Preface

Dreams
Posted originally on the fanfiction.lol at https://fanfiction.lol/works/1310.

Rating:
Mature
Archive Warning:
No Archive Warnings Apply
Category:
Hetero (F/M)
Fandom:
Supernatural (TV 2005)
Relationships:
John Winchester/Mary Winchester, Sam Winchester/Jessica Lee Moore, Dean Winchester/Original Female Character
Characters:
Dean Winchester, Sam Winchester, John Winchester, Mary Sandra Winchester, Original Female Characters
Additional Tags:
Dreams, Fantasy
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of Coloured Lights
Stats:
Published: 2026-11-05 Words: 27,954 Chapters: 10/10

Dreams

Summary

John Winchester is thrown into a very detailed dream, where he sees what life could have been like had his wife Mary never died. He and Mary are happy. His youngest son Sam is thriving at school and dating Jessica. His oldest son Dean has the home and family John's always known he deserved.

Part 1 in the Coloured Lights series

Chapter 1: A Dream

Show: Supernatural
Rating: M
Setting: Right after the car crash at the end of season 1 episode 22 “Devil’s Trap” and Inspired season 2 episode 20 “What Is and What Should Never Be” – then AU from there.
Characters: John, Dean, Sam, Mary, Jessica and OFCs
Pairings: John/Mary, Sam/Jesscia and Dean/OFC
Series: First story in the reworked Coloured Lights series
Disclaimer: I own nothing and no copyright is intended.
Author’s Notes: This is a remake of a story/series I started 15 years ago. I am re-doing it because I have new ideas of where I want the story and characters to go. For more info please see my bio on my profile.


Chapter One - A DREAM

The first thing John Winchester was aware of, as his eyes moved beneath his closed eyelids and his mind slowly drifted back into consciousness, was that there was no pain. John knew that this could not be normal. The last thing he remembered was the pain in his leg where his youngest son, Sam, had shot him in order to expel the demon from his body, and the sound of metal scraping against metal and glass shattering as the Impala was hit by something. After that, it was a blur, and while it was possible that he was now in a hospital somewhere, John knew that even with painkillers, there should be at least some lingering pain. But there was none.

The second thing John noticed was how comfortable he felt. He had been in a hospital bed on more than one occasion in his life, and he knew from experience that hospital beds tended to be firmer and less comfortable than wherever he was currently lying.

When he finally opened his eyes, he wasn’t greeted by the cold, clinical ceiling of a hospital room, but by the cream-colored ceiling of a room that felt familiar and yet distant. He turned his head to his left and took in his surroundings—the bedside table, the chest of drawers against the wall, the trees outside the window as the sun rose in the distance. It was all so familiar.

“It can’t be,” John whispered, his voice catching in his throat.

He slowly sat up and took several deep breaths.

“John?” a tired voice came from his right.

John closed his eyes. He hadn’t heard that voice in twenty-two years. He had dreamed of it almost every night since, and it had never sounded this clear. Hope began to rise as he slowly turned his head toward the voice and opened his eyes.

There, lying in the bed beside him, her blonde hair fanned out across her pillow and her hands tucked beneath her chin, was the love of his life. His wife. The mother of his boys… Mary.

John’s breath caught as he took her in. She still looked as beautiful as he remembered, though a little older now—fine lines at the corners of her eyes, her hair slightly shorter than it had been.

“Mary…” John breathed, reaching out to cup her cheek.

Mary smiled sleepily, her eyes half-lidded as she fought to wake fully.

“You’re awake? What’s wrong?” she asked.

“I think I’m dreaming,” John whispered. His hand moved from her cheek to the blonde curls at the back of her neck, his fingers stroking gently. Mary hummed softly in response. “I’m dreaming.” He repeated under his breath.

It wasn’t the first time he had dreamed of Mary. Of course not. But those dreams had never felt this vivid… this real.

Mary’s lips curved into a small smile as she sat up slightly and leaned in. Her lips brushed his, and something tight twisted in John’s chest—he had missed her kisses more than he could ever put into words. The hand on her neck moved down to rest between her shoulder blades.

Before he could deepen the kiss, Mary pulled back and glanced toward the window and the dawn sky beyond. Then she turned back to him, her smile a little wider.

“It does feel like a dream, doesn’t it?” she said. “Do you want to get up now, or…?”


He shook his head ever so slightly, “No”, he whispered.


He wanted to be closer to her – Needed it. He missed her so much that it ached, even after all these years. The hand on her back pressed more firmly, pulling her towards him while his other hand came up to rest on the side of her neck under her jaw. His thumb glided back and forth across her cheek tenderly. Almost timidly.


Pushing past the knowledge that this was all still just a dream that could end at any moment, John leaned in until his lips were on hers once more. Her lips were soft and warm against his own, and when she sighed her approval, he felt it vibrate from her lips to his. As she parted her lips just slightly to allow him to slip his tongue against hers, he began to lie back down, pulling her with him until both their heads had hit his pillow. Mary went willingly, one of her arms came up to drape loosely around his shoulder, while the other came to rest on his lower ribs.


Their kisses got deeper, more desperate.


After several moments, they pulled apart when the need to breathe became slightly more important than the need to keep kissing. John closed his eyes and pressed his forehead against hers. Taking in a deep, shaky breath as he tried to calm himself and not let his emotions take over so he wouldn’t cry. The feeling of her skin against his, her scent all around him, the taste of her, it was all so overwhelming.

“Not that I’m complaining,” Mary said, opening her eyes with a soft smile, “but you seem more affectionate this morning than usual.”

“God, I missed you,” he said honestly.

“What?” Mary chuckled. “In the five hours you were asleep?”

John couldn’t help but smile at her. He had missed her laugh so much.

“Yeah,” he said quietly.

He tightened his grip on her and pulled her closer, kissing her again. Mary welcomed it, pressing into him, and John let himself get lost in her.


As they kissed and as his hands roamed over her as if rediscovering something sacred, the realisation that this was just a dream lingered at the back of his mind. But in this moment—holding the woman he loved more than anything in the world—he decided that if it was a dream, it was one he was more than willing to stay in for as long as it lasted.


To be continued…
Next chapter: A New Reality

Chapter 2: A New Reality

Chapter Two – A NEW REALITY

Sometime after waking up, seeing his wife in his bed, and giving in to the desire to be with her in a way he had dreamt about for so many years, John now lay in bed with Mary curled at his side. Her cheek rested against his chest, his heartbeat strong in her ear. One arm wrapped around her hips while the other stroked the arm she had draped across his stomach.

He looked down at the top of her head. She could not be more perfect. Leaning down, he gently pressed his lips against the top of her hair, the soft strands tickling his skin.  

“I love you,” he said softly against her head. “So much.”

Mary turned her face further into his chest, and he felt her lips curl into a smile.  

“I love you too, John”, she murmured.

John’s arms tightened around her, almost squeezing her. The knowledge that he could wake up from this dream at any moment filled him with dread and only made him want to hold on to her longer, enjoy the feeling of her in his arms as long as possible.  

It was then that this perfect moment was interrupted by the shrill beeping of the alarm clock. John groaned and turned his head towards the dreaded machine that had decided to interrupt them. The old-fashioned radio alarm clock sat on the dresser beside his side of the bed, its red neon numbers displaying 6:45 a.m.

With the hand he was using to stroke Mary’s arm, he reached out and slapped at the top of the alarm until the beeping stopped.

He paused.

Something didn’t feel right.

Usually, when there was a loud sound in his dreams, it was because there was a similar noise in reality, and it would wake him up. But this time he remained in the dream.

Turning back, expecting to settle into the position they had been in before the alarm went off, he found Mary already moving away from him as she slipped out of bed.

“No, let's – can we stay here?” John said, trying not to sound as desperate as he felt. “Just for a little bit?”

Mary was sitting on the edge of the bed now. She turned her head slightly to look at him over her shoulder.

“As tempting as that is, you have work this morning,” she told him with a smile. “And I have things to get done before Sam and Jessica come over tonight for dinner.”

Then she planted her feet on the floor and stood.

John slowly sat up and watched her walk into their ensuite bathroom.

‘Sam and Jessica, ’ John repeated the names in his mind.

Of all the times he had dreamt of being here - back in his house, in his bed with his wife - it was usually set in the months before her passing, when Sam and Dean were little. But if Sam knew Jessica, it meant he was now dreaming of a present-day scenario in which Mary was still alive.

As the sunlight streaming through the window brightened the room, John took a better look around. There were photos around the room, on the dressers, and hung on the wall. Some of him and Mary, some baby photos he couldn’t quite place and wasn’t sure if they were of Dean or Sam.

Then he saw one that confirmed his suspicions.

A photo on Mary’s nightstand showing the four of them – himself, Mary, Dean and Sam. Sam wore graduation robes. It must have been taken at his high school graduation.

John scrambled across the bed to grab the frame. Holding it in one hand, he tried not to tremble.

They all looked so happy. Huge smiles stretched across every face.

This single photograph showed everything John had wanted for his family but could no longer have after losing Mary.

A normal life.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

After joining Mary in the shower to be close to her again - even if this was a dream, John wasn’t going to miss any opportunity to be with his wife after more than twenty years without her – he now found himself sitting at the small round kitchen table across from her as they ate breakfast.

On the way downstairs, he took in a few details of the house: furniture that wasn’t quite how he remembered it and photos of the boys through their childhood. But these things barely registered. His attention remained fixed on Mary as she walked ahead of him.

When they had entered the kitchen, Mary handed him the newspaper and made him a coffee. John accepted both gratefully but couldn’t focus on the paper. Instead, he kept his eyes on her as she busied herself making omelettes.

They didn’t say much, but that was okay.

The silence allowed John to simply admire how beautiful she was.

Over the last twenty-two years, he had tried to hold on to the image of Mary as perfectly as possible. Yet even with photographs, he sometimes felt his memory wasn’t as sharp as it used to be. Now, with her sitting right in front of him, he wanted to commit every detail of her to memory.

“Mary?” he began slowly. “Was there ever… a fire here?”

Mary, who had been about to take a bite of her omelette, paused with her fork halfway to her mouth. She gave him a quizzical look before frowning.

“A fire?” she asked. “What do you mean?”

John let out a sigh of relief.

“Nothing. I just… I had a weird dream last night, I guess. That’s all”

Mary set her fork down and reached across the table, placing her hand gently over his. Concern filled her eyes.

“Are you sure you’re ok?” she asked him.

John looked at her and nodded. Turning his hand over, he laced his fingers through hers.

“Yeah. I’m good”

And he smiled, because if there had never been a fire, if Mary had never died, if his boys had grown up and lived good lives, then he really was good.

Mary nodded before withdrawing her hand and returning to her breakfast.

John then remembered something she’d said before getting out of bed.

“So, um…” He cleared his throat. “What time is Sammy coming down from school?”

He didn’t mention Stanford specifically, just in case it wasn’t where Sam had ended up in this… whatever reality this dream seemed to be.

Mary swallowed her bite and picked up her coffee.

“Oh, sometime after five tonight.” She took a quick sip. “I’ll head out to get groceries for dinner after I tidy up around here.”

John nodded as he processed this information.

Sam was coming home with Jessica.

And the four of them were going to have dinner together.

“And Dean?” John asked, trying to sound casual rather than like someone who genuinely had no idea where Dean was or whether he was coming at all.

Mary finished the last of her coffee and stood.

“I’m not sure. He’ll either come over shortly after you two finish at the garage, or he’ll show up around the same time as Sam and Jessica.” She shrugged. “He didn’t say.”

“Right”, John said with a nod.

Mary carried her mug to the sink and rinsed it out.

John picked up his coffee and considered this new piece of information.

Not only was Dean joining them for dinner, but apparently, he worked with him at the garage.

John couldn’t help smiling.

He knew his love for cars and their mechanics had been passed down to Dean. Even with the life they’d led as hunters, Dean had learned the skills John possessed as a mechanic.

But having Dean work alongside him, fixing cars, had always been a secret wish. If only their lives had turned out differently from the harsh reality waiting for him when he woke up from this amazing dream.

Mary returned to the table to collect their empty plates. She noticed the smile on John’s face and the distant look in his eyes.

“What are you smiling about?” She asked, her own lips beginning to curve upward.

“Just thinking about how good my life is here”

He stood and walked over to her.

Once he reached her, he wrapped his arms around her waist and slowly pulled her closer.

“We’re happy, right?”

“Oh, I would say we are,” Mary agreed, her hands settling flat against his chest. A flirtatious smile appeared on her face.

John missed that smile.

He wanted to lean in and kiss that smile, but there was one more thing he needed to know.

“And our boys?” he asked. “They’re happy too?”

Again, he tried to sound casual, as though he were simply confirming the obvious rather than seeking reassurance.

Mary laughed and slid her arms around his neck.

“They are definitely happy.” She told him.

“Good.”

And with that, John leaned forward and kissed the still smiling lips of his wife.

Whatever this dream was, or wherever it was going, John didn’t care.

Right now, all that mattered was that he had his wife in his arms and that they and their sons were living good, happy lives.

He only hoped he didn’t wake up before he got to see both Dean and Sam.  

To be continued…
Next chapter: Mysterious Strangers

Chapter 3: Mysterious Strangers

Chapter Three ~ MYSTERIOUS STRANGERS


John had stood there in the kitchen, kissing Mary for what felt like too long and yet not long enough. The kiss was broken when Mary pulled back and sighed. She glanced over John's shoulder at the clock on the wall.

"You should get ready for work," she told him. "It's already eight o'clock."

"I could call in sick," he suggested seriously.

Mary laughed and stepped out of his arms.

"I have too much to do today, and if you stay and we end up doing what we were just doing," she said, waving an arm between the two of them, "then I'll get nothing done."

"And that's bad?" John asked, a small smile gracing his lips.

Mary shook her head but couldn't help the smile spreading across her own face.

"Go to work, John." She turned around and walked over to the sink. "Dean's probably on his way there now anyway."

John nodded. As much as he wanted to stay and be with his wife, he also had to admit that he was very curious to see Dean. If Sam were with Jessica, then John could guess that his sons were around the same ages they were in reality. And John wanted to know what sort of men they had turned into when given the opportunity to have normal lives.

He was also curious to see Dean working at the same garage he owned. He remembered that, back when Sam was about four months old, and Mary had taken him out to a mommy-and-me play session, John had been left alone with Dean. He had ended up taking Dean to work with him. Dean had stood beside the car that John had been working on and eagerly handed him tools when asked. He had been so fascinated by what his father was doing.

The memory made John smile, though his eyes also held the sadness he felt knowing that this was all still a dream. A very detailed, lifelike dream, but still a dream.

As he left the kitchen, he tried to remember his old routine for leaving for work. In reality, he hadn't worked at the garage in over twenty years. He decided he wasn't planning on doing much work anyway, seeing as this was a dream, but he did want to go and see Dean, so he decided to head straight to the garage as he was.

The curtains at the front of the house were open, and John could see a truck, similar to his real one, parked in the driveway. He guessed it was his truck and wondered if that meant Dean still had the Impala.

There was a small table against the wall beside the front door. On top sat a glass bowl filled with keys. John assumed one set was for his truck and the other for Mary's car.

John opened his mouth and was about to say goodbye to Mary when the loud chime of the doorbell rang through the house.

"John? Can you get that?" Mary called from the kitchen.

John made his way over to the door, stopping to grab what he assumed were his keys from the bowl. The other set had a butterfly keychain attached, so they were most likely Mary's. He held his keys in one hand and opened the door with the other.

At this time of the morning, the person on the other side was most likely a door-to-door salesman, someone wanting to spread their faith, or perhaps a neighbour with a question. All of whom John was prepared to get rid of quickly, so he could get to Dean faster.

Standing on the front porch was a young woman who looked to be in her early twenties. She had long blonde and light-brown hair that fell in loose curls around her face. Her eyes were light blue, and she didn't appear to be wearing any makeup. She wore a simple, floral-patterned, knee-length summer dress with short sleeves.

John noticed all of these things quickly. It was the baby she was holding on her left hip that drew his attention the most.

The baby had short light-brown hair and greenish-hazel eyes that John found slightly familiar. She wore a white shirt and light-blue overalls decorated with flowers. John guessed she was around six to nine months old. She was looking at the woman holding her and hadn't paid him any attention yet.

