Preface

Insatiable
Posted originally on the fanfiction.lol at https://fanfiction.lol/works/2256.

Rating:
Explicit
Archive Warning:
Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Fandoms:
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Elder Scrolls (Video Game Series)
Relationship:
Cicero/Listener (Elder Scrolls)
Characters:
Cicero (Elder Scrolls), Listener (Elder Scrolls)
Additional Tags:
Blood Kink, Knife Play, Penis In Vagina Sex, Licking, Non-Consensual Kissing, Mildly Dubious Consent, Takes place during A Cure for Madness, Unresolved Sexual Tension, Unresolved Emotional Tension, Depression, Rough Sex, Finger Sucking, Blood and Injury, Porn with Feelings, Aftercare, no beta we die like Festus Rex (yeouch), Asphyxiation, I Wrote This Instead of Sleeping, Squirting and Vaginal Ejaculation, Creampie, Biting, Emotionally Repressed Listener, Love/Hate, unnamed listener, mind the tags please, Enemies to Lovers, Kinda, No Use of Y/N for Reader-Insert, Adrenaline sex, Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Language:
English
Stats:
Published: 2026-04-19 Words: 3,292 Chapters: 1/1

Insatiable

Summary

The Listener has finally cornered the Keeper in his self-proclaimed sanctuary. But she knows she cannot cure his madness. She can only join him in it.

Notes

I want to portray a more belligerent Cicero, at a stage where he respects the Listener for their position but also remains weary of them because he does not know if they are loyal to Astrid or to the Old Ways. I really like the idea of him being devoted to the Listener eventually, but idk I feel like he would have trust issues first, ya know? After all that's happened in Cheydinhal Province the Dark Brotherhood aint what it used to be.

Insatiable

INSATIABLE

 

She was the first to raise her weapon against him, even after he pleaded for her to spare him, to turn away and go back, to lie to her Family. Yet he sprung up on his feet as if shot alive by a dark god's will and met her dagger gladly. His shrill voice echoed the room and they spun together in a violent dance of blades. He laughed when he bled, he praised her with each blow, teased her when she missed mere inches. Leather clothes torn in shreds, drops of crimson dripped on the old stone floor. To each other, a worthy foe. The best versus the best. A game of insanity that he invited her in and she fell to play.

In this clash between children of darkness, he proved to her the depth of his experience and his devotion to his beliefs with each successful blow he landed on her. In the end she triumphed, although she did not deliver a killing blow. She looked over the beaten body of the Keeper, who chuckled in defeat, one eye staring at her soul while the other eye was half-closed and bruised, covered by blood dripping down from his forehead. His jester hat and his weapons lay far away from them, both their clothes shredded from their vicious struggle. She too was broken, weakened by him through slices and sleights of hands.  Cold wind blew around them, dust dancing in circles. She pressed against him, straddling him by his hips with her thighs to pin him small body down. One hand around his neck, another one with a knife pointed at his chin.

All the Listener had known had come falling down around her.  She was here with one purpose in mind, to avenge her Family, but she knew that by pursuing this jester she was merely a lapdog, following orders from a woman trying to protect the Sanctuary but nonetheless trying to prove herself. She had known where she needed to go to find the Keeper, but even when she rode upon steed dipped in blackness, even when the light of Secunda guided her way at the crown of the night sky, she was so lost. 

Voices in her head telling her what to do. Voices of the people in her past and present, trying to convince her what was right and wrong. Truly, what was right and wrong, when they were in the business of killing? Ever since she was young she sought oblivion, to experience a death before death itself. She must fill the emptiness inside her by any means necessary, and it led her to this dark path. Each time her weapon plunged itself into her victim, she would finally feel something even if it were a distant dream, and with each kill and soul offered to Sithis, she was closer and closer to that dream's horizon. 

Yet among the raging voices at war in her mind, the Keeper--the mad jester who babbled and sang to himself and treated everything like play--only bared the truth as he knew it. Even Astrid saw that and she denied it. For him it was very simple: he was loyal to the Old Ways. No longer desperate for meaning. Just hungry for a killing. 

How she wished she could grant the death Cicero believed she deserved. In his mind, it must be sweet, guttural, agonizing. 

