Preface

in other news
Posted originally on the fanfiction.lol at https://fanfiction.lol/works/1769.

Rating:
Teen And Up Audiences
Archive Warning:
Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Category:
General (non relationship-focused)
Fandom:
Naruto
Relationships:
Hatake Kakashi & Maito Gai | Might Guy, Hatake Kakashi & Hoshigaki Kisame, Hoshigaki Kisame & Uchiha Itachi
Characters:
Maito Gai | Might Guy, Hatake Kakashi, Hoshigaki Kisame
Language:
English
Series:
Part 2 of a dog and a shark
Stats:
Published: 2026-11-12 Words: 3,329 Chapters: 2/?

in other news

Summary

addendums to "a dog and a shark walk into a bar"

Chapter 1: Gai

Chapter Summary

Gai didn't learn until he was twenty that love needs to be conditional from the outset. He cannot forgive Kakashi what his rival did because it isn't his place to and because, if he does, he will forgive Kakashi anything. I enjoy the world much better with you in it needs a point where it stops.

...He also cannot forgive Kakashi because he already has, which is making this all even harder than it should be.

Chapter Notes

hello! this will probably make very little sense if you haven't read to the end of chapter 2 in "a dog and a shark walk into a bar".

It's only March, but Hatake Sakumo's tomb has, as usual, been vandalized in the months since last August's Obon. Luckily, Gai comes prepared. He sweeps aside the leaves and dust, wipes off the graffiti, and then, carefully, removes what shattered fragments of the headstone remain on the grave and sets his newly commissioned one in its place, cementing it with a quiet earth jutsu. He lays a small tray of plain dango in front.

He turns to the half of the old headstone that lies buried in the unkempt grass, where the culprit who broke it left it like trash. No point guessing who did it this time: it could have been anyone. He buries it by hand, then sits back to consider his work.

It's always a little awkward. He shouldn't be the one here.

He met Sakumo a few times in passing, always with Kakashi as the bridge, so he remembers only an impression of a silver-haired man with bags under his eyes and wrinkles lining his face, soft-spoken, kind in a baffled sort of way like he wasn't sure he was doing it right.

For a time, Kakashi spoke the world of him, his father the White Fang, protector of the Village, a great shinobi who'd felled countless enemies. He'd bought Kakashi a pack of shuriken, shown him how to prepare an inkstone for calligraphy and how to draw an alarm seal, gotten home in time to heat breakfast and brought dried salmon to top the congee with. Gai got jealous sometimes. His own father never seemed to care about him as much as Sakumo did Kakashi.

Then he grew a bit older, and he began to wonder how many empty mornings Kakashi woke up to if his parent making breakfast was a special occasion worth getting excited about.

He clears his throat. “Hatake-san, I hope this finds you at peace. My rival and I met a week ago.”

He doesn't need to modulate his voice much. Sakumo's tomb is a forlorn place, hidden out of sight and out of memory past the small graveyard's boundaries.

Kakashi is, as ever, difficult to talk about, all the more so to his father. Every part of his character is tempered by the weight of his worst act. He was a dedicated shinobi, but.... He put his comrades' safety first, but.... He lived each stage of his life in the aftermath of tragedy, and eventually his grief took him over.

Gai tells Sakumo that Kakashi seems to be doing well. He looked like he hasn't eaten enough lately, but that might have been Gai's fault, what with the extent of the injuries Kakashi took from him. Kakashi's taijutsu has improved. He got along with Lee and Naruto and even spoke a direct apology for a mistake, which points to some degree of personal development. The ninja he was working with laughed at his vulnerability, and he allowed it; possibly he was distracted by Gai at the time, but Gai still wonders if he might have made a friend.

(Gai asked around Wave about that other ninja afterwards, but mostly got back that they were Blue and kind of tall.)

An hour after arriving, he stands and bows to take his leave. The sky has already gone eggshell blue. He doesn't have team training today, having given his subordinates a long weekend to recover their spirits following the mission, but Lee and, recently, Sakura like to join him for morning workouts. The living should always take precedent over the dead.

Chapter 2: Kisame (omake)

Chapter Summary

Snapshot of a different story, one where canon!verse Kisame dropped in on AU Kakashi after dying.
or: a shark and a dog walk into a bar

“What,” Kisame says after he dies.

For a throat he felt get ripped open by a shark, it's performing unexpectedly well. He ghosts his fingers over his neck, idly tracing the contours of seamless, bloodless skin, without taking his eyes off of the ninja sitting across the table from him.

