Chapter Text
Chapter Seven – A BLACK CAT
When John returned to Bobby’s house after visiting his friend for information about the demon, he was frankly relieved to find Bridget was no longer there. Apparently, she had left a few days after he had, except unlike him, she wasn’t planning on coming back anytime soon.
After John got back, his sons immediately told him what had happened at Ellen’s and that Ellen’s friend Ash—who, according to them, was some sort of genius—had designed a tracking system and would contact them if anything related to the yellow-eyed demon came up.
John could tell that Sam and Dean were both obviously curious about Ellen- who she was, how exactly he knew her, and what had happened between them- but for whatever reason, neither of them brought it up or asked any questions. Maybe it was because there was already enough tension between them due to the revelation that Dean had shared details of their lives with Bridget. Or maybe both Dean and Sam already understood that it was something he didn’t want to talk about.
Either way, John was just glad that they kept any questions to themselves. There was too much history between him and Ellen, and he didn’t have the time to get into any of that. Not when he was discovering so much about the yellow-eyed demon.
When his sons had asked him what new information he had managed to gather while he was gone, he had told them that it turned out his friend knew nothing that they themselves didn’t already know.
This was a lie.
The truth was that what John had found was new and very important, but he didn’t want to share it because it was about Sam and what his connection to the yellow-eyed demon was. John didn’t want to share any of it with his sons—especially Sam—until he had looked into it more. Because, in truth, it worried him greatly.
So he lied, even though he had promised them that anything related to the demon and finding it would be shared information between them, because he wasn’t about to put this burden on their shoulders. Not until he had all the information.
John could tell that there was some hesitation from his sons, especially Sam, when he had told them he hadn’t found out anything. He was sure that, on some level, his sons knew when he wasn’t being completely honest. Again, though, neither of them brought it up.
John was surprised by Sam’s choice not to push the subject yet. Sam had never been one to hold back his opinions, especially when those opinions greatly differed from John’s own. While Sam wasn’t asking questions now, John knew it wouldn’t be long before he started to, and he wanted to make sure he himself understood what was going on and how to handle it before they had that conversation.
John, however, was not surprised by Dean’s choice not to say anything and remain silent. Between Dean and Sam, Dean was always the one more likely to follow his orders, usually with little to no questions. John told Dean to go on a hunt—Dean went. He told him not to ask about something—Dean didn’t. And the times that Dean believed he had truly disappointed his father in any way always made him become more quiet, and he simply obeyed any order given to him out of guilt. He had been like this ever since he was a child.
John was well aware of this trait his son had, and as much as it caused a slight pain in John to know how much Dean wanted his approval and how guilty he felt when he did something that failed to earn it, John never addressed it or brought it up. Instead, he just let Dean act this way.
The strain on their relationship that had been left by the exposure of not only Dean’s relationship with Bridget, but also the betrayal John felt when he found out that Dean had shared such personal details about their lives and family with her, was still very raw. To the point that John found it much easier to just keep a little distance between himself and Dean.
He was annoyed about his son’s relationship with this woman and the threat it could put on what they were doing, but more than that, he was worried about her being a distraction for Dean. Being distracted by personal relationships was something John expected of Sam, and he would never have even thought Dean capable of it. But now, knowing how close Dean was with Bridget—well, now John wasn’t so sure.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
It took Dean only a few more weeks to get the Impala running again, looking almost brand-new.
Dean felt proud of himself for getting his precious baby into such good condition, even though he had never doubted this would be the end result.
Dean had half expected that seeing the Impala back up and running, and knowing how much effort he had put into it, would have thawed the tension between him and his father, but it hadn’t. Not really. Dean could tell there was a little bit of approval in his father’s eyes, but not enough for their relationship to be fixed yet.
Once the Impala had been fixed, there had been a conversation between the three Winchester men about what exactly they should be doing now—what the next step of their plan should be.
Sam had wanted them to travel together and do what they could to get information about the yellow-eyed demon. To continue working together as much as they could. John, however, had been adamant that wouldn’t do any good right now. The way he saw it, there were still hunts that needed to be taken care of, people who still needed to be saved, and there was no reason they shouldn’t continue doing their jobs while hunting for the thing that had killed Mary and Jessica.
So his orders had been for Dean and Sam to continue traveling on their own, working different jobs while he also worked jobs. If and when any of them came across information that could lead them to the yellow-eyed demon, they would meet up and deal with it together.
Neither Dean nor Sam were particularly happy about this arrangement, both feeling as if it were a step backward from what they had previously agreed on, but John had left them no room to argue about it.
What they didn’t know—but highly suspected—was that John was continuing to work the hunt without them. Sam was, of course, furious about this, but Dean had to believe that their dad had good reasons for it.
And this was how Dean and Sam found themselves back on the road two months after leaving Bobby’s, locating different supernatural creatures and hunting them while protecting and saving the people involved.
They had just finished one of these hunts—another shapeshifting creature making itself look like the dead relatives of a few businessmen before killing them. And now they were in some random motel room, about to rest for the night before heading back out on the road again.
Dean was in the bathroom having a long shower—and probably using up what little hot water a cheap motel like this had—while Sam was sitting at the small table by the window with his laptop open. As he did whenever he found extra time, he was trying to find anything he could about the yellow-eyed demon that had killed Jessica and his mom. And, as always, he wasn’t having much luck.
Sam was interrupted from his search by the sound of ringing coming from Dean’s cell phone, which lay on the table in front of him.
Without thinking, Sam’s hand snapped out and snatched up the phone, answering it quickly because he hoped it would be their dad with some new information for them. They hadn’t heard from him in almost two weeks.
Their dad had been managing to check in now and then since they had left Bobby’s, mostly, Sam assumed, to let them know that he was still around and to avoid them thinking he was taking off on his own permanently again.
“Hello?” Sam answered.
Because he hadn’t checked who was calling before he answered, and because he was expecting to hear his father’s voice respond to him, he was very surprised when he heard Bridget’s voice instead.
“Oh, hi, Sammy,” Bridget said, her voice also indicating that she was surprised to be speaking with him. She had called Dean’s cell, after all.
“Ah, hi, Bridget,” Sam said and paused briefly to compose himself.
Sam knew that after being at the Roadhouse, and after Bridget had left Bobby’s, Dean had been talking to Bridget mostly through text. But now and then, Sam would secretly catch his brother walking out of their motel room or going into another room away from him for a few minutes, and Sam knew this was because Dean was obviously calling Bridget.
His brother didn’t really need to continue hiding his friendship with Bridget, or the fact that they spoke now that Sam was aware of them, but for some reason, Dean still didn’t feel completely comfortable openly communicating with Bridget while Sam was around.
Their conversations also appeared to occur mostly late at night. Bridget had mentioned to Sam back at Bobby’s that this was usually when their phone calls happened, but now it was only midnight, which Sam certainly wouldn’t classify as late, at least not as late as he understood most of their phone calls to occur.
“Are you okay, Sammy?” Bridget asked, and she seemed genuinely interested, not just making conversation.
“I’m good,” Sam answered slowly. Sam had managed to have a few conversations with Bridget during their time at Bobby’s, but he still felt awkward around her.
“Is Dean around?”
“Yeah, he’s just, ah, in the shower,” Sam stammered quickly.
As if on cue, Sam heard the water in the shower switch off, indicating that Dean was finished and would be stepping out soon. Sam looked over at the bathroom door and was so focused on it that he almost missed Bridget asking him if they were anywhere close to where she was calling from. Sam managed to focus enough to tell her he would check.
There was a map folded in front of him, so Sam grabbed it with the hand not holding his brother’s phone to his ear. With a bit of a struggle, he opened the map with one hand. As he quickly glanced over it, the door to the bathroom swung open, and Dean walked out with only an off-white towel wrapped around his waist. He was using one hand to hold the towel in place as he walked over to his bed and the pile of clothes he had forgotten to take into the bathroom with him.
Out of the corner of his eye, Dean could see his brother with a map in one hand, scanning through it. It wasn’t until he reached his bed that he noticed Sam also had a phone against his ear.
His phone.
“Ah, maybe eight hours away,” Sam said to the person on the other end of the line.
Dean gripped the towel tighter and looked over at his brother, assuming he was either talking to their dad or maybe even Ash.
“Hey,” Dean called out quietly, but loud enough to get Sam to look over at him. Dean walked closer until he was standing beside Sam. “Dad?” he whispered, nodding his head toward his own cell phone.
Sam shook his head while placing the map down on top of his laptop keys.
“Bridget,” Sam murmured in reply.
Before Sam could say anything else, Dean reached a hand out and roughly snatched the phone away from his ear. The sudden movement caused Sam to jerk slightly in his chair. Sam looked startled as he turned his head to watch Dean place the phone to his own ear and start walking back toward his bed.
“—If you coul—” Bridget was in the middle of saying to Sam.
“—Hey, Bridge,” Dean said suddenly, interrupting her as he paced back over to his bed and clothes.
“Dean, did—did you just snatch the phone from your brother?” Bridget asked, startled slightly to hear Dean’s voice cut through as she was mid-sentence.
Dean scoffed and said, “No.”
“Right,” Bridget sighed, and there was a hint of amusement in her voice.
Dean tried not to smile at the thought of the knowing smirk that was most likely now on Bridget’s face.
Then his expression became serious as he remembered that she had called him a lot earlier than either of them usually did. At first, the late-night calls had become routine because they were trying to avoid exposing their friendship to their families—well, mostly Dean’s family. Whenever Bridget would call him, she would text first to see if he was free to talk, and she would wait for a reply before calling.
Even though their friendship was now out in the open, and they didn’t need to continue hiding and sneaking around, it was still something they tended to do. For one thing, it kept their conversations more private, which Dean appreciated. So for Bridget to suddenly call him when she knew there was a good chance Sam was around made Dean feel that maybe this wasn’t one of their casual catch-up chats.
“Everything good?” Dean asked suddenly, ignoring the fact that Sam was behind him looking at him.
“Yeah,” Bridget said quickly. She knew he was looking for one of two words. “I’m okay,” she added reassuringly.
Before Dean could ask her why she called, she continued speaking.
“I just, um, I think I may have found something… weird.”
“So we’re clear,” Dean began as he walked around to the other side of the bed and sat down on the edge, keeping his back to his brother. “When you say ‘weird,’ you mean my sort of weird, yeah?” he asked her, though he already knew the answer.
“I think so,” Bridget replied, slightly hesitantly.
Dean sat patiently and waited for Bridget to continue. He didn’t have to wait long because she immediately went on.
“I’m in the middle of a job, and when I was looking back over the photographs I took today, I noticed that there were… things in them that… weren’t there when I took them,” Bridget explained, her voice a little on edge.
Sam watched as Dean’s back straightened, a sign that Sam knew meant his brother was taking whatever Bridget was saying a little more seriously.
“That’s something that does happen, right?” Bridget asked suddenly. “Spirits and things appearing in photographs?”
“I’ve heard of it,” Dean told her, nodding slightly. “Ran into that sort of thing with paintings before.” He confirmed, then asked, “What were you taking pictures of?”
“There’s this tree—”
“—A tree?” Dean asked skeptically, one eyebrow raising slightly.
“It’s historical,” Bridget told him. “It’s supposed to be over four hundred years old.”