Looking at them, John decided the woman couldn't be selling something or wanting to talk about Jesus, so his best guess was that she was a neighbour. Though he couldn't remember anyone like them from when he had lived here over twenty years ago.

When John had opened the door, the woman's eyes had widened slightly, almost as if she were surprised to see him.

"Hi," he said, looking at her with some confusion.

The woman's mouth opened slightly, but she closed it when they heard Mary's voice drift toward them.

"John?" Mary called as she walked toward the front door.

John turned to watch Mary make her way toward him. Maybe she could shed some light on who this woman and child were.

Mary had her head down and was using a dish towel to dry her hands after washing the breakfast dishes.

"Who was at the d—" She looked up and stopped speaking.

The moment Mary saw the woman and child, her whole face broke into a huge grin. Her teeth showed, her eyes sparkled, and her face lit up with excitement.

"Oh!" she gasped, moving quickly toward the door and tossing the dish towel aside.

John stood back in shock, amazement, and curiosity. He watched his wife suddenly become so happy and move so quickly that part of his mind wasn't entirely sure what he was seeing.

Mary reached them and, with the smile still on her face, held her arms out toward the baby.

"Come here, my beautiful girl," Mary cooed as she scooped the baby into her arms, pulling the infant against her chest.

The baby smiled, obviously comfortable with her.

"Hi, how are you?" Mary asked, kissing her temple.

John couldn't help but stare as he watched this strange interaction between his wife and the baby. Who was this child, and why did the sight of her bring Mary so much joy?

While Mary continued to coo at the baby and John continued to watch them, they both seemed to have forgotten about the young woman still standing in the doorway.

The woman sighed dramatically before repeating, "I'm not invisible. I'm not invisible. I'm not invisible."

It sounded like a mantra to herself, but it was loud enough to get the others' attention.

Mary, who had been busy talking to and bouncing the happy baby, paused and looked over at the woman. A slight look of guilt crossed her face.

"Oh, I'm sorry, Bridget," Mary said with a smile. "Come in."

Bridget walked inside. Mary shifted the baby to her left hip and then leaned over to hug Bridget with her free arm.

"How are you?" Mary asked as she pulled back. "What brings you two over so early?"

Mary led the way into the living room, and Bridget followed, walking past John.
John forgot all about wanting to leave for work and instead closed the front door and silently followed them.

He just had to know more about who these people were and why they made his wife so happy.

"Well, I was kind of hoping you might be able to do me a favour?" Bridget asked, biting her lower lip.

"What do you need?" Mary asked with a nod.

"I was meant to have the day off today," Bridget began, sighing because that had obviously changed. "But there's been some sort of issue with tomorrow's launch, and they need me to come in and rearrange a few of the photos."

Bridget paused and looked at Mary with a sweet, knowing smile.

"So I was wondering if maybe..." She reached out and lightly tickled the baby, making her giggle. "...Aislin could hang out here with you today?"

John watched as Mary's face broke into another huge grin. It was clear that the idea of this child spending the day at their house was a very pleasant one.

"Of course," Mary beamed.

"Are you sure?" Bridget asked. "I know you had plans before Sammy comes and—"

"- Don't be silly, Bridget," Mary said, cutting her off.

John, who had been standing back and watching the exchange in silence, was a little thrown when Bridget mentioned Sam's name. The fact that she knew about their plans seemed strange to him as well.

And he was not prepared for what came out of his wife's mouth next.

Mary turned back to smile at the baby in her arms and said, "You know I love looking after my granddaughter."

John's jaw nearly dropped.

Did she just say… granddaughter?

That baby, that little girl, was his grandchild.

He almost couldn't fathom it.

Why had his mind created a grandchild who seemed so real?

His thoughts raced with questions. He looked from Mary to the younger woman, Bridget, and then to the baby, to his granddaughter.

As he looked at her, it suddenly hit him why her eyes had seemed so familiar.

Those eyes.

He had been looking into those same eyes for twenty-six years.

They were Dean's eyes.

This baby—the one currently being cuddled and clearly adored by his wife—had the exact same eyes as his son Dean.

And if she was in fact his granddaughter it meant that this baby was Dean’s daughter.


To be continued…
Next chapter: Dean

Chapter 4: Dean

Chapter Four ~ DEAN


John continued to look at the baby in Mary’s arms, staring at her as he took her in. He watched as her little hands came up and reached out, trying to grab Mary’s blonde hair, which had fallen over her shoulder. Mary took hold of Aislin’s hands, preventing her from grabbing her hair.

John was so sure that this little girl had to be Dean’s daughter, but he wanted to make sure.

He quickly swallowed the lump that had settled in his throat and focused on keeping his voice calm and the disbelief out of it as he asked, “So, where is your dad, Aislin?”

The baby’s name, leaving his lips, felt incredibly strange to John. He smiled and hoped that the two women with him could not tell how nervous he was. Thankfully, they were both so focused on Aislin that neither of them even looked at John when he spoke.

“Dean should be at work already,” Bridget replied, looking at her baby.

John let out a short breath. It was confirmed. This baby—this beautiful, green-eyed, happy little girl—belonged to Dean. John could not believe it. Of all the things he had ever dreamt up in his life, a grandchild was never one of them. He wondered why his mind had created this particular scenario.

“I’m actually surprised you’re not at work yet, John,” Bridget said, finally turning to look at him.

John took his eyes off Aislin and looked at Bridget, the young woman who was apparently with his eldest son. He thought back to when he had first opened the door and to how surprised Bridget had looked. Her surprise must have been from seeing him at home instead of at work.

“I was just heading out,” he told her with a nod.

Bridget didn’t seem to think this was strange, or at least, if she did, she didn’t let on. Instead, she turned back to Mary and baby Aislin.

“Okay, well, if you’re sure you don’t mind—” Bridget started to say.

Once again, Mary cut her off. “You know I never mind.”

“Okay,” Bridget nodded. “I’ll go grab Aislin’s stuff from the car.”

John’s attention had returned to the baby, and he only just registered Bridget turning to leave out of the corner of his eye.

While Bridget was gone, Mary’s attention was fully back on the little girl in her arms. John watched as his wife swayed from side to side while murmuring sweet words to the baby.

John felt a mixture of three things resonate within him. The first, of course, was the shock and surprise of seeing a child who was apparently his grandchild, and all that entailed. The second was awe. There was something so wonderful about watching how happy this baby made his wife. There was no other word for it—Mary was glowing. The third was sadness. Before he had lost her, she had been holding Sam and rocking him in the same way she was now rocking Aislin. The thought brought up so many painful feelings, and John pushed them down.

He knew this dream wouldn’t last, and he didn’t want to focus on what had been when he could be enjoying whatever this better reality was.

Mary turned and looked over at him. She frowned while still gently rocking back and forth. For a moment, John thought maybe he hadn’t been able to keep his emotions and thoughts from showing on his face.

“I’m doing it again, aren’t I?” she asked suddenly.

John opened his mouth to ask what she was referring to, but she kept talking, preventing him from responding.

“I’m hogging her,” Mary stated. She looked down at Aislin before adding, “I think Grandpa wants a cuddle before he joins Daddy at work.”

John stood very still, almost as though he were having an out-of-body experience, and watched as Mary took the few short steps towards him. Then, smiling, Mary pulled Aislin away from her, turned her around, and held her out to John. On autopilot, John put his arms out and took hold of the baby.

He pulled her against him and looked down into her eyes. She looked up at him, blinking a few times. It felt so real having her in his arms.

“Hi,” he murmured, smiling slightly when she reached out and grabbed his nose.

One word came to John’s mind as he both watched and held her in his arms: amazing.

Mary watched them with a smile on her face. She was still obviously oblivious to what was actually going on in John’s mind.

It was then that Bridget came back in, a black diaper bag over one shoulder and a small purple backpack slung over the other.

“Here,” Bridget said, handing the two bags to Mary. “Thanks, Mary. I really appreciate it. I’ll call you when I’m done. I should be done in a few hours, or maybe longer.”

“Don’t feel like you have to rush,” Mary said, placing the two bags on the floor and smiling. “We’ll be fine.”

Bridget looked over at Aislin in John’s arms and smiled as she visibly relaxed.

“Right,” she nodded. “Well, if you change your mind, just give Dean a call.”

Bridget then walked over to John. She leant down, placed a gentle kiss on top of Aislin’s hair, and smiled.

“Bye, sweetheart,” she said warmly. “You be good for Grandma, okay? I love you.”

Bridget kissed Aislin one more time. The baby smiled in John’s arms. Then Bridget stood up, nodded at John, and turned to Mary.

“Okay, I’ll see you later,” she told them. “And thanks again, Mary.”

“Bye, Bridget,” said Mary. “Good luck.”

Bridget smiled before walking out the door.

John barely registered her leaving. He was too focused on the baby in his arms. He almost forgot what he had originally set out to do when he had left Mary in the kitchen.

“Okay, my darling girl,” Mary began as she took the baby from John and cuddled her again. “Let’s say bye to Grandpa so he can go to work and fix some cars with your daddy.”

As thoughts of seeing Dean at the garage filled his head again, John’s lips curled into a soft smile.


“Right,” he agreed.

He moved closer until he was standing right in front of Mary. Then he placed one hand against Aislin’s back before leaning down to kiss the top of her head. Her hair was incredibly soft. He couldn’t help breathing in her scent. When he was done, he straightened up and captured Mary’s lips with his own, giving her a deep but brief kiss before pulling back. His hand remained on the baby for a moment.

A large part of him wanted to stay here with Mary and his granddaughter. But now that he had a granddaughter, he was curious to see what other new developments this dreamt-up reality had in store for him. So he wanted to go and see what kind of man Dean had become.

“I love you,” he told Mary as he finally stepped back.

Mary grinned. “I love you too.”

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

After leaving Mary and baby Aislin, John drove his truck to the garage. He was mostly going on instinct now, remembering how he used to drive to work before the demon had taken away his love.

On the way, he couldn’t stop thinking about the baby. Aislin. It was such a unique name, and John wondered why it had been chosen for her.

As he pulled up to the garage, the first thing John noticed was the Impala parked right out front. He parked next to it, and when he climbed out of his truck, he quickly looked it over. It looked almost exactly as it did in real life, except when he peered through the back window, he could see a car seat as well as several toys lying across the back seat and floor.

He couldn’t help but smile. It was so strange to see the car like this. It hadn’t had a baby seat in it since Sam had grown out of one. Even then, it had barely had any toys.

The knowledge that Dean was a father and had created such a beautiful daughter sent a sudden surge of pride through John.

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

When he walked into the garage, John could hear Black Sabbath playing on a distant radio. It didn’t take him long to find Dean. His son was standing in front of a red Toyota Camry with the bonnet up, leaning over the engine as he worked.

Dean must have heard John approach, or maybe he simply sensed he was no longer alone, because he stopped what he was doing and stepped back so he could stand up straight without hitting his head on the bonnet.

“So, when I take over here and become the boss,” Dean began as he turned to face his father, “can I turn up whenever I want as well?”

The smirk that crossed his face told John he was teasing.

John smiled back. He couldn’t remember the last time he had heard Dean joke with him like that. Usually, Dean was too busy trying his best to follow John’s orders.

At first, John didn’t know how to respond. Then he decided he wanted to see how Dean would react if the subject of his daughter was brought up.

“We had some unexpected visitors this morning,” John began, unable to stop his lips from curling into a knowing smile. “I was a bit distracted.”

Dean’s smirk turned into what John would call a grin of pride.

“Yeah. Bridge called after she got the call from the gallery.”

John nodded.

“She was worried Mom might have been too busy,” Dean continued.

“I don’t think your mother minded,” John replied.

Dean laughed, then turned back to the engine. “I keep tellin’ Bridge that. We could sit Aislin on the front step, ring the bell, and run. Mom would open the door, take Aislin inside, and not even question it.”

John chuckled as he remembered seeing Mary’s joy when she had realised who had been at the door and how she had practically run to get to the baby.

“You’re probably right,” John said with a nod. “You did make a beautiful baby.”

Dean looked back at John with a warm, proud smile on his face, “I know.”

There was something about the way Dean’s eyes lit up, and the soft smile that spread across his face when he agreed that his baby was beautiful, that made John want to smile and tear up a little. This was the life Dean should have had instead of one filled with hunting and revenge.

Needing to distract himself from the harsh reality that awaited him, John turned and pointed at the engine in front of them.

Changing the subject, he asked, “So, what else have you got to do here?”

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

John and Dean spent the next several hours at the garage working on cars. They managed to finish the Camry, and Dean called the owner to arrange for them to come and collect it. They changed the tyres on another car, and a new customer dropped off her vehicle because it had been making a funny noise.

They spent most of their time talking about the work at hand, barely having time to discuss anything else. While John wanted to ask Dean more questions about his life and his daughter, he also didn’t want to spoil the easy rhythm they had found. Instead, he decided to follow Dean’s lead so their conversations wouldn’t feel forced or awkward.

At one point, John went into his office and took some time to look over a few things. He discovered that, in this dream, he now owned the garage outright. Aside from Dean, he also had several other staff members, but none of them were working today, so it was just the two of them.

The office had a large window overlooking the main workshop, so while John was inside, he could still watch Dean work.

Dean knew exactly what he was doing when it came to working on cars, almost as though it were second nature. As John watched him, he wondered if this really was the life Dean had been meant to lead, had it not been for the tragedy their family had endured.


John had been enjoying spending this time with Dean—this time where he didn’t have to worry about hunting, risking their lives, or revenge—so much that he hadn’t even been paying attention to the time.

Dean was checking the oil in a new car that had been brought in when he glanced over at the clock on the wall.

“Hey, Dad,” he called. He grabbed the dirty rag hanging out of the back pocket of his jeans and started wiping his grimy hands. “It’s after one. Think we can call it a day?”

John had been filling out some forms on a clipboard. He set it down and walked over to Dean.

“We do have more work to do,” he said, though really he didn’t want to spend any more time here. Yes, he had enjoyed working alongside Dean, but after so many hours, he was ready to get back to Mary and spend time with his family in a different setting.

“Hmm.” Dean thought for a moment, possibly trying to come up with a good reason to get them out of work early. Then he slowly grinned and said, “If we leave now, you can spend more time with Aislin.”

The way Dean had said it—as though that idea alone should be enough to tempt his dad—made John chuckle.

“Think that’ll work?” John asked, referring to Dean’s suggestion.

Dean shrugged one shoulder. “Usually does.”

John shook his head, trying to suppress the smile spreading across his face. From that comment, it was clear that it wasn’t just Mary who adored the little girl. He must be just as devoted to her.

“Yeah, okay,” John finally agreed. “All this stuff can wait till tomorrow. Let’s go.”

A huge grin spread across Dean’s face, and he tossed the dirty rag off to one side.

It was then that John realised he really did want to see that little baby again—more than he had expected.


To be continued…
Next chapter: His Home

Chapter 5: His Home

Chapter Five ~ HIS HOME

After throwing the dirty rag away, Dean pulled his cell phone from the front pocket of his jeans.

"I'll call Mom and let her know I'll come and get Aislin," Dean said as he scrolled through his contacts to find Mary's number.

John watched as Dean held the phone to his ear. He heard the faint ringing, followed by the distant sound of his wife's voice.

"Hello, Dean," Mary greeted her son.

"Hi, Mom. How's your day been?" Dean asked, a knowing smile spreading across his face.

"Wonderful," Mary replied. "We've had a great morning. Haven't we, sweetheart?"

Standing close to Dean, John could just make out the baby's happy babbling in the background. There was no missing the way Dean's eyes lit up when he heard his daughter.

"Well," Dean began after listening to Aislin for a moment, "we're done for the day, so I can come grab Aislin and—"

"Oh, could you pick up some groceries for me first?" Mary interrupted. "I was going to get a few things for dinner tonight, but my plans changed..."

She trailed off as the sound of giggling came over the line. It was clear to both John and Dean that Mary had done something to make Aislin laugh—probably tickled her.

"You could still go to the shops after I pick up Aislin," Dean pointed out, an amused smirk crossing his face. "Or you could've said you were busy, and Bridge could've brought Aislin over here."

"Don't be ridiculous, Dean," Mary replied, implying those simply weren't options.

John chuckled. It was beyond clear that this little girl had captured his wife's heart completely.

