Actions

Work Header

Chapter 9: Perfect Family

Chapter Text

Chapter Nine ~ PERFECT FAMILY

Somehow, it was decided that the task of clearing the table and doing the dishes would fall to the men, while the women would relax in the living room and wait for them.

Doing the dishes together was never really something they did. More often than not, their dishes consisted of paper plates and plastic forks that got thrown away after one use. And on the rare occasions that they did have actual dishes; they would sit in the sink untouched for days until John—or sometimes Dean—finally got to them. This interaction was casual, as if it happened often. It was nice.

John was actually enjoying doing the dishes with his sons. Or with Sam, at least. Instead of helping, Dean was sitting at the table with his chair turned to face Aislin in her highchair as he spoon-fed her the custard he had purchased when they had gone shopping earlier.

Apparently, the custard was too messy for her to feed herself.

This left John standing at the sink, washing dish after dish before handing them off to Sam to dry and stack on the table to be put away. John didn’t mind that Dean was otherwise preoccupied, but Sam was getting a little annoyed.

“Thanks for the help, Dean,” Sam said sarcastically.

Dean looked up from Aislin, the plastic spoon he was holding dipped into the bowl of custard.

“Dude, I’m feeding my daughter. Calm down.”

“We could swap,” Sam suggested. “I could feed her for a bit.”

Sam placed the plate he had been drying on the stack of clean dishes, flung the dish towel over his left shoulder, and moved to stand behind Dean. He grinned down at Aislin, who was looking at the bowl of custard in Dean’s hands, waiting for him to give her more.

Dean looked over his shoulder at Sam for a moment before shrugging.

“Okay, Sam,” Dean agreed. “Let's have Aislin choose.” He turned back to his daughter. “Okay, baby, do you want Daddy to feed you or” —he waved back at Sam — “Uncle Sammy?”

Aislin looked at Sam. She smiled slightly, obviously very comfortable and happy around her uncle, but then her eyes went back to Dean.

“Da!” she yelled, giggling.

Dean looked back over at Sam, a triumphant grin on his face.

“Ha!” he yelled.

John smiled and shook his head in amusement. He was ninety-nine percent sure that, at this age, Aislin couldn’t really understand what she was being asked and was more likely just happy saying the sound "Da," but he wasn’t going to point that out to his sons.

“Yeah, well, of course she’s going to choose you,” Sam told Dean as he whipped the dish towel off his shoulder and skulked back over to John. “You’re her favourite.”

Dean’s smile grew even wider as he turned back to Aislin.

“I know.” He held the spoon out and gave her another mouthful of custard, using his other hand to gently push her little hands away as she tried to grab the spoon. “Don’t think so, missy. You’re messy enough.”

“Let's see if you're still the favourite when she’s older and I get to be the fun uncle,” Sam muttered, still clearly annoyed.

“Oh, get over it.” Dean rolled his eyes. “Can’t help it if Aislin’s a daddy’s girl. Can we, baby?” he added, smiling at Aislin.

“I don’t know if she has favourite people,” John began, his hands busy washing one of the wine glasses. “She probably just has a stronger bond with you, Dean, because you’re her father.”

“Everyone has favourite people, Dad,” Sam told him. “Parents have favourite children.” He pointed out.

John froze for a moment, his hands going still in the soapy water.

He turned to Sam and frowned.

“Parents don’t have favourites.”

Both Sam and Dean scoffed in disbelief.

A heavy weight suddenly settled in John’s stomach. Their response suggested that either he or Mary clearly favoured one of them over the other, which meant maybe their relationships weren’t as strong in this version of reality as John had first been led to believe.

Suddenly, the horrible words the demon had said to Dean through John's mouth when he had been possessed slammed into his mind like a brick.

"Sam—he’s clearly John’s favourite. Even when they fight, it’s more concern than he’s ever shown you."