Hatake Kakashi, jounin of Konoha. Kisame met him only once, but he remembers the man without much difficulty. Kakashi gave him plenty of reason to. Killing Zabuza, withstanding Itachi's horror show of a genjutsu, helping kill Kakuzu and Hidan and maiming Deidara, and word is he landed a finishing blow on a puppet body of Pein's. One of Konoha's problem cases as far as opponents go.

None of which goes any ways towards explaining why he's wearing Itachi's ring and a slashed headband and an Akatsuki cloak and watching Kisame with focus but no wariness from three feet and a pot of tea away.

Samehada's familiar weight rests on Kisame's back. Her betrayal still stings, even knowing he hasn't ever owned her, not truly – Samehada chooses her own wielders, years of feeding and caretaking and learning her moods be damned... and what a rich sentiment, coming from him. At the end of an interminably long life spent betraying nearly every small trust placed into his care, his final reward has been his own sword turning against him. He's in little position to cry foul.

But here she is now, content with Kisame and placid beneath her bandage wrappings. Unlike him, she never forgets a chakra signature; she must recognize Kakashi as an enemy, yet she's as drowsy as if she has no expectation of Kisame wielding her against him.

Well, Kakashi at the end of the day is Kisame's enemy, not Samehada's. He won't make the mistake twice of forgetting that distinction.

“Something happened there,” Kakashi says, straightening from his slouch.

If this is another Yamanaka technique, it's a notably ineffectual one. They're in what appears to be an Earth Country town, at a small teahouse with seating on the street. It's broad daylight and not a ninja in sight aside from the two of them. No urgency, no stressor, no one around who Kisame might be coaxed into speaking of sensitive information with, and Kakashi appears, at a glance, willing to sit and wait on him without pressing for at least a moment longer. Whatever this is, it isn't part of an interrogation.

He's going to express some opinions if this is Infinite Tsukuyomi. It'd be terribly anticlimactic for this non sequitur of a scene to be the best Madara's masterpiece can conjure.

Kakashi's brow furrows. “Do you recognize me?”

Kisame bit off his own tongue and got himself eaten by sharks not two minutes ago. That he is somehow alive makes every other question pale in comparison.

“Who do you believe I am?” he says in place of an answer, tone level in spite of the rising potential for violence.

Kakashi tips his head faintly to the side, still not visibly concerned for his own safety. He's not a clone, Samehada can tell that much, and he doesn't have allies nearby who she can sense. Village-aligned shinobi travel alone so rarely that it's practically a statistical error – and Copy Ninja Kakashi is aligned with Konoha, no matter how naturally and thoughtlessly he spaces out the fingers of his right hand to account for the ring. Kisame doesn't reach for Samehada, but he does identify the farthest six substitution points and sink his thumbnail into his index finger with enough force to draw the blood for a summoning.

“Well, we live together,” Kakashi murmurs. Kisame's expression twists, but he doesn't interrupt as Kakashi continues at a more casual volume, “You're Hoshigaki Kisame, missing-nin of Kiri. If you weren't, your sword would have noticed. Not to mention that you do act like him.” He'd know that, would he? “You're not under a genjutsu because they don't affect you if you don't let them.” That's... not actually true, not so long as Itachi existed at one point, but it's close enough that Kisame has to master his reaction. Itachi should be the only Konoha-nin aware of the specifics of how Samehada disrupts her wielder's chakra flow. “Who do you believe you are?”

When Kisame doesn't respond, Kakashi leans in, propping his elbow on the rickety table and his masked chin on his knuckles. Dust-sized specks of electricity flare and fade across his hand, though it feels more like a minor chakra control exercise than the prelude to any sort of real technique. He gives the date and the location, then asks for the last thing Kisame remembers.

“That is not the date,” Kisame says.

“Hm.” Again Kakashi asks, “Do you know who I am?”

Ignoring his own death, ignoring what he knows of Kakashi, ignoring every piece of information about how the world functions and looking only at what's in front of him in this instant: Kisame is alive, Samehada is nominally his, the Akatsuki are an unknown group worth no particular reaction from passersby, and Kakashi is just as baffled as Kisame for the opposite reasons. Akatsuki, after all, work in pairs, and Kisame to all appearances has suddenly, inexplicably forgotten as much.

In which case.... “You wouldn't happen to recognize the name Uchiha Itachi?”

Kakashi's breath catches. Kisame thinks, with the slow, ponderous inevitability of a glacier, that if Kakashi killed Itachi to claim that ring then Kisame will butcher him. Not that Kisame's usually so sentimental; it's only that, right now, he wouldn't turn down an excuse to hurt someone.

“I would,” Kakashi answers, voice even despite the reaction. He drums his fingers on the table. “Why do you ask?”