“Right,” Dean sighed.
Personally, he couldn’t see why anyone would want or need pictures of an old tree, but he knew that Bridget often got asked to take all kinds of photos for all sorts of reasons. And it wasn’t the important part of why she was calling him.
“So you’ve got something in your photos that you didn’t see before?” he asked her, in a way that confirmed exactly what she was telling him.
“Yes. And I just…” She trailed off. “Um…”
Something in her voice put Dean on edge. She was worried about something. He could instantly tell.
“Bridge?” he asked, his voice soft, almost forgetting that his brother was behind him.
“I don’t know,” Bridget sighed. “It’s just, ever since I got to this town, something just hasn’t… felt right. I don’t know how to explain it.”
“Are you safe?” Dean asked, his eyes widening slightly with concern and a bit of panic. His shoulders suddenly tensed.
“I’m okay,” she told him once more.
Dean’s shoulders relaxed a bit, but there was still tension within him.
“We’re on our way,” Dean told her firmly.
“Thank you,” Bridget said quietly.
Dean nodded. She didn’t need to thank him, but she did anyway.
“Text me the details,” he instructed her.
Then Dean lowered his phone and quickly ended the call. He threw the phone onto his bed, and as it landed next to the pillow, he quickly stood up. Still holding onto the towel around his waist with one hand, he grabbed his clothes with the other.
“Start packing, Sam,” Dean said quickly as he gathered his clothes and turned to head back into the bathroom, not bothering to stop and look at his brother. “We’re leaving.”
“What’s going on?” Sam asked. He was a little concerned, but mostly because of how obviously concerned Dean seemed to be, even if he was trying to hide it.
“We have a job.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
For a drive that should have taken eight hours, Dean managed to do it in six and a half, thankfully without getting pulled over or getting into any kind of accident. It was just after six thirty in the morning when they drove the Impala into the open-plan parking lot of a very expensive, posh-looking hotel.
The hotel was only two levels, but it was large, and the building was in a U-shape. There was a pebbled path leading up to the main entrance, with several rose plants in full bloom along either side of the path.
Sam looked at the hotel with wide eyes. It looked like the kind of place that would cost a fortune just for one night.
“Are you sure this is where Bridget is?” Sam asked suddenly as he looked out his window.
Dean shrugged. “Sometimes the magazine people fork out a bit of extra cash so Bridge can stay in places like this while she works.”
Then, because he didn’t think it needed any more explanation than that, Dean turned off the ignition, grabbed the keys, and got out of the Impala without waiting for his brother.
Sam quickly got out as well and turned to look at Dean over the top of the Impala. As he closed his door, he said, “Dean, this place looks like it costs hundreds, if not a thousand, dollars to stay here.”
“Bridge is good at what she does,” Dean said quickly before he started walking down the pebbled path toward the main entrance doors.
“But, I mean…” Sam started to say as he quickly walked to catch up with Dean. “She just takes photos, why—”
Sam stopped speaking when Dean turned around and glared at him. It was only a very slight, almost non-existent kind of glare, but it was enough to make Sam realize that he was about to cross some sort of line that Dean was not going to take lightly. Sam swallowed as Dean turned back around and kept walking.
Sam paused and looked at his brother’s back in shock. Dean was definitely protective of Bridget in a way that Sam had never known him to be with anyone else in their entire lives.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Even though it was still rather early in the morning, Dean and Sam had no trouble being let into the hotel and shown the way to the elevator to take them up to the second floor. As it turned out, Bridget had already informed the hotel staff of their arrival—she had told them they worked with her and were going to help her edit her photographs.
Dean wasn’t surprised that the hotel staff were happy to oblige her request. Bridget always had this way about her that made it easy for people to trust her. She had once told him it was just because she was polite and kind.
When they made it to the door of Bridget’s room, Dean raised a hand and knocked on it lightly, not wanting to have to deal with any angry neighbors he could accidentally wake up if he knocked too loudly.
The door opened, and Bridget was standing on the other side. She was still wearing her pajamas—long pants and a T-shirt.
Dean smiled when he saw her. It had only been a few months since they had seen each other, and even less time since they had spoken on the phone—not including their chat several hours ago—but it was still nice to see her.
Bridget smiled warmly, looking only at Dean for a moment.
“Hi,” she said, then finally turning to Sam. “You guys are earlier than I was expecting.” She paused and glanced down at herself, indicating that she had planned to be dressed before they arrived.
Dean’s lips twitched up slightly as he looked at her. This certainly wasn’t the first time he had seen her wearing pajamas, and at least these weren’t as embarrassing as the matching set she had with little ducks on them.
Bridget took a step back and held the door open with one arm, then raised the other toward the inside of the room in a welcoming gesture to the Winchester brothers.
“No trouble getting in, then?” she asked as they walked into her hotel room.
Dean walked past her and shook his head. He knew she meant if they had any trouble getting past the hotel staff.
When he heard her close the door, Dean turned around to look at Bridget, his expression more serious than it had been when she had first opened the door.
“Still good?” he asked her, his voice softer than usual.
Bridget nodded, a tight smile on her lips. “I’m okay,” she said.
Dean nodded.
Sam looked down at his own feet for a moment. Bridget had told him about the code she and Dean had come up with and how saying either “okay” or “all right” was their way of checking up on each other. And for some reason, witnessing such a moment almost felt as if Sam was intruding on something.
“Hi, Sammy,” Bridget said sweetly to the youngest Winchester.
Sam tilted his head up and gave her a little smile back.
“Hi, Bridget.”
Sam then finally took in the room they were in. He had spent most of his life in and out of motels and hotels, but none of them had been anything like this—it would have been way out of their father’s regular price range.
The door led to a small but still spacious living area, with a sofa, small coffee table, and a rather large TV against the other wall. On the coffee table sat one of Bridget’s cameras with a long cord sticking out of it. The other end of the cord seemed to be connected to the side of the TV. The back wall was entirely made of glass, so you could see a view of the gardens below.
To the right of the room was a small arch that Sam assumed led to the bedroom and bathroom. To the left of the room was a small kitchenette, with marble countertops, a sink, and a small fridge, which Sam guessed was the minibar.
Sam must have been staring and totally focused because he didn’t realize that his brother had moved closer to him until he heard him chuckle slightly and felt his hand hit his shoulder.
“Wait till you see the sort of food places like this have on room service,” Dean said with a smirk.
“Sorry, Dean. I’m not covered for room service this time,” Bridget said as she walked past them to stand by the coffee table.
Sam watched as Dean pouted for a second before he followed Bridget.
Sam had to wonder how often Dean had visited Bridget while she had been staying at a place as nice as this, and how he managed to do so without their dad finding out and exposing his relationship with Bridget.
“You’ve had room service?” Sam asked Dean as he slowly walked toward him and Bridget.
Not wanting to get into when he’d had room service, and when he’d been able to have it, Dean instead ignored his brother’s question and turned to Bridget.
“So what do you have for us, Bridge?” he asked her.
Bridget nodded and picked her camera up from the coffee table. “Right, well, I was here taking photos yesterday of that tree I was telling you about.”
As she spoke, she pressed a few buttons on the camera, which caused the TV screen to suddenly come to life.
“The really old one,” Dean confirmed with a nod.
“And when I was looking over the photos last night,” Bridget continued, her eyes moving to her camera for a minute as she pressed a few more buttons, “I noticed something that wasn’t there when I first took the photos.”
The TV screen then filled with an image of an old, large-looking tree in the middle of an open field. Some distance behind it was a small woodland. There didn’t seem to be anything weird or out of the ordinary at first glance, at least not to either Sam or Dean, who were trained to spot paranormal things.
“What am I looking for?” Dean asked as his eyes roamed over the TV screen.
Bridget placed her camera gently back down onto the coffee table, then walked around it until she was right in front of the TV. She carefully lifted her arm and pointed to the far bottom-right corner of the screen.
Both Winchesters’ eyes followed the path of her finger, and that’s when they saw the black cat on the screen.
The cat was sitting, perched on top of a small rock, looking directly at the camera, its eyes glowing slightly. But that could just be the reflection and nothing more.
“It’s a cat,” Sam said, a little confused, as he had been expecting to see something like an obvious spirit, weird markings, lights, or something.
“It’s a cat that wasn’t there when the photos were taken,” Bridget pointed out, turning away from the screen to look at Sam.
Sam turned to her and then looked back at the cat. There didn’t seem to be anything out of the ordinary about it. In fact, Sam was starting to wonder why they had dropped everything and rushed over here for something as insignificant as this.
“Maybe you just didn’t notice it at the time,” Sam said carefully, slightly shrugging his shoulders. “It is a little out of view. I mean, if you were focused on the tree.”
Bridget shook her head slightly and folded her arms gently over her chest. Her stance was determined and yet not off-putting.
“I would have noticed a cat, Sammy,” she told him.
Sam opened his mouth to say that maybe this time she hadn’t when Dean suddenly spoke.
“She would have called it over and picked it up,” Dean murmured, his eyes still on the cat on the screen.
Bridget looked at Dean and then turned to Sam and nodded.
Dean looked at the cat for another moment. He knew that Bridget loved animals. The only reason she didn’t have a pet of her own was because of all the traveling she did. The closest thing she had was Bobby’s dog.
If there had been a cat or any other animal, Bridget would have called it over, given it a few pats, picked it up, and maybe even tried to sneak it back into the hotel with her.
“Still,” Dean said, seeming to think out loud as he stood a bit straighter and turned away from the screen. “A random cat appearing out of nowhere isn’t really much to go on,” he said as he turned to Bridget.
“I know.” Bridget sighed as she dropped her arms to her sides. “It’s just…” She glanced at the cat on the screen and then looked back at Dean. “…something doesn’t feel… right.”
Dean’s eyes locked with hers, and he could instantly tell that something was making her feel uneasy. Growing up with a hunter meant that Bridget was more wary about certain things. That made her more cautious, of course, but she wasn’t usually one to stress over nothing.
So if she wasn’t feeling right, or if something was upsetting her, then it could mean that maybe something weird was going on.
“Okay.” Dean nodded once. “We’ll go check it out.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Dean and Sam sat in the Impala in the hotel parking lot, mostly in silence, waiting for Bridget to get dressed and join them. They had agreed to look around the tree in her photographs to see whether they could find the black cat or figure out whether something was going on that might require their expertise.
Sam still wasn’t sure if it was worth looking into just because of a cat that Bridget had obviously failed to notice at the time. Especially when they had other, more important things they could be doing, such as getting in contact with their dad to see if he had found anything new about the yellow-eyed demon or even trying to track it down themselves.
“Dean, are we really going to investigate just because Bridget didn’t notice a cat?” Sam asked. He tried to keep his tone neutral so it wouldn’t be so obvious that he found the whole thing a little ridiculous.
It wasn’t so much that Sam was against helping people. It was just that it had been months since their run-in with the thing that had killed their mom and Jessica, and the more unrelated hunts they went on, the more anxious he became about the whole thing. He feared that the longer they left it, the harder it was going to be to find it again.
“I told you, Bridge would have noticed it,” Dean said quickly, looking out his window as he waited for Bridget. He turned his head to look at Sam and added, “And yes.”