The demon had taunted Dean with such confidence, but what stung John more than the words themselves was how Dean had reacted to them. He hadn’t looked upset or even shocked. It was almost as if he accepted them as fact, as though he truly believed his father valued his brother more than him.

At the time, John remembered hearing his own voice screaming inside his head, telling the demon to shut up and stop, even before Dean had started to bleed.

“Your mom and I don’t have a favourite child,” he told them as seriously as he could, leaving no room for doubt that he was speaking the truth. It was something he knew he needed to make equally clear when he woke up and spoke with the real Dean.

His gaze lingered on this Dean for longer than it probably should have.

“Oh, please,” Dean muttered, not believing John at all.

“Dean—” John wanted to protest, to make his son understand that he loved them both the same.

“—Mom definitely has a favourite child,” Sam interrupted with a laugh.

John turned to him, his brow furrowing in confusion. Sam sounded happy that Mary had a favourite child. Did that mean he thought he was the favourite? It didn’t make sense. The Mary John knew loved both her boys equally, and he didn’t doubt that she always would, no matter what happened.

Dean nodded in agreement with Sam.

“I’m sure your mom doesn—” John began.

Dean interrupted him, looking toward the kitchen doorway and yelling, “Hey, Mom!”

There was a brief pause before Mary’s voice floated in from the other room.

“Yes, Dean?!” she called.

“Who’s your favourite child?!” Dean shouted.

The second Dean had gotten the ‘D’ sound out in the word ‘child’, Mary answered without hesitation.

“Aislin!” she yelled back.

John stared at his sons in shock.

Sam and Dean both turned to him with grins on their faces.

“Told ya!” they said triumphantly.

John had to laugh.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

After the dishes had been done and Dean had given Aislin another quick wipe-down because, despite his best efforts, she'd still managed to get a little custard on herself, the three Winchester men joined their respective partners in the living room. Mary, Jessica, and Dean took up the couch, with Bridget sitting on the floor, her back against it and her side pressed against one of Dean's legs. Sam sat in one of the two armchairs, while John sat in the other.

John had Aislin on his lap, cooing at the toy Sam had given her as he waved it around every now and then. His attention drifted between her and the conversation. He was enjoying having the little girl with him. He still couldn't get over the bond he seemed to feel with her. He had never experienced anything like this in any other dream before. Hell, he couldn't say he had ever experienced it in real life either. Sure, he adored his sons, but this was a different kind of love he couldn't put into words.

More wine had been poured for everyone—except Bridget, who was still only drinking water. The conversation turned back to Sam and Jessica's new engagement.

"Have you two chosen a date yet?" Mary asked the newly engaged couple.

"Not yet," Sam answered. "We haven't really decided how long we want to stay engaged."

"We were thinking we'd stay engaged for at least a year. Save up a bit before we get married," Jessica added.

"Plus, some of Jessica's family might think we're too young to get married right now," Sam added. He shrugged before continuing, "So it might just be easier to wait."

Bridget scoffed and shrugged. "Hey, I'm the same age as you, Sammy, and I've already got a baby." She smiled over at him.

Dean placed a hand on her shoulder and smiled down at her.

Sam gave them a sly grin as he teased, "But no ring yet."

Dean grabbed the small decorative cushion from behind him and hurled it toward his brother. It hit Sam on the side of the head. Instead of being annoyed or angry, Sam just laughed, clearly more pleased with the reaction he'd gotten from annoying his brother than anything else.

"Not that I'm pushing," Mary began gently, turning to Dean and clearly ignoring the fact that he had just thrown one of her cushions, "but have you two considered..." She trailed off, knowing she didn't need to finish the question.

John watched as Dean rolled his eyes and leaned his head back against the top of the couch. Bridget remained where she was, but she didn't seem bothered by the direction the conversation had taken.

John realised that although he'd noticed the lack of rings on Dean's and Bridget's fingers, he couldn't say he thought it made any difference. Perhaps because, for him, just knowing that Dean was in an apparently long-term relationship and had a daughter was enough to adjust to. Whether they were married or not didn't seem to matter.

