The sun sat high in the sky over the outskirts of Mushroom Park, where, at one of many tables dotting a plaza, Mario was unwrapping his lunch. It was another day in a week dedicated to a Mario Party (he still wasn't sure why they named those after him; Peach was the one who did most of the coordination legwork), and, off the heels of a decisive victory earlier in the morning, he wanted to get something to eat before the next game that was set to take place here later in the afternoon.
Mario was about to dig in when a small voice piped up from beside him.
“Um...excuse me!”
Mario looked over to see two Toad kids. The taller child, wearing a baseball cap and glasses, was clutching something in their hands, looking nervous. The other, in overalls and pigtails, was less so, toothily grinning up at Mario.
“Could you sign my brother’s poster?” the girl asked, taking said poster from her brother’s grip and holding it out to Mario. Mario agreed easily, pulling out a pen he carried around for this exact scenario. He signed his name with a flourish, handing it back to the star-struck brother, who shyly thanked him.
“Oh, and I have a question!” she then declared, to her brother’s chagrin. “I want to know...” She paused for dramatic effect. “When are you and Princess Peach gonna get married?”
Mario’s stomach sank.
Taking his silence as confusion, they barreled on. “Mom says that you're the one who rescues the Princess all the time because you're soulmates and Dad says the best way to make the girl you love happy is by marrying her, so the wedding’s going to happen soon, right? Tell me when it is so I can go!
Mario shook his head. He and Peach weren’t...planning on getting married. The brother shot him a look of disbelief.
“No,” the girl insisted, “You are! It’s okay, though; I can keep a secret~!”
Mario was at a loss for words, and the longer his silence stretched, the further the girl’s grin fell. Mario knew he could just backtrack and say that yes, they were right, he actually was planning to propose soon. But the ring on his left middle finger sat heavy, preventing him from telling that lie.
But the poor girl looked like she was about to cry now, and Mario wasn't keen on being the reason she burst into tears and caused a scene. He scrambled for something to say —
"MARIO!"
Bowser’s roar echoed across the plaza. The brother blanched at his approach, and he grabbed his sister’s arm and dragged her away against her protests. Mario sighed in relief.
“How dare you upstage me on my own turf!” he bellowed, getting up in Mario’s face.
Mario rolled his eyes. It's not like it was his fault that Bowser just barely couldn't afford that last star.
“You're the one who stole my coins!”
Not that it mattered. Mario smirked.
Bowser growled. “Just you wait, you wimp; I’ll smoke you at the next board, and then I’ll be the one who gets cake from Peach this time!”
Why does it always come back to cake with you, Mario thought to himself, now a little sour because everything’s gotta come back to his relationship with Peach, doesn't it? Why can't Bowser just straight up ask Peach for a cake instead of jumping through a million hoops like this?
“What?”
Oh, Mario said that last part out loud. His point still stood though; this was ridiculous. Peach liked baking things for people. She’d at least consider baking something for Bowser if he just asked nicely. Without any kidnappings. Mario would even put a good word in, to up the odds of her agreeing to do it.
“I - She wouldn't -” Mario caught a flash of consideration on Bowser’s face before it was swiftly hidden by a deep scowl. “Whatever! It doesn't matter! You’d still better watch out! I’ll have some better tricks up my sleeve, this time, so you're gonna be toast!”
Sure, sure.
Bowser stomped off. Mario turned back to his lunch. Well, at least he’ll know to look out for any funny business this afternoon. But then again, when was Bowser not engaged in any funny business?
"Mario~!"
Princess Peach waved at Mario as she walked towards them. The young girl brightened and ran to say hello, her brother trailing behind. The three of them ended up walking back towards Mario’s table, the girl chatting away. She must have asked Peach the marriage question, Mario thought, judging by how stiff Peach’s smile became. And judging by how agitated the toad girl was getting, Peach was completely avoiding the question.
“But you have to!” The girl stomped her foot. “That’s how it goes in all the stories!”
Glancing at Mario’s deer-in-the-headlights look, Peach crouched down to look the girl in the eye. “Well...sometimes things don't work out quite like they do in stories,” she said.
The girl scrunched her face up. For a moment, Mario was worried about her throwing a tantrum in the middle of the plaza. Luckily, they were saved by a couple running up to them, calling the kids’ names.
“There you are!” the mom exclaimed. ”Why did you run off like that? Didn’t I say we should stay close?”
“Sorry, Mom...” the girl sulked.
The dad, noticing Mario and Peach, chuckled heartily. “Well, it seems that our kids found themselves a couple of celebrities! They didn't cause you too much trouble, did they?”
“Not at all!” Peach lied.
