Preface

fool me
Posted originally on the fanfiction.lol at https://fanfiction.lol/works/1774.

Rating:
Teen And Up Audiences
Archive Warnings:
Ableism, Major Character Death
Categories:
General (non relationship-focused), Other
Fandom:
Bloodborne (FromSoftware 2015 Video Game)
Characters:
Gehrman‚ The First Hunter (Bloodborne), Laurence the First Vicar (Bloodborne), Ludwig the Holy Blade (Bloodborne), Simon the Harrowed (Bloodborne), Lady Maria of the Astral Clocktower (Bloodborne)
Additional Tags:
Canon-Typical Violence, Angst, nothing is good and no one is happy
Language:
English
Stats:
Published: 2026-11-12 Words: 7,320 Chapters: 5/?

fool me

Summary

nightmares all the way down, folks.

or: the player kills Gehrman without clearing the DLC, and Gehrman ends up where all hunters end up. he handles this turn of events with Great Poise™.

Chapter 1

“It won't be for long,” Laurence said more than once in the months before they contacted Her.

There were arguments all the time, those days, Laurence with his Church and his healing and Gehrman with his Workshop and his hunting, the bloated shadow of the corpse they hadn't had the sense to leave alone threading silent tendrils through their words. The thought of seeing Laurence inspired near as much dread in Gehrman as the sight of another of his hunters lost to the beasts that loomed large and larger with every passing dawn. Gehrman still went, of course, when Laurence sent for him, but otherwise he avoided white robes like the plague. He remained in the Workshop night after night, tinkering with schematics and delegating the chance of crossing paths with Ludwig's band to his students.

The summoning was the one common ground they found. Laurence needed divine counsel, Gehrman the power to turn the tide. She offered both. Anything they wanted, the Choir translators relayed – anything at all.

The price was hardly a price.

They still argued. It seemed impossible for them not to anymore. When they had to meet to discuss the progress in negotiations, Laurence sounded like a looping record, this will solve a great deal and it has to be done and Yharnam can't last with us as we are, until Gehrman bit at him who are you trying to convince and Laurence snapped back can't you put up with me for one hour, fingers pressing into his eyes. He was getting headaches more often and growing less averse to placing the blame for them at Gehrman's feet.

It won't be for long was a phrase that cropped up as they neared the end. Laurence said, “I'll look for an alternative while you're gone. There must be one.”

“I'm trusting you,” Gehrman replied. That was the least threatening part of the arrangement, the time span. It wouldn't be forever. Whatever else Gehrman could and would say about Vicar Laurence, he would never deny that the man was brilliant. If another way existed – and it must, there could not be only one method to any result – then Laurence would find it.

She agreed to that term as well: when the hour came that Her help was no longer necessary, She would return what She took without conflict. So far as the Choir could tell, She was sincere. Though the gods can lie, they tend to be very bad at it; they don't understand humans well enough to know what information they can get away with twisting.

But years passed and the hunters who came through the dream stopped speaking of Laurence. Vicar Amelia, they said in the same breath as the Healing Church, and Laurence? No, I don't. No one's seen him in years. The Church won't say.

And Gehrman and Laurence had not told anyone about Her outside of the few Choir masters they couldn't have contacted Her without.

That seems, in retrospect, something of an oversight.

They had reason for it. The Fishing Hamlet's long pall still loomed over them. The Hamlet had been a mistake. It had been, really, the worst mistake anyone would ever make, and the second worst mistake was the number of people Gehrman and Laurence dragged into the floodwaters with them. The agreement to keep things with Her quiet was an unspoken one, but it bound them both as tightly as a blood oath: neither could have borne a potential repeat.

(They still could not discover the fate of the child. Though Gehrman had dreams, sometimes, and when he woke from them there was salt on his tongue and rain on his face and a cry caught unvoiced in his throat.

He did not tell Laurence.)

Regret is paltry when set against the weight of so many years. Gehrman is nothing anymore but tired. He wants to sleep, he wants to cut off his hands so they will never make anything again, he wants a sky without moonlight and a darkness without memories.

What he gets is another nightmare.

 

---

 

It's a bloodbath once he realizes what's happened. He rages. He curses and spits and howls. He descends from the abandoned Workshop in an onslaught of siderite and silver and paves a road with bodies through the Cathedral Ward. In the haze, he doesn't notice that he recognizes most of them, or he notices and doesn't care.

The Grand Cathedral might have been carved brick by brick from his memories. His scythe drags on the stairs, clanging against stone with every step he takes between the statues of the watcher gods.