However, from Dean's reaction, John had to wonder whether this question came up often. Perhaps there had been pressure put on Dean and Bridget to get married one day, and he wondered whether having Aislin had only made that pressure worse.

"Well, we wouldn't be able to get a ring now," Bridget began. "We wouldn't want to steal Sammy's thunder." Her tone made it sound like this should have been the most obvious reason in the world. Then, in a falsely annoyed tone, she added, "Thanks, Sammy."

Dean smirked, his head still tilted back. He lifted it, leaned forward, and reached out to gently grasp Bridget's chin. Tilting her head to one side, he bent down and murmured, "Thank you," before giving her a brief kiss.

"You're welcome," she murmured back.

John couldn't help but smile. It seemed his mind had created just the right woman for Dean. The emotional connection between them was unmistakable. Maybe his mind had simply created someone who could give Dean the same kind of relationship John had once shared with Mary.

Bridget smiled, resting a hand on Dean's knee and absent-mindedly rubbing circles over it as she turned to Jessica.

"Back to your upcoming wedding," Bridget said cheerfully. "Have you got any plans in place at all? Or are you just waiting until you set a date?"

"There are a few things I think we've already settled on." Jessica nodded, looking over at Sam with a smile. "I'd really like to get married at the same church where my parents were married."

"Oh, is that the one with the white roses along the front path?" Bridget asked.

Dean twitched his leg to get her attention. "How the hell do you know that Bridge?"

"Because I pay attention when people show us holiday photos," she replied, twisting her head back to look at him. "Unlike you."

"And the fact that you're a photographer and can't help but study photographs has nothing to do with it?" Dean asked with a half-shrug.

"Nope." Bridget grinned. "Just being polite."

"We also know that we'd like Aislin to be our flower girl," Jessica told them, adding, "Obviously."

"Oh," Mary sighed, looking over at Aislin on John's lap. "Wonderful. She'll make the most adorable flower girl."

As if on cue, Aislin threw her new caterpillar toy onto the floor, almost like a flower girl scattering petals with a little too much enthusiasm. John wrapped one arm more securely around her back so he could bend down and retrieve the toy with the other without risking her slipping from his lap.

Dean laughed. "You don't have to audition, baby. You've already got the job."

John smiled as Aislin reached eagerly for the caterpillar when he held it out to her again. She giggled, and the sound filled his heart.

"Another benefit to having a longer engagement… Aislin might be able to walk down the aisle by then," Sam said with a proud smile directed at his niece.

Bridget smiled and nodded while Dean rested his hands on her shoulders, rubbing them gently. They both wore proud expressions as they watched their daughter happily play with her grandad.

"They're both great starts," Mary said.

"Actually," Sam began, a sly grin spreading across his face as he shared a look with Jessica, "there are two more things we've already figured out." He paused and nodded once at Jessica.

Jessica grinned back before looking down at Bridget.

"Bridget, would you be one of my bridesmaids?"

"What?" Bridget looked genuinely surprised. Her head whipped back and forth between Jessica and Sam. "Really?"

Jessica grinned and nodded vigorously.

"Yes. Of course." Bridget beamed.

She placed a hand on Dean's knee and used it for leverage as she stood. Then she sat on the couch between Dean and Jessica so she could give Jessica a big hug. Dean didn't move over for her. Instead, he simply let her lean comfortably against one of his legs.

"And Dean, I was kind of hoping you'd be my best man?" Sam asked with a huge grin.

"What's in it for me?" Dean asked with a completely straight face.

Still hugging Jessica, Bridget flung a hand backwards and smacked Dean on the arm. Not hard, but certainly not softly either.

"Dean!" Mary exclaimed at the same time, clearly concerned by his response.

Dean chuckled. He had, of course, been joking, but he seemed to enjoy the reaction he'd gotten from his mother. Maybe it was his way of getting back at her for the whole "Why aren't you married yet?" conversation.

