Actions

Work Header

Chapter 2: A New Reality

Chapter Text

Chapter Two – A NEW REALITY

Sometime after waking up, seeing his wife in his bed, and giving in to the desire to be with her in a way he had dreamt about for so many years, John now lay in bed with Mary curled at his side. Her cheek rested against his chest, his heartbeat strong in her ear. One arm wrapped around her hips while the other stroked the arm she had draped across his stomach.

He looked down at the top of her head. She could not be more perfect. Leaning down, he gently pressed his lips against the top of her hair, the soft strands tickling his skin.  

“I love you,” he said softly against her head. “So much.”

Mary turned her face further into his chest, and he felt her lips curl into a smile.  

“I love you too, John”, she murmured.

John’s arms tightened around her, almost squeezing her. The knowledge that he could wake up from this dream at any moment filled him with dread and only made him want to hold on to her longer, enjoy the feeling of her in his arms as long as possible.  

It was then that this perfect moment was interrupted by the shrill beeping of the alarm clock. John groaned and turned his head towards the dreaded machine that had decided to interrupt them. The old-fashioned radio alarm clock sat on the dresser beside his side of the bed, its red neon numbers displaying 6:45 a.m.

With the hand he was using to stroke Mary’s arm, he reached out and slapped at the top of the alarm until the beeping stopped.

He paused.

Something didn’t feel right.

Usually, when there was a loud sound in his dreams, it was because there was a similar noise in reality, and it would wake him up. But this time he remained in the dream.

Turning back, expecting to settle into the position they had been in before the alarm went off, he found Mary already moving away from him as she slipped out of bed.

“No, let's – can we stay here?” John said, trying not to sound as desperate as he felt. “Just for a little bit?”

Mary was sitting on the edge of the bed now. She turned her head slightly to look at him over her shoulder.

“As tempting as that is, you have work this morning,” she told him with a smile. “And I have things to get done before Sam and Jessica come over tonight for dinner.”

Then she planted her feet on the floor and stood.

John slowly sat up and watched her walk into their ensuite bathroom.

‘Sam and Jessica, ’ John repeated the names in his mind.

Of all the times he had dreamt of being here - back in his house, in his bed with his wife - it was usually set in the months before her passing, when Sam and Dean were little. But if Sam knew Jessica, it meant he was now dreaming of a present-day scenario in which Mary was still alive.

As the sunlight streaming through the window brightened the room, John took a better look around. There were photos around the room, on the dressers, and hung on the wall. Some of him and Mary, some baby photos he couldn’t quite place and wasn’t sure if they were of Dean or Sam.

Then he saw one that confirmed his suspicions.

A photo on Mary’s nightstand showing the four of them – himself, Mary, Dean and Sam. Sam wore graduation robes. It must have been taken at his high school graduation.

John scrambled across the bed to grab the frame. Holding it in one hand, he tried not to tremble.

They all looked so happy. Huge smiles stretched across every face.

This single photograph showed everything John had wanted for his family but could no longer have after losing Mary.

A normal life.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

After joining Mary in the shower to be close to her again - even if this was a dream, John wasn’t going to miss any opportunity to be with his wife after more than twenty years without her – he now found himself sitting at the small round kitchen table across from her as they ate breakfast.

On the way downstairs, he took in a few details of the house: furniture that wasn’t quite how he remembered it and photos of the boys through their childhood. But these things barely registered. His attention remained fixed on Mary as she walked ahead of him.

When they had entered the kitchen, Mary handed him the newspaper and made him a coffee. John accepted both gratefully but couldn’t focus on the paper. Instead, he kept his eyes on her as she busied herself making omelettes.

They didn’t say much, but that was okay.

The silence allowed John to simply admire how beautiful she was.

Over the last twenty-two years, he had tried to hold on to the image of Mary as perfectly as possible. Yet even with photographs, he sometimes felt his memory wasn’t as sharp as it used to be. Now, with her sitting right in front of him, he wanted to commit every detail of her to memory.

“Mary?” he began slowly. “Was there ever… a fire here?”

Mary, who had been about to take a bite of her omelette, paused with her fork halfway to her mouth. She gave him a quizzical look before frowning.

“A fire?” she asked. “What do you mean?”

John let out a sigh of relief.

“Nothing. I just… I had a weird dream last night, I guess. That’s all”

Mary set her fork down and reached across the table, placing her hand gently over his. Concern filled her eyes.

“Are you sure you’re ok?” she asked him.

John looked at her and nodded. Turning his hand over, he laced his fingers through hers.

“Yeah. I’m good”

And he smiled, because if there had never been a fire, if Mary had never died, if his boys had grown up and lived good lives, then he really was good.

Mary nodded before withdrawing her hand and returning to her breakfast.

John then remembered something she’d said before getting out of bed.

“So, um…” He cleared his throat. “What time is Sammy coming down from school?”

He didn’t mention Stanford specifically, just in case it wasn’t where Sam had ended up in this… whatever reality this dream seemed to be.

Mary swallowed her bite and picked up her coffee.

“Oh, sometime after five tonight.” She took a quick sip. “I’ll head out to get groceries for dinner after I tidy up around here.”

John nodded as he processed this information.

Sam was coming home with Jessica.

And the four of them were going to have dinner together.

“And Dean?” John asked, trying to sound casual rather than like someone who genuinely had no idea where Dean was or whether he was coming at all.

Mary finished the last of her coffee and stood.

“I’m not sure. He’ll either come over shortly after you two finish at the garage, or he’ll show up around the same time as Sam and Jessica.” She shrugged. “He didn’t say.”

“Right”, John said with a nod.

Mary carried her mug to the sink and rinsed it out.

John picked up his coffee and considered this new piece of information.

Not only was Dean joining them for dinner, but apparently, he worked with him at the garage.

John couldn’t help smiling.

He knew his love for cars and their mechanics had been passed down to Dean. Even with the life they’d led as hunters, Dean had learned the skills John possessed as a mechanic.

But having Dean work alongside him, fixing cars, had always been a secret wish. If only their lives had turned out differently from the harsh reality waiting for him when he woke up from this amazing dream.

Mary returned to the table to collect their empty plates. She noticed the smile on John’s face and the distant look in his eyes.

“What are you smiling about?” She asked, her own lips beginning to curve upward.

“Just thinking about how good my life is here”

He stood and walked over to her.

Once he reached her, he wrapped his arms around her waist and slowly pulled her closer.

“We’re happy, right?”

“Oh, I would say we are,” Mary agreed, her hands settling flat against his chest. A flirtatious smile appeared on her face.

John missed that smile.

He wanted to lean in and kiss that smile, but there was one more thing he needed to know.

“And our boys?” he asked. “They’re happy too?”

Again, he tried to sound casual, as though he were simply confirming the obvious rather than seeking reassurance.

Mary laughed and slid her arms around his neck.

“They are definitely happy.” She told him.

“Good.”

And with that, John leaned forward and kissed the still smiling lips of his wife.

Whatever this dream was, or wherever it was going, John didn’t care.

Right now, all that mattered was that he had his wife in his arms and that they and their sons were living good, happy lives.

He only hoped he didn’t wake up before he got to see both Dean and Sam.  

To be continued…
Next chapter: Mysterious Strangers