"Pick up a few things for me, and by the time you get here you may as well stay for dinner," Mary suggested. "It seems silly for you to go home and then come back again."

"Yeah," Dean said, drawing the word out. "And that would have nothing to do with you wanting to spend more time with Aislin?"

John heard Mary laugh before replying, "Oh, it absolutely does."

She didn't even try to deny it.

"Alright, Mom. What do you need?" Dean asked.

"Is your dad going with you?" Mary asked.

Dean knew John could hear Mary's side of the conversation, so he simply looked over at him and waited for an answer to the question he didn't need to repeat.

John considered it for a moment. He could head straight home, or he could spend a little more one-on-one time with Dean. He decided on the latter and nodded.

"Yeah, Dad's coming."

"Okay, he should know what I need," Mary said. "Or I can text you a list?"

John's eyes widened for a second. This was a dream, and he was new to this reality. He had no idea what Mary needed from the grocery store.

Dean must have noticed the brief look of panic on John's face because he chuckled.

"You'd better send a list."

Mary laughed softly. "Okay. We'll see you when you get here."

"Bye, Mom," Dean said. Then, raising his voice, he added, "Bye, baby!"

Dean lowered the phone, flipped it closed, and slipped it back into his pocket before turning his attention to his father.

"Alright, well, I wanna grab a shower before we go out," Dean said. "You wanna come back to mine for a bit, or I can come back here?"

"I'll come with you. It'll be easier," John decided.

Dean nodded in agreement, and the two of them walked out of the garage together.

John was curious to see the place Dean now called home. Dean hadn't had a home of his own since they'd left Kansas. Instead, he'd grown up moving from one motel to the next. The closest Dean and Sam had come to having a real home was during the brief periods they'd stayed with friends of John's, like Pastor Jim.

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

They drove to Dean's house in the Impala, John mentioning that he'd make arrangements to come back and pick up his truck another time.

In truth, John was sure he was bound to wake up at any moment—though he hoped he'd stay asleep long enough to see Sam and discover what kind of man he'd become in this reality. There was no point worrying about when or how he'd retrieve his truck.

Once they were on the road, Dean slid a cassette into the stereo, and Led Zeppelin filled the car, leaving little reason to talk. That was fine. John had spent countless hours driving with Dean over the years, and they rarely spoke much anyway. It was the one part of this dream that felt most like reality.

Except this silence felt different. It was comfortable instead of tense.

It only took about ten minutes to reach Dean's house. Dean pulled the Impala into the driveway and switched off the engine.

As Dean removed the keys from the ignition, John took in the front of the house.

It was a small, single-storey home with a carport running alongside the driveway. A narrow flower garden lined the front of the house, broken only by the path leading to the front door. It looked like it could use a little work, but John imagined it had been affordable and made a good first home for a young family like Dean, Bridget, and Aislin.

It wasn't much, but if Dean was happy there, then that was all that mattered.

Without a word, Dean climbed out of the Impala and headed for the front door. John followed, hanging back while Dean unlocked it.

"Alright, Dad," Dean said as he led the way inside. "I'm gonna grab a quick shower. You know where everything is if you want anything."


And it was a statement rather than a question.

That statement made John realise that he and Dean must be close in this reality. Close enough that Dean assumed his father knew where everything was and would feel comfortable making himself at home.

The truth was, John had no idea where anything was.

Even so, he simply nodded before watching Dean wander down the short hallway and disappear into what John assumed was his bedroom.

John ventured farther into the house, taking his time to look around and absorb everything. For the most part, it was a typical home—a living room at the front, a hallway leading to the bedrooms and bathroom, and a kitchen just off the living room.

The furniture was exactly what he would have expected: a television, a couch, and a coffee table. What stood out instead were all the things that clearly belonged to Aislin.

There were toys scattered around the room, a baby bouncer, a playmat spread across the floor, and an activity walker tucked neatly into one corner.

This was unmistakably the home of a little girl.

His gaze drifted to the many photographs hanging on the walls and sitting atop cabinets.

Most of them were of Aislin. Some were the same photographs he'd already seen at his own house—photos he'd mistakenly assumed had been of either Dean or Sam. There were also photographs of himself and Mary, as well as pictures of the three of them together.

One photograph in particular caught his attention.

Sam and Jessica.

John picked it up and studied it for a moment. It was the first time he'd seen what Sam looked like in this dream. Sam wore his familiar lopsided grin, though his hair was a little longer than John remembered.

More importantly...

He looked happy.

John couldn't wait to see him that evening. Their relationship had always been strained, and John found himself hoping that, at least in this strange reality his mind had created, things between them were better.

His attention was soon drawn to two larger photographs hanging above the television.

The first showed Dean holding Aislin.

She looked to be about six months old, so the picture must have been fairly recent. Father and daughter were looking at one another, and even in a still photograph, the love on Dean's face was impossible to miss. It was there in his eyes and in the small, contented smile tugging at his lips.

John couldn't wait to see Dean with his daughter in person.

The second photograph was of Dean and Bridget.

It had clearly been taken candidly. Bridget's arm rested loosely around Dean's neck as she leaned up toward him while he bent down slightly to meet her. They were both grinning from ear to ear.

Dean looked...

Happy.

Relaxed.

Content.

A wave of emotion washed over John, and he quietly drew in a deep breath, fighting back the sting in his eyes.

The happiness in those photographs was undeniable.

His thoughts drifted back to the conversation he'd had with Sam not long ago.

"I want Dean to have a home."

Those words had come from the heart. It was something he'd always wanted for his eldest son.

Deep down, John had always known that Dean's willingness to follow orders came, in part, from wanting something that resembled a normal family. Maybe that was why his subconscious had created this world—a world where Dean not only had a home of his own, but a family to fill it.

"Ready to go?"

Dean's voice floated down the hallway.

John took one last look at the photographs before turning around, silently hoping Dean wouldn't notice how deeply they had affected him.

Dean walked into the living room, his hair still damp from his shower. He'd changed into a fresh, clean outfit, replacing the grease- and oil-stained clothes he'd been wearing earlier.

Holding up his phone, he gave it a small wave.

"Mom texted me the shopping list."

He grinned.

"Looks like we're having roast chicken."

John found himself smiling in return.

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Something as ordinary as buying groceries—a simple, everyday domestic task—felt strangely surreal to John Winchester.

Once, it had been a normal part of his life.

After Mary's death, it had become nothing more than another chore to complete as quickly as possible.

There had been little thought given to what they actually needed. If food was running low, John would rush into a store, grab the basics—bread, milk, cereal—and leave again. The quicker he got back on the road, the sooner he could continue hunting the thing that had murdered his wife.

More often than not, they simply ate at diners or cafés.

Once Dean was old enough, grocery shopping had mostly become his responsibility. John would hand him some cash, give him a quick rundown of what they needed—or simply tell him to buy enough food to last however many days John expected to be away on a hunt.

Dean had always done the job quickly.

Efficiently.

Without complaint.

Now, there was no rush.

There was no hunt waiting.

No race to return before John disappeared for days at a time.

It was simply an ordinary afternoon spent buying groceries.

It felt almost... peaceful.

They were nearly finished. Everything on Mary's list was already in the trolley, along with a few extras—custard for Aislin, a six-pack of beer, and a bag of M&M's—when Dean's phone rang.

Dean stopped walking and pulled his phone from his pocket. He flipped it open, glanced at the screen, and grinned.

"It's Bridge." He nodded toward John before answering. "Hey. How'd you go?"

Standing beside him once again, John could just make out Bridget's voice through the phone.

"Pretty sure the place would've completely fallen apart without me," Bridget said with an exaggerated sigh.

"Time to ask for a raise, then," Dean replied.

Bridget laughed.

"Sure."

"Well, we're done for the day," Dean said. "Just grabbing some groceries for Mom since her plans changed."

John noticed the small smirk tugging at the corner of Dean's mouth.

"Don't make fun of me, Dean," Bridget said.

“I’m not” Dean protested.


"I can feel you smirking from here, Dean!"

"Okay, okay, sorry." Dean chuckled. His smirk softened into a warm, genuine smile. "But you do know Mom never minds watching Aislin or changing her plans for her."

"Yes, I know. You're right."

"Getting Mom to take Aislin is the easy part," Dean replied. Then he quickly added, "It's trying to get her back that's the hard part."

John couldn't help laughing at that. He could hear Bridget laughing as well.

After a moment, once she'd stopped laughing, Bridget asked, "So, are you planning on picking Aislin up and coming home for a bit before dinner?"

"Nah." Dean shook his head, even though Bridget couldn't see him. "Figured we may as well stay and wait for Sam."

"Oh."

"Yeah, so I'll meet you at Mom's?" Dean asked before adding, "Or I could come pick you up?"

"That does make more sense," Bridget agreed. "No point in us having two cars at your parents'."

"Cool. Well, Dad and I are pretty much done here, so I'll meet you at home in a few."

"Okay. Bye, Dean."

Dean nodded, a faint affectionate smile on his face.

"Bye, Bridge."

He had just started lowering the phone when Bridget spoke again.

"Oh, and Dean?"

"Yeah?"

"Put the M&M's back," Bridget said. "We already have, like, three bags at home."

John turned his head slightly, letting out a quiet chuckle.

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

John and Dean quickly swung by Dean's house. Bridget was already waiting outside. Dean pulled up along the curb, as Bridget's yellow Volkswagen Beetle was parked in the driveway.

After she climbed into the Impala, the three of them headed back to John and Mary's house.

John remained mostly silent during the drive, choosing instead to observe the easy interaction between Dean and Bridget as they chatted about the problems she'd been having at work.

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

When they arrived, Mary greeted them from the living room. She was sitting on the floor with Aislin, who was perched on a small pink playmat that had clearly been bought especially for her.

"Hi," Mary said with a smile.

"Hey, Mom," Dean replied.

John watched, fascinated, as Aislin immediately turned toward the sound of Dean's voice.

Her entire face lit up.

"Da!"

She squealed happily and threw both arms into the air, making it abundantly clear that she wanted her father.

The smile that spread across Dean's face was probably the biggest John had ever seen in all of his son's twenty-six years.

Dean crossed the room in only a few quick strides before bending down and scooping Aislin into his arms.

"Hi, baby," he laughed, lifting her above his head for a second before bringing her back down again, making her giggle the entire time. "Were you a good girl for Grandma?"

"Of course she was," Mary replied as she climbed to her feet. "We always have the best time together, don't we, Aislin?"

Aislin paid her grandmother no attention. She was far too busy staring at her father.

Dean simply looked back at her, his eyes slowly taking in every inch of her tiny face.

"Thank you again for watching her, Mary," Bridget said.

"Anytime," Mary replied with a smile.

"I'm guessing Grandma wasn't able to get you down for a nap yet?" Dean asked, finally lifting his gaze from Aislin to his mother.

"That was next on our list."

Dean nodded and pulled Aislin a little closer.

The little girl rested her head against her father's shoulder with a contented sigh.

Bridget stepped over and gently kissed the top of Aislin's head.

Dean began swaying slowly from side to side while John wandered over to Mary. Wrapping an arm around her waist, he leaned down and kissed her briefly before looking back at Dean and Aislin.

He watched as Aislin's eyelids slowly began to droop, though they hadn't quite closed.

"Okay," Dean murmured, resting his cheek lightly against the top of her head. "Time for a nap, baby."

John watched in quiet amazement.

He was so used to seeing Dean constantly alert—ready to follow orders, fight, or kill at a moment's notice.

Now, he was holding a sleepy little girl with incredible tenderness, gently rocking her as though nothing else in the world mattered.

"Go put her upstairs," Mary said softly. "The cot's already set up for her."

Dean nodded, his cheek brushing lightly against Aislin's hair. The little girl instinctively snuggled even closer against his chest.

"Have you two had lunch yet?" Mary asked, turning toward John.

Only then did John realise that neither he nor Dean had eaten since breakfast.

"No," he admitted.

Mary nodded. "Alright. I'll whip up a few sandwiches." Turning to Dean, she added, "Come into the kitchen after you've gotten my beautiful granddaughter to sleep."

Dean nodded. He shifted Aislin against his chest so he could support her with one arm. With the other, he silently reached down, took Bridget's hand, and gently led her toward the stairs.

John watched as the young couple made their way upstairs with their daughter—Dean in front, Bridget following close behind, their hands still entwined.

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

After Dean and Bridget disappeared upstairs, John followed Mary into the kitchen.

He put the groceries away while Mary gathered everything she needed to make sandwiches. Once he was finished, he sat at the kitchen table and quietly watched her work.

He noticed she only set out two plates.

John wondered if it was common for him and Dean to skip meals while they were working, because Mary didn't seem to be making anything for herself or Bridget.

As he watched her, he couldn't help noticing how happy she looked. There was a gentle smile on her face as she moved about the kitchen, completely at ease.

"You really love it, don't you?" he asked.

Mary paused halfway through cutting a sandwich and looked over at him.

"Love what?"

John smiled.

"Being a grandmother."

A broad grin spread across Mary's face.

"Of course I do. Aislin's so perfect and adorable. It's hard not to be happy when she's here."

"You love her," John said with a nod.

"Just like you do," Mary replied before returning to the sandwich in front of her.

John fell silent.

Maybe she was right.

He had only just met Aislin. He'd barely spent any time with her.

And yet...

There was something he felt whenever he looked at her. Something impossible to put into words.

It was powerful.

Comforting.

Maybe it was instinct. She was Dean's daughter, after all, and she looked so much like him.

Or maybe he was simply becoming accustomed to this reality, one where he'd already been Aislin's grandfather for months.

Perhaps it was seeing the joy she brought to both Dean and Mary that made it impossible not to love her himself.

Whatever the reason, John found himself hoping that, when he finally woke, he would one day, dream about his granddaughter again.

To be continued...

Next Chapter: The Bet

Chapter 6: The Bet

Chapter Six ~ THE BET

After she was done making sandwiches for him and Dean, Mary had prepped their dinner for that night and placed it into the oven. John had helped her chop some vegetables, but mostly he had simply watched as she went about performing such a basic, everyday task.

He watched because he had missed being able to see her do these everyday things. Things he used to take for granted but now would do anything to have back once he woke from this dream and had to once again face the reality of a life without her.

Dean and Bridget had joined them in the kitchen after putting Aislin down for her afternoon nap. Dean had been carrying one half of a baby monitor set. John wondered if it was from a set that he and Mary had for when Aislin visited, as it was clear that she must come over often, or if Bridget had packed it in the bags she'd left when she dropped Aislin off that morning.

Now the four of them were sitting around the small round table, enjoying some casual conversation. John and Dean were eating lunch while Mary and Bridget each sipped on some iced tea that Mary had made.

"Were you able to sort everything out at the gallery, Bridget?" Mary asked the younger woman.

Bridget nodded. "The first problem was easy," she said. Then, with a roll of her eyes, she added, "Then suddenly there were more and more issues to deal with." She paused to take another sip of her tea before continuing, "It's why it took me all morning to get out of there."

"Again, I say you need to ask for a raise, Bridge," said Dean around a mouthful of sandwich. "Or demand a promotion."

"A promotion would mean I'd have to work more hours—" Bridget began.

"You literally got called in to work for nearly five hours on your day off!" Dean exclaimed, interrupting her. "You're already working more hours."

"I agree with Dean," Mary said. "That place would fall apart without you."

Bridget smiled, a little embarrassed. "Thanks," she murmured. Then, wanting to change the subject, she asked Mary, "So, um, any idea why Sammy insisted on this family get-together all of a sudden?"

John noticed the look Dean sent Bridget, one that clearly said he knew she'd changed the subject on purpose.

"He didn't say, but I have a feeling he wants to tell us something," Mary replied. "He was very eager for all of us to get together."

"Maybe he just wanted to see Aislin," Dean suggested.

"Dean, we saw them two weeks ago," Bridget reminded him.

"What's your point?" Dean asked.

Bridget nodded and shrugged at the same time because he did have a point.

"Maybe he just wanted to come by?" John suggested with a slight shrug.

He felt like he should contribute to the conversation, but since he was new to this version of reality, he was working with zero background information. So he decided to keep his comments as vague as possible.

Bridget placed one finger against her lips and tapped it thoughtfully for a moment. Then she lowered her hand and pointed between the Winchesters.