"Nah, just kidding, Sam. Of course I'll do it."

"I thought so—" Sam began.

"—Not wearing a tux, though."

Sam scoffed. "My wedding. My dress code," he said firmly.

Mary laughed, clearly happy that Dean was going to be involved in the wedding.

In this dream, it was clear that even though they lived far apart, Dean and Sam were very close. In real life, John knew they had become close after travelling together for so long over the last year, but they had been anything but close before that. He also knew that his own relationship with Sam had become terribly strained when Sam left for Stanford and, as a consequence, Sam and Dean's relationship had suffered as well.

Watching Sam ask Dean to be his best man was not something that would have happened in reality had Sam been able to ask Jessica to marry him. John couldn't even say for sure whether he and Dean would have received an invitation to the wedding.

John smiled to himself as he watched his family before him. Sam and Dean were teasing each other without any real annoyance fuelling their jabs. Mary seemed thrilled to have everyone home. Jessica and Bridget both seemed to fit perfectly into the Winchester family, completely at ease, as though they'd always belonged there.

This was the biggest thing that John, Dean, and Sam had missed out on because of the demon who had killed Mary: the chance to create happy family memories like these.

As he watched them, he couldn't help but feel guilty. Maybe he shouldn't have focused on revenge so much. Maybe he should have tried harder to give his sons a normal life.

He looked down at Aislin, who was staring up at him. He smiled softly at her.


Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

As the evening went on, they continued to enjoy the flow of conversation.

Aislin had been passed around quite a bit. Not that she seemed to mind, as she smiled and babbled at everyone. She had been sitting on Sam’s lap for the last twenty minutes or so. Every now and then, Sam bounced his knees up and down, causing the little girl to giggle. The proud grin across Sam’s face showed how much he loved being able to make her laugh like that.

It was clear to John that Sam really did like being an uncle and would always be there for that little girl.

After one last knee bounce and giggle, Sam stood up with Aislin in his arms. He bounced her gently as she reached out to grab his hair.

“Anyone want more wine?” he asked, smiling at Aislin.

“Oh, I’ll get them, Sam—” Mary began.

“—No, I got it, Mom,” Sam told her. He walked over to stand in front of her and lowered Aislin down, offering her to his mother. “I know you’ve been waiting for cuddles anyway.” He laughed.

Mary laughed and smiled widely as she reached out and took her granddaughter, settling her onto her lap.

John wondered if this was how these gatherings usually went—with Aislin being passed around like the collection plate at church. Again, though, she didn’t seem to mind as she now focused her attention on her grandmother.

Sam started collecting everyone’s glasses.

“I’ll help, Sam,” Bridget offered as she stood from her position on the couch between Jessica and Dean.

While holding her own glass, Bridget turned and took the glass Dean was holding out.

“You know, Sammy, I’m actually surprised,” Bridget said.

“About what?” Sam asked.

“I would have thought you’d want us all at some fancy, posh restaurant to announce your engagement,” she told him.

“I did think of it,” he admitted. “But I didn’t want to give the secret away too soon.”

Bridget laughed and started walking out of the living room.

“I’m also surprised Dean didn’t already know.”

“Actually, he did know,” Sam admitted, shrugging one shoulder as he walked beside her.

Bridget suddenly stopped walking, causing Sam to stop as well.

They were now standing just behind John, and he had to twist his head slightly to see them properly.

“What?” Bridget asked slowly.

Sam turned to face her, looking confused.

“Yeah, I told him about a week ago...” Sam trailed off as, clearly, the same thing that was now catching John’s eye also caught Sam’s.

Behind Bridget, Dean stood, frantically waving his hand back and forth across his neck, making the universal sign for "cut it out" or, in this case, "shut the hell up." He was shaking his head and glaring at his brother.

Clearly, Sam had no idea why Dean was doing any of that because he kept talking to Bridget.

“…I couldn’t wait until we got here.”

Dean frowned at his brother just as Bridget turned around and frowned angrily at him.