Sam just looked at his brother as Dean turned back around to look out his window. The thought occurred to Sam that maybe if it had been anyone else—anyone—Dean would be on the same page as he was about all of this. But because it was Bridget, it became a different story.
Sam noticed Dean sit up a little straighter and shift in his seat. When Sam turned his own gaze away from his brother to look out the window as well, he saw Bridget, now dressed and carrying two small bags over her shoulders. One looked like a purse, while Sam assumed the other was to carry her camera in.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Once they reached the old tree, the Winchesters and Bridget took their time looking around. Bridget took photos in case anything else showed up later; Sam held his EMF device and checked for abnormal activity, and Dean just looked around.
After several minutes with no readings on the EMF device and nothing strange showing up around the tree or the surrounding area, Sam sighed and turned the EMF off.
“There’s no readings,” Sam said.
He turned to Dean and Bridget, who were standing close to each other as they both looked down at the screen on Bridget’s camera, going over the photos she had just taken.
“Nothing in the photos either,” Dean said, his eyes still on the camera.
“The cat didn’t appear right away,” Bridget said, turning to look at Dean. When Dean looked up to meet her eyes, she said, “It wasn’t until I was looking the photos over last night that I saw it.”
Dean nodded.
Bridget looked back down at her camera and frowned slightly. She looked almost puzzled.
“We could look again, Bridget,” Sam offered, although he believed it would be a waste of time.
“No, that, that’s okay,” Bridget said quickly as she lowered her camera. She smiled slightly as she looked over at Sam and said, “You were probably right. I must have just... missed seeing the cat at the time.”
“You sure?” Dean asked, his eyes shifting over her face.
He could tell that she didn’t fully believe what she was saying. She was smiling to reassure them, but he could see in her eyes that she didn’t mean it. For whatever reason, she still felt uneasy in this town, which wasn’t like her. She traveled all over and did fine in new places, even towns that tended to be a little bit on the creepy side.
“We could check out the tree’s history,” Dean suggested suddenly, making both Sam and Bridget turn to him. “See if anything comes up,” he added with a slight shrug of his shoulders.
Bridget shook her head slowly. “No, I don’t want to put you out—”
“ - You’re not—”
“ - How about I buy you two some breakfast?” Bridget asked, cutting Dean off. “I’m thinking you came straight here and didn’t stop anywhere to eat?” she asked, looking at Dean and then turning to Sam. “I feel like I owe you for wasting your time—”
“ - Not a waste of time, Bridge,” Dean muttered firmly, just loud enough for her to hear.
Bridget looked at Dean and smiled a little, but this time her smile was more genuine than before.
While Sam hadn’t been able to hear what his brother had just said, it didn’t stop him from feeling a little awkward as he watched the two people in front of him standing very close together.
Shifting nervously from one foot to the other, Sam said, “Actually, we should probably get going. Ah, you know, check in with Dad.”
Dean turned away from Bridget and looked at Sam over his shoulder, giving his brother a stern look, as if to silently tell him to keep his mouth shut, or at least keep his opinion that they should be leaving to himself.
“We still need to eat, don’t we?” Dean asked, but it was rhetorical. He turned back around to Bridget and grinned as he asked hopefully, “Room service?”
Bridget shook her head, but her smile grew bigger.
“Still not covered.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To Dean’s disappointment, they hadn’t gone back to the hotel for room service. Instead, Bridget had given them the address to a little café in the middle of town. It was the kind of place with a large outdoor seating area, round tables, and a large umbrella over each one. They went inside to order and then sat at one of the outdoor tables.
As they ate their food and talked, Dean tried to think of a task he could give Sam that would allow him and Bridget some time alone together. He wanted to be able to talk to her and see what she was really feeling. He knew she wouldn’t want to worry Sam or make it seem like she didn’t believe them when they said nothing was going on. But if it were just him and her talking, Dean knew she wouldn’t pretend. She wouldn’t be worried about how she sounded to him.
And even though there hadn’t been anything abnormal going on, Dean could tell that Bridget wasn’t at ease. And if Dean were being honest, something didn’t feel right to him either. It was a gut feeling that there was something going on that he just couldn’t put his finger on. He also wondered if he could come up with an excuse to stick around a little longer, just until Bridget was feeling better.
They were halfway through their food when Sam changed the subject from Bridget’s current job to why she had called them.
“How come you called us and not Bobby?” Sam asked after taking a bite of his omelette.
“You two were closer,” Bridget replied matter-of-factly.
Sam blinked at her for a moment, looked over at Dean—who was busy shoveling bacon into his mouth—then looked back at Bridget and nodded.
Sam found himself a little surprised because Bridget wasn’t saying that she thought they were closer. No, she was implying that she knew they were closer. Because she must have known exactly where he and Dean had been, or at least had a rough idea. And that meant that she and Dean had been in contact recently, and he had been giving her updates on where they were.
Though he shouldn’t have been that surprised. Over the last few months, while he was still getting used to the idea of his brother having a friend he contacted regularly, he was beginning to understand just how close Dean and Bridget were. If she was, in fact, just a friend like Dean argued she was, then she was more than just a casual friend. There was clearly something deeper going on.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
After breakfast, the three of them made their way back to the Impala, which was parked behind the café in a small parking lot. The plan was for Dean and Sam to drop Bridget back at her hotel and then be on their way. Dean, of course, was trying to think of any reason he could come up with that would give them an excuse to stick around a little longer.
“You sure you don’t want us to look into the tree’s history?” Dean asked Bridget as he walked next to her toward the Impala.
Bridget turned to him and shook her head slightly.
“No, I’m sure you won’t find anything... except boring tree heritage stuff,” she told him.
By this time, they had reached the Impala and were all standing along the driver’s side. Dean turned around and leaned his body back against the driver’s door, folding his arms over his chest and trying to act casual and nonchalant. He wanted to hang around a little longer, if for no other reason than to spend more time with Bridget, but he knew Sam was eager to get back on the road and contact their dad. So he wanted to make what he said next seem like no big deal.
“Couldn’t hurt to look around,” Dean said with a shrug. “Towns like this, there’s usually something going on.”
Dean tried to keep his gaze on Bridget, but out of the corner of his eye, he could see Sam standing behind her with a look on his face that clearly said he was about to start protesting the idea.
Which, of course, he did.
“Dean, there’s—” Sam began, but stopped when Bridget made a surprised noise.
“Oh...” she said as she stared out into the parking lot.
“What?” Dean frowned, pushing himself off the Impala.
Bridget pointed toward the parking lot and whatever she was looking at.
“I think that’s the cat from my photos,” she told them.
Sam and Dean both turned in the direction she was pointing. There, standing in the middle of the parking lot a few feet away from them, was a completely black cat. It slowly sat down and then turned its head in their direction.
“You two see it too, right?” Bridget asked. She was trying to joke, but something in her tone sounded uneasy.
“Yeah,” Dean said slowly.
It looked like a normal cat—not that Dean had been around a lot of cats before. Yet there was something...off about it. Years of experience told Dean that something wasn’t right here.
Dean turned back to Bridget and was suddenly very concerned because, as she looked at the cat, there was a hint of fear in her eyes. It was clear that whatever was making him feel uneasy was making Bridget feel the same way.
Dean turned back to the cat, and as he did, he saw the cat’s yellowish eyes start to glow just slightly. And not in a light-reflecting-off-the-sun kind of way, either. No, this was definitely a paranormal-shit kind of glow.
It was then that something suddenly came whizzing toward them through the air. Something small and fast.
“Ah!” Bridget suddenly winced in pain.
Dean spun back to face her, and his eyes went wide in shock when he saw her face. Whatever had come toward them had struck Bridget across the cheek, leaving a purplish bruise and an open cut across her skin.
“What the hell?” Dean asked, raising one hand and gently running his fingers beneath the bruise.
“Dean—” Sam said suddenly, getting Dean’s attention.
Behind him, Dean heard the cat hiss loudly, but he didn’t care about that. He only cared about Bridget and making sure she was okay.
Bridget’s eyes went wide, and before Dean could ask her any questions or even react, there was suddenly a barrage of what looked like rocks coming toward them from the direction of the cat. Some of the rocks appeared to be as big as Dean’s palm. They were coming out of nowhere, and they were coming fast.
Within a matter of seconds, they were hitting their target—Bridget.
It was almost as if the rocks were zeroing in on her and her alone. No rocks seemed to be hitting Dean or Sam, and the Impala looked like it was completely untouched.
Bridget winced and cried out in pain over and over as she was struck again and again. Within milliseconds, Dean could see cuts and bruises appearing over her arms, legs, and chest wherever the rocks hit her. Sam tried to shield her from the rocks, but they seemed determined to strike her and only her.
On instinct—or maybe out of dumb luck—Dean suddenly pulled his handgun from the back of his waistband, spun around, and aimed it in the direction of the cat. He fired twice, one bullet seeming to hit the cat right in the face.
The cat turned into a pile of blackish-purple smoke and disappeared.
The moment it did, the rocks stopped coming.
Dean spun back around just as Bridget gasped and her legs gave out. Quickly, Dean moved forward and grabbed her, helping her stay upright.
Sam also grabbed onto Bridget and helped Dean pull her back to her feet, but he let go once she was standing straight again.
Dean held Bridget in his arms, supporting most of her weight as she regained her breath. She looked scared, and he wanted to reassure her, but he had no idea what the hell had just happened.
“Let’s go to the hospi—” Sam began to say, but stopped suddenly.
Dean was too focused on keeping eye contact with Bridget and silently letting her know that he had her and she was okay. He had no idea what had made his brother stop talking until his eyes darted from Bridget’s eyes to the rest of her face.
The cut and bruise that had been there only moments ago had vanished.
As if they had never been there in the first place.
Dean let Bridget go, keeping one hand on her hip as he tilted his head down to look at the rest of her body. All the bruises and cuts that had covered her body were now completely gone. If he hadn’t just seen them with his own eyes, he would have sworn they had never happened.
Dean lifted the hand that wasn’t already resting on Bridget’s hip to her face and gently brushed his fingertips against the spot where her face had been cut moments ago.
“I don’t think I’m okay,” Bridget barely whispered, still in shock.
The concern in Dean’s expression was impossible to miss as he nodded, the hand on her hip tightening slightly.
“Maybe,” Sam began softly as he looked at his brother and Bridget. “There is something here after all.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Back at the hotel, after making sure that Bridget was okay, they got straight into research mode, which meant that Sam and Bridget had their laptops out. Sam stood in the kitchenette with his laptop on the marble counter, while Bridget sat on the sofa with her laptop on the coffee table in front of her. Dean was sitting at one end of the sofa, holding their father’s journal—which their father had not asked for back since they’d been in contact with one another again.
Dean’s eyes would scan a page of the journal and then dart over to Bridget to make sure she was okay. She seemed focused on whatever was on her laptop screen, but Dean could tell she was still freaked out by what had happened.
“Nothin’ in here,” Dean murmured after he’d reached the end of his dad’s journal.
He closed the journal and tossed it onto the coffee table, where it landed just next to Bridget’s laptop.
“We could call Dad,” Sam suggested. “Or Bobby. See if they—”
“—No,” Bridget called out suddenly, quickly turning to look at Sam.