"I bet he got that internship. You know, the one he would've had to beat a thousand applicants for. The one he told us about the other week."

"Hmm." John nodded in agreement.

Then John watched as Dean also placed a finger against his own lips in a gesture clearly meant to mock Bridget, judging by the little glare she sent him. Dean lowered his finger and pointed at everyone around the table.

"Maybe he finally asked Jessica to marry him," he suggested with a shrug.

Mary's eyes widened as she tried to contain her excitement. "You think so?"

"Wouldn't Sammy want to announce something like that at a fancy restaurant with wine and gourmet food?" Bridget asked.

"That's true," Mary agreed.

"Besides," Bridget continued, "you know if he was going to propose, he would've told Dean. And Dean couldn't keep that a secret."

"Hey!" Dean protested, his annoyance clear in his tone. "I'm great at keeping secrets, thank you very much."

Both Bridget and Mary looked at him sceptically.

"What?" Dean asked, feeling ganged up on by the two women.

"You can't keep a secret, sweetie," Mary told her oldest son.

"Yeah, you told your parents I was pregnant like an hour after we found out," Bridget added.

Dean's frown immediately shifted into a knowing grin, almost as though he was pleased that he'd shared that particular secret when he had.

John couldn't help but smile. If Dean had shared the news that they were expecting their first child so quickly, it meant they must have a very close relationship. The fact that they worked together, and that John apparently felt comfortable in Dean's home, hadn't been enough evidence on its own. Knowing how eager Dean had been to share the news of becoming a father only reinforced that conclusion.

"Okay, fine. I'm bad at keeping secrets," Dean admitted. "But I still say Sam's getting married."

"Well, I say it's the internship," Bridget replied.

A sly grin spread across Dean's face. "Wanna make a bet?"

"What? Internship versus proposal?"

Dean nodded.

Bridget bit her lower lip as she considered it.

"All right." She nodded. "What do I get if I win?"

"What do you want?" Dean asked cautiously, clearly aware she might ask for something he'd really hate.

Without hesitation, Bridget replied, "I want to drive the Impala."

Dean scoffed. "Okay—"

"For a week," Bridget added.

"Fine—" Dean began to nod.

Bridget interrupted him. "Which means you, Dean Winchester, will have to drive my car for that week."

John watched with amusement as the smile on his son's face quickly disappeared, replaced by a hard, serious stare. He glanced over and caught the sly, amused smile on his wife's face. Clearly, she found this just as entertaining.

While John didn't know much about this version of his family or their lives, it was obvious that Dean—who worked with cars, appreciated what made them great, and put a lot of effort into maintaining the Impala—would feel very strongly about having to be anywhere near a car like a Volkswagen Beetle. John was surprised Dean was even dating someone who drove one.

Dean leaned in close to Bridget, his eyes narrowing. "Fine, but if I win..."

He trailed off and motioned for her to come closer. She did, leaning over until he was close enough to whisper something in her ear.

John couldn't hear what Dean said, but judging by the blush that immediately crept across Bridget's cheeks and the way her eyes widened, he could make a pretty good guess that it had been something embarrassing.

Dean pulled back and smirked at the look on his girlfriend's face. Then he leaned back and raised his hand, offering it for her to shake.

"So, do we have a bet?" he asked.

Bridget quickly recovered from whatever Dean had whispered and clasped his hand. They shook on it as though this bet was the most serious thing in the world.

Then a sly smile spread across Dean's face as he suddenly gave Bridget's hand a firm tug, pulling her toward him so he could steal a quick kiss.

John could tell that, even despite all the banter, his son was deeply in love with this woman. He knew Dean had dated a few girls here and there as a teenager, and maybe even a few during adulthood, but John had never actually seen him interact with any of them before. There was something about the way Dean acted around Bridget that suggested he was happy to let his guard down with her.

John turned to look at Mary, who was watching the younger couple with a smile on her face. It was clear she was just as fond of Bridget and happy to have her as part of their family.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Around an hour after being put down for her nap, baby Aislin woke up, and her sleepy little cries crackled through the baby monitor. By this time, both Winchester men had finished their lunch.

At the sound of his daughter's cries, Dean clapped his hands together and rubbed them, saying, "Someone's up."

"I'll get her if you want," Mary said as she pushed her chair back.

She was about to stand when John suddenly placed a firm hand on her shoulder.

"No," he said, giving a quick shake of his head. "I've got it."

Mary smiled at him and settled back into her chair. John glanced over at Dean and Bridget, but neither of them seemed bothered by his offer at all. He couldn't help wondering if getting Aislin after her naps was simply something he regularly did in this version of his life.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

When John reached the top of the stairs, he realised he didn't actually know which room the little girl was in. When he'd woken up beside Mary that morning, he hadn't exactly been focused on exploring the house.

As he walked down the hallway, though, it was easy enough to figure out where Aislin was.

He simply followed the sound of her cries.

A heavy weight suddenly settled in the pit of his stomach as John realised which room they were coming from.

It was the room that had once been Sam's nursery.

Then one terrible night, it had become the place where he'd lost the love of his life.

John stopped outside the door.

He could still feel the heat of the fire.

He could still smell the smoke and burning wood... and the scorched linen from the cot.

It was a painful reminder that sooner or later he would wake up and return to that reality.

Aislin's cries suddenly cut through his thoughts.

John drew in a slow breath.

Yes, eventually he would be forced back into a world filled with demons, hunting, and death.

But for now...

For now, he could play the role this new reality had given him.

A loving grandfather.

He opened the door and quickly took in the room.

There was a queen-sized bed, most likely for guests, and on the opposite side sat a white cot.

Sitting up inside it, her tiny hands gripping the rails, was the little girl who had somehow already captured his heart.

The moment she saw him, she held both arms out toward him. She was still crying, but there was no mistaking what she wanted.

John walked over and found himself once again struck by her green eyes.

The fact that she looked so much like Dean never stopped amazing him.

"Hey there," he whispered.

He gently brushed a hand over her cheek, and she blinked up at him.

"You ready to come downstairs?"

He reached into the cot, carefully lifted her over the railing, and settled her against his chest.

She leaned back slightly so she could study his face.

By then, she'd stopped crying altogether.

She simply blinked at him.

There was no other word for it.

She was beautiful.

Her little face was so full of innocence... and trust.

Which made perfect sense. She clearly spent a lot of time with him in this life.

She was new to him.

But he wasn't new to her.

She reached up with one tiny hand and patted the stubble along his jaw, her eyes widening with fascination at the rough texture.

John couldn't help smiling.

A quiet chuckle escaped him.

"You know," he murmured, "your dad used to look at me like that when he felt my beard too."

"Da!" Aislin squealed, her face instantly lighting up.

"Prefer your dad over me, huh?" John laughed softly. "That's fair enough."

He shifted her a little higher in his arms.

"Come on. Let's go downstairs and see your parents."

As he stepped out of the room, Aislin clutching the front of his shirt with one hand while continuing to explore his stubbled chin with the other, John suddenly came to a stop.

The realisation of what he was doing hit him with more force than the truck hitting the Impala.

He wasn't just holding a baby.

He wasn't simply carrying some child who happened to trust him.

This was his granddaughter.

"Oh, Aislin," John whispered as he stopped at the top of the stairs.

He looked down at her, blinking rapidly as he fought back the tears.

"I wish you could be in the real world."

He leaned down and gently pressed his lips against the side of her head, closing his eyes as he breathed in her scent.

Maybe one day...

After they'd killed the demon that had taken Mary...

After all of this was finally over...

Maybe Dean would find someone.

Maybe he'd settle down.

Maybe he'd have a family of his own.

Maybe...

To be continued...

Next Chapter: Sam and Jessica

Chapter 7: Sam and Jessica

Chapter Seven ~ SAM AND JESSICA

The rest of the afternoon and early evening at the Winchester home was spent in casual conversation as the four adults devoted most of their attention to the little girl, who, now awake from her nap, was happily playing on the pink playmat with a few toys scattered around her.

John and Bridget were sitting on either side of the couch, while Dean and Mary both sat on the floor with Aislin. It was very clear that Mary simply doted on the little girl.

There was also a very strong and obvious bond between Dean and Aislin. Neither one could really take their eyes off the other, and Dean seemed to instinctively know what Aislin wanted without her having to verbalise it. He instantly picked up on her cues. Sure, Aislin seemed happy and content with the rest of them, and yes, her face had lit up when John had brought her downstairs, and she had seen her mother... but there was no denying that little Aislin was a complete daddy's girl.

John smiled as he watched his wife and son on the floor playing with the baby girl. Fatherhood suited Dean, though it really shouldn't have surprised John. The number of times he had left Dean in charge of looking after Sam while he went on hunts should have told him that Dean would make an exceptional father one day. In the real world, anyway. Here, in this reality, John wasn't sure how much responsibility Dean had taken on while growing up.

As John contemplated these thoughts, there was the distinctive sound of a car pulling up outside. It was then that he realised it was getting close to 5:30 p.m., meaning the car outside must be Sam and Jessica.

As if reading his mind, Mary announced, "Oh, that'll be Sam and Jessica."

She stood up and started walking towards the door, not even giving Sam time to ring the doorbell.

John stood up to follow her. At the same time, Dean also got to his feet before picking Aislin up from the floor.

As he followed Mary to the door, John heard Dean mutter, "Time for a change," to Aislin.

John couldn't help feeling both excited and nervous at the thought of seeing his youngest son. He had been curious ever since he'd realised he was dreaming some sort of alternative life for all of them, eager to see what kind of person Sam had become here.

Mostly, he wanted to see what kind of relationship he had with Sam. In reality, their relationship was shaky at best, filled with arguments and strong opinions. John and his youngest son were very similar, and because they often held opposing views, this often led to far more fights than John would have liked.

Mary eagerly opened the door, clearly just as excited to see her youngest son and his girlfriend.

With the door now open, they were greeted by a smiling Sam and Jessica.

John quickly took them both in. Sam looked good. His hair was slightly longer than John was used to seeing and a little messier as well. He looked happy and healthy, and there didn't seem to be any tension, which was a good sign.

Jessica also looked happy. John had never been close to her before. He had seen her from afar during the times he'd gone to Stanford to check up on Sam, but he had never interacted with her or had any conversations with her. All he knew was that she made his son happy.

In all honesty, John was a little nervous to know what kind of relationship his dream had conjured up between himself and Jessica. He seemed to have an okay relationship with Dean's girlfriend, so there was a good chance he had a similar relationship with Sam's girlfriend.

Sam was carrying a medium-sized duffel bag over his shoulder, leading John to wonder if he and Jessica were planning on spending the night and staying in the room with the cot and the queen-size bed. Either that, or, like a lot of kids in college, Sam had laundry he wanted to get done.

Jessica was holding a small purple gift bag in her hand.

"Hi!" Mary beamed happily at the young couple.

Sam dropped the duffel bag at his feet before stepping towards his mother and leaning down, because of his height, to give her a hug.

"Hi, Mom," Sam said.

Seeing Mary and Sam hug was a little overwhelming for John. In reality, Mary had not been in Sam's life since he was a baby. She had missed so much—his first steps, his first birthday... she had missed everything. And now here she was, embracing the man he had become.

John quickly pulled himself together because, before he knew it, Sam had let go of Mary and was now coming over to hug him.

"Hey, Dad," Sam said.

John hugged him back, trying not to hold him too tightly and give away how much this meant to him. The ease with which Sam hugged him was another sign that their relationship here must be good.

"Hi, Mary. How are you?" Jessica asked before giving Mary a hug.

"I'm good," Mary replied. "How are you two?"

Jessica pulled back and smiled. "Things are really good." She turned to John and smiled. "Hey, John."

Then, just as Sam had done, she gave John a hug. John hugged her back. Surely this meant he also had a good relationship with her.

"The others here yet?" Sam asked, his eyes wandering around the entrance hall.

"They've been here all afternoon," Mary confirmed. At Sam's questioning look, she added, "They're in the living room."

John watched as Sam's face broke into a grin before he made his way quickly and eagerly towards the living room, with John, Jessica, and Mary following close behind. When they got there, Dean and Aislin were nowhere to be seen, John guessing that Dean was upstairs changing her diaper. Bridget stood in the living room by herself.

Sam's grin suddenly fell, replaced with a look of disappointment as he asked, "Where's Aislin?" He was almost... pouting.

Bridget suddenly held her hands out in front of herself and turned them over a few times before waving them around dramatically.

"You Winchesters can see me, right?" she asked, gesturing to herself before adding, "I mean, I am a real person with feelings and everything."

Sam suddenly looked a little embarrassed, a slight blush colouring his cheeks.

"Sorry, Bridget," he said sheepishly.

He stepped forward until he was standing in front of her.

Bridget rolled her eyes but smiled before wrapping her arms around Sam and rising onto her toes slightly to hug him.

"It's fine, Sammy," she told him before kissing his cheek. Pulling back, she added, "But I swear you lot are going to give me an identity complex one day."

John found the whole interaction amusing, and he thought back to that morning when Mary had practically ignored Bridget in favour of baby Aislin. From Bridget's outburst, he guessed this was a bad habit shared not only by Mary but also by himself and Sam, where their eagerness to see Aislin caused them to unintentionally overlook her mother. Though Bridget's comments suggested she found it annoying, the smile on her face told John that maybe she didn't mind all that much. He supposed it was simply a sign of how loved her little girl was.

"Hey, Bridget," Jessica said, walking over to Bridget and Sam. "How's the gallery going?"

"Hi, Jess." Bridget smiled as the two women hugged. "It's good. Thanks."

It was nice to see that the two of them also got along well. It would have made not only the evening but their whole lives awkward if the two women in his sons' lives hadn't developed some sort of friendship.

John turned to Sam, who was smiling again as he watched his girlfriend hug Bridget. Then Sam looked up as a noise from the stairs caught his attention. Instantly, the grin he had worn before returned, and his whole face lit up.

It was easy to see why.

Dean had reached the bottom of the stairs with Aislin in his arms.

Much like Mary had done that morning, Sam hurried over to Dean and, instead of greeting or even acknowledging his brother, simply reached out and took Aislin from his arms.

Dean's brow shot up in annoyance, but John noticed that he made no attempt to stop Sam.

"Hey, Aislin," Sam beamed down at the baby, bouncing her gently. "How are you?"

Aislin babbled and smiled in response, clearly happy to be in her uncle's arms.

John watched with a smile. It was obvious that Sam adored the little girl every bit as much as he and Mary did. It was amazing how someone so small could capture their hearts so completely.

"Dude!" Dean suddenly exclaimed, his tone full of annoyance. "You just totally ignored me!"

"Be happy he wasn't disappointed to see you," Bridget said as she walked over to stand beside Dean.

Dean frowned at her before shooting his brother a glare. Then he slipped an arm around Bridget's waist and pulled her against his side. She rested her head on his shoulder.

"I said sorry!" Sam exclaimed, looking up from Aislin briefly. He looked back down and shrugged. "Besides, it's your own fault anyway."

"How?" Dean asked.

"You shouldn't have made my niece so adorable," Sam replied with a grin.

Dean chuckled, and Bridget shook her head with a smile.

"If it makes you guys feel any better," Jessica began as she walked over to Sam. He offered Aislin to her, and she took the little girl, gently rocking her from side to side while still holding the gift bag in one hand before continuing, "There have been times I've been ignored in favour of Aislin too."

Both Dean and Bridget laughed.

Sam pouted before reaching out and taking Aislin back. As he settled the little girl against him, he leaned over and quickly kissed Jessica on the lips. Jessica smiled up at him before walking over to Dean and hugging him.

"It's good to see you, Jess," Dean told her, still laughing. "Any trouble keeping Sammy in line?"

"Sam!" Sam corrected.

John smirked and shook his head. The interaction between his sons and their girlfriends was very amusing to watch. Even through all the banter, it was easy to see the strong brotherly bond between Dean and Sam.

John was also curious that Sam still wasn't happy about being called Sammy. In real life, he knew Sam hated it and only really tolerated John using the nickname—though that was probably more because he didn't want to argue than because he actually liked it. But John also knew Sam had often told Dean off for calling him Sammy, just as he had now.

Yet there had been no correction when Bridget had called him Sammy. Perhaps he only allowed certain people to use the nickname.

Dean noticed the gift bag still in Jessica's hand.