“Oh, you cheated, Dean!” she accused.

“I didn’t—” Dean began to defend himself.

“—Cheated on what?” Sam interrupted, obviously very confused about what the hell was going on.

“They had a bet,” John answered. He was a little nervous, hoping this wasn’t about to turn into an uncomfortable fight between Dean and Bridget.

Mary and Jessica watched as Bridget walked right up to Dean. Mary seemed a little concerned but not especially worried. Jessica looked... amused.

“A bet about what?” Jessica asked.

“About what you and Sam wanted to tell everyone. I said it was going to be about that internship, and Dean said you were going to tell us Sammy proposed.” Bridget kept her gaze fixed on Dean. “You cheated. You already knew Sammy was going to tell us he was engaged.”

“I may have technically left out some key bits of information,” Dean said with a shrug. It was clear he knew arguing was pointless now, so his only choice was to admit his mistake.

“Key bits of - You already knew the outcome,” Bridget said accusingly, shaking her head in disbelief. “Now you can forget about your win. It doesn’t count.”

“What were the terms this time?” Sam asked.

This time. That told John these sorts of bets must have been common between Dean and Bridget.

At Sam’s question, Bridget’s cheeks turned a very slight shade of pink, and she bit her bottom lip for just a fraction of a moment. John had not actually heard what Dean wanted if he won the bet, but he could tell by Bridget’s reaction that it was something private.

“I think because Dean cheated, Bridget should win by default, and Dean should do whatever it was she wanted,” Jessica said thoughtfully.

Bridget’s eyes lit up as Dean’s lowered into a scowl.

“Yes!” she said at the exact same time Dean said, “No!”

Sam was grinning now.

“Why? What did you want, Bridget?”

“I get to drive the Impala while Dean has to drive my car,” Bridget told him as a slight smile curled at her lips.

Sam started laughing, “Okay, I agree with Jessica.”

As Sam laughed, Jessica giggled, and Mary hid what John assumed was a smile of her own behind her hand. It was clear that Dean’s apparent hatred of his girlfriend’s car was very well known.

Mary cleared her throat before saying, “I agree with them, Dean.”

Dean finally broke eye contact with Bridget and turned to look at his mother. He frowned slightly.

“Really, Mom?” he asked, clearly surprised that she would even get involved.

Then he turned to John, his expression becoming an obvious plea as he simply asked,

“Dad?”

John briefly considered defending Dean, but as he looked at how much everyone else was enjoying this new turn of events, he found that he, too, wanted to be part of it. After all, if all Dean had to do was drive a car he didn’t like for a while, it wasn’t going to be the end of the world.

“You did cheat, son,” John reminded him.

Dean groaned and threw his head back.

“Why are you all on her side?” he huffed, waving a hand in Bridget’s direction. “You’re my family.”

Bridget grinned.

“It’s because they like me.” She flicked a hand toward Mary and John. “I gave them a granddaughter.”

Then she waved the same hand toward Sam.

“I gave your brother a niece—”

“—So did I!” Dean pointed out, almost scoffing at the fact that she could think she had him with that.

Bridget shook her head slowly.

“Yes, Dean, because all that constant nausea, cramps, back pain, sore breasts, and heartburn I went through for nine months of pregnancy—not to mention the actual excruciating pain of seventeen hours of labour—are totally the same as your sacrifice of having sex for five minutes!”

John watched as Dean’s jaw dropped open and his eyes grew as wide as saucers. A slight shade of pink crept up Dean’s neck and cheeks. His mouth quickly snapped shut, and his expression became a mixture of shock, embarrassment, and annoyance.

Sam and Jessica burst out laughing once again, Sam nearly dropping the three wine glasses he had been holding throughout all of this. Mary pursed her lips together in an attempt to stop herself from laughing as well. Aislin was busy playing with her caterpillar toy and seemed completely unaware of what was happening between her parents.

