumbled toward Damian.

“I’m sorry I didn’t realize sooner.” He crouched in front of the chair and began undoing the restraints around Damian’s wrists. “I should have told you more often. I forgot you might need to hear it.”

Once Damian’s hands were free, Dick took them in his own and squeezed gently. “You’re my little brother, Damian. Of course I love you.”

Damian threw himself forward and wrapped both arms around him.

His crying only grew worse. He couldn’t hold any of it back now. The relief, the happiness, everything he’d been trying so hard to swallow came spilling out at once.

They were all alive. No one hated him.

He buried his face against Dick’s neck and clung to him, his whole body shaking with each sob.

It was okay.

Everything was finally okay.


“Diana, could you get me out of this?” Jason looked toward her, still standing firmly behind him. “I promise I won’t try to hurt Tim for suggesting we get killed.”

Tim frowned. “You’re lying. How can you lie with the Lasso around you?”

“I don’t lie,” Jason said with thoroughly unconvincing innocence.

“I don’t believe you.” A mischievous smile crept across Tim’s face. “So. Do you love Damian?”

Jason scoffed. “Obviously. He’s a more capable and less annoying brother than you.” He turned the look back on Tim. “What about you? How much do you love your brothers?”

“Dick, Cass, Damian, Steph, Duke—”

“I said brothers!” Jason stared at him. “Are you seriously going to name everyone before you admit you love me?”

Tim didn’t blink.

“Carrie, Jarro—”

“Tim!”

“Will you two shut the hell up?!” Respawn shouted as Hal’s restraints vanished. “What the fuck am I even doing here? What the hell do I have to do with all your fucking family drama?”

“Biologically, you’re Damian’s brother,” Bruce said. “His half-brother, to be exact.”

He gestured for Diana to release Jason and Tim. He looked about as tired of their argument as Respawn sounded.

“I’ll call Talia. We’ll get you on the first available flight home.”

“First class. I won’t accept anything less.”

Someone objected. Someone else joined in.

Damian’s sobs began to subside. With his face still tucked against Dick’s neck, he listened to the argument gathering around him and found himself almost amused.

It was good to have them all back.

Notes:

I've been using this site to edit my fanfics while AO3 was down. I figured the least I could do was leave one of them here. (The others don't comply with your TOS, sorry about that xd)

Notes:

Thank you for the kudos. For commenting. Just for reading. I truly appreciate it all💖