"What's in the bag?" Dean asked, nodding towards it.

"A present for Aislin," Jessica replied with a smile.

She turned and held the bag out to Sam, who now had Aislin balanced on one hip, leaving one hand free to reach inside. He pulled out a small, fluffy caterpillar toy with oversized eyes.

"Look, Aislin," he said happily as he showed her the new toy.

Aislin's eyes lit up with curiosity as she reached out with her tiny hands to grab it.

"You keep spoilin' her, man," Dean said, shaking his head as he watched his daughter happily wave her new toy around.

Sam scoffed. "Yeah, because I'm the only one in this room who does that."

He rolled his eyes before turning to look at his parents.

Mary smiled. "I make no apologies for spoiling my beautiful granddaughter."

John couldn't help smiling at his wife. Moments like this reminded him of why he had fallen in love with her.

"Anyway, I was just about to serve dinner," Mary said. "Sam, why don't you go put your stuff upstairs? Then it should be ready."

She nodded before heading towards the dining room.

"I'll help," John told her, following after her.

Behind him, he could hear his sons beginning to bicker again.

"Give me Aislin," Dean said.

"No. You get her whenever you want," Sam argued. "It's my turn."

"Dude, go put your crap away and give her here!"

John heard Bridget sigh loudly and mutter, "Every time."

John couldn't help but grin.

To be continued...

Next Chapter: The Announcement

Chapter 8: The Announcment

Chapter Eight ~ THE ANNOUNCEMENT

There were two things that really stood out to John as moments he knew would be engraved in his memory of this dream long after he woke up.

The first, of course, was his beautiful baby granddaughter. In all the ways he had ever imagined his sons' lives going when they finally moved on from hunting, having children had never seemed to enter his mind. But now that he had seen Dean as a father, had witnessed the father-daughter relationship, and had held his granddaughter... well, now John couldn't imagine any other life for Dean.

The second thing was here and now. Sitting in his dining room at one end of the long rectangular table, having a home-cooked meal with his family. His entire family. Something that would be a normal occurrence for everyone else, but to John Winchester, it was literally a dream come true.

While conversation flowed between the others, John was content to sit silently and take it all in, speaking only when someone addressed him directly. The atmosphere was relaxed and fun, and happiness radiated from all of them. He knew that once he woke up, the chance of ever experiencing this feeling of family and belonging probably wasn't going to happen for him. So he was going to enjoy this meal as much as he could.

From his spot at the end of the table, John was able to see everyone clearly. Mary sat opposite him on the other side of the table. Every now and then, she would look over at him and flash him a smile. Sam and Jessica were on one side of the table, with Dean and Bridget on the other. Baby Aislin was seated in a high chair—one that was already here, adding more evidence that Aislin must spend a lot of time here with him and Mary. The high chair was pulled up to the table between Dean and Mary.

While the adults had glasses of wine—except for Bridget, who had water, which John found odd but didn't dwell on—and large servings of roast chicken, potatoes, pumpkin, and asparagus on their plates, baby Aislin had a plate of the same foods, only mashed up instead. John happily watched as she used her fingers to play with her food before bringing handfuls of it to her mouth. She was clearly enjoying herself.

Mary laughed as she watched Aislin make a mess, and John smiled even bigger. There was now a third thing that was going to stay with him after he woke up, and that was how happy his wife was.

He missed her being happy.

Hell, he just missed her.

"John, you okay?" Mary asked suddenly.

John then realised he must have been staring at her. The others had stopped in the middle of their conversation about Sam's latest exam results because of the worried tone they heard in Mary's voice.

John quickly nodded and smiled, trying to show that he was okay and not that he was thinking about a life where none of this was real.

"Yeah, yeah. Just enjoying this home-cooked meal," he said, bringing his fork, which held a piece of chicken, up and waving it around slightly before putting it into his mouth. "Best thing I've tasted in a long time," he added around the chicken.

Mary laughed again and shook her head, amused.

"You sound like you haven't had my cooking in years."

John nearly choked when he heard those words, but quickly managed to swallow instead. Then he grabbed his wine and took a long drink. When he was done, he cleared his throat and turned to look at Sam.

Wanting to change the subject and get everyone's attention off him, John asked his youngest, "You were telling us about your results, Sam?"

"Oh yeah." Sam nodded and shrugged. "It's no big deal—"

"—It's a very big deal," Jessica interrupted with a smile. She placed a hand on Sam's shoulder and proudly told the others, "Sam got the highest grade in the class."

"That's great, Sammy," Bridget said.

"Good job, Sam," Dean added as he raised his wine glass in Sam's direction. "Kickin' all those other nerds' asses," he added with a wink.

Sam rolled his eyes.

"We're so proud of you, Sam," Mary told her youngest son.

"Yeah, Sam," John nodded.

"Thanks, Mom. Thanks, Dad." Sam looked at each of them and couldn't help the proud grin that spread across his face, showing he was proud of himself, too.

During brief stops at Stanford to check in on Sam, John had gathered enough information to know that Sam was doing well in his studies. Sam had always been smart, and when he applied himself to something, he always succeeded. So knowing that he was passing his exams and excelling was something John had experienced in the real world. What John had never experienced was being able to celebrate those achievements with him.

The conversation continued to flow easily while baby Aislin babbled and made gurgling noises around her food. They spoke about the garage, life at Stanford, the new book Mary was reading, and the cute things Aislin had done during the week.

"Still doing that weekend away for your birthday, Bridget?" Jessica asked.

"Hopefully." Bridget smiled, turning to Dean.

"Yep," Dean agreed. He leaned over and quickly pecked Bridget on the lips before pulling back with a frown. "Just got to make sure we can find someone to look after Aislin. It's such a hard task after all," he joked.

"Oh, be quiet, Dean. You know we're having her," Mary scolded her oldest son. She turned to Aislin, who was busy with a mouthful of mashed potatoes. "Isn't that right, sweetheart?"

"How come I never get to watch her?" Sam asked with a pout. "We've got room. She could easily stay with us for a night."

"You live in another state..." Dean said slowly, as though explaining something to a child. "Mom and Dad"—he gestured between John and Mary—"are literally around the corner."

"Okay, sure... but, I mean, you could come visit before you go on your trip and leave Aislin with us then," Sam replied, looking as though he had really thought this through.

"Maybe." Bridget nodded.

"Didn't realise you felt that strongly about it, Sam," Dean said. All joking had now stopped as it became clear that Sam was being completely serious.

"I don't know." Sam shrugged. "She changes so much. I just miss her."

"I think that's lovely, Sam," Mary replied, a soft smile of pride on her face.

"So do I," Bridget agreed. She turned to Dean. "I'm happy to arrange for a weekend where Aislin stays with Sammy if you're good with that."

"Hey, I'm all for any type of free babysitting." Dean grinned.

As if she knew she was being spoken about, Aislin started slapping her hands on her plate, sending the remaining food splattering all over the tray of the high chair. She giggled happily. The adults all turned to her and laughed.

Time went on, and when their meals were almost finished, John noticed that every time Sam or Jessica spoke, Dean and Bridget would lean in slightly, as though both of them were eager to find out whether Sam's visit had another reason behind it, so they could settle their little bet from earlier.

Surprisingly, though, it was actually Mary who finally broke and blurted out, "Okay. I can't wait any longer. We know you have something you want to tell us, Sam. So what is it?"

Sam and Jessica looked at Mary, but they didn't seem annoyed or even surprised by her sudden question. Dean and Bridget also turned to Mary before immediately looking back at Sam and Jessica.

Sam and Jessica then looked at each other and smiled.

"You wanna tell 'em?" Sam asked Jessica.

Jessica shrugged and shook her head. "They're your family."

"All right." Sam nodded and grabbed Jessica's left hand. He brought it under the table for a moment before bringing both hands back into view.

John couldn't see what had happened beneath the table, but it became clear when Sam suddenly held Jessica's left hand up. On her ring finger was a beautiful diamond engagement ring.

"We're getting married!" Sam and Jessica both shouted happily.

Mary squealed with delight. She pushed her chair back and quickly hurried over to the newly engaged couple. Dean and Bridget also stood and walked around the table to join them.

John stood slowly and watched as his wife hugged their son. Happiness radiated from her. In fact, happiness radiated from all of them. Sam looked so proud to be sharing the news that he was going to marry the woman he loved.

John remembered the words the demon had spoken when it had possessed him.

"...Sam was going to ask her to marry him. Been shopping for rings and everything..."

If it wasn't for their lives, if it wasn't for the demon... maybe, if Jessica were still alive, she and Sam would be engaged right now. And while there was also a chance that, given how strained their relationship had become over the last few years, Sam might not even have told his father or Dean about it, at least Sam would have been happy. At least he would have gotten what he wanted.

But instead, Sam had to live with the pain of losing the woman he loved—a pain John knew all too well and hated that his son knew as well.

It wasn't fair. Not by any means. The life of hunting, of moving from place to place, of missing out on normal lives... that wasn't what his sons deserved.

This... this was what they deserved.

Being happy.

Celebrating together.

And it broke John to know that this was only a fictional reality his own mind had created.

"Dad?"

Sam's voice suddenly cut through John's thoughts.

John finally looked at his son. Sam's face held an expression of concern and worry.

"You okay?" Sam asked.

John let out a breath he hadn't even realised he'd been holding and smiled.

"Yeah, yeah. I'm just happy for you, son."

His smile widened as he walked over and pulled Sam into a hug.

When they pulled apart, John placed a hand on Sam's shoulder.

"I'm proud of you."

Sam smiled.

"Thanks, Dad."

After everyone had hugged one another, and while Mary held Jessica's hand to get a better look at and admire her ring, Sam walked over to Aislin, who had been watching the adults' excitement with confusion and great interest. She had no idea why they were all smiling and hugging. She was now well and truly covered in the remnants of her food, having even managed to get some in her hair.

"What do you think, Aislin?" he asked.

He grabbed the nearest napkin and quickly wiped most of the food from her head and hands. Her face scrunched up in annoyance as she tried to swat the offending material away.

Once she was a little cleaner, Sam picked her up out of the high chair and settled her on his hip. Grinning down at her, he continued, "You happy Jessica is officially your aunt now?"

"Jessica's been her aunt from the day she was born," Bridget corrected. She was admiring the engagement ring. Looking up at Sam with a smirk, she added, "And if you ever muck this up, she'll still be Aislin's aunt."

Sam laughed and gently swayed with Aislin in his arms.

"That's absolutely right," Mary agreed. She reached out and took Jessica's and Bridget's hands before saying, "You two know that you'll always be welcome here, and you'll always be our family. Even if our sons do something stupid and screw up the best things that have ever happened to them."

"Gee, thanks for the vote of confidence, Mom," Dean mocked, rolling his eyes.

John watched as Jessica smiled gratefully, but it was the look in Bridget's eyes that he couldn't quite place. She looked happy but also a little sad.

Then he watched as Dean stepped up behind her, placed a comforting hand on her shoulder, gave it a gentle squeeze, and leaned down to kiss her temple softly, as though he understood exactly what Mary's words had stirred in her without Bridget having to say a thing.

There was definitely a story behind that, but John wasn't sure if he was meant to know what it was.

No one else seemed to notice the little interaction, or if they did, they didn't mention it. Instead, Mary and Jessica had moved over to Sam and started playing with Aislin. The baby babbled and waved her hands around, happy to be the centre of attention.

John couldn't help the smile that spread across his face.

This is what true happiness feels like, he thought.

He looked over at Dean and Bridget.

Dean, still standing behind her, lowered his head beside her face, his lips only inches from her ear as he confidently bragged with a smirk, "I win."

John watched as Bridget's eyes went wide.

To be continued...

Next Chapter: Perfect Family

Chapter 9: Perfect Family

Chapter Nine ~ PERFECT FAMILY

Somehow, it was decided that the task of clearing the table and doing the dishes would fall to the men, while the women would relax in the living room and wait for them.

Doing the dishes together was never really something they did. More often than not, their dishes consisted of paper plates and plastic forks that got thrown away after one use. And on the rare occasions that they did have actual dishes; they would sit in the sink untouched for days until John—or sometimes Dean—finally got to them. This interaction was casual, as if it happened often. It was nice.

John was actually enjoying doing the dishes with his sons. Or with Sam, at least. Instead of helping, Dean was sitting at the table with his chair turned to face Aislin in her highchair as he spoon-fed her the custard he had purchased when they had gone shopping earlier.

Apparently, the custard was too messy for her to feed herself.

This left John standing at the sink, washing dish after dish before handing them off to Sam to dry and stack on the table to be put away. John didn’t mind that Dean was otherwise preoccupied, but Sam was getting a little annoyed.

“Thanks for the help, Dean,” Sam said sarcastically.

Dean looked up from Aislin, the plastic spoon he was holding dipped into the bowl of custard.

“Dude, I’m feeding my daughter. Calm down.”

“We could swap,” Sam suggested. “I could feed her for a bit.”

Sam placed the plate he had been drying on the stack of clean dishes, flung the dish towel over his left shoulder, and moved to stand behind Dean. He grinned down at Aislin, who was looking at the bowl of custard in Dean’s hands, waiting for him to give her more.

Dean looked over his shoulder at Sam for a moment before shrugging.

“Okay, Sam,” Dean agreed. “Let's have Aislin choose.” He turned back to his daughter. “Okay, baby, do you want Daddy to feed you or” —he waved back at Sam — “Uncle Sammy?”

Aislin looked at Sam. She smiled slightly, obviously very comfortable and happy around her uncle, but then her eyes went back to Dean.

“Da!” she yelled, giggling.

Dean looked back over at Sam, a triumphant grin on his face.

“Ha!” he yelled.

John smiled and shook his head in amusement. He was ninety-nine percent sure that, at this age, Aislin couldn’t really understand what she was being asked and was more likely just happy saying the sound "Da," but he wasn’t going to point that out to his sons.

“Yeah, well, of course she’s going to choose you,” Sam told Dean as he whipped the dish towel off his shoulder and skulked back over to John. “You’re her favourite.”

Dean’s smile grew even wider as he turned back to Aislin.

“I know.” He held the spoon out and gave her another mouthful of custard, using his other hand to gently push her little hands away as she tried to grab the spoon. “Don’t think so, missy. You’re messy enough.”

“Let's see if you're still the favourite when she’s older and I get to be the fun uncle,” Sam muttered, still clearly annoyed.

“Oh, get over it.” Dean rolled his eyes. “Can’t help it if Aislin’s a daddy’s girl. Can we, baby?” he added, smiling at Aislin.

“I don’t know if she has favourite people,” John began, his hands busy washing one of the wine glasses. “She probably just has a stronger bond with you, Dean, because you’re her father.”

“Everyone has favourite people, Dad,” Sam told him. “Parents have favourite children.” He pointed out.

John froze for a moment, his hands going still in the soapy water.

He turned to Sam and frowned.

“Parents don’t have favourites.”

Both Sam and Dean scoffed in disbelief.

A heavy weight suddenly settled in John’s stomach. Their response suggested that either he or Mary clearly favoured one of them over the other, which meant maybe their relationships weren’t as strong in this version of reality as John had first been led to believe.

Suddenly, the horrible words the demon had said to Dean through John's mouth when he had been possessed slammed into his mind like a brick.

"Sam—he’s clearly John’s favourite. Even when they fight, it’s more concern than he’s ever shown you."

The demon had taunted Dean with such confidence, but what stung John more than the words themselves was how Dean had reacted to them. He hadn’t looked upset or even shocked. It was almost as if he accepted them as fact, as though he truly believed his father valued his brother more than him.

At the time, John remembered hearing his own voice screaming inside his head, telling the demon to shut up and stop, even before Dean had started to bleed.

“Your mom and I don’t have a favourite child,” he told them as seriously as he could, leaving no room for doubt that he was speaking the truth. It was something he knew he needed to make equally clear when he woke up and spoke with the real Dean.

His gaze lingered on this Dean for longer than it probably should have.

“Oh, please,” Dean muttered, not believing John at all.

“Dean—” John wanted to protest, to make his son understand that he loved them both the same.

“—Mom definitely has a favourite child,” Sam interrupted with a laugh.

John turned to him, his brow furrowing in confusion. Sam sounded happy that Mary had a favourite child. Did that mean he thought he was the favourite? It didn’t make sense. The Mary John knew loved both her boys equally, and he didn’t doubt that she always would, no matter what happened.