John found himself biting the inside of his cheek to stop himself from laughing, too. Sure, Dean was obviously uncomfortable with his sex life being mentioned in front of his parents, but it felt so good to see everyone else laughing and enjoying themselves, even if it was at Dean’s expense. It was something they were all experiencing together as a family.

Bridget, clearly pleased with herself, tilted her head slightly.

“Have fun driving my car,” she told Dean.

Then she turned and walked quickly out of the living room. Sam followed right behind her, still laughing.

“I’ll drive it to the scrap yard,” Dean muttered, though loudly enough for everyone to hear.

“I heard that!” Bridget shouted from near the kitchen.

“That’s because I said it!” he shouted back.

Dean let out a short groan and dropped back down onto the couch like dead weight. Jessica nudged him with her elbow.

“Why do you always get yourself into trouble?” she asked, still thoroughly amused by the argument that had just happened.

Dean turned his head and glared at her, his jaw set firmly. Then he looked past her to his mother and daughter. Aislin was playing her own game of making her caterpillar bounce up and down, her eyes twinkling with amazement, even though she was the one moving the toy. Dean’s annoyed expression changed immediately as he watched his daughter.

Suddenly, Dean let out a long sigh before hurling himself off the couch and, without saying a word, walking out in the direction Sam and Bridget had just gone.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Not long after Dean had left, Sam walked back into the living room on his own. He was balancing two half-filled wine glasses between the fingers of his right hand, while in his left he held the necks of two bottles of beer. As he walked past John, he offered him one of the beers.

“Thanks, Sam,” John nodded, taking hold of the offered beverage.

Sam nodded and walked over to the couch where Mary and Jessica were still sitting. He placed one wine glass on the little end table beside Mary, as she was holding Aislin, making it difficult for her to also hold a glass of wine.

“Everything okay with Dean and Bridget?” Mary asked as Sam sat down next to Jessica in the seat that Dean had previously been in.

“Yeah,” Sam said with a smile. He lifted his own beer to his mouth and added, “You know they never fight for long,” before taking a drink.

“I can’t believe Dean thought he could get away with it,” Jessica said, shaking her head slightly.

“I know.” Sam laughed. “I mean, Bridget usually finds out when he pulls stuff like this eventually. You’d think he’d learn by now.”

John smiled as he tipped his beer back and took a long drink. He very much liked seeing Sam laugh and have fun. He hadn’t really seen this side of Sam in years.

It was then that Aislin dropped her toy and started to whimper. Her bottom lip began to tremble as her eyes started to glisten with the tears that were on their way. Mary held her tightly and immediately tried to calm her down. Aislin snuggled closer against the warmth of her grandmother but continued to fuss.

All laughter was forgotten as the adults in the room looked at the baby with concern. Even John found that he didn’t like knowing she was upset. He watched as Mary gently rocked her while making soft shushing noises.

“Hey, Aislin, what’s up?” Sam asked with concern as he reached an arm across Jessica to gently rub one of Aislin’s legs.

Aislin ignored him, and soon her whimpers turned into soft cries, with the potential to become much louder.

“It’s probably time for her to have a bottle,” Mary said. “Might be best if she has one now before they go home.”

“I’ll go get one,” John offered.

He leaned forward and placed his beer bottle on the floor beside his armchair before standing up. He took one last look at his little baby granddaughter as she cried in her grandmother’s arms, then turned and left the living room.

John considered himself to be a pretty tough guy. A nothing gets to me and I can handle anything type of guy. After all, he had to become like that to survive the life of a hunter. That included pushing back his emotions, even where his own sons were concerned. He was very good at it too—acting as though seeing his sons hurt or in danger didn’t affect him as much as it really did.

But... seeing little Aislin upset—hearing her cry... well, damn if that wasn’t affecting him and making him emotional.

Maybe it was some sort of biological connection his dream state had created because that little baby was meant to be his granddaughter. Or maybe it was seeing his wife trying to comfort her when he hadn’t seen her with a baby since Sam was little.