Both Dean and Sam looked at her curiously.
“I-I just don’t want to worry Granddad,” Bridget explained, shaking her head slightly.
Dean and Sam turned to look at one another, sharing a silent agreement that they wouldn’t contact Bobby—at least for now.
Sam turned back and looked down at his laptop.
“What did it, uh, feel like?” he asked, still looking at the screen in front of him. “When the rocks were…”
“Painful. Like I could feel them hitting my skin,” Bridget explained, a frown crossing her face as she remembered what it had felt like.
As she spoke, Dean stood up from his place on the sofa and walked toward the kitchenette. At first, Sam thought his brother was coming to look over his shoulder and see what he was looking at, but instead, Dean walked past him to the minibar.
Sam turned and watched as Dean opened the door of the minibar, leaned down and pulled out a bottle of water, then closed the door as he stood back up before silently walking over to the sofa where Bridget was sitting.
“And then they just sort of… went away,” Bridget continued while Dean was getting the drink. “Physically, I feel fine now.”
Dean walked around to stand behind the sofa. Without saying a word, he reached out with the bottle of water, extending it past Bridget’s head and holding it in front of her. She took it and turned to give him a grateful smile.
Dean nodded once in response.
“What I don’t get,” Dean began as Bridget took a sip of her water, “is what the hell does a cat, an old tree, and some rocks have to do with each other?”
At hearing Dean’s question, a thought suddenly popped into Sam’s head. He looked at the other two, wide-eyed for half a second as his mind started working.
“I don’t know about the tree,” Sam said as he turned back to his laptop and started typing quickly. “But the cat and the rocks might mean we’re looking at witches.”
“Witches?” Bridget asked.
She stood up from the sofa and walked over to stand beside Sam. Dean moved over and stood beside her.
“Back in the sixteen hundreds, there were a lot of witch trials going on,” Sam explained, looking up from his laptop. “They became really popular.”
“Like Salem,” Dean stated.
“Yeah.” Sam nodded. “But they actually took place all over the country. They just weren’t all as well known as Salem or even documented.”
“You saying this town had its own witch trials?” Dean asked.
“It kind of fits,” Sam said, nodding his head. “One way witches would be executed during these trials was by being stoned to death.”
“Being pelted nonstop by rocks,” Bridget confirmed. Not because she knew the history of it, but because she had just recently experienced it.
“And witches really did just hang around with black cats like freakin’ Sabrina?” Dean asked, arching one eyebrow.
“Well, it wasn’t unheard of for witches to have… a spirit animal,” Sam said. “That could explain the cat.”
“So, we’re looking at one of these witches’ spirits?” Bridget asked, looking at Sam and then at Dean.
“An angry witch’s spirit, by the looks of it,” Dean agreed. “So how do we stop it, Sam?” he asked, turning to his brother.
Dean walked around until he was standing right next to Sam so he could look directly at the screen of Sam’s laptop and see if his brother had found out how to stop what was happening. Dean frowned when, after a quick scan, he realized that all that was there was an Internet site describing what a “stoning” actually was.
“I don’t know,” Sam replied. “We have to find out which spirit we’re dealing with first.”
Sam turned back to his laptop. He nudged Dean slightly to give himself more room and started typing on the keyboard. He tried to search for any mention of witch trials taking place in this particular town, but nothing seemed to be showing up. He even tried searching supernatural-based online public threads and posts, but still nothing.
“There’s nothing online about any witch trials in this place,” he announced. “At least, none that I can find.”
“Hmm.” Bridget hummed and bit her bottom lip as she thought for a moment. “Older towns like this usually have a rich history documented in journals or historical documents somewhere, right?”
“Is there a library here?” Sam asked.
Bridget nodded. “Yes, on the west side of town. A decent-sized one, too.”
“I say the library’s our best bet.”
“Okay, let’s go,” Dean said as he started walking toward the door. He grabbed the door handle and held it open. Using his other hand to gesture for Sam and Bridget to leave the room, he added, “Let’s figure out who we’re dealing with before that demon feline and its rocks come back.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
This town’s library looked like it was built for researchers. It was situated in a rather large, older building, with dozens of shelves full of books and a few round tables in the middle, clearly designed for those who wanted to sit and read or study. There was also another set of long, rectangular tables toward the left with several computers on them.
After arriving at the library, Sam had asked the librarian—an older lady with short gray hair and glasses—where they could find information about the town’s history, saying the three of them were history students from a nearby university. The librarian showed them a few sections where they might find what they needed, including old historical records and journals, as well as the digital archives on the computers.
Sam said he’d go check out the archives on the library’s own computer network first and then mentioned looking somewhere else. To be honest, Dean wasn’t really listening to him. He was more focused on Bridget. Dean followed Bridget as she moved to a row of books in the “local history” section of the library.
He watched as she moved along the shelf, touching the spine of each book with her index finger, her face looking like she might be concentrating. To anyone else, it might have looked like she was contemplating the title of each book and thinking about whether or not she was interested in it... But Dean knew she wasn’t really seeing the books in front of her. He knew she was thinking about—or more like trying not to think about—what had just happened.
She had shared with them what it had felt like when she’d been... attacked and had the rocks hit her, and it was clear that she didn’t want to talk about it anymore. Dean wouldn’t push her, in the same way she never pushed him. Helping them research what was going on probably seemed like a good start to distracting herself, but Dean wanted to be able to help her more. ’Cause he hated when something was bothering her.
He was still standing at the start of the row of books while Bridget had already made it to the middle. She hadn’t even noticed that he hadn’t moved with her. Dean got an idea and quickly glanced around where they were before spotting a small display bookshelf across from them. He turned to look at Bridget, seeing her finally grab one of the books and open it up, then turned back and quickly strode over to the small display shelf. Without looking, he grabbed one of the books from it before making his way back over to Bridget.
“Here.” Dean held the book he’d just grabbed just above the open one in her hands. “Thought this could be your book from here, if you haven’t done that yet,” he added with a shrug.
Bridget, who had been slightly startled when Dean had placed the book in front of her—not because she was focused on the book in her own hands, but because she was remembering the feeling of the rocks hitting her skin—blinked a few times before focusing on the cover of the book he was holding below her face.
It was a copy of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl.
The worried frown that had been on her face moments before was now replaced by a soft, thankful yet amused smile.
With one hand, she reached up and took the book from Dean, while her other hand put the book she had been attempting to read—and failing—back on the shelf in front of her.
“When I get books from the places I visit, I tend to get them from bookstores,” she told him as she looked down at the book he’d given her and then back up at him. “Not from libraries. Or I’d have a lot of overdue book fees under my name.”
“I’ll make you up some fake IDs,” Dean said, a smirk forming on his lips. “Then it won’t matter.”
The smile on Bridget’s face grew ever so slightly, and that made Dean feel good. One, because it meant that he had accomplished his goal of trying to take her mind off what had happened, and two, because he always just felt better when she smiled.
The reason Dean had grabbed the book for her was that he knew that she had this little tradition. When she went to a city or town she had never been to before, she would buy a book and take it back with her. She’d never keep the books. Instead, she would take it with her to the next new place and leave the book at a thrift store or other donation place before buying another new one. The book itself didn’t matter as long as she could say she picked it out in the place she had been.
The whole thing probably started from not being able to have many books when she was growing up. Dean had asked her once why she got rid of the books after she had read them instead of just keeping them at her apartment, and she had told him that it was because she wouldn’t have much room left in her apartment if she did that. There was also something nice about being able to pass a book on to someone else.
Dean had never been much of a reader himself, except when he needed to look things up and research for a job—like what they should be doing now, but had left that task to Sam temporarily. But he knew that it was something Bridget enjoyed.
“Why Charlie and the Chocolate Factory?” Bridget asked. “Where did you get this from?”
Dean shrugged and pointed behind him in the vague direction of where he had gotten the book. Bridget leaned slightly to look past him and noticed the section he must have gotten the book from straight away.
Across from where they stood was a small display of books with a sign above it that read, “Revisit the Classics.”
Bridget straightened herself back up and nodded gratefully.
She reached out and placed a hand on Dean’s arm before saying, “Thank you.” She looked back down at the book and added, “But I’m going to put this back.” Looking back at Dean with a smile, she said, “I would rather not start a life of crime by stealing from a library.”
Dean chuckled slightly as she let go of his arm and started walking toward the display shelf to put the book back.
“But as soon as... this witch thing is dealt with,” Bridget called softly behind her as she walked, “I’ll find this exact book for sale before I leave.”
Dean turned and followed Bridget, watching as she set Charlie and the Chocolate Factory back down on the smaller bookshelf.
“Hey,” Dean said softly once he was standing beside her again. “We’ll figure out this whole ‘witch thing,’ and we’ll stop it. Don’t worry.”
When Bridget turned to face him, Dean had expected her to look nervous or unsure, but instead she looked calm—at least calmer than she had looked minutes ago, before the distraction of a book had interrupted her thoughts.
“I know you will,” she told him honestly. “I feel like whatever is happening, at least I’m in good hands.”
“Yeah.” Dean nodded with a serious look on his face.
She was in good hands. At least, Dean swore to himself that he wouldn’t stop until this witch—or whatever was doing this—was long gone, Bridget was safe, and she felt okay again.
He was confident because he knew he and Sam had a pretty good track record when it came to their hunts. He refused to think about the unsuccessful ones right now.
As they spoke near the row of “classic” stories, neither one of them noticed that Sam had started approaching them but had stopped several feet away.
Sam had been on his way to get their attention and bring them over to the computer where he’d been working to show them what he had found so far. He should be annoyed that they were standing around talking while he was the one actually doing the research, but when he had gotten close enough to hear what they were talking about, it made him stop and hesitate.
Their conversation appeared to be somewhat casual as they spoke about books—which in itself seemed weird to Sam because he’d never in a million years thought he’d hear his brother talking about books—but there was something in Dean’s body language that caught Sam’s attention. Dean was, to put it bluntly, on edge. Sure, they had been on hunts before where things seemed harder than normal, but this was clearly different. It was very clear to Sam that Dean’s uneasiness had everything to do with the fact that this hunt involved Bridget.
For a second, Sam tried to think if there was a way he could avoid showing them what he’d found out because he knew they weren’t going to like it.
“Ah, hey!” Sam called out, trying to act as if he had only just seen them instead of the truth that he’d been observing them for a minute.
“Found anything, Sam?” Dean asked as he looked over at his brother.
“Yeah.” Sam nodded and waved one arm, indicating that he wanted his brother and Bridget to follow him. “You better come take a look.”
Sam watched as Dean and Bridget shared a quick look before they both turned and walked over to him together.
Sam led them both to the very last computer in a row of several on the long table. He also had several books and newspaper clippings spread out around it. Sam sat down in front of the computer while Dean gestured for Bridget to take the seat next to him. Dean moved behind both of them to look over their shoulders from his standing position.
Dean noticed a few people glancing and frowning at them, most likely annoyed by how much space Sam had taken up. But that wasn’t Dean’s problem.
“What have you found?” Bridget asked, and if Sam picked up the hint of concern in her voice, he didn’t mention it.
“I did a lot of digging, but this town wasn’t known for having witch trials—” Sam started to say.