The air is clear and sharp and hollow in his lungs. Nostalgia gnaws at the orange-lit shadows, homesickness sours each breath he takes, and he does not know if they come from the stench of the town's blood or the weight of the nightmarish sky. More of his life has been spent beneath the bleeding moon's eye than under Yharnam's spires.

“Laurence!” he shouts, voice cracking.

If he spared a thought to consider, he would come to the conclusion that Laurence has been buried for decades, that if he was not buried he would still be Gehrman's age and most likely retired, and that if he was not retired then he would still not be waiting here for Gehrman while there is a literal river of blood flowing through the Ward. But logic is not what brought him to the Cathedral. It has been a long night, and the non-sense of dreams comes too easily to him. If Laurence is anywhere in this parody of Yharnam, then this is the place where Gehrman will find him. That's all.

Some part of him hopes, as the name rings in his ears, that he'll clear the stairs to an empty hall. Laurence should not be in a nightmare. If Gehrman had his way, no one would. But the rest of him wants in that moment nothing more than to see Laurence again. His hands are steady, and his eyes are clear, and his voice shakes. He has waited; and he has waited; and he has waited; and the wait is over and it is not Laurence's doing.

He should know better than this. Searching for answers was what landed them here. But he is old and tired and stupid (Laurence was always the brilliant one); he is beyond regret and beyond consequences.

If Laurence is dead, Gehrman would like to see the corpse. It has been such a long night. He should be allowed that much resolution, at least.

Chapter 2: gods. laurence,

"what did you do?"

Chapter 3: there are no answers here

Time passes, maybe. The moon does not dim. Shadows remain.

(Gehrman couldn't name the moment in the dream when it happened. It was a thought he never consciously touched. But there arrived a point where he noticed that his fingers ached after he woke from sleep, that his knee burned when he forgot to favor it, that his doll stood taller than him and his bowing back; and he did not let himself think this is how it will end. He doesn't think that, still.)

Chapter 4

The nightmare is a litany of mistakes Gehrman never had the chance to make and others he never had the chance to stop. All he has left to him is the ability to clean up after the ruin.

To no one's surprise, he does that poorly.

He sinks to his knees beside Ludwig's head. Not out of respect or remorse or anything like that, he's just woozy from blood loss. It's been some time since he fought a beast. With his teeth and usable hand he ties the shredded rags of his sleeve around his shoulder.

“Gehrman?” Ludwig murmurs, eye rolling in its socket until it fixes on Gehrman's face.

“It's me, Ludwig.” The bandages are already dripping. Gehrman presses his hand to the wound until his wrinkled fingers are white under the blood. He rasps, “What should be done with the sword?”

Ludwig blinks, and some of the fog thins from his gaze. His distended pupil shines a little more clearly through the cataract. “He manages himself. Leave him be, or take him elsewhere. It shouldn't matter.” (Gehrman glances at the glowing, ten-foot relic lying in a pile of mangled not-quite-corpses and decides to opt for the former.) “Gehrman,” Ludwig mutters again, testing the word, searching for the familiarity that was once in it and which might be there still.

He snorts, and there's no trace of humanity in the sound. His voice, though – ah, but Gehrman can see, if he closes his eyes, a man speaking to him with that voice, warm and smiling and fair-haired under the sun. “Where were you?”

“Oh,” Gehrman sighs, “it's a long story.”

Ludwig does not press. Gehrman hopes it's not because Ludwig thinks he's already guessed some of the answer. Gehrman would rather Ludwig not think on it at all.

What occurred with Gehrman and with the dream and with Her was largely his own fault. It can't be compared to Yharnam's tragedy, to the stories of every human person caught in this nightmare unending and to the hurt of the good man in front of him who he still hasn't offered mercy to. Small and selfish thing that it is, his loss shouldn't be raised in the same breath as theirs. Ludwig should not feel the need to care about it.

“What happened when I was gone?” Gehrman asks.

“I don't know,” says Ludwig. His voice fades with his words, growing distant. “I don't know. The plague grew insistent. The beasts were larger. Stronger. They learned cunning. We required more blood each night. I worried our stock would run dry, but there was always more....”

Gehrman lets go of his shoulder to rub his thumb over Ludwig's cheek. The once-captain of the Church hunters closes his eye. “I wasn't any help to the Healing Church,” Ludwig says, “nor to the vicar.”

“No one can help Laurence when he isn't looking for it.”

“Have you seen him?” Ludwig asks.

Gehrman's expression does not change, but his hand stills.