But not now, not yet.

Cicero stopped chuckling and coughed, choking on his blood. He quieted and the silence in the Sanctuary haunted her. She did not raise the dagger, nor did she sheathe it. They stared at each other, a stand off between life and death. With one quick move, one of them would die. Their duties, their secrets, they would take it all to the Void with them, and from that they would take away what was left and true of the Dark Brotherhood. 

But she would not kill him. There would be no more killing amongst the Night Mother's chosen. There would be no more breaking of the Tenets. Cicero has spilled his blood, and that was his penance for harming the members of their Sanctuary. He has spilled her blood for the offense of lifting a hand against the sacred Keeper, against the wishes of the Night Mother and the Dread Father, and that too was a just price. So here they remained still, locked in deadly standoff. His chest rose and fell slowly, peppered with raspy breaths. Creases hugged the sides of his mad eyes, marks of a man who has been in this profession for too long, a profession that almost always killed its young. 

How could she bear this damnable silence? The jester did not speak, did not laugh, did not attempt to fill the stillness with his voice like he always did. He stared at her so searchingly, it was torture knowing she was the one being read, not him. He raised his hand slowly, painfully, and caressed her aching face, smearing blood and grime over her skin. The touch sent a shiver down her spine, this unexpected gesture of affection, especially after they had tried to kill each other. Her mind screamed deception, lies, she should not fall for this trick again but she chased his touch, her cheek cupped at his rough palm. She had known pain all her life. The Family was kind,  she finally found a place she belonged. She had trysts with strangers and even her victims before she killed them to fulfill a primal need. But nothing, nothing else came so close to this gesture, from the man she expected it the least. Doting. Longing. Loving. 

But why?

"Will you finally send poor Cicero to the embrace of our sweet Night Mother?" He muttered, he did not squeal like he would. "Oh, but will she accept me? Forgive me? After what I have done to the Listener? When I have just found you my poor, bloody, Listener..."

She said nothing. He retreated his hand. The emptiness in the air was wrong. Just wrong. 

"Do what you will," he croaked, using a lower voice register. A glimpse of the man he used to be, before the laughter took hold of him. "Cicero has no fight left. In the end, Sithis will judge us both." 

She removed her hand from his neck and grabbed his jaw. The voices in her head roared, her body locked in tension as she stared back at him with bloodshot eyes. She wanted to slice him open and look at his insides, peek into his organs, his systems. What would she try to find first? The source of his madness, or the beautiful man that died long ago?

She wanted to make sense of it all, and the answer was in him. 

The air was heavy with a tension of a different kind. Still holding her dagger, still straddling his body, she pulled him to a bloody kiss. He moaned, struggling underneath her, but she kept pulling him back, tightening the grip she had of him. A woozy rush went to her head, drinking his blood and drool, moving their lips together. She wanted to taste this madness, slake this hunger in her belly and between her legs. He ceased struggling and opened his mouth to meet her tongue with his own, and she groaned in response, pushing herself deeper into him. 

She broke away to breathe, a trail of saliva tinged with red connecting their lips together, her eyes hazy, her grip loosening from his face. A thin sheen of sweat perspired on the top of his lips and his nose. The Keeper grinned and clicked his tongue. "Oh, my naughty, beautiful Listener...you have no idea..." 

"Enough, jester." Stands of her hair fell across her eyes, the tips grazing Cicero's brow and eyelashes. She pushed the blade against him again.  "You will listen to me." Seeing him so blood-soaked, subdued and under her whim made her mind race fast.  She wanted to devour him, control him, bend him to her will because after all she was the Listener, and she was tired of being told what to do what about what she wanted and by Sithis she wanted him and she would reach into the babel inside him and take it for herself and he would not deny her because he would never disobey the Listener and she knew that.  “I want you to be quiet and fuck me.”

He broke into a wide wicked grin, exposing even redness on his teeth. Even in duress, even under her knife, he found amusement in his own predicament. Did he see this as punishment or a reward? Perhaps both things could be true. “Of course. The Listener wants to be listened to. And a good Keeper listens.” 