“—I thought you said we were dealing with a witch’s spirit?” Dean interrupted irritably, trying to keep his voice low.
“We are,” Sam said quickly. “That’s what I was saying. This place wasn’t known for having a lot of witches around, which is why I think I’ve found who we’re dealing with.”
Sam turned and pulled over an older-looking journal. He flipped through the pages for a second before stopping on the one he was looking for. He pushed the open book in between himself and Bridget so that she and Dean could get a better look at its contents.
“I did manage to find several stories and pieces of folklore that talk about a woman named Agnes Davis,” Sam explained as Bridget and Dean both looked over the pages in front of them.
“And she’s our witch?” Bridget asked, looking up from the book and over at Sam.
“Well, I can’t see anything that confirms she was a witch,” Sam explained. “But she was definitely accused of being a witch, and the townspeople had their own mini trial for her because of it.”
“Vengeful spirit using a black cat to stalk people. Sounds like a witch to me,” Dean huffed, folding his arms over his chest.
“She could be manifesting as a witch now because of what was done to her,” Sam said as he turned to his brother.
“What happened to her?” Bridget asked suddenly.
Sam looked away from his brother and over at Bridget. She looked concerned, but this time she seemed to be concerned over the fate of a woman who had died centuries ago.
“I’m not sure of all the details,” Sam began slowly, pausing to look over the various forms of information before them. “But from what I have managed to find so far, Agnes was accused of being a witch, and then the townspeople... well, they...”
“What, Sam?” Dean asked, his voice low but demanding.
“They subjected her to several... trials over a few days,” Sam said slowly. “She was tortured.”
Sam watched as a mix of fear and anger flashed behind Dean’s eyes. Not for the injustice that this Agnes woman had gone through, but because of what this could mean for Bridget, who had already seemed to have been a victim of one of the things that Agnes had been through.
“Like stoning?” Bridget asked, her voice soft and sad.
“Yeah.” Sam nodded, turning back to her. “I’m still trying to find out what else she went through, but, uh... there’s something else—”
“What?” Dean demanded from his spot behind them.
“After the, um... after what happened to you, Bridget, I wanted to see if anything like that had happened before,” Sam said, speaking quickly, like you would when you knew you were about to give bad news but wanted to get it over with quickly. “There have been cases of women over the years dying in mysterious ways.”
“What do you mean? Mysterious ways how?” Bridget asked.
“Well, about five years ago, a woman was found in the back of the local grocery store. The autopsy determined her cause of death as severe internal bleeding due to multiple blunt force trauma, only—”
“—only there were no markings on her,” Bridget said, finishing Sam’s explanation as she remembered how quickly her own cuts and bruises from the stones had vanished.
“Have there been any other victims?” Dean asked, leaning forward a bit.
Sam looked at his brother and then back at Bridget and nodded regretfully.
“Yeah, a lot, actually. Always women,” Sam explained. “I can’t seem to find any pattern to connect when the deaths are happening. The last one, like I said, was five years ago. Before that, seven years, then three years before that. The timing of it is all over the place, which might be why it hasn’t been flagged by local police.”
“That’s not usual for this sort of haunting,” Dean said, confused. “Are they at least happening around the same time each year?”
“No,” Sam said, shaking his head.
“Have you found anything that, um, connects the victims?” Bridget asked, her eyes looking over the materials in front of them.
Again, Sam shook his head. “Other than they’re all women...” He paused and raised his hands slightly before shrugging one shoulder. “There’s nothing I’ve been able to find.”
“Oh.” Bridget sighed.
“I’ll keep looking,” Sam reassured her quickly.
From behind them, Dean stood up straight and looked down at Bridget. He could tell just by looking at her that she was worried for herself, but also feeling regret and sorrow for all those women who had already died because of this particular witch.
Not caring about hiding his concern in the moment, Dean placed a firm hand on Bridget’s shoulder, making her turn her head to look over at him.
“You said we’re dealing with this Agnes chick, right?” Dean asked, his hand still on Bridget’s shoulder but his face turned toward his brother. “So let’s find out where she’s buried and torch her bones.”
“That might be easier said than done, Dean,” Sam said pointedly. “Finding the location of someone who died that long ago isn’t going to be as easy as just looking it up. And even if we did find her, there’s no guarantee that burning her bones will stop her.”
“What do you mean?” Bridget asked, frowning slightly. “I thought burning a spirit’s bones was meant to force them to... move on?”
“Not if they’ve attached themselves to something,” Dean explained, knowing exactly what his brother was talking about. “Like jewelry, paintings... dolls.”
“There’s an antique store in the middle of town,” Bridget told them, looking from one brother to the other. “So if we’re looking for something very old, it will probably be there, right?”
“It’s a start,” Sam agreed with a nod.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
With two tasks to complete, they had decided to split up and get them both done at once. Dean had gone to the antique store to see if there might be anything that was knowingly connected to this Agnes person, while Sam and Bridget had gone to the town’s rather large cemetery in the hopes of being able to find Agnes’s burial place.
Dean hadn’t been exactly thrilled with Bridget choosing to go with Sam instead of him, even though she had said she thought having two people search the cemetery made more sense, and she wanted to be out in the fresh air. Dean had agreed, as he understood that she wasn’t trying to get away from him but probably thought he’d be able to get his task done quicker without her.
And if he had to trust anyone with her safety, it had to be Sam, right?
After all, they were just looking around some graves. If they found anything, they were going to call him.
Now, Dean was walking around the decently sized antique store. Well, weaving around it, more like. It wasn’t exactly the most organized place. In fact, it felt less like a store and more like he had stumbled into some hoarder’s house. There didn’t seem to be any form of organization to anything, which meant Dean had no idea where he should even start looking.
‘The hell with this,’ he thought as he looked around the massive mess in the store.
He turned and made his way over to the sales counter. The cash register sat on top of a glass display case. The case was filled with knickknacks, various pieces of jewelry, and glasses and plates. There was a woman standing behind it. She looked like she was in her sixties or seventies and was wearing glasses. Dean approached, hoping that maybe she could help him.
“Hi,” Dean said, smiling and trying to use his best charm. “I was wondering if you could help me with something?”
“Of course,” the woman said cheerfully, eager to maybe make a sale. “Are you needing help looking for something in particular?”
“Yeah.” Dean nodded. “I’m doing some research on some of this town’s history. You ever heard the story about Agnes Davis by any chance?”
“Oh yes, that’s a well-known tale,” the woman replied. “She was accused of being a witch during the times when witch trials were very popular.”
“Right. You wouldn’t happen to know if there’s anything she might have owned that’s still around, would you?”
The woman smiled proudly and nodded. “Actually, I do have something.”
She turned around and walked over to the wall behind her, where she grabbed a set of keys hanging from a nail. Then, with the keys in hand, she walked back over to the display case in front of Dean. He watched as she knelt down and opened the case, sliding the glass door to the side before reaching in and pulling out a brooch the size of his palm.
The brooch looked like it was made of bronze, but it had faded over the centuries. It was shaped like a flower, with several small red stones in the middle and a few pearls placed around the petals. It was sitting on top of a navy-blue felt pillow as the woman stood up and placed it on top of the counter.
“This belonged to Agnes,” the woman announced. “At least, that’s what I’ve been told. It’s been passed down through generations. Apparently, it was found with Agnes’s body.”
Dean bent down and looked at the brooch, studying it for a moment. It certainly looked like it came from the 1600s, and if the owner of an antique store was pretty sure that it did belong to Agnes Davis, then there was a good chance that it did.
Standing back up, Dean tried once again to put on his best charming smile as he asked, “How much does something like that go for?”
“Oh, it’s not for sale,” the woman answered as she shook her head. When she saw the slight frown on Dean’s face, she added, “Sorry. It’s just a rich part of this town’s history. I couldn’t part with it.”
“Are you sure?” Dean asked, trying not to sound desperate. “I’m just really interested in the whole Agnes story. Owning that would be pretty cool.”
The woman shook her head and then offered, “You’re welcome to take a few pictures if you like, but I’m afraid that’s all I can do.”
Dean nodded and pulled his cell phone out. He flipped it open and quickly took several pictures with his phone’s camera. Then he watched the woman pick the brooch back up and bend down again to put it back into the display case. He knew full well that he would be back later and would steal the damn brooch if he had to.
“It’s such a tragedy, isn’t it?” the woman said as she relocked the case.
“What is?” Dean asked curiously.
“You know, what happened to poor Agnes and how it was her husband who first accused her of being a witch,” the woman said, in a tone that suggested she thought Dean already knew this piece of the history. “The story goes that he wanted to be with another woman, so to get rid of poor Agnes, he accused her of being a witch. They say he led the rest of the town on a mission to hunt and torture Agnes. It’s such a heartbreaking story, really.”
“Yeah,” Dean said with a nod, hoping the woman couldn’t see that this was the first time he was hearing any of this. He was surprised none of this had come up in Sam’s research, but maybe he had been distracted by the news that this Agnes woman had already killed dozens of women.
“You happen to know exactly what the townspeople did to Agnes?” Dean asked suddenly.
“You don’t know?” The woman raised an eyebrow in confusion. Clearly, she believed that she was talking to some sort of expert.
Dean shrugged. “I, uh, I’ve only just started my research on her. I know she was stoned. Is that what killed her?”
“Well, there are a few different versions of the specifics of what happened,” the woman explained. “The main one I’ve heard was that Agnes was eventually hanged, and that’s what killed her.”
Dean nodded and muttered, “Ah, thanks,” before turning around and walking straight out of the store.
The moment she had said that Agnes had been hanged, the first thought that went through Dean’s mind was Bridget. She had already been subjected to being stoned because it was something that Agnes had suffered through before she died, but if she had also been hanged, it meant there was a good chance Bridget was now in danger of that happening to her.
And that thought scared the shit out of Dean.
Once outside, Dean opened his cell phone and called his brother.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
At the same time Dean was investigating the antique store, Sam and Bridget were walking around the town’s massive cemetery, trying to see if they could locate a grave that indicated Agnes Davis was buried there. They had immediately ignored all of the newer, more recent graves and instead made their way toward the back, where it was clear the older graves were located. There were several large trees scattered around the middle of the rows of graves, as if the cemetery had been built around them.
Not many of the graves had tombstones. Most had plaques set into the ground, while others simply had an old, half-deteriorated white wooden cross marking them. They had been searching for several minutes, with Bridget walking along one row of graves and Sam walking along another.
After a while, Bridget stopped and looked over at Sam.
“Sammy, a lot of these don’t even have names on them. How are we supposed to find which one belongs to Agnes?”
Sam stopped and looked over at her. He sighed in defeat, knowing she was right. Most of these graves had no markings, and the ones that did were extremely difficult to read.
“I don’t know,” he answered honestly. “I guess we just... hope we find something.”
Bridget nodded, and Sam caught the concerned look in her eyes.
Sam had been surprised that Bridget had volunteered to go with him instead of going to help Dean. He would have thought, given what he now knew about their friendship, that they would want to spend more time together. But they were still in the habit of trying not to be too open about whatever they had between them when he or anyone else was around.
Sam had managed to catch certain conversations and interactions between his brother and Bobby Singer’s granddaughter, like at the library earlier that day and while Dean had been fixing the Impala, but Sam knew those moments were only brief glimpses into their relationship. He was still curious about so much of their friendship.