Ludwig's eye meets his. “I have not, but I've heard he's here. Please – if you can, find him. This fate shouldn't be his.”

“All right,” Gehrman says, soft.

With the rush of the fight wearing off, pain sinks its claws in inch by inch. Gehrman'd rather forgotten the feeling of surviving a heavy injury. He doesn't much care about the possibility of losing the arm, knowing as he does that it will mend over whether he would like it to or not, but the knives stabbing into his left shoulder make it harder to put his thoughts in order. It takes a disproportionate amount of concentration simply to keep his thumb moving in a steady pattern.

Ludwig gasps for breath under his hand. Damp, long, snuffling inhalations. Gurgles when he sucks in the blood on the floor in place of air.

“Gehrman,” he manages. A plea. “If you've asked what you had to....” Gehrman's grip tightens involuntarily at the flare of anger that snares him, the desire to see broken everything that brought a proud man down to begging in his own and others' filth.

There is nothing Gehrman can lash out at. The scourge is not an enemy he can hurt any more than his self of the past is. He smooths away the anger with an effort – but some edges remain, still, and perhaps those are what lead Gehrman to turn the conversation away from what Ludwig wants. He tsks. “When did this happen to you? How long after I left?”

“You left when.... It was thirteen years after. No, it was fourteen.”

“Laurence?”

Ludwig's answer lodges behind Gehrman's ribs with a physical presence. “He was human when I fell.”

The Church hunter says, “I cannot tell you when that changed.”

And: “Forgive me.”

Two decades, thereabouts. Gehrman hopes it was longer than that, that Laurence held on to his sharp mind for as long as he could have, but – Laurence found nothing in that time, no alternative to Her. Not one.

Gehrman wondered, after he came to know Her well, how She could have agreed so readily to give him up once the terms expired –

She knew long before they did that they would not find another solution in time.

It came down to hubris, did it not? Always that. They thought they'd learned something from their mistakes, and yet it hadn't seemed overconfidence to them to think that they could end the hunt in a lifetime. They'd destroyed so much in the short years after Byrgenwerth, broken the limits of humanity and gained an understanding of the world that they couldn't have imagined before. They'd brought miracles to Yharnam. What was the scourge against what they had found? The hunters had even conquered the Fishing Hamlet, the shining proof that it could be done, that the scourge was not unbreakable, that they had not lost all control over what they had sought the attention of.

Gods, but they'd thought the Hamlet a resolution at the time. What went on in that village happened once, and so they would not let it happen again, and that was the end of the matter, nearly a victory. A regrettable victory, a wretched and broken one, but they had salvaged lessons from the wreckage. Knowledge was greater than the minds that held it. Learning was what mattered, and they had found much of that in the Fishing Hamlet.

“Forgive you,” says Gehrman. He sounds cold to his own ears; bitter, biting ice. Steel and teeth, like the things he made in younger days. His hearing isn't what it was. “Whatever for, Ludwig?”

Ludwig doesn't respond. His eye is lidded. The blood on the floor hardly stirs when his breaths ghost across it.

Gehrman splays his hands over Ludwig's snout. The thick, bristle-haired beast-hide under his fingers, slick with blood and phlegm and sweat, burns feverishly hot. He can feel the shape of the teeth beneath it. “Shh, shh. Stay with me, old friend,” he says, and Ludwig startles back to focus with a gasp. “How much longer do you have?”

“Don't ask me that. Gehrman, please – ”

“I must sleep,” he says, cutting easily through Ludwig's words, “if this is to heal. Can you keep watch?”

“Damn it, Gehrman,” Ludwig rasps, lips peeling back from his gums.

Not a refusal.

Gehrman says, “The injury wouldn't exist if you hadn't put it there.”

Ludwig whickers. “That was not my fault,” he says with heat. That's an area Ludwig used to agree with him on, Gehrman remembers. A man is not to be judged for how he acts as a beast. He only didn't think Ludwig would apply his own words to himself.

“Then call it a favor,” Gehrman replies.

It's a moment before Ludwig speaks again. He sighs then, a long, wet, rattling exhalation. “Have you heard of honor duels?”

“The Cainhurst tradition?”

“It's tempting,” he murmurs.

Ludwig could only currently hurt a fly if the insect took the initiative to land on his tongue. They're both aware of as much. That's rather the point. “It won't be for long,” Gehrman says, trying for reassuring and taking a wrong turn into the neighboring province of exhausted instead. “A few hours.”

“And after....”

“Yes. Of course.”