The brother handed his dad the signed poster. “The Princess said that she wasn't gonna marry Mario,” he informed his parents, dashing Mario’s hopes that he was free from that topic of conversation.
The mom laughed. “Well you can't rush these things you know. Relationships can be quite complicated.”
“I’m sure they’ll sort things out soon, dear!” The dad winked at Mario. Mario grimaced back.
“Well, we should leave these two to their date!” the mom said, guiding the kids away. “It was lovely to chat with you!”
The family bustled away before Mario and Peach could respond with their own goodbyes. Once they were finally out of sight, Peach slumped onto the chair across from Mario with a sigh. Mario passed her what was left of his food, and she tore off a piece to nibble on.
“...That sucked.”
Mario put his head in his hands and groaned.
“I mean! Is it so unreasonable that someone can rescue a girl from an evil king over and over again and just stay friends with her?” she clenched her hands into fists. “Who decided this was solely a romance thing I would like to have a word with them.”
Changing that was probably going to be harder than we would want it to be. And it’s not like he was going to stop rescuing Peach in the meantime.
“I know...” Peach slumped over onto the table.
Though Peach’s fervor was appreciated, in the end there really wasn't much to be done, was there? People were always going to draw those sorts of conclusions, no matter what he or Peach said. Mario was starting to think that maybe he should swallow his discomfort and get married to Peach after all.
But Peach read the thoughts on his face instantly. “Absolutely not!” she reached over to swat at Mario. “I'm not doing that to you, you'll hate it!”
But -
“Nope!” She settled back down. “You might be on to something though... maybe if I married someone else..? Heh. Could you imagine if I went and got married to Bowser of all people? Toadsworth would have a fit!”
Didn't the world literally almost end when you married Bowser that one time?
“Oh yeah...”
They sat in silence, picking at Mario’s food. Around them, the lunch rush was finishing up, and people were leaving the coffee shops and restaurants in droves to get on with their days. Most of them were strangers, but some of them were friends, including...
Mario nudged Peach and pointed out Pauline, who was stepping out of one such shop carrying a takeout bag in one hand and a coffee cup in the other. Peach sighed dreamily, watching her walk across the plaza. Mario rolled his eyes with a smirk. She always reacted like that. Didn't mean he couldn't have fun with it, though, even if he didn't get it.
Peach sighed again. “Hey Mario, do you think she - what are you doing.”
Mario waved at Pauline, catching her attention. She smiled, and changed course to approach them.
“Mario, why did you do that?!” Peach hissed, frantically smoothing out her hair and straightening her dress. “She’s coming this way!”
Mario laughed and got up to leave.
“Mario don't leave me here!”
“Mario! Princess Peach!” Pauline greeted them. “Fancy seeing you here! Isn't this weather gorgeous?”
Mario nodded, ignoring Peach's betrayed gaze. He'd love to stay and chat, but he needed to go meet his brother in the park. But he was sure that Peach would enjoy some company as she finished her lunch?
“I suppose that paperwork can wait a while longer,” Pauline sat down, putting her things on the table. “We haven't talked in forever, haven’t we? Are you feeling alright, though, Princess? You’re looking a bit red.”
“I’m fine!” Peach squeaked, blushing up a storm. “Um! So...how was your morning...?”
Annnd that was Mario’s cue to get out of earshot.
(Hopefully Peach would manage to not make too much of a fool of herself.
...
Oh, who was he kidding.)
"MAARIOOOO!!!!"
Mario knew that blood-curdling scream of terror anywhere! Luigi was in danger, and it was serious!
Mario jumped out of his chair and dashed off, leaving the kids standing at the table, bewildered.
Considering the size of Mushroom Park, Mario was able to find Luigi relatively quickly next to one of the gift shops. He skid to a halt in front of his brother, almost bowling him over. What's wrong?
“Nothing!”
...Are you sure?
“Yep!”
Mario stared at Luigi, who shrugged. “I dunno what you were doing over there, but you seemed kinda uncomfortable, so...”
How did you -
“You're not the only one with brotherly instincts!” Luigi beamed.
Mario still had so many questions, but in the end, he just patted his brother’s shoulder in thanks. Luigi puffed up in pride.
“So what were you doing, anyway?” Luigi asked as they picked a direction and started walking.
Mario described his encounter with the Toad children. Luigi winced in sympathy. “Yikes, that sucks, bro.”
Mario smiled weakly.
Shoulder-to-shoulder, the pair turned a corner past the Ferris wheel, and Luigi spotted a food stand. “Hey, I could go for a hot dog right now,” he remarked. “What about you?”
Mario thought of the lunch he’d abandoned in the plaza. Yeah, a hot dog sounded good.