Dean nodded in agreement with Sam.

“I’m sure your mom doesn—” John began.

Dean interrupted him, looking toward the kitchen doorway and yelling, “Hey, Mom!”

There was a brief pause before Mary’s voice floated in from the other room.

“Yes, Dean?!” she called.

“Who’s your favourite child?!” Dean shouted.

The second Dean had gotten the ‘D’ sound out in the word ‘child’, Mary answered without hesitation.

“Aislin!” she yelled back.

John stared at his sons in shock.

Sam and Dean both turned to him with grins on their faces.

“Told ya!” they said triumphantly.

John had to laugh.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

After the dishes had been done and Dean had given Aislin another quick wipe-down because, despite his best efforts, she'd still managed to get a little custard on herself, the three Winchester men joined their respective partners in the living room. Mary, Jessica, and Dean took up the couch, with Bridget sitting on the floor, her back against it and her side pressed against one of Dean's legs. Sam sat in one of the two armchairs, while John sat in the other.

John had Aislin on his lap, cooing at the toy Sam had given her as he waved it around every now and then. His attention drifted between her and the conversation. He was enjoying having the little girl with him. He still couldn't get over the bond he seemed to feel with her. He had never experienced anything like this in any other dream before. Hell, he couldn't say he had ever experienced it in real life either. Sure, he adored his sons, but this was a different kind of love he couldn't put into words.

More wine had been poured for everyone—except Bridget, who was still only drinking water. The conversation turned back to Sam and Jessica's new engagement.

"Have you two chosen a date yet?" Mary asked the newly engaged couple.

"Not yet," Sam answered. "We haven't really decided how long we want to stay engaged."

"We were thinking we'd stay engaged for at least a year. Save up a bit before we get married," Jessica added.

"Plus, some of Jessica's family might think we're too young to get married right now," Sam added. He shrugged before continuing, "So it might just be easier to wait."

Bridget scoffed and shrugged. "Hey, I'm the same age as you, Sammy, and I've already got a baby." She smiled over at him.

Dean placed a hand on her shoulder and smiled down at her.

Sam gave them a sly grin as he teased, "But no ring yet."

Dean grabbed the small decorative cushion from behind him and hurled it toward his brother. It hit Sam on the side of the head. Instead of being annoyed or angry, Sam just laughed, clearly more pleased with the reaction he'd gotten from annoying his brother than anything else.

"Not that I'm pushing," Mary began gently, turning to Dean and clearly ignoring the fact that he had just thrown one of her cushions, "but have you two considered..." She trailed off, knowing she didn't need to finish the question.

John watched as Dean rolled his eyes and leaned his head back against the top of the couch. Bridget remained where she was, but she didn't seem bothered by the direction the conversation had taken.

John realised that although he'd noticed the lack of rings on Dean's and Bridget's fingers, he couldn't say he thought it made any difference. Perhaps because, for him, just knowing that Dean was in an apparently long-term relationship and had a daughter was enough to adjust to. Whether they were married or not didn't seem to matter.

However, from Dean's reaction, John had to wonder whether this question came up often. Perhaps there had been pressure put on Dean and Bridget to get married one day, and he wondered whether having Aislin had only made that pressure worse.

"Well, we wouldn't be able to get a ring now," Bridget began. "We wouldn't want to steal Sammy's thunder." Her tone made it sound like this should have been the most obvious reason in the world. Then, in a falsely annoyed tone, she added, "Thanks, Sammy."

Dean smirked, his head still tilted back. He lifted it, leaned forward, and reached out to gently grasp Bridget's chin. Tilting her head to one side, he bent down and murmured, "Thank you," before giving her a brief kiss.

"You're welcome," she murmured back.

John couldn't help but smile. It seemed his mind had created just the right woman for Dean. The emotional connection between them was unmistakable. Maybe his mind had simply created someone who could give Dean the same kind of relationship John had once shared with Mary.

Bridget smiled, resting a hand on Dean's knee and absent-mindedly rubbing circles over it as she turned to Jessica.

"Back to your upcoming wedding," Bridget said cheerfully. "Have you got any plans in place at all? Or are you just waiting until you set a date?"

"There are a few things I think we've already settled on." Jessica nodded, looking over at Sam with a smile. "I'd really like to get married at the same church where my parents were married."

"Oh, is that the one with the white roses along the front path?" Bridget asked.

Dean twitched his leg to get her attention. "How the hell do you know that Bridge?"

"Because I pay attention when people show us holiday photos," she replied, twisting her head back to look at him. "Unlike you."

"And the fact that you're a photographer and can't help but study photographs has nothing to do with it?" Dean asked with a half-shrug.

"Nope." Bridget grinned. "Just being polite."

"We also know that we'd like Aislin to be our flower girl," Jessica told them, adding, "Obviously."

"Oh," Mary sighed, looking over at Aislin on John's lap. "Wonderful. She'll make the most adorable flower girl."

As if on cue, Aislin threw her new caterpillar toy onto the floor, almost like a flower girl scattering petals with a little too much enthusiasm. John wrapped one arm more securely around her back so he could bend down and retrieve the toy with the other without risking her slipping from his lap.

Dean laughed. "You don't have to audition, baby. You've already got the job."

John smiled as Aislin reached eagerly for the caterpillar when he held it out to her again. She giggled, and the sound filled his heart.

"Another benefit to having a longer engagement… Aislin might be able to walk down the aisle by then," Sam said with a proud smile directed at his niece.

Bridget smiled and nodded while Dean rested his hands on her shoulders, rubbing them gently. They both wore proud expressions as they watched their daughter happily play with her grandad.

"They're both great starts," Mary said.

"Actually," Sam began, a sly grin spreading across his face as he shared a look with Jessica, "there are two more things we've already figured out." He paused and nodded once at Jessica.

Jessica grinned back before looking down at Bridget.

"Bridget, would you be one of my bridesmaids?"

"What?" Bridget looked genuinely surprised. Her head whipped back and forth between Jessica and Sam. "Really?"

Jessica grinned and nodded vigorously.

"Yes. Of course." Bridget beamed.

She placed a hand on Dean's knee and used it for leverage as she stood. Then she sat on the couch between Dean and Jessica so she could give Jessica a big hug. Dean didn't move over for her. Instead, he simply let her lean comfortably against one of his legs.

"And Dean, I was kind of hoping you'd be my best man?" Sam asked with a huge grin.

"What's in it for me?" Dean asked with a completely straight face.

Still hugging Jessica, Bridget flung a hand backwards and smacked Dean on the arm. Not hard, but certainly not softly either.

"Dean!" Mary exclaimed at the same time, clearly concerned by his response.

Dean chuckled. He had, of course, been joking, but he seemed to enjoy the reaction he'd gotten from his mother. Maybe it was his way of getting back at her for the whole "Why aren't you married yet?" conversation.

"Nah, just kidding, Sam. Of course I'll do it."

"I thought so—" Sam began.

"—Not wearing a tux, though."

Sam scoffed. "My wedding. My dress code," he said firmly.

Mary laughed, clearly happy that Dean was going to be involved in the wedding.

In this dream, it was clear that even though they lived far apart, Dean and Sam were very close. In real life, John knew they had become close after travelling together for so long over the last year, but they had been anything but close before that. He also knew that his own relationship with Sam had become terribly strained when Sam left for Stanford and, as a consequence, Sam and Dean's relationship had suffered as well.

Watching Sam ask Dean to be his best man was not something that would have happened in reality had Sam been able to ask Jessica to marry him. John couldn't even say for sure whether he and Dean would have received an invitation to the wedding.

John smiled to himself as he watched his family before him. Sam and Dean were teasing each other without any real annoyance fuelling their jabs. Mary seemed thrilled to have everyone home. Jessica and Bridget both seemed to fit perfectly into the Winchester family, completely at ease, as though they'd always belonged there.

This was the biggest thing that John, Dean, and Sam had missed out on because of the demon who had killed Mary: the chance to create happy family memories like these.

As he watched them, he couldn't help but feel guilty. Maybe he shouldn't have focused on revenge so much. Maybe he should have tried harder to give his sons a normal life.

He looked down at Aislin, who was staring up at him. He smiled softly at her.


Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

As the evening went on, they continued to enjoy the flow of conversation.

Aislin had been passed around quite a bit. Not that she seemed to mind, as she smiled and babbled at everyone. She had been sitting on Sam’s lap for the last twenty minutes or so. Every now and then, Sam bounced his knees up and down, causing the little girl to giggle. The proud grin across Sam’s face showed how much he loved being able to make her laugh like that.

It was clear to John that Sam really did like being an uncle and would always be there for that little girl.

After one last knee bounce and giggle, Sam stood up with Aislin in his arms. He bounced her gently as she reached out to grab his hair.

“Anyone want more wine?” he asked, smiling at Aislin.

“Oh, I’ll get them, Sam—” Mary began.

“—No, I got it, Mom,” Sam told her. He walked over to stand in front of her and lowered Aislin down, offering her to his mother. “I know you’ve been waiting for cuddles anyway.” He laughed.

Mary laughed and smiled widely as she reached out and took her granddaughter, settling her onto her lap.

John wondered if this was how these gatherings usually went—with Aislin being passed around like the collection plate at church. Again, though, she didn’t seem to mind as she now focused her attention on her grandmother.

Sam started collecting everyone’s glasses.

“I’ll help, Sam,” Bridget offered as she stood from her position on the couch between Jessica and Dean.

While holding her own glass, Bridget turned and took the glass Dean was holding out.

“You know, Sammy, I’m actually surprised,” Bridget said.

“About what?” Sam asked.

“I would have thought you’d want us all at some fancy, posh restaurant to announce your engagement,” she told him.

“I did think of it,” he admitted. “But I didn’t want to give the secret away too soon.”

Bridget laughed and started walking out of the living room.

“I’m also surprised Dean didn’t already know.”

“Actually, he did know,” Sam admitted, shrugging one shoulder as he walked beside her.

Bridget suddenly stopped walking, causing Sam to stop as well.

They were now standing just behind John, and he had to twist his head slightly to see them properly.

“What?” Bridget asked slowly.

Sam turned to face her, looking confused.

“Yeah, I told him about a week ago...” Sam trailed off as, clearly, the same thing that was now catching John’s eye also caught Sam’s.

Behind Bridget, Dean stood, frantically waving his hand back and forth across his neck, making the universal sign for "cut it out" or, in this case, "shut the hell up." He was shaking his head and glaring at his brother.

Clearly, Sam had no idea why Dean was doing any of that because he kept talking to Bridget.

“…I couldn’t wait until we got here.”

Dean frowned at his brother just as Bridget turned around and frowned angrily at him.

“Oh, you cheated, Dean!” she accused.

“I didn’t—” Dean began to defend himself.

“—Cheated on what?” Sam interrupted, obviously very confused about what the hell was going on.

“They had a bet,” John answered. He was a little nervous, hoping this wasn’t about to turn into an uncomfortable fight between Dean and Bridget.

Mary and Jessica watched as Bridget walked right up to Dean. Mary seemed a little concerned but not especially worried. Jessica looked... amused.

“A bet about what?” Jessica asked.

“About what you and Sam wanted to tell everyone. I said it was going to be about that internship, and Dean said you were going to tell us Sammy proposed.” Bridget kept her gaze fixed on Dean. “You cheated. You already knew Sammy was going to tell us he was engaged.”

“I may have technically left out some key bits of information,” Dean said with a shrug. It was clear he knew arguing was pointless now, so his only choice was to admit his mistake.

“Key bits of - You already knew the outcome,” Bridget said accusingly, shaking her head in disbelief. “Now you can forget about your win. It doesn’t count.”

“What were the terms this time?” Sam asked.

This time. That told John these sorts of bets must have been common between Dean and Bridget.

At Sam’s question, Bridget’s cheeks turned a very slight shade of pink, and she bit her bottom lip for just a fraction of a moment. John had not actually heard what Dean wanted if he won the bet, but he could tell by Bridget’s reaction that it was something private.

“I think because Dean cheated, Bridget should win by default, and Dean should do whatever it was she wanted,” Jessica said thoughtfully.

Bridget’s eyes lit up as Dean’s lowered into a scowl.

“Yes!” she said at the exact same time Dean said, “No!”

Sam was grinning now.

“Why? What did you want, Bridget?”

“I get to drive the Impala while Dean has to drive my car,” Bridget told him as a slight smile curled at her lips.

Sam started laughing, “Okay, I agree with Jessica.”

As Sam laughed, Jessica giggled, and Mary hid what John assumed was a smile of her own behind her hand. It was clear that Dean’s apparent hatred of his girlfriend’s car was very well known.

Mary cleared her throat before saying, “I agree with them, Dean.”

Dean finally broke eye contact with Bridget and turned to look at his mother. He frowned slightly.

“Really, Mom?” he asked, clearly surprised that she would even get involved.

Then he turned to John, his expression becoming an obvious plea as he simply asked,

“Dad?”

John briefly considered defending Dean, but as he looked at how much everyone else was enjoying this new turn of events, he found that he, too, wanted to be part of it. After all, if all Dean had to do was drive a car he didn’t like for a while, it wasn’t going to be the end of the world.

“You did cheat, son,” John reminded him.

Dean groaned and threw his head back.

“Why are you all on her side?” he huffed, waving a hand in Bridget’s direction. “You’re my family.”

Bridget grinned.

“It’s because they like me.” She flicked a hand toward Mary and John. “I gave them a granddaughter.”

Then she waved the same hand toward Sam.

“I gave your brother a niece—”

“—So did I!” Dean pointed out, almost scoffing at the fact that she could think she had him with that.

Bridget shook her head slowly.

“Yes, Dean, because all that constant nausea, cramps, back pain, sore breasts, and heartburn I went through for nine months of pregnancy—not to mention the actual excruciating pain of seventeen hours of labour—are totally the same as your sacrifice of having sex for five minutes!”

John watched as Dean’s jaw dropped open and his eyes grew as wide as saucers. A slight shade of pink crept up Dean’s neck and cheeks. His mouth quickly snapped shut, and his expression became a mixture of shock, embarrassment, and annoyance.

Sam and Jessica burst out laughing once again, Sam nearly dropping the three wine glasses he had been holding throughout all of this. Mary pursed her lips together in an attempt to stop herself from laughing as well. Aislin was busy playing with her caterpillar toy and seemed completely unaware of what was happening between her parents.

John found himself biting the inside of his cheek to stop himself from laughing, too. Sure, Dean was obviously uncomfortable with his sex life being mentioned in front of his parents, but it felt so good to see everyone else laughing and enjoying themselves, even if it was at Dean’s expense. It was something they were all experiencing together as a family.

Bridget, clearly pleased with herself, tilted her head slightly.

“Have fun driving my car,” she told Dean.

Then she turned and walked quickly out of the living room. Sam followed right behind her, still laughing.

“I’ll drive it to the scrap yard,” Dean muttered, though loudly enough for everyone to hear.

“I heard that!” Bridget shouted from near the kitchen.

“That’s because I said it!” he shouted back.

Dean let out a short groan and dropped back down onto the couch like dead weight. Jessica nudged him with her elbow.

“Why do you always get yourself into trouble?” she asked, still thoroughly amused by the argument that had just happened.

Dean turned his head and glared at her, his jaw set firmly. Then he looked past her to his mother and daughter. Aislin was playing her own game of making her caterpillar bounce up and down, her eyes twinkling with amazement, even though she was the one moving the toy. Dean’s annoyed expression changed immediately as he watched his daughter.

Suddenly, Dean let out a long sigh before hurling himself off the couch and, without saying a word, walking out in the direction Sam and Bridget had just gone.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Not long after Dean had left, Sam walked back into the living room on his own. He was balancing two half-filled wine glasses between the fingers of his right hand, while in his left he held the necks of two bottles of beer. As he walked past John, he offered him one of the beers.

“Thanks, Sam,” John nodded, taking hold of the offered beverage.

Sam nodded and walked over to the couch where Mary and Jessica were still sitting. He placed one wine glass on the little end table beside Mary, as she was holding Aislin, making it difficult for her to also hold a glass of wine.

“Everything okay with Dean and Bridget?” Mary asked as Sam sat down next to Jessica in the seat that Dean had previously been in.