 

---

 

He carries Ludwig up to the drier grounds at the top of the stairs and falls asleep with his back against the paladin. His dreams are of rain.

The former beast's voice mixes with the crying child's for a bare, awful moment, and then sleep falls away. Ludwig says quietly, “Watch the entrance.”

Gehrman twists around to check on him first. He looks much the same as earlier, no worse and certainly no better. Gehrman rests a hand against his cheek. Then he moves away and pushes himself up with the scythe for support.

There is someone by the way he entered, stopped close enough to the exit to make an easy escape should things come to that. Caution is not a trait beasts are known for. This might not end in a death. “Well?” Gehrman calls.

The gaunt newcomer doesn't move. One of the Harrowed. Or an imitator, but he doesn't judge it likely. There are very few reasons one would steal the garments of a hunter dressed in rags. The Harrowed approaches once the last echoes fade, halting again after crossing half the space between them. Gehrman can't immediately identify the weapon on the hunter's back. “Did you defeat him?” the Harrowed asks.

“I did.”

“You made all the corpses between here and the Cathedral Ward,” he says.

It's not what the man means to imply, but Gehrman's face still creases at the thought that he might be known by only the deaths he's responsible for. He agrees, as it happens – how could he not, standing in the red nightmare of his legacy? – but the fact remains cutting. “You are....”

“I....” The Harrowed hesitates. “Simon is my name.”

Informative.

“You seek the end of the nightmare, do you not?” he quickly adds. “Then let me come with you. You owe me as much. You owe me more than that.”

“Oh.... You know who I am?”

“The first of us, and nearly the last,” says Simon, and very suddenly Gehrman notices the tension he tries to conceal. It doesn't come from simple wariness. The man is frightened, of a former hunter who lost his wheelchair somewhere in the ether. Stars above. What does he think Gehrman might do to him? “The only one of the old guard I couldn't find in this place no matter how I searched.” He swallows then, fingers clenching as he steels himself. He says, a little hoarsely, “You've joined the rest of us at last. Was it time that finally caught up to you?”

“If time comes in the guise of multiple stab wounds,” Gehrman says casually, and pays attention to the blade-edged smile that briefly touches Simon's lips. No one in this room died well.

He folds up the scythe and returns it to the carrier on his back. He doesn't need a weapon now. “Yes, it was our mistakes that brought you here, I don't deny it.” He thinks of rain, and brine, and a mother's curse. Kos was not the one who first made the decision to haul innocents into the crossfire. “I won't stop you from coming if that's what you want.”

He returns to Ludwig, and the quiet splashes behind him tell him that Simon has taken the invitation to approach. Gehrman doesn't mind if the Harrowed listens on this conversation. The man's not likely to spread around what he hears, after all.

Ludwig, too, puts in only a perfunctory effort at lowering his voice. “Stab wounds?” he murmurs.

“A disagreement.”

“Over what?”

“They didn't say.” Ludwig squints at him. Gehrman caves a little, enough to add, “I pulled a blade on them.”

“That doesn't sound like you.”

He's tempted in that moment to explain the dream simply to delay by a little more what's coming, but he's put it off for too long already. Ludwig's patience won't hold. Gehrman only says mildly, “It's what happened,” before he hesitates. The quiet waxes between them. “Ludwig. You're certain.”

“This liminal state won't last.” The scourge doesn't play by half measures. Ludwig cannot be a man in a beast's body forever. The captain of hunters breathes in deeply, slowly, and with all the weight of desperation tells Gehrman, “I can't fall again. I can't.”

“No,” Gehrman agrees softly.

Ludwig holds his gaze. “I did you your favor.”

He nods.

It's not so different, in the end, from what She had him doing. He's crafted much in his life, weapons and armors and orders and dolls, and yet the kindest thing his wrinkled hands have ever been able to offer remains unchanging. Ludwig follows the blade as Gehrman draws it. He does not look away when Gehrman splays a steady hand against his skin, framing his eye between thumb and forefinger. "Take care of yourself," he says, and it is Gehrman then who cannot entirely hold back a flinch.

He does not look away when Gehrman brings the sword down. Siderite tears through his blotted pupil and sinks into his brain. His muscles slacken all at once.

When Gehrman slides the blade out, there is nothing left of Ludwig but the body that betrayed him.

 

---

 

Gehrman gets to his feet. Simon, by the stair railing, makes a small aborted motion towards him, as if he was about to help Gehrman up before he remembered where and who they are.