One thing he did know was that Dean’s feelings for Bridget were a lot stronger than those of a simple friendship, no matter what his brother said.
“Maybe if I look into a little more about Agnes’s history, it might help us narrow down where she might be buried,” Sam suggested after they looked at a few more graves.
He could tell how nervous Bridget was getting, and he found himself wanting to reassure her and help her feel better.
“I don’t think it will help,” Bridget said with a sigh. “We’re talking about bones that are four centuries old. Even if we did find some reference to where she could be, that doesn’t mean she’s still going to be there.”
Sam made his way over to her. She was standing beneath one of the trees, looking down at one of the unmarked graves beneath it.
“Maybe Dean’s had better luck,” Sam offered.
He pulled his cell phone from his front jeans pocket with the intention of calling his brother for an update when a noise behind them startled him.
The noise had been an unmistakable meow.
Sam and Bridget turned and looked over their shoulders. Standing just a few feet away from them was the same black cat they had seen before. Its eyes seemed to be glowing even brighter than the last time they had seen it.
“Brid—” Sam began.
At the same time, the cat meowed again, louder this time.
Then suddenly, Bridget’s entire body flew up into the air, and she screamed.
Sam spun around, wide-eyed, and watched as Bridget’s body hung from one of the branches of the tree. A rope had appeared, one end wrapped around the branch and the other looped around Bridget’s neck in a noose. Her legs kicked helplessly as her hands flew to her neck, desperately trying to pull the rope away from her throat. She struggled to breathe, gasping for air.
All of it happened within seconds of the cat appearing.
Sam’s momentary shock was replaced by years of hunting instinct. He quickly pulled his gun and spun around, aiming it at the cat. He fired several shots, hitting the cat in its side. Just as it had when Dean had shot at it, the cat turned into a cloud of blackish-purple smoke and disappeared.
Sam had just enough time to turn around and catch Bridget as the rope disappeared and she dropped toward the ground. The sudden force of her fall sent them both crashing to the ground, with Bridget gasping for breath and rubbing her neck.
Sam quickly sat up and pulled her into a sitting position as well so he could look her over and make sure she was fine.
“Are you okay?” he asked quickly, his eyes darting over her.
Bridget’s eyes were wide, still filled with shock and panic from what had just happened. She licked her lips and shook her head rapidly.
“I—I don’t know.”
Sam could see a clear rope burn across her throat. He watched as it suddenly disappeared, just as the cuts and bruises from the rocks had before.
“We—” Sam began when suddenly the shrill sound of his ringtone filled the air.
Sam grabbed his phone, which he had dropped when Bridget had been pulled into the air. He flipped it open and answered, knowing it was going to be Dean. Then he stood and offered Bridget a hand to help her up as well.
As he pulled her to her feet, Sam noticed that she was a little shaky.
“Dean—” Sam began, but Dean interrupted him.
“ - Turns out this Agnes chick was hung as well as stoned, so—”
“Yeah, we know,” Sam replied.
“Sam, put Bridge on the phone,” Dean suddenly said, his voice firm and serious.
Sam didn’t hesitate. He could hear the clear dread in his brother’s voice.
Quickly, Sam passed his phone to Bridget, who immediately pressed it against her ear.
“Bridge, what happened?” Dean asked, his voice alarmed but gentle as he tried to remain soft for her sake.
“I’m alright, Dean,” Bridget said softly, a slight quiver in her voice.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
The three of them had quickly met back up in Bridget’s hotel room after what had happened at the cemetery.
Bridget had insisted that she was feeling better with each passing minute and had excused herself to take a long, hot shower. Even though all the marks had vanished, she could still feel the rope around her neck and needed a long wash to get rid of the sensation.
While Bridget was busy in the shower, Sam sat on the sofa with his laptop back out in front of him on the coffee table. Dean, on the other hand, was pacing around on the other side of the coffee table, caught somewhere between anger and frustration.
Dean was angry at this Agnes chick for terrorizing Bridget, but he was also angry at himself. He couldn’t stop blaming himself and thinking that if he had insisted Bridget come with him, or if he had sent Sam to the antique store and gone with Bridget to the cemetery himself, he could have stopped her from being attacked.
Another part of him understood that there was nothing Sam could have done to prevent it from happening and that Bridget probably would have been attacked whether he was with her or not. He also knew that Sam would have done the same thing he would have done if he had been there. That didn’t stop Dean from blaming himself.
“What the hell happened, Sam?” Dean demanded, trying to keep his voice low so he wouldn’t disturb Bridget in the shower. He continued pacing, only looking at Sam occasionally.
“I told you, we were at the cemetery when we saw the cat,” Sam explained, his head turning in time with his brother’s pacing. “The next thing, Bridget was in the air with a rope—”
“—And you fired a shot at the cat,” Dean said, more as a recap than a question.
Sam nodded.
“Great. At least we know shooting the demonic furball in the face stops it for a little bit.” Dean huffed as he continued pacing.
Sam watched his brother and realized that he needed to do something to calm him down. He knew Dean was getting close to the point where his anger could get the better of him, and he needed him to stay focused.
“Dean, you said the antique store had a brooch that belonged to Agnes.”
“Yeah.” Dean finally stopped pacing and turned to look down at his younger brother. “It looked old enough. And since you couldn’t find any graves, that could be our only shot.”
Sam nodded.
“Did you find out anything else?”
“Apparently, Agnes was accused of being a witch by her husband,” Dean explained, shaking his head slightly. “Dude wanted to bang some other chick, and I guess starting a town witch hunt was easier than getting a divorce.”
“That would explain why she became a vengeful spirit,” Sam said thoughtfully.
“If she was done dirty by her husband, then why are all her victims women?” Dean demanded. “Why not seek her revenge on men?”
“I don’t know.”
And Sam really didn’t. On paper, it made way more sense for a spirit like Agnes to attack and murder men, considering she had been so deeply betrayed by a man in her life, but that didn’t seem to be the case.
“Yeah, well, whatever the reason is, I don’t give a damn,” Dean spat angrily. “’Cause whatever she went through, she’s now making Bridge go through it, and we need to stop it before—”
A terrible thought suddenly occurred to Dean, and a feeling of dread filled him as something he knew about witches entered his mind.
“Weren’t witches burned at the stake?” Dean asked, trying to keep his panic in check.
Sam shook his head quickly. “In Europe, yes. But there’s no evidence that there were any witch burnings in the United States.”
Sam watched as the tension in Dean’s shoulders halved as he let out a short breath. It was clear he was still anxious about what was going on, but at least knowing that burning wasn’t something they had to worry about seemed to make him feel a little better.
“So this brooch thing is our only lead right now,” Dean said with a sigh after a moment of silence.
Dean then heard movement behind him and turned around to see Bridget walking into the room. She was no longer wearing her dress and was instead wearing a pair of sweatpants and a T-shirt. Her hair was still damp and had curled slightly around her face.
“Hey,” Dean said softly.
Any trace of frustration had completely disappeared from his voice, replaced with something much softer. It was actually very interesting for Sam to witness.
Dean walked over and met Bridget halfway across the room. His eyes quickly darted over her, taking extra time to look at her neck and where he assumed the rope had dug into her skin.
“You doing better?” he asked her, his tone still soft.
She answered with a short nod.
They held eye contact for a brief moment, almost forgetting that Sam was even in the room with them. There was definitely more than friendship here, at least in Sam’s eyes.
“So, um… what do we do now?” she asked, moving her eyes from Dean to Sam and then back again.
“Like Dean said, this brooch is our best shot,” Sam explained.
Dean held an arm out and gestured for Bridget to go and sit on the sofa. She did, sitting down next to Sam while Dean remained standing. Sam tried not to let his gaze linger on either of them, but it was a struggle. He couldn’t help but be fascinated by the way they were with one another.
“I’ll go back to the antique store tonight and steal it,” Dean told them.
Dean had moved and was now leaning against the glass wall while still keeping his eyes on Bridget as she sat next to Sam.
Sam nodded and opened his mouth to say something when Bridget spoke.
“How much do you think the brooch is worth?” Bridget asked, looking over at Dean.
Sam turned to face her and frowned.
“We’ll need to destroy it,” he told her quickly, frankly a little shocked that she didn’t already understand. “We can’t resell it.”
“I—” Bridget started to say but was interrupted by Dean.
“She’s asking ’cause she wants to leave money for it,” Dean explained as he folded his arms over his chest and rolled his eyes.
“Wait… what?” Sam asked, turning back to look at Dean.
“Bridge,” Dean sighed, shaking his head. “That’s not how stealing works.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
That night, Dean took Bridget back to the antique store to steal the brooch. It would have made more sense for Sam to join him, but Dean wanted to make sure it got done, and after what happened at the cemetery, he also wanted to keep Bridget close. So when he heavily suggested that she join him, she didn’t argue. She simply got changed, and together they waited until it was very late before leaving Sam in the hotel room.
Breaking into the store had been surprisingly easy. At least for Dean, who had learned to pick locks at an early age and carried a lock-picking kit with him. Thankfully, there didn’t appear to be any high-tech security system in place.
With flashlights in hand, they moved through the store until they came to the display counter where Agnes’s brooch was being kept. Dean briefly pointed his flashlight at the wall behind it, hoping that maybe the old lady who owned the place had a bad habit of leaving her keys out overnight, but the nail that had previously held the keys was now empty.
So instead, he pulled out his lock-picking set again, placed his own flashlight on top of the case, and bent down to start picking the lock. Bridget moved to stand beside him and shined her own flashlight on the lock to give him some light to work with.
“Thank goodness you’ve mastered the art of lock picking and stealing,” Bridget told him as she watched him easily get into the display case.
He could tell she was joking, but there was also a hint of appreciation and pride in her voice.
“Well, they’re valuable skills to have,” he agreed as he heard a click, signaling that he had successfully opened the case.
As he slid the door open, he added, “Especially when my best friend decides to get herself targeted by a dead witch.”
“I just wanted to take some photos of a tree,” Bridget said with a pout.
Dean looked up at her with a sympathetic expression before continuing his task of reaching into the display case and pulling out the brooch.
“I’m your best friend?” Bridget suddenly asked, as if his words had only just caught up to her.
Dean rolled his eyes and stood up, the brooch now securely in his hand.
“This isn’t news to you, Bridge,” he told her.
She nodded.
Even though they had never said it out loud, it was pretty obvious to both of them. They were closer to each other than almost anyone else in either of their lives. If that didn’t make them best friends, then what the hell did?
“I’m glad you’re here,” she said quietly. “I feel a bit more okay, even with… you know.” She shrugged slightly.
Dean knew she was referring to what she had been subjected to during these attacks.
He nodded, put his lock-picking kit into his back pocket, picked up his flashlight, and tilted his head toward the back door they had originally entered through.
“C’mon, let’s go,” he told her. “The sooner we destroy this, the sooner we can send that son of a bitch witch packing.”
Dean led the way through the shop but stopped when he realized Bridget wasn’t following him. He turned around and opened his mouth to ask what was wrong when he saw her reach into her bag and pull out some money. She placed the bills down on the display case next to the register. Dean couldn’t see how much she had put down, but knowing her the way he did, he guessed it was a decent amount. A couple hundred, maybe.