“Yeah,” Sam said with a smile. He lifted his own beer to his mouth and added, “You know they never fight for long,” before taking a drink.

“I can’t believe Dean thought he could get away with it,” Jessica said, shaking her head slightly.

“I know.” Sam laughed. “I mean, Bridget usually finds out when he pulls stuff like this eventually. You’d think he’d learn by now.”

John smiled as he tipped his beer back and took a long drink. He very much liked seeing Sam laugh and have fun. He hadn’t really seen this side of Sam in years.

It was then that Aislin dropped her toy and started to whimper. Her bottom lip began to tremble as her eyes started to glisten with the tears that were on their way. Mary held her tightly and immediately tried to calm her down. Aislin snuggled closer against the warmth of her grandmother but continued to fuss.

All laughter was forgotten as the adults in the room looked at the baby with concern. Even John found that he didn’t like knowing she was upset. He watched as Mary gently rocked her while making soft shushing noises.

“Hey, Aislin, what’s up?” Sam asked with concern as he reached an arm across Jessica to gently rub one of Aislin’s legs.

Aislin ignored him, and soon her whimpers turned into soft cries, with the potential to become much louder.

“It’s probably time for her to have a bottle,” Mary said. “Might be best if she has one now before they go home.”

“I’ll go get one,” John offered.

He leaned forward and placed his beer bottle on the floor beside his armchair before standing up. He took one last look at his little baby granddaughter as she cried in her grandmother’s arms, then turned and left the living room.

John considered himself to be a pretty tough guy. A nothing gets to me and I can handle anything type of guy. After all, he had to become like that to survive the life of a hunter. That included pushing back his emotions, even where his own sons were concerned. He was very good at it too—acting as though seeing his sons hurt or in danger didn’t affect him as much as it really did.

But... seeing little Aislin upset—hearing her cry... well, damn if that wasn’t affecting him and making him emotional.

Maybe it was some sort of biological connection his dream state had created because that little baby was meant to be his granddaughter. Or maybe it was seeing his wife trying to comfort her when he hadn’t seen her with a baby since Sam was little.

Either way, John just wanted to get out of there before the others noticed how much it was getting to him.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

It wasn’t until John was several feet away from the kitchen doorway and began to hear voices that he remembered Dean and Bridget were in there sorting out their argument. He had been so focused on getting Aislin a bottle that he had completely forgotten about them.

As he walked closer to the doorway, he could clearly hear their conversation. He paused, knowing he should go in but also sensing that they needed to finish the private conversation they were having in order to move past the fight they'd had. As well as that, John found himself curious to see how they were going to sort it out.

John had not expected Dean to follow Bridget in the first place. Usually, Dean didn’t show any emotional vulnerability around women, preferring to play the tough guy instead. But instead of leaving things alone, he had gone after Bridget, clearly not to continue arguing but to try to fix things.

So, out of curiosity, and knowing that he could wake up at any moment and lose all of this anyway, John stood still by the kitchen doorway and watched the young couple.

They didn’t see him, as both their backs were to the door.

Bridget was standing by the sink, her hands moving as she performed a task that John couldn’t identify from his current vantage point. Dean was standing behind her, his arms loosely around her midsection, while his chin rested on her left shoulder. They were clearly having an intense discussion, but the fact that they were standing so intimately had to be a good sign.

"—So why not just tell me you knew what Sammy wanted us all here for?" Bridget asked as their conversation continued.

"I didn’t want to give away Sam’s secret," Dean told her.

"But you did give it away," she pointed out. "You’re the one who suggested an engagement as an option to begin with. You could have suggested anything else to throw us off and keep Sammy’s secret, but you didn’t."

"I know," Dean admitted, rubbing his chin lightly against her shoulder.

"You really are terrible at keeping secrets," she told him, shaking her head.

"That’s not true," Dean began, pulling back a little so he could look at the side of her face. "I haven’t told anyone about the gallery wanting to showcase some of your photos next month because I know you don’t want anyone to know until it’s officially confirmed. You don’t want to jinx it."

Bridget stopped what she was doing and nodded slowly.

"I guess that’s true," she agreed. She turned her head to face him and said, "Thank you for that, by the way."

She leaned toward him and briefly pressed her lips against his. The gesture was so quick that Dean didn’t even have time to close his eyes.

"Still, why did you want to bet against something you already knew the outcome of?" Bridget asked when she pulled back and turned toward the sink.

Dean leaned back a little to look at her, his arms still wrapped around her.

"I hardly ever win our bets, and I really wanted to win one, so you’d have to do what I wanted, and—"

Bridget suddenly stiffened in his arms.

"So, you actually want me to do all that... stuff you asked for?" There was a hint of disgust in her voice.

Dean sighed and lowered his head, resting it against the back of Bridget’s neck, her brownish-blonde hair tickling his face.

"No," he admitted. "Never that."

Bridget shook her head.

"Okay, now I’m just confused."

Dean lifted his head and took a step back as she started to turn around in his arms. His arms slipped from around her, his hands coming to rest on her hips.

"So, you created a bet you knew you were going to win, but you don’t actually want your winnings?" she asked slowly, clearly confused.

"Okay... don’t be mad," Dean said carefully.

Bridget folded her arms across her chest. She looked like she wanted to interrupt, but instead remained silent and let him continue.

"There is something that I really want—something else," he added quickly when she opened her mouth to speak. "But I don’t know how you’re going to take it. So, I figured if I gave you an option of stuff you would never actually agree to, you might be more open to thinking about agreeing to what I actually want."

Bridget simply stood there and blinked at him.

"Does that make sense?" he asked, taking her silence to mean she was confused.

"Surprisingly, yes," she sighed. Unfolding her arms and placing her hands on his forearms, she asked, "While I’m now a little afraid to ask... what is it that you actually want?"

Dean looked into her eyes.

"I want another kid."

Bridget leaned back from him until her back hit the sink behind her.

"I... what?" she asked, her shock obvious.

Dean dropped his hands from her waist and took half a step back.

"Not right now, obviously," he said quickly. "I was thinking in a year or two, when Aislin’s a bit older."

Bridget straightened herself.

"How long have you been thinking about this?" she asked.

Dean shrugged.

"Why would you think I wouldn’t be open to the idea of another child?"

Dean gave her a knowing smile.

"Well, as you pointed out in front of my parents a moment ago, my contribution to creating our daughter was a lot more... fun, than all the stuff you had to go through to get her here."

His smile faded, replaced by a look of genuine concern.

"I know pregnancy wasn’t easy for you. I was worried you’d already made up your mind."

"And tricking me and lying to me was going to help sway my decision in your favour?" she asked, raising an eyebrow.

"More like making you think there were worse things I could ask for, so you'd at least think about this instead of saying no straight away." He paused before shaking his head. "Not my best idea."

Bridget shook her head.

"No, it wasn’t," she agreed. "So, what if I think about it and my answer is no? Then what?"

"Then nothing," he shrugged. "I want another kid. Growing up, Sam and I had the best times together, and I’d love that for Aislin. But I’m not going to force you to do anything you don’t want to do. It’s your body, Bridge."

Bridget’s eyes softened. She stepped toward him and, once she was close enough, rested her hands on his collarbones, her fingers lightly tapping against the base of his neck.

"How is it that you can be so incredibly sweet and thoughtful, yet so cunning and manipulative at the same time?" she asked, shaking her head in disbelief as she tried to suppress a smile.

Dean’s lips curled into a small grin.

"I don’t know. How is it that you always want to kiss me and throttle me at the same time?"

Bridget laughed, then slid her hands up to his neck before gently pulling him down to meet her in a kiss. Dean wrapped his arms around her waist again, drawing her against him. They shared a sweet kiss that lasted several moments.

John watched from his hidden spot by the doorway. He was shocked, but also a little in awe of what he had just witnessed. He had never known Dean to be so thoughtful about someone else's feelings before. He had never really known Dean to express his own feelings as openly as he had just done with Bridget.

There had been plenty of times when it was obvious Dean wanted to say something about how he felt or what he really thought, but before he could get the words out, he would usually deflect with a joke or hide them behind sarcasm so they wouldn’t be taken seriously. It was only when he was truly angry that he tended to let his guard down.

But with this woman—this woman John had somehow created to fit into this dream life for his son—Dean had let his guard down completely. There had been no hesitation or fear about sharing such personal thoughts and desires. Instead, he had simply explained why he had done what he did, trusting her enough to be honest.

Bridget pulled back slightly.

"Okay," she said. "I’ll think about having another baby."

She leaned in again and briefly kissed him before murmuring, "But you’re still driving my car."

Dean groaned in annoyance but tightened his arms around her waist and pulled her closer to continue kissing her.

There was no other way to describe it.

Dean was absolutely in love with this woman.

It was then that the muffled sound of a baby's cry drifted in from the other end of the house. John remembered why he was here, interrupting this private moment in the first place.

He cleared his throat to make Dean and Bridget aware of his presence before stepping into the kitchen.

Dean and Bridget broke apart. Bridget lowered her hands to her sides. Dean, however, didn’t remove his arms from around her waist, only loosening his hold. Neither of them looked embarrassed at being caught kissing. Instead, they simply smiled at each other.

"Sorry," John said quickly. "Your mom thinks Aislin might want a bottle, and—"

He stopped mid-sentence as he watched Dean release one arm from around Bridget. Without breaking eye contact with her, Dean reached around her toward the sink and grabbed something from behind her. Then he brought the object closer and held it up for John to see.

Dean held up a baby bottle filled with milk, and John realised that was what Bridget had been doing when he had first seen her standing at the sink. She had been getting Aislin's bottle ready.

Dean smirked, turned to John, and gave the bottle a small wave, saying, "Already on it."

To be continued...
Next Chapter: Mary’s Guidance

Chapter 10: Mary's Guidance

Chapter Ten ~ MARY’S GUIDANCE

Shortly after John had interrupted them in the kitchen; Dean had taken the bottle of milk out to Aislin. John had watched as Dean took the baby from his mother, settled her in his lap, and helped her hold the bottle. As she leaned back in his arms, her gaze locked with his, and they sat without ever breaking eye contact. Dean continued to talk and join in the conversations, but he never looked away from his daughter.

It was just one more sign showing John how devoted Dean was to that little girl.

It was getting late now, as evidenced by the fact that Aislin was fighting very hard to keep her eyes open.

Sam had ended up with Aislin once more. John smiled as he watched Sam standing and gently rocking a tired Aislin against his chest, her head resting on him and her little hands clutching fistfuls of his shirt. Dean, Jessica, and Bridget were all back on the couch again. Mary was sitting in an armchair, and John sat on its arm beside her. Mary had one hand resting over his knee, rubbing it in affectionate circles. The simple touch, which should have been seen as nothing more than casual contact, instead meant so much to John and was full of affection.

John knew that soon Dean would leave with his little family, and Sam and Jessica would probably turn in for the night. He knew it was coming, but he really wanted to keep talking with them a little longer.

"So, what about lunch tomorrow?" Mary asked everyone. "You don't have to go back too early tomorrow, right, Sam?"

Sam smiled at his mother and said in a soft voice so as not to disturb his niece, who was drifting off to sleep against him, "No, we're here for two nights."

He looked down at Aislin and smiled as her head drooped slightly.

"If that's okay?" Jessica asked.

"Of course." Mary smiled happily. "Stay as long as you want."

"Lunch it is then," Bridget confirmed. "Where?"

"What's best for Aislin?" Sam asked, looking over at Bridget and Dean. "We're happy to just stay here or go to your place."

"Well, it's meant to be nice weather tomorrow," Bridget said. "Maybe we could do a picnic?" she suggested with a small shrug.

Dean turned to her and said, "At the duck pond?"

Bridget nodded.

After a few minutes of making and confirming their plans for lunch tomorrow—plans that John was sure he would never see, as he knew he was going to wake up soon and return to his real life—Bridget stood up, obviously about to get ready to go home.

"Dean, can you go grab Aislin's stuff and put it in the car so we can go home?" she asked, turning to look down at the oldest Winchester son.

Dean placed an arm along the back of the couch. "Or we could stay here," he suggested with a brief shrug. Stretching his legs out in front of him, he added, "Dad and Mom have the spare bed—"

"—No!" Sam interrupted quickly, managing to keep his voice low so as not to disturb Aislin, who was basically asleep at this point. "Jessica and I are guests. We get the bed."

"Not if I decide I'm too tired... or drunk to go home," Dean said with a grin and a look that clearly said he was enjoying annoying his little brother. "Then Bridge and I would get the bed, and you'd be stuck on the couch."

"What makes you so sure you'd get the bed instead of the couch if you stayed?" Sam demanded.

Without answering, both Dean and Jessica looked at Sam, their brows raised with expressions that clearly said, You've got to be kidding me, before they each lifted an arm and pointed directly at the sleeping baby in Sam's arms. Both knew full well that having Aislin would give Dean and Bridget priority over the spare bed more than Sam and Jessica. Sam frowned at the response and shook his head. John guessed that Sam knew it was true and didn't argue.

"In fact..." Dean started before yawning and stretching, making it a much larger gesture than it needed to be. "I think we might stay after all."

Sam glared at Dean and was about to say something when Bridget interrupted him.

"Dean, if we stay, then Jessica and I will share the bed," Bridget told him, gesturing toward the other young woman. "And you and Sammy"—she waved a hand between the brothers before adding—"can fight over the couch."

Now Dean was frowning, and Sam was laughing silently, his mouth closed and his shoulders shaking slightly.

John couldn't help but be amused by the interaction between his sons and their partners—or fiancée, in Sam's case.

"Fine." Dean pouted. He stood up until he was only a few inches away from his girlfriend. Looking down at her, he said, "But I'm driving."

"You," Bridget said, placing a finger against his chest, "have been drinking tonight." She smirked before adding, "And my week to drive the Impala starts now."

Dean gave her an annoyed stare.

Mary shook her head, a slight smile on her face as she pushed herself up from the chair, her hand pressing against John's knee as she used it to help herself stand. Once on her feet, she made her way over to Sam and gently took baby Aislin from him for what John assumed was one last cuddle before she was taken home by her parents.

Bridget turned and walked past Dean to join them. John watched as Dean stayed where he was but turned to face the others, his face still frowning and his arms now crossed over his chest. John wasn't sure whether it was because his teasing of Sam had been cut short or because he'd been reminded that he'd be forced to drive a car he didn't like that was causing Dean to pout.

Bridget smiled down at Aislin in Mary's arms as Mary cuddled her granddaughter close, swaying gently out of habit.

"Thank you again, Mary, for watching her today," Bridget said sincerely. "It really helped me out."

"I'll always watch her. She's my granddaughter," Mary said with a small smile. Looking down at Aislin, she added, "It's what grandmothers are for."

John watched Bridget react much as she had in the dining room when Mary had told her and Jessica that they were family. It was as though she was happy to hear that Mary would always support Aislin, but at the same time, she looked sad, as if those same words had stirred some unhappy memory that she was trying hard to keep buried.

John watched as Dean's expression changed. He went from pouting in annoyance to wearing a softer, understanding expression. Then, just as he had done before, Dean walked over to Bridget, this time placing a hand on her lower back in silent comfort.

In both cases, Dean had been standing behind Bridget, so he couldn't have seen how Mary's words had affected her, and yet he somehow knew that those simple words—words that should have brought only happiness—had affected her differently and that she needed just the briefest bit of comfort.

John knew there was clearly something going on, which was confusing because why would his mind create something deeper than what he was seeing for this woman, his dream had created simply to give Dean a partner?

With his hand gently rubbing her back, Dean told Bridget in a soft tone, "I'll go put Aislin's stuff in the car." Then he kissed her temple before moving away to get the bags.

Bridget nodded, then lightly cleared her throat before telling the others, "Okay, one last cuddle before we take Aislin home."

Mary sighed and held the sleeping baby just a little tighter. John stood from the arm of the chair and crossed the short distance to his wife and granddaughter. He couldn't help but smile at how beautiful the image of the two of them together was. Mary must have felt him watching because she looked up at him and smiled. Without a word, she carefully lifted the sleeping baby and placed her against his chest.

John's eyes left Mary's so he could look down at the sleeping baby nestled against him, amazed that she hadn't woken even while being passed around. Her little head lolled slightly to one side, and John knew she was in a deep sleep. Perhaps it was simply too late for her and well past her usual bedtime.