“Let us continue,” Gehrman says. He doesn't quite recognize his own voice, but the Harrowed makes no comment on it as he follows

Chapter 5

Ludwig's death broke a seal, carved a crack into the nightmare's shell. When Gehrman presses a hand (steady, ever steady) to the flesh beneath he can feel the cold pulse of its blood, the rise and the ebb of it, as if it beats under his own skin. Even beyond the nightmare's contortion of the landscape, the Church's facilities have morphed and grown since last he walked them, but all veins circle back to the heart. In the nightmare of a man born and raised in the lee of a mountain, the answer to where to go will always be up.

Simon trails him, a silent shadow whose input comes entirely in the form of well-aimed arrows. It's an unconventional choice of weapon, moreso since its wielder appears to be wholly and totally blind, but Simon's eccentricities are not Gehrman's to question.

Then they reach a lift and Simon reveals himself to be chatty enough after all. Gehrman wipes his blade down – as if there's any point, as if it will stay clean in this place – while Simon pokes and prods away at the altar on the elevator, speaking his conjectures aloud.

Much of the business of maintaining a cult relies on ceremony and dramatics. A vicar with the funds might decide, then, to manufacture an intensely symbolic ritual involving a mummified corpse and a set of looming statues instead of simply setting down a pressure plate to operate his elevator. Laurence has a talent for that sort of calculation, material costs against ideological gains. With half a liter of blood, a friend whose great ambition lay in improving farming tools, a half-baked ideology of salvation through destruction of the body's ills, and what loans he could pull together from sources that wouldn't ask terribly inconvenient questions, he took over a city in eight years. Money alone couldn't have done that. Few things could have. Laurence happened to be one.

Gehrman remembers with perfect clarity the first time he saw Laurence again after the latter left Byrgenwerth. Which is a strange claim to make, when most of that memory has worn down with age. He does not remember the smell of the lamps, or the pattern of the wallpaper, or whether the floorboards creaked. He does not even remember what Laurence was doing when Gehrman pushed open the door.

“Surprise. I hope you didn't leave because you were sick of rooming with me,” Gehrman said then. “You're stuck with me.”

Looking faintly shell-shocked, Laurence asked, “Did you leave Byrgenwerth?”

“Yes,” Gehrman replied, lying.

He had packed his things and walked out of the college gates, but that was not what Laurence was asking. The question he meant was Did Master Willem throw you out too? And to that the answer was No. Master Willem hadn't said a word to him. The ultimatum had been issued only to Laurence. With the ringleader removed, the provost must have thought the followers would fall into line without more pressure. It was a novelty – Willem does not often misjudge people.

Gehrman cannot imagine the sound of Laurence's voice anymore, could not sketch his face onto paper and expect to recognize it afterwards. But somehow, even without those details, he remembers Laurence's expression in that moment. And he remembers what he thought, seeing it. That whatever else would come, wherever they might end up, at the very least this would always have been the right decision.

Gehrman cuts his palm on the scythe blade so he'll have a little more blood to clean off. Only a little, as Simon's nearly done. The man's narrowed it down to the head of the corpse on the altar. He sounds very knowledgeable on the Church's traditions, as he would be if he was born after its establishment and grew up to find employment in its ranks. He's part of a generation Gehrman has met only in passing.

Simon finds a mechanism hidden inside the skull and goes to look over the bodies of the clergymen who occupied the room until their arrival. His search turns up an eye-shaped pendant that fits neatly into the slot, at which point the lift cranks into motion.

When it halts at the top, Simon asks, “Do you hear that?”

“I hear water.”

“No, I meant... what water?”

“Nothing.”

Something about Gehrman's tone shuts Simon down. He doesn't stop to examine what it might be.

Onwards, now, into the most infamous of the Church's medical research centers.

(Simon does not bring it up again.)

 

---

 

The Research Hall began with good intentions.

They had need of a facility in which to isolate and treat the Fishing Hamlet's afflicted – a proper facility, with equipment and laboratories and personnel, not the makeshift camp erected around the witch doctor's home. It would have had to be in Yharnam proper, and near to the Church's headquarters, where supplies could be easily accessed and where the air was cleaner closer to the heavens. It would have had to be somewhere few ever went, because at the time they had not yet determined the cause or spread of the illness.

The building at the base of the Clocktower suited their purposes. Though – it's a misnomer to claim their purposes. Gehrman's knowledge of the human body's functions is entirely practical and centers largely on how to stop them. Though he helped in the Fishing Hamlet, where manpower was in more demand than expertise, his aid became obsolete when the Church relocated their efforts. He remained in the Hamlet then to enforce the quarantine. Laurence likewise delegated the matter of treatment to those more practiced and turned his own efforts to determining the cause of the sickness, which was characterized in those early days by dreams of cold waters and a compulsion to drink brine. Manageable symptoms. There were no physical transformations yet.