“Is he alive?”

“Should be. Ah...” He cracks a smile that reaches his eye. It's visibly lopsided even with the mask hiding most of it: a little embarrassed. “...his family, too. Some of them.”

“The little brother.” More than that?

“...The little brother,” Kakashi echoes. “Uchiha Sasuke-chan. I don't imagine Itachi would have let anything happen to him.” He cocks his head. “No one else?”

“No,” says Kisame.

“Mikoto-san? Shisui? ...No?” The smile hasn't wavered. “Well, this isn't anywhere close to what I thought would be happening today, but we can go visit Itachi if you want. I can't think of a reason he'd have to recognize you, Kisame, so talking to him might be a bad idea, but taking a quick look should be harmless.”

“In Konoha?” Kisame asks slowly, through several layers of skepticism. On one hand, that Itachi's alive... and on the other, that a Konoha-nin is raising the possibility that Kisame might follow him into a hostile stronghold on nothing but his word.

“He's been there for the past few years, I think. Hasn't left that I've heard. Do you want to go alone?”

Kisame's lips draw back to bare teeth. “What is happening here?”

Kakashi hums, fingers curling loosely against his palm. A few last sparks dwindle to nothing against his skin, but it feels like he might still be circulating lightning chakra around the hand even though the visible indicator of it has stopped. “I don't know. You're not...” His expression evens out into something more considering. “...who you're supposed to be. As far as you remember, Itachi's the one who killed his family and spared just his little brother? Ah – and he was wearing this ring, too, I assume. Odd how that works out.”

“You're the one who killed most of that clan,” Kisame says, testing the idea. It fits wrongly.

“Yep.”

The man could have come from the Bloody Mist with that attitude. Even Itachi couldn't sound so blasé about the unprovoked slaughter of several hundred of his own countrymen.

“Itachi-san took you down in less than a second.” Which isn't very fair to mention when Itachi had to use Tsukuyomi to accomplish the feat, but Kisame has little interest in playing nice at the moment. He went to some lengths to ensure he wouldn't leave a body behind – edo tensei is a violation he refuses to undergo – yet here he sits, still.

It's an unfortunate circumstance to get caught up on. There's nothing noteworthy about dying. People do it all the time. You don't see most of them afterwards having the indecency to dwell on it.

More importantly: if any of this is real, and if Kakashi's being truthful, then he's confirming Kisame's long-held suspicion that Itachi did not kill his entirely family one night on a whim. It could have happened that way, of course. It's nearly a regular occurrence in Kiri (speaking from personal history), but Itachi never struck him as the type. Too selective about his violence to kill for the sake of testing if he could, and too reasonable to commit to such a drastic course of action without mulling over the consequences first.

Kakashi frowns. “He – ? Ah, Mangekyo Sharingan?” As if the Itachi who Kakashi knows doesn't carry that form of the bloodline limit, and for the first time the thought intrudes, for Kisame, of Itachi as he might be if he yet had a home. With neither Kisame's input nor consent, his imagination softens the furrowed stress lines on Itachi's face, softens the exhaustion that shadowed every expression, softens the long and murky years that led Itachi, one day, to sit on a pier in lazy summer warmth to watch the sunlight fracturing across the water and wait for the missing-nin he'd have to put up with for the remainder of his years.

So he's alive, then. Or could be.

Of the two of them, he was the one with the hobby of sitting around at tea and snack shops. It grew on Kisame, too, but Kisame wouldn't have known he enjoyed it if Itachi hadn't introduced him. Did Kakashi do that here? Is it such a commonplace habit?

With a half-hearted shrug, Kakashi continues, “I probably deserved it. Well, he wasn't at home when I killed his family. I wouldn't have put a teammate through that. So if he has that form of the bloodline limit now then I'd be – wait, did he ever tell you how it's activated?”

“Yes.”

“Oh. Good.” Kakashi tilts his head back, eye distantly following a lone cloud near the horizon. “Just the little brother.” A second passes, and then he exhales and lets his gaze drift back down. He raises an eyebrow. “Well? Konoha? Any interest?”

Kisame grimaces. “With you?”

Although, as much as he would prefer not to examine that nuance yet, his distaste isn't entirely warranted. The person across from him is not Hatake Kakashi as Kisame is familiar with. He's interacted with both versions for about the same amount of time now, and, despite some outward similarities in temperament, he doesn't understand this one in any capacity. A loyal Village ninja makes sense as a concept, but, when it comes to this missing-nin who's apparently been familiar with a different him for years, he doesn't know where to even begin to guess at motives.

