Chapter Text
Chapter Four ~ DEAN
John continued to look at the baby in Mary’s arms, staring at her as he took her in. He watched as her little hands came up and reached out, trying to grab Mary’s blonde hair, which had fallen over her shoulder. Mary took hold of Aislin’s hands, preventing her from grabbing her hair.
John was so sure that this little girl had to be Dean’s daughter, but he wanted to make sure.
He quickly swallowed the lump that had settled in his throat and focused on keeping his voice calm and the disbelief out of it as he asked, “So, where is your dad, Aislin?”
The baby’s name, leaving his lips, felt incredibly strange to John. He smiled and hoped that the two women with him could not tell how nervous he was. Thankfully, they were both so focused on Aislin that neither of them even looked at John when he spoke.
“Dean should be at work already,” Bridget replied, looking at her baby.
John let out a short breath. It was confirmed. This baby—this beautiful, green-eyed, happy little girl—belonged to Dean. John could not believe it. Of all the things he had ever dreamt up in his life, a grandchild was never one of them. He wondered why his mind had created this particular scenario.
“I’m actually surprised you’re not at work yet, John,” Bridget said, finally turning to look at him.
John took his eyes off Aislin and looked at Bridget, the young woman who was apparently with his eldest son. He thought back to when he had first opened the door and to how surprised Bridget had looked. Her surprise must have been from seeing him at home instead of at work.
“I was just heading out,” he told her with a nod.
Bridget didn’t seem to think this was strange, or at least, if she did, she didn’t let on. Instead, she turned back to Mary and baby Aislin.
“Okay, well, if you’re sure you don’t mind—” Bridget started to say.
Once again, Mary cut her off. “You know I never mind.”
“Okay,” Bridget nodded. “I’ll go grab Aislin’s stuff from the car.”
John’s attention had returned to the baby, and he only just registered Bridget turning to leave out of the corner of his eye.
While Bridget was gone, Mary’s attention was fully back on the little girl in her arms. John watched as his wife swayed from side to side while murmuring sweet words to the baby.
John felt a mixture of three things resonate within him. The first, of course, was the shock and surprise of seeing a child who was apparently his grandchild, and all that entailed. The second was awe. There was something so wonderful about watching how happy this baby made his wife. There was no other word for it—Mary was glowing. The third was sadness. Before he had lost her, she had been holding Sam and rocking him in the same way she was now rocking Aislin. The thought brought up so many painful feelings, and John pushed them down.
He knew this dream wouldn’t last, and he didn’t want to focus on what had been when he could be enjoying whatever this better reality was.
Mary turned and looked over at him. She frowned while still gently rocking back and forth. For a moment, John thought maybe he hadn’t been able to keep his emotions and thoughts from showing on his face.
“I’m doing it again, aren’t I?” she asked suddenly.
John opened his mouth to ask what she was referring to, but she kept talking, preventing him from responding.
“I’m hogging her,” Mary stated. She looked down at Aislin before adding, “I think Grandpa wants a cuddle before he joins Daddy at work.”
John stood very still, almost as though he were having an out-of-body experience, and watched as Mary took the few short steps towards him. Then, smiling, Mary pulled Aislin away from her, turned her around, and held her out to John. On autopilot, John put his arms out and took hold of the baby.
He pulled her against him and looked down into her eyes. She looked up at him, blinking a few times. It felt so real having her in his arms.
“Hi,” he murmured, smiling slightly when she reached out and grabbed his nose.
One word came to John’s mind as he both watched and held her in his arms: amazing.
Mary watched them with a smile on her face. She was still obviously oblivious to what was actually going on in John’s mind.
It was then that Bridget came back in, a black diaper bag over one shoulder and a small purple backpack slung over the other.
“Here,” Bridget said, handing the two bags to Mary. “Thanks, Mary. I really appreciate it. I’ll call you when I’m done. I should be done in a few hours, or maybe longer.”
“Don’t feel like you have to rush,” Mary said, placing the two bags on the floor and smiling. “We’ll be fine.”
Bridget looked over at Aislin in John’s arms and smiled as she visibly relaxed.
“Right,” she nodded. “Well, if you change your mind, just give Dean a call.”
Bridget then walked over to John. She leant down, placed a gentle kiss on top of Aislin’s hair, and smiled.
“Bye, sweetheart,” she said warmly. “You be good for Grandma, okay? I love you.”
Bridget kissed Aislin one more time. The baby smiled in John’s arms. Then Bridget stood up, nodded at John, and turned to Mary.
“Okay, I’ll see you later,” she told them. “And thanks again, Mary.”
“Bye, Bridget,” said Mary. “Good luck.”
Bridget smiled before walking out the door.
John barely registered her leaving. He was too focused on the baby in his arms. He almost forgot what he had originally set out to do when he had left Mary in the kitchen.
“Okay, my darling girl,” Mary began as she took the baby from John and cuddled her again. “Let’s say bye to Grandpa so he can go to work and fix some cars with your daddy.”
As thoughts of seeing Dean at the garage filled his head again, John’s lips curled into a soft smile.
“Right,” he agreed.
He moved closer until he was standing right in front of Mary. Then he placed one hand against Aislin’s back before leaning down to kiss the top of her head. Her hair was incredibly soft. He couldn’t help breathing in her scent. When he was done, he straightened up and captured Mary’s lips with his own, giving her a deep but brief kiss before pulling back. His hand remained on the baby for a moment.