Under the Church's guidance, most of the Fishing Hamlet's afflicted recovered. The facility that would become the Research Hall did measurable good. It saved lives.

That's always been the trouble with plagues: you never can see enough of the battlefield to know that you're losing.

The Hall was already on its way to morphing into a different sort of institution when Gehrman left. More experimental treatment methods to combat the vicious pace of the beast plague's growth. More ambitious projects to increase the potency and healing of blood. Laurence invested more funding and his personal attention into the Research Hall's progress. Its purpose had shifted away from patient care, earning it its name. It stopped taking in those with a chance of recovery.

However, the Research Hall in the nightmare is not the Hall as Gehrman last remembers it any more than it is the Hall as it first began. The discrepancy almost gives him pause. There's no reason for the nightmare to have recreated it in this state.

But he takes that unease no further. He acknowledges that the facility should not be but does not speculate as to why it is regardless. Does not voice the question aloud, where an answer might find it. Given a choice, he chooses not to know.

Of the more lucid patients, the ones who can still speak enough to request – he does for them what they ask. There's no more reason to hold them trapped. He takes their hands, waits for their fingers to grip his back, waits for them to realize that they are not alone, and then he sinks his sword into their swollen heads. Clear, bloodless fluid follows when he pulls the blade out. It spreads into their mattresses and pools across the tiles, stinking of salt and sick and iron; as it flows out, the patients' heads flatten to the thinness of leather, becoming mere skin with whatever traces of liquid remain inside. These are men and women who can potentially survive as nothing but a head; this is the only way to be sure, other than burning.

Gehrman was the first hunter in Yharnam. The designation is not a title. At best and at worst, it is only a statement of fact. He was the first in Yharnam to walk out into the night to seek the terrors that lurked in it. He was the first to acknowledge that beasts could not be healed and then to act upon that understanding. He was the first to offer plague victims that final mercy. Some things don't change so quickly.

It's as he's doing this that he hears the name spoken for the first time. The recognition doesn't catch immediately and won't for some time. The name is not so uncommon that she is the only one to come to mind when he hears it. Some part of him does notice – without intending to, he thinks one of the abrupt, meaningless distraction thoughts that only ever crop up when they serve the least use: you could do worse than that one if your last word has to be a name.

(He'll hear her name spoken again, and again, and again, on the way up. The nightmare might be Gehrman's, might be Kos's, might be Yharnam's, but the Research Hall is Maria's as much as it is the patients', her victory and her failure. Maria is nothing like Gehrman: she would not allow herself to be forgotten. Rip away the mountain below and the Hall would not waver where it stands. The foundation it rests upon is the mercy he taught her, nothing so ephemeral as brick or mortar. She carved her name onto its lips and with her death stole its heart.

She always seemed the sort to take a grudge to the grave.)

Gehrman looks up from the last patient's cot to see that Simon's come back and is leaning against the doorway. He left for a while earlier, to scout or to stand guard or… Gehrman wasn't paying attention. New splatters have joined the existing community of suspicious stains across his rags. “Are you done? So that's all of them. In just this room, at least,” Simon says. He crosses his arms. “I wonder where they are now.”

“Not here.”

“It doesn't get any worse than here,” says Simon, sardonic. It's an indictment, not agreement.

Later, in the rafters and shadows overlooking the open Hall, Simon asks him, “Were you involved?”

“I'm going to have to ask you to specify.”

Simon's footsteps stop. Gehrman's don't. “The Church,” Simon says to his back. Low, and trailing to nothing. Maybe it wasn't what he planned to ask. But his voice rings out again after the hesitation, louder this time and no more confident: “How much involvement did you have in the Church?”

Didn't Simon claim to know of Gehrman? Gehrman frowns, rapping his sword against his shoulder thrice before he notices what he's doing and drops his hand back to his side. (Rats ahead, but steel arrows topple them limply one by one out of the rafters.) How can he answer that? How should he boil down the most tumultuous years of his life into simple noise for a stranger to understand?

When he reaches the wheel controlling the central staircase, he waits rather than turn it immediately. If Simon wants to talk, they might as well do it here, where there's the least chance of interruption. He leans against the pillar that the wheel circles, groaning when the shift in weight sets off a spike of pain where the false leg connects. An ache has been building with every step climbed. By design, the prosthetic is terrible. His first was less shoddy in all respects, but it ended up lobbed over the side of the dream in a fit of pique. No use for a good leg he couldn't go anywhere on.