He started cackling, and she kissed him roughly again to silence him, even when she hated the nothingness. This time he obliged, opening himself up and deepening the kiss in his own volition, the edges of her dagger still between their necks. She moved her hips down to meet his growing bulge in his trousers, and shifted against his hardened length. She drank him up, playing with his tongue and whined when he brushed at the most sensitive parts of her mouth. 

Cicero released himself from her lips to latch on her neck, kissing and biting down hard. It drew blood with his teeth but she did not flinch, only rocked against him harder. 

“I hate you,” she hissed, shaking above him. “And I hate that I want you.” 

He hummed in reply, quaking underneath her and lapping at her skin. Goosebumps traveled down her arms, Cicero’s quick work made her so sensitive to his touch.  Dust and ash drifted the charged air, the smell of mold and dew seeped on cold walls. They grabbed each other with such frenzy in this doomed and abandoned sacrarium even when both of them were almost at death’s door.

She ripped away his tattered vest with her blade, that wretched hunger growing and growing and letting the intoxication take over her veins. The Keeper clawed at her clothes with equal desperation, grasping with his long black nails to tear fabric and leather apart, digging into her with small red craters. His hands roamed reverently down her exposed back, white marks trailing down skin and she arched at his touch. 

He took in this special attention, bathed in the sweat and blood of his Listener, smelled her earthly leather scent, imprinted it in his own soul if this was the last thing he must take with him before he inevitably goes to the Void.

She trailed her tongue down his freckled chest and licked at his scars both old and new, even the cuts she gave him. She tasted the iron of his blood, their blood mixed together. She inhaled his musk, it was old earth, melted snow, and fresh death. She was slick and wet from the sounds he created with each touch she made. Cicero looped his fingers around her hair, mouthed her name over and over, almost like a silent song, an incantation. When she came back up, he bit and sucked her skin, leaving more bruises on her shoulders and her collarbone. She shuddered, her breath catching in her throat, the desire zipping down from her head to her loins. Her impatience took over and she tore through his pants, exposing his erection against the heat between her thighs, protecting it from the cold around them. He mewled in need, squirming underneath her, his face flushed red, and his freckles redder than before. 

She shed what remained of their clothes and stretched atop of him with her whole body. She needed to feel all of his skin with her own, to exhume the dead man the Fool of Hearts killed and once unearthed she would desecrate his tomb with her want. She grabbed his red hair and locked his head down the ground as she guided herself to the tip of his exposed erect cock and rubbed her folds between him, gliding along his length, her clit rubbing against rough skin and coarse hair. 

He held her face again, focusing on her, and she did not realize how brown and intense his eyes had become. Intense and so…empty. She opened her mouth and captured his thumb between her lips, rubbed her tongue against the callouses, cuts, and dirt underneath his nail. Her knees and his back scraped the old stone floor as they both grinded against each other, leaving more scratches and red bruises.

Her anger, her pain, her confusion came to a head, with her own cunt pulsing, aching, needy, hungry. Silently, she lowered herself down to him and he plunged himself into her. She gasped, letting go of his thumb between her teeth. A sweet pain filled her up just as quickly as he entered her, and it made her so lightheaded. Dark spots danced around her eyes as she moved her hips up and down, still locking the jester under her pleasant weight. Oh, how delicious, how feverish this pleasure had taken a hold of them. Euphoria bloomed in the Keeper’s face, holding so much back before fully giving in, offering her what he had left.  If she could surrender her soul to him right now she would, but no, not yet, she needed to be in control, be control, she was finally experiencing life as she desired, her long-awaited baptism by fire. 

She bent down to meet his ear. "Purify me, Keeper," the Listener murmured. "Make me whole. Make me new."

Still loyal to his Listener, loyal to her words because she was the closest incarnate to the voice of their sweet Night Mother, he said nothing and dutifully followed her suit. Without words,  she understood him and what he had to say, understood from the way he hurt and ravaged her how much he loathed her for the privilege of being the Listener, the only one who can hear the Mother's voice when he too wanted that privilege for his devotion. 

At the same time, she understood how he loved her by saying nothing and letting his hands and his mouth speak for itself, because she was the one he was looking for all these years, spoke the words he wanted to hear for so long, and now their sounds of obscenity filled the dreaded silence together. The darkness embraced them both, blessed this unholy union between Keeper and Listener in ancient grounds. 