A large part of him wanted to stay here with Mary and his granddaughter. But now that he had a granddaughter, he was curious to see what other new developments this dreamt-up reality had in store for him. So he wanted to go and see what kind of man Dean had become.
“I love you,” he told Mary as he finally stepped back.
Mary grinned. “I love you too.”
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
After leaving Mary and baby Aislin, John drove his truck to the garage. He was mostly going on instinct now, remembering how he used to drive to work before the demon had taken away his love.
On the way, he couldn’t stop thinking about the baby. Aislin. It was such a unique name, and John wondered why it had been chosen for her.
As he pulled up to the garage, the first thing John noticed was the Impala parked right out front. He parked next to it, and when he climbed out of his truck, he quickly looked it over. It looked almost exactly as it did in real life, except when he peered through the back window, he could see a car seat as well as several toys lying across the back seat and floor.
He couldn’t help but smile. It was so strange to see the car like this. It hadn’t had a baby seat in it since Sam had grown out of one. Even then, it had barely had any toys.
The knowledge that Dean was a father and had created such a beautiful daughter sent a sudden surge of pride through John.
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
When he walked into the garage, John could hear Black Sabbath playing on a distant radio. It didn’t take him long to find Dean. His son was standing in front of a red Toyota Camry with the bonnet up, leaning over the engine as he worked.
Dean must have heard John approach, or maybe he simply sensed he was no longer alone, because he stopped what he was doing and stepped back so he could stand up straight without hitting his head on the bonnet.
“So, when I take over here and become the boss,” Dean began as he turned to face his father, “can I turn up whenever I want as well?”
The smirk that crossed his face told John he was teasing.
John smiled back. He couldn’t remember the last time he had heard Dean joke with him like that. Usually, Dean was too busy trying his best to follow John’s orders.
At first, John didn’t know how to respond. Then he decided he wanted to see how Dean would react if the subject of his daughter was brought up.
“We had some unexpected visitors this morning,” John began, unable to stop his lips from curling into a knowing smile. “I was a bit distracted.”
Dean’s smirk turned into what John would call a grin of pride.
“Yeah. Bridge called after she got the call from the gallery.”
John nodded.
“She was worried Mom might have been too busy,” Dean continued.
“I don’t think your mother minded,” John replied.
Dean laughed, then turned back to the engine. “I keep tellin’ Bridge that. We could sit Aislin on the front step, ring the bell, and run. Mom would open the door, take Aislin inside, and not even question it.”
John chuckled as he remembered seeing Mary’s joy when she had realised who had been at the door and how she had practically run to get to the baby.
“You’re probably right,” John said with a nod. “You did make a beautiful baby.”
Dean looked back at John with a warm, proud smile on his face, “I know.”
There was something about the way Dean’s eyes lit up, and the soft smile that spread across his face when he agreed that his baby was beautiful, that made John want to smile and tear up a little. This was the life Dean should have had instead of one filled with hunting and revenge.
Needing to distract himself from the harsh reality that awaited him, John turned and pointed at the engine in front of them.
Changing the subject, he asked, “So, what else have you got to do here?”
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
John and Dean spent the next several hours at the garage working on cars. They managed to finish the Camry, and Dean called the owner to arrange for them to come and collect it. They changed the tyres on another car, and a new customer dropped off her vehicle because it had been making a funny noise.
They spent most of their time talking about the work at hand, barely having time to discuss anything else. While John wanted to ask Dean more questions about his life and his daughter, he also didn’t want to spoil the easy rhythm they had found. Instead, he decided to follow Dean’s lead so their conversations wouldn’t feel forced or awkward.
At one point, John went into his office and took some time to look over a few things. He discovered that, in this dream, he now owned the garage outright. Aside from Dean, he also had several other staff members, but none of them were working today, so it was just the two of them.
The office had a large window overlooking the main workshop, so while John was inside, he could still watch Dean work.
Dean knew exactly what he was doing when it came to working on cars, almost as though it were second nature. As John watched him, he wondered if this really was the life Dean had been meant to lead, had it not been for the tragedy their family had endured.
John had been enjoying spending this time with Dean—this time where he didn’t have to worry about hunting, risking their lives, or revenge—so much that he hadn’t even been paying attention to the time.
Dean was checking the oil in a new car that had been brought in when he glanced over at the clock on the wall.
“Hey, Dad,” he called. He grabbed the dirty rag hanging out of the back pocket of his jeans and started wiping his grimy hands. “It’s after one. Think we can call it a day?”
John had been filling out some forms on a clipboard. He set it down and walked over to Dean.
“We do have more work to do,” he said, though really he didn’t want to spend any more time here. Yes, he had enjoyed working alongside Dean, but after so many hours, he was ready to get back to Mary and spend time with his family in a different setting.
“Hmm.” Dean thought for a moment, possibly trying to come up with a good reason to get them out of work early. Then he slowly grinned and said, “If we leave now, you can spend more time with Aislin.”
The way Dean had said it—as though that idea alone should be enough to tempt his dad—made John chuckle.
“Think that’ll work?” John asked, referring to Dean’s suggestion.
Dean shrugged one shoulder. “Usually does.”
John shook his head, trying to suppress the smile spreading across his face. From that comment, it was clear that it wasn’t just Mary who adored the little girl. He must be just as devoted to her.
“Yeah, okay,” John finally agreed. “All this stuff can wait till tomorrow. Let’s go.”
A huge grin spread across Dean’s face, and he tossed the dirty rag off to one side.
It was then that John realised he really did want to see that little baby again—more than he had expected.
To be continued…
Next chapter: His Home