Either way, John just wanted to get out of there before the others noticed how much it was getting to him.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

It wasn’t until John was several feet away from the kitchen doorway and began to hear voices that he remembered Dean and Bridget were in there sorting out their argument. He had been so focused on getting Aislin a bottle that he had completely forgotten about them.

As he walked closer to the doorway, he could clearly hear their conversation. He paused, knowing he should go in but also sensing that they needed to finish the private conversation they were having in order to move past the fight they'd had. As well as that, John found himself curious to see how they were going to sort it out.

John had not expected Dean to follow Bridget in the first place. Usually, Dean didn’t show any emotional vulnerability around women, preferring to play the tough guy instead. But instead of leaving things alone, he had gone after Bridget, clearly not to continue arguing but to try to fix things.

So, out of curiosity, and knowing that he could wake up at any moment and lose all of this anyway, John stood still by the kitchen doorway and watched the young couple.

They didn’t see him, as both their backs were to the door.

Bridget was standing by the sink, her hands moving as she performed a task that John couldn’t identify from his current vantage point. Dean was standing behind her, his arms loosely around her midsection, while his chin rested on her left shoulder. They were clearly having an intense discussion, but the fact that they were standing so intimately had to be a good sign.

"—So why not just tell me you knew what Sammy wanted us all here for?" Bridget asked as their conversation continued.

"I didn’t want to give away Sam’s secret," Dean told her.

"But you did give it away," she pointed out. "You’re the one who suggested an engagement as an option to begin with. You could have suggested anything else to throw us off and keep Sammy’s secret, but you didn’t."

"I know," Dean admitted, rubbing his chin lightly against her shoulder.

"You really are terrible at keeping secrets," she told him, shaking her head.

"That’s not true," Dean began, pulling back a little so he could look at the side of her face. "I haven’t told anyone about the gallery wanting to showcase some of your photos next month because I know you don’t want anyone to know until it’s officially confirmed. You don’t want to jinx it."

Bridget stopped what she was doing and nodded slowly.

"I guess that’s true," she agreed. She turned her head to face him and said, "Thank you for that, by the way."

She leaned toward him and briefly pressed her lips against his. The gesture was so quick that Dean didn’t even have time to close his eyes.

"Still, why did you want to bet against something you already knew the outcome of?" Bridget asked when she pulled back and turned toward the sink.

Dean leaned back a little to look at her, his arms still wrapped around her.

"I hardly ever win our bets, and I really wanted to win one, so you’d have to do what I wanted, and—"

Bridget suddenly stiffened in his arms.

"So, you actually want me to do all that... stuff you asked for?" There was a hint of disgust in her voice.

Dean sighed and lowered his head, resting it against the back of Bridget’s neck, her brownish-blonde hair tickling his face.

"No," he admitted. "Never that."

Bridget shook her head.

"Okay, now I’m just confused."

Dean lifted his head and took a step back as she started to turn around in his arms. His arms slipped from around her, his hands coming to rest on her hips.

"So, you created a bet you knew you were going to win, but you don’t actually want your winnings?" she asked slowly, clearly confused.

"Okay... don’t be mad," Dean said carefully.

Bridget folded her arms across her chest. She looked like she wanted to interrupt, but instead remained silent and let him continue.

"There is something that I really want—something else," he added quickly when she opened her mouth to speak. "But I don’t know how you’re going to take it. So, I figured if I gave you an option of stuff you would never actually agree to, you might be more open to thinking about agreeing to what I actually want."

Bridget simply stood there and blinked at him.

"Does that make sense?" he asked, taking her silence to mean she was confused.

"Surprisingly, yes," she sighed. Unfolding her arms and placing her hands on his forearms, she asked, "While I’m now a little afraid to ask... what is it that you actually want?"

Dean looked into her eyes.

"I want another kid."

Bridget leaned back from him until her back hit the sink behind her.

"I... what?" she asked, her shock obvious.