Simon catches up to him in his own time. Gehrman's fingers go still against the pillar, and only then does he realize that he was drumming them on the wood in time with the falling water. The sound of it is clearer up here.

He shakes the distraction off and asks Simon, “Were you asking after the Workshop or after me?”

“It's not the Workshop I'm talking to.”

So it isn't. “I helped Laurence when he was getting it off the ground. Found some benefactors, some supporters. Carried heavy things. It wasn't a religious order then. Laurence wasn't a vicar, only a preacher. And then he became a messiah, and the Healing Church rose around him,” Gehrman says. The blood has ever been a miracle. There was a plague in Yharnam even then, before the scourge. It took a vastly different form than its successor would, but at the time it inspired near as much fear. They did not think that there could be so much worse.

That particular illness, at least, has not returned to Yharnam since its eradication, even as it flares up cyclically in surrounding towns. For that, one might have the grounds to call the past seventy-odd years a rousing success.

“You're asking if the Church would exist differently if not for me. I can't answer that. Many of the structures we put into place in the earliest days didn't survive into the leviathan that the organization became. They were meant for holding together a fledgling group that had just begun to grow in numbers. When it was large enough to be called a church we recreated it from the ground up, and then Laurence and his followers did it once more with less of my input after we took control of City Hall. That is… you would know it as the Upper Cathedral Ward."

There is bile in his throat, rising with each word spoken. His eyes are hot. It's a physical reaction, not an emotional one; he recalls it happening these past years whenever he has the rare occasion to speak on this topic. On the whole, it's more irritating than anything else. He looks up quickly, blinks the heat and bitterness away, and continues without interruption, “I slept through most of it that time. I'd only just gone several days without rest. But Laurence waited until I was up to draft the plans for a new order of hunters for the Church. I asked why he didn't just agree to fold the Workshop into the Church, and he said the Workshop shouldn't be burdened with politics.” Something of a shift from his stance a few days prior. Then again, a few days prior Laurence was both not on speaking terms with Gehrman and in gaol, Gehrman was technically an outlaw, and City Hall was under the governance of lawfully elected officials.

Speaking aloud puts things into clearer perspective. Gehrman sighs. “It would have taken longer to establish the Healing Church if I weren't there,” he tells Simon, “and hunters might not exist. They would exist differently, at the least.”

Ludwig might –

– Simon didn't ask.

Simon is quiet for a moment, before he says, “I don't truthfully know much about you.”

“You recognized me quickly enough.”

Simon shrugs. “I've known of you, although I didn't understand until I… until I went looking.” He treats the phrase gingerly, a euphemism. Gehrman doesn't ask, though he imagines Simon might want him to. “When someone points to a custom as something hunters have always practiced, they don't mean hunters, really. They mean you. Even when they wouldn't recognize your name, they mean you.” An unnameable expression crawls over what part of his face isn't hidden. “You are going to see things through.”

“Have – ” – I given you a reason to think I won't?

But the question remains buried, as mysteries should. He replies instead, “Yes. Yes, that's right.”

He sets his weight against the wheel. Far below, a path opens through to the Astral Clocktower.

They don't proceed immediately. Gehrman sits down to let the ache in his leg ebb. Though it's a mistake to sleep so close to the source, he manages to doze off inadvertently. He wakes to Simon shaking him by the shoulder. “I did try to wait,” Simon says – twice, when Gehrman doesn't register it the first time – stepping back as Gehrman hauls himself to his feet.

Gehrman wipes the tears off with a sleeve. “Good call. I wouldn't have come out on my own,” he replies briskly.

He doesn't ask if he talked. What he saw is already fading, but he has dreamed that dream so many times that the memory of it has built upon itself into clarity. He always speaks in it, and his voice is not always his own.

They descend. At some point during the climb he hears his name spoken, hears it clear as day. Turning, he asks quietly, “Ludwig?” But there's no one there but for Simon, who did not say anything and now says only a small and terrible “No.” Gehrman looks at him. It takes him a second to remember what he did that prompted the reply, and a second more to remember why it could not have been Ludwig.

Never mind.

Through the gardeners, over the bridge. The Clocktower, doors shut tight. He makes to open them, and a realization hits then, sudden and cold like flash frost: there's nothing within the Clocktower's interior that can be called relevant to what occurred. These doors might open directly to the Fishing Hamlet.