She placed both his hands around her neck, urging him to squeeze at the sides. He could end her life then and there, when she was in her most vulnerable. She had given him a fool's trust, just squeeze hard enough or snap her neck completely. He put enough pressure that blood rushed up to her head, and more of her vision swirled. The knife against his neck begets more crimson from him, and he groaned in ecstasy as he thrust harder and faster inside her, frantic, searching.  

She welcomed the violence inflicted to her body, in her womb, and nothing was more fitting than being sanctified by a madman.  Her pussy tensed around him, and her suppressed pants transformed into wild moans, repeating his name and they echoed through the walls of this horrible place. The Keeper's breath became more shallow and erratic, saying no more and concentrating towards the climax, the glimpse of the nothingness he had not felt for so long. 

He tightened his grip around her neck. That finally sent his Listener tipping from the edge, to the oblivion she longed to search for. A thunder of spasms trembled her body, and she keened over him writhing. She ripped the air with a desperate plea, her juices overflowing underneath her and coating his hips and her thighs. He chased after her, grabbing her sides and ramming his cock with blistering pace, the impact of their skin together squelching and lewd, riding along her licentious prayer, the smell of her heat and her own cum overwhelming him until he exploded inside her, twitching and convulsing. His seed filled her womb, and it oozed around his shaft as he slowed his movements down to a quiet, quivering halt.

When she collapsed on him, she let go of the dagger. An assassin's mistake. But he did not reach for it. They remained still, drenched in blood, sudor, and cum, bodies hot with energy. Then she placed her forehead against his, sharing each other's breaths with closed eyes. And the silence returned, uninvited but not unwanted.  

 

###

 

When she was still a fresh-faced assassin, she stared at those fading Tenets in the Falkreath Sanctuary, memorizing them into heart.  In their world, they would inevitably meet violent deaths, just as members of their Brotherhood did in the past, and just as their current family members would in the future. So of course Cicero would sleep lightly, might even still be awake when the Listener got up because she was still a threat to him until she walked out of his sacred Sanctuary. There was no innocence to be found here even after they shared intimacy. If there was no innocence, these tenets held them together, but if they would not follow it so, then they would not be a Dark Brotherhood, and if they were not the Dark Brotherhood, then what was this that they fought and killed and died horribly for?

Poor and honourable Cicero sat up against the crude wall, resting his eyes. The Listener wiped away the blood from his face and body, and dressed the jester's wounds. She could have easily left him for dead after he outlived his usefulness to her, but in the end she recognized a survivor, just like her. She placed a rough blanket over him and ran her hand through his damp copper hair, traced the crinkles around his eyes with her fingertips. The emptiness returned, and if she had the strength she could have taken him again.  Her body ached all over and tiredness hovered over her. When she was done caring for the Keeper, she addressed her own ache.  

At some point he woke up, opening one eye and watching her dress herself. "What will my Listener do now?" He whispered, a solemn shadow on his face.

She did not turn around, kept her eyes forward and her back exposed to him. A large target for a knife to sink in. A perfect opportunity. A wasted opportunity. "I will bid my time, Keeper. That is all." 

He lulled his head to the side, as if about to fall asleep once more. "Then all shall finally be set right."

 

###

 

The sea salt wind and rising sun greeted her as soon as she opened the Black Door back to the outskirts of Dawnstar. The Listener would return to Falkreath Sanctuary, would lie to Astrid and would continue to serve her, to follow the path that would bring the Dark Brotherhood to its full glory, and finally glory to the Dread Father and their unholy matron. 

The Keeper would disappear from this Sanctuary for now, hiding away from the Family that did not follow the Old Ways, but nonetheless they too were survivors, he recognized that. He would recover from his wounds and wait, be around and around and kill to kill time until he could come back to the Night Mother and carry out his duties once more, and perhaps--just a perhaps--return to the Listener's side, if she would take him back, and take him again.  

Alone at the water's edge, Cicero laughed and laughed and laughed until he couldn't. 

Afterword

Please drop by the Archive and comment to let the creator know if you enjoyed their work!