As she turned around to start following him toward the exit, Dean rolled his eyes.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
After stealing—well, sort of stealing—the brooch, Dean and Bridget drove the Impala until they reached the edge of town. Dean figured that would be the safest place to destroy the brooch.
Once parked, Dean got out and went to the trunk, where he grabbed a can of gasoline. He walked a few feet away from the Impala and tossed Agnes’s brooch onto the ground. As he tipped the gasoline onto it, Bridget came up and stood next to him.
Dean turned around and placed the now half-empty gasoline can behind him. He took a few steps back and motioned for Bridget to do the same, which she did.
Bridget lifted her hand and opened her palm, revealing a box of matches. Dean took them from her, lit one, and quickly tossed it onto the brooch. The brooch caught fire instantly, beginning to burn and melt. Within minutes, the brooch was nothing more than a melted pile of goo on the ground.
When there was nothing left of it to burn and the fire had started to fizzle out, Dean stepped forward and stomped out the remaining flames and embers with his boot.
For a moment, they both just stared at what was now left of the brooch.
“So… is that… it?” Bridget asked as she slowly turned to look at Dean.
Dean shrugged slightly. “Should be.”
He paused and looked around before asking, “Do you see that damn cat anywhere?”
Bridget looked around for a moment before turning back to Dean and shaking her head.
“Do you still… not feel right?” he asked, his eyes looking her up and down.
Bridget swallowed and thought for a moment.
“A little,” she answered honestly. She looked in the direction of the now-rising sun and added, “I might just be tired, though.”
“Yeah?” Dean asked, his voice full of concern because he didn’t quite believe her.
When her only answer was a slow nod, he nodded back.
“Okay. Let’s go back to the hotel.”
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
By the time Dean and Bridget made it back to the hotel, the sun was up, but it was still early morning. Sam was already waiting for them in the parking lot.
Dean pulled the Impala into an empty spot and turned off the engine. He could see Sam walking toward them, but he was more focused on Bridget. As Dean looked at her, he could tell immediately that she was exhausted and fighting sleep.
Dean opened his door and got out of the Impala before making his way around to the other side. It didn’t take him long to reach the passenger side, where Bridget already had her door half open. Dean grabbed it and pulled it the rest of the way open. Then he reached out a hand, offering it to Bridget. She took it and allowed Dean to help pull her up out of the car.
By this time, Sam had made his way over to them and was standing beside the Impala as well.
“Hey, how’d it go?” Sam asked them.
“Brooch is destroyed,” Dean replied, not taking his eyes off Bridget.
Dean’s hand was still holding one of Bridget’s from when he had helped her out of the Impala moments ago. Neither he nor Bridget seemed to take notice of it, but Sam definitely did. Then Sam noticed how tired Bridget looked.
“You okay? How are you feeling?” Sam asked her.
Bridget turned to Sam and said, “I’m okay. Just tired, I think.”
Dean nodded. That made sense. She probably hadn’t slept since she had first called them for help. He and Sam hadn’t slept since then either, but they were used to going without sleep for a day or two during a hunt.
“You should go sleep,” Dean told her, letting go of her hand.
Bridget opened her mouth to say something—maybe protest and argue that she wasn’t as tired as she looked—but Dean interrupted her before any words could come out.
“Sam and I will hang around for a little bit. Then we’ll get breakfast.” Dean paused and thought for a moment before adding, “Or an early lunch, depending on how long you sleep.”
“So brunch, then?” Bridget asked, a tiny smile forming on her lips.
The same small smile graced Dean’s lips.
Then he placed one hand on her shoulder and gently spun her around until she was facing away from the Impala. He gave her a gentle push forward, sending her in the direction of the hotel entrance.
“Go,” he told her in a soft but firm voice. “Sleep.”
“Fine.” She sighed, nodded her head, and started walking.
Dean knew she was tired if she wasn’t even going to protest his request.
As she walked through the doors of the hotel, Dean continued to watch her, a look of concern crossing his face. Sam, on the other hand, took his eyes off Bridget and looked at his brother instead.
“Dean,” Sam began slowly. “If you wanna stay, I could—”
But Dean quickly interrupted him.
“—let’s just go, Sam.”
Without waiting for Sam to say anything else, Dean moved back around the Impala and climbed into the driver’s seat.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
After driving around town for a few hours—not going anywhere near the antique store—and stopping to get coffee to wake up a little more and kill some time, it was finally around eight in the morning.
With their coffees in hand, they walked around for a while, keeping an eye out for any cats. They saw a stray near a small grocery store, but it was orange, so they didn't pay it much attention.
As they walked, Dean had his takeout cup of coffee in one hand and his cell phone in the other. Every few minutes, he glanced down at his phone, obviously waiting to see if Bridget had woken up and was calling him—as if somehow staring at the screen would make her name suddenly appear on it.
Sam watched his brother with interest. It was clear that Dean was still worried about Bridget and wanted to be with her—or at least find out if she was okay. But he was still holding back when it came to his feelings about her, for whatever reason. Sam had wanted to talk to his brother about it, but the thing was, he didn't really know what to say. Anything he could think of sounded awkward in his own head, so he knew it would probably make his brother cringe.
Instead, he chose to think about Agnes and why her spirit had gone after the women it had. Sam felt like there was something else about all of this that they were missing. So, to give himself something to do while they waited around town—and to give Dean and Bridget some privacy when Bridget finally woke up—he told Dean that he wanted to do a little more research on Agnes and find out more about her story.
Dean just muttered, "Yeah, sure."
That told Sam just how much of Dean's focus was elsewhere, because he didn't even tell Sam it was a waste of time now that they'd destroyed the brooch and gotten rid of Agnes's spirit.
So Sam left his brother, choosing to walk the few blocks to the library instead of driving.
Once he was gone, Dean walked around aimlessly for a while, finished his coffee, discarded the cup in the nearest trash can, and then made his way to the little café where they'd had lunch the day before. He remembered they'd had a breakfast menu and wanted to check it out.
As he stood outside the café, looking over the menu displayed in the window, his cell phone started ringing. He stepped back from the window and quickly answered the phone, already knowing who was on the other end.
"Thought you'd be sleeping a little longer," he said as he pressed the phone against his ear.
"All these years, you've been interrupting my sleep, and now you're worried I'm not getting enough."
Dean chuckled at her joke and the reference to his many late-night calls to her. Then he became more serious, because what she'd gone through wasn't exactly something to laugh about.
"Are you okay, Bridge?" he asked her.
He could hear her sigh before she answered.
"I feel better, but I still have this... strange feeling," she admitted honestly.
"Yeah." Dean sighed softly. "I keep feeling like we're... missing something."
"Maybe we just need to get the hell away from this town."
"No arguments there." Dean agreed quickly. "Why don't I grab some breakfast, then we'll wait for you to pack your stuff and follow you?"
"Where?"
"Anywhere," Dean answered with a shrug. "Just as long as it's not this town."
"I like that plan," Bridget said gratefully. "I do want to quickly take some photos of the tree again for work."
"Don't you already have enough photos?" he asked, surprised.
"I have photos with a demon cat in them," Bridget replied quickly. "I'd rather not have photos with a demon cat in them. And I still have a job to do."
Dean wanted to argue that it would be better if they just packed up and got the hell out of Dodge, but he knew how seriously Bridget took her photography job and how much it would bother her if she wasn't able to do what she'd been paid to do. He also guessed that seeing the damn cat in the photos after everything that had happened was just another unwanted reminder.
"Let me grab some food, then I'll pick you up and—"
"I'd rather just head over now and get it over with," Bridget said quickly, interrupting him. "Plus, the sooner I finish taking the photos, the sooner we can leave. So why don't you get us something to eat and meet me there?"
"Are you sure?"
"...Yes..."
Dean hesitated to agree at first. Bridget didn't sound completely convinced, and he still had this weird feeling in his gut that there was something going on. He wasn't sold on the idea of her being anywhere in this town on her own, outside of her hotel room, but he also didn't want to worry her or stress her out any more than she already was.
"Okay," he reluctantly agreed.
"I'll be fine, Dean," she said gently, trying to reassure both him and herself.
Dean nodded to himself. Of course she would be fine.
She had to be fine.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Shortly after his call with Bridget, Dean had grabbed some breakfast for the three of them—bacon and egg rolls for him and Sam, and a fruit salad for Bridget—then tossed the food into the back of the Impala before heading to the library to pick up Sam.
He planned to quickly get his brother and then meet Bridget at the tree. As soon as she was done taking her photos, they would all drive as far away from this town as they could… or at least until they reached another town or city.
Dean pulled up in front of the library and quickly got out of the Impala, not wanting to waste any time if he didn't have to. He had only made it about halfway between the Impala and the library stairs when Sam suddenly came bursting through the doors, his cell phone in his hand. He looked like he was about to call someone urgently.
“Sam!” Dean called as he stopped walking.
Sam looked up, startled. His expression was serious.
“Dean, I was just about to call you,” Sam said in one quick breath. He sounded serious and a little worried. “Where's Bridget?” he asked as he came down the stairs.
A sudden sense of dread came over Dean at his brother's question and the tone of his voice.
“Why?!” Dean demanded.
“I was just going to call you,” Sam said quickly. “I was doing more research on Agnes and her victims, at least the ones I could find records on.”
“And?” Dean asked impatiently.
“And it looks like all of her past victims were betrayed by men in their lives somehow, but the other thing I found out was—”
“Just spit it out, Sam!” Dean snapped.
“I think Agnes eventually died after being burned at the stake,” Sam replied as quickly as he could.
“What!” Dean yelled angrily.
Dean spun on his heel and marched back toward the Impala. Sam had to almost run to reach the car before Dean could pull out of the parking spot. Once they were both inside, Dean pulled away quickly, determined to get to Bridget before anything happened to her.
“You said witches didn't get burned at the stake in America!” Dean snapped angrily, reminding Sam of what he had assured him before.
“They didn't,” Sam replied, looking at his brother and then back at the road ahead of them, which was passing by far too quickly. “But I guess someone from this town heard about what they were doing in Europe and decided to have their own burning. I think that's why I wasn't able to find out that Agnes was eventually burned. They wouldn't want that to be well-known knowledge, since it doesn't exactly look good for the town's history.”
Sam glanced back at his brother and could tell by the way his knuckles were turning white from his harsh grip on the steering wheel that he was becoming increasingly distressed at the thought of something happening to Bridget.
“Dean,” Sam began carefully. “You already destroyed Agnes's brooch, so it's probably going to be fine—”
“Probably isn't good enough, Sam,” Dean hissed through clenched teeth.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
The Impala’s tires screeched to a stop as Dean roughly pulled it up beside Bridget’s Volkswagen Beetle in front of the old tree. Looking ahead, the first thing Dean noticed—or didn’t notice—was that he couldn’t see Bridget. She was nowhere near the front of the tree. Panic started to rise within him.
Next to him, Sam turned and noticed something.
“Dean!” Sam warned, his eyes wide as he nodded slightly.
Dean quickly whipped his head around to see what his brother was talking about. Standing to the side of the tree was a woman; only she seemed transparent—a spirit. She had long, light brown hair and was wearing old, tattered rags. She seemed to be staring at something behind the tree, out of view of Sam and Dean.