He doesn't notice Simon moving until the man's pushed the doors halfway open already; by then it's a tad late to do anything for it.

Through the doorway is –

– a figure he knows. Knows that hair, knows that face: hours on days held between his hands, whittling the wood into shape, time stolen away between hunting and waiting and killing and burying and delving and praying and waking and dreaming spent in the crafting of a thing beautiful and absolutely, utterly, pointedly functionless. Knows that posture, slumped where he abandoned it, though she never remains so for longer than the time it takes a hunter to learn how to rouse her. Even after she's shattered. He has tried... but she remembers the reason by which she exists, and for all that she might pass for lifelike, that she might even bleed, she is yet something made. She is still and ever what he built her to be, and he did not build her to die.

Why is she here? Why is she here? The sight of her dredges up the scent-memory of lumenflowers (he does not, in that moment, remember to think of the garden behind him) and the dust and dryness in the Workshop (aged wood all smells much the same, be it in a house on a hill or in a sealed clocktower) and the moon above (golden, this one, reflecting an older and more weathered light, but only the moon in red holds a markedly different scent from its other phases). Which dream is he dreaming? Should he wake again, where will he wake to?

He turns away, but the flowers that cover the bridge, the open air over the railings, the moon burnished and bloody amber overhead – he takes a long breath, holds his brow against the lightheadedness until it passes. “I hate this place,” he whispers. Simon snorts.

“Have I been going in the wrong direction?” Gehrman asks. He doesn't know any reason why Simon might have a better idea than him, but on the chance that the man does, and on the chance that the answer might be yes....

Simon genuinely seems to consider the question. “This is the Astral Clocktower, is it not?”

“What the hell does the Clocktower have to do with anything? We didn't kill anyone there.” Not that he remembers, at least.

Simon doesn't respond for a second. Then: “That explains much more than it should.”

“What?”

“Maybe you never killed anyone here,” he says magnanimously, “but someone did. She killed a significant number of people, even. The Church had no easy time of it sweeping things under the rug afterwards. I don't know if you've been in Yharnam lately, but the Research Hall as I know it is haunted. The Lady Maria's final living act left echoes.”

“The – ” Gehrman doesn't look inside the room. He doesn't move at all. Easy enough to ignore it before, with Maria being hardly a rare name and the title attached to it being one she never once brought up of her own accord, but his denial is reaching its limit. “...From Cainhurst?”

Simon replies with something, but Gehrman doesn't hear it. He turns back, and there she is still, still, perfectly preserved as she should never have been – she must have passed on barely any time at all after Gehrman left – and if it is her, if it truly is her, then nothing will ever change the fact that he saw her again and the first identity that came to his mind was the doll's. Here is a thought from the time after he stopped hearing Laurence's name spoken: that there might arrive down the distant road a night when no passing hunter remembered the person Gehrman stole the features on the doll from. That the broken imitation might become all they would know of her. And now he –

He almost doesn't notice moving. Somehow he avoids setting his false leg through any of the holes in the floor, and then he's near enough to see that it is skin, not paint after all, even though the color is one shade of pale off from a corpse. Her eyes are closed, she is not stirring, she is not breathing, and neither at the moment is Gehrman. He reaches out to break her stasis.

It works, more or less: she grabs him by the wrist before he comes anywhere close to touching her.

She opens her eyes, and Gehrman sees then the instant when whatever she meant to say dies on her tongue. He does not much want to consider the doll, but it is impossible to see the expressions flitting across Maria's face and not think of how much he has missed seeing that face carry any affect at all.

After Ludwig, after... Gehrman did not imagine he might meet any old compatriot in the nightmare still human and lucid. His throat is too choked to speak.

It is a gunshot that breaks the silence.

Gehrman's knees buckle. Maria catches him as the pain hits, a searing, stabbing ache in his chest. “You really were not expecting that?” she asks, a strange note in her voice.

“No,” Gehrman gasps. Of course he wasn't. His blood is getting all over Maria's coat. She shot him nearly in the heart. He thinks that he should be more upset at her for it, but all his anger is wrapped up around himself for mistaking her for the doll. Redirecting it would frankly require too much effort. He's not sure what he is feeling about Maria right now, but it's nothing like anger.

He grabs her sleeves through the spreading weakness, trying to haul himself upright to no effect. The last thing he hears before things go dark is Maria's voice saying into his ear, “I made a mistake.”

Afterword

Please drop by the Archive and comment to let the creator know if you enjoyed their work!