Said missing-nin takes the antipathy in stride and answers, “Doesn't have to be, even if I really do recommend it. I understand why you don't – I think I understand why you don't trust me. It seems more personal than I would have expected, but ignoring that.” He pauses, offering Kisame a chance to fill in a reason, though he doesn't give any indication of surprise or disappointment when Kisame doesn't take it.

(In truth, it's not particularly personal. Kakashi did kill Zabuza, and for that Kisame would shred him, but that's an average response anyone might have to the murderer of a mildly annoying former coworker. Kisame is merely indisposed towards Konoha as a whole currently, with Kakashi wrapped in as collateral damage.

It'll pass. These things do. He can never hold on to anger for very long, even on the rare occasion when he tries to.)

“If it helps,” Kakashi adds, “this isn't altruistic. I get a much better shot at figuring out what happened to you if we stick together. I'm sure you're perfectly nice” – which shocks a bark of genuine laughter out of Kisame, and Kakashi's eye crinkles in an overemphasized smile – “but you're not who's supposed to be here. If there's a way to reverse this – ”

“What if there isn't?” Kisame cuts across. He's smiling slightly too, with more teeth.

“...Then I guess we live with it. Unless you turn out to have other plans.”

“You're taking this well.”

“I'm not, actually,” Kakashi says placidly. “But that doesn't matter. You're still some version of yourself, so I'm not ever going to fight you with intent to kill. I feel like that's important to get out of the way.”

Kisame tries very hard to imagine any way at all to respond and draws nothing but blanks.

Kakashi, meanwhile, suddenly straightens in his seat with an incredulous huff. “So Itachi didn't ever say anything similar – ? No, he wouldn't have. He was still loyal to Konoha, wasn't he. Even after that. Even after all of that. Just the little brother, and he still – ” He laughs under his breath with what sounds like real humor. It might be closer to a cackle, actually.

“He was what,” says Kisame. Then, as a number of formerly disparate observations and intuitions from over the years suddenly crash together at once: “It was ordered.”

Kakashi's still laughing, nearly silent now even while he shudders with the force of it. Kisame shoves his chair back and stands, and Kakashi drags himself together enough to manage, “He won't talk to you.”

“But he'll speak to you.” Kisame isn't sure what to call his own tone any more than he knows what name to give to the emotion curdling under his ribs. “Won't he?” Itachi knew Kakashi, he remembers, and here... and here, Kakashi took over an execution order that was meant for Itachi to carry out. Itachi has to owe him for that.

“I can't promise you anything.”

“Try,” says Kisame with forced steadiness, teeth still showing, “if you can. I don't need anything to work, only to – have an attempt made.” Is he losing his words? Ah, that's just embarrassing. It must have been decades since it happened last. Whatever it is that's doing its best to control him, he shoves it back into the cage where it belongs and almost immediately feels lighter.

“I'll take that back. I can promise you one thing,” Kakashi murmurs. He looks rather far up to meet Kisame's eyes. “And what do you want me to ask him, if he agrees to meet?”

A handful of absurd questions jostle to make themselves known, but Kisame stamps them out without difficulty or fanfare. Is he happier here? Gods above. Even if he wanted to find out, he wouldn't want it relayed through a stranger. “I'll come up with something,” he decides instead. “It isn't the shortest trip from Earth Country.”

Kakashi blinks. “And I guess we're... not in any especial rush?”

“Is there a reason to be?” Kisame wouldn't object to getting there quickly, but it doesn't sound like Itachi is likely to wander off any time soon. Between the two Konoha-nin (former and present), the more immediately pressing concern is Kakashi, who Kisame still doesn't have enough context for to read well. It doesn't help that almost none of Kakashi's reactions throughout this entire interaction have been standard. There's something off about him, even beyond the typical levels of eccentricity in shinobi who've survived for too long.

Kakashi's eye narrows faintly. “It's more obvious when you do that, somehow.”

The cage trick, he means. Kisame should probably start getting used to assuming that Kakashi knows considerably more about him than Kisame has any memory of telling him. Grating as it is, trying to lie to himself about the present state of reality won't help him any. “The point isn't to be subtle as long as it's effective.”

“It is effective,” Kakashi says, parceling out the syllables gingerly. In a mutter: “I genuinely wasn't expecting anything like this to happen.” He sighs and gets to his feet. “I know you said you're not in a rush, but I can't see a reason not to get there quickly, either. Up to you. I can follow the pace you set.”

Slower, then. Kisame could use a little extra time to verify if any of what Kakashi has said has been true.

Afterword

Please drop by the Archive and comment to let the creator know if you enjoyed their work!