Agnes.
It had to be the spirit of Agnes. Destroying the brooch hadn’t stopped her.
Without a second thought, Dean grabbed his shotgun, which was lying next to him on the front seat, then quickly opened the car door and jumped out. Sam grabbed his own handgun and got out of the Impala just as fast.
“Hey, bitch!” Dean spat angrily as he raised his gun and aimed it at Agnes.
Dean was in a state of half panic and half anger, which was probably why he was pointing a gun at a spirit instead of thinking about how that wouldn’t really work.
Agnes didn’t turn. She didn’t even acknowledge him. Instead, she just kept looking at whatever was behind the tree.
Sam was now beside Dean, his own gun raised and pointed at Agnes. He looked at the spirit. She seemed almost sad. Then he turned to Dean, and that’s when Sam noticed the smoke. Dark, thick clouds of smoke were starting to come from around the tree.
“Dean, look!” Sam yelled.
The moment Dean saw the smoke, his heart dropped.
Fearing the worst and moving on pure instinct, Dean suddenly dropped his gun and started running as fast as he could. His eyes were wide with adrenaline and fear as he ran past Agnes’s spirit, not even caring about her anymore.
Sam ran as well, following his brother, but managed to keep hold of his own gun.
Behind the tree, Bridget was standing frozen, her arms pinned to her sides as if something invisible were holding her in place. She was coughing and gasping for breath, tears running down her face as her expression showed just how terrified she was. Flames surrounded her legs, moving upward from a fire that seemed to have started out of nowhere. The flames grew bigger with every second, climbing higher up her torso.
Dean didn’t seem to notice any of that because he just kept running. He didn’t stop. He ran at full speed until he reached the fire and tackled Bridget, knocking both her and himself to the ground. They twisted around in the process, causing Dean’s body to take most of the impact as his shoulder came crashing against the ground with a thud.
The flames didn’t stop. Instead, they shifted, now engulfing both Bridget and Dean as they lay on the ground.
Dean rolled them over so that Bridget’s body was underneath his, protecting her from the flames.
“DEAN!” Sam yelled.
Sam took a step forward, but the flames suddenly grew bigger, and the heat coming off them became almost unbearable, causing Sam to take half a step back.
It was then, in the midst of his fear and panic, that Sam remembered Agnes. He moved quickly toward her, now standing a few feet away from her, and raised his gun, pointing it directly at her face again.
She didn’t flinch. She simply continued to stare at the couple on the ground.
“Hey!” Sam yelled, trying to get Agnes’s attention.
Sam watched in confusion as a sad yet understanding smile began to spread across Agnes’s face.
Very slowly, Agnes turned her head toward Sam and nodded once.
Sam’s eyes widened with confusion and shock because he wasn’t sure what to make of her expression. He was even more confused when she spoke.
“Sorry,” she whispered, deep regret evident in her voice.
Sam watched as Agnes looked away from him and turned back to Dean and Bridget, who were not making a sound. Dean’s body was still shielding Bridget’s, and he was holding her against him as tightly as he could.
As she looked at them, Agnes raised her arms out in front of her and tilted her head back slightly.
To Sam’s shock and amazement, the flames and smoke that had been engulfing his brother and friend suddenly pulled back and spread across the ground as they made their way toward Agnes herself.
Within a matter of moments, the flames had consumed Agnes, climbing up her body and encasing her from head to toe in record speed.
Sam’s arm dropped, and he held his gun at his side as he watched.
The orange-red flames began to mix with blackish-purple smoke as Agnes’s body began to deteriorate.
Agnes turned her face toward Sam one last time and smiled gently. Then her face became covered in flames like the rest of her body.
Behind him, Sam heard the unmistakable sound of a cat meowing loudly, and before he could turn around, the feline that had started them on this hunt ran past his legs toward the burning Agnes.
The cat jumped into the flames, and after a sudden whoosh, both the cat and Agnes were gone, consumed by the flames.
Sam stared at the spot where Agnes—and the cat—had just been, now nothing more than a small pile of ash. He had no idea what the hell had just happened, only that Agnes’s spirit was now gone.
Then, from the corner of his eye, Sam saw Dean and Bridget still on the ground.
“Dean,” he gasped before quickly making his way over to them, not knowing in that moment whether they were okay.
With Bridget still beneath him, Dean slowly began to sit up and look around. He had no idea what the hell had just happened. One minute Bridget had been in danger, and the next... well, the next thing he knew, the spirit was gone, and so was the fire. The heat and pain he had felt from the flames moments ago were now gone.
Dean placed a hand on Bridget’s shoulder and gently pushed her so that she rolled over to face him before grabbing her upper arm and helping her sit up. His eyes rapidly searched her face and body, making sure she was okay. Any burns or marks she had suffered from the fire had disappeared as if they had never even been there.
Dean sat on his knees as Bridget sat in front of him. Both of his hands were now on her arms while her hands gripped his elbows, holding onto each other.
“You okay?” Dean asked her, his eyes moving over her again before coming to rest on her own.
Tear streaks still ran down her cheeks from where she had been crying from the pain and fear of what was happening, but she quickly nodded her head.
“I’m okay,” she said, slightly out of breath, then repeated it a few more times. “I’m okay. I’m okay.”
At her words, the tension in Dean’s body began to fade because he knew she wouldn’t lie about that—not after what they’d just been through.
“Are you okay?” Bridget asked, her own concern for him and his well-being showing clearly as her voice broke slightly.
“Yeah,” Dean murmured, moving his right hand up to splay it across her neck, his thumb stroking her jaw. “I’m okay.” He told her softly as he leaned forward and placed his forehead against hers before taking a deep breath and closing his eyes.
He’s okay.
He nearly lost her, but he didn’t.
He didn’t, so he’s okay.
Dean and Bridget were so focused on one another that neither of them remembered that Sam was standing right in front of them.
Sam couldn’t help but stare at them as a realization suddenly hit him. It came to him as suddenly as something falling and crashing onto your head. Something he felt stupid for not noticing before.
For months, Sam had been convinced that there was something else going on between Dean and Bridget—something more than ‘just friends’—but it wasn’t until now, until he had seen Dean risk his life for Bridget and now watched them hold each other, that it finally clicked into place for the youngest Winchester.
This wasn’t just friendship.
This was love.
His brother was in love with Bridget.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
After they had made sure that neither Dean nor Bridget was hurt in any way by the fire—and after Sam had asked if either of them wanted to go to the hospital just to be sure, which they had both declined—they all drove back to Bridget’s hotel in the Impala, with Sam sitting in the back so Bridget could sit in the front with Dean. They didn’t even mention what was going to happen to Bridget’s car, and surprisingly, Dean didn’t even make a joke about leaving it there for good.
On the drive back, Sam couldn’t stop thinking about what he’d come to realize as he sat behind Dean and Bridget, trying not to stare at them. He watched as Dean kept glancing over at Bridget, obviously making sure she was still okay.
As he watched them and thought over the encounters he’d witnessed between the two of them since they’d been at Bobby’s, along with the number of times Dean had insisted they were only friends, Sam had to wonder if maybe his brother was actually in denial about what his true feelings for Bridget were—or maybe he just hadn’t fully realized them himself.
Maybe it was because of their lives. Or their dad. Or maybe it was because his brother had convinced himself it was easier that way. Whatever the reason, though, Sam found himself feeling bad that this was a feeling his brother couldn’t—or wouldn’t—admit to.
Once they arrived at the hotel, Bridget invited them both back up to her room.
“I’m guessing you two could probably use a drink from the minibar,” she told them. “You’ve earned it.”
So the Winchester men followed her to her room. All the while, Dean stayed pretty close to Bridget while Sam hung back, hesitating over whether or not to voice his concerns or just keep them to himself.
It wasn’t until they reached the room and Bridget went inside first that Sam finally made up his mind.
“Ah, hey, Dean,” Sam called softly.
Dean had one foot inside the hotel room but stopped and turned to look at his brother. It was then that he noticed Sam was standing away from the door, clearly indicating that he didn’t intend to join them in the hotel room.
“…I…um…” Sam mumbled, trying to find the right words.
This had the potential to be very awkward.
“What’s your problem, Sam?” Dean huffed, annoyed with his brother.
Then, as if deciding within himself exactly what he wanted to say and how he wanted to say it, Sam let out a short sigh and fixed his brother with a serious yet understanding gaze.
“I’m gonna go for a walk,” Sam announced.
Dean’s brow arched in confusion, and he opened his mouth to ask why, but before any sound could come out, Sam kept talking.
“You know, I loved Jessica,” Sam said suddenly, yet his voice remained gentle. “I mean, I really loved her. I was in love with her, man.”
“Sam. What are you—”
“And when she died, it hurt. More than I can explain,” Sam continued, feeling both happy remembering what he’d shared with Jessica and saddened by the grief of her death. Even after all this time.
Dean’s expression was now one of confusion and deep concern. Why was his brother bringing this up now?
“Because of that, I’ll probably never get close to anyone again. Not like that, anyway.” Sam added with a shake of his head. “But I…I also know that…” Sam paused and looked thoughtfully at his brother. “That if Jessica was here…I wouldn’t waste any opportunity I had to be with her. No matter how terrified I was about our lives or anything else.”
Sam gave Dean one last look as his brother continued to stare at him with the same confused and concerned expression. Sam didn’t think he needed to say more. He hoped his big brother understood what he was trying to tell him. What he was trying to convey.
Without another word, Sam slowly turned around and headed back toward the elevator, leaving a slightly stunned Dean behind.
Dean frowned as he watched his brother for a long moment, until Sam entered the elevator and disappeared behind its sliding silver doors.
Dean knew that his brother was trying to tell him something in his own confusing, cryptic way. Dean just had no idea what that message was.
Sam’s words started replaying in his mind.
I loved Jessica.
I was in love with her.
I wouldn’t waste any opportunity to be with her.
And it was then—those words—that made something inside Dean Winchester suddenly snap as he understood not only what his brother had been trying to tell him, but also what he had been denying to himself for months…even years.
Slowly, Dean turned and walked into Bridget’s hotel room.
Bridget was in the kitchenette, standing in front of the minibar with the door open as she looked down at what was inside. As he watched her, Dean slowly closed the door and made his way toward her, his steps soft yet determined.
Bridget heard him and turned around, closing the door of the minibar as she did so.
“I wasn’t sure what you wanted,” she said, referring to the drink selection.
Instead of answering her, Dean took a step toward her until he was a breath away. He carefully placed one hand on her hip, smoothing out the fabric of her dress against her skin, while his other hand reached up to her cheek, his warm palm resting against her skin as his fingers lightly played with her earlobe.
Bridget let out a soft sigh.
Dean swallowed, knowing his next move could either be really good or really bad.
His eyes roamed over her face, lingering on her lips for a moment before moving back up to her eyes. When he was pretty sure he could see exactly what he was thinking—what he was feeling—reflected in her eyes, he did what, if he was honest with himself, he had wanted to do since that night in the rain.
Dean leaned in and closed his eyes. He saw hers flutter shut as well.
Then, very lightly, he pressed his lips against hers.
To be continued…
Next chapter: Long Time Coming