He knew he was going to miss this—miss her—when he woke up. He was happy that his mind had created this experience for him, but he was also angry that it was giving him something he'd probably never experience in real life.

It was bittersweet.

In his peripheral vision, John could see Sam, Jessica, and Mary taking turns hugging Bridget, and he could hear them saying their goodbyes and finalising plans for tomorrow's lunch.

Dean walked back in from outside, holding the keys to the Impala in one hand. Bridget held out her hand, palm up, and Dean, knowing what she wanted, placed the keys into it. Then he walked over to John and gave his father a warm smile.

"Alright," Dean said softly. "Come here, baby."

As much as John wanted to hold the little girl a little longer, he found himself willingly handing her back to Dean because he knew that was where she belonged.

Dean gathered Aislin against him, kissed the top of her head, and began to sway gently.

Bridget walked over to them and smiled warmly at John.

"Bye, John."

Then she hugged him.

Strangely, it didn't feel as awkward as John had thought it would. Even after spending just one day with this woman, he already felt as though he knew her—or at least that she belonged with his family.

When Bridget pulled away, she turned to the others and said softly, "We'll see you guys tomorrow."

"Night, Bridget," Sam said.

Dean simply nodded before tilting his head toward the door, indicating that he wanted Bridget to lead the way out of the house. With Bridget in the lead, they started walking toward the front door.

John had so much he wanted to say to his oldest son. So many things he was afraid he'd never be able to say, because he knew that eventually this whole dream—this life—was going to end. If this was their last interaction, he didn't want it to end with a simple goodbye.

Trying to keep his emotions in check, John followed Dean and Bridget to the front door.

When Dean noticed John coming with them, he turned to his father with a questioning look but didn't say anything, instead waiting for the older man to speak.

John took a moment to look at Dean, trying to engrave the image of him holding his baby into his memory.

Placing a hand firmly on one of Dean's shoulders, John looked into his son's eyes, tried to smile without revealing his true thoughts and emotions, and said, "I'm proud of you, Dean."

Dean simply watched his father without speaking. Bridget stood in front of them, leaning against the doorframe as she watched.

"You're an amazing father," John continued, looking down at the sleeping child. "Aislin is very lucky."

Dean grinned, and John wasn't sure whether it was because of the compliment or simply because his daughter's name had been mentioned.

"Well, she makes it easy," Dean said with a shrug before resting his cheek against the top of Aislin's head.

John nodded in agreement. He hadn't spent much time with her, but she did seem to be a very easy baby to look after. Sam had been similar, at least before Mary had died and their lives had changed. John knew a large part of that had been because Sam had realised—even at such a young age—that something was missing from his life. He also would have picked up on the anxiety and grief that John and Dean had carried.

Dean, on the other hand, had been a little more difficult. Not in a bad way, but he had certainly cried more and needed more attention. He had been their first child, so John and Mary had still been learning, and everything they learned with Dean had made things much easier when Sam was born. They had definitely been stressed first-time parents with no idea what they were doing, but they had done the best they could.

Even though Dean was a first-time parent here, he didn't seem stressed at all. It was as though he'd always been meant to do this. To be a father.

"See you tomorrow, Dad," Dean said, bringing John out of his thoughts.

"Yeah." John sighed and nodded.

Deep down, he knew this would probably be the last time he saw his son like this.

John turned and started walking back toward Mary, Sam, and Jessica. As he walked, he could hear Dean and Bridget talking.

"Last chance to crash here for the night?" Dean suggested, his voice almost a whisper.

"You're not getting out of me driving the Impala, Dean," Bridget told him firmly. "It's happening."

John heard Dean briefly groan his disapproval, and it caused him to glance back at the young couple. They continued speaking, unaware they were being watched.

"Besides," Bridget began, biting her lower lip slightly, almost shyly, "we have to go home and practice."

"Practice what?" Dean asked, tilting his head with a frown.

Bridget gave him a sly smile, her eyes sparkling as she replied, "Making Aislin a baby brother or sister."

Her gaze dropped seductively for a moment before she looked back up at Dean and grinned, then pushed herself away from the doorframe and walked outside.

From where he stood, John saw Dean's eyes light up as a wide grin spread across his face before he hurried after his girlfriend.

John couldn't help letting out a quiet chuckle.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

It hadn’t been long after Dean and Bridget had left that John and the others had said their goodnights, with he and Mary heading to their bedroom and Sam and Jessica going to the spare bedroom.

The main thing John took away as he watched Sam close the door to the spare room was how happy he was. And why shouldn’t he be happy? He was doing well at school, and he had Jessica, the woman he obviously loved. It devastated John to know that instead of having all of that, his son now knew the trauma and grief of losing the woman he loved.

Now, John sat on the edge of the bed he had once spent every night in beside the woman he loved. He watched her as she sat at the vanity with her back to him, taking out her earrings before placing them away. She was already in her pyjamas, wearing a nightgown.

John just watched her, taking in her beauty.

He had not bothered to get changed and ready for bed yet, focused instead on simply watching Mary go through her regular nightly routine. Another small, insignificant moment that John desperately missed.

John also didn’t want to go to sleep too quickly, as he knew deep down that falling asleep would probably be what triggered his mind to reawaken in the real world, and he would lose all of this.

"I'm so happy for Sam," Mary said. She grabbed her hairbrush and began brushing her blonde hair. "He and Jessica are going to be so happy."

"Yeah," John agreed, his voice sad because the real Sam would never get this happy ending. "He'll make a good husband."

The tone in John's voice must have caught Mary's attention because she stopped brushing her hair and looked at John through the mirror, seeing him sitting on their bed with his shoulders slumped.

"John? Are you okay?" she asked gently, concern clear in her voice.

John caught her eyes in the mirror and nodded, trying so hard not to let her know how scared he was that he was about to lose her all over again.

"I'm just thinking about Sam and Dean," he told her. "They're... both great young men." He paused and smiled very slightly. "I'm just proud of them."

"I know you are," Mary said, turning slightly to look at him directly.

"I think... I think I should tell them that more often," John said sadly, mostly to himself.

Thinking about his actual relationship with his sons and how it was very clear that neither of them truly knew how deeply proud John was of them and who they had become made him incredibly sad. He knew it was his own fault. Instead of telling them—showing them how proud he was—he had been too focused on revenge and finding the thing that had destroyed their lives.

His mind drifted to being possessed and to Dean's almost non-reaction to the demon saying his family didn't need him. His son should never question how much he was needed and wanted by his father.

"Well, you'll be able to tell them tomorrow," Mary said with a smile.

She turned back to the mirror and continued brushing her hair. John watched her for a minute and let the love he had for her—the love he would always have for her—wash over him.

Seeing her as a grandmother had amazed him beyond words. The love she obviously had for that little girl was undeniable. If Aislin was meant to be Dean's daughter, then she was also very much meant to be Mary's granddaughter and to have Mary in her life. This made John sad that Mary would never get to experience that relationship.

"You had a good day. With Aislin," John said, and it was a statement of fact because it was so clear that she had.

Mary laughed and smiled broadly as she replied, "Always."

John sighed and smiled, taking in her laugh and happiness, allowing them to wash over him in an attempt to preserve them in his memory.

"I love you," he told her after a moment. "I love this life... and Aislin... she's..." He trailed off because words couldn't describe how incredible he found his baby granddaughter.

Without looking at him, Mary finished his thought with a single word.

"Everything."

John nodded in agreement.

There was still one thing he was curious about, and that was how Aislin had come to have that name. There was something about it that intrigued John, but he couldn't, for the life of him, figure out what it was. He just knew it meant something important.

Wanting to get the answer before he woke up, he asked, "Why did they choose her name again? Why Aislin?" He tried to keep his voice casual and make it sound as though it was simply a fact he had briefly forgotten instead of something he genuinely had no idea about. He looked down at his hands resting in his lap.

"It actually means 'dream,'" Mary said simply.

"What?" John's head snapped up to look at her, his eyes widening in shock.

Her name means dream... and he was currently in a dream where his mind had created her entire existence. Was it all just a coincidence?

As John tried to wrap his head around all of that, Mary placed her hairbrush down and stood up. She turned to him and smiled softly, yet knowingly.

"You know, John," she began, her voice calm and gentle, "dreams can mean so many different things."

John watched her in confusion as she slowly walked over to him.

"They can be a way to help regulate your emotions," she continued, almost as if she were explaining something of great importance to him. It was a dramatic shift from their previous conversation. "Or they can give you moments where you feel anxious or out of control, like when you dream of falling."

She moved to stand right in front of him, her legs against his knees as she continued.

"Sometimes dreams are just your mind reliving certain moments from your life. Mostly as they were, or sometimes showing you how things could have gone."

"Mary?" he asked, unsure of what was happening and why she was telling him all of this.

"And sometimes..." she said, nudging his legs with her own until they fell open. She stepped between them, standing close and looking down at him, smiling with love shining clearly in her eyes. "Sometimes a dream is a way to show you not just what could have been, but what can and will still be—and to prepare you for that."

"Mary... I don't..." John said, confused.

He looked at her with deep confusion as she reached up and placed a hand on each of his cheeks, stroking her thumbs gently across his cheekbones and jaw while keeping him still.

"Think about today," she gently instructed him. "Think about what you know can never be because of the loss that's been dealt."

John's mouth dropped open, and a short gasp escaped him. It sounded like Mary was referring to her death... to Jessica's death. But she couldn't be.

Mary's expression changed to one of sorrow for a moment before it was replaced by one of faith and quiet certainty as she continued.

"Now, think about what could still happen because there has been no loss there."

"Mary," he sighed, his eyes closing briefly. "I don't understand."

She ran a thumb gently over his lips, making his eyes snap open again to look up at her. Why was she telling him all of this? What did it all mean? He felt so deeply confused that he could only half-process what she was saying.

"Even if you don't remember any of this," Mary began, holding his face more firmly in her hands, "it will help you realise that what could happen—what will happen—will be okay in the end."

John just looked at her. His voice had left him. He was stunned and overwhelmed with emotion.

Then Mary leaned down and pressed her lips gently against his, leaving them there for a moment before pulling back just enough that only a breath separated them.

"I love you, John," she breathed against his lips.

John snapped out of his trance enough to quickly bring his arms up and wrap them securely around his wife's hips, holding her tightly against him.

"I love you," he told her, his voice cracking with emotion. "I'll never stop."

Mary kissed him again, deeper this time, running her tongue lightly over his bottom lip until he opened his mouth for her.

John drew in a sharp breath when Mary pulled back from the kiss, just enough to look at him again.

"I'm so proud of you, John," she told him. "No matter what, you love our sons, and that's what matters."

As she leaned in for another kiss, she whispered, "Trust me."

Then her lips met his once more...

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

…John woke with a start, his whole body jerking as if he had been drifting off and had suddenly been slammed against a hard surface. A sharp breath escaped his lips.

He looked around, noticing the medical machines and monitors beside him, the tube attached to his arm, and the IV pole it was connected to, with a bag most likely filled with some sort of painkiller. His right arm was encased in a blue cast and supported by a sling.

John closed his eyes and let his head fall back onto the pillow.

He was in hospital. Pain coursed through his body, though it was worse in his leg and arm. Then he remembered being possessed by the demon that had killed Mary, and Sam using the Colt to shoot him in the leg in order to save him and drive the demon out at the same time. His mind then shifted to the feeling he'd had when the Impala had been hit by the truck. He remembered the sound of metal crashing against metal and the glass shattering around him.

They must have been brought to the hospital and treated, but John had no way of knowing how long he had been there, or even if his sons were okay.

He also had the feeling that he'd had the strangest, yet most incredible dream while heavily sedated, most likely influenced by the drugs that had been pumped into him during surgery on his leg and were still being given to him to help with the pain.

The only problem was, try as he might, he couldn't really remember what the dream had been. He knew he had most likely been dreaming, but the longer he remained awake, the foggier and more distant it became.

He opened his eyes and carefully sat up before searching for the remote that controlled the position of the hospital bed he was lying in. Finding it, he pressed a few buttons and adjusted the bed so the top half reclined upward, allowing him to sit comfortably while resting his back against it.

He let out a deep sigh.

He thought maybe he had dreamt of Mary, as he had so often throughout his life, but he wasn't sure. A very blurry image of her standing between his legs and kissing him came to mind, but as he tried to focus on it, the image drifted further and further away, as if it were more of an old memory that had faded over the years rather than something from a dream he had only just woken from.

"Dad," came a voice, interrupting John's thoughts.

He looked over and saw Sam standing in the doorway of his hospital room, looking hugely relieved to see his father sitting up and awake.

John took in Sam's appearance and was grateful to see that he didn't seem to have suffered anything worse than a few scratches on his cheek and nose. From what he remembered, the truck had struck the passenger side of the Impala, meaning that at least Sam had been spared the full force of the impact.

"Sam," John breathed.

One of his sons was okay. That was something.

"You're awake," Sam said as he moved into the room and stopped beside his father's bed.

"Where's your brother?" John asked.

He tried to keep the fear out of his voice. He didn't want to think the worst, but he couldn't help it. Dean had lost a lot of blood even before the car accident, and John knew his injuries were more severe than any they had ever suffered before.

When Sam smiled slightly, John felt as though a huge weight of fear and dread had suddenly been lifted from his shoulders. Smiling was definitely a good sign.

"They're just waiting for him to wake up," Sam told his father.

John could hear the unmistakable relief in Sam's voice and had no doubt that the hours while he and Dean had been in surgery had been incredibly hard on him. All Sam could have done was wait, not knowing whether either of them would pull through.

"He was hurt pretty bad," Sam continued. "But the doctors said he should be fine. He might need to take it easy for a while, but..." He paused and let out a breath. "He's going to be okay."

John nodded at his youngest son and released the breath he hadn't realised he'd been holding.

He didn't know what was going to happen now. The demon was still out there. They only had one bullet left for the Colt. The Impala was probably severely damaged.

But none of that mattered right now.

Both his sons were alive.

They might not be completely fine, either physically or mentally, after everything that had happened, but they were alive. Right now, that was what John needed to focus on. Even trying to remember the dream he had woken from—where he was fairly certain he had dreamt of Mary—didn't matter anymore, even though something deep inside him told him the dream had somehow been important.

The only thought in John's mind now was:

My sons are okay.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

The gentle yet constant humming and beeping were what dragged Dean from his sleep. He breathed deeply for a moment before opening his eyes. Instantly, he knew he was in a hospital. After all, it wasn't the first time he had found himself in a hospital bed after a fight with a demon or some other creature.

He felt an ache throughout his body, especially in his chest, but not really any pain. Though he guessed that was probably due to the IV line attached to him, which was most likely filled with some pretty strong pain medication.

He reached a hand out and fumbled around until his fingers found what he knew was the remote to control the position of his bed. Bringing the remote up above his head, he quickly located the button that would allow him to raise the top half of the bed so he could sit up.

Once he was sitting upright, he was able to take in his surroundings a little better. He was no longer wearing his own clothes and was instead dressed in a white shirt. The blanket covering him had slipped down past his hips when he had sat up, and he could see he was wearing light blue pants instead of his jeans.

His mind was a little unfocused at first, but then the memories of being attacked by the demon while it possessed his father came flooding back to him. After that, he remembered being in the back of the Impala. He remembered listening to his father and brother argue while he fought to remain conscious. He also remembered barely finding the strength to take out his cell phone and send a very quick text. After that, he had no idea what had happened. There had been nothing but darkness until he had opened his eyes a few moments ago.

He looked around for the other remote that he knew would let him call a nurse or doctor. He needed to see someone. He needed to know if his dad and brother were okay.

He had his head down, searching for the call remote, when a soft tapping at the door of his private hospital room made him stop. He lifted his head and paused as he saw who was standing there.

Half leaning into his room, with the rest of her body still outside and obscured by the wall, was a young woman with long blonde and brownish hair that fell in loose curls around her face. Her light blue eyes met his with a gentle expression.

As he looked at her, he couldn't help but let go of some of his worries. That was just the effect she had on him.

A tiny smile graced his lips as he looked at her.

She returned the smile before saying, "Hi, Dean."

"Hi, Bridge."

THE END

Series Continues in the next story:
THIS WEIRD THING OF OURS

Afterword

Please drop by the Archive and comment to let the creator know if you enjoyed their work!