Dean dropped his hands from her waist and took half a step back.

"Not right now, obviously," he said quickly. "I was thinking in a year or two, when Aislin’s a bit older."

Bridget straightened herself.

"How long have you been thinking about this?" she asked.

Dean shrugged.

"Why would you think I wouldn’t be open to the idea of another child?"

Dean gave her a knowing smile.

"Well, as you pointed out in front of my parents a moment ago, my contribution to creating our daughter was a lot more... fun, than all the stuff you had to go through to get her here."

His smile faded, replaced by a look of genuine concern.

"I know pregnancy wasn’t easy for you. I was worried you’d already made up your mind."

"And tricking me and lying to me was going to help sway my decision in your favour?" she asked, raising an eyebrow.

"More like making you think there were worse things I could ask for, so you'd at least think about this instead of saying no straight away." He paused before shaking his head. "Not my best idea."

Bridget shook her head.

"No, it wasn’t," she agreed. "So, what if I think about it and my answer is no? Then what?"

"Then nothing," he shrugged. "I want another kid. Growing up, Sam and I had the best times together, and I’d love that for Aislin. But I’m not going to force you to do anything you don’t want to do. It’s your body, Bridge."

Bridget’s eyes softened. She stepped toward him and, once she was close enough, rested her hands on his collarbones, her fingers lightly tapping against the base of his neck.

"How is it that you can be so incredibly sweet and thoughtful, yet so cunning and manipulative at the same time?" she asked, shaking her head in disbelief as she tried to suppress a smile.

Dean’s lips curled into a small grin.

"I don’t know. How is it that you always want to kiss me and throttle me at the same time?"

Bridget laughed, then slid her hands up to his neck before gently pulling him down to meet her in a kiss. Dean wrapped his arms around her waist again, drawing her against him. They shared a sweet kiss that lasted several moments.

John watched from his hidden spot by the doorway. He was shocked, but also a little in awe of what he had just witnessed. He had never known Dean to be so thoughtful about someone else's feelings before. He had never really known Dean to express his own feelings as openly as he had just done with Bridget.

There had been plenty of times when it was obvious Dean wanted to say something about how he felt or what he really thought, but before he could get the words out, he would usually deflect with a joke or hide them behind sarcasm so they wouldn’t be taken seriously. It was only when he was truly angry that he tended to let his guard down.

But with this woman—this woman John had somehow created to fit into this dream life for his son—Dean had let his guard down completely. There had been no hesitation or fear about sharing such personal thoughts and desires. Instead, he had simply explained why he had done what he did, trusting her enough to be honest.

Bridget pulled back slightly.

"Okay," she said. "I’ll think about having another baby."

She leaned in again and briefly kissed him before murmuring, "But you’re still driving my car."

Dean groaned in annoyance but tightened his arms around her waist and pulled her closer to continue kissing her.

There was no other way to describe it.

Dean was absolutely in love with this woman.

It was then that the muffled sound of a baby's cry drifted in from the other end of the house. John remembered why he was here, interrupting this private moment in the first place.

He cleared his throat to make Dean and Bridget aware of his presence before stepping into the kitchen.

Dean and Bridget broke apart. Bridget lowered her hands to her sides. Dean, however, didn’t remove his arms from around her waist, only loosening his hold. Neither of them looked embarrassed at being caught kissing. Instead, they simply smiled at each other.

"Sorry," John said quickly. "Your mom thinks Aislin might want a bottle, and—"

He stopped mid-sentence as he watched Dean release one arm from around Bridget. Without breaking eye contact with her, Dean reached around her toward the sink and grabbed something from behind her. Then he brought the object closer and held it up for John to see.

Dean held up a baby bottle filled with milk, and John realised that was what Bridget had been doing when he had first seen her standing at the sink. She had been getting Aislin's bottle ready.

Dean smirked, turned to John, and gave the bottle a small wave, saying, "Already on it."

To be continued...
Next Chapter: Mary’s Guidance