Grian was like Scar's personal caretaker. Vowed to devote his first life to Scar after taking his, now spending his days keeping the idiot alive.
But simultaneously, Grian wasn't the best caretaker. He kept Scar alive, yes, but instead of keeping him from reeking havoc, they reeked havoc together.
Grian did what Scar asked immediately, but has also been able to keep the idiot safe for longer than ever he'd imagined.
So obviously it broke him internally when he had to kill Scar in the end. Kept him alive for so long, just to be the one to kill him.